Analyst whitepaper idc-best-practices_in_business_continuity___disaster_recovery
•
0 likes•45 views
best-practices_in_business_continuity
![!
!
! " # $ % & ' (' % ) &
!
* + , - & ' . / 0 - 1 0 + , & 1 2 & * 3 , 1 2 + , , & 4 5 2 - 1 2 3 1 - 6& / 2 7 & 8 1 , / , - + . &
) + 0 5 9 + . 6 &
"#$%&$'()!*+,!-./('*()!0(12%$3$4+!
!
567'6!879$.&! !
:(*'76'+!;<==!
% : % 4 ; $ # < % & = ; > > () ? &
97&.%(&&! 1$%>.%7.>+! 6%)! ).&6&>('! '(1$/('+! 16%! ?(6%! (.>2('! 3.@(! $'! )(6>2! @$'! 6!
1$?#6%+A! B%! >2(! (/(%>! $@! 6! ).&6&>('C! .%6)(D76>(! #36%%.%4! 6%)E$'! >(12%$3$4+!
)(#3$+?(%>!16%!1$?#'$?.&(!6!'(>7'%!>$!$#('6>.$%&!6%)!*'.%4!@.%6%1.63!)$F%@633A!G.>2!
>2.&!.%!?.%)C!F(!%$>(!>26>!$#('6>.$%63!1$%>.%7.>+!6%)!'(1$/('+!$*H(1>./(&!1$%>.%7(!>$!
.%1'(6&(!.%!#'.$'.>+!@$'!1$??('1.63!6%)!4$/('%?(%>!(%>.>.(&!63.I(A!-(1$/('+!$*H(1>./(&!
$%1(!?(6&7'()!.%!)6+&!$'!2$7'&!6'(!%$F!?(6&7'()!.%!&(1$%)&!$'!?.%7>(&A!02.&!.&!
?$>./6>()!*+!.%1'(6&()!*7&.%(&&!'(3.6%1(!$%!>(12%$3$4+!6%)!6!).?.%.&2.%4!>$3('6%1(!
@$'!)$F%>.?(!6%)!.>&!@.%6%1.63!.?#61>A!02.&!)$F%>.?(!16%!63&$!*'.%4!7%F6%>()!/.&.*.3.>+!
*+!17&>$?('&C!#6'>%('&C!&>6I(2$3)('&C!1$?#(>.>$'&C!6%)!>2(!.%)7&>'+!6>!36'4(!J!6%)!
>2'(6>(%!>2(!1'().*.3.>+!$@!6!@.'?A!!
B8K!'(&(6'12!2.423.42>&!6!%7?*('!$@!#'61>.163!12633(%4(&!@'(D7(%>3+!6>!$))&!F.>2!6!
@.'?L&! 1$%>.%7.>+! 6%)! '(1$/('+! $*H(1>./(&A! M$&>! 1$??$%3+C! .&&7(&! &712! 6&! )6>6!
/$37?(!6%)!6%%763!4'$F>2C!%(>F$'I!*6%)F.)>2!6%)!36>(%1+C!6%)!.%@'6&>'71>7'(!1$&>&!
.%2.*.>!6! @.'?L&!?$/(! >$! 6!*(&>! #'61>.1(!&1(%6'.$! @$'! ?((>.%4! *7&.%(&&! &('/.1(N3(/(3!
64'((?(%>&! O"5P&Q! $%! 6/6.36*.3.>+! 6%)! '(1$/('+A! R>2('! >(12%$3$4+! >'(%)&! &712! 6&!
&('/('!/.'>763.S6>.$%!6%)!.%@'6&>'71>7'(!1$%&$3.)6>.$%!@7'>2('!(T61('*6>(!1$%>.%7.>+!6%)!
'(1$/('+! $*H(1>./(&! 6&! ?$'(! )6>6! .&! .%1'(6&.%43+! '(&.)(%>! .%! @(F('! #2+&.163! 6&&(>&!!
$'!3$16>.$%&A!
B%! ;<=<! 63$%(C! >2('(! F('(! $/('! U<! ).&6&>('! )(136'6>.$%&! .%! >2(! V%.>()! ">6>(&C!
611$').%4!>$!>2(!:()('63!W?('4(%1+!M6%64(?(%>!P4(%1+!O:WMPQA!P%!(/(%!36'4('!
%7?*('! $@! &(17'.>+C! >(12%$3$4+C! %(>F$'IC! 6%)! >(3(1$??7%.16>.$%&! $7>64(&! 6%)!
).&'7#>.$%&! 63&$! $117'! 6%%7633+A! P33! *7&.%(&&(&! (T#('.(%1(! >2(&(! 1$%).>.$%&A! B%!
#'(#6'6>.$%! @$'! 6! ?6H$'! $7>64(C! ).&6&>('C! $'! ).&'7#>.$%! >$! 6! 1$'#$'6>(! B0! %(>F$'IC!
*7&.%(&&(&!@.%)!>26>!$%(!$@!>2(!?$&>!#'$@$7%)!27')3(&!>$!)6>6!#'$>(1>.$%!6%)!'(1$/('+!
.&!?$/.%4!>('6*+>(&!$@!)6>6!61'$&&!6!1$%4(&>()!6%)!&26'()!1$'#$'6>(!GPXA!GPX!
$#>.?.S6>.$%! &$37>.$%&! .%>'$)71(! *$>2! %(>F$'I! /.&.*.3.>+! 6%)! 611(3('6>()! )6>6!
'(#3.16>.$%!>26>!@.>!.%>$!(T.&>.%4!&>$'64(!6%)!*61I7#!#'$1(&&(&A!02(&(!&$37>.$%&!16%!
&7##$'>!'(#3.16>.$%!$@!)6>6!6>!2.42!&#(()&!6%)!>'6%&@('!274(!)6>6!3$6)&!$/('!>2(!GPX!
>$!611(3('6>(!'(1$/('+!#$.%>!$*H(1>./(&!O-YR&Q!6%)!'(1$/('+!>.?(!$*H(1>./(&!O-0R&Q!
6%)!?((>!(/(%!>2(!?$&>!&>'.%4(%>!)(?6%)&!$@!>2(!*7&.%(&&A!
02.&!#6#('!2.423.42>&!>2(!12633(%4(&!>$!6%)!*(&>!#'61>.1(&!@$'!1$%>.%7.>+!6%)!'(1$/('+A!
B>! >2(%! 2.423.42>&! >2(! &>'6>(4.(&! >26>! -./('*()! 0(12%$3$4+C! 6! GPX! $#>.?.S6>.$%!
&$37>.$%! #'$/.)('C! (%6*3(&! @.'?&! >$! (?#3$+! >$! ?((>! >2(.'! '(1$/('+! '(D7.'(?(%>&A!
-./('*()L&!*'(6)>2!$@!&$37>.$%&!16%!$#>.?.S(!1$%>.%7.>+!6%)!'(1$/('+!61'$&&!6!'6%4(!
Z3$*63![(6)D76'>('&,!!"#((%!">'((>!!:'6?.%426?C!MP!<=]<=!V"P!!!!YA<UAU];AU;<<!!!!:A<UA^_A`<=!!!!FFFA.)1A1$?!](https://image.slidesharecdn.com/analystwhitepaper-idc-bestpracticesinbusinesscontinuitydisasterrecovery-220209113722/85/analyst-whitepaper-idcbestpracticesinbusinesscontinuitydisasterrecovery-1-320.jpg)
![;! a;;b]`! c;<==!B8K!
$@! *61I7#C! '(#3.16>.$%C! 6%)! 13$7)! &>$'64(! ?(126%.&?&! F.>2$7>! ).&'7#>.%4! 6! @.'?L&!
17''(%>!.%@'6&>'71>7'(!J!(%&7'.%4!>2(!#'$>(1>.$%!$@!(T.&>.%4!.%/(&>?(%>&A!P&!6!'(&73>C!
-./('*()! $@@('&! 6! @.'?! *$>2! 12$.1(! 6%)! 1$%>'$3! 6&! .>! (/6376>(&! 6%)! >6I(&! ).@@('(%>!
6##'$612(&! >$! ?((>.%4! *7&.%(&&! "5P&! @$'! 4./(%! 6##3.16>.$%&C! )6>61(%>('&C! $'!
).&>'.*7>()!(%/.'$%?(%>&A!!
= # $ ; ($ # @ A & @ < % ) < # % ! &
97&.%(&&!1$%>.%7.>+!6%)!).&6&>('!'(1$/('+!6'(!F$')&!$@>(%!7&()!.%>('126%4(6*3+C!*7>!
>2(+!6'(!).@@('(%>!.%!>('?&!$@!*$>2!#$3.1+!6%)!>(12%$3$4+A!!
!
! " # $ % & # # ' ( ) % * $ % " $ * + '
P>! .>&! ?$&>! &.?#3.&>.1! 3(/(3C! *7&.%(&&! 1$%>.%7.>+! .&! >2(! 6*.3.>+! >$! ?6.%>6.%!
$#('6>.$%&E&('/.1(&!.%!>2(!@61(!$@!6!).&'7#>./(!(/(%>A!97&.%(&&!1$%>.%7.>+!'(D7.'(&!>2(!
6/6.36*.3.>+!$@!1$?#7>.%4C!6##3.16>.$%!&('/.1(&C!#2+&.163!%(>F$'I!611(&&!6%)!%(>F$'I!
&('/.1(&C!6&!F(33!6&!7&('E13.(%>!611(&&!>$!>2.&!.%@'6&>'71>7'(A!M6.%>6.%.%4!1$%>.%7.>+!.%!
$#('6>.$%&! 6%)! &('/.1(&C! .%137).%4! &+&>(?&! &712! 6&! G(*! &('/('&C! (?6.3C! 1'.>.163!
)6>6*6&(&C! 6%)! &$! @$'>2C! '(D7.'(&! &#(1.@.1! >(12%$3$4+A! 02.&! >(12%$3$4+! 6%)!
.%@'6&>'71>7'(!16%!.%137)(!/.'>763.S6>.$%C!137&>('.%4E@6.3$/('E@6.3*61IC!&('/('!26')F6'(C!
%(>F$'I! 6%)! %(>F$'I.%4! &('/.1(&C! '(?$>(! )6>61(%>('! @61.3.>.(&C! '(#3.16>.$%! &('/.1(&C!
6%)!'()7%)6%>!&26'()!&>$'64(A!8(#(%).%4!$%!>2(!>+#(!$@!(/(%>C!1$%>.%7.>+!$@!6!4./(%!
6##3.16>.$%!.&!612.(/()!*+!@6.3.%4!$/('!.>&!&('/.1(&!6%)!7&('E13.(%>!611(&&!3$1633+!F.>2.%!
>2(!&6?(!)6>61(%>('!$'!>$!6!'(?$>(C!#2+&.1633+!).'6>(!)6>61(%>('A!G.>2!*7&.%(&&!
1$%>.%7.>+C! >2(! @6.3$/('! $@! 6! &('/.1(! .&! ?(6&7'()! .%! &(1$%)&! $'! 3(&&A! 961I7#!
>(12%$3$4.(&C!.%137).%4!>2$&(!>26>!'(3+!$%!).&I!6&!6!*61I7#!>6'4(>C!16%%$>!#'$/.)(!>2.&!
3(/(3! $@! 1$%>.%7.>+! $@! &('/.1(&A! 961I7#&C! .%! $')('! >$! *(! 7&()C! '(D7.'(! 6! '(&>$'6>.$%!
#'$1(&&!6%)!6'(!>+#.1633+!7&()!@$'!).&6&>('!'(1$/('+!#7'#$&(&A!!
!
, $ # - # * & . ' / & 0 ) 1 & . + '
8.&6&>('!'(1$/('+!.&!6!*'$6)!1$%1(#>!>26>!16%!.%137)(!'(1$/('+!$@!#($#3(C!@61.3.>.(&C!
6%)! >2(! 3.I(A! :$'! >2(! #7'#$&(&! $@! >2.&! #6#('C! ).&6&>('! '(1$/('+! .&! >2(! 1$$').%6>()!
61>./.>+!$@!'(1$/('.%4!B0!&+&>(?&!@$33$F.%4!>2(!1$?#3(>(!$'!#6'>.63!3$&&!$@!6!&.>(!)7(!>$!
6! %6>7'63! ).&6&>('! $'! 6! &(17'.>+! (/(%>A! 8(#(%).%4! $%! >2(! (T>(%>! $@! >2(! ).&6&>('C!
).&6&>('!'(1$/('+!16%!*(!612.(/()!*+!'(&>$'.%4!&+&>(?&!6>!6%!63>('%6>./(!&.>(!$'!F.>2.%!
>2(! &6?(! &.>(! 7&.%4! 63>('%6>(! (D7.#?(%>A! 8.&6&>('! '(1$/('+! '(D7.'(&! (T>(%&./(!
?6%763!?(>2$)&!>$!*'.%4!>2(!B0!(%/.'$%?(%>!7#!>$!6%!$#('6>.$%63!&>6>(A!:$'!(T6?#3(C!
&('/.1(&!%(()!>$!*(!'((&>6*3.&2()C!&('/('&!'(*7.3>C!6##3.16>.$%&!'(.%&>633()C!6%)!)6>6!
'(&>$'6>.$%! 1$?#3(>()A! B%@'6&>'71>7'(! 7&()! @$'! ).&6&>('! '(1$/('+! 16%! .%137)(!
/.'>763.S6>.$%C!&('/('!26')F6'(C!%(>F$'I!6%)!%(>F$'I.%4!&('/.1(&C!'(?$>(!)6>61(%>('!
@61.3.>.(&C! '(#3.16>.$%C! *61I7#! >$! ).&IC! *61I7#! >$! >6#(C! 6%)! >6#(! /673>.%4A! G2.3(!
*7&.%(&&!1$%>.%7.>+!.&!?(6&7'()!.%!&(1$%)&C!).&6&>('!'(1$/('+!.&!>+#.1633+!?(6&7'()!
.%!2$7'&!$'!)6+&A
Recommended
Recommended
More Related Content
What's hot
What's hot (17)
Analyst whitepaper idc-best-practices_in_business_continuity___disaster_recovery
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`<=!!!!FFFA.)1A1$?!
- 2. ;! a;;b]`! c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
- 3. c;<==!B8K! a;;b]`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d-(#3.16>.$%!6%)!e).&6&>('!'(1$/('+f!6'(!/('+!2.42!#'.$'.>+!'.42>! %$FA! G(! 26)! 6! )6>6! 1$''7#>.$%! .&&7(! .%! $7'! #'$)71>.$%! R'613(! @.%6%1.63&! )6>6*6&(! g! >2(! F2$3(! &1(%6'.$! #7>! >2(! @(6'! $@! Z$)! .%! >2(! (T(17>./(&Ad! !"#$%&#'(%)*$+,! !! )1,F&G1-1H/-152E!dG.>2.%!;`!2$7'&!F(!26/(!>$!*(!*61I!7#!6%)!'7%%.%4A!G(!26/(! '(4736>$'+!.&&7(&!F.>2!16%1(336>.$%!%$>.1(&!6%)!/6'.$7&!>2.%4&!>26>!%(()!>$!*(!)$%(! F.>2.%!6!1('>6.%!#('.$)!$@!>.?(C!6%)!.@!F(!1$73)%L>!#'$)71(!1('>6.%!)$17?(%>&!F.>2.%! >26>!#('.$)!$@!>.?(C!>2(%!>26>!(T>(%)&!$7'!(T#$&7'(Ad!!-$.%)#$'/,! !! )+H3C/-5.6& 05GIC1/20+J05,-& 5K& 75L2-1G+E! d02(! &1'((%N*6&()! >'6).%4! '(633+! 16%L>!*(!)$F%A!G(!6'(!'(D7.'()!*+!>2(!"WK!.@!F(!6'(!)$F%!@$'!_<!?.%7>(&!>$!&27>! $7'!)$$'&C!&$!>2('(!'(633+!.&!%$!611(#>6*3(!)$F%>.?(Ad!!0*$#$'*#123/)4*'/.,! !! 45,-&5K&75L2-1G+E!dB@!F(!6'(!3$$I.%4!6>!;`!2$7'&!>$!'(1$/('!6%!(%/.'$%?(%>C!F(! 6'(!&>'6%).%4!>$%&!$@!@$$)!$%!1$%/(+$'&!>26>!F(!16%L>!'(&>$1IA!G(!6'(!>2'$F.%4! 6F6+!6%+F2('(!@'$?!h_<<C<<<!>$!h<<C<<<!$@!@$$)!$%!6!4./(%!)6+!.@!F(!3$&(!$7'! W-Y!&+&>(?A!W/(%!6%!2$7'!$7>64(!16%!*(!6!).&6&>('A!G(!%(()!>$!*(!7%)('!=<! ?.%7>(&Ad!!56$.%7/)23/)4*'/.,! !! 4M/2H12H& 5DN+0-19+,J05,-& 5K& 75L2-1G+E! dG(! %(()()! >$! 7#4'6)(! >2(! $#(%! &+&>(?&! >$! 4$! @'$?! _<! ?.%7>(&! )$F%! >$! =! &(1$%)&A! :.@>((%! &(1$%)&! .%! ?+! $'46%.S6>.$%! 16%! ?(6%C! 3.>('633+C! *.33.$%&! $@! )$336'&A!G(! 13(6'! h! >'.33.$%! 6! )6+Ad! !0*$#$'*#123/)4*'/.,! !! ;2+OI+0-+7&+9+2-,E!dG(!26)!6!@6.37'(!(/(%>!>26>!>$$I!)$F%!*$>2!>2(!(?('4(%1+! #$F('! 6%)! >2(! &.>(! #$F('! @'$?! >2(! &>'((>A! 02(! 2$>(3! 26)! >$! *(! 13$&()! @$'! @./(! )6+&A!026>!F6&!)(/6&>6>.%4A!B>!26)!%(/('!26##(%()!.%!>2.&!>$F%!*(@$'(C!6%)!.>! 26##(%()!>$!7&Ad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
- 4. `! a;;b]`! c;<==!B8K! !! 81KK+.12H& =P(,E! X$>! 633! )6>6! 6%)! &+&>(?&! 6'(! (D763A! 0.('! =! 6%)! >.('! ! 6##3.16>.$%&! 26/(! ).@@('(%>! "5P&! 6%)! '(D7.'(! ).@@('(%>! >(12%$3$4+! >$! ?((>! >2(! $*H(1>./(&A! !! 8/-/&H.5L-ME!R%!6/('64(C!&>$'64(!/$37?(!4'$F&!;i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j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`A! W%&7'(!.%@'6&>'71>7'(!'()7%)6%1+!O%(>F$'I.%4C!#$F('C!1$$3.%4C!>(3(1$?QA! A! -7%! #('.$).1! >(&>.%4! $@! #36%&C! .)(633+! D76'>('3+C! F.>2! #7*3.&2()! '(&73>&! 6%)! /73%('6*.3.>+!#6>12.%4!6%63+&.&A! bA! K$%)71>! 6%! 6%%763! '(/.(F! $@! *7&.%(&&! 1$%>.%7.>+E).&6&>('! '(1$/('+! 4$63&E#36%&! F.>2! >2(! 5R9C! .%137).%4! (/6376>.$%! $@! >(12%$3$4+! >$! 612.(/(! "5P&! @$'! ).@@('(%>! 6##3.16>.$%!>.('&A! ]A! 8(#3$+! >$$3&!>$! .)(%>.@+! /73%('6*.3.>.(&! 6%)! /.'>763!&('/('! $'#26%&! O.A(AC!&+&>(?&! F.>2!%$!"5P!$'!#'$>(1>.$%!&12(?6QA!
- 5. c;<==!B8K! a;;b]`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k$"QC! #'$/.)(!1$%>'$3! $/('! #'.$'.>.S6>.$%! $@! ).&6&>('! '(1$/('+! /('&7&! $>2('! *7&.%(&&! %(>F$'I! >'6@@.1A! 02(+! 63&$! $@@('! &.4%.@.16%>! #('@$'?6%1(! .?#'$/(?(%>&! 6*$/(! 6%)! *(+$%)! &>$'64(N3(/(3! )()7#3.16>.$%!6%)!1$?#'(&&.$%A!! -./('*()L&!GPX!$#>.?.S6>.$%!&$37>.$%&!6.)!.%!'(1$/('+!6%)!*7&.%(&&!1$%>.%7.>+!*+,! !! )+73012H!>2(!6?$7%>!$@!)6>6!>'6%&#$'>()!$/('!>2(!%(>F$'I!@$'!(.>2('!*61I7#!$'! '(#3.16>.$%! #'$1(&&(&A! 027&C! -./('*()! &2.@>&! >2(! %(>F$'I! @'$?! 6! *6''.('! >$! 6%! (%6*3('!.%!?$/.%4!)6>6!&(17'(3+!$@@&.>(A!! !! '.15.1-1U12H!GPX!>'6@@.1C!>27&!.%1'(6&.%4!'(#3.16>.$%!6%)!*61I7#!>2'$742#7>!6%)! '()71.%4!*6%)F.)>2! '(D7.'(?(%>&A! 02.&! (?#$F('&!6! @.'?! >$! #'$>(1>!?$'(! )6>6C! ?$'(!$@>(%!6%)!'(1$/('!@6&>('A!!
- 6. b! a;;b]`! c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
- 7. c;<==!B8K! a;;b]`! ]! )19+.D+7&,5C3-152V&-./('*()!">((32(6)!6##3.6%1(&!?6I(!7&(!$@!(T.&>.%4!GPXN*6&()! *61I7#!$'!'(#3.16>.$%!#'$1(&&(&!6%)!%(>F$'I!.%@'6&>'71>7'(C!*7>!>2(+!(?#$F('!@.'?&!>$! #'$>(1>!?$'(!)6>6C!?$'(!$@>(%!O@$'!6!*(>>('!-YRQ!6%)!'(1$/('!@6&>('!O@$'!6!*(>>('!-0RQ! 61'$&&! >2(! GPXA! -./('*()L&! 86>6! ">'(6?3.%.%4! $%! *6%)F.)>2N1$%&>'6.%()! 1$%%(1>.$%&!16%!'(?$/(!7#!>$!b<l^i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
- 8. U! a;;b]`! c;<==!B8K! 1$?#'(&&()! @$'! 6)).>.$%63!&6/.%4&A! Z./(%! ).@@('(%>! 1$%%(1>.$%! >+#(&C! >2(.'! 6)6#>./(! @(6>7'(&! 16%! &(3@N>7%(! (612! 1$%%(1>.$%C! )+%6?.1633+! *636%1.%4! >2'$742#7>! /('&7&! *6%)F.)>2! '(D7.'(?(%>&A! P! 1$??$%! 12633(%4(! .%! '(?$>(! 3$16>.$%&! .&! >2(! 361I! $@! >(12%.163!#('&$%%(3A!:$'!@.'?&!F.>2!3.?.>()!B0!#('&$%%(3!.%!'(?$>(!$@@.1(E*'6%12!$@@.1(! O-R9RQ!3$16>.$%&!6%)!6!)(&.'(!>$!3.?.>!#2+&.163!26')F6'(!.%!).&>'.*7>()!(%/.'$%?(%>&C! 6!j.'>763!">((32(6)!&$37>.$%!16%!*(!)(#3$+()A!j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j.'>763!Y'./6>(!K3$7)!OjYKQ!(%/.'$%?(%>&A!!
- 9. c;<==!B8K! a;;b]`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j.1(!Y'(&.)(%>!$'!K$7%>'+!M6%64('A!P!)'6@>!$@!>2(! #'$#$&()!)$17?(%>!&2$73)!611$?#6%+!6%+!&712!'(D7(&>A!B8K!'(&('/(&!>2(!'.42>!>$! )(%+!6##'$/63!$@!(T>('%63!7&64(!@$'!6%+!'(6&$%A! K$#+'.42>!;<==!B8KA!-(#'$)71>.$%!F.>2$7>!F'.>>(%!#('?.&&.$%!.&!1$?#3(>(3+!@$'*.))(%A! !