SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 8
Download to read offline
Project Outline

 • Project Period:
   Apr. 2008~Mar. 2011
 • Project Area:Catchment
   areas of 6 health centers in
   Prey Veng Operational
   District, Prey Veng Province
 • Target group:Health center
   staff and Community Health
   Workers(VHSG and TBA)of
   the target area,
   approximately 300 in total.


1) VHSG :Village Health Support Group
Project purpose:6 target Health Centers provide
Integrated ANC/PNC and Growth Monitoring services
through collaboration with Community Health
Workers.
*Integrated services include measuring weight/height, history taking
and physical check-up, early detection of problems , immunization,
micro-nutrient, and health education.



             Objective of the survey
To identify activities by VHSG and collaboration
between HC staff and VHSG at the time of
starting the project.
Survey method

• Target:18 Health Center staff and 97 VHSG who were
  randomly selected.
• Target area:Catchment areas of the 6 target HC
• Method:Face-to-face interview by using questionnaire
• Period:June - July, 2008
• Contents:VHSG activities (selection process, motivation,
  contents of activities), collaboration between VHSG and
  HC (including management by HC), contributing factors
  for VHSG to continue their activities.
• Analysis:Comparing answers by HC staff and VHSG for
  the same question.
• Ethical consideration:The interviewers explained the
  purpose of the survey and confidentiality to interviewees.
Results
                         Main Activities done by VHSG
                       (Answers by HC staff and VHSG)
100
 90
 80
 70
 60
 50
                                                                                                                        HC staff
 40                                                                                                                     VHSG
 30
 20
 10
  0        Collect   Collect and inform Disseminate       Detect TB      Conduct HE        Inform      Refer patients
      children/women     health data information about suspect/Supprot                  community's
       for outreach                      HC service       TB DOTS                     complain/request
           activity                                                                   about HC service
Results (continued)
                                                                                            Request/consulation HC
            Difficulties in VHSG                                                            staff have received from
             activities (N=36)
                                                                                                VHSG (N=18)
45

40                                                                                     60
35
                                                                                       50
30

25
                                                                                       40

20                                                                                     30
15
                                                                                       20
10
                                                                                       10
5

0     Nomeans of      No collaboration Too much work   Lack of health   No financial
                                                                                       0    Request for   Request for     Health       Difficult to get
     transportation    from villagers                    knowledge       benefits
                                                                                              financial     material    education in    collboration
                                                                                             incentive     incentive    community      from villagers


Main difficulties raised by VHSG raised were; collecting mothers and
children for outreach services(61.1%) ; and conducting health
education(27.8%).
Results (continued)

 Factors for VHSG to continue their activities
             Answers by VHSG(N=93)                                                   Answers by HC staff (N=18)

90                                                                          90

80                                                                          80

70                                                                          70

60                                                                          60

50                                                                          50

40                                                                          40

30                                                                          30

20                                                                          20

10                                                                          10

 0   Satisfaction as HV Material and financial   Increase health   Others
                                                                             0   Financial   Technical Material support
                                                                                                                     Emorional/moral   Others
                              benefits              knowledge                    support      support                   support
Main findings
• Main activities by VHSG were supporting HC’s
  outreach services.
• Health Center did not pay much recognition to
  some VHSG activities such as health education,
  referral of patients and sending voices of
  community people to Health Center.
• While majority of VHSG chose moral/emotional
  support as the most important factor for them to
  continue their activities, HC staff considered
  providing financial benefits was more important.
Conclusion
• Health Center staff were rather negative towards collaboration
  with VHSG which supposed to be essential for HC to provide
  quality services to community members. Many HC staff were
  hesitant to collaborate with VHSG without providing financial
  benefits.
• Such attitudes of HC staff were largely influenced by the
  situation where many aid agencies (especially NGOs) actually
  provided financial incentives to VHSG, much more than HC
  could afford to do so. As VHSG became ‘paid-volunteers’ ,
  which was actually opposite to their expected roles under the
  national policy, a big challenge arose in promoting VHSG’s
  activities with their own initiative.
• There is a necessity to strengthen collaboration among
  community members, CHWs, and HC staff in more sustainable
  way, such as providing technical support and creating
  opportunity for mutual communication; this is a core element of
  our approach to implement project activities.

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

stepwise interpretation of ECG ID279 RVH
stepwise interpretation of ECG ID279 RVHstepwise interpretation of ECG ID279 RVH
stepwise interpretation of ECG ID279 RVHAnas Nader
 
Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #912 no Dx ID111
Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #912 no Dx  ID111Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #912 no Dx  ID111
Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #912 no Dx ID111Anas Nader
 
Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #02 no Dx ID352
Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #02 no Dx ID352Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #02 no Dx ID352
Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #02 no Dx ID352Anas Nader
 
File thu nghiem van hoa kinh doanh
File thu nghiem van hoa kinh doanhFile thu nghiem van hoa kinh doanh
File thu nghiem van hoa kinh doanhtaoxanh1509
 
Integrated activity posters
Integrated activity postersIntegrated activity posters
Integrated activity postersTUAT
 
Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #7 no Dx ID259
Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #7 no Dx  ID259Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #7 no Dx  ID259
Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #7 no Dx ID259Anas Nader
 
Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #05 no Dx ID175
Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #05 no Dx  ID175Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #05 no Dx  ID175
Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #05 no Dx ID175Anas Nader
 
Stepwise interpretation of ECG ID122
Stepwise interpretation of ECG ID122Stepwise interpretation of ECG ID122
Stepwise interpretation of ECG ID122Anas Nader
 
Tanya jawab kesehatan adm toa
Tanya  jawab kesehatan  adm toaTanya  jawab kesehatan  adm toa
Tanya jawab kesehatan adm toaleonid63
 
Newsletter dec09
Newsletter dec09Newsletter dec09
Newsletter dec09TUAT
 

Viewers also liked (12)

stepwise interpretation of ECG ID279 RVH
stepwise interpretation of ECG ID279 RVHstepwise interpretation of ECG ID279 RVH
stepwise interpretation of ECG ID279 RVH
 
Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #912 no Dx ID111
Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #912 no Dx  ID111Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #912 no Dx  ID111
Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #912 no Dx ID111
 
Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #02 no Dx ID352
Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #02 no Dx ID352Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #02 no Dx ID352
Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #02 no Dx ID352
 
File thu nghiem van hoa kinh doanh
File thu nghiem van hoa kinh doanhFile thu nghiem van hoa kinh doanh
File thu nghiem van hoa kinh doanh
 
Integrated activity posters
Integrated activity postersIntegrated activity posters
Integrated activity posters
 
Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #7 no Dx ID259
Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #7 no Dx  ID259Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #7 no Dx  ID259
Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #7 no Dx ID259
 
Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #05 no Dx ID175
Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #05 no Dx  ID175Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #05 no Dx  ID175
Stepwise interpretation of ECG - #05 no Dx ID175
 
Stepwise interpretation of ECG ID122
Stepwise interpretation of ECG ID122Stepwise interpretation of ECG ID122
Stepwise interpretation of ECG ID122
 
Gsbpm
GsbpmGsbpm
Gsbpm
 
Tanya jawab kesehatan adm toa
Tanya  jawab kesehatan  adm toaTanya  jawab kesehatan  adm toa
Tanya jawab kesehatan adm toa
 
Gsbpm
GsbpmGsbpm
Gsbpm
 
Newsletter dec09
Newsletter dec09Newsletter dec09
Newsletter dec09
 

Similar to Baselinesurvey2008

Peter Colclough: Torbay experience
Peter Colclough: Torbay experiencePeter Colclough: Torbay experience
Peter Colclough: Torbay experienceNuffield Trust
 
saskdocs' presentation to U of S alumni
saskdocs' presentation to U of S alumni saskdocs' presentation to U of S alumni
saskdocs' presentation to U of S alumni James Winkel
 
20150320 integration
20150320 integration20150320 integration
20150320 integrationAge UK
 
Students'health promotion at public health, kku.
Students'health promotion at public health, kku.Students'health promotion at public health, kku.
Students'health promotion at public health, kku.chusot
 
ANIS2011_SI sitour koto _vietnam
ANIS2011_SI sitour koto _vietnamANIS2011_SI sitour koto _vietnam
ANIS2011_SI sitour koto _vietnamngoinnovation
 
Gregor Coster: The national health board in New Zealand
Gregor Coster: The national health board in New ZealandGregor Coster: The national health board in New Zealand
Gregor Coster: The national health board in New ZealandNuffield Trust
 
Global Health Action-Haiti
Global Health Action-HaitiGlobal Health Action-Haiti
Global Health Action-HaitiGirija Sankar
 
Influence of GHIs on Mozambique public health system
Influence of GHIs on Mozambique public health systemInfluence of GHIs on Mozambique public health system
Influence of GHIs on Mozambique public health systemGlobalHealthObserver
 
The benefits of rural resource centres and farmer-to-farmer extension; exper...
The benefits of rural resource centres and farmer-to-farmer extension; exper...The benefits of rural resource centres and farmer-to-farmer extension; exper...
The benefits of rural resource centres and farmer-to-farmer extension; exper...Pan African Farmers Organization
 
Evaluation of participatory disease surveillance for highly pathogenic avian...
Evaluation of participatory disease surveillance  for highly pathogenic avian...Evaluation of participatory disease surveillance  for highly pathogenic avian...
Evaluation of participatory disease surveillance for highly pathogenic avian...ILRI
 
Tina Lloren & Habtamu Fekadu
Tina Lloren & Habtamu FekaduTina Lloren & Habtamu Fekadu
Tina Lloren & Habtamu Fekadunacsconf
 
Walking at Wisner
Walking at WisnerWalking at Wisner
Walking at Wisnerkbhall82
 
Public healthpresentationapril2012heatherkapp
Public healthpresentationapril2012heatherkappPublic healthpresentationapril2012heatherkapp
Public healthpresentationapril2012heatherkappmedenison
 
How's Life: The OECD Better Life Index
How's Life: The OECD Better Life IndexHow's Life: The OECD Better Life Index
How's Life: The OECD Better Life IndexOECD Washington Center
 
Snapshot of integrated working
Snapshot of integrated workingSnapshot of integrated working
Snapshot of integrated workingNHS Confederation
 
Consumer beh aior of desi ghee
Consumer beh aior of desi gheeConsumer beh aior of desi ghee
Consumer beh aior of desi gheeSahil Marwaha
 

Similar to Baselinesurvey2008 (20)

Peter Colclough: Torbay experience
Peter Colclough: Torbay experiencePeter Colclough: Torbay experience
Peter Colclough: Torbay experience
 
saskdocs' presentation to U of S alumni
saskdocs' presentation to U of S alumni saskdocs' presentation to U of S alumni
saskdocs' presentation to U of S alumni
 
20150320 integration
20150320 integration20150320 integration
20150320 integration
 
Students'health promotion at public health, kku.
Students'health promotion at public health, kku.Students'health promotion at public health, kku.
Students'health promotion at public health, kku.
 
ANIS2011_SI sitour koto _vietnam
ANIS2011_SI sitour koto _vietnamANIS2011_SI sitour koto _vietnam
ANIS2011_SI sitour koto _vietnam
 
Gregor Coster: The national health board in New Zealand
Gregor Coster: The national health board in New ZealandGregor Coster: The national health board in New Zealand
Gregor Coster: The national health board in New Zealand
 
Getting co production right in health services
Getting co production right in health servicesGetting co production right in health services
Getting co production right in health services
 
Global Health Action-Haiti
Global Health Action-HaitiGlobal Health Action-Haiti
Global Health Action-Haiti
 
Influence of GHIs on Mozambique public health system
Influence of GHIs on Mozambique public health systemInfluence of GHIs on Mozambique public health system
Influence of GHIs on Mozambique public health system
 
The benefits of rural resource centres and farmer-to-farmer extension; exper...
The benefits of rural resource centres and farmer-to-farmer extension; exper...The benefits of rural resource centres and farmer-to-farmer extension; exper...
The benefits of rural resource centres and farmer-to-farmer extension; exper...
 
09.18.20 | Sustaining the HIV Workforce through Med Ed Innovations
09.18.20 | Sustaining the HIV Workforce through Med Ed Innovations09.18.20 | Sustaining the HIV Workforce through Med Ed Innovations
09.18.20 | Sustaining the HIV Workforce through Med Ed Innovations
 
Mhrn liam ennis
Mhrn  liam ennisMhrn  liam ennis
Mhrn liam ennis
 
Evaluation of participatory disease surveillance for highly pathogenic avian...
Evaluation of participatory disease surveillance  for highly pathogenic avian...Evaluation of participatory disease surveillance  for highly pathogenic avian...
Evaluation of participatory disease surveillance for highly pathogenic avian...
 
Tina Lloren & Habtamu Fekadu
Tina Lloren & Habtamu FekaduTina Lloren & Habtamu Fekadu
Tina Lloren & Habtamu Fekadu
 
Walking at Wisner
Walking at WisnerWalking at Wisner
Walking at Wisner
 
Public healthpresentationapril2012heatherkapp
Public healthpresentationapril2012heatherkappPublic healthpresentationapril2012heatherkapp
Public healthpresentationapril2012heatherkapp
 
How's Life: The OECD Better Life Index
How's Life: The OECD Better Life IndexHow's Life: The OECD Better Life Index
How's Life: The OECD Better Life Index
 
Consumers’ Role In Phc – Lessons From Slovenia E
Consumers’ Role In Phc – Lessons From Slovenia EConsumers’ Role In Phc – Lessons From Slovenia E
Consumers’ Role In Phc – Lessons From Slovenia E
 
Snapshot of integrated working
Snapshot of integrated workingSnapshot of integrated working
Snapshot of integrated working
 
Consumer beh aior of desi ghee
Consumer beh aior of desi gheeConsumer beh aior of desi ghee
Consumer beh aior of desi ghee
 

Baselinesurvey2008

  • 1. Project Outline • Project Period: Apr. 2008~Mar. 2011 • Project Area:Catchment areas of 6 health centers in Prey Veng Operational District, Prey Veng Province • Target group:Health center staff and Community Health Workers(VHSG and TBA)of the target area, approximately 300 in total. 1) VHSG :Village Health Support Group
  • 2. Project purpose:6 target Health Centers provide Integrated ANC/PNC and Growth Monitoring services through collaboration with Community Health Workers. *Integrated services include measuring weight/height, history taking and physical check-up, early detection of problems , immunization, micro-nutrient, and health education. Objective of the survey To identify activities by VHSG and collaboration between HC staff and VHSG at the time of starting the project.
  • 3. Survey method • Target:18 Health Center staff and 97 VHSG who were randomly selected. • Target area:Catchment areas of the 6 target HC • Method:Face-to-face interview by using questionnaire • Period:June - July, 2008 • Contents:VHSG activities (selection process, motivation, contents of activities), collaboration between VHSG and HC (including management by HC), contributing factors for VHSG to continue their activities. • Analysis:Comparing answers by HC staff and VHSG for the same question. • Ethical consideration:The interviewers explained the purpose of the survey and confidentiality to interviewees.
  • 4. Results Main Activities done by VHSG (Answers by HC staff and VHSG) 100 90 80 70 60 50 HC staff 40 VHSG 30 20 10 0 Collect Collect and inform Disseminate Detect TB Conduct HE Inform Refer patients children/women health data information about suspect/Supprot community's for outreach HC service TB DOTS complain/request activity about HC service
  • 5. Results (continued) Request/consulation HC Difficulties in VHSG staff have received from activities (N=36) VHSG (N=18) 45 40 60 35 50 30 25 40 20 30 15 20 10 10 5 0 Nomeans of No collaboration Too much work Lack of health No financial 0 Request for Request for Health Difficult to get transportation from villagers knowledge benefits financial material education in collboration incentive incentive community from villagers Main difficulties raised by VHSG raised were; collecting mothers and children for outreach services(61.1%) ; and conducting health education(27.8%).
  • 6. Results (continued) Factors for VHSG to continue their activities Answers by VHSG(N=93) Answers by HC staff (N=18) 90 90 80 80 70 70 60 60 50 50 40 40 30 30 20 20 10 10 0 Satisfaction as HV Material and financial Increase health Others 0 Financial Technical Material support Emorional/moral Others benefits knowledge support support support
  • 7. Main findings • Main activities by VHSG were supporting HC’s outreach services. • Health Center did not pay much recognition to some VHSG activities such as health education, referral of patients and sending voices of community people to Health Center. • While majority of VHSG chose moral/emotional support as the most important factor for them to continue their activities, HC staff considered providing financial benefits was more important.
  • 8. Conclusion • Health Center staff were rather negative towards collaboration with VHSG which supposed to be essential for HC to provide quality services to community members. Many HC staff were hesitant to collaborate with VHSG without providing financial benefits. • Such attitudes of HC staff were largely influenced by the situation where many aid agencies (especially NGOs) actually provided financial incentives to VHSG, much more than HC could afford to do so. As VHSG became ‘paid-volunteers’ , which was actually opposite to their expected roles under the national policy, a big challenge arose in promoting VHSG’s activities with their own initiative. • There is a necessity to strengthen collaboration among community members, CHWs, and HC staff in more sustainable way, such as providing technical support and creating opportunity for mutual communication; this is a core element of our approach to implement project activities.