Downloaded 10 times
Uploaded byYuki Koyama
視覚デザイン探索のためのクラウドソーシングを活用したパラメタ空間解析（WISS 2014）
The document describes a design task analysis that involves: 1. Analyzing design parameters and parameter space. 2. Involving crowd workers to evaluate designs within the parameter space. 3. Developing a user interface with tools like a VisOpt slider to facilitate the interactive design optimization process.
![[SIGGRAPH 2017] Sequential Line Search for Efficient Visual Design Optimizati...](https://cdn.slidesharecdn.com/ss_thumbnails/siggraph2017-170807053216-thumbnail.jpg?width=640&height=640&fit=bounds)
![[UIST 2022] BO as Assistant: Using Bayesian Optimization for Asynchronously G...](https://cdn.slidesharecdn.com/ss_thumbnails/uist2022-pdf-221104183030-9cfd4402-thumbnail.jpg?width=640&height=640&fit=bounds)
![[SIGGRAPH 2020] Sequential Gallery for Interactive Visual Design Optimization](https://cdn.slidesharecdn.com/ss_thumbnails/siggraph2020-slide-200824063821-thumbnail.jpg?width=640&height=640&fit=bounds)
![[CHI 2018] OptiMo: Optimization-Guided Motion Editing for Keyframe Character ...](https://cdn.slidesharecdn.com/ss_thumbnails/chi2018slide-180421025550-thumbnail.jpg?width=640&height=640&fit=bounds)
![[IPSJ-ONE 2017] コンピュテーションがつなぐ人とデザイン](https://cdn.slidesharecdn.com/ss_thumbnails/ipsj-one-170319043454-thumbnail.jpg?width=640&height=640&fit=bounds)
![[CEDEC2016] 大規模学習を用いたCGの最先端研究の紹介 - 前半](https://cdn.slidesharecdn.com/ss_thumbnails/cg-160826014839-thumbnail.jpg?width=640&height=640&fit=bounds)
![Coded Agents – with UiPath SDK + LangGraph [Virtual Hands-on Workshop]](https://cdn.slidesharecdn.com/ss_thumbnails/codedagentsdeck-251215155422-5497c599-thumbnail.jpg?width=640&height=640&fit=bounds)
視覚デザイン探索のためのクラウドソーシングを活用したパラメタ空間解析（WISS 2014）
- 1. 8*44 鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךך ؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿 㼭㿊酔䊹խխ㖩劤㣐➜խխ✿⼧䆀⨳㣗 Not Good Good Parameter Space Suggested Designs Visualization User’s Edit Interactive Optimization Not Good Good Parameter Space Suggested Designs Visualization User’s Edit Interactive Optimization
- 2.
- 3.
- 4. 鎘皾ח״גرؠ؎ٝ佄䴂ׅ 劤灇瑔ך㼎韋ػًٓة锃侭ח״رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊 ⹛歗 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 5. 灇瑔嚊銲 ! ؼُ٦وٝ؝ٝؾُذ٦ءّٝח״ג رؠ؎ٝ瑞鍑匿ׅ䩛岀ך䲿周 رؠ؎ٝךչ葺׃䝤׃պך瑞ⴓ䋒䱿㹀ׅ ! رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךך؎ٝةؿؑ٦أך䲿周 4NBSU4VHHFTUJPO 7JT0QU4MJEFS 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 6. 灇瑔嚊銲 ! ؼُ٦وٝ؝ٝؾُذ٦ءّٝח״ג رؠ؎ٝ瑞鍑匿ׅ䩛岀ך䲿周 رؠ؎ٝךչ葺׃䝤׃պך瑞ⴓ䋒䱿㹀ׅ ! رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךך؎ٝةؿؑ٦أך䲿周 4NBSU4VHHFTUJPO 7JT0QU4MJEFS 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 7. 灇瑔嚊銲 ! ؼُ٦وٝ؝ٝؾُذ٦ءّٝח״ג رؠ؎ٝ瑞鍑匿ׅ䩛岀ך䲿周 رؠ؎ٝךչ葺׃䝤׃պך瑞ⴓ䋒䱿㹀ׅ ! رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךך؎ٝةؿؑ٦أך䲿周 4NBSU4VHHFTUJPO 7JT0QU4MJEFS 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 8.
- 9. ٙ٦ؙؿٗ٦ Design Task design parameters 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 10. ٙ٦ؙؿٗ٦ Design TaskAnalysis design parameters parameter space parameter 1 parameter 2 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 11. ٙ٦ؙؿٗ٦ Design TaskAnalysis design parameters parameter space parameter 1 parameter 2 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 12. ٙ٦ؙؿٗ٦ Design TaskAnalysis design parameters parameter space parameter 1 parameter 2 crowd workers 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 13. ٙ٦ؙؿٗ٦ Design TaskAnalysis design parameters parameter space ⹛歗 parameter 1 parameter 2 crowd workers 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 14. ٙ٦ؙؿٗ٦ Design TaskAnalysis design parameters parameter space parameter 1 parameter 2 crowd workers 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 15. ٙ٦ؙؿٗ٦ Design TaskAnalysis design parameters not good good parameter space parameter 1 parameter 2 crowd workers 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 16. ٙ٦ؙؿٗ٦ Design TaskAnalysis f : n design parameters not good good parameter space parameter 1 parameter 2 crowd workers 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 17. ٙ٦ؙؿٗ٦ Design TaskAnalysis f : n crowd workers User Interface VisOpt Slider design parameters not good good parameter space parameter 1 parameter 2 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 18.
- 19.
- 20.
- 21. ꧊さ濼欽ְرؠ؎ٝ 5BMUPO 7PZBOU9V ךِ٦ؠךرؠ؎ٝהח 倜׃ְٌرٕرؠ؎ׅٝ 㢳ֻך⸇罏הꞿְ麊欽劍ָ䗳銲 ֮رؠ؎ٝחאְג ؿ؍٦سغحؙ꧊ ػًٓة瑞ך鍑匿٥䱱稊דכזְ 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 22. ꧊さ濼欽ְرؠ؎ٝ 5BMUPO 7PZBOU9V ךِ٦ؠךرؠ؎ٝהח 倜׃ְٌرٕرؠ؎ׅٝ 㢳ֻך⸇罏הꞿְ麊欽劍ָ䗳銲 ֮رؠ؎ٝחאְג ؿ؍٦سغحؙ꧊ ػًٓة瑞ך鍑匿٥䱱稊דכזְ 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 23. ꧊さ濼欽ְرؠ؎ٝ 5BMUPO 7PZBOU9V ךِ٦ؠךرؠ؎ٝהח 倜׃ְٌرٕرؠ؎ׅٝ 㢳ֻך⸇罏הꞿְ麊欽劍ָ䗳銲 ֮رؠ؎ٝחאְג ؿ؍٦سغحؙ꧊ ػًٓة瑞ך鍑匿٥䱱稊דכזְ 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 24. 纇遚鎘皾ח״رؠ؎ٝ瑞ך鍑匿 'POU0ˏ%POPWBO 7JFX%JSFDUJPO4FDPSE8FC3FJOFDLF ぐرؠ؎ٝ걄㚖ח㔿剣ך濼陎 暴䗙ꆀ 欽ְגְ 䧮ղך䩛岀כ⟣䠐ךرؠ؎ٝ瑞ח黝欽〳腉 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 25. 纇遚鎘皾ח״رؠ؎ٝ瑞ך鍑匿 'POU0ˏ%POPWBO 7JFX%JSFDUJPO4FDPSE8FC3FJOFDLF ぐرؠ؎ٝ걄㚖ח㔿剣ך濼陎 暴䗙ꆀ 欽ְגְ 䧮ղך䩛岀כ⟣䠐ךرؠ؎ٝ瑞ח黝欽〳腉 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 26. 纇遚鎘皾ח״رؠ؎ٝ瑞ך鍑匿 'POU0ˏ%POPWBO 7JFX%JSFDUJPO4FDPSE8FC3FJOFDLF ぐرؠ؎ٝ걄㚖ח㔿剣ך濼陎 暴䗙ꆀ 欽ְגְ 䧮ղך䩛岀כ⟣䠐ךرؠ؎ٝ瑞ח黝欽〳腉 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 27. 䲿爙؎ٝةؿؑ٦أ %FTJHO(BMMFSJFT.BSLT #SBJOTUPSNGUFSFDUT 䲿爙ⰻ㺁ָ➂ך繟涸䠬鋙ח㛇בְגְזְ 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 28. 䲿爙؎ٝةؿؑ٦أ %FTJHO(BMMFSJFT.BSLT #SBJOTUPSNGUFSFDUT 䲿爙ⰻ㺁ָ➂ך繟涸䠬鋙ח㛇בְגְזְ 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 29. 䲿爙؎ٝةؿؑ٦أ %FTJHO(BMMFSJFT.BSLT #SBJOTUPSNGUFSFDUT 䲿爙ⰻ㺁ָ➂ך繟涸䠬鋙ח㛇בְגְזְ 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 30. أٓ؎ت؎ٝةؿؑ٦أ رؠ؎ٝفٖؽُ٦〳鋔⻉ ꟼ鸬ر٦ة〳鋔⻉ 4JEF7JFXT5FSSZ 4DFOUFE8JEHFU8JMMFUU չ葺׃䝤׃պך〳鋔⻉דכזְ 剑黝⻉堣腉כזְ 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 31. أٓ؎ت؎ٝةؿؑ٦أ رؠ؎ٝفٖؽُ٦〳鋔⻉ ꟼ鸬ر٦ة〳鋔⻉ 4JEF7JFXT5FSSZ 4DFOUFE8JEHFU8JMMFUU չ葺׃䝤׃պך〳鋔⻉דכזְ 剑黝⻉堣腉כזְ 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 32. أٓ؎ت؎ٝةؿؑ٦أ رؠ؎ٝفٖؽُ٦〳鋔⻉ ꟼ鸬ر٦ة〳鋔⻉ 4JEF7JFXT5FSSZ 4DFOUFE8JEHFU8JMMFUU չ葺׃䝤׃պך〳鋔⻉דכזְ 剑黝⻉堣腉כזְ 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 33.
- 34. رؠ؎ٝ瑞ך鍑匿 4BNQMJOH 1BSBNFUFS4FUT (BUIFSJOH1BJSXJTF $PNQBSJTPOT TUJNBUJOH(PPEOFTT 7BMVFTPG1PJOUT TUJNBUJOH(PPEOFTT 7BMVFTPG1PJOUT 'JUUJOHB(PPEOFTT 'VODUJPO ػًٓةإحزך ؟ٝفؚٔٝ 挿חֶֽ 嫰鯰ر٦ةך ꧊ ぐ挿חֶֽ (PPEOFTTך䱿㹀 鸬竲ꟼ侧פך ؿ؍حذ؍ؚٝ 鑫稢 Yuki Koyama, Daisuke Sakamoto, and Takeo Igarashi. 2014. Crowd-powered parameter analysis for visual design exploration. In Proceedings of the 27th annual ACM symposium on User interface software and technology (UIST '14). ACM, New York, NY, USA, 65-74. 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 35. رؠ؎ٝ瑞ך鍑匿 4BNQMJOH 1BSBNFUFS4FUT (BUIFSJOH1BJSXJTF $PNQBSJTPOT TUJNBUJOH(PPEOFTT 7BMVFTPG1PJOUT TUJNBUJOH(PPEOFTT 7BMVFTPG1PJOUT 'JUUJOHB(PPEOFTT 'VODUJPO ػًٓةإحزך ؟ٝفؚٔٝ 挿חֶֽ 嫰鯰ر٦ةך ꧊ ぐ挿חֶֽ (PPEOFTTך䱿㹀 鸬竲ꟼ侧פך ؿ؍حذ؍ؚٝ 鑫稢 Yuki Koyama, Daisuke Sakamoto, and Takeo Igarashi. 2014. Crowd-powered parameter analysis for visual design exploration. In Proceedings of the 27th annual ACM symposium on User interface software and technology (UIST '14). ACM, New York, NY, USA, 65-74. 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 36. رؠ؎ٝ瑞ך鍑匿 4BNQMJOH 1BSBNFUFS4FUT (BUIFSJOH1BJSXJTF $PNQBSJTPOT TUJNBUJOH(PPEOFTT 7BMVFTPG1PJOUT TUJNBUJOH(PPEOFTT 7BMVFTPG1PJOUT 'JUUJOHB(PPEOFTT 'VODUJPO ػًٓةإحزך ؟ٝفؚٔٝ 挿חֶֽ 嫰鯰ر٦ةך ꧊ ぐ挿חֶֽ (PPEOFTTך䱿㹀 鸬竲ꟼ侧פך ؿ؍حذ؍ؚٝ 鑫稢 Yuki Koyama, Daisuke Sakamoto, and Takeo Igarashi. 2014. Crowd-powered parameter analysis for visual design exploration. In Proceedings of the 27th annual ACM symposium on User interface software and technology (UIST '14). ACM, New York, NY, USA, 65-74. 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 37. رؠ؎ٝ瑞ך鍑匿 4BNQMJOH 1BSBNFUFS4FUT 纇遚鎘皾 (BUIFSJOH1BJSXJTF $PNQBSJTPOT crowd workers TUJNBUJOH(PPEOFTT 7BMVFTPG1PJOUT TUJNBUJOH(PPEOFTT 7BMVFTPG1PJOUT 'JUUJOHB(PPEOFTT 'VODUJPO ػًٓةإحزך ؟ٝفؚٔٝ 挿חֶֽ 嫰鯰ر٦ةך ꧊ ぐ挿חֶֽ (PPEOFTTך䱿㹀 鸬竲ꟼ侧פך ؿ؍حذ؍ؚٝ 鑫稢 Yuki Koyama, Daisuke Sakamoto, and Takeo Igarashi. 2014. Crowd-powered parameter analysis for visual design exploration. In Proceedings of the 27th annual ACM symposium on User interface software and technology (UIST '14). ACM, New York, NY, USA, 65-74. 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 38. رؠ؎ٝ瑞ך鍑匿 4BNQMJOH 1BSBNFUFS4FUT (BUIFSJOH1BJSXJTF $PNQBSJTPOT 剑㼭✳⛦岀 TUJNBUJOH(PPEOFTT 7BMVFTPG1PJOUT TUJNBUJOH(PPEOFTT 7BMVFTPG1PJOUT 'JUUJOHB(PPEOFTT 'VODUJPO ػًٓةإحزך ؟ٝفؚٔٝ 挿חֶֽ 嫰鯰ر٦ةך ꧊ ぐ挿חֶֽ (PPEOFTTך䱿㹀 鸬竲ꟼ侧פך ؿ؍حذ؍ؚٝ 鑫稢 Yuki Koyama, Daisuke Sakamoto, and Takeo Igarashi. 2014. Crowd-powered parameter analysis for visual design exploration. In Proceedings of the 27th annual ACM symposium on User interface software and technology (UIST '14). ACM, New York, NY, USA, 65-74. 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 39. رؠ؎ٝ瑞ך鍑匿 4BNQMJOH 1BSBNFUFS4FUT (BUIFSJOH1BJSXJTF $PNQBSJTPOT TUJNBUJOH(PPEOFTT 7BMVFTPG1PJOUT TUJNBUJOH(PPEOFTT 7BMVFTPG1PJOUT 3#'酡 'JUUJOHB(PPEOFTT 'VODUJPO ػًٓةإحزך ؟ٝفؚٔٝ 挿חֶֽ 嫰鯰ر٦ةך ꧊ ぐ挿חֶֽ (PPEOFTTך䱿㹀 鸬竲ꟼ侧פך ؿ؍حذ؍ؚٝ 鑫稢 Yuki Koyama, Daisuke Sakamoto, and Takeo Igarashi. 2014. Crowd-powered parameter analysis for visual design exploration. In Proceedings of the 27th annual ACM symposium on User interface software and technology (UIST '14). ACM, New York, NY, USA, 65-74. 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 40.
- 41. ؎ٝةؿؑ٦أ 4NBSU4VHHFTUJPO ؝ٝإفز չ葺׃䝤׃պך䞔㜠欽ְג䲿爙ⰻ㺁欰䧭 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 42. ؎ٝةؿؑ٦أ 4NBSU4VHHFTUJPO 植㖈ך㹋鄲 ٓٝتيח⦐ך رؠ؎ٝ欰䧭 挿侧ָ넝ְ⦐䲿爙 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 43.
- 44. 剑黝⻉ 0QU xi xj xi xj 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 45.
- 46. 剑黝⻉ 0QU xi xj xi xj 植㖈ך⦼ 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 47.
- 48. 剑黝⻉ 0QU xi xj xi xj 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 49.
- 50. 剑黝⻉ 0QU xi xj xi xj 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 51.
- 52. 剑黝⻉ 0QU xi xj xi xj 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 53.
- 54. 剑黝⻉ 0QU xi xj xi xj ِ٦ؠך箟꧊ 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 55.
- 56. 剑黝⻉ 0QU xi xj xi xj 荈⹛锃眍 ِ٦ؠך箟꧊ 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 57.
- 58. 黝欽⢽ $PMPS$PSSFDUJPO ⹛歗 ةأؙⱖ溪ך葿酡姻խػًٓة侧 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 59.
- 60.
- 61. 黝欽⢽ $BNFSB-JHIU ةأؙ 葺ְؽُ٦䱱ׅ ػًٓة侧 Y Z [ 僇ׁ Y Z [ 鋔ꅿ錬 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 62.
- 63. 黝欽⢽ 4IBEFS 颵䠬 ةأؙأذٖٝأ醡ך暟⡤ך鋅湡ךرؠ؎ٝ ⹛歗 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 64. 黝欽⢽ 4IBEFS 颵䠬 ةأؙأذٖٝأ醡ך暟⡤ך鋅湡ךرؠ؎ٝ 鐰⣣鯥ˑSFBMJTUJDBTTUBJOMFTT˒ ػًٓة侧 h)JTGPS)PNF FHأذٖٝأ 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 65.
- 66. 黝欽⢽ 邌䞔ٌرؚٔٝ #MFOETIBQFػًٓة锃眍ח״ג邌䞔ⵖ䖴ׅ䩛岀 ⹛歗 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 67. 黝欽⢽ 邌䞔ٌرؚٔٝ #MFOETIBQFػًٓة锃眍ח״ג邌䞔ⵖ䖴ׅ䩛岀 ٓٝتيז邌䞔ך⢽ קהוךرؠ؎ָٝ♶荈搫 㠨גְ 鐰⣣鯥OBUVSBM OPUCSPLFO ػًٓة侧 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 68.
- 69. 黝欽⢽ 邌䞔ٌرؚٔٝ OPUOBUVSBM OBUVSBM 00..1155 00..3311 00..4499 00..6611 0.88 鋔鋙涸ח㧅䔲ז䱿㹀穠卓ָ䖤 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 70. 黝欽⢽ 邌䞔ٌرؚٔٝ OPUOBUVSBM OBUVSBM 00..1155 00..3311 00..4499 00..6611 0.88 鋔鋙涸ח㧅䔲ז䱿㹀穠卓ָ䖤 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 71. 黝欽⢽窟鎘ر٦ة $PMPS $PSSFDUJPO $BNFSB -JHIU 4IBEFS 'BDJBM YQSFTTJPO ػًٓة侧 鐰⣣鯥 HPPE HPPE SFBMJTUJD OBUVSBM 嫰鯰ر٦ة侧 さ鎘ꆃ겘 64% 64% 64% 64% さ鎘儗 NJO NJO NJO NJO 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 72.
- 73. 鐰⣣鍑匿䩛岀 勲 XSU嫰鯰侧 ❛䊴嗚鏾 鑫稢 Yuki Koyama, Daisuke Sakamoto, and Takeo Igarashi. 2014. Crowd-powered parameter analysis for visual design exploration. In Proceedings of the 27th annual ACM symposium on User interface software and technology (UIST '14). ACM, New York, NY, USA, 65-74. 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 74. 鐰⣣ِ٦ؠ؎ٝةؿؑ٦أ ِ٦ؠأةر؍ ➂ך㷕欰חِ٦ؠ؎ٝةؿؑ٦أ⢪גֲ 4ZTUFN6TBCJMJUZ4DBMF#BOHPS ˑHPPE˒ WFSBHF 4% 鑫稢 Yuki Koyama, Daisuke Sakamoto, and Takeo Igarashi. 2014. Crowd-powered parameter analysis for visual design exploration. In Proceedings of the 27th annual ACM symposium on User interface software and technology (UIST '14). ACM, New York, NY, USA, 65-74. 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 75.
- 76. ٔىذ٦ءّٝ ! ةأָؙ㢌䏝חؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝך װ湫׃ָ䗳銲 ! 鸬竲涸זػًٓةך黝欽〳腉 ꨄ侔涸זػًٓةכ♶〳 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 77. תה ! ؼُ٦وٝ؝ٝؾُذ٦ءّٝח״ג ⟣䠐ךرؠ؎ٝ瑞鍑匿ׅ䩛岀 ! رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךך؎ٝةؿؑ٦أ 4NBSU4VHHFTUJPO 7JT0QU4MJEFS ! אך殯זرؠ؎ٝ걄㚖ח黝欽 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 78. תה ! ؼُ٦وٝ؝ٝؾُذ٦ءّٝח״ג ⟣䠐ךرؠ؎ٝ瑞鍑匿ׅ䩛岀 ! رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךך؎ٝةؿؑ٦أ 4NBSU4VHHFTUJPO 7JT0QU4MJEFS ! אך殯זرؠ؎ٝ걄㚖ח黝欽 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 79. תה ! ؼُ٦وٝ؝ٝؾُذ٦ءّٝח״ג ⟣䠐ךرؠ؎ٝ瑞鍑匿ׅ䩛岀 ! رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךך؎ٝةؿؑ٦أ 4NBSU4VHHFTUJPO 7JT0QU4MJEFS ! אך殯זرؠ؎ٝ걄㚖ח黝欽 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 80. תה ! ؼُ٦وٝ؝ٝؾُذ٦ءّٝח״ג ⟣䠐ךرؠ؎ٝ瑞鍑匿ׅ䩛岀 ! رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךך؎ٝةؿؑ٦أ 4NBSU4VHHFTUJPO 7JT0QU4MJEFS ! אך殯זرؠ؎ٝ걄㚖ח黝欽 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 81.
- 82.
- 83. $SPXETPVSDJOH)VNBO$PNQVUBUJPO )VNBO@ $SPXE1PXFSFE )VNBO$PNQVUBUJPO $PNQVUBUJPO@ $SPXETPVSDJOH $SPXETPVSDJOHBTLDSPXEXPSLFSTUPEPTPNFUBTLT )VNBO$PNQVUBUJPOBTTVNFIVNBOBTBQSPDFTTPS TFF2VJOOGPSEFUBJMT 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 84. .JDSP5BTLGPS$SPXETPVSDJOH 8IBUJTUIFHPPEOFTTTDPSF ✗OB®WFBQQSPBDI BTLBCTPMVUFWBMVF • EJDVMUUPDPOTJTUFOUMZBOTXFSFWFSZUJNF • EJFSFOUTDBMFGPSFBDIXPSLFS 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 85. .JDSP5BTLGPS$SPXETPVSDJOH ✔ QBJSXJTFDPNQBSJTPO 4FDPSE(JOHPME$IBVEPIVSJ 8IJDIJTCFUUFS FBTZGPSOPOFYQFSUT TVJUBCMFGPSDSPXETPVSDJOH 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 86. .JDSP5BTLGPS$SPXETPVSDJOH Which ofthe two images of OPVOis more BEKFDUJWF? ! For example, DMBVTF.! Please choose the most appropriate one from the 5 options below.! YBNQMFPGVTFSˏTTQFDJDBUJPO OPVO vegetables BEKFDUJWF good DMBVTF suppose that you had to choose one of these two images to appear in a magazine or product advertisement! 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 87. .JDSP5BTLGPS$SPXETPVSDJOH 2 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 88. 2VBMJUZ$POUSPM ˑ%VQMJDBUF˒BQQSPBDI4FDPSE (JOHPME $IBVEIVSJ 2 2 %FUFDUDPOUSBEJDUJPO 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44
- 89. 2VBMJUZ$POUSPM ˑ%VQMJDBUF˒BQQSPBDI4FDPSE(JOHPME$IBVEIVSJ TLRVFTUJPOTSTU TLUIFTBNFRVFTUJPOTXJUIJQQFEBSSBOHFNFOUT *GBQBJSPGBOTXFSTJTDPOUSBEJDUFE EJTDBSEUIFN *GPWFSIBMGBOTXFSTBSFDPOUSBEJDUFE EJTDBSEBMMPGUIFN 㼭㿊酔䊹㖩劤㣐➜✿⼧䆀⨳㣗խխ鋔鋙رؠ؎ٝ䱱稊ךךؙٓؐسا٦ءؚٝ崞欽׃ػًٓة瑞鍑匿խխ8*44