SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 1
Download to read offline
To the Editor:
This is in response to the June 4 letter to the editor regarding the psychology prescribing bill (SB2187)
that affects the vulnerable citizens of Illinois. I am a board-certified psychiatrist. I have worked closely
with physicians and psychologists for 15 years. Psychiatrists learn about all medications, their uses and
their side effects in four years of medical school. They then learn more about the proper diagnosis of
psychiatric disease in their four-year residency after medical school. They also learn more about the
medications that are used: their risks, their benefits, and how they interact with each other and other
medications a patient may be taking. This includes laboratory testing, interpretation and medical
communication with other physicians. Psychiatrists also are trained in psychotherapy. In my practice,
I provide psychotherapy and medications, and only when each is needed. Psychologists learn about
behavioral disorders in their training. They do not get extensive education or experience in choosing
psychiatric drugs. They get basically no training in the side effects of these medications, or their
interaction with other medications. Psychologists are our valuable colleagues in the treatment of patients
with psychiatric disease. But they are not trained to prescribe psychiatric medications, plain and simple.
If there is a shortage in psychiatric practitioners in Illinois, or any other state, let’s fix that. But asking
professionals untrained in those medications to prescribe them is no fix at all. It’s a quick and dirty
patch that will end up hurting, not helping, the patients involved.
Shalini Varma
Journal Star June 28 2103
http://www.pjstar.com/opinions/forum/x987154178/Forum-Psychologists-should-not-prescribe-drugs

More Related Content

What's hot

medicine_adherenceNahu
medicine_adherenceNahumedicine_adherenceNahu
medicine_adherenceNahu
Joshua Powell
 
Page 20 winter issue of empowerment magazine
Page 20   winter issue of empowerment magazinePage 20   winter issue of empowerment magazine
Page 20 winter issue of empowerment magazine
sacpros
 
Depression and Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder
Depression and Post-Traumatic Stress DisorderDepression and Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder
Depression and Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder
A Place of Hope
 
Depression On A Societal Scale
Depression On A Societal ScaleDepression On A Societal Scale
Depression On A Societal Scale
akashmansingh
 

What's hot (19)

History taking in psychiatry
History taking in psychiatryHistory taking in psychiatry
History taking in psychiatry
 
SA 202 Week 3 lecture 5 relapse
SA 202 Week 3 lecture 5 relapseSA 202 Week 3 lecture 5 relapse
SA 202 Week 3 lecture 5 relapse
 
How to take case history in psychiatric patients
How to take case history in psychiatric patientsHow to take case history in psychiatric patients
How to take case history in psychiatric patients
 
medicine_adherenceNahu
medicine_adherenceNahumedicine_adherenceNahu
medicine_adherenceNahu
 
Abnormal Psychology (Psychiatric history) Case Study
Abnormal Psychology (Psychiatric history) Case StudyAbnormal Psychology (Psychiatric history) Case Study
Abnormal Psychology (Psychiatric history) Case Study
 
Cssi Ppt Portland Family Practice
Cssi Ppt Portland Family PracticeCssi Ppt Portland Family Practice
Cssi Ppt Portland Family Practice
 
Maternal Mental Health Medicaid Innovation 8 2020
Maternal Mental Health Medicaid Innovation 8 2020Maternal Mental Health Medicaid Innovation 8 2020
Maternal Mental Health Medicaid Innovation 8 2020
 
Maternal Mental Health What All Employers Should Know
Maternal Mental Health What All Employers Should Know Maternal Mental Health What All Employers Should Know
Maternal Mental Health What All Employers Should Know
 
Psychiatric malpractice to present
Psychiatric malpractice to presentPsychiatric malpractice to present
Psychiatric malpractice to present
 
Recovery- Oriented System of Care ,Motivational Approach , in Substance Use D...
Recovery- Oriented System of Care ,Motivational Approach , in Substance Use D...Recovery- Oriented System of Care ,Motivational Approach , in Substance Use D...
Recovery- Oriented System of Care ,Motivational Approach , in Substance Use D...
 
Page 20 winter issue of empowerment magazine
Page 20   winter issue of empowerment magazinePage 20   winter issue of empowerment magazine
Page 20 winter issue of empowerment magazine
 
Psychiatry Malpractice
Psychiatry MalpracticePsychiatry Malpractice
Psychiatry Malpractice
 
Underground HRT
Underground HRTUnderground HRT
Underground HRT
 
Curious About Sex Therapy?
Curious About Sex Therapy?Curious About Sex Therapy?
Curious About Sex Therapy?
 
Akshat ethics in medicine
Akshat ethics in medicineAkshat ethics in medicine
Akshat ethics in medicine
 
Maria Cambiaso | How to Choose a Psychologist?
Maria Cambiaso | How to Choose a Psychologist?Maria Cambiaso | How to Choose a Psychologist?
Maria Cambiaso | How to Choose a Psychologist?
 
Depression and Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder
Depression and Post-Traumatic Stress DisorderDepression and Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder
Depression and Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder
 
Depression On A Societal Scale
Depression On A Societal ScaleDepression On A Societal Scale
Depression On A Societal Scale
 
Careers in education by (your name here)job description
Careers in education by (your name here)job descriptionCareers in education by (your name here)job description
Careers in education by (your name here)job description
 

Similar to JournalStarart

Data Transcription 21. Research question What are barriers to
Data Transcription 21. Research question What are barriers to Data Transcription 21. Research question What are barriers to
Data Transcription 21. Research question What are barriers to
OllieShoresna
 
Psychiatry slideshow
Psychiatry slideshowPsychiatry slideshow
Psychiatry slideshow
Holy Redeemer
 
Running head DRUG ABUSE1DRUG ABUSE3Dr.docx
Running head DRUG ABUSE1DRUG ABUSE3Dr.docxRunning head DRUG ABUSE1DRUG ABUSE3Dr.docx
Running head DRUG ABUSE1DRUG ABUSE3Dr.docx
susanschei
 
CASE STUDYFemale, 15, separation anxiety disorder, Depression.docx
CASE STUDYFemale, 15, separation anxiety disorder, Depression.docxCASE STUDYFemale, 15, separation anxiety disorder, Depression.docx
CASE STUDYFemale, 15, separation anxiety disorder, Depression.docx
bartholomeocoombs
 
Running head PSYCHOTHERAPY APPROACHES .docx
Running head PSYCHOTHERAPY APPROACHES                            .docxRunning head PSYCHOTHERAPY APPROACHES                            .docx
Running head PSYCHOTHERAPY APPROACHES .docx
todd581
 
Chief Complaint Follow upHistory of Presenting IllnessMr
Chief Complaint Follow upHistory of Presenting IllnessMrChief Complaint Follow upHistory of Presenting IllnessMr
Chief Complaint Follow upHistory of Presenting IllnessMr
JinElias52
 
Psychology awareness column
Psychology awareness columnPsychology awareness column
Psychology awareness column
Kattie Cool
 
Kitchen j ss310-13-finalproject
Kitchen j ss310-13-finalprojectKitchen j ss310-13-finalproject
Kitchen j ss310-13-finalproject
Jenni Kitchen
 
NRNPPRAC 6645 Comprehensive Psychiatric Evaluation Note Tem.docx
NRNPPRAC 6645 Comprehensive Psychiatric Evaluation Note Tem.docxNRNPPRAC 6645 Comprehensive Psychiatric Evaluation Note Tem.docx
NRNPPRAC 6645 Comprehensive Psychiatric Evaluation Note Tem.docx
pauline234567
 
Ethical Viewpoints AssignmentResearch QuestionShould schools s.docx
Ethical Viewpoints AssignmentResearch QuestionShould schools s.docxEthical Viewpoints AssignmentResearch QuestionShould schools s.docx
Ethical Viewpoints AssignmentResearch QuestionShould schools s.docx
humphrieskalyn
 
Psychology of AddictionIntroductionAddiction is an intrica.docx
Psychology of AddictionIntroductionAddiction is an intrica.docxPsychology of AddictionIntroductionAddiction is an intrica.docx
Psychology of AddictionIntroductionAddiction is an intrica.docx
amrit47
 

Similar to JournalStarart (13)

Data Transcription 21. Research question What are barriers to
Data Transcription 21. Research question What are barriers to Data Transcription 21. Research question What are barriers to
Data Transcription 21. Research question What are barriers to
 
Impact of substance abuse on.pdf
Impact of substance abuse on.pdfImpact of substance abuse on.pdf
Impact of substance abuse on.pdf
 
Psychiatry slideshow
Psychiatry slideshowPsychiatry slideshow
Psychiatry slideshow
 
Running head DRUG ABUSE1DRUG ABUSE3Dr.docx
Running head DRUG ABUSE1DRUG ABUSE3Dr.docxRunning head DRUG ABUSE1DRUG ABUSE3Dr.docx
Running head DRUG ABUSE1DRUG ABUSE3Dr.docx
 
CASE STUDYFemale, 15, separation anxiety disorder, Depression.docx
CASE STUDYFemale, 15, separation anxiety disorder, Depression.docxCASE STUDYFemale, 15, separation anxiety disorder, Depression.docx
CASE STUDYFemale, 15, separation anxiety disorder, Depression.docx
 
Running head PSYCHOTHERAPY APPROACHES .docx
Running head PSYCHOTHERAPY APPROACHES                            .docxRunning head PSYCHOTHERAPY APPROACHES                            .docx
Running head PSYCHOTHERAPY APPROACHES .docx
 
Chief Complaint Follow upHistory of Presenting IllnessMr
Chief Complaint Follow upHistory of Presenting IllnessMrChief Complaint Follow upHistory of Presenting IllnessMr
Chief Complaint Follow upHistory of Presenting IllnessMr
 
Psychology awareness column
Psychology awareness columnPsychology awareness column
Psychology awareness column
 
Kitchen j ss310-13-finalproject
Kitchen j ss310-13-finalprojectKitchen j ss310-13-finalproject
Kitchen j ss310-13-finalproject
 
Clinical Psychology L1.pdf
Clinical Psychology L1.pdfClinical Psychology L1.pdf
Clinical Psychology L1.pdf
 
NRNPPRAC 6645 Comprehensive Psychiatric Evaluation Note Tem.docx
NRNPPRAC 6645 Comprehensive Psychiatric Evaluation Note Tem.docxNRNPPRAC 6645 Comprehensive Psychiatric Evaluation Note Tem.docx
NRNPPRAC 6645 Comprehensive Psychiatric Evaluation Note Tem.docx
 
Ethical Viewpoints AssignmentResearch QuestionShould schools s.docx
Ethical Viewpoints AssignmentResearch QuestionShould schools s.docxEthical Viewpoints AssignmentResearch QuestionShould schools s.docx
Ethical Viewpoints AssignmentResearch QuestionShould schools s.docx
 
Psychology of AddictionIntroductionAddiction is an intrica.docx
Psychology of AddictionIntroductionAddiction is an intrica.docxPsychology of AddictionIntroductionAddiction is an intrica.docx
Psychology of AddictionIntroductionAddiction is an intrica.docx
 

JournalStarart

  • 1. To the Editor: This is in response to the June 4 letter to the editor regarding the psychology prescribing bill (SB2187) that affects the vulnerable citizens of Illinois. I am a board-certified psychiatrist. I have worked closely with physicians and psychologists for 15 years. Psychiatrists learn about all medications, their uses and their side effects in four years of medical school. They then learn more about the proper diagnosis of psychiatric disease in their four-year residency after medical school. They also learn more about the medications that are used: their risks, their benefits, and how they interact with each other and other medications a patient may be taking. This includes laboratory testing, interpretation and medical communication with other physicians. Psychiatrists also are trained in psychotherapy. In my practice, I provide psychotherapy and medications, and only when each is needed. Psychologists learn about behavioral disorders in their training. They do not get extensive education or experience in choosing psychiatric drugs. They get basically no training in the side effects of these medications, or their interaction with other medications. Psychologists are our valuable colleagues in the treatment of patients with psychiatric disease. But they are not trained to prescribe psychiatric medications, plain and simple. If there is a shortage in psychiatric practitioners in Illinois, or any other state, let’s fix that. But asking professionals untrained in those medications to prescribe them is no fix at all. It’s a quick and dirty patch that will end up hurting, not helping, the patients involved. Shalini Varma Journal Star June 28 2103 http://www.pjstar.com/opinions/forum/x987154178/Forum-Psychologists-should-not-prescribe-drugs