SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 8
Download to read offline
The Energy and Resources Institute
TERI–ACPCPOLICYBRIEF2013/2
Background
The Kyoto Protocol never prescribed how CDM projects
must be distributed among host countries, though
interest in regional distribution patterns have been
high ever since. While the Kyoto mechanism prompted
successful investments in most of the emerging
economies across the world, some regions like Africa
saw a dampener. Africa policy panel (in 2010)
concluded the average external financing need (2010–
2020 p.a.) for mitigation activities (including REDD+)
to be approximately $13–26 billion. While CDM helped
in leveraging finance for emission reduction projects (by
creating incentives), the investments in Africa for CDM
project development was seen to be meagre.
Table 1: Regional distribution of CDM projects
registered and undergoing registration
Regional distribution of CDM projects shows that 27
African countries with an existing DNA do not have
registered projects till now while the countries which
do, the number spans between 1 to 10 projects only.
Geographical distribution of CDM exhibits large share
of projects for countries such as South Africa, Kenya,
Egypt, Morocco, Nigeria, and Uganda. Sector-wise
distribution of CDM projects illustrates negligible share
of projects in every CDM sector for the continent as a
whole. Differences in level of CDM participation is even
more pronounced when measured in terms of CERs
by region.
Table 2: Share of CERs from CDM projects by
region
Swati Agarwal
Regions Countries
without
a DNA
& zero
projects
Countries
with DNA
& zero
projects
Countries
with
1–10
projects
Countries
with
11–100
projects
Countries
with
>100
projects
Africa
(33)
5 27 18 3 0
Asia and
Pacific
(13)
11 11 17 7 2
Europe
and
Central
Asia
1 4 8 1 0
Latin
America
and
Carib-
bean
(1)
4 8 12 7 2
China
and
India
0 0 0 0 2
Regions Total Small-
scale
projects
Large-
scale
projects
Non-
Industrial
gas
projects
Projects
under
validation
Africa 3% 2% 3% 3% 5%
China 68% 41% 70% 67% 57%
India 7% 19% 6% 8% 12%
Rest of
the World
22% 38% 21% 22% 26%
Source: UNFCCC, Benefits of the Clean Development
Mechanism Report 2012
Africa accounts for only 3% of the total Certified
Emission Reductions (CERs) and the share of non-
Industrial gas projects also remains low for the continent.
This denotes that the sectors which had potential for
mitigation in Africa were also not exploited within the
mechanism. Moreover ‘CER generated as a share of
national emissions’ is also low for the continent which
amounts to approximately 2% of national emissions,
while it is at 5% and 6% of national emissions for
India and China, respectively (UNFCCC 2012). Only 32
CDM projects from Africa (out of 148 registered CDM
projects) have been issued CERs till now. A possibility
Source: UNFCCC, Benefits of the Clean Development
Mechanism Report 2012
2
is that some of these projects are still idling at the
development stage due to lack of money for project
execution.
Though Africa contributed least to the global GHG
emissions in the past, its potential in carbon markets
relies both in its ability to produce a wide range of
carbon mitigation projects as well as its possibilities
for sustainable development. Since Africa is growing
at above the global average — generating consumer
demands — growth from underdevelopment and high
renewable energy sources offer good potential for
carbon mitigation and avoided emissions in Africa.
The small percentage of CERs as a share of national
emissions in Africa is worrisome and demands attention.
This suggests that there are factors other than national
emission reduction potential in Africa that discouraged
CDM investments in the continent.
With provision of suitable market-based opportunities
to reduce and/or avoid emissions conducive to African
circumstances, the small share of investments in
conventional energies in Africa could be seen as an
opportunity to transform it into one of the cleanest
energy generation continents of the world. For this,
the barriers and opportunities need to be realized, to
effectively utilize opportunities and enhance country
readiness for future market mechanisms.
Barriers particularly impacting CDM in Africa
Project cost recovery
Attractiveness to investments in CDM projects
particularly depend upon the nature of economy, type
of finance availability, impact of carbon finance on
project cost recovery, etc. Studies quote that Africa’s
potential primarily lie in projects with ‘low carbon credit
contribution to the total project cost recovery’ (such
as landfill gas, renewable energy sector, LULUCF, etc.),
which dis-incentivize CDM investors from investing in
African projects However, the fact that the African share
of projects even in the so called low attractive sectors is
negligible as compared to China and India (as seen in
Table 2) reflects that there are barriers other than the
‘nature of project availability’ in a country which drives
the motivation of CDM investors.
Cleaner grids
With a comparatively small share of investments
in conventional energy systems in comparison to
economies such as China and India, the grids in some
African economies are cleaner. Further, with lower grid
emission factors, the returns to CDM credits are also
lower which discourages investments, as in the case of
Ethiopia. Hence, a large share of CDM projects in Africa
are still idling at development stage, with developers
lacking money to implement projects effectively.
Transaction costs
‘Higher transaction costs’ is an important determinant
that drives investors away. The dispersed nature of
projects and relatively sparse DOE presence in the
continent runs CDM projects in Africa into higher
transaction costs of project execution. This in turn
reduces the financial viability of the projects thereby
increasing investment risks, which demotivate investors
from investing.
National CDM capacity
A necessary but not a sufficient determinant of CDM
uptake in a country is its national CDM capacity.
Some of the African countries do not have a DNA
till now. Moreover, lack of awareness of the CDM in
the financial sector and lack of local CDM consulting
capacity is also expected to act as a barrier for CDM
uptake in Africa. While successful CDM projects build
awareness and private sector capacity to take up more
such activities, lack of experience with CDM in Africa
makes it difficult for the countries to cope with CDM
system complexities and modalities.
Suppressed demand
In 2011, only 34.57% of the population in Sub-Saharan
Africa had access to electricity. Moreover, the energy
consumption per capita in Africa is also low. This in
turn leads to the problem of suppressed demands
wherein the actual demand for energy is not equal
to the desired demand for energy in a country. Since
CDM in its methodology takes the baseline from the
current level of energy use in a country (which is very
low for Africa on account of underdevelopment) and do
not take into account the future projections of energy
consumptions (which is likely to increase with economic
expansion), the feasibility/profitability of CDM projects
in Africa diminishes.
Investment climate in Africa: A barrier?
It is well understood that opportunities in carbon
markets would be limited if the basic framework for
investment and markets are weak within a country. This
is because market-based mechanisms presuppose that
markets in a country are well developed and the private
sector is well mobilized within the system to undertake
project developments.
3
 Studies reveal that the investment climate in the host
country is a crucial determinant of CDM activity
(Michaelowa and Buen, 2012)
 The funds available for domestic investments, such
as from domestic financial institutions and private
sectors’ internal funds, also affects CDM activities in
a country (Michaelowa and Buen, 2012).
 The extent of ‘market maturities’ for private sector
activities is also expected to be crucial.
Table 3 summarizes Africa’s development progress
between 2005 and 2012 in comparison to China and
India and derives results from the same.
Table 3: Africa’s development progress between
2005 and 2012 in comparison to China and India
General investment climate
The general investment climate of the host country is
considered to be an important determinant for CDM
activities. Indicators such as cost of business start-up,
Global Competitiveness Index, FDI, and others have
been taken to analyse the investment climate in Africa.
Data reveals that since 2005 (the beginning of CDM),
some considerable efforts have been made in Africa
for promoting more business friendly environment.
The cost of business start-ups has fallen from 217
to 64.5 (%GNI per capita) and the time required for
business start-up has almost halved. These buoyant
prospects are increasingly attracting the Foreign Direct
Investments (FDI) into the continent. Since 2000s, FDI
across the continent has increased to five-fold leading
to its growth and economic expansion (AfDB, 2012).
However, progress could be expected to be slower than
potential on account of the slow improvement in the
Global Competitiveness Index and asymmetric trade
benefits due to lack of regional integration among
neighbouring countries in Africa. It is a well-known fact
that as Africa integrates its economies and invests in
better infrastructure, it can achieve economies of scale
in production, leading to better management of shared
resources and effective utilization of its capacity for joint
action on regional public goods. Its markets can expand
attracting larger private sector participation, increasing
competitiveness, and attracting faster investments. The
intra-African trade currently stands at only 108.4 billion
USD in 2012 which has increased marginally from
47.4 billion USD in 2005.
Despite improvements in the general investment
climate in Africa since 2005, its ‘Global Competitiveness
Index’ has not improved substantially and its ‘business
extent of disclosure index’ also features way below that
of China and India. Hence, in high capital investment
ventures (riskier projects) like that of CDM, attracting
investors would require a strong policy push within
the system concurrent to the improvements in general
investment climate in Africa.
Domestic financial Sector
The availability of funds from the domestic financial
sector for leveraging finance also impacts CDM uptake
in a region. In Africa, the bank assets to GDP ratio for
all countries are way below that of South Africa which
stands at 106% of total banking assets as a percentage
of GDP. Though the asset value of banks has increased
rapidly over the years, the market development is
building up from an extremely low level. Moreover,
despite several reforms in the national financial
Indicator All African Countries China India
Baseline
2005
Current
2012
Current
2012
Current
2012
Investment climate and domestic financial sector
GDP per capita 833 953 3348.01 1106.797
Access to electricity (%
population)
-- 34.57*^ 99.7c 75c
Global competitiveness
index
3.4 3.6 4.83 4.32
Cost of business start-
up (% GNI per capita)
217 64.5 2.1 49.8
Business extent of
disclosure index
4.6* 4.9* 10 7
Time required for
business start-up (Days)
58 33 33 27
FDI (% GDP) 3.27* 3.3* 3.03 1.7^
Domestic credit to
private sector(% GDP)
63.79* 61.36* 131.60 51.49
Strength of legal
rights index (0=weak,
10-strong)
4.4 5.8 6.0 8.0
% share of global trade 2.5 3.1 10.4 2
Intra-African Trade
(billion USD)
47.4 108.4 -- --
Governance and transparency
Country Policy and
Institutional Assessment
(CPIA) Financial sector
rating (1=low, 6=high)
2.9 3.0 -- 3.5
CPIA, fiscal policy
rating (1=low, 6=high)
3.3 2.9 -- 3.5
Number of fragile
countries in Africa
20 19 -- --
Note: *= Data available for Sub-Saharan Africa, ^ = 2011 data, C=
2010 data
Source: Author’s own compilation based on African
Development Bank, World Bank Group, International Energy
Agency, CDM Pipeline database, Organization for Economic
Co-operation and Development
4
institutions in Africa, the financial sector remained
relatively small and fragmented. The minimum capital
requirement by banks in African states is generally
below $10 million (Price Waterhouse Coopers, 2008).
For example, Nigeria consolidated from more than 80
to 25 banks in 2007, by way of raising the minimum
capital requirement to $200 million. This is one reason
that in most economies in Africa, sometimes capital
is not available for all kind of investments including
investments in CDM activities. In coming years, other
countries are likely to follow suit in order to streamline
and better capitalize their domestic financial sector.
The availability of domestic capital is considered
significant because it is observed that the countries
where the domestic credit to private sector (% GDP)
is higher, the number of CDM projects is also higher.
Some countries showing this trend are South Africa,
Kenya, and Egypt. This is also essential because credit
lending by domestic banks signal confidence in the
markets to the foreign investors as well. These findings
are consistent with other studies which show that a
week financial sector and/or limited supply of finance
for domestic investments limits CDM uptake in many
African Countries and LDCs (Castro and Michaelowa
2011; Byigero et al. 2010; Schmidt-Traub 2011; Burian
et al. 2011).
Private sector mobilization
In Africa, SMEs make up the bulk of private sector
economy and hence are extremely averse to risks and
vulnerable to incremental costs.
In the upper middle income countries in Africa where
markets are sufficiently developed and banking system
is reliable, capital is not always available for all kinds
of investments including CDM. In such situations these
countries (such as India, China, and South Africa) are
better able to finance projects with their domestic
budgets combined with international flows and private
equity. While on the other hand, countries in low-
income categories have small market capitalization
of private sector, insufficient domestic budgets, and
unreliable banking systems which makes investments
in CDM kind activities extremely difficult. Thus,
private sector players do not have the capacity to rely
on its own funds unless supported and mobilized by
public vehicles.
Institutional capacity
Institutional frailty, fear of regulatory changes, lack
of coordination mechanisms across various levels
of government, governance, and conflicts also puts
constraints on the overall attractiveness to investments
— 19 out of 54 countries in Africa (33 LDCs) feature
as ‘fragile’ in the global rankings by the African
Development Bank (AfDB) (2012). The Country Policy
and Institutional Assessment (CPIA) rating of the African
fiscal policy is lower that of other emerging economies
under study. Also, the ‘strength of legal rights Index’
though have increased significantly from 4.4 in 2005
to 5.8 in 2012 for all African countries, most of the
countries still stands at lower index levels.
Relevance of carbon funds and facilities for
African carbon market growth
Though mitigation potential existed in Africa, CDM as
a leveraging instrument did not work in the continent
on account of several barriers. While some of the
CDM specific barriers in Africa have been addressed
with constant efforts to modify the methodologies and
modalities such that they are conducive to the African
circumstances like ‘adoption of PoAs’, ‘methodology
for interstate electricity connection developed by AfDB’
etc,; the issue of leveraging investments for CDM
activities remained a challenge for the continent.
Over the recent years, the proliferation of instruments
such as carbon funds and facilities are seen likely
to increase the appetite to leverage finances and
support for CDM and future market-based activities
in the continent. A wide range of instruments have
been established by the Multilateral Bank, Regional
Development Banks, and Bilateral Financial Institutions
to catalyse growth of carbon markets in Africa. They
not only address some of the existing market barriers
(like high perceived risks, high transaction costs
etc.), but also help in leveraging private finances
(domestic/ international) for the underlying carbon
market investments.
Carbon funds as credit purchasers
Carbon funds are investment vehicles which raise
public/private capital to invest directly in projects to
reduce GHGs and/or purchase carbon credits using a
standardized purchase agreement (ERPA). They have
been playing a crucial role in mitigating risks from CDM
markets such as risk of delivery, portfolio diversification,
risk from volatile credit prices, etc., and their significance
is well observed in their exponential growth trend
from a single fund (Prototype carbon fund) in 1999
to 96 funds in 2009 (CDC Climat Research, 2010). In
the span of these years, the carbon funds have also
diversified their activities from pure carbon credit buying
to other support activities. However, the role of carbon
5
funds as credit purchasers in Africa is very meagre. Data
reveals that a major share of credits buying in Africa
is by private sector buyers (35%) followed by financial
Institutions (8%), government buyers (5%), carbon
funds (5%), and combination buyers (5%). Out of the
credits bought jointly, 31% of projects feature carbon
funds as one of the joint buyers.
Results from CDC Climate Research (2010) also
the markets. These public institutions help fill the gap
for the asymmetry of information among the different
stakeholder groups in project development, thereby
build trust in private enterprises and lead to more
maturity in the market with their participation.
Since a few years, many institutions such as World
Bank, UNFCCC, AfDB, UNDP, EIB, and some private
sector companies are playing significant role in leveraging
Joint Buyers, (5%)
Government Buyers, (5%)
Not mentioned, (42%)
Carbon Funds, (5%)
Private Buyers, (35%)
Financial Institution, (8%)
Govt + Pvt +
FI, 46%
Govt + Pvt +
FI, 15%
Govt + FI, 8%
CF + Pvt, 15%
CF + FI, 8%
CF + Govt + Pvt, 8%
Percentageshareofjointbuyers
resonates our findings. Study highlights that major
credits from CDM are bought by carbon funds in China
and India and to a lesser extent in Africa. Even then,
the funds have bought credits in only Egypt (5), Kenya
(2), Morocco (3), Nigeria (1), South Africa (1), Tunisia
(1), and Uganda (4), which are primarily located in the
northern and eastern geographies of Africa. Though
carbon funds are the primary buyers of credits from
PoAs as well in most of the emerging economies such as
China, Bangladesh, Thailand, and Vietnam, not a single
CDM credit has been purchased by them in Africa.
Carbon funds as CDM consultants
While role of carbon funds as credit buyers is not seen
to play a significant role in Africa, it is observed that
most of the CDM and PoA projects were developed
and assisted by the funds and their parent institutions
as PDD consultants.
Figure 1: Credit buyers’ portfolio in Africa
Source: Authors’ own calculations based on CDM pipeline database (as on September 2013).
Notes: Govt: Government Buyers; FI: Financial Institutions; Pvt: Private Buyers; CF: Carbon Funds
Funds/facilities leveraging finance
Most of the multilateral/bilateral/regional institutions
have set up funds and facilities that help leverage capital
for investments in CDM activities by project developers.
These are in the form of upfront/seed financing,
provision of debt loans, provision of project equities,
concessional loans, and even grants [refer Annex I].
Funds/facilities building institutional capacities
One of most promising feature of the facilities is
the fact that they are designed with an approach for
long-term sustainability such that it aims at creating
the ‘readiness/preparedness’ in countries for availing
benefits from the emerging market instruments. In
this regard, while some facilities aim at building the
capacity for the government organizations, others focus
more on building capacity for the domestic financial
system, thereby building reliability and confidence in
6
finance for Carbon mitigation activities and capacity
building in country stakeholders. Some institutions
have prime focus on specific countries and some also
earmark their sectors of implementation. For Instance,
while KfW carbon fund has its key focus in sectors of
renewable energy and afforestation, African Biofuels
and Renewable Energy Company (ABREC) focuses
mainly on biofuels and landfills. Moreover, some of
the facilities developed by the AfDB, offer support and
capacity to projects featuring in the banks’ pipeline.
In addition to the readiness building activities of the
funds and financial institutions, they are increasingly
beginning to look at the risk mitigation from African
markets for leveraging private sector participation and
also provide assistance with respect to new market
mechanisms post-2012, and NAMAs.
Recommendations and a way forward
Despite surge of support instruments in Africa to leverage
finances and upscale CDM activities in the continent,
a strong policy push is needed in the continent to
catalyse the private sector activities in carbon markets.
Some recommendations in this direction are:
 One of the priorities for Africa to increase its access
to international funds would be to manage its
shared resources and to expand its domestic markets
via regional integration in order to attain global
competitiveness.
 The banking sector in Africa can play an important
role in assessing the soundness of project proposals.
This is because foreign lenders/ international investors
find it easy and acceptable to lend to entities which
are appraised by local FIs/banks/ local agencies.
For Instance, in India, IREDA and few other banks
have set appraisal procedure for the CDM projects in
renewable energy sector.
 In order to facilitate the CDM projects expeditiously
in Africa, the financial intermediaries, such as energy
service companies, mutual funds, etc., which are
involved conventionally in project financing, can
orient resources and approval mechanism towards
CDM project as well, in their sector of operations.
For example, the appraisal mechanism is already in
place in India as an arrangement between World
Bank PCF and IDFC (India). After a due diligence
of IDFC’s appraisal mechanism, PCF decided to
fast track the project PINs proposed through it.
 The guarantees such as the Partial Risk Guarantees
(PRGs), Multilateral Investment Guarantee (MIGA),
and Export Credit Guarantees (ECG) are important
in mitigating country risks in Africa.
 Institutions such as International Finance
Corporation (IFC) have introduced some value-
added financial products to help mitigate risks
in emerging markets, carbon delivery guarantee
products, and provision for upfront finances/
loans to carbon projects with a prerequisite of
having a mature market in place. The role of
public institutions and other support instruments
is therefore crucial in mobilizing funds for private
sector activities for market maturity and newer
market developments necessary for exploiting
these opportunities.
 There is need for creating role models and for
replicating innovative financial schemes such as
the revolving fund scheme by the World Bank,
Micro-finance lending by ACAD, venture capital
funding practiced in India, etc.
 Need for host country DOEs or similar institutional
arrangements for future carbon market instruments.
 Need for push to create new methodologies
to address the issue of suppressed demand in
the continent.
Annex I: Financing and support instruments available for African Carbon markets
Programme Year Target
Sectors
Target
Countries
Financial Support Poor
country
focused
Capacity-Building Activities Technical
assistance
Support
PoAs/
NMMs/
Post
2012
focus
Seed
Finance
Debt
Finance
Private
Equity
Grants DNA Financial
Institutions
Private
Sector
World Bank
Carbon
Finance Unit
2002-
2011
OPEN Most African
Countries
Elltrix Carbon
Credit
Program
2012 Solar
techno-
logies
South Africa,
Namibia,
Mozambique,
Swaziland,
and Lesotho
7
KfW Carbon
Fund
2005 RE,
Afforest
-
African
Biofuels and
Renewable
Energy Co.
(ABREC)
2008 RE,
Biofuels,
landfill
Emphasis
placed on
the ECOWAS
countries
UNDP MDG
Carbon
Facility
2007 Open Open
Africa Carbon
Facility
2011 - Address
projects
coming
from AfDBs
lending
pipeline
UNFCCC
Schemes
2010
2012
2013
Open Most African
Countries
African
Carbon
Support
Program by
AfDB
2010 Open Ethiopia,
Nigeria,
Lagos,
Burkina Faso
Africa
Carbon Ssset
Develop-
ment Facility
(ACAD)
2009 Open Burkina
Faso, Kenya,
Mozam-
bique, Mali,
Mauritius,
Nigeria,
Rwanda,
South Africa,
Uganda
Africa Carbon
Credit
Exchanges
- Open -
Africa Carbon
Exchange
2011 Open -
Carbon Fund
for Africa
2012 RE,
methani-
zation, EE
Sub-Saharan
Africa
EIB Post
2012 Carbon
Credit Fund
2008 Wind,
waste
manage-
ment, EE
-
EIB Carbon
Fund in
Morocco
2008 RE, EE,
waste
manage-
ment,
A&R
Morocco
-
Carbon
finance for
Agriculture,
Silviculture,
Conservation,
and Action
against
Deforestation
(CASCADe)
2007 LULUCF,
bioenergy
activities
Sub-Saharan
Africa
NEFCO
Carbon
Finance and
Funds
2008 RE, EE,
Fuel
switching
Africa
Notes: **RE - Renewable Energy, EE - Energy Efficiency
Source: Authors’ own compilation from various sources World Bank Carbon Finance Unit <https://wbcarbonfinance.org/>, Africa carbon Asset
Development Facility <http://www.acadfacility.org/>, Elltrix Carbon credit program <http://www.elltrix.co.za/Property_Developer.php>, UNFCCC Loan
scheme <http://www.cdmloanscheme.org>, UNDP’s MDP Carbon Facility <http://www.mdgcarbonfacility.org/>, KfW Carbon Fund <http://www.kfw.
de/carbonfund>, Africa carbon Facility <http://www.afdb.org/en/topics-and-sectors/initiatives-partnerships/>, Africa carbon Credit Exchange<http://
www.africacce.com/>, ABREF<http://www.faber-abref.org/index_english.php>, European Investment bank <http://www.eib.org/projects/documents/eib-
and-carbon-finance---faq.htm
For further details, contact
Neha Pahuja
Earth Science and Climate Change Division Tel. 24682100 or 41504900
The Energy and Resources Institute (TERI) Fax 24682144 or 24682145
Darbari Seth Block, IHC Complex India +91 • Delhi (0) 11
Lodhi Road E-mail neha.pahuja@teri.res.in
New Delhi – 110 003 Web www.teriin.org
Reference
Alberola, E., & Stephan, N. (2010). Carbon Funds in 2010: Investment
in Kyoto Credits and Emissions Reductions. France: CDC Climate
Research.
Annan, K., Blair, T., Camdessus, M., Eigen, P., & Yunus, M. (2010).
Finance for Climate Resilient development in Africa, An agenda for
action following the Copenhagen conference . Switzerland: Africa
Policy Panel (UNECA).
Arens, C., Burian, M., Sterk, W., Schnurr, J., & Beuermann, C. (2011).
The CDM Project Potential in Sub-Sahar Africa with focus on selected
least developed countries. Germany: Wuppertal and Hamburg.
Bahsen, N., Figueres, C., Pedersen, M., Skov, S., Stehr, H. J., &
Valdimarsson, J. (2009). Potential use of Micro-financing in support
of CDM projects in LDCs. Denmark: NIRAS A/S.
World Bank (n.d.). 10 years of experience in carbon finance.
Retrieved September 2013, from World Bank Carbon finance unit:
http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTCARBONFINANCE/Resources/
Carbon_Fund_12-1-09_web.pdf
Boutin-Dufresne, F., Pena, S., Williams, O., & Zawisza, T. A. (2013).
Benchmarking Banking Sector Efficiency across regional blocks in
Sub-Saharan Africa: What Room for Policy. African Department:
International Monetary Fund.
Bowden, W. N. (2011, October 13). The future of carbon finance
PoAs in a post-2012 world. World Bank Carbon Finance Unit.
Brown, J. (Overseas Development Institute) (2009). Carbon Finance
in Africa. Africa Partnership Forum. Ethiopia: UNECA.
Burian, M., Arens, C., Sterk, W., & Wang-Helmreich, H. (2011).
Integrating Africa’s Least Developed countries into the global carbon
market: Analyzing CDM implementation barriers. Germany: Wyppertal
Institutte for Climate, Environment and Energy & GFA Invest. Available
at: http://www.jiko-bmu.de/files/english/application/pdf/
Byigero, A., Clancy, J., & Skutsch, M. (2010). CDM in Sub-Saharn
Africa and the prospects of the Nairobi Framework Initiative. Climate
Policy, 181-189.
Calland, R., Dubosse, N., Mohamed, N., Schalatek, L., Davidson, S.
R., & Reyes, O. (2011). No Romance. Mobilizing Climate Finance for
Africa. Southern Africa: Henreich Boll Stiftung, Available at: http://
www.boell.org/web/140.html
Castro, P., & Michaelowa, A. (2011). Would Preferential access
measures be sufficient to overcome current barriers to CDM projects
in least developed countries? Climate and Development, 123-142.
Collier, P. (2010, June). McKinsey & Company. Retrieved 2013, from
http://www.mckinsey.com/insights/economic_studies/the_case_for_
investing_in_africa
Cox, M. (2013). Annual Effectiveness Development Review. Tunisia:
African Development Bank.
Ellis, J., & Kamel, S. (2007). Overcoming barriers to clean
development mechanism projects. France: OECD/IEA.
Leke, A., Lund, S., Roxburgh, C., & Wamelen, A. v. (2010, June).
What’s Driving Africa’s Growth. Retrieved 2013, from McKinsey and
Company: http://www.mckinsey.com/insights/economic_studies/
whats_driving_africas_growth
Makhooda, S., Caravani, A., Bird, N., & Schalatek, L. (2012,
November). Climate Finance in Sub-Saharan Africa. Climate
Finance Policy Briefs. ODI, Available at: http://www.odi.org.uk/
publications/6151-climate-finance-sub-saharan-africa.
Michaelowa, A., & J, B. (2012). Carbon markets or climate finance?
Low carbon and adaptation investment choices for the developing
world. london, pp. 1-38: Routedge.
Murray, W., Garibaldi, J. A., Hampton, K., Hohne, N., & Jung,
M. (2009). Scaling up investment in climate change mitigation
activities. Climate Change Capital, Ecofys, energia, GtripleC.
PWC. (2008). Into Africa: Investment prospects in the sub-Saharan
banking sector. London: Price Waterhouse Coopers.
Ryan, L., Selmet, N., & Aasrud, A. (2012). Plugging the Energy
efficiency gap with climate finance . France: OECD/IEA.
Schmidt - Traub, G. (2011, March). Meeting Africa’s climate finance
challenge . Carbon First, pp. 5 - 7. Available at www.ideacarbon.
com.
Sinclair, G. (2012, July 9 - 11). Options for mobilizing climate finance
from private sector. UNEP Finance Initiative. UNFCCC, Availavle at:
http://unfccc.int/files/cooperation_support/financial_mechanism/
long-term_finance/application/pdf/sinclair10july2012.pdf.
Soren, L., & Michaelowa, A. (2008). Corporate strategies and
clean development mechanism: Developing country financing for
developed country commitments. Edward Elgar Publishing.
Spalding Fecher, R., Achanta, A. N., Erickson, P., Haites, E., Lazarus,
M., Pahuja, N., et al. (2012). Assessing the impact of the clean
development mechanism. Report commissioned by the High Level
Panel on the CDM Policy Dialogue .
UNFCCC. (2012). Benefits of the Clean Development Mechanism.
Germany: UNFCCC, Available at: cdm.unfccc.int/about/dev_ben/
ABC_2012.pdf
UNFCCC. (2012). CDM IN Africa: Finance and support. UNFCCC.
Zhu, J. (2012). The correlated factors of the uneven performance
of CDM host countries. IEL paper in Comparative Analysis of
Institutions, Economics and Law.
1
This policy brief is part of the project ‘Carbon Finance’ supported by the African Climate Policy Centre, UNECA, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.

More Related Content

What's hot

slEconomics - Models for funding infrastructure in South Africa - Nov 2013
slEconomics  - Models for funding infrastructure in South Africa - Nov 2013slEconomics  - Models for funding infrastructure in South Africa - Nov 2013
slEconomics - Models for funding infrastructure in South Africa - Nov 2013Stephen Labson
 
Infrastructure Development in South Africa, Stephen Labson slEconomics
Infrastructure Development in South Africa, Stephen Labson slEconomicsInfrastructure Development in South Africa, Stephen Labson slEconomics
Infrastructure Development in South Africa, Stephen Labson slEconomicsStephen Labson
 
UNCTAD LEAST DEVELOP
UNCTAD LEAST DEVELOPUNCTAD LEAST DEVELOP
UNCTAD LEAST DEVELOPKopulande
 
Icmbe durres albania musstafe hasani
Icmbe  durres albania  musstafe hasaniIcmbe  durres albania  musstafe hasani
Icmbe durres albania musstafe hasaniUBT University
 
Presentation by Declan Magee, ADB Senior Country Economist for Mongolia: “Ove...
Presentation by Declan Magee, ADB Senior Country Economist for Mongolia: “Ove...Presentation by Declan Magee, ADB Senior Country Economist for Mongolia: “Ove...
Presentation by Declan Magee, ADB Senior Country Economist for Mongolia: “Ove...The Business Council of Mongolia
 
Financing solutions to increase Ivory Coast Energy supply in rural areas
Financing solutions to increase Ivory Coast Energy supply in rural areasFinancing solutions to increase Ivory Coast Energy supply in rural areas
Financing solutions to increase Ivory Coast Energy supply in rural areasHadiza Hamid
 
Financing for development Final Project : Urbanizing Central African Republic...
Financing for development Final Project : Urbanizing Central African Republic...Financing for development Final Project : Urbanizing Central African Republic...
Financing for development Final Project : Urbanizing Central African Republic...Mel Makoge
 
SPEEDA INSIGHTS_Will foreign funds take away from private investment as the p...
SPEEDA INSIGHTS_Will foreign funds take away from private investment as the p...SPEEDA INSIGHTS_Will foreign funds take away from private investment as the p...
SPEEDA INSIGHTS_Will foreign funds take away from private investment as the p...Kyna Tsai
 
Final project unlocking investment & finance in emerging markets and develo...
Final project   unlocking investment & finance in emerging markets and develo...Final project   unlocking investment & finance in emerging markets and develo...
Final project unlocking investment & finance in emerging markets and develo...Damian Attah
 
Africa's partnership forum ict in africa boosting economic growth and povert...
Africa's partnership forum ict in africa  boosting economic growth and povert...Africa's partnership forum ict in africa  boosting economic growth and povert...
Africa's partnership forum ict in africa boosting economic growth and povert...Dr Lendy Spires
 
GCC Capital Expenditure Expected to Rise in 2013
GCC Capital Expenditure Expected to Rise in 2013GCC Capital Expenditure Expected to Rise in 2013
GCC Capital Expenditure Expected to Rise in 2013QNB Group
 
Gou budget economic analysis 2015 2016 final
Gou budget economic analysis 2015 2016 finalGou budget economic analysis 2015 2016 final
Gou budget economic analysis 2015 2016 finalUganda Coffee Federation
 

What's hot (20)

Digital artefact taf by agunbiade seun richards
Digital artefact   taf by agunbiade seun richardsDigital artefact   taf by agunbiade seun richards
Digital artefact taf by agunbiade seun richards
 
slEconomics - Models for funding infrastructure in South Africa - Nov 2013
slEconomics  - Models for funding infrastructure in South Africa - Nov 2013slEconomics  - Models for funding infrastructure in South Africa - Nov 2013
slEconomics - Models for funding infrastructure in South Africa - Nov 2013
 
Infrastructure Development in South Africa, Stephen Labson slEconomics
Infrastructure Development in South Africa, Stephen Labson slEconomicsInfrastructure Development in South Africa, Stephen Labson slEconomics
Infrastructure Development in South Africa, Stephen Labson slEconomics
 
PIDA Brief Closing Gap
PIDA Brief Closing GapPIDA Brief Closing Gap
PIDA Brief Closing Gap
 
Final project
Final projectFinal project
Final project
 
ADF: Concept note
ADF: Concept noteADF: Concept note
ADF: Concept note
 
UNCTAD LEAST DEVELOP
UNCTAD LEAST DEVELOPUNCTAD LEAST DEVELOP
UNCTAD LEAST DEVELOP
 
Icmbe durres albania musstafe hasani
Icmbe  durres albania  musstafe hasaniIcmbe  durres albania  musstafe hasani
Icmbe durres albania musstafe hasani
 
Adb mongolia factsheet
Adb mongolia factsheetAdb mongolia factsheet
Adb mongolia factsheet
 
Presentation by Declan Magee, ADB Senior Country Economist for Mongolia: “Ove...
Presentation by Declan Magee, ADB Senior Country Economist for Mongolia: “Ove...Presentation by Declan Magee, ADB Senior Country Economist for Mongolia: “Ove...
Presentation by Declan Magee, ADB Senior Country Economist for Mongolia: “Ove...
 
Financing solutions to increase Ivory Coast Energy supply in rural areas
Financing solutions to increase Ivory Coast Energy supply in rural areasFinancing solutions to increase Ivory Coast Energy supply in rural areas
Financing solutions to increase Ivory Coast Energy supply in rural areas
 
Financing for development Final Project : Urbanizing Central African Republic...
Financing for development Final Project : Urbanizing Central African Republic...Financing for development Final Project : Urbanizing Central African Republic...
Financing for development Final Project : Urbanizing Central African Republic...
 
SPEEDA INSIGHTS_Will foreign funds take away from private investment as the p...
SPEEDA INSIGHTS_Will foreign funds take away from private investment as the p...SPEEDA INSIGHTS_Will foreign funds take away from private investment as the p...
SPEEDA INSIGHTS_Will foreign funds take away from private investment as the p...
 
Asian infrastructure investment bank
Asian infrastructure investment bank Asian infrastructure investment bank
Asian infrastructure investment bank
 
Arab Concessional Financing for Development
Arab Concessional Financing for DevelopmentArab Concessional Financing for Development
Arab Concessional Financing for Development
 
Final project unlocking investment & finance in emerging markets and develo...
Final project   unlocking investment & finance in emerging markets and develo...Final project   unlocking investment & finance in emerging markets and develo...
Final project unlocking investment & finance in emerging markets and develo...
 
Africa's partnership forum ict in africa boosting economic growth and povert...
Africa's partnership forum ict in africa  boosting economic growth and povert...Africa's partnership forum ict in africa  boosting economic growth and povert...
Africa's partnership forum ict in africa boosting economic growth and povert...
 
GCC Capital Expenditure Expected to Rise in 2013
GCC Capital Expenditure Expected to Rise in 2013GCC Capital Expenditure Expected to Rise in 2013
GCC Capital Expenditure Expected to Rise in 2013
 
Gou budget economic analysis 2015 2016 final
Gou budget economic analysis 2015 2016 finalGou budget economic analysis 2015 2016 final
Gou budget economic analysis 2015 2016 final
 
Research statement_FDI_EU_MENA
Research statement_FDI_EU_MENAResearch statement_FDI_EU_MENA
Research statement_FDI_EU_MENA
 

Viewers also liked

Thefutureofretail 141207175051-conversion-gate02
Thefutureofretail 141207175051-conversion-gate02Thefutureofretail 141207175051-conversion-gate02
Thefutureofretail 141207175051-conversion-gate02JOHAN BROODCOORENS
 
Martinovich - Wearing Seat Belts Saves Lives
Martinovich - Wearing Seat Belts Saves LivesMartinovich - Wearing Seat Belts Saves Lives
Martinovich - Wearing Seat Belts Saves Liveslibertyville
 
Martinovich prevent truck-accidents
Martinovich prevent truck-accidentsMartinovich prevent truck-accidents
Martinovich prevent truck-accidentslibertyville
 
Unintentional Poisoning is a Major Concern for Young Children
Unintentional Poisoning is a Major Concern for Young ChildrenUnintentional Poisoning is a Major Concern for Young Children
Unintentional Poisoning is a Major Concern for Young Childrenlibertyville
 
Form.analisis jabatan
Form.analisis jabatanForm.analisis jabatan
Form.analisis jabatanYusminus
 
UUD Republik Indonesia tahun 1945
UUD Republik Indonesia tahun 1945UUD Republik Indonesia tahun 1945
UUD Republik Indonesia tahun 1945Luthfi Syuhada
 
Hoe verbinden met Acerta op Doccle?
Hoe verbinden met Acerta op Doccle?Hoe verbinden met Acerta op Doccle?
Hoe verbinden met Acerta op Doccle?Doccle
 

Viewers also liked (10)

BV_Shanmuka_Srinivas_
BV_Shanmuka_Srinivas_BV_Shanmuka_Srinivas_
BV_Shanmuka_Srinivas_
 
Thefutureofretail 141207175051-conversion-gate02
Thefutureofretail 141207175051-conversion-gate02Thefutureofretail 141207175051-conversion-gate02
Thefutureofretail 141207175051-conversion-gate02
 
DrYRR cv.vc c
DrYRR cv.vc cDrYRR cv.vc c
DrYRR cv.vc c
 
Martinovich - Wearing Seat Belts Saves Lives
Martinovich - Wearing Seat Belts Saves LivesMartinovich - Wearing Seat Belts Saves Lives
Martinovich - Wearing Seat Belts Saves Lives
 
Martinovich prevent truck-accidents
Martinovich prevent truck-accidentsMartinovich prevent truck-accidents
Martinovich prevent truck-accidents
 
Unintentional Poisoning is a Major Concern for Young Children
Unintentional Poisoning is a Major Concern for Young ChildrenUnintentional Poisoning is a Major Concern for Young Children
Unintentional Poisoning is a Major Concern for Young Children
 
HIEXpress SC WJ
HIEXpress SC WJHIEXpress SC WJ
HIEXpress SC WJ
 
Form.analisis jabatan
Form.analisis jabatanForm.analisis jabatan
Form.analisis jabatan
 
UUD Republik Indonesia tahun 1945
UUD Republik Indonesia tahun 1945UUD Republik Indonesia tahun 1945
UUD Republik Indonesia tahun 1945
 
Hoe verbinden met Acerta op Doccle?
Hoe verbinden met Acerta op Doccle?Hoe verbinden met Acerta op Doccle?
Hoe verbinden met Acerta op Doccle?
 

Similar to Role of Carbon Finance Support Instruments in Africa

Private Sector Perspective on the Green Climate Fund_AfDB 210916
Private Sector Perspective on the Green Climate Fund_AfDB 210916Private Sector Perspective on the Green Climate Fund_AfDB 210916
Private Sector Perspective on the Green Climate Fund_AfDB 210916Gori Daniel
 
IHA 2013 World Congress: GDF Suez: Climate change: Four dimensions for hydrop...
IHA 2013 World Congress: GDF Suez: Climate change: Four dimensions for hydrop...IHA 2013 World Congress: GDF Suez: Climate change: Four dimensions for hydrop...
IHA 2013 World Congress: GDF Suez: Climate change: Four dimensions for hydrop...International Hydropower Association
 
Economic Brief - Innovation and Productivity North Africa 2014
Economic Brief - Innovation and Productivity North Africa 2014Economic Brief - Innovation and Productivity North Africa 2014
Economic Brief - Innovation and Productivity North Africa 2014Dr Lendy Spires
 
Green Industrialisation story Q32015
Green Industrialisation story Q32015Green Industrialisation story Q32015
Green Industrialisation story Q32015Thabo Thulare
 
CEFIM Roadmap Overview - offshore wind and green hydrogen under the Clean Ene...
CEFIM Roadmap Overview - offshore wind and green hydrogen under the Clean Ene...CEFIM Roadmap Overview - offshore wind and green hydrogen under the Clean Ene...
CEFIM Roadmap Overview - offshore wind and green hydrogen under the Clean Ene...OECD Environment
 
Current (and best) practices in financing industry decarbonisation: Wale Shon...
Current (and best) practices in financing industry decarbonisation: Wale Shon...Current (and best) practices in financing industry decarbonisation: Wale Shon...
Current (and best) practices in financing industry decarbonisation: Wale Shon...OECD Environment
 
A national investment infrastructure bank {nib} presentation 1 11-11(01)
A national investment infrastructure bank {nib} presentation 1 11-11(01)A national investment infrastructure bank {nib} presentation 1 11-11(01)
A national investment infrastructure bank {nib} presentation 1 11-11(01)Nigel Campbell
 
20081124 cdm-fdi paper 2 rs final
20081124 cdm-fdi paper 2 rs final20081124 cdm-fdi paper 2 rs final
20081124 cdm-fdi paper 2 rs finalLichia Saner-Yiu
 
Development finance impact project
Development finance impact projectDevelopment finance impact project
Development finance impact projectAbel Owotemu, PMP
 
How are African banks coping with Climate Change
How are African banks coping with Climate ChangeHow are African banks coping with Climate Change
How are African banks coping with Climate ChangeFrancois Stepman
 
Improving Public Sector Infrastructure Investment by Fernando Fernholz
Improving Public Sector Infrastructure Investment by Fernando FernholzImproving Public Sector Infrastructure Investment by Fernando Fernholz
Improving Public Sector Infrastructure Investment by Fernando FernholzOECD Governance
 
Ensuring affordability, economic viability and fiscal sustainability - Gerd S...
Ensuring affordability, economic viability and fiscal sustainability - Gerd S...Ensuring affordability, economic viability and fiscal sustainability - Gerd S...
Ensuring affordability, economic viability and fiscal sustainability - Gerd S...OECD Governance
 
Developing an investment strategy for a private direct investor
Developing an investment strategy for a private direct investorDeveloping an investment strategy for a private direct investor
Developing an investment strategy for a private direct investorSenia Nhamo
 
Carbon Finance Risks and Opportunities
Carbon Finance Risks and OpportunitiesCarbon Finance Risks and Opportunities
Carbon Finance Risks and OpportunitiesACX
 
20160323 EEP opens calls for proposals
20160323 EEP opens calls for proposals20160323 EEP opens calls for proposals
20160323 EEP opens calls for proposalsWim Jonker Klunne
 
Introduction to competitive supplier dev prog(1)
Introduction to competitive supplier dev prog(1)Introduction to competitive supplier dev prog(1)
Introduction to competitive supplier dev prog(1)Dr Lendy Spires
 

Similar to Role of Carbon Finance Support Instruments in Africa (20)

Private Sector Perspective on the Green Climate Fund_AfDB 210916
Private Sector Perspective on the Green Climate Fund_AfDB 210916Private Sector Perspective on the Green Climate Fund_AfDB 210916
Private Sector Perspective on the Green Climate Fund_AfDB 210916
 
Economic transformation, industrialization and extractives: At the core of Ag...
Economic transformation, industrialization and extractives: At the core of Ag...Economic transformation, industrialization and extractives: At the core of Ag...
Economic transformation, industrialization and extractives: At the core of Ag...
 
IHA 2013 World Congress: GDF Suez: Climate change: Four dimensions for hydrop...
IHA 2013 World Congress: GDF Suez: Climate change: Four dimensions for hydrop...IHA 2013 World Congress: GDF Suez: Climate change: Four dimensions for hydrop...
IHA 2013 World Congress: GDF Suez: Climate change: Four dimensions for hydrop...
 
Economic Brief - Innovation and Productivity North Africa 2014
Economic Brief - Innovation and Productivity North Africa 2014Economic Brief - Innovation and Productivity North Africa 2014
Economic Brief - Innovation and Productivity North Africa 2014
 
Green Industrialisation story Q32015
Green Industrialisation story Q32015Green Industrialisation story Q32015
Green Industrialisation story Q32015
 
Africa fdi
Africa fdiAfrica fdi
Africa fdi
 
CEFIM Roadmap Overview - offshore wind and green hydrogen under the Clean Ene...
CEFIM Roadmap Overview - offshore wind and green hydrogen under the Clean Ene...CEFIM Roadmap Overview - offshore wind and green hydrogen under the Clean Ene...
CEFIM Roadmap Overview - offshore wind and green hydrogen under the Clean Ene...
 
Overcoming barriers to international investment in clean energy
Overcoming barriers to international investment in clean energyOvercoming barriers to international investment in clean energy
Overcoming barriers to international investment in clean energy
 
MENA Region PPP Development Strategy and Success Framework
MENA Region PPP Development Strategy and Success FrameworkMENA Region PPP Development Strategy and Success Framework
MENA Region PPP Development Strategy and Success Framework
 
Current (and best) practices in financing industry decarbonisation: Wale Shon...
Current (and best) practices in financing industry decarbonisation: Wale Shon...Current (and best) practices in financing industry decarbonisation: Wale Shon...
Current (and best) practices in financing industry decarbonisation: Wale Shon...
 
A national investment infrastructure bank {nib} presentation 1 11-11(01)
A national investment infrastructure bank {nib} presentation 1 11-11(01)A national investment infrastructure bank {nib} presentation 1 11-11(01)
A national investment infrastructure bank {nib} presentation 1 11-11(01)
 
20081124 cdm-fdi paper 2 rs final
20081124 cdm-fdi paper 2 rs final20081124 cdm-fdi paper 2 rs final
20081124 cdm-fdi paper 2 rs final
 
Development finance impact project
Development finance impact projectDevelopment finance impact project
Development finance impact project
 
How are African banks coping with Climate Change
How are African banks coping with Climate ChangeHow are African banks coping with Climate Change
How are African banks coping with Climate Change
 
Improving Public Sector Infrastructure Investment by Fernando Fernholz
Improving Public Sector Infrastructure Investment by Fernando FernholzImproving Public Sector Infrastructure Investment by Fernando Fernholz
Improving Public Sector Infrastructure Investment by Fernando Fernholz
 
Ensuring affordability, economic viability and fiscal sustainability - Gerd S...
Ensuring affordability, economic viability and fiscal sustainability - Gerd S...Ensuring affordability, economic viability and fiscal sustainability - Gerd S...
Ensuring affordability, economic viability and fiscal sustainability - Gerd S...
 
Developing an investment strategy for a private direct investor
Developing an investment strategy for a private direct investorDeveloping an investment strategy for a private direct investor
Developing an investment strategy for a private direct investor
 
Carbon Finance Risks and Opportunities
Carbon Finance Risks and OpportunitiesCarbon Finance Risks and Opportunities
Carbon Finance Risks and Opportunities
 
20160323 EEP opens calls for proposals
20160323 EEP opens calls for proposals20160323 EEP opens calls for proposals
20160323 EEP opens calls for proposals
 
Introduction to competitive supplier dev prog(1)
Introduction to competitive supplier dev prog(1)Introduction to competitive supplier dev prog(1)
Introduction to competitive supplier dev prog(1)
 

Recently uploaded

(ANAYA) Call Girls Hadapsar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(ANAYA) Call Girls Hadapsar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(ANAYA) Call Girls Hadapsar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(ANAYA) Call Girls Hadapsar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Serviceranjana rawat
 
(NANDITA) Hadapsar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune ...
(NANDITA) Hadapsar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune ...(NANDITA) Hadapsar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune ...
(NANDITA) Hadapsar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune ...ranjana rawat
 
Russian Call Girls Nashik Anjali 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
Russian Call Girls Nashik Anjali 7001305949 Independent Escort Service NashikRussian Call Girls Nashik Anjali 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
Russian Call Girls Nashik Anjali 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashikranjana rawat
 
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Parvati Darshan 6297143586 Call Hot I...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Parvati Darshan  6297143586 Call Hot I...Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Parvati Darshan  6297143586 Call Hot I...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Parvati Darshan 6297143586 Call Hot I...Call Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
VIP Call Girls Moti Ganpur ( Hyderabad ) Phone 8250192130 | ₹5k To 25k With R...
VIP Call Girls Moti Ganpur ( Hyderabad ) Phone 8250192130 | ₹5k To 25k With R...VIP Call Girls Moti Ganpur ( Hyderabad ) Phone 8250192130 | ₹5k To 25k With R...
VIP Call Girls Moti Ganpur ( Hyderabad ) Phone 8250192130 | ₹5k To 25k With R...Suhani Kapoor
 
(PARI) Viman Nagar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune ...
(PARI) Viman Nagar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune ...(PARI) Viman Nagar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune ...
(PARI) Viman Nagar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune ...ranjana rawat
 
(ANIKA) Call Girls Wagholi ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(ANIKA) Call Girls Wagholi ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(ANIKA) Call Girls Wagholi ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(ANIKA) Call Girls Wagholi ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Serviceranjana rawat
 
Freegle User Survey as visual display - BH
Freegle User Survey as visual display - BHFreegle User Survey as visual display - BH
Freegle User Survey as visual display - BHbill846304
 
Horizon Net Zero Dawn – keynote slides by Ben Abraham
Horizon Net Zero Dawn – keynote slides by Ben AbrahamHorizon Net Zero Dawn – keynote slides by Ben Abraham
Horizon Net Zero Dawn – keynote slides by Ben Abrahamssuserbb03ff
 
Call Girls Service Nagpur Aditi Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls Service Nagpur Aditi Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur EscortsCall Girls Service Nagpur Aditi Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls Service Nagpur Aditi Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur EscortsCall Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Kalighat 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Kalighat 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Kalighat 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Kalighat 👉 8250192130 Available With Roomdivyansh0kumar0
 
The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Shirwal 8250192130 Will You Miss This Cha...
The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Shirwal 8250192130 Will You Miss This Cha...The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Shirwal 8250192130 Will You Miss This Cha...
The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Shirwal 8250192130 Will You Miss This Cha...ranjana rawat
 
VIP Call Girls Service Bandlaguda Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130
VIP Call Girls Service Bandlaguda Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130VIP Call Girls Service Bandlaguda Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130
VIP Call Girls Service Bandlaguda Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130Suhani Kapoor
 
Low Rate Call Girls Bikaner Anika 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Bikaner
Low Rate Call Girls Bikaner Anika 8250192130 Independent Escort Service BikanerLow Rate Call Girls Bikaner Anika 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Bikaner
Low Rate Call Girls Bikaner Anika 8250192130 Independent Escort Service BikanerSuhani Kapoor
 
Call Girls South Delhi Delhi reach out to us at ☎ 9711199012
Call Girls South Delhi Delhi reach out to us at ☎ 9711199012Call Girls South Delhi Delhi reach out to us at ☎ 9711199012
Call Girls South Delhi Delhi reach out to us at ☎ 9711199012sapnasaifi408
 
VIP Call Girl Gorakhpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Gorakhpur
VIP Call Girl Gorakhpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service GorakhpurVIP Call Girl Gorakhpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Gorakhpur
VIP Call Girl Gorakhpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service GorakhpurSuhani Kapoor
 
9873940964 High Profile Call Girls Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...
9873940964 High Profile  Call Girls  Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...9873940964 High Profile  Call Girls  Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...
9873940964 High Profile Call Girls Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...Delhi Escorts
 
Environmental Toxicology (environmental biology)
Environmental Toxicology (environmental biology)Environmental Toxicology (environmental biology)
Environmental Toxicology (environmental biology)RaviPrajapat11
 

Recently uploaded (20)

(ANAYA) Call Girls Hadapsar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(ANAYA) Call Girls Hadapsar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(ANAYA) Call Girls Hadapsar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(ANAYA) Call Girls Hadapsar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
 
(NANDITA) Hadapsar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune ...
(NANDITA) Hadapsar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune ...(NANDITA) Hadapsar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune ...
(NANDITA) Hadapsar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune ...
 
Russian Call Girls Nashik Anjali 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
Russian Call Girls Nashik Anjali 7001305949 Independent Escort Service NashikRussian Call Girls Nashik Anjali 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
Russian Call Girls Nashik Anjali 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
 
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Parvati Darshan 6297143586 Call Hot I...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Parvati Darshan  6297143586 Call Hot I...Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Parvati Darshan  6297143586 Call Hot I...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Parvati Darshan 6297143586 Call Hot I...
 
Escort Service Call Girls In Shakti Nagar, 99530°56974 Delhi NCR
Escort Service Call Girls In Shakti Nagar, 99530°56974 Delhi NCREscort Service Call Girls In Shakti Nagar, 99530°56974 Delhi NCR
Escort Service Call Girls In Shakti Nagar, 99530°56974 Delhi NCR
 
VIP Call Girls Moti Ganpur ( Hyderabad ) Phone 8250192130 | ₹5k To 25k With R...
VIP Call Girls Moti Ganpur ( Hyderabad ) Phone 8250192130 | ₹5k To 25k With R...VIP Call Girls Moti Ganpur ( Hyderabad ) Phone 8250192130 | ₹5k To 25k With R...
VIP Call Girls Moti Ganpur ( Hyderabad ) Phone 8250192130 | ₹5k To 25k With R...
 
(PARI) Viman Nagar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune ...
(PARI) Viman Nagar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune ...(PARI) Viman Nagar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune ...
(PARI) Viman Nagar Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pune ...
 
(ANIKA) Call Girls Wagholi ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(ANIKA) Call Girls Wagholi ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(ANIKA) Call Girls Wagholi ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(ANIKA) Call Girls Wagholi ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
 
Freegle User Survey as visual display - BH
Freegle User Survey as visual display - BHFreegle User Survey as visual display - BH
Freegle User Survey as visual display - BH
 
Horizon Net Zero Dawn – keynote slides by Ben Abraham
Horizon Net Zero Dawn – keynote slides by Ben AbrahamHorizon Net Zero Dawn – keynote slides by Ben Abraham
Horizon Net Zero Dawn – keynote slides by Ben Abraham
 
Call Girls Service Nagpur Aditi Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls Service Nagpur Aditi Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur EscortsCall Girls Service Nagpur Aditi Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls Service Nagpur Aditi Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Kalighat 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Kalighat 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Kalighat 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Kalighat 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
 
Call Girls In R.K. Puram 9953056974 Escorts ServiCe In Delhi Ncr
Call Girls In R.K. Puram 9953056974 Escorts ServiCe In Delhi NcrCall Girls In R.K. Puram 9953056974 Escorts ServiCe In Delhi Ncr
Call Girls In R.K. Puram 9953056974 Escorts ServiCe In Delhi Ncr
 
The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Shirwal 8250192130 Will You Miss This Cha...
The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Shirwal 8250192130 Will You Miss This Cha...The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Shirwal 8250192130 Will You Miss This Cha...
The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Shirwal 8250192130 Will You Miss This Cha...
 
VIP Call Girls Service Bandlaguda Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130
VIP Call Girls Service Bandlaguda Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130VIP Call Girls Service Bandlaguda Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130
VIP Call Girls Service Bandlaguda Hyderabad Call +91-8250192130
 
Low Rate Call Girls Bikaner Anika 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Bikaner
Low Rate Call Girls Bikaner Anika 8250192130 Independent Escort Service BikanerLow Rate Call Girls Bikaner Anika 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Bikaner
Low Rate Call Girls Bikaner Anika 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Bikaner
 
Call Girls South Delhi Delhi reach out to us at ☎ 9711199012
Call Girls South Delhi Delhi reach out to us at ☎ 9711199012Call Girls South Delhi Delhi reach out to us at ☎ 9711199012
Call Girls South Delhi Delhi reach out to us at ☎ 9711199012
 
VIP Call Girl Gorakhpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Gorakhpur
VIP Call Girl Gorakhpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service GorakhpurVIP Call Girl Gorakhpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Gorakhpur
VIP Call Girl Gorakhpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Gorakhpur
 
9873940964 High Profile Call Girls Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...
9873940964 High Profile  Call Girls  Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...9873940964 High Profile  Call Girls  Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...
9873940964 High Profile Call Girls Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...
 
Environmental Toxicology (environmental biology)
Environmental Toxicology (environmental biology)Environmental Toxicology (environmental biology)
Environmental Toxicology (environmental biology)
 

Role of Carbon Finance Support Instruments in Africa

  • 1. The Energy and Resources Institute TERI–ACPCPOLICYBRIEF2013/2 Background The Kyoto Protocol never prescribed how CDM projects must be distributed among host countries, though interest in regional distribution patterns have been high ever since. While the Kyoto mechanism prompted successful investments in most of the emerging economies across the world, some regions like Africa saw a dampener. Africa policy panel (in 2010) concluded the average external financing need (2010– 2020 p.a.) for mitigation activities (including REDD+) to be approximately $13–26 billion. While CDM helped in leveraging finance for emission reduction projects (by creating incentives), the investments in Africa for CDM project development was seen to be meagre. Table 1: Regional distribution of CDM projects registered and undergoing registration Regional distribution of CDM projects shows that 27 African countries with an existing DNA do not have registered projects till now while the countries which do, the number spans between 1 to 10 projects only. Geographical distribution of CDM exhibits large share of projects for countries such as South Africa, Kenya, Egypt, Morocco, Nigeria, and Uganda. Sector-wise distribution of CDM projects illustrates negligible share of projects in every CDM sector for the continent as a whole. Differences in level of CDM participation is even more pronounced when measured in terms of CERs by region. Table 2: Share of CERs from CDM projects by region Swati Agarwal Regions Countries without a DNA & zero projects Countries with DNA & zero projects Countries with 1–10 projects Countries with 11–100 projects Countries with >100 projects Africa (33) 5 27 18 3 0 Asia and Pacific (13) 11 11 17 7 2 Europe and Central Asia 1 4 8 1 0 Latin America and Carib- bean (1) 4 8 12 7 2 China and India 0 0 0 0 2 Regions Total Small- scale projects Large- scale projects Non- Industrial gas projects Projects under validation Africa 3% 2% 3% 3% 5% China 68% 41% 70% 67% 57% India 7% 19% 6% 8% 12% Rest of the World 22% 38% 21% 22% 26% Source: UNFCCC, Benefits of the Clean Development Mechanism Report 2012 Africa accounts for only 3% of the total Certified Emission Reductions (CERs) and the share of non- Industrial gas projects also remains low for the continent. This denotes that the sectors which had potential for mitigation in Africa were also not exploited within the mechanism. Moreover ‘CER generated as a share of national emissions’ is also low for the continent which amounts to approximately 2% of national emissions, while it is at 5% and 6% of national emissions for India and China, respectively (UNFCCC 2012). Only 32 CDM projects from Africa (out of 148 registered CDM projects) have been issued CERs till now. A possibility Source: UNFCCC, Benefits of the Clean Development Mechanism Report 2012
  • 2. 2 is that some of these projects are still idling at the development stage due to lack of money for project execution. Though Africa contributed least to the global GHG emissions in the past, its potential in carbon markets relies both in its ability to produce a wide range of carbon mitigation projects as well as its possibilities for sustainable development. Since Africa is growing at above the global average — generating consumer demands — growth from underdevelopment and high renewable energy sources offer good potential for carbon mitigation and avoided emissions in Africa. The small percentage of CERs as a share of national emissions in Africa is worrisome and demands attention. This suggests that there are factors other than national emission reduction potential in Africa that discouraged CDM investments in the continent. With provision of suitable market-based opportunities to reduce and/or avoid emissions conducive to African circumstances, the small share of investments in conventional energies in Africa could be seen as an opportunity to transform it into one of the cleanest energy generation continents of the world. For this, the barriers and opportunities need to be realized, to effectively utilize opportunities and enhance country readiness for future market mechanisms. Barriers particularly impacting CDM in Africa Project cost recovery Attractiveness to investments in CDM projects particularly depend upon the nature of economy, type of finance availability, impact of carbon finance on project cost recovery, etc. Studies quote that Africa’s potential primarily lie in projects with ‘low carbon credit contribution to the total project cost recovery’ (such as landfill gas, renewable energy sector, LULUCF, etc.), which dis-incentivize CDM investors from investing in African projects However, the fact that the African share of projects even in the so called low attractive sectors is negligible as compared to China and India (as seen in Table 2) reflects that there are barriers other than the ‘nature of project availability’ in a country which drives the motivation of CDM investors. Cleaner grids With a comparatively small share of investments in conventional energy systems in comparison to economies such as China and India, the grids in some African economies are cleaner. Further, with lower grid emission factors, the returns to CDM credits are also lower which discourages investments, as in the case of Ethiopia. Hence, a large share of CDM projects in Africa are still idling at development stage, with developers lacking money to implement projects effectively. Transaction costs ‘Higher transaction costs’ is an important determinant that drives investors away. The dispersed nature of projects and relatively sparse DOE presence in the continent runs CDM projects in Africa into higher transaction costs of project execution. This in turn reduces the financial viability of the projects thereby increasing investment risks, which demotivate investors from investing. National CDM capacity A necessary but not a sufficient determinant of CDM uptake in a country is its national CDM capacity. Some of the African countries do not have a DNA till now. Moreover, lack of awareness of the CDM in the financial sector and lack of local CDM consulting capacity is also expected to act as a barrier for CDM uptake in Africa. While successful CDM projects build awareness and private sector capacity to take up more such activities, lack of experience with CDM in Africa makes it difficult for the countries to cope with CDM system complexities and modalities. Suppressed demand In 2011, only 34.57% of the population in Sub-Saharan Africa had access to electricity. Moreover, the energy consumption per capita in Africa is also low. This in turn leads to the problem of suppressed demands wherein the actual demand for energy is not equal to the desired demand for energy in a country. Since CDM in its methodology takes the baseline from the current level of energy use in a country (which is very low for Africa on account of underdevelopment) and do not take into account the future projections of energy consumptions (which is likely to increase with economic expansion), the feasibility/profitability of CDM projects in Africa diminishes. Investment climate in Africa: A barrier? It is well understood that opportunities in carbon markets would be limited if the basic framework for investment and markets are weak within a country. This is because market-based mechanisms presuppose that markets in a country are well developed and the private sector is well mobilized within the system to undertake project developments.
  • 3. 3  Studies reveal that the investment climate in the host country is a crucial determinant of CDM activity (Michaelowa and Buen, 2012)  The funds available for domestic investments, such as from domestic financial institutions and private sectors’ internal funds, also affects CDM activities in a country (Michaelowa and Buen, 2012).  The extent of ‘market maturities’ for private sector activities is also expected to be crucial. Table 3 summarizes Africa’s development progress between 2005 and 2012 in comparison to China and India and derives results from the same. Table 3: Africa’s development progress between 2005 and 2012 in comparison to China and India General investment climate The general investment climate of the host country is considered to be an important determinant for CDM activities. Indicators such as cost of business start-up, Global Competitiveness Index, FDI, and others have been taken to analyse the investment climate in Africa. Data reveals that since 2005 (the beginning of CDM), some considerable efforts have been made in Africa for promoting more business friendly environment. The cost of business start-ups has fallen from 217 to 64.5 (%GNI per capita) and the time required for business start-up has almost halved. These buoyant prospects are increasingly attracting the Foreign Direct Investments (FDI) into the continent. Since 2000s, FDI across the continent has increased to five-fold leading to its growth and economic expansion (AfDB, 2012). However, progress could be expected to be slower than potential on account of the slow improvement in the Global Competitiveness Index and asymmetric trade benefits due to lack of regional integration among neighbouring countries in Africa. It is a well-known fact that as Africa integrates its economies and invests in better infrastructure, it can achieve economies of scale in production, leading to better management of shared resources and effective utilization of its capacity for joint action on regional public goods. Its markets can expand attracting larger private sector participation, increasing competitiveness, and attracting faster investments. The intra-African trade currently stands at only 108.4 billion USD in 2012 which has increased marginally from 47.4 billion USD in 2005. Despite improvements in the general investment climate in Africa since 2005, its ‘Global Competitiveness Index’ has not improved substantially and its ‘business extent of disclosure index’ also features way below that of China and India. Hence, in high capital investment ventures (riskier projects) like that of CDM, attracting investors would require a strong policy push within the system concurrent to the improvements in general investment climate in Africa. Domestic financial Sector The availability of funds from the domestic financial sector for leveraging finance also impacts CDM uptake in a region. In Africa, the bank assets to GDP ratio for all countries are way below that of South Africa which stands at 106% of total banking assets as a percentage of GDP. Though the asset value of banks has increased rapidly over the years, the market development is building up from an extremely low level. Moreover, despite several reforms in the national financial Indicator All African Countries China India Baseline 2005 Current 2012 Current 2012 Current 2012 Investment climate and domestic financial sector GDP per capita 833 953 3348.01 1106.797 Access to electricity (% population) -- 34.57*^ 99.7c 75c Global competitiveness index 3.4 3.6 4.83 4.32 Cost of business start- up (% GNI per capita) 217 64.5 2.1 49.8 Business extent of disclosure index 4.6* 4.9* 10 7 Time required for business start-up (Days) 58 33 33 27 FDI (% GDP) 3.27* 3.3* 3.03 1.7^ Domestic credit to private sector(% GDP) 63.79* 61.36* 131.60 51.49 Strength of legal rights index (0=weak, 10-strong) 4.4 5.8 6.0 8.0 % share of global trade 2.5 3.1 10.4 2 Intra-African Trade (billion USD) 47.4 108.4 -- -- Governance and transparency Country Policy and Institutional Assessment (CPIA) Financial sector rating (1=low, 6=high) 2.9 3.0 -- 3.5 CPIA, fiscal policy rating (1=low, 6=high) 3.3 2.9 -- 3.5 Number of fragile countries in Africa 20 19 -- -- Note: *= Data available for Sub-Saharan Africa, ^ = 2011 data, C= 2010 data Source: Author’s own compilation based on African Development Bank, World Bank Group, International Energy Agency, CDM Pipeline database, Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development
  • 4. 4 institutions in Africa, the financial sector remained relatively small and fragmented. The minimum capital requirement by banks in African states is generally below $10 million (Price Waterhouse Coopers, 2008). For example, Nigeria consolidated from more than 80 to 25 banks in 2007, by way of raising the minimum capital requirement to $200 million. This is one reason that in most economies in Africa, sometimes capital is not available for all kind of investments including investments in CDM activities. In coming years, other countries are likely to follow suit in order to streamline and better capitalize their domestic financial sector. The availability of domestic capital is considered significant because it is observed that the countries where the domestic credit to private sector (% GDP) is higher, the number of CDM projects is also higher. Some countries showing this trend are South Africa, Kenya, and Egypt. This is also essential because credit lending by domestic banks signal confidence in the markets to the foreign investors as well. These findings are consistent with other studies which show that a week financial sector and/or limited supply of finance for domestic investments limits CDM uptake in many African Countries and LDCs (Castro and Michaelowa 2011; Byigero et al. 2010; Schmidt-Traub 2011; Burian et al. 2011). Private sector mobilization In Africa, SMEs make up the bulk of private sector economy and hence are extremely averse to risks and vulnerable to incremental costs. In the upper middle income countries in Africa where markets are sufficiently developed and banking system is reliable, capital is not always available for all kinds of investments including CDM. In such situations these countries (such as India, China, and South Africa) are better able to finance projects with their domestic budgets combined with international flows and private equity. While on the other hand, countries in low- income categories have small market capitalization of private sector, insufficient domestic budgets, and unreliable banking systems which makes investments in CDM kind activities extremely difficult. Thus, private sector players do not have the capacity to rely on its own funds unless supported and mobilized by public vehicles. Institutional capacity Institutional frailty, fear of regulatory changes, lack of coordination mechanisms across various levels of government, governance, and conflicts also puts constraints on the overall attractiveness to investments — 19 out of 54 countries in Africa (33 LDCs) feature as ‘fragile’ in the global rankings by the African Development Bank (AfDB) (2012). The Country Policy and Institutional Assessment (CPIA) rating of the African fiscal policy is lower that of other emerging economies under study. Also, the ‘strength of legal rights Index’ though have increased significantly from 4.4 in 2005 to 5.8 in 2012 for all African countries, most of the countries still stands at lower index levels. Relevance of carbon funds and facilities for African carbon market growth Though mitigation potential existed in Africa, CDM as a leveraging instrument did not work in the continent on account of several barriers. While some of the CDM specific barriers in Africa have been addressed with constant efforts to modify the methodologies and modalities such that they are conducive to the African circumstances like ‘adoption of PoAs’, ‘methodology for interstate electricity connection developed by AfDB’ etc,; the issue of leveraging investments for CDM activities remained a challenge for the continent. Over the recent years, the proliferation of instruments such as carbon funds and facilities are seen likely to increase the appetite to leverage finances and support for CDM and future market-based activities in the continent. A wide range of instruments have been established by the Multilateral Bank, Regional Development Banks, and Bilateral Financial Institutions to catalyse growth of carbon markets in Africa. They not only address some of the existing market barriers (like high perceived risks, high transaction costs etc.), but also help in leveraging private finances (domestic/ international) for the underlying carbon market investments. Carbon funds as credit purchasers Carbon funds are investment vehicles which raise public/private capital to invest directly in projects to reduce GHGs and/or purchase carbon credits using a standardized purchase agreement (ERPA). They have been playing a crucial role in mitigating risks from CDM markets such as risk of delivery, portfolio diversification, risk from volatile credit prices, etc., and their significance is well observed in their exponential growth trend from a single fund (Prototype carbon fund) in 1999 to 96 funds in 2009 (CDC Climat Research, 2010). In the span of these years, the carbon funds have also diversified their activities from pure carbon credit buying to other support activities. However, the role of carbon
  • 5. 5 funds as credit purchasers in Africa is very meagre. Data reveals that a major share of credits buying in Africa is by private sector buyers (35%) followed by financial Institutions (8%), government buyers (5%), carbon funds (5%), and combination buyers (5%). Out of the credits bought jointly, 31% of projects feature carbon funds as one of the joint buyers. Results from CDC Climate Research (2010) also the markets. These public institutions help fill the gap for the asymmetry of information among the different stakeholder groups in project development, thereby build trust in private enterprises and lead to more maturity in the market with their participation. Since a few years, many institutions such as World Bank, UNFCCC, AfDB, UNDP, EIB, and some private sector companies are playing significant role in leveraging Joint Buyers, (5%) Government Buyers, (5%) Not mentioned, (42%) Carbon Funds, (5%) Private Buyers, (35%) Financial Institution, (8%) Govt + Pvt + FI, 46% Govt + Pvt + FI, 15% Govt + FI, 8% CF + Pvt, 15% CF + FI, 8% CF + Govt + Pvt, 8% Percentageshareofjointbuyers resonates our findings. Study highlights that major credits from CDM are bought by carbon funds in China and India and to a lesser extent in Africa. Even then, the funds have bought credits in only Egypt (5), Kenya (2), Morocco (3), Nigeria (1), South Africa (1), Tunisia (1), and Uganda (4), which are primarily located in the northern and eastern geographies of Africa. Though carbon funds are the primary buyers of credits from PoAs as well in most of the emerging economies such as China, Bangladesh, Thailand, and Vietnam, not a single CDM credit has been purchased by them in Africa. Carbon funds as CDM consultants While role of carbon funds as credit buyers is not seen to play a significant role in Africa, it is observed that most of the CDM and PoA projects were developed and assisted by the funds and their parent institutions as PDD consultants. Figure 1: Credit buyers’ portfolio in Africa Source: Authors’ own calculations based on CDM pipeline database (as on September 2013). Notes: Govt: Government Buyers; FI: Financial Institutions; Pvt: Private Buyers; CF: Carbon Funds Funds/facilities leveraging finance Most of the multilateral/bilateral/regional institutions have set up funds and facilities that help leverage capital for investments in CDM activities by project developers. These are in the form of upfront/seed financing, provision of debt loans, provision of project equities, concessional loans, and even grants [refer Annex I]. Funds/facilities building institutional capacities One of most promising feature of the facilities is the fact that they are designed with an approach for long-term sustainability such that it aims at creating the ‘readiness/preparedness’ in countries for availing benefits from the emerging market instruments. In this regard, while some facilities aim at building the capacity for the government organizations, others focus more on building capacity for the domestic financial system, thereby building reliability and confidence in
  • 6. 6 finance for Carbon mitigation activities and capacity building in country stakeholders. Some institutions have prime focus on specific countries and some also earmark their sectors of implementation. For Instance, while KfW carbon fund has its key focus in sectors of renewable energy and afforestation, African Biofuels and Renewable Energy Company (ABREC) focuses mainly on biofuels and landfills. Moreover, some of the facilities developed by the AfDB, offer support and capacity to projects featuring in the banks’ pipeline. In addition to the readiness building activities of the funds and financial institutions, they are increasingly beginning to look at the risk mitigation from African markets for leveraging private sector participation and also provide assistance with respect to new market mechanisms post-2012, and NAMAs. Recommendations and a way forward Despite surge of support instruments in Africa to leverage finances and upscale CDM activities in the continent, a strong policy push is needed in the continent to catalyse the private sector activities in carbon markets. Some recommendations in this direction are:  One of the priorities for Africa to increase its access to international funds would be to manage its shared resources and to expand its domestic markets via regional integration in order to attain global competitiveness.  The banking sector in Africa can play an important role in assessing the soundness of project proposals. This is because foreign lenders/ international investors find it easy and acceptable to lend to entities which are appraised by local FIs/banks/ local agencies. For Instance, in India, IREDA and few other banks have set appraisal procedure for the CDM projects in renewable energy sector.  In order to facilitate the CDM projects expeditiously in Africa, the financial intermediaries, such as energy service companies, mutual funds, etc., which are involved conventionally in project financing, can orient resources and approval mechanism towards CDM project as well, in their sector of operations. For example, the appraisal mechanism is already in place in India as an arrangement between World Bank PCF and IDFC (India). After a due diligence of IDFC’s appraisal mechanism, PCF decided to fast track the project PINs proposed through it.  The guarantees such as the Partial Risk Guarantees (PRGs), Multilateral Investment Guarantee (MIGA), and Export Credit Guarantees (ECG) are important in mitigating country risks in Africa.  Institutions such as International Finance Corporation (IFC) have introduced some value- added financial products to help mitigate risks in emerging markets, carbon delivery guarantee products, and provision for upfront finances/ loans to carbon projects with a prerequisite of having a mature market in place. The role of public institutions and other support instruments is therefore crucial in mobilizing funds for private sector activities for market maturity and newer market developments necessary for exploiting these opportunities.  There is need for creating role models and for replicating innovative financial schemes such as the revolving fund scheme by the World Bank, Micro-finance lending by ACAD, venture capital funding practiced in India, etc.  Need for host country DOEs or similar institutional arrangements for future carbon market instruments.  Need for push to create new methodologies to address the issue of suppressed demand in the continent. Annex I: Financing and support instruments available for African Carbon markets Programme Year Target Sectors Target Countries Financial Support Poor country focused Capacity-Building Activities Technical assistance Support PoAs/ NMMs/ Post 2012 focus Seed Finance Debt Finance Private Equity Grants DNA Financial Institutions Private Sector World Bank Carbon Finance Unit 2002- 2011 OPEN Most African Countries Elltrix Carbon Credit Program 2012 Solar techno- logies South Africa, Namibia, Mozambique, Swaziland, and Lesotho
  • 7. 7 KfW Carbon Fund 2005 RE, Afforest - African Biofuels and Renewable Energy Co. (ABREC) 2008 RE, Biofuels, landfill Emphasis placed on the ECOWAS countries UNDP MDG Carbon Facility 2007 Open Open Africa Carbon Facility 2011 - Address projects coming from AfDBs lending pipeline UNFCCC Schemes 2010 2012 2013 Open Most African Countries African Carbon Support Program by AfDB 2010 Open Ethiopia, Nigeria, Lagos, Burkina Faso Africa Carbon Ssset Develop- ment Facility (ACAD) 2009 Open Burkina Faso, Kenya, Mozam- bique, Mali, Mauritius, Nigeria, Rwanda, South Africa, Uganda Africa Carbon Credit Exchanges - Open - Africa Carbon Exchange 2011 Open - Carbon Fund for Africa 2012 RE, methani- zation, EE Sub-Saharan Africa EIB Post 2012 Carbon Credit Fund 2008 Wind, waste manage- ment, EE - EIB Carbon Fund in Morocco 2008 RE, EE, waste manage- ment, A&R Morocco - Carbon finance for Agriculture, Silviculture, Conservation, and Action against Deforestation (CASCADe) 2007 LULUCF, bioenergy activities Sub-Saharan Africa NEFCO Carbon Finance and Funds 2008 RE, EE, Fuel switching Africa Notes: **RE - Renewable Energy, EE - Energy Efficiency Source: Authors’ own compilation from various sources World Bank Carbon Finance Unit <https://wbcarbonfinance.org/>, Africa carbon Asset Development Facility <http://www.acadfacility.org/>, Elltrix Carbon credit program <http://www.elltrix.co.za/Property_Developer.php>, UNFCCC Loan scheme <http://www.cdmloanscheme.org>, UNDP’s MDP Carbon Facility <http://www.mdgcarbonfacility.org/>, KfW Carbon Fund <http://www.kfw. de/carbonfund>, Africa carbon Facility <http://www.afdb.org/en/topics-and-sectors/initiatives-partnerships/>, Africa carbon Credit Exchange<http:// www.africacce.com/>, ABREF<http://www.faber-abref.org/index_english.php>, European Investment bank <http://www.eib.org/projects/documents/eib- and-carbon-finance---faq.htm
  • 8. For further details, contact Neha Pahuja Earth Science and Climate Change Division Tel. 24682100 or 41504900 The Energy and Resources Institute (TERI) Fax 24682144 or 24682145 Darbari Seth Block, IHC Complex India +91 • Delhi (0) 11 Lodhi Road E-mail neha.pahuja@teri.res.in New Delhi – 110 003 Web www.teriin.org Reference Alberola, E., & Stephan, N. (2010). Carbon Funds in 2010: Investment in Kyoto Credits and Emissions Reductions. France: CDC Climate Research. Annan, K., Blair, T., Camdessus, M., Eigen, P., & Yunus, M. (2010). Finance for Climate Resilient development in Africa, An agenda for action following the Copenhagen conference . Switzerland: Africa Policy Panel (UNECA). Arens, C., Burian, M., Sterk, W., Schnurr, J., & Beuermann, C. (2011). The CDM Project Potential in Sub-Sahar Africa with focus on selected least developed countries. Germany: Wuppertal and Hamburg. Bahsen, N., Figueres, C., Pedersen, M., Skov, S., Stehr, H. J., & Valdimarsson, J. (2009). Potential use of Micro-financing in support of CDM projects in LDCs. Denmark: NIRAS A/S. World Bank (n.d.). 10 years of experience in carbon finance. Retrieved September 2013, from World Bank Carbon finance unit: http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTCARBONFINANCE/Resources/ Carbon_Fund_12-1-09_web.pdf Boutin-Dufresne, F., Pena, S., Williams, O., & Zawisza, T. A. (2013). Benchmarking Banking Sector Efficiency across regional blocks in Sub-Saharan Africa: What Room for Policy. African Department: International Monetary Fund. Bowden, W. N. (2011, October 13). The future of carbon finance PoAs in a post-2012 world. World Bank Carbon Finance Unit. Brown, J. (Overseas Development Institute) (2009). Carbon Finance in Africa. Africa Partnership Forum. Ethiopia: UNECA. Burian, M., Arens, C., Sterk, W., & Wang-Helmreich, H. (2011). Integrating Africa’s Least Developed countries into the global carbon market: Analyzing CDM implementation barriers. Germany: Wyppertal Institutte for Climate, Environment and Energy & GFA Invest. Available at: http://www.jiko-bmu.de/files/english/application/pdf/ Byigero, A., Clancy, J., & Skutsch, M. (2010). CDM in Sub-Saharn Africa and the prospects of the Nairobi Framework Initiative. Climate Policy, 181-189. Calland, R., Dubosse, N., Mohamed, N., Schalatek, L., Davidson, S. R., & Reyes, O. (2011). No Romance. Mobilizing Climate Finance for Africa. Southern Africa: Henreich Boll Stiftung, Available at: http:// www.boell.org/web/140.html Castro, P., & Michaelowa, A. (2011). Would Preferential access measures be sufficient to overcome current barriers to CDM projects in least developed countries? Climate and Development, 123-142. Collier, P. (2010, June). McKinsey & Company. Retrieved 2013, from http://www.mckinsey.com/insights/economic_studies/the_case_for_ investing_in_africa Cox, M. (2013). Annual Effectiveness Development Review. Tunisia: African Development Bank. Ellis, J., & Kamel, S. (2007). Overcoming barriers to clean development mechanism projects. France: OECD/IEA. Leke, A., Lund, S., Roxburgh, C., & Wamelen, A. v. (2010, June). What’s Driving Africa’s Growth. Retrieved 2013, from McKinsey and Company: http://www.mckinsey.com/insights/economic_studies/ whats_driving_africas_growth Makhooda, S., Caravani, A., Bird, N., & Schalatek, L. (2012, November). Climate Finance in Sub-Saharan Africa. Climate Finance Policy Briefs. ODI, Available at: http://www.odi.org.uk/ publications/6151-climate-finance-sub-saharan-africa. Michaelowa, A., & J, B. (2012). Carbon markets or climate finance? Low carbon and adaptation investment choices for the developing world. london, pp. 1-38: Routedge. Murray, W., Garibaldi, J. A., Hampton, K., Hohne, N., & Jung, M. (2009). Scaling up investment in climate change mitigation activities. Climate Change Capital, Ecofys, energia, GtripleC. PWC. (2008). Into Africa: Investment prospects in the sub-Saharan banking sector. London: Price Waterhouse Coopers. Ryan, L., Selmet, N., & Aasrud, A. (2012). Plugging the Energy efficiency gap with climate finance . France: OECD/IEA. Schmidt - Traub, G. (2011, March). Meeting Africa’s climate finance challenge . Carbon First, pp. 5 - 7. Available at www.ideacarbon. com. Sinclair, G. (2012, July 9 - 11). Options for mobilizing climate finance from private sector. UNEP Finance Initiative. UNFCCC, Availavle at: http://unfccc.int/files/cooperation_support/financial_mechanism/ long-term_finance/application/pdf/sinclair10july2012.pdf. Soren, L., & Michaelowa, A. (2008). Corporate strategies and clean development mechanism: Developing country financing for developed country commitments. Edward Elgar Publishing. Spalding Fecher, R., Achanta, A. N., Erickson, P., Haites, E., Lazarus, M., Pahuja, N., et al. (2012). Assessing the impact of the clean development mechanism. Report commissioned by the High Level Panel on the CDM Policy Dialogue . UNFCCC. (2012). Benefits of the Clean Development Mechanism. Germany: UNFCCC, Available at: cdm.unfccc.int/about/dev_ben/ ABC_2012.pdf UNFCCC. (2012). CDM IN Africa: Finance and support. UNFCCC. Zhu, J. (2012). The correlated factors of the uneven performance of CDM host countries. IEL paper in Comparative Analysis of Institutions, Economics and Law. 1 This policy brief is part of the project ‘Carbon Finance’ supported by the African Climate Policy Centre, UNECA, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.