SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 10
The penalties assessed by our government agencies for
  even unintentional violations of the export regulations
   (Export Administration Regulations and International
Traffic in Arms Regulations, and others) are such that small
   and medium-sized manufacturer/exporters can cause
   serious harm to their own future by taking a cavalier
  attitude toward exporting. The regulations are written
     such that it is not easy, without some training and
   experience, to wade through all the various rules and
exceptions that may apply to your specific export action. I
 have recently experienced a few incidents of companies
  using "a little knowledge" to address complex subjects.
                     Some of those follow:
Dual Use. While the Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS)
      under the Department of Commerce is generally
responsible for dual use items, the Directorate of Defense
   Trade Controls (DDTC) in the Department of State has
   "first rights of refusal" for taking jurisdiction over the
  items. In addition, there can be a significantly different
approach for an item initially designed for the military and
modified for commercial applications than for one initially
  designed for commercial and later modified for military
applications. There is no recipe available that can assure a
company that it is taking the safe approach. Each situation
                            is unique.
The Canadian Exemption. An initial reading taken a face
     value of the information available concerning the
 Canadian Exemption to license requires for International
  Trade in Arms Regulations (ITAR) type items seems to
   indicate that there is no issue with any military items
   going to Canada without requiring an export license.
  However, upon further investigation, the astute export
      expert will find more than 21 exceptions to the
exemption, in addition to the normal general prohibitions
    to export. Even if a license is not required, a certain
    amount of paperwork is required so that the Census
              Bureau can keep their statistics.
Commodity Jurisdiction. It's tempting for a manufacturer
 to self determine the jurisdiction of commodities and in
most cases it's relatively easily done by the manufacturer
on those items that clearly have no military application. In
    fact, the vast majority of items require no license for
  exporting. However, there are two inherent dangers: 1)
          certain records MUST be maintained for all
exports, including those that do not require a license, and
 2) it is often difficult to determine whether an item has a
    military or terrorist application. The government has
   recently made the process safer for manufacturers by
          offering to define the ECCN number for any
   commodity, and by providing an electronic means for
   submitting a Commodity Jurisdiction request. I would
   always recommend that a company take advantage of
I have discovered over many years of association with the
    government in various capacities, that nothing about
   government regulations is easy or obvious. The idea of
    writing these documents in "plain English" has been
  discussed over the years, but it's never really caught on.
 Even the definition of "plain English" has not yet achieved
agreement. A cursory reading of the Export Administration
     Regulations (EAR) and ITAR and publications on the
Internet relating to those documents can lead one to error.
For instance, not long ago a member of a client
organization stated to the effect that since most items do
 not require an export license (something he read on an
 official government website), the item he was exporting
 obviously would not require a license so he could safely
    proceed with its export. In addition, in his previous
 company he had done the same and since it was a large
  company they obviously knew what they were doing. I
  advised him, and his supervisor, to first determine the
ECCN of the subject item, which he had not done, then go
    to the EAR and see if a license was required and, if
   so, whether an exception was allowed. Whether he
              followed through, I don't know.
In another case, an item was stated to be ITAR controlled -
which was probably correct - but a derivative item, nearly
  identical, was not. Again, this determination was made
     without researching the regulations or exercising a
    Commodity Jurisdiction determination. I advised the
company to determine the ECCN, either themselves or via
   SNAP-R, and request a Commodity Jurisdiction. In this
  case, I have been lead to understand that the company
        will follow through on my recommendation.
Both those situations involved small companies and
relatively small exports. The odds of getting caught in a
violation were likely small, but the penalties, if they had
 committed the violations, could break either company.
                  The risks are too high.
If you don't have a knowledgeable export compliance
   person on your staff, hire a consultant. Don't assume,
unless you've been through a good training program, that
  you understand the regulations. Go on the government
    websites, either the Bureau of Industry and Security
www.bis.doc.gov or Directorate of Defense Trade Controls
www.pmddtc.state.gov, and take a look at the penalties of
 those companies, large and small, that have violated the
                 export rules. It's sobering.
http://wealth4allteam.com/?spon=3373/

More Related Content

Similar to A Little Knowledge Is a Dangerous Thing in the World of Exporting

Jurisdictional Determinations
Jurisdictional DeterminationsJurisdictional Determinations
Jurisdictional DeterminationsJohn Priecko
 
2016 ICPA Annual Conference
2016 ICPA Annual Conference2016 ICPA Annual Conference
2016 ICPA Annual ConferenceKathleen Murphy
 
Fcpa enforcement-aerospace-defense-industry
Fcpa enforcement-aerospace-defense-industryFcpa enforcement-aerospace-defense-industry
Fcpa enforcement-aerospace-defense-industryAlberto Garcia Romera
 
Cbp tips new_importers_exporters
Cbp tips new_importers_exportersCbp tips new_importers_exporters
Cbp tips new_importers_exporterssasan1
 
Export Compliance ITAR 2 of 3
Export Compliance ITAR 2 of 3Export Compliance ITAR 2 of 3
Export Compliance ITAR 2 of 3Robert Corona
 
Export Control for Patent Research Off-shoring
Export Control for Patent Research Off-shoringExport Control for Patent Research Off-shoring
Export Control for Patent Research Off-shoringArpit Chhabra
 
Export Control - Patent Services Offshoring
Export Control - Patent Services OffshoringExport Control - Patent Services Offshoring
Export Control - Patent Services Offshoringanantkataria
 
Export Compliance ITAR 3 of 3
Export Compliance ITAR 3 of 3Export Compliance ITAR 3 of 3
Export Compliance ITAR 3 of 3Robert Corona
 
Respond to at least two response posts made to your.docx
Respond to at least two response posts made to your.docxRespond to at least two response posts made to your.docx
Respond to at least two response posts made to your.docxwrite4
 
FTC Protecting Info A Guide For Business Powerpoint
FTC  Protecting  Info A  Guide  For  Business  PowerpointFTC  Protecting  Info A  Guide  For  Business  Powerpoint
FTC Protecting Info A Guide For Business PowerpointBucacci Business Solutions
 
Transatlantic business brief march 2014
Transatlantic business brief march 2014Transatlantic business brief march 2014
Transatlantic business brief march 2014Eliot Norman
 
Conflict Minerals: Understanding Dodd-Frank 1502 and Its Affect on Your Suppl...
Conflict Minerals: Understanding Dodd-Frank 1502 and Its Affect on Your Suppl...Conflict Minerals: Understanding Dodd-Frank 1502 and Its Affect on Your Suppl...
Conflict Minerals: Understanding Dodd-Frank 1502 and Its Affect on Your Suppl...Optimum Design Associates
 
Week5IRACFinalDraft
Week5IRACFinalDraftWeek5IRACFinalDraft
Week5IRACFinalDraftRachel Krebs
 
Doing Business With The Department of Defense (DOD)
Doing Business With The Department of Defense (DOD)Doing Business With The Department of Defense (DOD)
Doing Business With The Department of Defense (DOD)WBDC of Florida
 

Similar to A Little Knowledge Is a Dangerous Thing in the World of Exporting (20)

Jurisdictional Determinations
Jurisdictional DeterminationsJurisdictional Determinations
Jurisdictional Determinations
 
2016 ICPA Annual Conference
2016 ICPA Annual Conference2016 ICPA Annual Conference
2016 ICPA Annual Conference
 
BDG International - Global Trade
BDG International - Global TradeBDG International - Global Trade
BDG International - Global Trade
 
Fcpa enforcement-aerospace-defense-industry
Fcpa enforcement-aerospace-defense-industryFcpa enforcement-aerospace-defense-industry
Fcpa enforcement-aerospace-defense-industry
 
Cbp tips new_importers_exporters
Cbp tips new_importers_exportersCbp tips new_importers_exporters
Cbp tips new_importers_exporters
 
US Trade law Regulation of Technology Exports
US Trade law Regulation of Technology ExportsUS Trade law Regulation of Technology Exports
US Trade law Regulation of Technology Exports
 
Swttu
SwttuSwttu
Swttu
 
Export Compliance ITAR 2 of 3
Export Compliance ITAR 2 of 3Export Compliance ITAR 2 of 3
Export Compliance ITAR 2 of 3
 
Export Control for Patent Research Off-shoring
Export Control for Patent Research Off-shoringExport Control for Patent Research Off-shoring
Export Control for Patent Research Off-shoring
 
Export Control - Patent Services Offshoring
Export Control - Patent Services OffshoringExport Control - Patent Services Offshoring
Export Control - Patent Services Offshoring
 
UK Export Controls: Taking a Strategic Approach
UK Export Controls: Taking a Strategic ApproachUK Export Controls: Taking a Strategic Approach
UK Export Controls: Taking a Strategic Approach
 
Export Compliance ITAR 3 of 3
Export Compliance ITAR 3 of 3Export Compliance ITAR 3 of 3
Export Compliance ITAR 3 of 3
 
Respond to at least two response posts made to your.docx
Respond to at least two response posts made to your.docxRespond to at least two response posts made to your.docx
Respond to at least two response posts made to your.docx
 
FTC Protecting Info A Guide For Business Powerpoint
FTC  Protecting  Info A  Guide  For  Business  PowerpointFTC  Protecting  Info A  Guide  For  Business  Powerpoint
FTC Protecting Info A Guide For Business Powerpoint
 
Transatlantic business brief march 2014
Transatlantic business brief march 2014Transatlantic business brief march 2014
Transatlantic business brief march 2014
 
Conflict Minerals: Understanding Dodd-Frank 1502 and Its Affect on Your Suppl...
Conflict Minerals: Understanding Dodd-Frank 1502 and Its Affect on Your Suppl...Conflict Minerals: Understanding Dodd-Frank 1502 and Its Affect on Your Suppl...
Conflict Minerals: Understanding Dodd-Frank 1502 and Its Affect on Your Suppl...
 
Conflict Minerals and Your Supply Chain
Conflict Minerals and Your Supply ChainConflict Minerals and Your Supply Chain
Conflict Minerals and Your Supply Chain
 
Week5IRACFinalDraft
Week5IRACFinalDraftWeek5IRACFinalDraft
Week5IRACFinalDraft
 
Busn 420 final exam
Busn 420 final examBusn 420 final exam
Busn 420 final exam
 
Doing Business With The Department of Defense (DOD)
Doing Business With The Department of Defense (DOD)Doing Business With The Department of Defense (DOD)
Doing Business With The Department of Defense (DOD)
 

More from mlmner

2013 vw lifewave leaflet
2013 vw lifewave leaflet2013 vw lifewave leaflet
2013 vw lifewave leafletmlmner
 
The Costs Of Telemarketing
The Costs Of TelemarketingThe Costs Of Telemarketing
The Costs Of Telemarketingmlmner
 
Help From Debt Consolidation Companies Is Handy
Help From Debt Consolidation Companies Is HandyHelp From Debt Consolidation Companies Is Handy
Help From Debt Consolidation Companies Is Handymlmner
 
Business Networking: A Tool for Success
Business Networking: A Tool for SuccessBusiness Networking: A Tool for Success
Business Networking: A Tool for Successmlmner
 
Running a Business in These Uncertain Times
Running a Business in These Uncertain TimesRunning a Business in These Uncertain Times
Running a Business in These Uncertain Timesmlmner
 
The Five Point Close
The Five Point CloseThe Five Point Close
The Five Point Closemlmner
 
Offshore Company Registration - The Procedure and the Benefits
Offshore Company Registration - The Procedure and the BenefitsOffshore Company Registration - The Procedure and the Benefits
Offshore Company Registration - The Procedure and the Benefitsmlmner
 
Sales Techniques: 7 Steps To A Successful Sales Call
Sales Techniques: 7 Steps To A Successful Sales CallSales Techniques: 7 Steps To A Successful Sales Call
Sales Techniques: 7 Steps To A Successful Sales Callmlmner
 
Capture and Maintain a 360 Degree View of Customers Through CRM Technology
Capture and Maintain a 360 Degree View of Customers Through CRM TechnologyCapture and Maintain a 360 Degree View of Customers Through CRM Technology
Capture and Maintain a 360 Degree View of Customers Through CRM Technologymlmner
 
Great American Corporations Taking an Interest In Future Math Superstars - Go...
Great American Corporations Taking an Interest In Future Math Superstars - Go...Great American Corporations Taking an Interest In Future Math Superstars - Go...
Great American Corporations Taking an Interest In Future Math Superstars - Go...mlmner
 
Debt Collector Harassment and Knowing Your Rights
Debt Collector Harassment and Knowing Your RightsDebt Collector Harassment and Knowing Your Rights
Debt Collector Harassment and Knowing Your Rightsmlmner
 
Why Do You Need a Sales Commission Scheme?
Why Do You Need a Sales Commission Scheme?Why Do You Need a Sales Commission Scheme?
Why Do You Need a Sales Commission Scheme?mlmner
 
Turning Your Partner Network Into A Team
Turning Your Partner Network Into A TeamTurning Your Partner Network Into A Team
Turning Your Partner Network Into A Teammlmner
 
Are Your Marketing Activities Stuck in a Rut?
Are Your Marketing Activities Stuck in a Rut?Are Your Marketing Activities Stuck in a Rut?
Are Your Marketing Activities Stuck in a Rut?mlmner
 
Benefits of Vertical Fame: 10 Reasons Why You Should Niche Now!
Benefits of Vertical Fame: 10 Reasons Why You Should Niche Now!Benefits of Vertical Fame: 10 Reasons Why You Should Niche Now!
Benefits of Vertical Fame: 10 Reasons Why You Should Niche Now!mlmner
 
Income Tax Preparation - Guide
Income Tax Preparation - GuideIncome Tax Preparation - Guide
Income Tax Preparation - Guidemlmner
 
No BS Grassroots Marketing Inconvenient Truth 2 - Don't Promote Your Yellow P...
No BS Grassroots Marketing Inconvenient Truth 2 - Don't Promote Your Yellow P...No BS Grassroots Marketing Inconvenient Truth 2 - Don't Promote Your Yellow P...
No BS Grassroots Marketing Inconvenient Truth 2 - Don't Promote Your Yellow P...mlmner
 

More from mlmner (17)

2013 vw lifewave leaflet
2013 vw lifewave leaflet2013 vw lifewave leaflet
2013 vw lifewave leaflet
 
The Costs Of Telemarketing
The Costs Of TelemarketingThe Costs Of Telemarketing
The Costs Of Telemarketing
 
Help From Debt Consolidation Companies Is Handy
Help From Debt Consolidation Companies Is HandyHelp From Debt Consolidation Companies Is Handy
Help From Debt Consolidation Companies Is Handy
 
Business Networking: A Tool for Success
Business Networking: A Tool for SuccessBusiness Networking: A Tool for Success
Business Networking: A Tool for Success
 
Running a Business in These Uncertain Times
Running a Business in These Uncertain TimesRunning a Business in These Uncertain Times
Running a Business in These Uncertain Times
 
The Five Point Close
The Five Point CloseThe Five Point Close
The Five Point Close
 
Offshore Company Registration - The Procedure and the Benefits
Offshore Company Registration - The Procedure and the BenefitsOffshore Company Registration - The Procedure and the Benefits
Offshore Company Registration - The Procedure and the Benefits
 
Sales Techniques: 7 Steps To A Successful Sales Call
Sales Techniques: 7 Steps To A Successful Sales CallSales Techniques: 7 Steps To A Successful Sales Call
Sales Techniques: 7 Steps To A Successful Sales Call
 
Capture and Maintain a 360 Degree View of Customers Through CRM Technology
Capture and Maintain a 360 Degree View of Customers Through CRM TechnologyCapture and Maintain a 360 Degree View of Customers Through CRM Technology
Capture and Maintain a 360 Degree View of Customers Through CRM Technology
 
Great American Corporations Taking an Interest In Future Math Superstars - Go...
Great American Corporations Taking an Interest In Future Math Superstars - Go...Great American Corporations Taking an Interest In Future Math Superstars - Go...
Great American Corporations Taking an Interest In Future Math Superstars - Go...
 
Debt Collector Harassment and Knowing Your Rights
Debt Collector Harassment and Knowing Your RightsDebt Collector Harassment and Knowing Your Rights
Debt Collector Harassment and Knowing Your Rights
 
Why Do You Need a Sales Commission Scheme?
Why Do You Need a Sales Commission Scheme?Why Do You Need a Sales Commission Scheme?
Why Do You Need a Sales Commission Scheme?
 
Turning Your Partner Network Into A Team
Turning Your Partner Network Into A TeamTurning Your Partner Network Into A Team
Turning Your Partner Network Into A Team
 
Are Your Marketing Activities Stuck in a Rut?
Are Your Marketing Activities Stuck in a Rut?Are Your Marketing Activities Stuck in a Rut?
Are Your Marketing Activities Stuck in a Rut?
 
Benefits of Vertical Fame: 10 Reasons Why You Should Niche Now!
Benefits of Vertical Fame: 10 Reasons Why You Should Niche Now!Benefits of Vertical Fame: 10 Reasons Why You Should Niche Now!
Benefits of Vertical Fame: 10 Reasons Why You Should Niche Now!
 
Income Tax Preparation - Guide
Income Tax Preparation - GuideIncome Tax Preparation - Guide
Income Tax Preparation - Guide
 
No BS Grassroots Marketing Inconvenient Truth 2 - Don't Promote Your Yellow P...
No BS Grassroots Marketing Inconvenient Truth 2 - Don't Promote Your Yellow P...No BS Grassroots Marketing Inconvenient Truth 2 - Don't Promote Your Yellow P...
No BS Grassroots Marketing Inconvenient Truth 2 - Don't Promote Your Yellow P...
 

A Little Knowledge Is a Dangerous Thing in the World of Exporting

  • 1. The penalties assessed by our government agencies for even unintentional violations of the export regulations (Export Administration Regulations and International Traffic in Arms Regulations, and others) are such that small and medium-sized manufacturer/exporters can cause serious harm to their own future by taking a cavalier attitude toward exporting. The regulations are written such that it is not easy, without some training and experience, to wade through all the various rules and exceptions that may apply to your specific export action. I have recently experienced a few incidents of companies using "a little knowledge" to address complex subjects. Some of those follow:
  • 2. Dual Use. While the Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) under the Department of Commerce is generally responsible for dual use items, the Directorate of Defense Trade Controls (DDTC) in the Department of State has "first rights of refusal" for taking jurisdiction over the items. In addition, there can be a significantly different approach for an item initially designed for the military and modified for commercial applications than for one initially designed for commercial and later modified for military applications. There is no recipe available that can assure a company that it is taking the safe approach. Each situation is unique.
  • 3. The Canadian Exemption. An initial reading taken a face value of the information available concerning the Canadian Exemption to license requires for International Trade in Arms Regulations (ITAR) type items seems to indicate that there is no issue with any military items going to Canada without requiring an export license. However, upon further investigation, the astute export expert will find more than 21 exceptions to the exemption, in addition to the normal general prohibitions to export. Even if a license is not required, a certain amount of paperwork is required so that the Census Bureau can keep their statistics.
  • 4. Commodity Jurisdiction. It's tempting for a manufacturer to self determine the jurisdiction of commodities and in most cases it's relatively easily done by the manufacturer on those items that clearly have no military application. In fact, the vast majority of items require no license for exporting. However, there are two inherent dangers: 1) certain records MUST be maintained for all exports, including those that do not require a license, and 2) it is often difficult to determine whether an item has a military or terrorist application. The government has recently made the process safer for manufacturers by offering to define the ECCN number for any commodity, and by providing an electronic means for submitting a Commodity Jurisdiction request. I would always recommend that a company take advantage of
  • 5. I have discovered over many years of association with the government in various capacities, that nothing about government regulations is easy or obvious. The idea of writing these documents in "plain English" has been discussed over the years, but it's never really caught on. Even the definition of "plain English" has not yet achieved agreement. A cursory reading of the Export Administration Regulations (EAR) and ITAR and publications on the Internet relating to those documents can lead one to error.
  • 6. For instance, not long ago a member of a client organization stated to the effect that since most items do not require an export license (something he read on an official government website), the item he was exporting obviously would not require a license so he could safely proceed with its export. In addition, in his previous company he had done the same and since it was a large company they obviously knew what they were doing. I advised him, and his supervisor, to first determine the ECCN of the subject item, which he had not done, then go to the EAR and see if a license was required and, if so, whether an exception was allowed. Whether he followed through, I don't know.
  • 7. In another case, an item was stated to be ITAR controlled - which was probably correct - but a derivative item, nearly identical, was not. Again, this determination was made without researching the regulations or exercising a Commodity Jurisdiction determination. I advised the company to determine the ECCN, either themselves or via SNAP-R, and request a Commodity Jurisdiction. In this case, I have been lead to understand that the company will follow through on my recommendation.
  • 8. Both those situations involved small companies and relatively small exports. The odds of getting caught in a violation were likely small, but the penalties, if they had committed the violations, could break either company. The risks are too high.
  • 9. If you don't have a knowledgeable export compliance person on your staff, hire a consultant. Don't assume, unless you've been through a good training program, that you understand the regulations. Go on the government websites, either the Bureau of Industry and Security www.bis.doc.gov or Directorate of Defense Trade Controls www.pmddtc.state.gov, and take a look at the penalties of those companies, large and small, that have violated the export rules. It's sobering.