SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 2
Download to read offline
Federal judge strikes down Texas law requiring voter ID at
polls | Reuters
A federal judge on Thursday struck down a Texas law requiring voters to show identification at polls,
saying it placed an unconstitutional burden on voters and discriminated against minorities.
In a ruling that follows a two-week trial in Corpus Christi of a lawsuit challenging the law, U.S.
District Judge Nelva Gonzales Ramos also found that it amounted to an unconstitutional poll tax.
"The court holds that SB 14 creates an unconstitutional burden on the right to vote, has an
impermissible discriminatory effect against Hispanics and African-Americans and was imposed with
an unconstitutional lawyers in Texas discriminatory purpose," Ramos wrote in a 147-page ruling.
The case is part of a strategy by the Obama administration to challenge voting laws it says
discriminate by race in order to counter a U.S. Supreme Court ruling in June that freed states from
strict federal oversight.
"We are extremely heartened by the court's decision, which affirms our position that the Texas voter
identification law unfairly and unnecessarily restricts access to the franchise," U.S. Attorney General
Eric Holder said in a written statement following the ruling.
"Even after the Voting Rights Act was seriously eroded last year, we vowed to continue enforcing the
remaining portions of that statute as aggressively as possible," Holder said. "This ruling is an
important vindication of those efforts."
But Texas Attorney General Greg Abbot said the state would "immediately" appeal Ramos's ruling to
the U.S. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals and hoped to avoid confusion ahead of the November
elections.
"The U.S. Supreme Court has already ruled that voter ID laws are constitutional, so we are confident
the Texas law will be upheld on appeal," Abbott said in a written statement.
The trial stemmed from a battle over stringent voter ID measures signed into law by Texas
Republican Governor Rick Perry in 2011. The measure, which supporters say will prevent voter
fraud, requires voters to present a photo identification such as a driver's license, passport or military
ID card.
Plaintiffs argued the law would hit elderly and poorer voters, including ethnic minorities, hardest
because they are less likely to have such identification.
They would therefore be more likely to be turned away on voting day, suppressing the turnout of
groups who traditionally have supported Democrats, the plaintiffs charged.
The ruling comes on the same day that the U.S. Supreme Court prevented a new voter identification
law in Wisconsin http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/calaw.html from going into effect.
The nation's top court, with three conservative members dissenting, granted a last-minute request
by civil rights groups seeking to block an appeals court ruling that the law could be implemented.
Holder said in July that Texas would be the start of his push to overturn the voter ID laws.
The Obama administration sees such statutes as discriminatory and has launched a national rollout
of cases to work around Shelby County v. Holder, the Alabama case in which the Supreme Court
invalidated a key part of the 1965 Voting Rights Act.
(Reporting by Dan Whitcomb; Editing by Eric Walsh and Robert Birsel)
http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/10/10/us-usa-texas-voterid-idUSKCN0HZ04D20141010

More Related Content

What's hot

Ryan.brehmer.delaware and the death penalty
Ryan.brehmer.delaware and the death penaltyRyan.brehmer.delaware and the death penalty
Ryan.brehmer.delaware and the death penaltyRWB0314
 
Department of homeland security foia 2016 hqfo-00609 acknowledgment
Department of homeland security foia 2016 hqfo-00609 acknowledgmentDepartment of homeland security foia 2016 hqfo-00609 acknowledgment
Department of homeland security foia 2016 hqfo-00609 acknowledgmentBryan Johnson
 
India Legal 29 October 2018
India Legal 29 October 2018India Legal 29 October 2018
India Legal 29 October 2018ENC
 
Www nacdl org_resource_center_aspx_id_21257
Www nacdl org_resource_center_aspx_id_21257Www nacdl org_resource_center_aspx_id_21257
Www nacdl org_resource_center_aspx_id_21257Oswaldo Danna
 
A Look into the Laws on Homosexuality and Same-sex Marriage in Ghana, USA and...
A Look into the Laws on Homosexuality and Same-sex Marriage in Ghana, USA and...A Look into the Laws on Homosexuality and Same-sex Marriage in Ghana, USA and...
A Look into the Laws on Homosexuality and Same-sex Marriage in Ghana, USA and...Kwabena Amponsah Asare
 
The Project Vision
The Project VisionThe Project Vision
The Project VisionCandisClear
 

What's hot (8)

The incarcerated
The incarceratedThe incarcerated
The incarcerated
 
Ryan.brehmer.delaware and the death penalty
Ryan.brehmer.delaware and the death penaltyRyan.brehmer.delaware and the death penalty
Ryan.brehmer.delaware and the death penalty
 
Department of homeland security foia 2016 hqfo-00609 acknowledgment
Department of homeland security foia 2016 hqfo-00609 acknowledgmentDepartment of homeland security foia 2016 hqfo-00609 acknowledgment
Department of homeland security foia 2016 hqfo-00609 acknowledgment
 
India Legal 29 October 2018
India Legal 29 October 2018India Legal 29 October 2018
India Legal 29 October 2018
 
Www nacdl org_resource_center_aspx_id_21257
Www nacdl org_resource_center_aspx_id_21257Www nacdl org_resource_center_aspx_id_21257
Www nacdl org_resource_center_aspx_id_21257
 
A Look into the Laws on Homosexuality and Same-sex Marriage in Ghana, USA and...
A Look into the Laws on Homosexuality and Same-sex Marriage in Ghana, USA and...A Look into the Laws on Homosexuality and Same-sex Marriage in Ghana, USA and...
A Look into the Laws on Homosexuality and Same-sex Marriage in Ghana, USA and...
 
The Project Vision
The Project VisionThe Project Vision
The Project Vision
 
Law Research Paper
Law Research PaperLaw Research Paper
Law Research Paper
 

Viewers also liked

Solid state synthesis of mixed metal oxides repot final
Solid state synthesis of mixed metal oxides repot finalSolid state synthesis of mixed metal oxides repot final
Solid state synthesis of mixed metal oxides repot finalamgonzalezpineiro
 
4.identif de los traumatismos
4.identif de los traumatismos4.identif de los traumatismos
4.identif de los traumatismosRodo Cairo
 
9789740332930
97897403329309789740332930
9789740332930CUPress
 
pervers sexuel bourre façon hardcore la foune tout juste épilée d'une pompeus...
pervers sexuel bourre façon hardcore la foune tout juste épilée d'une pompeus...pervers sexuel bourre façon hardcore la foune tout juste épilée d'une pompeus...
pervers sexuel bourre façon hardcore la foune tout juste épilée d'une pompeus...quaintharmony5060
 
De vacaciones de la pérdida de Grasa
De vacaciones de la pérdida de GrasaDe vacaciones de la pérdida de Grasa
De vacaciones de la pérdida de Grasaaliketyro1706
 
Nandos radio advert analysis
Nandos radio advert analysisNandos radio advert analysis
Nandos radio advert analysisshaunaeleacy
 
Degree Certificate
Degree CertificateDegree Certificate
Degree CertificateXavier Teo
 
Uw project op Facebook nu uitlezen op Volgjewoning.nl
Uw project op Facebook nu uitlezen op Volgjewoning.nlUw project op Facebook nu uitlezen op Volgjewoning.nl
Uw project op Facebook nu uitlezen op Volgjewoning.nlMiranca Van der Tol
 
1. fix cover journal reading dokter erna copy
1. fix cover journal reading dokter erna   copy1. fix cover journal reading dokter erna   copy
1. fix cover journal reading dokter erna copyAndres Tandean
 
Premio Pritzker de Arquitectura Noticias, Fotos y Videos
Premio Pritzker de Arquitectura Noticias, Fotos y VideosPremio Pritzker de Arquitectura Noticias, Fotos y Videos
Premio Pritzker de Arquitectura Noticias, Fotos y Videosfidelegaspar2
 
Six Sigma White Belt Certificate
Six Sigma White Belt CertificateSix Sigma White Belt Certificate
Six Sigma White Belt CertificateDiona Aviles
 

Viewers also liked (16)

Pom 1
Pom 1Pom 1
Pom 1
 
Researching Genre
Researching GenreResearching Genre
Researching Genre
 
Solid state synthesis of mixed metal oxides repot final
Solid state synthesis of mixed metal oxides repot finalSolid state synthesis of mixed metal oxides repot final
Solid state synthesis of mixed metal oxides repot final
 
4.identif de los traumatismos
4.identif de los traumatismos4.identif de los traumatismos
4.identif de los traumatismos
 
9789740332930
97897403329309789740332930
9789740332930
 
Riesgos laborales
Riesgos laboralesRiesgos laborales
Riesgos laborales
 
pervers sexuel bourre façon hardcore la foune tout juste épilée d'une pompeus...
pervers sexuel bourre façon hardcore la foune tout juste épilée d'une pompeus...pervers sexuel bourre façon hardcore la foune tout juste épilée d'une pompeus...
pervers sexuel bourre façon hardcore la foune tout juste épilée d'une pompeus...
 
De vacaciones de la pérdida de Grasa
De vacaciones de la pérdida de GrasaDe vacaciones de la pérdida de Grasa
De vacaciones de la pérdida de Grasa
 
Horario
HorarioHorario
Horario
 
Nandos radio advert analysis
Nandos radio advert analysisNandos radio advert analysis
Nandos radio advert analysis
 
Degree Certificate
Degree CertificateDegree Certificate
Degree Certificate
 
Uw project op Facebook nu uitlezen op Volgjewoning.nl
Uw project op Facebook nu uitlezen op Volgjewoning.nlUw project op Facebook nu uitlezen op Volgjewoning.nl
Uw project op Facebook nu uitlezen op Volgjewoning.nl
 
1. fix cover journal reading dokter erna copy
1. fix cover journal reading dokter erna   copy1. fix cover journal reading dokter erna   copy
1. fix cover journal reading dokter erna copy
 
Premio Pritzker de Arquitectura Noticias, Fotos y Videos
Premio Pritzker de Arquitectura Noticias, Fotos y VideosPremio Pritzker de Arquitectura Noticias, Fotos y Videos
Premio Pritzker de Arquitectura Noticias, Fotos y Videos
 
Raghavendra Resume
Raghavendra ResumeRaghavendra Resume
Raghavendra Resume
 
Six Sigma White Belt Certificate
Six Sigma White Belt CertificateSix Sigma White Belt Certificate
Six Sigma White Belt Certificate
 

Similar to Federal judge strikes down Texas law requiring voter ID at polls | Reuters

VOTING FEATURE
VOTING FEATUREVOTING FEATURE
VOTING FEATUREBen Landis
 
Idealism refers to behavior or thought that is based on a concepti
Idealism refers to behavior or thought that is based on a conceptiIdealism refers to behavior or thought that is based on a concepti
Idealism refers to behavior or thought that is based on a conceptiLizbethQuinonez813
 
Undocumented immigrant can practice law in California, court rules
Undocumented immigrant can practice law in California, court rulesUndocumented immigrant can practice law in California, court rules
Undocumented immigrant can practice law in California, court rulesnoiselesshuman320
 
Undocumented immigrant can practice law in California, court rules
Undocumented immigrant can practice law in California, court rulesUndocumented immigrant can practice law in California, court rules
Undocumented immigrant can practice law in California, court rulesnoiselesshuman320
 
Missouri Supreme Court Selection and Retention in National Perspective
Missouri Supreme Court  Selection and Retention  in National PerspectiveMissouri Supreme Court  Selection and Retention  in National Perspective
Missouri Supreme Court Selection and Retention in National PerspectiveStephen Ware
 
More Than 300 Republicans Call on Supreme Court to Recognize Gay Marriage Nat...
More Than 300 Republicans Call on Supreme Court to Recognize Gay Marriage Nat...More Than 300 Republicans Call on Supreme Court to Recognize Gay Marriage Nat...
More Than 300 Republicans Call on Supreme Court to Recognize Gay Marriage Nat...madlytroupe9498
 
Elections, Parties and Interest Groups SP2020
Elections, Parties and Interest Groups SP2020Elections, Parties and Interest Groups SP2020
Elections, Parties and Interest Groups SP2020William Carder
 
17Supreme Court Cases – the right to voteJesus Mojica.docx
17Supreme Court Cases – the right to voteJesus Mojica.docx17Supreme Court Cases – the right to voteJesus Mojica.docx
17Supreme Court Cases – the right to voteJesus Mojica.docxdrennanmicah
 
ACLU of Delaware Summer 2017 Newsletter
ACLU of Delaware Summer 2017 NewsletterACLU of Delaware Summer 2017 Newsletter
ACLU of Delaware Summer 2017 NewsletterMindy Bogue
 
Study: Millions of Americans Go To Court Without a Lawyer
Study: Millions of Americans Go To Court Without a LawyerStudy: Millions of Americans Go To Court Without a Lawyer
Study: Millions of Americans Go To Court Without a LawyerMark_Carnell
 
Supreme Court on Voting Rights October 9, 2014WASHINGTON — The .docx
Supreme Court on Voting Rights  October 9, 2014WASHINGTON — The .docxSupreme Court on Voting Rights  October 9, 2014WASHINGTON — The .docx
Supreme Court on Voting Rights October 9, 2014WASHINGTON — The .docxmattinsonjanel
 
SB 1070 vs. Genocide
SB 1070 vs. GenocideSB 1070 vs. Genocide
SB 1070 vs. Genocidebecause789
 
Aila Urges Arizona Governor To Veto Unconstitutional And Overly Punitive Anti...
Aila Urges Arizona Governor To Veto Unconstitutional And Overly Punitive Anti...Aila Urges Arizona Governor To Veto Unconstitutional And Overly Punitive Anti...
Aila Urges Arizona Governor To Veto Unconstitutional And Overly Punitive Anti...bernard wolfsdorf
 
Fourteenth Amendment Brandon-L-Blankenship
Fourteenth Amendment Brandon-L-BlankenshipFourteenth Amendment Brandon-L-Blankenship
Fourteenth Amendment Brandon-L-BlankenshipBrandon L. Blankenship
 
10 ICE agents file lawsuit against DHS and ICE for executive order amnesty - ...
10 ICE agents file lawsuit against DHS and ICE for executive order amnesty - ...10 ICE agents file lawsuit against DHS and ICE for executive order amnesty - ...
10 ICE agents file lawsuit against DHS and ICE for executive order amnesty - ...2legal
 
Police-Records-Darren-Chaker
Police-Records-Darren-ChakerPolice-Records-Darren-Chaker
Police-Records-Darren-ChakerDarren Chaker
 
Hr4437
Hr4437Hr4437
Hr4437T. Lee
 
The Controversy Surrounding H.R. 4437
The Controversy Surrounding H.R. 4437The Controversy Surrounding H.R. 4437
The Controversy Surrounding H.R. 4437T. Lee
 
New Jersey arrest records
New Jersey arrest recordsNew Jersey arrest records
New Jersey arrest recordsdawidwillson586
 

Similar to Federal judge strikes down Texas law requiring voter ID at polls | Reuters (20)

VOTING FEATURE
VOTING FEATUREVOTING FEATURE
VOTING FEATURE
 
Idealism refers to behavior or thought that is based on a concepti
Idealism refers to behavior or thought that is based on a conceptiIdealism refers to behavior or thought that is based on a concepti
Idealism refers to behavior or thought that is based on a concepti
 
honestymarkherring
honestymarkherringhonestymarkherring
honestymarkherring
 
Undocumented immigrant can practice law in California, court rules
Undocumented immigrant can practice law in California, court rulesUndocumented immigrant can practice law in California, court rules
Undocumented immigrant can practice law in California, court rules
 
Undocumented immigrant can practice law in California, court rules
Undocumented immigrant can practice law in California, court rulesUndocumented immigrant can practice law in California, court rules
Undocumented immigrant can practice law in California, court rules
 
Missouri Supreme Court Selection and Retention in National Perspective
Missouri Supreme Court  Selection and Retention  in National PerspectiveMissouri Supreme Court  Selection and Retention  in National Perspective
Missouri Supreme Court Selection and Retention in National Perspective
 
More Than 300 Republicans Call on Supreme Court to Recognize Gay Marriage Nat...
More Than 300 Republicans Call on Supreme Court to Recognize Gay Marriage Nat...More Than 300 Republicans Call on Supreme Court to Recognize Gay Marriage Nat...
More Than 300 Republicans Call on Supreme Court to Recognize Gay Marriage Nat...
 
Elections, Parties and Interest Groups SP2020
Elections, Parties and Interest Groups SP2020Elections, Parties and Interest Groups SP2020
Elections, Parties and Interest Groups SP2020
 
17Supreme Court Cases – the right to voteJesus Mojica.docx
17Supreme Court Cases – the right to voteJesus Mojica.docx17Supreme Court Cases – the right to voteJesus Mojica.docx
17Supreme Court Cases – the right to voteJesus Mojica.docx
 
ACLU of Delaware Summer 2017 Newsletter
ACLU of Delaware Summer 2017 NewsletterACLU of Delaware Summer 2017 Newsletter
ACLU of Delaware Summer 2017 Newsletter
 
Study: Millions of Americans Go To Court Without a Lawyer
Study: Millions of Americans Go To Court Without a LawyerStudy: Millions of Americans Go To Court Without a Lawyer
Study: Millions of Americans Go To Court Without a Lawyer
 
Supreme Court on Voting Rights October 9, 2014WASHINGTON — The .docx
Supreme Court on Voting Rights  October 9, 2014WASHINGTON — The .docxSupreme Court on Voting Rights  October 9, 2014WASHINGTON — The .docx
Supreme Court on Voting Rights October 9, 2014WASHINGTON — The .docx
 
SB 1070 vs. Genocide
SB 1070 vs. GenocideSB 1070 vs. Genocide
SB 1070 vs. Genocide
 
Aila Urges Arizona Governor To Veto Unconstitutional And Overly Punitive Anti...
Aila Urges Arizona Governor To Veto Unconstitutional And Overly Punitive Anti...Aila Urges Arizona Governor To Veto Unconstitutional And Overly Punitive Anti...
Aila Urges Arizona Governor To Veto Unconstitutional And Overly Punitive Anti...
 
Fourteenth Amendment Brandon-L-Blankenship
Fourteenth Amendment Brandon-L-BlankenshipFourteenth Amendment Brandon-L-Blankenship
Fourteenth Amendment Brandon-L-Blankenship
 
10 ICE agents file lawsuit against DHS and ICE for executive order amnesty - ...
10 ICE agents file lawsuit against DHS and ICE for executive order amnesty - ...10 ICE agents file lawsuit against DHS and ICE for executive order amnesty - ...
10 ICE agents file lawsuit against DHS and ICE for executive order amnesty - ...
 
Police-Records-Darren-Chaker
Police-Records-Darren-ChakerPolice-Records-Darren-Chaker
Police-Records-Darren-Chaker
 
Hr4437
Hr4437Hr4437
Hr4437
 
The Controversy Surrounding H.R. 4437
The Controversy Surrounding H.R. 4437The Controversy Surrounding H.R. 4437
The Controversy Surrounding H.R. 4437
 
New Jersey arrest records
New Jersey arrest recordsNew Jersey arrest records
New Jersey arrest records
 

More from hesitantobstruc30

Brelo verdict protestors in court, get free legal advice
Brelo verdict protestors in court, get free legal adviceBrelo verdict protestors in court, get free legal advice
Brelo verdict protestors in court, get free legal advicehesitantobstruc30
 
Scott Panetti, Texas death row inmate, set to die, but lawyers say he's delus...
Scott Panetti, Texas death row inmate, set to die, but lawyers say he's delus...Scott Panetti, Texas death row inmate, set to die, but lawyers say he's delus...
Scott Panetti, Texas death row inmate, set to die, but lawyers say he's delus...hesitantobstruc30
 
At Least 1 Dead as Two Tornadoes Touch Down in North Texas
At Least 1 Dead as Two Tornadoes Touch Down in North TexasAt Least 1 Dead as Two Tornadoes Touch Down in North Texas
At Least 1 Dead as Two Tornadoes Touch Down in North Texashesitantobstruc30
 
Legal Technology 3.0 | Oliver R. Goodenough
Legal Technology 3.0 | Oliver R. GoodenoughLegal Technology 3.0 | Oliver R. Goodenough
Legal Technology 3.0 | Oliver R. Goodenoughhesitantobstruc30
 

More from hesitantobstruc30 (6)

Brelo verdict protestors in court, get free legal advice
Brelo verdict protestors in court, get free legal adviceBrelo verdict protestors in court, get free legal advice
Brelo verdict protestors in court, get free legal advice
 
Scott Panetti, Texas death row inmate, set to die, but lawyers say he's delus...
Scott Panetti, Texas death row inmate, set to die, but lawyers say he's delus...Scott Panetti, Texas death row inmate, set to die, but lawyers say he's delus...
Scott Panetti, Texas death row inmate, set to die, but lawyers say he's delus...
 
At Least 1 Dead as Two Tornadoes Touch Down in North Texas
At Least 1 Dead as Two Tornadoes Touch Down in North TexasAt Least 1 Dead as Two Tornadoes Touch Down in North Texas
At Least 1 Dead as Two Tornadoes Touch Down in North Texas
 
Test
TestTest
Test
 
Test
TestTest
Test
 
Legal Technology 3.0 | Oliver R. Goodenough
Legal Technology 3.0 | Oliver R. GoodenoughLegal Technology 3.0 | Oliver R. Goodenough
Legal Technology 3.0 | Oliver R. Goodenough
 

Federal judge strikes down Texas law requiring voter ID at polls | Reuters

  • 1. Federal judge strikes down Texas law requiring voter ID at polls | Reuters A federal judge on Thursday struck down a Texas law requiring voters to show identification at polls, saying it placed an unconstitutional burden on voters and discriminated against minorities. In a ruling that follows a two-week trial in Corpus Christi of a lawsuit challenging the law, U.S. District Judge Nelva Gonzales Ramos also found that it amounted to an unconstitutional poll tax. "The court holds that SB 14 creates an unconstitutional burden on the right to vote, has an impermissible discriminatory effect against Hispanics and African-Americans and was imposed with an unconstitutional lawyers in Texas discriminatory purpose," Ramos wrote in a 147-page ruling. The case is part of a strategy by the Obama administration to challenge voting laws it says discriminate by race in order to counter a U.S. Supreme Court ruling in June that freed states from strict federal oversight. "We are extremely heartened by the court's decision, which affirms our position that the Texas voter identification law unfairly and unnecessarily restricts access to the franchise," U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder said in a written statement following the ruling. "Even after the Voting Rights Act was seriously eroded last year, we vowed to continue enforcing the remaining portions of that statute as aggressively as possible," Holder said. "This ruling is an important vindication of those efforts." But Texas Attorney General Greg Abbot said the state would "immediately" appeal Ramos's ruling to the U.S. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals and hoped to avoid confusion ahead of the November elections. "The U.S. Supreme Court has already ruled that voter ID laws are constitutional, so we are confident the Texas law will be upheld on appeal," Abbott said in a written statement. The trial stemmed from a battle over stringent voter ID measures signed into law by Texas Republican Governor Rick Perry in 2011. The measure, which supporters say will prevent voter fraud, requires voters to present a photo identification such as a driver's license, passport or military ID card. Plaintiffs argued the law would hit elderly and poorer voters, including ethnic minorities, hardest because they are less likely to have such identification. They would therefore be more likely to be turned away on voting day, suppressing the turnout of groups who traditionally have supported Democrats, the plaintiffs charged. The ruling comes on the same day that the U.S. Supreme Court prevented a new voter identification law in Wisconsin http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/calaw.html from going into effect. The nation's top court, with three conservative members dissenting, granted a last-minute request
  • 2. by civil rights groups seeking to block an appeals court ruling that the law could be implemented. Holder said in July that Texas would be the start of his push to overturn the voter ID laws. The Obama administration sees such statutes as discriminatory and has launched a national rollout of cases to work around Shelby County v. Holder, the Alabama case in which the Supreme Court invalidated a key part of the 1965 Voting Rights Act. (Reporting by Dan Whitcomb; Editing by Eric Walsh and Robert Birsel) http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/10/10/us-usa-texas-voterid-idUSKCN0HZ04D20141010