Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.
5th	  Wave	  Launch	  Ceremony	                                            The	  5th	  Wave	                              ...
ENoLL	  Waves:	  Terms	  of	  Reference	          •  Openness	                     –  Opportunity	  for	  all	  potenBal	 ...
ENoLL	  Waves	  1-­‐4	                                250	                                200	                            ...
New	  for	  the	  5°	  Wave	          •       ENoLL	  as	  an	  legal	  enBty	          •       AdministraBon	  fee	  for	...
5wave	  applicaBons                                                         	          •  122	  pre-­‐registraBons	       ...
EvaluaBon	  teams                                                       	          •  6	  evaluaBon	  teams	  of	  3	  mem...
EvaluaBon	  scoring	          •  Scores	  of	  0-­‐5	  for	  each	  of	  the	  20	  criteria	          •  Aggregated	  ave...
EvaluaBon	  phases                                                        	          1.  Individual	  evaluators	  read	  ...
Typical	  weaknesses                                                          	          •  Where	  are	  the	  users?	  W...
Results                                                	          •  62	  Living	  Labs	  selected	          •  48	  EU	  ...
Country	  distribuBon	          20/05/11	                                                                                 ...
ThemaBc	  domains                                                                       	                                 ...
ENoLL	  today	          20/05/11	                                                                             13	  Budapes...
Welcome	  to	  ENoLL!                                                            	          •       Compile	  and	  send	 ...
Thank	  you	  for	  your	  aXenBon	          •  Jesse	  Marsh,	  5°	  wave	  coordinator	          •  Álvaro	  Oliveira	  ...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

5wave Process and Results Jesse Marsh, 5th Wave Coordinator

1,849 views

Published on

ENoLL 5th Wave publication of results in Budapest, May 16th, 2011.

  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

5wave Process and Results Jesse Marsh, 5th Wave Coordinator

  1. 1. 5th  Wave  Launch  Ceremony   The  5th  Wave   Process  and  Outcomes   Jesse  Marsh   5wave  Coordinator  Budapest,  16  May,  2011   The  5th  Wave  Process  and  Outcomes   1  
  2. 2. ENoLL  Waves:  Terms  of  Reference   •  Openness   –  Opportunity  for  all  potenBal  Living  Labs   •  Transparency   –  Clear  rules,  criteria  and  processes   •  Fairness   –  ObjecBvity,  avoiding  conflict  of  interest   20/05/11   2  Budapest,  16  May,  2011   The  5th  Wave  Process  and  Outcomes   2   2  
  3. 3. ENoLL  Waves  1-­‐4   250   200   150   100   Non-­‐EU   EU   50   0   2006   2007   2008   2009   20/05/11   3  Budapest,  16  May,  2011   The  5th  Wave  Process  and  Outcomes   3   3  
  4. 4. New  for  the  5°  Wave   •  ENoLL  as  an  legal  enBty   •  AdministraBon  fee  for  new  members   •  Pre-­‐registraBon   •  Info  on  themaBc  domains   •  Public  status  of  successful  applicaBon  forms   20/05/11   4  Budapest,  16  May,  2011   The  5th  Wave  Process  and  Outcomes   4   4  
  5. 5. 5wave  applicaBons   •  122  pre-­‐registraBons   •  80  proposals  submiXed   •  77  eligible  proposals   20/05/11   5  Budapest,  16  May,  2011   The  5th  Wave  Process  and  Outcomes   5   5  
  6. 6. EvaluaBon  teams   •  6  evaluaBon  teams  of  3  members  each   –  All  ENoLL  members   –  Team  members  from  different  countries   –  Team  leaders  with  previous  experience   •  12-­‐13  proposals  per  team   –  3  readers  minimum  for  each  proposal   –  None  from  same  country   •  X-­‐Team  cross-­‐evaluaBons   –  1  common  and  1  specific  from  each  team   20/05/11   6  Budapest,  16  May,  2011   The  5th  Wave  Process  and  Outcomes   6   6  
  7. 7. EvaluaBon  scoring   •  Scores  of  0-­‐5  for  each  of  the  20  criteria   •  Aggregated  averages  for  each  of  the  5  groups   –  OrganisaBon,  openness,  resources,  users  and   reality,  value   •  Total  score  of  aggregate  values   •  Scores  averaged  for  each  team   •  Thresholds  for  both  group  and  total  scores   20/05/11   7  Budapest,  16  May,  2011   The  5th  Wave  Process  and  Outcomes   7   7  
  8. 8. EvaluaBon  phases   1.  Individual  evaluators  read  and  score   2.  Teams  reach  consensus  and  submit   3.  All  results  compiled,  thresholds  adjusted   4.  Team  results  compared  with  each  other  and   X-­‐Team  scores   5.  Teams  revise  scoring  for  overall  coherence   6.  Final  results  compiled,  consensus  reached   7.  Results  sent  to  ENoLL  Council  for  approval   20/05/11   8  Budapest,  16  May,  2011   The  5th  Wave  Process  and  Outcomes   8   8  
  9. 9. Typical  weaknesses   •  Where  are  the  users?  Weak  involvement  in   co-­‐design,  lack  of  methodology   •  Project,  not  innovaBon  ecosystem   •  Excessive  technology  push  /  insufficient  ICT   •  Weak,  closed,  or  limited  partnerships,  lack  of   commitment  and/or  resources   •  Future  plans,  liXle  experience   •  Lack  of  focus,  limited  value  and  impact   20/05/11   9  Budapest,  16  May,  2011   The  5th  Wave  Process  and  Outcomes   9   9  
  10. 10. Results   •  62  Living  Labs  selected   •  48  EU  members,  from  12  countries   •  14  Non-­‐EU  members  (23%),  from  6  countries   20/05/11   10  Budapest,  16  May,  2011   The  5th  Wave  Process  and  Outcomes   10   10  
  11. 11. Country  distribuBon   20/05/11   11  Budapest,  16  May,  2011   The  5th  Wave  Process  and  Outcomes   11   11  
  12. 12. ThemaBc  domains   New  topics   Security   Industrial  &  logisBcs   Sustainable  Mobility   Regional  &  rural   Tourism  &  Culture   Media,  Content,  Web  2.0   e-­‐Gov  &  e-­‐ParBcipaBon   Social  InnovaBon  &  Inclusion   Smart  CiBes,  FI,  IoT   Wellbeing  &  Health   Energy  &  Climate  Change   0   5   10   15   20   25   Requests to join ENoLL thematic domain networks from 70% of applications 20/05/11   12  Budapest,  16  May,  2011   The  5th  Wave  Process  and  Outcomes   12   12  
  13. 13. ENoLL  today   20/05/11   13  Budapest,  16  May,  2011   The  5th  Wave  Process  and  Outcomes   13   13  
  14. 14. Welcome  to  ENoLL!   •  Compile  and  send  your  info  leaflet   •  Register  with  the  ENoLL  site   •  Choose  your  membership  profile   •  Express  your  interest  in  a  Working  Group   •  Join  one  or  more  ThemaBc  Domain  Networks   and...   •  Stay  around  for  the  group  photo!       20/05/11   14  Budapest,  16  May,  2011   The  5th  Wave  Process  and  Outcomes   14   14  
  15. 15. Thank  you  for  your  aXenBon   •  Jesse  Marsh,  5°  wave  coordinator   •  Álvaro  Oliveira  and  Mikael  Börjeson,  Task  Force  core   group   •  Pieter  Balloon  and  Anna  Kivilehto,  secretarial   support   •  The  ENoLL  evaluaBon  team   ...and  our  thanks  all  proposers  and  the  Corvinno  team   info@enoll.org   20/05/11   15  Budapest,  16  May,  2011   The  5th  Wave  Process  and  Outcomes   15   15  

×