- A complaint was filed alleging that an immigration judge denied the complainant a fair hearing and that their attorney was inexperienced. - The complaint was reviewed by Assistant Chief Immigration Judge Gary Smith who determined there was no evidence to substantiate the claims and dismissed the complaint. - The complainant had been represented by counsel on appeal and their case was properly processed through the Hartford Immigration Court and Board of Immigration Appeals.

1. Page 26. 12-20-14 Release
EOIRFOIAProcessing(EOIR)
From:
Sent
To:
SubjKt:
Smith,GiJI'/(EOIR)
Tuesday,November08,2011 8:20 AM
Keller, Mary Beth (EOIR); Moutinho , Debo rah (EOIR}
FW: REIMMIGRATIONJUDGECOMPLAINT.
Virginiatold methismorningthat thisfellow-ca lled her at the Court last week andhis tone gave her a lot of
concern. I told her to letDHSknowthathe~ contactingthecoort.
From:DConduct,EOIR(EOIR)
Se-mber07, 2011 1:58PM
To:
SUb : IGRATIONJUDGECOMPlAINT.
I receivedyourcorrespondenceof November2, 2011,sentto thelJConductwebsite. I havereviewedthe matters
thatyou raisedin your correspondence. Myreviewrevealed thatyourcasewas properlyprocessedthroughthe Hartford
Immigration Court, and your case was heard onAugust27, 2004. You wererepresentedby counsel on appeal, and the
Board of Immigration Appeals diemiesedyour appeal on November 30, 2006. You filed a Motion to R-,pen with the
Boardof Immigration Appeals with assistance of counsel. and the Boardof Immigration Appeals deniedthe Motionto
Reopenon March 7,2006. I haveconcllKledthat yourcasewasproperlyprocessed throughthe courtsystem.
Thankyou foryourcorretpor.dence,aod I hopethis hasbeenresponsive.
I, :..• '!.... •• ~ '.,. • .... I ' I ••
To:IJConduct,EOIR(EOIR}
Svbjact: REIMM1GRATIONJUDGECOMPLAINT.
Michael W. Straus
Sincerely,
Garyw.Smith
AssistantChief

2. pg. 22)
22 (same as 4857 499 Email 6/24/ 11 Burr Moutinho 9
pg. 21)
23 4864 503 Email 7/11/11 Keller Moutinho Joke about the work ACIJ needed to do
close complain t
24 4940 520 Email 8/10/11 Bmr Kaler 9 ACDs •. - tbeir -
bvac:ation
25(same as 4967 524 Email 8/22/11 Kelly Moutinho 9
35 in 1/ 13)
26 4983 563 Email 11/8/ 11 Smith Keller 1
27 (same• 5034 591 Email 1/9/12 Mapnl Kaler a/a ACD infmmngoda ACD abouthis
pg. 133 in scbecluleso thattheyCIOllldplanto talk
2/5}
28 5052 596 Memo 1/25/ 12 Nadkami Complainant 9
29 5229 661 Email 8/30/ 12 Fong Keller 9
30 5232 661 hltake Various Fone: 9
31-34 5234- 661 E-Mail Various Poag u 9 DiscussioobctwemU andACD about
37 scbeclulingmeclingto discuss
complaintandclisapcmmtbctwem
themaboutwbetberandwbm.
, 'IIIIIC • • • •
35 5352 714 Email 1/18/13 Weil O'Lea1y Redacted under Exemption 5 as well as
Non-Responsive

3. Y~L !:)!:)~ ·1U/Lb/1 'I U4/' IL /U'I
ASO 560 10/26/11 04/16/12
PBZ 561 10/28/11 11/14/11
ANY 562 10/18/11 10/27/11
HPY [563l 11/02/11 11/07/11
QJC 564 11/07/11 01/05/12
KMJ 565 11/07/11 11/07/11
GEP 566 11/07/11 11/09/11
QVI 567 11/08/11 01/04/12

4. e Detail
Complaint Number: 563
Current ACIJ
Smith, Garyw.
PastACDS:
A-Namben(s)
Immigration Judge: (b)(6)
BaseCity
--ComplaintNatare(s)
b)(6) Dueprocess l:l.mllm1b)(6}
ComplaintReceivedDate; I1/02/11
Final Action
Complaintdismissodbecauseit
cannotbesubstantiated
FinalActionDate
11107/11
ComplaintSolll'Ce(s)·----·-- --1
(b) (6)
ComplaintNarrative: Complainantstateshe didn'tget a fair bearingandhis attorneywas shy or new ai herjob.
11/02/11
11/03/11
11/03/11
11/07/11
Sep 11, 2013
Complaint referredto ACIJ
/C!J readdecisioas
Databaseentrycreated
ComplaintHistory
Complaintdismissed because it cannotbesubstantiated
l of l
0
<X)
0)
;g
0
0)
<X)
,.._
NI
(")
.,...
0
N