SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 2
Download to read offline
CA No.435/2018
IN
CP No.183/Chd/Hry/2018
NATIONAL COMPANY LAW TRIBUNAL,
CHANDIGARH BENCH, CHANDIGARH.
CA No.435/2018
IN
CP No.183/Chd/Hry/2018
In the matter of:
Sunil Goel & Ors. ….Petitioners.
Versus
Guild Builders Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. ….Respondents.
Present: Mr.U.K.Chaudhary, Senior Advocate with Mr.Himanshu
Vij, Advocate, Mr.Anand Chhibbar, Senior Advocate with
Mr.Gaurav Mankotia, Mr.Vaibhav Sahni, Advocate and
Ms.Munisha Gandhi, Senior Advocate with Mr.Adarsh
Dubey, Advocate for the petitioners.
Mr.Arun Kathpalia, Senior Advocate with Mr.Ankit Singal,
Advocate for respondents No.2 and 14.
Mr.Prateek Gupta, Advocate for respondent No.10.
Mr.Randeep Singh Rai, Senior Advocate with Ms.Rubina
Varmani, Mr.Manohar Kumar Garg and Mr.Abhinav Sood,
Advocates for respondent No.1.
Mr.Rakesh Kumar, Advocate for respondent No.12 and 13.
Mr.Deepankur Sharma, Advocate for Regional Director.
CA No.435/2018:
Learned senior counsel for the petitioners filed the affidavit
of service vide diary No.4468, dated 16.11.2018. Copies of the emails,
postal receipts and tracking reports have also been annexed therewith.
Learned senior counsel for the respondents seeks time to file the reply.
Learned senior counsel for the petitioners have
vehemently pressed the prayer for interim directions to the respondent No.1
company for not creating any encumbrance/pledge of the remaining shares
of the Guild Builders Private Limited in the Omaxe (India) Limited.
The other prayer, which is also pressed at this stage is for
directing the respondent No.1 Company for permitting the petitioners to
CA No.435/2018
IN
CP No.183/Chd/Hry/2018
have access to the record of respondent No.1 Company in terms of Section
171 of the Companies Act, 2013 at this stage.
Having heard the learned Senior Counsel for both the
parties, we deem it appropriate that the reply of the respondents should be
filed for disposal of the prayer regarding pledging/encumbering of the
shares.
Learned senior counsel for the respondent No.1 submitted
that the respondents have never denied the inspection of the record, to
which the shareholders are entitled to.
List the matter on 21.12.2018. Reply to the application and
the written statement to the main petition be filed at least a week before the
date fixed with copy advance to the counsel opposite.
In the meanwhile, respondent No.1 Company is directed
to allow inspection of the record/registers during business hours and take
extract copies as asked for as per Section 171 of the Companies Act, 2013,
on receiving the written communication dasti or by post/email.
Copy of this order be supplied to the learned counsel for
both the parties under the signatures of the Bench Officer.
Sd/-
(Justice R.P.Nagrath)
Member (Judicial)
Sd/-
(Pradeep R.Sethi)
Member (Technical)
November 16, 2018.
Ashwani

More Related Content

Similar to Court Order

Allahabad hc order ashish kumar bail
Allahabad hc order   ashish kumar bailAllahabad hc order   ashish kumar bail
Allahabad hc order ashish kumar bailsabrangsabrang
 
Petition seeking stay on the arrest of Jumman and Parvaz
Petition seeking stay on the arrest of Jumman and ParvazPetition seeking stay on the arrest of Jumman and Parvaz
Petition seeking stay on the arrest of Jumman and Parvazsabrangsabrang
 
Written Arguments against Writ 90 of 2016
Written Arguments against Writ 90 of 2016Written Arguments against Writ 90 of 2016
Written Arguments against Writ 90 of 2016Om Prakash Poddar
 
Gauhati hc 482 inherent juris for foreigner order
Gauhati hc 482 inherent juris for foreigner orderGauhati hc 482 inherent juris for foreigner order
Gauhati hc 482 inherent juris for foreigner ordersabrangsabrang
 
Gauhati hc order july 20
Gauhati hc order july 20Gauhati hc order july 20
Gauhati hc order july 20ZahidManiyar
 
Rcs no 332 98 (possession)
Rcs no 332 98  (possession)Rcs no 332 98  (possession)
Rcs no 332 98 (possession)Santosh Garad
 
Most important judgement for filing of form GST TRAN-1
Most important judgement for filing of form GST TRAN-1Most important judgement for filing of form GST TRAN-1
Most important judgement for filing of form GST TRAN-1CA PRADEEP GOYAL
 
Final status of PRSEC/E/2018/18152 dated 09.10.2018
Final status of  PRSEC/E/2018/18152 dated 09.10.2018Final status of  PRSEC/E/2018/18152 dated 09.10.2018
Final status of PRSEC/E/2018/18152 dated 09.10.2018Om Prakash Poddar
 
Source of income of complainant has to be proved in 138 ni act cases
Source of income of complainant has to be proved in 138 ni act casesSource of income of complainant has to be proved in 138 ni act cases
Source of income of complainant has to be proved in 138 ni act casesanjsur28
 
Cr.WJC No.1238 of 2019(Token no. 45078 of 2019) before Patna High Court dated...
Cr.WJC No.1238 of 2019(Token no. 45078 of 2019) before Patna High Court dated...Cr.WJC No.1238 of 2019(Token no. 45078 of 2019) before Patna High Court dated...
Cr.WJC No.1238 of 2019(Token no. 45078 of 2019) before Patna High Court dated...Om Prakash Poddar
 
Moot Memorial
Moot MemorialMoot Memorial
Moot MemorialAnkit Sha
 
Gauhati hc sep 9 order
Gauhati hc sep 9 orderGauhati hc sep 9 order
Gauhati hc sep 9 ordersabrangind
 
BAIL APPLICATION
BAIL APPLICATIONBAIL APPLICATION
BAIL APPLICATIONS.Ezhil Raj
 

Similar to Court Order (20)

Allahabad hc order ashish kumar bail
Allahabad hc order   ashish kumar bailAllahabad hc order   ashish kumar bail
Allahabad hc order ashish kumar bail
 
Petition seeking stay on the arrest of Jumman and Parvaz
Petition seeking stay on the arrest of Jumman and ParvazPetition seeking stay on the arrest of Jumman and Parvaz
Petition seeking stay on the arrest of Jumman and Parvaz
 
Written Arguments against Writ 90 of 2016
Written Arguments against Writ 90 of 2016Written Arguments against Writ 90 of 2016
Written Arguments against Writ 90 of 2016
 
Gauhati hc 482 inherent juris for foreigner order
Gauhati hc 482 inherent juris for foreigner orderGauhati hc 482 inherent juris for foreigner order
Gauhati hc 482 inherent juris for foreigner order
 
Written Statement
Written StatementWritten Statement
Written Statement
 
Gauhati hc order july 20
Gauhati hc order july 20Gauhati hc order july 20
Gauhati hc order july 20
 
Jharkhand hc order
Jharkhand hc orderJharkhand hc order
Jharkhand hc order
 
E.mohanammal
E.mohanammalE.mohanammal
E.mohanammal
 
Rcs no 332 98 (possession)
Rcs no 332 98  (possession)Rcs no 332 98  (possession)
Rcs no 332 98 (possession)
 
Internship diary by ronak
Internship diary by ronakInternship diary by ronak
Internship diary by ronak
 
Chandni v state of up
Chandni v state of upChandni v state of up
Chandni v state of up
 
Land Dispute
Land DisputeLand Dispute
Land Dispute
 
Most important judgement for filing of form GST TRAN-1
Most important judgement for filing of form GST TRAN-1Most important judgement for filing of form GST TRAN-1
Most important judgement for filing of form GST TRAN-1
 
Final status of PRSEC/E/2018/18152 dated 09.10.2018
Final status of  PRSEC/E/2018/18152 dated 09.10.2018Final status of  PRSEC/E/2018/18152 dated 09.10.2018
Final status of PRSEC/E/2018/18152 dated 09.10.2018
 
Internship diary by ronak
Internship diary by ronakInternship diary by ronak
Internship diary by ronak
 
Source of income of complainant has to be proved in 138 ni act cases
Source of income of complainant has to be proved in 138 ni act casesSource of income of complainant has to be proved in 138 ni act cases
Source of income of complainant has to be proved in 138 ni act cases
 
Cr.WJC No.1238 of 2019(Token no. 45078 of 2019) before Patna High Court dated...
Cr.WJC No.1238 of 2019(Token no. 45078 of 2019) before Patna High Court dated...Cr.WJC No.1238 of 2019(Token no. 45078 of 2019) before Patna High Court dated...
Cr.WJC No.1238 of 2019(Token no. 45078 of 2019) before Patna High Court dated...
 
Moot Memorial
Moot MemorialMoot Memorial
Moot Memorial
 
Gauhati hc sep 9 order
Gauhati hc sep 9 orderGauhati hc sep 9 order
Gauhati hc sep 9 order
 
BAIL APPLICATION
BAIL APPLICATIONBAIL APPLICATION
BAIL APPLICATION
 

Recently uploaded

Land as a Resource for urban finanace- 24-1-23.ppt
Land as a Resource  for urban finanace- 24-1-23.pptLand as a Resource  for urban finanace- 24-1-23.ppt
Land as a Resource for urban finanace- 24-1-23.pptJIT KUMAR GUPTA
 
Kohinoor Viva Pixel Dhanori Pune Brochure.pdf
Kohinoor Viva Pixel Dhanori Pune Brochure.pdfKohinoor Viva Pixel Dhanori Pune Brochure.pdf
Kohinoor Viva Pixel Dhanori Pune Brochure.pdfabbu831446
 
Are You Thinking About Selling Your House Soon? | KM Realty Group LLC
Are You Thinking About Selling Your House Soon?  | KM Realty Group LLCAre You Thinking About Selling Your House Soon?  | KM Realty Group LLC
Are You Thinking About Selling Your House Soon? | KM Realty Group LLCTammy Jackson
 
Purvanchal Skyline Vista Noida Expressway Sector 94
Purvanchal Skyline Vista Noida Expressway Sector 94Purvanchal Skyline Vista Noida Expressway Sector 94
Purvanchal Skyline Vista Noida Expressway Sector 94vivekpalprc
 
Mahindra Kanakpura Road Bangalore.pdf.pdf
Mahindra Kanakpura Road Bangalore.pdf.pdfMahindra Kanakpura Road Bangalore.pdf.pdf
Mahindra Kanakpura Road Bangalore.pdf.pdfkratirudram
 
Understanding the Dholera Price Trend An In-depth Analysis.pdf
Understanding the Dholera Price Trend An In-depth Analysis.pdfUnderstanding the Dholera Price Trend An In-depth Analysis.pdf
Understanding the Dholera Price Trend An In-depth Analysis.pdfShivgan Infratech
 
The Superior Living Batisehir - Listing Turkey
The Superior Living Batisehir - Listing TurkeyThe Superior Living Batisehir - Listing Turkey
The Superior Living Batisehir - Listing TurkeyListing Turkey
 
A Guide to NRI Investment in India for Real Estate
A Guide to NRI Investment in India for Real EstateA Guide to NRI Investment in India for Real Estate
A Guide to NRI Investment in India for Real EstateSunil Agrawal and Associates
 
Ashiana Vatsalya Senior Living Mahindra World City, Chennai
Ashiana Vatsalya Senior Living Mahindra World City, ChennaiAshiana Vatsalya Senior Living Mahindra World City, Chennai
Ashiana Vatsalya Senior Living Mahindra World City, Chennaisvrishavraj
 
VTP Dhanori Pune Residential Apartment Brochure.pdf
VTP Dhanori Pune Residential Apartment Brochure.pdfVTP Dhanori Pune Residential Apartment Brochure.pdf
VTP Dhanori Pune Residential Apartment Brochure.pdfsabhyara24
 
Purva Kensho Hills Sarjapur Bangalore.pdf.pdf
Purva Kensho Hills Sarjapur Bangalore.pdf.pdfPurva Kensho Hills Sarjapur Bangalore.pdf.pdf
Purva Kensho Hills Sarjapur Bangalore.pdf.pdfkratirudram
 
Top^Clinic ^%[+27785538335__Safe*Abortion Pills For Sale In Ebony park tembisa
Top^Clinic ^%[+27785538335__Safe*Abortion Pills For Sale In Ebony park tembisaTop^Clinic ^%[+27785538335__Safe*Abortion Pills For Sale In Ebony park tembisa
Top^Clinic ^%[+27785538335__Safe*Abortion Pills For Sale In Ebony park tembisadoctorjoe1984
 
Are You Thinking About Buying a Home | KM Realty Group LLC
Are You Thinking About Buying a Home | KM Realty Group LLCAre You Thinking About Buying a Home | KM Realty Group LLC
Are You Thinking About Buying a Home | KM Realty Group LLCTammy Jackson
 
Edenic Parth Kiona Hinjewadi, Pune - PDF.pdf
Edenic Parth Kiona Hinjewadi, Pune - PDF.pdfEdenic Parth Kiona Hinjewadi, Pune - PDF.pdf
Edenic Parth Kiona Hinjewadi, Pune - PDF.pdfmonikasharma630
 
What are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Buying a Resale Home
What are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Buying a Resale HomeWhat are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Buying a Resale Home
What are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Buying a Resale HomeSunil Agrawal and Associates
 
SVN Live 5.20.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN Live 5.20.24 Weekly Property BroadcastSVN Live 5.20.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN Live 5.20.24 Weekly Property BroadcastSVN International Corp.
 
Improvise, Adapt, Overcome - Sales Meeting, May '24
Improvise, Adapt, Overcome - Sales Meeting, May '24Improvise, Adapt, Overcome - Sales Meeting, May '24
Improvise, Adapt, Overcome - Sales Meeting, May '24Tom Blefko
 
Merlin-Ventana-Apartments-Baner-Pune-Brochure
Merlin-Ventana-Apartments-Baner-Pune-BrochureMerlin-Ventana-Apartments-Baner-Pune-Brochure
Merlin-Ventana-Apartments-Baner-Pune-Brochurekishor21012022
 
SVN Live 5.13.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN Live 5.13.24 Weekly Property BroadcastSVN Live 5.13.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN Live 5.13.24 Weekly Property BroadcastSVN International Corp.
 
Edenic Parth Kiona Hinjewadi | A Return To Better Living
Edenic Parth Kiona Hinjewadi | A Return To Better LivingEdenic Parth Kiona Hinjewadi | A Return To Better Living
Edenic Parth Kiona Hinjewadi | A Return To Better Livingaidasheikh47
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Land as a Resource for urban finanace- 24-1-23.ppt
Land as a Resource  for urban finanace- 24-1-23.pptLand as a Resource  for urban finanace- 24-1-23.ppt
Land as a Resource for urban finanace- 24-1-23.ppt
 
Kohinoor Viva Pixel Dhanori Pune Brochure.pdf
Kohinoor Viva Pixel Dhanori Pune Brochure.pdfKohinoor Viva Pixel Dhanori Pune Brochure.pdf
Kohinoor Viva Pixel Dhanori Pune Brochure.pdf
 
Are You Thinking About Selling Your House Soon? | KM Realty Group LLC
Are You Thinking About Selling Your House Soon?  | KM Realty Group LLCAre You Thinking About Selling Your House Soon?  | KM Realty Group LLC
Are You Thinking About Selling Your House Soon? | KM Realty Group LLC
 
Purvanchal Skyline Vista Noida Expressway Sector 94
Purvanchal Skyline Vista Noida Expressway Sector 94Purvanchal Skyline Vista Noida Expressway Sector 94
Purvanchal Skyline Vista Noida Expressway Sector 94
 
Mahindra Kanakpura Road Bangalore.pdf.pdf
Mahindra Kanakpura Road Bangalore.pdf.pdfMahindra Kanakpura Road Bangalore.pdf.pdf
Mahindra Kanakpura Road Bangalore.pdf.pdf
 
Understanding the Dholera Price Trend An In-depth Analysis.pdf
Understanding the Dholera Price Trend An In-depth Analysis.pdfUnderstanding the Dholera Price Trend An In-depth Analysis.pdf
Understanding the Dholera Price Trend An In-depth Analysis.pdf
 
The Superior Living Batisehir - Listing Turkey
The Superior Living Batisehir - Listing TurkeyThe Superior Living Batisehir - Listing Turkey
The Superior Living Batisehir - Listing Turkey
 
A Guide to NRI Investment in India for Real Estate
A Guide to NRI Investment in India for Real EstateA Guide to NRI Investment in India for Real Estate
A Guide to NRI Investment in India for Real Estate
 
Ashiana Vatsalya Senior Living Mahindra World City, Chennai
Ashiana Vatsalya Senior Living Mahindra World City, ChennaiAshiana Vatsalya Senior Living Mahindra World City, Chennai
Ashiana Vatsalya Senior Living Mahindra World City, Chennai
 
VTP Dhanori Pune Residential Apartment Brochure.pdf
VTP Dhanori Pune Residential Apartment Brochure.pdfVTP Dhanori Pune Residential Apartment Brochure.pdf
VTP Dhanori Pune Residential Apartment Brochure.pdf
 
Purva Kensho Hills Sarjapur Bangalore.pdf.pdf
Purva Kensho Hills Sarjapur Bangalore.pdf.pdfPurva Kensho Hills Sarjapur Bangalore.pdf.pdf
Purva Kensho Hills Sarjapur Bangalore.pdf.pdf
 
Top^Clinic ^%[+27785538335__Safe*Abortion Pills For Sale In Ebony park tembisa
Top^Clinic ^%[+27785538335__Safe*Abortion Pills For Sale In Ebony park tembisaTop^Clinic ^%[+27785538335__Safe*Abortion Pills For Sale In Ebony park tembisa
Top^Clinic ^%[+27785538335__Safe*Abortion Pills For Sale In Ebony park tembisa
 
Are You Thinking About Buying a Home | KM Realty Group LLC
Are You Thinking About Buying a Home | KM Realty Group LLCAre You Thinking About Buying a Home | KM Realty Group LLC
Are You Thinking About Buying a Home | KM Realty Group LLC
 
Edenic Parth Kiona Hinjewadi, Pune - PDF.pdf
Edenic Parth Kiona Hinjewadi, Pune - PDF.pdfEdenic Parth Kiona Hinjewadi, Pune - PDF.pdf
Edenic Parth Kiona Hinjewadi, Pune - PDF.pdf
 
What are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Buying a Resale Home
What are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Buying a Resale HomeWhat are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Buying a Resale Home
What are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Buying a Resale Home
 
SVN Live 5.20.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN Live 5.20.24 Weekly Property BroadcastSVN Live 5.20.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN Live 5.20.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
 
Improvise, Adapt, Overcome - Sales Meeting, May '24
Improvise, Adapt, Overcome - Sales Meeting, May '24Improvise, Adapt, Overcome - Sales Meeting, May '24
Improvise, Adapt, Overcome - Sales Meeting, May '24
 
Merlin-Ventana-Apartments-Baner-Pune-Brochure
Merlin-Ventana-Apartments-Baner-Pune-BrochureMerlin-Ventana-Apartments-Baner-Pune-Brochure
Merlin-Ventana-Apartments-Baner-Pune-Brochure
 
SVN Live 5.13.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN Live 5.13.24 Weekly Property BroadcastSVN Live 5.13.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN Live 5.13.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
 
Edenic Parth Kiona Hinjewadi | A Return To Better Living
Edenic Parth Kiona Hinjewadi | A Return To Better LivingEdenic Parth Kiona Hinjewadi | A Return To Better Living
Edenic Parth Kiona Hinjewadi | A Return To Better Living
 

Court Order

  • 1. CA No.435/2018 IN CP No.183/Chd/Hry/2018 NATIONAL COMPANY LAW TRIBUNAL, CHANDIGARH BENCH, CHANDIGARH. CA No.435/2018 IN CP No.183/Chd/Hry/2018 In the matter of: Sunil Goel & Ors. ….Petitioners. Versus Guild Builders Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. ….Respondents. Present: Mr.U.K.Chaudhary, Senior Advocate with Mr.Himanshu Vij, Advocate, Mr.Anand Chhibbar, Senior Advocate with Mr.Gaurav Mankotia, Mr.Vaibhav Sahni, Advocate and Ms.Munisha Gandhi, Senior Advocate with Mr.Adarsh Dubey, Advocate for the petitioners. Mr.Arun Kathpalia, Senior Advocate with Mr.Ankit Singal, Advocate for respondents No.2 and 14. Mr.Prateek Gupta, Advocate for respondent No.10. Mr.Randeep Singh Rai, Senior Advocate with Ms.Rubina Varmani, Mr.Manohar Kumar Garg and Mr.Abhinav Sood, Advocates for respondent No.1. Mr.Rakesh Kumar, Advocate for respondent No.12 and 13. Mr.Deepankur Sharma, Advocate for Regional Director. CA No.435/2018: Learned senior counsel for the petitioners filed the affidavit of service vide diary No.4468, dated 16.11.2018. Copies of the emails, postal receipts and tracking reports have also been annexed therewith. Learned senior counsel for the respondents seeks time to file the reply. Learned senior counsel for the petitioners have vehemently pressed the prayer for interim directions to the respondent No.1 company for not creating any encumbrance/pledge of the remaining shares of the Guild Builders Private Limited in the Omaxe (India) Limited. The other prayer, which is also pressed at this stage is for directing the respondent No.1 Company for permitting the petitioners to
  • 2. CA No.435/2018 IN CP No.183/Chd/Hry/2018 have access to the record of respondent No.1 Company in terms of Section 171 of the Companies Act, 2013 at this stage. Having heard the learned Senior Counsel for both the parties, we deem it appropriate that the reply of the respondents should be filed for disposal of the prayer regarding pledging/encumbering of the shares. Learned senior counsel for the respondent No.1 submitted that the respondents have never denied the inspection of the record, to which the shareholders are entitled to. List the matter on 21.12.2018. Reply to the application and the written statement to the main petition be filed at least a week before the date fixed with copy advance to the counsel opposite. In the meanwhile, respondent No.1 Company is directed to allow inspection of the record/registers during business hours and take extract copies as asked for as per Section 171 of the Companies Act, 2013, on receiving the written communication dasti or by post/email. Copy of this order be supplied to the learned counsel for both the parties under the signatures of the Bench Officer. Sd/- (Justice R.P.Nagrath) Member (Judicial) Sd/- (Pradeep R.Sethi) Member (Technical) November 16, 2018. Ashwani