SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 19
Renata Avila Pinto  Münich  11 May 2009 “ Market Failure and Regulation in Intellectual Property Markets ”
My presentation will discuss: I.  Intellectual   Property  Market II. Intellectual Property Regulation III. The effects and response
“ Intellectual Property Markets”
Exclusive Rights  strategies are  (not) dominant. Exclusive  rights  are (not) the roots of all growth and productivity  . Education System, Voluteers and social motivations, interoperability and improved efficencies Emerging “sharing economies”  Generativity “ Digital Natives”
The Global Market Developed Countries Developing Countries GDP per Capita Multilingualism Price Parity
The Market and The Marginal
“ Intellectual Property Regulation ”
Internationalization - Harmonization 70´s  WIPO and  Development Early 80 mid 90: SHIFT WTO TRIPS  WIPO Treaties BILATERALS FREE TRADE AGREEMENTS ACTA!!! EXTENSION OF PROTECTION AND ENFORCEMENT
Legal Hybrids, Exotic Rights Draw by Prof. Jerome Reichmann.
TODAY... ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
The most reasonable solution would be to change laws instead of trying to change people's ways.
Renata Avila Pinto  Münich  11 May 2008 “ Market Failure”
Not yet available Not available anymore  ( Authors Gild v. Google (orphan works?)  Only avaliable at distant markets Too high the price (Drugs, Derivative Works in certain languages, books in the south) Too little demand Difficult to aggregate demand ( Science Research)
Knowledge is a public good.  In many contexts, the threat of copyright liability chills creativity.  Different kinds of investments/innovations/discoveries  may deserve different degrees of protection
Market failure:  a loss of  allocative  efficency. “ The reason why piracy’s come along is that there weren’t enough products at the right price soon enough”
Price based on the local economic realities, demand recognized and served. Creating new markets.
Intellectual property rules diminish the supply of new ideas. Innovation depends on the  continuing supply on upstream row material. For All.  What most of developing countries lack is not human creativity or skills to innovate.
[object Object],[object Object]
Thank You! Design By Octopus under an attribution Creative Commons License

More Related Content

Similar to Market Failure - IP

Permissionless Innovation and the Future of Tech Policy (Thierer - Oct 2017 ed)
Permissionless Innovation and the Future of Tech Policy (Thierer - Oct 2017 ed)Permissionless Innovation and the Future of Tech Policy (Thierer - Oct 2017 ed)
Permissionless Innovation and the Future of Tech Policy (Thierer - Oct 2017 ed)Adam Thierer
 
“Permissionless Innovation” & the Clash of Visions over Emerging Technologies
“Permissionless Innovation” & the Clash of Visions over Emerging Technologies“Permissionless Innovation” & the Clash of Visions over Emerging Technologies
“Permissionless Innovation” & the Clash of Visions over Emerging TechnologiesAdam Thierer
 
Intellectual property rights in the global creative economy report 2013
Intellectual property rights in the global creative economy report 2013Intellectual property rights in the global creative economy report 2013
Intellectual property rights in the global creative economy report 2013Giuliano Tavaroli
 
Economics of Digital Information
Economics of Digital InformationEconomics of Digital Information
Economics of Digital InformationKathy Gill
 
Manifesto: David Koepsell
Manifesto: David KoepsellManifesto: David Koepsell
Manifesto: David KoepsellSTEPS Centre
 
Japanese Students @ UW
Japanese Students @ UWJapanese Students @ UW
Japanese Students @ UWKathy Gill
 
Freecultureforum barcelona2009 acta
Freecultureforum barcelona2009 actaFreecultureforum barcelona2009 acta
Freecultureforum barcelona2009 actaEddan Katz
 
AI and Robotics policy overview - Adam Thierer (Aug 2022)
AI and Robotics policy overview - Adam Thierer (Aug 2022)AI and Robotics policy overview - Adam Thierer (Aug 2022)
AI and Robotics policy overview - Adam Thierer (Aug 2022)Adam Thierer
 
The Future of Innovation of Policy - Adam Thierer - Mercatus Center
The Future of Innovation of Policy - Adam Thierer - Mercatus CenterThe Future of Innovation of Policy - Adam Thierer - Mercatus Center
The Future of Innovation of Policy - Adam Thierer - Mercatus CenterAdam Thierer
 
Tech Giants, the Moligopoly Hypothesis and Conglomerate Competition
Tech Giants, the Moligopoly Hypothesis and Conglomerate CompetitionTech Giants, the Moligopoly Hypothesis and Conglomerate Competition
Tech Giants, the Moligopoly Hypothesis and Conglomerate CompetitionNicolas Petit
 
Economics of Information/Technology
Economics of Information/TechnologyEconomics of Information/Technology
Economics of Information/TechnologyKathy Gill
 
Generative AI and law.pptx
Generative AI and law.pptxGenerative AI and law.pptx
Generative AI and law.pptxChris Marsden
 
LECTURE 4 - Cyberculture
LECTURE 4 - CybercultureLECTURE 4 - Cyberculture
LECTURE 4 - CybercultureKim Flintoff
 
IMPALA's Digital Action Plan
IMPALA's Digital Action PlanIMPALA's Digital Action Plan
IMPALA's Digital Action PlanIMPALAMusic
 
Linkedinjune2011
Linkedinjune2011Linkedinjune2011
Linkedinjune2011Chris Ngo
 
10 Ideas For A Better, Simpler World
10 Ideas For A Better, Simpler World10 Ideas For A Better, Simpler World
10 Ideas For A Better, Simpler Worldecneves
 

Similar to Market Failure - IP (20)

Permissionless Innovation and the Future of Tech Policy (Thierer - Oct 2017 ed)
Permissionless Innovation and the Future of Tech Policy (Thierer - Oct 2017 ed)Permissionless Innovation and the Future of Tech Policy (Thierer - Oct 2017 ed)
Permissionless Innovation and the Future of Tech Policy (Thierer - Oct 2017 ed)
 
“Permissionless Innovation” & the Clash of Visions over Emerging Technologies
“Permissionless Innovation” & the Clash of Visions over Emerging Technologies“Permissionless Innovation” & the Clash of Visions over Emerging Technologies
“Permissionless Innovation” & the Clash of Visions over Emerging Technologies
 
Guidelines on Intellectual Property Rights
Guidelines on Intellectual Property RightsGuidelines on Intellectual Property Rights
Guidelines on Intellectual Property Rights
 
Intellectual property rights in the global creative economy report 2013
Intellectual property rights in the global creative economy report 2013Intellectual property rights in the global creative economy report 2013
Intellectual property rights in the global creative economy report 2013
 
Economics of Digital Information
Economics of Digital InformationEconomics of Digital Information
Economics of Digital Information
 
Manifesto: David Koepsell
Manifesto: David KoepsellManifesto: David Koepsell
Manifesto: David Koepsell
 
Innovation & Law
Innovation & LawInnovation & Law
Innovation & Law
 
Innovation & Law
Innovation & LawInnovation & Law
Innovation & Law
 
Japanese Students @ UW
Japanese Students @ UWJapanese Students @ UW
Japanese Students @ UW
 
Freecultureforum barcelona2009 acta
Freecultureforum barcelona2009 actaFreecultureforum barcelona2009 acta
Freecultureforum barcelona2009 acta
 
AI and Robotics policy overview - Adam Thierer (Aug 2022)
AI and Robotics policy overview - Adam Thierer (Aug 2022)AI and Robotics policy overview - Adam Thierer (Aug 2022)
AI and Robotics policy overview - Adam Thierer (Aug 2022)
 
The Future of Innovation of Policy - Adam Thierer - Mercatus Center
The Future of Innovation of Policy - Adam Thierer - Mercatus CenterThe Future of Innovation of Policy - Adam Thierer - Mercatus Center
The Future of Innovation of Policy - Adam Thierer - Mercatus Center
 
Ethics Presentation
Ethics PresentationEthics Presentation
Ethics Presentation
 
Tech Giants, the Moligopoly Hypothesis and Conglomerate Competition
Tech Giants, the Moligopoly Hypothesis and Conglomerate CompetitionTech Giants, the Moligopoly Hypothesis and Conglomerate Competition
Tech Giants, the Moligopoly Hypothesis and Conglomerate Competition
 
Economics of Information/Technology
Economics of Information/TechnologyEconomics of Information/Technology
Economics of Information/Technology
 
Generative AI and law.pptx
Generative AI and law.pptxGenerative AI and law.pptx
Generative AI and law.pptx
 
LECTURE 4 - Cyberculture
LECTURE 4 - CybercultureLECTURE 4 - Cyberculture
LECTURE 4 - Cyberculture
 
IMPALA's Digital Action Plan
IMPALA's Digital Action PlanIMPALA's Digital Action Plan
IMPALA's Digital Action Plan
 
Linkedinjune2011
Linkedinjune2011Linkedinjune2011
Linkedinjune2011
 
10 Ideas For A Better, Simpler World
10 Ideas For A Better, Simpler World10 Ideas For A Better, Simpler World
10 Ideas For A Better, Simpler World
 

Market Failure - IP

  • 1. Renata Avila Pinto Münich 11 May 2009 “ Market Failure and Regulation in Intellectual Property Markets ”
  • 2. My presentation will discuss: I. Intellectual Property Market II. Intellectual Property Regulation III. The effects and response
  • 4. Exclusive Rights strategies are (not) dominant. Exclusive rights are (not) the roots of all growth and productivity . Education System, Voluteers and social motivations, interoperability and improved efficencies Emerging “sharing economies” Generativity “ Digital Natives”
  • 5. The Global Market Developed Countries Developing Countries GDP per Capita Multilingualism Price Parity
  • 6. The Market and The Marginal
  • 7. “ Intellectual Property Regulation ”
  • 8. Internationalization - Harmonization 70´s WIPO and Development Early 80 mid 90: SHIFT WTO TRIPS WIPO Treaties BILATERALS FREE TRADE AGREEMENTS ACTA!!! EXTENSION OF PROTECTION AND ENFORCEMENT
  • 9. Legal Hybrids, Exotic Rights Draw by Prof. Jerome Reichmann.
  • 10.
  • 11. The most reasonable solution would be to change laws instead of trying to change people's ways.
  • 12. Renata Avila Pinto Münich 11 May 2008 “ Market Failure”
  • 13. Not yet available Not available anymore ( Authors Gild v. Google (orphan works?) Only avaliable at distant markets Too high the price (Drugs, Derivative Works in certain languages, books in the south) Too little demand Difficult to aggregate demand ( Science Research)
  • 14. Knowledge is a public good. In many contexts, the threat of copyright liability chills creativity. Different kinds of investments/innovations/discoveries may deserve different degrees of protection
  • 15. Market failure: a loss of allocative efficency. “ The reason why piracy’s come along is that there weren’t enough products at the right price soon enough”
  • 16. Price based on the local economic realities, demand recognized and served. Creating new markets.
  • 17. Intellectual property rules diminish the supply of new ideas. Innovation depends on the continuing supply on upstream row material. For All. What most of developing countries lack is not human creativity or skills to innovate.
  • 18.
  • 19. Thank You! Design By Octopus under an attribution Creative Commons License