SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 5
Download to read offline
20/10/23, 12:45 PM
Who’s Responsible for the Gaza Hospital Explosion? Here’s Why It’s Hard to Know What’s Real | WIRED
Page 1 of 5
https://www.wired.com/story/al-ahli-baptist-hospital-explosion-disinf…2Fstory%2Fal-ahli-baptist-hospital-explosion-disinformation-osint%2F
Who’s Responsible for the Gaza
Hospital Explosion? Here’s Why It’s
Hard to Know What’s Real
A flood of false information, partisan narratives, and
weaponized “fact-checking" has obscured efforts to
find out who’s responsible for an explosion at a
hospital in Gaza.
David Gilbert Oct 18, 2023 5:27 PM
Al-Ahli Baptist Hospital after it was hit in Gaza City, Gaza, on October 18, 2023.Photograph: Ali
Jadallah/Getty Images
Yesterday evening around 7 pm local time, an explosion rocked the Al-Ahli
Baptist Hospital in Gaza City. Within minutes, information about what had
happened was distorted by partisan narratives, disinformation, and a rush
to be first to post about the blast. Add in mainstream media outlets
parroting official statements without verifying their veracity, and the result
was a chaotic information environment in which no one was sure what had
happened or how.
“There’s just been this massive sort of pressure to get videos out there,
get your take, get your analysis, and it’s like a perfect storm for chaos,”
Kolina Koltai, a senior researcher at open source intelligence (OSINT)
news outlet Bellingcat, tells WIRED.
Moments after the explosion was reported, Gaza’s health ministry claimed
the blast was caused by an Israeli rocket attack and that hundreds of
people had died, marking what would be among the deadliest attacks of
the current conflict between Israel and Hamas, which controls the
Palestinian territory of Gaza. News organizations such as The New York
20/10/23, 12:45 PM
Who’s Responsible for the Gaza Hospital Explosion? Here’s Why It’s Hard to Know What’s Real | WIRED
Page 2 of 5
https://www.wired.com/story/al-ahli-baptist-hospital-explosion-disinf…2Fstory%2Fal-ahli-baptist-hospital-explosion-disinformation-osint%2F
Times and Reuters ran with the claim, pushing notification alerts to
people’s phones with the news that Israeli rockets had killed Palestinians
sheltering in a hospital in Gaza. “Breaking news: Israeli strike on hospitals
kill hundreds, Palestinian officials say,” the Times alert read.
Soon after those push notifications went out, the Israeli military said its
intelligence officers had tracked rockets fired by the Palestinian Islamic
Jihad, an armed militant group in Gaza that is aligned with Hamas against
Israel but often acts independently. Israeli military officials said they
observed Islamic Jihad rockets passing the hospital at the time of the
strike, adding that it was these projectiles—not an Israeli rocket—that hit
the facility’s parking lot.
News organizations quickly changed their headlines to reflect the
counterclaim from Israel and pushed out more notifications to their
audiences. The updated headline from The New York Times read, “At least
500 dead in blast at Gaza hospital, Palestinians say.”
This was only the beginning of the confusion.
In the hours after the attack, @Israel, the official Israeli account on X
(formerly Twitter), posted a video it claimed was proof that the explosion
was the result of a misguided rocket launched by Islamic Jihad militants.
But within minutes, Aric Toler, a former Bellingcat researcher who now
works for The New York Times, pointed out that the time stamp on the
video showed 8 pm local time, a full hour after the explosion took place.
“When you see people in such a capacity putting out a claim, walking it
back, putting out a video, deleting the video, it makes it tough, not just for
us to do our job but even for the public to find out what’s going on,” Koltai
says.
The post on Israel’s official account was subsequently edited to remove
the video while maintaining its claim that the attack was not the result of
20/10/23, 12:45 PM
Who’s Responsible for the Gaza Hospital Explosion? Here’s Why It’s Hard to Know What’s Real | WIRED
Page 3 of 5
https://www.wired.com/story/al-ahli-baptist-hospital-explosion-disinf…2Fstory%2Fal-ahli-baptist-hospital-explosion-disinformation-osint%2F
an Israeli strike.
Meanwhile, social media was flooded with videos and images that claimed
to provide proof of the origin of the attacks, with many accounts making
definitive judgments about those they claimed were responsible for the
attack, all without any actual proof.
For experts in the OSINT community who have spent years working on
incidents just like this, the confusion and misinformation were frustrating.
Figuring out what happened takes time, and the deluge of misinformation
only made that work more difficult.
“It’s because we are trying to track a rocket, at night, via a couple of
livestreams, a security camera, and a phone camera,” an OSINT
researcher, who posts anonymously on social media using the handle
OSINTtechnical, tells WIRED. “Oh, and there are bad actors purposely
trying to muddy the waters. I would say we still have an acceptable
number of resources to see into Gaza, but it takes some time to parse
everything to a complete degree.”
The researcher adds that their job was made infinitely more difficult by
media outlets running with the claim that Israel was responsible. “That
blows everything out of the water,” OSINTtechnical says.
Koltai says she began trying to figure out what had happened within hours
of the incident, before her colleagues in Europe took over today. Despite
being among the first to begin investigating the incident, as of this
afternoon Bellingcat had still not confirmed how the attack happened or
who was responsible.
Similarly, the BBC Verify team published its analysis of the explosion
based on the available information but has been unable to conclude what
exactly happened. A number of videos captured with mobile phones and
circulated on social media appear to show the moment of the explosion
20/10/23, 12:45 PM
Who’s Responsible for the Gaza Hospital Explosion? Here’s Why It’s Hard to Know What’s Real | WIRED
Page 4 of 5
https://www.wired.com/story/al-ahli-baptist-hospital-explosion-disinf…2Fstory%2Fal-ahli-baptist-hospital-explosion-disinformation-osint%2F
from different angles. A livestream operated by Al Jazeera shows two
flashes, one farther from the camera and one much closer, which some
claim shows the rocket launching, followed by the explosion. Footage
captured this morning shows the hospital’s parking lot and what appears
to be a small impact crater. Footage shows damage to a number of cars
but only minor damage to the exterior of the hospital building.
Today, the Times reported that US officials said they have “multiple
strands of intelligence,” including infrared satellite imagery, indicating that
the deadly blast was caused by the Islamic Jihad group, though that
evidence has not been released publicly. US president Joe Biden, who is
meeting with officials in Israel today, echoed Israel’s claim that its military
did not fire the rocket that hit the hospital. “Based on the information we
have seen today, it appears the result of an errant rocket fired by a
terrorist group in Gaza,” he said.
In the days since Hamas attacked Israel on October 7, people claiming to
be OSINT practitioners have emerged on social media who are much more
willing to make conclusive findings almost immediately than people who
have a long history of conducting OSINT work.
This new group is “publishing analysis as quickly as possible when events
are taking place, in an attempt to compete for public attention,” Francesco
Sebregondi, a forensic architect who helps investigate human rights
abuses through a technique known as forensic architecture, tells WIRED.
“This is of course detrimental to the fundamental goal of citizen-led open
source investigations.”
The purpose of OSINT investigations is to independently verify
information “and to enable counter-investigations of authoritative
arguments and sometimes misleading official accounts,” Sebregondi says.
Sebregondi says OSINT accounts that rush to post analyses prematurely
not only mislead their followers but help bolster the narrative of political
20/10/23, 12:45 PM
Who’s Responsible for the Gaza Hospital Explosion? Here’s Why It’s Hard to Know What’s Real | WIRED
Page 5 of 5
https://www.wired.com/story/al-ahli-baptist-hospital-explosion-disinf…2Fstory%2Fal-ahli-baptist-hospital-explosion-disinformation-osint%2F
actors who may be “counting on the eagerness of some OSINT actors to
use any image, material, or data to quickly publish new content or
‘analysis’—and thereby more or less directly support its version of the
events.”
Aside from the apparent bragging rights of being first, there is also now a
financial incentive to post updates before anyone else because if you’re
“first and put out a hot take even if you’re maybe not correct you can
actually get paid out for it,” Koltai says, referring to X’s revenue-sharing
program.
Fact-checking and open source investigations have long been seen as a
way to hold platforms accountable by debunking disinformation that
spreads unchecked on social media, but the Israel-Hamas war has shown
how the language of OSINT investigators has been co-opted by self-
interested parties, says Caroline Orr, a behavioral scientist and
postdoctoral researcher at the University of Maryland who tracks
disinformation online.
“I think one of the most disturbing aspects of studying disinfo is when you
realize that even fact-checking has become weaponized,” Orr wrote on X.
“Most people don’t care about the truth about the hospital being bombed;
they just care about finding a truth to use against the other side.”

More Related Content

Similar to Who’s Responsible for the Gaza Hospital Explosion? Here’s Why It’s Hard to Know

China, us spar over origin of coronavirus
China, us spar over origin of coronavirusChina, us spar over origin of coronavirus
China, us spar over origin of coronavirusDeepak S. Sawant
 
China, us spar over origin of coronavirus
China, us spar over origin of coronavirusChina, us spar over origin of coronavirus
China, us spar over origin of coronavirusDeepak S Sawant
 
Speci fics data acquisition from www.msn.com
Speci fics data acquisition from www.msn.comSpeci fics data acquisition from www.msn.com
Speci fics data acquisition from www.msn.comDeepak Somajee-Sawant
 
China lied about origin of coronavirus, leaked intelligence report says
China lied about origin of coronavirus, leaked intelligence report saysChina lied about origin of coronavirus, leaked intelligence report says
China lied about origin of coronavirus, leaked intelligence report saysDaglyAngola
 
Opinion | What we pretend to know about the coronavirus could kill us
Opinion | What we pretend to know about the coronavirus could kill usOpinion | What we pretend to know about the coronavirus could kill us
Opinion | What we pretend to know about the coronavirus could kill usJoseAnzorena2
 
Boston Marathon Bombing "Crowdsourcing:" How citizens are using the Internet ...
Boston Marathon Bombing "Crowdsourcing:" How citizens are using the Internet ...Boston Marathon Bombing "Crowdsourcing:" How citizens are using the Internet ...
Boston Marathon Bombing "Crowdsourcing:" How citizens are using the Internet ...uptighthairstyl51
 
Edward Snowden's NSA surveillance revelations strain China-US relations - Cro...
Edward Snowden's NSA surveillance revelations strain China-US relations - Cro...Edward Snowden's NSA surveillance revelations strain China-US relations - Cro...
Edward Snowden's NSA surveillance revelations strain China-US relations - Cro...Paula Pepe
 
Burkett matthew digital_citizenship
Burkett matthew digital_citizenshipBurkett matthew digital_citizenship
Burkett matthew digital_citizenshipMatthew Burkett
 
Advertisementfinal
AdvertisementfinalAdvertisementfinal
AdvertisementfinalBurn_Red
 
Could COVID-19 Kickstart Surveillance Culture?
Could COVID-19 Kickstart Surveillance Culture?Could COVID-19 Kickstart Surveillance Culture?
Could COVID-19 Kickstart Surveillance Culture?Bennat Berger
 

Similar to Who’s Responsible for the Gaza Hospital Explosion? Here’s Why It’s Hard to Know (20)

China, us spar over origin of coronavirus
China, us spar over origin of coronavirusChina, us spar over origin of coronavirus
China, us spar over origin of coronavirus
 
China, us spar over origin of coronavirus
China, us spar over origin of coronavirusChina, us spar over origin of coronavirus
China, us spar over origin of coronavirus
 
China, us spar over origin of coronavirus
China, us spar over origin of coronavirusChina, us spar over origin of coronavirus
China, us spar over origin of coronavirus
 
China, us spar over origin of coronavirus
China, us spar over origin of coronavirusChina, us spar over origin of coronavirus
China, us spar over origin of coronavirus
 
Speci fics data acquisition from www.msn.com
Speci fics data acquisition from www.msn.comSpeci fics data acquisition from www.msn.com
Speci fics data acquisition from www.msn.com
 
China lied about origin of coronavirus, leaked intelligence report says
China lied about origin of coronavirus, leaked intelligence report saysChina lied about origin of coronavirus, leaked intelligence report says
China lied about origin of coronavirus, leaked intelligence report says
 
IPF portfolio
IPF portfolio IPF portfolio
IPF portfolio
 
Opinion | What we pretend to know about the coronavirus could kill us
Opinion | What we pretend to know about the coronavirus could kill usOpinion | What we pretend to know about the coronavirus could kill us
Opinion | What we pretend to know about the coronavirus could kill us
 
We Should Try to Prevent Another Alex Jones
We Should Try to Prevent Another Alex JonesWe Should Try to Prevent Another Alex Jones
We Should Try to Prevent Another Alex Jones
 
State of Hawaii - False Missile Attack Alarm - The Noble Hero
State of Hawaii - False Missile Attack Alarm - The Noble HeroState of Hawaii - False Missile Attack Alarm - The Noble Hero
State of Hawaii - False Missile Attack Alarm - The Noble Hero
 
Hawaii - COVID-19 - Objectively Terrible - Tippecanoe and Ige Too
Hawaii - COVID-19 - Objectively Terrible - Tippecanoe and Ige TooHawaii - COVID-19 - Objectively Terrible - Tippecanoe and Ige Too
Hawaii - COVID-19 - Objectively Terrible - Tippecanoe and Ige Too
 
Jenny hauser dublin ac14
Jenny hauser dublin ac14Jenny hauser dublin ac14
Jenny hauser dublin ac14
 
Boston Marathon Bombing "Crowdsourcing:" How citizens are using the Internet ...
Boston Marathon Bombing "Crowdsourcing:" How citizens are using the Internet ...Boston Marathon Bombing "Crowdsourcing:" How citizens are using the Internet ...
Boston Marathon Bombing "Crowdsourcing:" How citizens are using the Internet ...
 
Edward Snowden's NSA surveillance revelations strain China-US relations - Cro...
Edward Snowden's NSA surveillance revelations strain China-US relations - Cro...Edward Snowden's NSA surveillance revelations strain China-US relations - Cro...
Edward Snowden's NSA surveillance revelations strain China-US relations - Cro...
 
Burkett matthew digital_citizenship
Burkett matthew digital_citizenshipBurkett matthew digital_citizenship
Burkett matthew digital_citizenship
 
Advertisementfinal
AdvertisementfinalAdvertisementfinal
Advertisementfinal
 
Could COVID-19 Kickstart Surveillance Culture?
Could COVID-19 Kickstart Surveillance Culture?Could COVID-19 Kickstart Surveillance Culture?
Could COVID-19 Kickstart Surveillance Culture?
 
Mike Kicklighter
Mike KicklighterMike Kicklighter
Mike Kicklighter
 
“‘We have a lot of evidence that it’s a fake story all over the world’ – germ...
“‘We have a lot of evidence that it’s a fake story all over the world’ – germ...“‘We have a lot of evidence that it’s a fake story all over the world’ – germ...
“‘We have a lot of evidence that it’s a fake story all over the world’ – germ...
 
Coronavirus is devastating the conference circuit
Coronavirus is devastating the conference circuitCoronavirus is devastating the conference circuit
Coronavirus is devastating the conference circuit
 

More from LUMINATIVE MEDIA/PROJECT COUNSEL MEDIA GROUP

More from LUMINATIVE MEDIA/PROJECT COUNSEL MEDIA GROUP (20)

A.I. Has a Measurement Problem: Can It Be Solved?
A.I. Has a Measurement Problem: Can It Be Solved?A.I. Has a Measurement Problem: Can It Be Solved?
A.I. Has a Measurement Problem: Can It Be Solved?
 
Let’s Say Someone Did Drop the Bomb. Then What?
Let’s Say Someone Did Drop the Bomb. Then What?Let’s Say Someone Did Drop the Bomb. Then What?
Let’s Say Someone Did Drop the Bomb. Then What?
 
How Tech Giants Cut Corners to Harvest Data for A.I.
How Tech Giants Cut Corners to Harvest Data for A.I.How Tech Giants Cut Corners to Harvest Data for A.I.
How Tech Giants Cut Corners to Harvest Data for A.I.
 
Why democracy dies in Trumpian boredom (by Edward Luce)
Why democracy dies in Trumpian boredom (by Edward Luce)Why democracy dies in Trumpian boredom (by Edward Luce)
Why democracy dies in Trumpian boredom (by Edward Luce)
 
An interview with the director of "Zone of Interest"
An interview with the director of "Zone of Interest"An interview with the director of "Zone of Interest"
An interview with the director of "Zone of Interest"
 
"Schindler’s List" : an oral history with the actors
"Schindler’s List" : an oral history with the actors"Schindler’s List" : an oral history with the actors
"Schindler’s List" : an oral history with the actors
 
Chinese Startup 01.AI Is Winning the Open Source AI Race
Chinese Startup 01.AI Is Winning the Open Source AI RaceChinese Startup 01.AI Is Winning the Open Source AI Race
Chinese Startup 01.AI Is Winning the Open Source AI Race
 
The mismeasuring of AI: How it all began
The mismeasuring of AI: How it all beganThe mismeasuring of AI: How it all began
The mismeasuring of AI: How it all began
 
Google’s Gemini Marketing Trick: what a trickster!
Google’s Gemini Marketing Trick: what a trickster!Google’s Gemini Marketing Trick: what a trickster!
Google’s Gemini Marketing Trick: what a trickster!
 
Inside the Magical World of AI Prompters on Reddit
Inside the Magical World of AI Prompters on RedditInside the Magical World of AI Prompters on Reddit
Inside the Magical World of AI Prompters on Reddit
 
Regulators blame Bezos for making Amazon worse in new lawsuit details
Regulators blame Bezos for making Amazon worse in new lawsuit detailsRegulators blame Bezos for making Amazon worse in new lawsuit details
Regulators blame Bezos for making Amazon worse in new lawsuit details
 
Bariatric Surgery at 16
Bariatric Surgery at 16Bariatric Surgery at 16
Bariatric Surgery at 16
 
Palestinians Claim Social Media 'Censorship' Is Endangering Lives
Palestinians Claim Social Media 'Censorship' Is Endangering LivesPalestinians Claim Social Media 'Censorship' Is Endangering Lives
Palestinians Claim Social Media 'Censorship' Is Endangering Lives
 
Why ChatGPT Is Getting Dumber at Basic Math
Why ChatGPT Is Getting Dumber at Basic MathWhy ChatGPT Is Getting Dumber at Basic Math
Why ChatGPT Is Getting Dumber at Basic Math
 
U.S. and E.U. Finalize Long-Awaited Deal on Sharing Data
U.S. and E.U. Finalize Long-Awaited Deal on Sharing DataU.S. and E.U. Finalize Long-Awaited Deal on Sharing Data
U.S. and E.U. Finalize Long-Awaited Deal on Sharing Data
 
Will A.I. Become the New McKinsey?
Will A.I. Become the New McKinsey?Will A.I. Become the New McKinsey?
Will A.I. Become the New McKinsey?
 
AI is already writing books, websites and online recipes
AI is already writing books, websites and online recipesAI is already writing books, websites and online recipes
AI is already writing books, websites and online recipes
 
What happens when ChatGPT lies about real people?
What happens when ChatGPT lies about real people?What happens when ChatGPT lies about real people?
What happens when ChatGPT lies about real people?
 
The Brilliant Inventor Who Made Two of History’s Biggest Mistakes
The Brilliant Inventor Who Made Two of History’s Biggest MistakesThe Brilliant Inventor Who Made Two of History’s Biggest Mistakes
The Brilliant Inventor Who Made Two of History’s Biggest Mistakes
 
Wirecard fraudster Jan Marsalek’s grandfather was suspected Russian spy
Wirecard fraudster Jan Marsalek’s grandfather was suspected Russian spyWirecard fraudster Jan Marsalek’s grandfather was suspected Russian spy
Wirecard fraudster Jan Marsalek’s grandfather was suspected Russian spy
 

Recently uploaded

2024 02 15 AZ GOP LD4 Gen Meeting Minutes_FINAL_20240228.docx
2024 02 15 AZ GOP LD4 Gen Meeting Minutes_FINAL_20240228.docx2024 02 15 AZ GOP LD4 Gen Meeting Minutes_FINAL_20240228.docx
2024 02 15 AZ GOP LD4 Gen Meeting Minutes_FINAL_20240228.docxkfjstone13
 
AI as Research Assistant: Upscaling Content Analysis to Identify Patterns of ...
AI as Research Assistant: Upscaling Content Analysis to Identify Patterns of ...AI as Research Assistant: Upscaling Content Analysis to Identify Patterns of ...
AI as Research Assistant: Upscaling Content Analysis to Identify Patterns of ...Axel Bruns
 
Powerful Love Spells in Phoenix, AZ (310) 882-6330 Bring Back Lost Lover
Powerful Love Spells in Phoenix, AZ (310) 882-6330 Bring Back Lost LoverPowerful Love Spells in Phoenix, AZ (310) 882-6330 Bring Back Lost Lover
Powerful Love Spells in Phoenix, AZ (310) 882-6330 Bring Back Lost LoverPsychicRuben LoveSpells
 
Nurturing Families, Empowering Lives: TDP's Vision for Family Welfare in Andh...
Nurturing Families, Empowering Lives: TDP's Vision for Family Welfare in Andh...Nurturing Families, Empowering Lives: TDP's Vision for Family Welfare in Andh...
Nurturing Families, Empowering Lives: TDP's Vision for Family Welfare in Andh...narsireddynannuri1
 
BDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 135 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort Service
BDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 135 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort ServiceBDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 135 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort Service
BDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 135 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort ServiceDelhi Call girls
 
Embed-4.pdf lkdiinlajeklhndklheduhuekjdh
Embed-4.pdf lkdiinlajeklhndklheduhuekjdhEmbed-4.pdf lkdiinlajeklhndklheduhuekjdh
Embed-4.pdf lkdiinlajeklhndklheduhuekjdhbhavenpr
 
Enjoy Night⚡Call Girls Iffco Chowk Gurgaon >༒8448380779 Escort Service
Enjoy Night⚡Call Girls Iffco Chowk Gurgaon >༒8448380779 Escort ServiceEnjoy Night⚡Call Girls Iffco Chowk Gurgaon >༒8448380779 Escort Service
Enjoy Night⚡Call Girls Iffco Chowk Gurgaon >༒8448380779 Escort ServiceDelhi Call girls
 
TDP As the Party of Hope For AP Youth Under N Chandrababu Naidu’s Leadership
TDP As the Party of Hope For AP Youth Under N Chandrababu Naidu’s LeadershipTDP As the Party of Hope For AP Youth Under N Chandrababu Naidu’s Leadership
TDP As the Party of Hope For AP Youth Under N Chandrababu Naidu’s Leadershipanjanibaddipudi1
 
Pakistan PMLN Election Manifesto 2024.pdf
Pakistan PMLN Election Manifesto 2024.pdfPakistan PMLN Election Manifesto 2024.pdf
Pakistan PMLN Election Manifesto 2024.pdfFahimUddin61
 
Kishan Reddy Report To People (2019-24).pdf
Kishan Reddy Report To People (2019-24).pdfKishan Reddy Report To People (2019-24).pdf
Kishan Reddy Report To People (2019-24).pdfKISHAN REDDY OFFICE
 
WhatsApp 📞 8448380779 ✅Call Girls In Chaura Sector 22 ( Noida)
WhatsApp 📞 8448380779 ✅Call Girls In Chaura Sector 22 ( Noida)WhatsApp 📞 8448380779 ✅Call Girls In Chaura Sector 22 ( Noida)
WhatsApp 📞 8448380779 ✅Call Girls In Chaura Sector 22 ( Noida)Delhi Call girls
 
Israel Palestine Conflict, The issue and historical context!
Israel Palestine Conflict, The issue and historical context!Israel Palestine Conflict, The issue and historical context!
Israel Palestine Conflict, The issue and historical context!Krish109503
 
29042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
29042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf29042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
29042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdfFIRST INDIA
 
Minto-Morley Reforms 1909 (constitution).pptx
Minto-Morley Reforms 1909 (constitution).pptxMinto-Morley Reforms 1909 (constitution).pptx
Minto-Morley Reforms 1909 (constitution).pptxAwaiskhalid96
 
2024 03 13 AZ GOP LD4 Gen Meeting Minutes_FINAL.docx
2024 03 13 AZ GOP LD4 Gen Meeting Minutes_FINAL.docx2024 03 13 AZ GOP LD4 Gen Meeting Minutes_FINAL.docx
2024 03 13 AZ GOP LD4 Gen Meeting Minutes_FINAL.docxkfjstone13
 
Gujarat-SEBCs.pdf pfpkoopapriorjfperjreie
Gujarat-SEBCs.pdf pfpkoopapriorjfperjreieGujarat-SEBCs.pdf pfpkoopapriorjfperjreie
Gujarat-SEBCs.pdf pfpkoopapriorjfperjreiebhavenpr
 
BDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 143 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort Service
BDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 143 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort ServiceBDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 143 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort Service
BDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 143 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort ServiceDelhi Call girls
 
Lorenzo D'Emidio_Lavoro sullaNorth Korea .pptx
Lorenzo D'Emidio_Lavoro sullaNorth Korea .pptxLorenzo D'Emidio_Lavoro sullaNorth Korea .pptx
Lorenzo D'Emidio_Lavoro sullaNorth Korea .pptxlorenzodemidio01
 
Verified Love Spells in Little Rock, AR (310) 882-6330 Get My Ex-Lover Back
Verified Love Spells in Little Rock, AR (310) 882-6330 Get My Ex-Lover BackVerified Love Spells in Little Rock, AR (310) 882-6330 Get My Ex-Lover Back
Verified Love Spells in Little Rock, AR (310) 882-6330 Get My Ex-Lover BackPsychicRuben LoveSpells
 
Nara Chandrababu Naidu's Visionary Policies For Andhra Pradesh's Development
Nara Chandrababu Naidu's Visionary Policies For Andhra Pradesh's DevelopmentNara Chandrababu Naidu's Visionary Policies For Andhra Pradesh's Development
Nara Chandrababu Naidu's Visionary Policies For Andhra Pradesh's Developmentnarsireddynannuri1
 

Recently uploaded (20)

2024 02 15 AZ GOP LD4 Gen Meeting Minutes_FINAL_20240228.docx
2024 02 15 AZ GOP LD4 Gen Meeting Minutes_FINAL_20240228.docx2024 02 15 AZ GOP LD4 Gen Meeting Minutes_FINAL_20240228.docx
2024 02 15 AZ GOP LD4 Gen Meeting Minutes_FINAL_20240228.docx
 
AI as Research Assistant: Upscaling Content Analysis to Identify Patterns of ...
AI as Research Assistant: Upscaling Content Analysis to Identify Patterns of ...AI as Research Assistant: Upscaling Content Analysis to Identify Patterns of ...
AI as Research Assistant: Upscaling Content Analysis to Identify Patterns of ...
 
Powerful Love Spells in Phoenix, AZ (310) 882-6330 Bring Back Lost Lover
Powerful Love Spells in Phoenix, AZ (310) 882-6330 Bring Back Lost LoverPowerful Love Spells in Phoenix, AZ (310) 882-6330 Bring Back Lost Lover
Powerful Love Spells in Phoenix, AZ (310) 882-6330 Bring Back Lost Lover
 
Nurturing Families, Empowering Lives: TDP's Vision for Family Welfare in Andh...
Nurturing Families, Empowering Lives: TDP's Vision for Family Welfare in Andh...Nurturing Families, Empowering Lives: TDP's Vision for Family Welfare in Andh...
Nurturing Families, Empowering Lives: TDP's Vision for Family Welfare in Andh...
 
BDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 135 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort Service
BDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 135 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort ServiceBDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 135 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort Service
BDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 135 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort Service
 
Embed-4.pdf lkdiinlajeklhndklheduhuekjdh
Embed-4.pdf lkdiinlajeklhndklheduhuekjdhEmbed-4.pdf lkdiinlajeklhndklheduhuekjdh
Embed-4.pdf lkdiinlajeklhndklheduhuekjdh
 
Enjoy Night⚡Call Girls Iffco Chowk Gurgaon >༒8448380779 Escort Service
Enjoy Night⚡Call Girls Iffco Chowk Gurgaon >༒8448380779 Escort ServiceEnjoy Night⚡Call Girls Iffco Chowk Gurgaon >༒8448380779 Escort Service
Enjoy Night⚡Call Girls Iffco Chowk Gurgaon >༒8448380779 Escort Service
 
TDP As the Party of Hope For AP Youth Under N Chandrababu Naidu’s Leadership
TDP As the Party of Hope For AP Youth Under N Chandrababu Naidu’s LeadershipTDP As the Party of Hope For AP Youth Under N Chandrababu Naidu’s Leadership
TDP As the Party of Hope For AP Youth Under N Chandrababu Naidu’s Leadership
 
Pakistan PMLN Election Manifesto 2024.pdf
Pakistan PMLN Election Manifesto 2024.pdfPakistan PMLN Election Manifesto 2024.pdf
Pakistan PMLN Election Manifesto 2024.pdf
 
Kishan Reddy Report To People (2019-24).pdf
Kishan Reddy Report To People (2019-24).pdfKishan Reddy Report To People (2019-24).pdf
Kishan Reddy Report To People (2019-24).pdf
 
WhatsApp 📞 8448380779 ✅Call Girls In Chaura Sector 22 ( Noida)
WhatsApp 📞 8448380779 ✅Call Girls In Chaura Sector 22 ( Noida)WhatsApp 📞 8448380779 ✅Call Girls In Chaura Sector 22 ( Noida)
WhatsApp 📞 8448380779 ✅Call Girls In Chaura Sector 22 ( Noida)
 
Israel Palestine Conflict, The issue and historical context!
Israel Palestine Conflict, The issue and historical context!Israel Palestine Conflict, The issue and historical context!
Israel Palestine Conflict, The issue and historical context!
 
29042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
29042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf29042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
29042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
 
Minto-Morley Reforms 1909 (constitution).pptx
Minto-Morley Reforms 1909 (constitution).pptxMinto-Morley Reforms 1909 (constitution).pptx
Minto-Morley Reforms 1909 (constitution).pptx
 
2024 03 13 AZ GOP LD4 Gen Meeting Minutes_FINAL.docx
2024 03 13 AZ GOP LD4 Gen Meeting Minutes_FINAL.docx2024 03 13 AZ GOP LD4 Gen Meeting Minutes_FINAL.docx
2024 03 13 AZ GOP LD4 Gen Meeting Minutes_FINAL.docx
 
Gujarat-SEBCs.pdf pfpkoopapriorjfperjreie
Gujarat-SEBCs.pdf pfpkoopapriorjfperjreieGujarat-SEBCs.pdf pfpkoopapriorjfperjreie
Gujarat-SEBCs.pdf pfpkoopapriorjfperjreie
 
BDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 143 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort Service
BDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 143 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort ServiceBDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 143 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort Service
BDSM⚡Call Girls in Sector 143 Noida Escorts >༒8448380779 Escort Service
 
Lorenzo D'Emidio_Lavoro sullaNorth Korea .pptx
Lorenzo D'Emidio_Lavoro sullaNorth Korea .pptxLorenzo D'Emidio_Lavoro sullaNorth Korea .pptx
Lorenzo D'Emidio_Lavoro sullaNorth Korea .pptx
 
Verified Love Spells in Little Rock, AR (310) 882-6330 Get My Ex-Lover Back
Verified Love Spells in Little Rock, AR (310) 882-6330 Get My Ex-Lover BackVerified Love Spells in Little Rock, AR (310) 882-6330 Get My Ex-Lover Back
Verified Love Spells in Little Rock, AR (310) 882-6330 Get My Ex-Lover Back
 
Nara Chandrababu Naidu's Visionary Policies For Andhra Pradesh's Development
Nara Chandrababu Naidu's Visionary Policies For Andhra Pradesh's DevelopmentNara Chandrababu Naidu's Visionary Policies For Andhra Pradesh's Development
Nara Chandrababu Naidu's Visionary Policies For Andhra Pradesh's Development
 

Who’s Responsible for the Gaza Hospital Explosion? Here’s Why It’s Hard to Know

  • 1. 20/10/23, 12:45 PM Who’s Responsible for the Gaza Hospital Explosion? Here’s Why It’s Hard to Know What’s Real | WIRED Page 1 of 5 https://www.wired.com/story/al-ahli-baptist-hospital-explosion-disinf…2Fstory%2Fal-ahli-baptist-hospital-explosion-disinformation-osint%2F Who’s Responsible for the Gaza Hospital Explosion? Here’s Why It’s Hard to Know What’s Real A flood of false information, partisan narratives, and weaponized “fact-checking" has obscured efforts to find out who’s responsible for an explosion at a hospital in Gaza. David Gilbert Oct 18, 2023 5:27 PM Al-Ahli Baptist Hospital after it was hit in Gaza City, Gaza, on October 18, 2023.Photograph: Ali Jadallah/Getty Images Yesterday evening around 7 pm local time, an explosion rocked the Al-Ahli Baptist Hospital in Gaza City. Within minutes, information about what had happened was distorted by partisan narratives, disinformation, and a rush to be first to post about the blast. Add in mainstream media outlets parroting official statements without verifying their veracity, and the result was a chaotic information environment in which no one was sure what had happened or how. “There’s just been this massive sort of pressure to get videos out there, get your take, get your analysis, and it’s like a perfect storm for chaos,” Kolina Koltai, a senior researcher at open source intelligence (OSINT) news outlet Bellingcat, tells WIRED. Moments after the explosion was reported, Gaza’s health ministry claimed the blast was caused by an Israeli rocket attack and that hundreds of people had died, marking what would be among the deadliest attacks of the current conflict between Israel and Hamas, which controls the Palestinian territory of Gaza. News organizations such as The New York
  • 2. 20/10/23, 12:45 PM Who’s Responsible for the Gaza Hospital Explosion? Here’s Why It’s Hard to Know What’s Real | WIRED Page 2 of 5 https://www.wired.com/story/al-ahli-baptist-hospital-explosion-disinf…2Fstory%2Fal-ahli-baptist-hospital-explosion-disinformation-osint%2F Times and Reuters ran with the claim, pushing notification alerts to people’s phones with the news that Israeli rockets had killed Palestinians sheltering in a hospital in Gaza. “Breaking news: Israeli strike on hospitals kill hundreds, Palestinian officials say,” the Times alert read. Soon after those push notifications went out, the Israeli military said its intelligence officers had tracked rockets fired by the Palestinian Islamic Jihad, an armed militant group in Gaza that is aligned with Hamas against Israel but often acts independently. Israeli military officials said they observed Islamic Jihad rockets passing the hospital at the time of the strike, adding that it was these projectiles—not an Israeli rocket—that hit the facility’s parking lot. News organizations quickly changed their headlines to reflect the counterclaim from Israel and pushed out more notifications to their audiences. The updated headline from The New York Times read, “At least 500 dead in blast at Gaza hospital, Palestinians say.” This was only the beginning of the confusion. In the hours after the attack, @Israel, the official Israeli account on X (formerly Twitter), posted a video it claimed was proof that the explosion was the result of a misguided rocket launched by Islamic Jihad militants. But within minutes, Aric Toler, a former Bellingcat researcher who now works for The New York Times, pointed out that the time stamp on the video showed 8 pm local time, a full hour after the explosion took place. “When you see people in such a capacity putting out a claim, walking it back, putting out a video, deleting the video, it makes it tough, not just for us to do our job but even for the public to find out what’s going on,” Koltai says. The post on Israel’s official account was subsequently edited to remove the video while maintaining its claim that the attack was not the result of
  • 3. 20/10/23, 12:45 PM Who’s Responsible for the Gaza Hospital Explosion? Here’s Why It’s Hard to Know What’s Real | WIRED Page 3 of 5 https://www.wired.com/story/al-ahli-baptist-hospital-explosion-disinf…2Fstory%2Fal-ahli-baptist-hospital-explosion-disinformation-osint%2F an Israeli strike. Meanwhile, social media was flooded with videos and images that claimed to provide proof of the origin of the attacks, with many accounts making definitive judgments about those they claimed were responsible for the attack, all without any actual proof. For experts in the OSINT community who have spent years working on incidents just like this, the confusion and misinformation were frustrating. Figuring out what happened takes time, and the deluge of misinformation only made that work more difficult. “It’s because we are trying to track a rocket, at night, via a couple of livestreams, a security camera, and a phone camera,” an OSINT researcher, who posts anonymously on social media using the handle OSINTtechnical, tells WIRED. “Oh, and there are bad actors purposely trying to muddy the waters. I would say we still have an acceptable number of resources to see into Gaza, but it takes some time to parse everything to a complete degree.” The researcher adds that their job was made infinitely more difficult by media outlets running with the claim that Israel was responsible. “That blows everything out of the water,” OSINTtechnical says. Koltai says she began trying to figure out what had happened within hours of the incident, before her colleagues in Europe took over today. Despite being among the first to begin investigating the incident, as of this afternoon Bellingcat had still not confirmed how the attack happened or who was responsible. Similarly, the BBC Verify team published its analysis of the explosion based on the available information but has been unable to conclude what exactly happened. A number of videos captured with mobile phones and circulated on social media appear to show the moment of the explosion
  • 4. 20/10/23, 12:45 PM Who’s Responsible for the Gaza Hospital Explosion? Here’s Why It’s Hard to Know What’s Real | WIRED Page 4 of 5 https://www.wired.com/story/al-ahli-baptist-hospital-explosion-disinf…2Fstory%2Fal-ahli-baptist-hospital-explosion-disinformation-osint%2F from different angles. A livestream operated by Al Jazeera shows two flashes, one farther from the camera and one much closer, which some claim shows the rocket launching, followed by the explosion. Footage captured this morning shows the hospital’s parking lot and what appears to be a small impact crater. Footage shows damage to a number of cars but only minor damage to the exterior of the hospital building. Today, the Times reported that US officials said they have “multiple strands of intelligence,” including infrared satellite imagery, indicating that the deadly blast was caused by the Islamic Jihad group, though that evidence has not been released publicly. US president Joe Biden, who is meeting with officials in Israel today, echoed Israel’s claim that its military did not fire the rocket that hit the hospital. “Based on the information we have seen today, it appears the result of an errant rocket fired by a terrorist group in Gaza,” he said. In the days since Hamas attacked Israel on October 7, people claiming to be OSINT practitioners have emerged on social media who are much more willing to make conclusive findings almost immediately than people who have a long history of conducting OSINT work. This new group is “publishing analysis as quickly as possible when events are taking place, in an attempt to compete for public attention,” Francesco Sebregondi, a forensic architect who helps investigate human rights abuses through a technique known as forensic architecture, tells WIRED. “This is of course detrimental to the fundamental goal of citizen-led open source investigations.” The purpose of OSINT investigations is to independently verify information “and to enable counter-investigations of authoritative arguments and sometimes misleading official accounts,” Sebregondi says. Sebregondi says OSINT accounts that rush to post analyses prematurely not only mislead their followers but help bolster the narrative of political
  • 5. 20/10/23, 12:45 PM Who’s Responsible for the Gaza Hospital Explosion? Here’s Why It’s Hard to Know What’s Real | WIRED Page 5 of 5 https://www.wired.com/story/al-ahli-baptist-hospital-explosion-disinf…2Fstory%2Fal-ahli-baptist-hospital-explosion-disinformation-osint%2F actors who may be “counting on the eagerness of some OSINT actors to use any image, material, or data to quickly publish new content or ‘analysis’—and thereby more or less directly support its version of the events.” Aside from the apparent bragging rights of being first, there is also now a financial incentive to post updates before anyone else because if you’re “first and put out a hot take even if you’re maybe not correct you can actually get paid out for it,” Koltai says, referring to X’s revenue-sharing program. Fact-checking and open source investigations have long been seen as a way to hold platforms accountable by debunking disinformation that spreads unchecked on social media, but the Israel-Hamas war has shown how the language of OSINT investigators has been co-opted by self- interested parties, says Caroline Orr, a behavioral scientist and postdoctoral researcher at the University of Maryland who tracks disinformation online. “I think one of the most disturbing aspects of studying disinfo is when you realize that even fact-checking has become weaponized,” Orr wrote on X. “Most people don’t care about the truth about the hospital being bombed; they just care about finding a truth to use against the other side.”