The document discusses Buddhist and Catholic beliefs about the afterlife. In Buddhism, beings may be reborn or reach nirvana, and their destiny is decided by karma. In Catholicism, souls face immediate judgment after death and are sent to either heaven or hell. Both religions influence art and festivals in Bhutan and Italy. However, religion has a closer tie to politics in Bhutan, while Italy maintains a separation between church and state.
14. Tsang Tsz Chun
Judgment
Souls shall be taken to
judgment before
Christ immediately at
the moment of death.
A definitive and
irrevocable sentence
shall be given.
37. Tsang Tsz Chun
Disputes on Moral Standard
With the influence
Of Catholicism, the
Stands of the Holy
See have much
Influence.
It influence
Development of
Technology and
Moral issues
38. Tam Ka Pui
Comparison - perception
Similarities
Death is not the end.
There are more desirable ways and less
desirable ways to go.
People are encouraged to have moral actions
during present life.
39. Tam Ka Pui
Comparison - perception
Differences
In Bhutan,
beings may enter a realm and be reborn or
enter nirvana.
beings decide where to go.
salvation partly depends on others.
In Italy,
beings either go to heaven or hell after death.
beings are judged by Jesus Christ and it is a
irrevocable judgment.
salvation depends on oneself.
40. Comparison - impacts
Comparison – impacts
Similarities
Joining religious festivals is essential as to
Similarities
add merit for people’s afterlife.
Joining religious festivals is essential as to
People respect religious leaders as they
add merit for people’s afterlife.
are the representative of the god and
People respect religious leaders as they
truth on the world.
are the representative of the god and
Much of the arts are related to religion.
truth on the world.
Much of the arts are related to religion.
41. Comparison – impacts
Comparison – impacts
Differences
In Bhutan
Religious masters are the reincarnations of the past lamas
Religion is much related to politics.
Government strictly forbid other religion coming in.
In Italy
Pope is only the representative and leader of Catholicism on
world.
The Holy See and Italy cooperate but did not share a close
relations.
The Holy See did not require the status of “State religion”
since 1978.
Editor's Notes
In Asia, many people’s perceptions of afterlife are affected by Buddhism. In Kingdom of Bhutan, Tibetan Buddhism is the national religion so perception of afterlife of Bhutanese is influenced by Buddhism.
Buddhist afterlife belief is reincarnation belief. Reincarnation means that a being’s life continues after death and he exists over many lifetimes. When a being dies, it will then reborn as other entity. It may go to anyone of the six realms of existence. The six realms can be divided into heaven, semi-god, human being, animals, hungry ghosts and hell. No matter which realm a being enter as rebirth, it has to experience sufferings including birth and death.
Rebirth in one of the six realms of existence is not the only situation in afterlife. Another possibility, also the best one, is that the dead being achieves a state named nirvana. Achieving nirvana means a permanent release from the cycle of life and death. In fact, there are different thoughts about the meaning of nirvana. Whatever which thought is adopted, nirvana is considered to be the most desirable state where people would like to achieve. In this state, there is no suffering anymore.
The realm to enter is simply a result of the being’s actions, which is called Karma, in its past life. Any kind of intentional action, including both moral and immoral volitions in mental, verbal, or physical form, is regarded as Karma. If good and moral karma dominated in the being’s past life, it will enter one of the upper realms which are god, semi-god and human being. Otherwise, it will enter one of the lower realms.
It can be believed that Buddhist perception of afterlife is still greatly influencing Bhutan society.
This is shown in the religious festivals in Bhutan. One of the well-known religious festivals in Bhutan is Tshechus. It is in memory of Guru Rinpoche and remembering one of his great deeds. At the end of the festival, Bhutanese worship a large applique thangka which represents Guru Rinpoche and his Eight Manifestations. Bhutanese believe that they can be released from the cycle of life and death by viewing the thangka. Also, Bhutanese think that participating in religious festivals can help them gaining merits so they will have a better life in reincarnation.
Besides the Buddha, Bhutanese also worship religious masters known as tulkus. These religious masters are considered to be reincarnations of high lamas. Tulkus have very high statuses in Bhutan. For example, the head of state clergy who controls all religious affairs in Bhutan is usually tulku.