SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 8
Download to read offline
Social Housing Green
Space in Europe
A CABE Space Design Skills Scholarship
“Turning Mean Streets into Green Streets”
Noel Murphy
2009
Vauban Freiberg Germany
Hammarby Stockholm
CABE
1 Kemble Street
London
WC2B 4AN
Tel: 020 7070 6700
Fax: 020 7070 6777
Email: info@cabe.org.uk
Social Housing Green Space in Europe | Noel Murphy 20092 Noel Murphy 2009 | Social Housing Green Space in Europe 3
Social Housing landlords in the UK now own and manage large
estates and this has increased significantly over the last decade
as stock transfers and the creation of ALMOs has taken the
Housing stock away from Local Authorities and there is a vast
amount of Green
Space within these
Neighbourhoods
which is not
particularly well
designed or
maintained and does
not meet the needs
of the communities
who we expect to
live there. My own
organisation Places
for People Group has
over 60,000 social
rented properties
from Edinburgh to
the Isle of White in
over 200 local
authority areas. We
have as much Green
Space as a medium
sized town or local
authority area, and if
we can improve the
quality of this Green
Space and engage
the residents at the
same time we will
have a much better
chance of creating
sustainable communities with improved Social Cohesion. The
Green Spaces in these neighbourhoods give us the opportunity
for recreation whether passive or active, this is where people
meet and get to know each other.
Social housing in Europe accounts for around 15 Million units of
the available housing (see table below). Social Housing as a
percentage of the housing stock ranges from a high of 35% in
the Netherlands to 6% in Germany. There is no single definition
of Social Housing across Europe. Also the profile of Social
Housing stock differs from countries in terms of age, type of
housing and the percentage located on Estates. Providers and
funders also vary from country to country as do the type of
residents from the very poor to the low paid and middle classes
in general the social sector tends to house either the elderly, the
poor and a disproportionate number of single parent
households.
Project Overview
Background to Social Housing in Europe
Housing Tenure and Size of Sector by Country
Social Housing in the UK houses approximately one fifth of the
countries inhabitants with some 9 million people living in
around 4 Million homes. Very often the Green Spaces in and
around these homes are poorly designed and maintained
leading to a lack of ownership and usage by the residents.
Good design is a key factor in the success of the Landscape of
our Neighbourhoods. Too often the Landscaping has been
designed without input from the people who are expected to
live in these environments and the budgets are vulnerable to
being cut as the cost for the building works inevitably overruns.
Therefore we are left with inappropriate designs delivered with
inadequate budgets, quite often not very well maintained and
with no additional funds for improvements or replacement over
time. It is not surprising then that Social Housing
Neighbourhoods in the UK have some of the poorest quality
environments and this contributes to vandalism, anti social
behaviour and a general lack of respect for the environment and
each other.
The Bijlmermeer is an area in the South East district Zuidoost of
Amsterdam; The Zuidoost comprises four areas, Gaasperdam,
the Bijlmermeer, Driemond and Kantorenpark. The Zuidoost has
a population of approximately 80,000 and provides
employment for around 50,000 people.
The Bijlmermeer was my main area of interest and comprised 9
neighbourhoods in total, 3 low rise, 3 medium rise and three
high rise gallery flat blocks. The original layout for the high-rise
blocks was an Architects utopian dream and was constructed
from 1966 to 1975 and was laid out in Le Corbusier, style
designed around the segregation of functions, so that
residential, business and traffic and recreation were separated.
There are around 12,500 social housing units in 11 storey
apartments. The apartments were spacious and there were
interior walkways and also rooms with communal facilities. They
were constructed in park like surroundings with 80% of the land
given over to landscaped green space, separate from cars and
traffic. The blocks had a hexagonal honeycomb pattern and the
surrounded landscape provided play areas and cycle tracks in a
traffic free environment. Residents could park their cars in car
parks accessed by elevated roadways then walk home under
cover. Shopping centres and social facilities were also part of
the design although these took some time to follow on after
the residential construction.
Originally there was a waiting list of people wanting to move to
the Bijlmermeer due to chronic housing shortages within
Amsterdam. Straight away there were problems with security,
the interior walkways and the public open space were
considered unsafe, and the lifts and the waste disposal system
did not work properly. Crime rates of drug dealing and robbery
Social Housing Green Space in the UK
I decided to visit the European countries with the largest stock of Social Housing as identified on the table (below left), I met
with a range of stakeholders from senior Town Planning Officers to retired residents, Project Workers and Consultants. My aim
was to try to see what lessons could be learnt from successful Neighbourhoods in terms of the design and management of their
Green Spaces that we could then apply back in the UK. My Starting point was the Netherlands where I visited three diverse
areas, ljborg,Western Garden City and Bijlmermeer.Whilst my purpose was to concentrate on the Green Spaces I was also
considering the context of these spaces in relation to the building Architecture, transport links and different social issues that I
found to be inherently linked together and I have commented on these also.
Study Tour
Bijlmermeer, Amsterdam
The aim of this study was to bring together good practice in Social Housing Green Space from across Europe to see what
lessons could be learned and good practice identified so that we can apply what works to our own Neighbourhoods in the UK.
Netherlands 54 11 35 2,400,000
Denmark 52 17 21 530,000
Sweden 59 21 20 780,000
England 70 11 19 3,983,000
France 56 20 17 4,230,000
Germany 46 49 6 1,800,000
Owner
Occupied %
Private
Rented %
Social
Rented %
Number of
Social Units
Sonder Boulevard in Copenhagen runs for over a kilometre
through the city quarter of Vesterbro. This is a dense urban area
with little if any Green Space around the high density Housing.
It is in situations like this that areas of public open space are
very important to the communities that live beside them as
they offer the opportunity for recreation outdoors that is so
vital to health and well being. The Boulevard has recently been
redeveloped to provide a variety of experiences for the
community living adjacent to it and those who travel along it.
From wildflower and seating areas to ball courts and play
facilities the redesigned Boulevard caters for all age groups and
sections of the community. Those who live in the apartments
close to the Boulevard that have no communal Green Space use
the Boulevard as their garden Through a comprehensive
community participation process the residents of the area have
had the opportunity to place their ideas on the urban space in
the form of basket ball courts, seating areas, walks and small
peaceful gardens. The residents have determined which
activities and uses should be incorporated. This has created
inclusive spaces for everyone and amenity values for the whole
area. Sonder Boulevard in Copenhagen now directs the traffic in
a calmer fashion with reduced speed and widening of the linear
recreational space down the centre of the boulevard. A simple
arrangement of the space with rows of different tree species
along the entire boulevard provides variation, but also allows
future uses to be incorporated in the plan. The trees are chosen
so they flower, spring into leaf and drop their foliage at different
times. Thus the boulevard is always experienced in different
ways, and draws the beauty of nature right into the inner city.
were high and the neighbourhood spiralled into decline with up
to one in four flats unoccupied. Various attempts to improve the
situation were attempted and in 1992 a wholesale renovation
commenced, this meant demolishing some of the high rise
blocks and replacing them with low rise accommodation,
renovating some of the high rise blocks, removing the internal
walkways, putting the lifts on the outside of the structure,
lowering the elevated roads and closing and demolishing some
of the car parks.
The Green Spaces were originally laid out in the English
Landscape Parkland style and accounted for 80% of the land. In
certain areas this ratio will stay but in others where the old
high-rise blocks have been pulled down this will reduce to 40%
of available land so that cars can then be parked in front of
homes. Most of the Bijlmerpark approximately 40 hectares is
being redeveloped into an urban park with sports facilities, with
the remainder being designed as a natural park, some 800
homes are also being constructed around the parks boundary.
The redevelopment of the open spaces includes a clear Green
Belt area, which is easy to maintain, and where people feel safe,
it will also include more private areas for single-family homes.
Trees and shrubs have been removed to increase security, create
space for play and parking facilities, and the replanting of
specimen groups of trees and shrubs. When the original design
was conceived there was no provision made for places of
worship, so the residents who came to live there made their
own, either in the Green Spaces or the car parks. Nine of the
twenty-one car parks have now been demolished, and most of
the new parking places will be on the streets.
There is a strong presence of public art in evidence in the
Bijlmermeer, which appears to be well received by the residents
and has not been vandalised. Also it is the site of the memorial
garden for the people who lost their lives in the early nineties
when a cargo plane crashed into one of the high-rise
honeycomb blocks. The final death toll has never been known
due to the high number of illegal immigrants inhabiting these
blocks at the time. There has been a memorial garden created
for the people who lost their lives in that accident and this is
well maintained and respected by the residents.
The footprint of the honeycomb block that was hit by the plane
also remains as a memorial.
Charlotte Garden is a housing complex comprising around 200
units adjacent to Nordhavn Station in a suburb of Copenhagen.
Residents and people who live in the local area use the garden,
as a meeting place, and to bring their families to use the play
facilities.
The design of this space is quite stunning and the impact is
striking particularly when you consider it is based on a dune
style of landscape planted mostly with grass species, the idea
behind the design is to reflect the proximity of the sea and to
create movement through the planting and the contours of the
design. It has the sensation of a large outdoor room, when
viewed from one of the surrounding apartment windows the
landscape is constantly changing and unusually for gardens this
far North there is also year round colour as the grasses change
from blue and green to more golden tones. The quality of
materials used in the construction is impressive with steel up
stands used to form the elaborate curves that are a key feature
of the garden. The different and changing spaces are held
together by a series of paths crossing the garden, whilst the
different elements of the garden are accentuated by a change in
materials. The garden was constructed in 2004 at a cost of 1.1
million Euros. The garden has become a place and an outdoor
room loved by the surrounding community.
Bijlmermeer, Amsterdam (continued)
Western Garden City, Amsterdam
Charlotte Garden, Copenhagen Denmark
Social Housing Green Space in Europe | Noel Murphy 20094
In the west of Amsterdam 130.000 people live in 54.000
dwellings. 10.000 Of these dwellings will be torn down in the
following years. Taking until 2015 17,500 new dwellings will be
built instead. Within this city transformation are a number of
innovative housing projects, which attempt to develop a
contemporary image of the garden city. The Western Garden
Suburbs are characterised by broad avenues, waterways, open
space, and dwellings in green surroundings. Tall blocks of flats,
dwellings with shared entrance halls and stairways, and houses
with gardens predominate. Open building blocks are a common
feature. Despite the idyllic layout, the garden suburbs no longer
meet current Housing standards. The district is currently
undergoing a large-scale restructuring. The task is sizeable, a
quarter of the existing stock of 41,000 rental dwellings will be
demolished and replaced by privately owned homes. In addition,
11,000 dwellings will be built. Social and economic renewal will
lead to new programmes, and improving public space is a
priority. An urban- rather than garden-suburb character has
been opted for.
Noel Murphy 2009 | Social Housing Green Space in Europe 5
Sonder Boulevard, Copenhagen Denmark
Hammarby Sjostad, Stockholm, Sweden Augustenborg, Malmo, Sweden
Hammarby is a city district of Stockholm set around a lake in
the South of the city, eventually up to 20,000 people will live
there as it is currently under construction and should be
completed around the middle of the next decade. Hammarby is
a truly inspirational place which has brought together the best
in design and sustainable development. The design of the
district places a strong emphasis on the environment and
sustainability. Throughout the development runs a network of
small parks and Green Spaces. Use of native species like birch
and oak trees along the lake side give structure to this newly
developed site. The whole development has been designed
along principles of working in harmony with nature alongside
the contemporary architecture of the buildings. There is a strong
green infrastructure permeating throughout the district where it
is possible to walk through large sections of the estate without
coming into contact with traffic.. It is a mixed tenure
development which is aiming for a 50 - 50 split between owned
and rented properties. The district is characterised by a sense of
being close to nature due to the lake and the large amount of
Green infrastructure, and around each different block the
landscape provided a different experience, whether this was
play, allotment gardening or areas for quiet relaxation, all
interests appeared to be catered for. There is a high number of
allotment gardens within the blocks and these all appeared to
be in cultivation and well maintained, this was in contrast with
the contemporary architecture but at the same time did not
appear out of place, . I visited the district on late midsummer
afternoon 2009 which is a time of year that Scandinavian
countries particularly celebrate. There where families picnicking
and barbequing in the Green Spaces and a real sense of family
celebration. A number of schemes that I visited across Europe
catered for impromptu celebrations and events by having
communal facilities within the Green Spaces, such as barbeques,
large tables and seating, table tennis tables and this feature
must help to encourage people out of doors to partake in
parties and gatherings and help with social cohesion. Public art
again was very much in evidence throughout the district which
was again another feature in many of the Green Spaces.
Reading the background to the planning and development of
the district the local authority have been very much the driving
force that have shaped the development with strong leadership
aligned to sustainable design principles, again this is a common
factor across the successful European housing schemes that I
have seen.
Augustenborg is district of the city of Malmo in Sweden. There
are currently around 1800 properties there owned and managed
by MKB Housing Association.
It was originally built
in the 1950s and in
the beginning it was a
successful mixture of
housing, employment
and social facilities.
However in the 1970s
the 32-hectare
neighbourhood was
failing. There were
problems with damp
affecting the buildings
and the drainage
system could not
handle the storm
water. The problem of annual flooding from an overwhelmed
sewage system also led to further problems for residents, with
disruption and damage to cars and private property. The estate
continued to suffer a spiral of decline as more people moved
out, flats remained unoccupied and the remaining residents
became marginalised with a high level of unemployment storm
water system has gone through a major change. Augustenborg
now is a model of sustainability with excellent initiatives
around Green Roofs and water harvesting with open storm
water channels leading into ponds have stopped the flooding in
the area and have created a beautiful environment and a richer
biodiversity. There are a total of 6km canals and water channels
in Augustenborg. 90 % of the storm water from roofs and hard
surfaces is led into the open storm-water system in the housing
area. The aim the project was that 70 % of all storm-water
should be captured for the whole of Augustenborg.
As well as Green Roofs and sustainable drainage systems there
is also solar hot water systems and geo thermal heating
systems in place. The Neighbourhood is very attractive now
with any available accommodation quickly being taken. I was
told by one of the housing managers that there can be as many
as 300 people wanting each property as they become available
Barnistan Project, Malmo, Sweden
Close to Augustenberg is one of the most notorious
Neighbourhoods in Sweden with at its centre the Sevedsplan
square. In the past this was a high crime area with lots of drug
related crime and conflict in the Neighbourhood between the
Somalian community and the established Swedish community.
Much work has
been done to try
and improve
social cohesion in
this area and the
most inspiring
project that I saw
was Barnistan,
This is a Somalian
funded project
which aims to
bring greater
understanding
between the
different groups
of residents
through small
scale Horticultural projects such as fruit and vegetable growing,
establishing a community centre and café and public art. The
idea is to increase understanding between the young Somalian
children and youths and the ageing Swedish residents who have
the Horticultural skills, by growing fruit that the Somalian
children can recognise. To create planting areas they have taken
up sections of pavement as well as creating raised beds and
containers out of weld mesh. This project has had a positive
effect on crime in the area, and the community has held events
which have further improved understanding and respect
between all sections of the community.
Social Housing Green Space in Europe | Noel Murphy 20096 Noel Murphy 2009 | Social Housing Green Space in Europe 7
Tingbjerg, Denmark
Tingjberg is a large Housing Project designed and built from
1950 – 1972 by the famous Danish Architect Steen Eiler
Rasmussen it is located 6km North West of Copenhagen
Denmark. The area is isolated from the rest of Copenhagen with
the road leading to Tingbjerg being essentially a dead end. It
does have many Green areas and is surrounded by the
Vestvolden and Uttersley Mose which are large Green Spaces.
The residents are a mixture of Danes and immigrants with
6,500 inhabitants 42% are Danes, 37% are immigrants and
21% are Danes with immigrant parents. The area has just
undergone major improvement works both to the properties
and the Green Spaces and public realm. The improvements to
the Green Spaces are characterised by very high quality street
furniture and hard landscaping materials, natural play provision
and public artwork.
Berlin
I was particularly interested in the six Housing Estates in the
suburbs of Berlin which are on the UNESCO world heritage list.
These Estates were constructed in the 1920s and are still
vibrant and vital and attractive places to live. In the UK we are
demolishing estates that we have built in the 1960s and even
more recently than this, we have estates that we have built and
then had to demolish without anyone ever living in some of the
properties, due to bad planning and social problems. This cannot
be allowed to happen, and is a terrible waste of resources and
the worst example of unsustainable practice.
Berlin Modernism Housing Estates. consist of six housing
estates that testify to innovative housing policies from 1910 to
1933, especially during the Weimar Republic, when the city of
Berlin was particularly progressive socially, politically and
culturally. The property is an outstanding example of the
building reform movement that contributed to improving
housing and living conditions for people with low incomes
through novel approaches to town planning, architecture and
garden design. The estates also provide exceptional examples of
new urban and architectural typologies, featuring fresh design
solutions, as well as technical and aesthetic innovations. Bruno
Taut, Martin Wagner and Walter Gropius were among the
leading architects of these projects which exercised considerable
influence on the development of housing around the world.
These housing estates in the Berlin Modern Style provide
outstanding testimony to the implementation of housing
policies during the period 1910 – 1933 and especially during
the Weimar Republic,
when the city of Berlin
was characterised by its
political, social, cultural
and technical
progressiveness.
The housing estates
reflect, with the highest
degree of quality, the
combination of
urbanism, architecture,
garden design and
aesthetic research
typical of early 20th
century modernism, as well as the application of new hygienic
and social standards. Some of the most prominent leading
architects of German modernism were involved in the design
and construction of the properties; they developed innovative
urban, building and flat typologies, technical solutions and
aesthetic achievements.
The six Berlin housing estates provide an outstanding expression
of a broad housing reform movement that made a decisive
Freiburg,Vauban, Germany
Freiburg is a suburb of Vauban in the South West of Germany, it
is a new Neighbourhood created on the site of a former military
base, the Neighbourhood has been completed over the last 10
years and houses around 5,000 people. From the planning
stages the idea was to create a truly sustainable development
based around public transport and energy conservation.
The citizens were actively encouraged to partake in the design
process and the developers were encouraged to adopt an
ecological approach and the planning process allowed for
learning while developing so that new ideas and proposals could
be incorporated as the project developed. The first thing that
strikes you when you visit Vauban is the absence of cars, there
are excellent public transport networks with the tram running
through the Neighbourhood with trams into the town every 10
minutes. Car ownership was also discouraged by making it
prohibitively expensive to purchase a parking space in one of
the public car parks
costing around 40,000
euro. Car sharing is
encouraged and free
public transport is
available to those who
participate in the car
sharing scheme. There
are some car parking
spaces within the estate
but these have been
designed so as to
minimise the sight and
presence of cars. This all
contributes to the
Green feel of the estate
with excellent use of
plants particularly
climbers up the built
structures. There are
also larger Green Spaces
and Green Corridors
running through the
estate with play facilities and climbing walls as well as facilities
for very young children. There is a vibrant shopping area and
well equipped cycle repair shop centred in the Neighbourhood.
Vauban is an excellent example of a new development that is
based upon a sustainable model with a great deal of resident
participation. Strong leadership and vision have also been a vital
element to producing this exemplar development.
Social Housing Green Space in Europe | Noel Murphy 20098 Noel Murphy 2009 | Social Housing Green Space in Europe 9
Berlin (continued...) Aalborg, Denmark, City project
Malakoff, Nantes, France
contribution to
improving housing
and living conditions
in Berlin. Their quality
of urban, architectural
and garden design, as
well as the housing
standards developed
during the period,
served as guidelines
for social housing
constructed since
then, both in and
outside Germany.
The six Berlin housing estates are exceptional examples of new
urban and architectural typologies, designed in the search for
improved social living conditions. Fresh design solutions and
technical and aesthetic innovations were incorporated by the
leading modern architects who participated in their design and
construction. The six properties were selected out of the
ensemble of housing estates of the period existing in the city,
on the basis of their historical, architectural, artistic and social
significance and the fact that, due to their location, they
suffered little damage during World War II. Even though minor
reconstruction and interior changes were carried out in the post
war period, restoration works within the framework of the
protection law of 1975 and their current state of conservation
achieve a high standard of integrity and authenticity.
Adequate protection is ensured by the legislation in place,
especially by the Berlin Law on the Preservation of Historic
Places and Monuments (1995). The properties, buildings and
open spaces, are in a good state of conservation. The blocks are
typically arranged around a Green centre which in some cases
has been turned into allotment gardens for the residents which
were attractive to look down on and were obviously well
tended by the residents.
Social Housing Green Space in Europe | Noel Murphy 200910
Aalborg East was planned and developed in the mid-1960s as a
greenfield development some 6-8 kilometers to the southeast
of the Aalborg city centre. The area was planned in the
modernist tradition with separate zones for social housing,
detached housing, shopping, services, sports and recreation, and
industry, separated by extensive green areas.
The dominant housing type in Aalborg East is two-storey social
housing blocks, which in combination with atrium houses make
up two thirds of the area's present day housing. The rest of the
housing stock is detached housing and low rise-high density
student housing.
As a 60s development, Aalborg East has a highly segregated
traffic system with a hierarchy of roads from arteries to housing
lanes and bicycle and footpaths which cross the roads at split-
level. While the major roads constitute barriers between the
different zones of development, the paths constitute the only
direct connections between them. While the majority of the
workplaces in Aalborg East are light industrial and
administrative, there is only very little commerce and services
and the area has no distinct commercial or shopping area. Most
of the people working in Aalborg East live outside the area. The
15.000 inhabitants of Aalborg East therefore have to go outside
of the area for working and shopping.
Aalborg East contains three primary schools, 15 kindergartens, a
number of youth clubs and sports facilities, a public library, a
cultural facility, and a number of community buildings. There is
a number of social facilities, such as a retirement home,
serviced homes for the elderly, and daycare facilites for the
mentally ill. South of the area lies the Aalborg University main
campus.
Demographically, the child and youth population of Aalborg East
is above the average of the Municipality of Aalborg, and so is
the number of single parent households. It also has a highly
culturally mixed population with many immigrant residents,
including refugees, particularly from Somalia, who make up 7-
8% of the residents.
The suburb of Malakoff is directly adjacent to the city centre of
Nantes but has suffered from effectively being cut off from the
rest of the city by the river, the high speed TGV, line and a main
road. This has led to the area becoming disconnected from the
main City and the general decline of the area as it became an
undesirable place to live and increasingly ghettoised. The area is
now undergoing a complete re modelling both of the 6,500
mostly high rise properties and also the Landscaping of the
entire estate, the planners and designers have ensured that
there is a significant amount of Green Space in and around the
development and through extensive consultation with the
residents have designed an appropriate landscape that caters for
all sections of the community. Including areas for active play
and passive recreation. The designers have specified large
specimen planting which gives structure and maturity to the
new Landscape, although costly there is less risk of damage
from vandalism and the planting has an instant impact.
Noel Murphy 2009 | Social Housing Green Space in Europe 11
Le Plessis Robinson, France
Le Plessis Robinson is a suburb about 6 km South West of Paris.
It has undergone a transformation over the last decade to
improve the quality of life for the residents whilst at the same
time managing resources to achieve a sustainable development
working towards carbon neutrality. The first thing that strikes
you when you visit this area is the high quality planning and
maintenance of the public realm which is truly outstanding.
The mixed tenure development caters for around 20% Social
Housing in one of the most attractive Housing environments
that it is possible to create.
There are seven parks and 50 hectares of Green Space which
gives the development a rural feel within an urban setting.
There is a theme of water running through the development
and the original wetland habitat of the area has been preserved
with stunning landscape architecture. This truly is an
inspirational development and shows what can be achieved
when the right principles are adopted and due consideration is
given to the impact that such a development can bring.
The attention to detail in the hard landscape materials used is
truly remarkable as well as the inspirational planting schemes.
The district is an attractive place to live and work and has
excellent transport links to Paris being only 20 minutes away.
There is also a vibrant commercial sector within the
neighbourhood providing jobs and attractive propositions for
businesses as the land prices are cheaper than being in Paris
itself.
This appears to be a truly sustainable development from the
drawing board up as well as being a desirable place to live both
for social housing and home owners. A lot of this is about how
the place looks and feels to walk through, and this is the
challenge for the designer and the planners to try to recreate a
similar effect in Salford or Newcastle, which we know is
possible.
Social Housing Green Space in Europe | Noel Murphy 200912
Each country and scheme had it’s own unique reason for being
special but I was able to identify some common themes which I
felt could apply to all the schemes that I visited. These were:
• Visionary and strong leadership
• Thorough and appropriate consultation
• Find the “Glue People”
• Robust design with quality materials
• Sustainability
• Innovation
• High standard of maintenance
Visionary and strong leadership has been a common factor in
the majority of the schemes I visited, from the Berlin schemes
of the 1920s to Augustenborg in Malmo there had been
resistance to the ideas behind the developments and the driving
force behind these projects whether a Local Authority, Architect
or Town Planner had to overcome considerable resistance to see
the project to fruition.
Thorough and appropriate consultation is also a key factor in
the success of these Estates. It is probably the most difficult
element of the planning process and this is why it is so often
not done well resulting in designs that are not sustainable or
owned by the community and therefore do not last much
beyond the first couple of years after completion.
One of the terms used by NIRAS Consultants in Denmark who
are experts in Green Space consultation was the term “Glue
People” these are the natural born community leaders who have
respect from the community in which they live and who are
very influential in getting the community to accept new ideas
and who “Glue” the community together. It is very important
that these people are identified in the consultation process and
that their skills are harnessed to cascade the information and
ideas down through the community.
Social Housing Estates in any country can be challenging
environments for plants and hard Landscape materials and
features, it is important that the materials specified are robust
and of the best quality if the design has a chance of survival.
Some of the newly planted schemes I visited such as
Hammerby and Malakoff had utilised large specimen plants and
trees, as well as giving instant impact they can also withstand
vandalism better than smaller specimens. The play equipment
and street furniture, benches etc was also of the highest quality
meaning that it would last longer and even though initially
more expensive would present better value for money over
time.
Sustainability had also been addressed on many of the schemes
from the green roofs and water harvesting schemes in
Augustenborg Sweden, to solar power and energy efficient
design in Freiburg as well as the many community gardening
and allotments that were present on these schemes. The Green
Spaces on these Estates provided many opportunities for
sustainable living as well as the benefits to community
cohesion that these activities also brought. In particular
community gardening and public art had been used as hooks to
engage the community and delivered many benefits over and
Lessons Learnt
Noel Murphy 2009 | Social Housing Green Space in Europe 13
When planning my itinerary and choosing the schemes that I wanted to visit I was hoping to find the magic ingredients that
make these places so special and loved by the communities that they serve, and then to be able to apply this information
through my own work to improve the Green Spaces for our residents back in the UK.
above the physical or aesthetic gains that these features or
activities had brought to these Estates.
Innovation was also a feature in the design of these schemes
right through from innovative consultation techniques to the
Universty of Aalborg and their work on GPS tracking of people
to understand how they use and move around Green Spaces. Dr.
Thomas Randrup from NIRAS associates in Copenhagen has also
developed a formula for valuing Green Spaces dependant on the
scale and experiences that an individual Green Space can bring.
As you can probably see from the photographs all of the
schemes I visited were maintained to very high standards,
whether this was undertaken by external Contractors or the
Housing organisations in-house workforce, or there was
evidence of residents involvement is maintenance as in
Augustenborg where the residents were offered a reduction in
their service charges if the maintained areas of the estate.
Maintenance is a very important consideration if the Estates
are kept looking their best the residents also have more respect
for their environment. Managers need to ensure that there are
sufficient budgets available to keep these areas maintained to
the highest standard and also that there has been consideration
given to future replanting and repairs to hard Landscaping.
How will I promote my findings
and how will I bring good practice
to my industry?
I am currently bringing forward a comprehensive Green Space
strategy for my organisation, Places for People. This will draw on
my experiences gained from the CABE scholarship and guide
our Green Space policy for the next ten years. I have also
become involved in the early design stages of our development
programme in influencing the design of the Green Spaces
around our new build portfolio. These are significant schemes, in
Brooklands on the outskirts of Milton Keynes we are building a
development of 2,500 units including a school and a
community centre. We also have a site in early planning stages
in Harlow which will eventually see the construction of over
20,000 properties in a mixed tenure community and I will be
involved in the planning stage as this project develops over the
next ten years.
I am keen to share the best practice that I have seen, aligned
with what I think will be the first Green Spaces strategy for a
Housing organisation that I hope will be adopted by others to
raise the standards of design and maintenance of Green Space
for a significant proportion of the UK population. The most
important factor that I think I
can bring is improved social
cohesion by involving the local
communities in this process.
Many thanks to all that assisted me with this study,
including;
Mathew Frith London Wildlife Trust
Noel Farrer Landscape Architect
Sarah Gaventa CABE space
Helen Beck CABE space
Lasse Flygare [lasse@barnistan.info]
Sille Askefrø Bjørn (SAB) [SAB@niraskon.dk]
Sille Askefrø Bjørn
chefkonsulent arkitekt maa
telefon 8732 3203
mobil 2920 7449
e-mail sab
NIRAS Konsulenterne
Åboulevarden 80
8100 Århus C
www.niraskon.dk
Camilla Richter-Friis van Deurs [Camilla.Deurs@karch.dk]
Camilla Richter-Friis van Deurs
Ph.D. studerende, arkitekt MAA
Center for Byrumsforskning
Kunstakademiets Arkitektskole
Philip de Langes Allé 10
1435 København K
Tlf.: 32 68 66 48 / 32 68 66 67
http://www.karch.dk
Åse Dannestam [Ase.Dannestam@mkbfastighet.se]
MKB Fastighets AB (publ)
Box 50405
202 14 MALMÖ
Besöksadress:
Augustenborgsgatan 3
Tel vx: 040-31 33 00
Fax: 040-31 34 80
www.mkbfastighet.se
Thomas Barfoed Randrup (TRA)
[TRA@niraskon.dk]
Petter Åkerblom [petter.akerblom@sol.slu.se]
Martin Søberg [mas@sla.dk]
Martin Søberg
Head of Communications
Art Historian Mag.Art.
Arne Juul (AJU)
[AJU@niraskon.dk]
Oord C.V. van der
[C.vanderOord@dro.amsterdam.nl]
Haan (PVB), Joop de
[HaanJde@zuidoost.amsterdam.nl]
F.Blom@wonen.amsterdam.nl
Morten Weeke Borup [mwb@ghb-landskab.dk]
Morten Weeke Borup
Arkitekt MAA
Partner
GHB Landskabsarkitekter a/s
Frederiksholms Kanal 18 A
1220 København K
Tlf.: +45 33123738
juliane [juliane.bailly@gmail.com]
Simon @ Supersonic Travel London
Experiences from GPS tracking of visitors in three Public
Parks in Denmark based on GPS technologies
Paper presented at the International workshop SPM2008 in
Tartu, Estonia
http://www.ut.ee/spm2008
Lessons Learnt (continued...) References and Acknowledgements
Social Housing Green Space in Europe | Noel Murphy 200914 Noel Murphy 2009 | Social Housing Green Space in Europe 15

More Related Content

What's hot

Plotted housing aniruddh jain 2.5
Plotted housing aniruddh jain 2.5Plotted housing aniruddh jain 2.5
Plotted housing aniruddh jain 2.5Aniruddh Jain
 
Radburn city, vikas rathore
Radburn city, vikas rathoreRadburn city, vikas rathore
Radburn city, vikas rathoreVikas Rathore
 
Bulfinch east cambridge courthouse 06 22-12
Bulfinch   east cambridge courthouse 06 22-12Bulfinch   east cambridge courthouse 06 22-12
Bulfinch east cambridge courthouse 06 22-12ecafasso
 
Kathputli colony slum development
Kathputli colony slum developmentKathputli colony slum development
Kathputli colony slum developmentM.I.T.,AURANGABAD
 
Sustainable City - Brochure
Sustainable City - BrochureSustainable City - Brochure
Sustainable City - BrochureProvident Estate
 
Clarence perry faheem atif
Clarence perry faheem  atifClarence perry faheem  atif
Clarence perry faheem atifMariyam Zakiah
 
Final Year Project
Final Year ProjectFinal Year Project
Final Year ProjectK B
 
Villa verde housing 2013 constitución by shubham harlalka.docx
Villa verde housing 2013 constitución by shubham harlalka.docxVilla verde housing 2013 constitución by shubham harlalka.docx
Villa verde housing 2013 constitución by shubham harlalka.docxshubham harlalka
 
Community Architecture
Community ArchitectureCommunity Architecture
Community ArchitectureMark Ollis
 
I concept design presentation - expooilgas
I concept design presentation - expooilgasI concept design presentation - expooilgas
I concept design presentation - expooilgaspegasgroupfzc
 
Cabe Design Council - Estate of the Nation by Alison Brooks
 Cabe Design Council -  Estate of the Nation by Alison Brooks Cabe Design Council -  Estate of the Nation by Alison Brooks
Cabe Design Council - Estate of the Nation by Alison BrooksDesign Council
 
Orange Avenue Overlay Final Report
Orange Avenue Overlay Final ReportOrange Avenue Overlay Final Report
Orange Avenue Overlay Final ReportBrendan O'Connor
 
The Destruction and Reconstruction of a City Street: The Cork Street Corridor
The Destruction and Reconstruction of a City Street: The Cork Street CorridorThe Destruction and Reconstruction of a City Street: The Cork Street Corridor
The Destruction and Reconstruction of a City Street: The Cork Street Corridorkieran rose
 
Sensitive Retrofit of Traditional Heritage Buildings, Bath Preservation Trust...
Sensitive Retrofit of Traditional Heritage Buildings, Bath Preservation Trust...Sensitive Retrofit of Traditional Heritage Buildings, Bath Preservation Trust...
Sensitive Retrofit of Traditional Heritage Buildings, Bath Preservation Trust...The Future Economy Network
 
Ideas for Eleanor Park Site
Ideas for Eleanor Park SiteIdeas for Eleanor Park Site
Ideas for Eleanor Park SiteGary Mitchell
 
Histon & Impington Neighbourhood Plan
Histon & Impington Neighbourhood PlanHiston & Impington Neighbourhood Plan
Histon & Impington Neighbourhood Planhisimp
 

What's hot (20)

Radburn city planning
Radburn city planningRadburn city planning
Radburn city planning
 
Plotted housing aniruddh jain 2.5
Plotted housing aniruddh jain 2.5Plotted housing aniruddh jain 2.5
Plotted housing aniruddh jain 2.5
 
Radburn city, vikas rathore
Radburn city, vikas rathoreRadburn city, vikas rathore
Radburn city, vikas rathore
 
Radburn City
Radburn CityRadburn City
Radburn City
 
Bulfinch east cambridge courthouse 06 22-12
Bulfinch   east cambridge courthouse 06 22-12Bulfinch   east cambridge courthouse 06 22-12
Bulfinch east cambridge courthouse 06 22-12
 
Radburn
RadburnRadburn
Radburn
 
Kathputli colony slum development
Kathputli colony slum developmentKathputli colony slum development
Kathputli colony slum development
 
Reinventing cities,
Reinventing cities,Reinventing cities,
Reinventing cities,
 
Sustainable City - Brochure
Sustainable City - BrochureSustainable City - Brochure
Sustainable City - Brochure
 
Clarence perry faheem atif
Clarence perry faheem  atifClarence perry faheem  atif
Clarence perry faheem atif
 
Final Year Project
Final Year ProjectFinal Year Project
Final Year Project
 
Villa verde housing 2013 constitución by shubham harlalka.docx
Villa verde housing 2013 constitución by shubham harlalka.docxVilla verde housing 2013 constitución by shubham harlalka.docx
Villa verde housing 2013 constitución by shubham harlalka.docx
 
Community Architecture
Community ArchitectureCommunity Architecture
Community Architecture
 
I concept design presentation - expooilgas
I concept design presentation - expooilgasI concept design presentation - expooilgas
I concept design presentation - expooilgas
 
Cabe Design Council - Estate of the Nation by Alison Brooks
 Cabe Design Council -  Estate of the Nation by Alison Brooks Cabe Design Council -  Estate of the Nation by Alison Brooks
Cabe Design Council - Estate of the Nation by Alison Brooks
 
Orange Avenue Overlay Final Report
Orange Avenue Overlay Final ReportOrange Avenue Overlay Final Report
Orange Avenue Overlay Final Report
 
The Destruction and Reconstruction of a City Street: The Cork Street Corridor
The Destruction and Reconstruction of a City Street: The Cork Street CorridorThe Destruction and Reconstruction of a City Street: The Cork Street Corridor
The Destruction and Reconstruction of a City Street: The Cork Street Corridor
 
Sensitive Retrofit of Traditional Heritage Buildings, Bath Preservation Trust...
Sensitive Retrofit of Traditional Heritage Buildings, Bath Preservation Trust...Sensitive Retrofit of Traditional Heritage Buildings, Bath Preservation Trust...
Sensitive Retrofit of Traditional Heritage Buildings, Bath Preservation Trust...
 
Ideas for Eleanor Park Site
Ideas for Eleanor Park SiteIdeas for Eleanor Park Site
Ideas for Eleanor Park Site
 
Histon & Impington Neighbourhood Plan
Histon & Impington Neighbourhood PlanHiston & Impington Neighbourhood Plan
Histon & Impington Neighbourhood Plan
 

Similar to Cabe Report

Ici final project
Ici final projectIci final project
Ici final projectdeantkc
 
Birchgrove properties + bendigo cc  maca homes for change  outside the squa...
Birchgrove properties + bendigo cc  maca homes for change  outside the squa...Birchgrove properties + bendigo cc  maca homes for change  outside the squa...
Birchgrove properties + bendigo cc  maca homes for change  outside the squa...Makeachangeaustralia
 
Urban Design Portfolio Tim Hays
Urban Design Portfolio Tim HaysUrban Design Portfolio Tim Hays
Urban Design Portfolio Tim HaysTim Hays
 
London's Green Spaces. Pocket Parks: The Design Challenge.
London's Green Spaces. Pocket Parks: The Design Challenge.London's Green Spaces. Pocket Parks: The Design Challenge.
London's Green Spaces. Pocket Parks: The Design Challenge.marcusshields
 
Wellesley application summary brochure
Wellesley application summary brochureWellesley application summary brochure
Wellesley application summary brochureKurt Mueller
 
Wellesley Application Summary Brochure
Wellesley Application Summary BrochureWellesley Application Summary Brochure
Wellesley Application Summary BrochureKurt Mueller
 
buttress masterplanning lr
buttress masterplanning lrbuttress masterplanning lr
buttress masterplanning lrGavin Sorby
 
James Carr Design Portfolio
James Carr Design PortfolioJames Carr Design Portfolio
James Carr Design PortfolioJames Carr
 
Sustainable Urban Neighbourhoods- Nick Falk, URBED
Sustainable Urban Neighbourhoods- Nick Falk, URBEDSustainable Urban Neighbourhoods- Nick Falk, URBED
Sustainable Urban Neighbourhoods- Nick Falk, URBEDDesign South East
 
Manifesto for better public spaces
Manifesto for better public spacesManifesto for better public spaces
Manifesto for better public spacesThành Nguyễn
 
Rekreators brochure
Rekreators brochureRekreators brochure
Rekreators brochureStipo
 
Portfolio_CLilyBenoit
Portfolio_CLilyBenoitPortfolio_CLilyBenoit
Portfolio_CLilyBenoitC Lily Benoit
 
Strategic plan poster final
Strategic plan poster finalStrategic plan poster final
Strategic plan poster finalVanessa Baratta
 
Sapa Building System: Reference book volume 2
Sapa Building System: Reference book volume 2Sapa Building System: Reference book volume 2
Sapa Building System: Reference book volume 2Architectura
 
Enbe final project
Enbe final project Enbe final project
Enbe final project czlun
 

Similar to Cabe Report (20)

SIRIUS HALL 2012-2020
SIRIUS HALL 2012-2020 SIRIUS HALL 2012-2020
SIRIUS HALL 2012-2020
 
Ici final project
Ici final projectIci final project
Ici final project
 
Birchgrove properties + bendigo cc  maca homes for change  outside the squa...
Birchgrove properties + bendigo cc  maca homes for change  outside the squa...Birchgrove properties + bendigo cc  maca homes for change  outside the squa...
Birchgrove properties + bendigo cc  maca homes for change  outside the squa...
 
Urban Design Portfolio Tim Hays
Urban Design Portfolio Tim HaysUrban Design Portfolio Tim Hays
Urban Design Portfolio Tim Hays
 
London's Green Spaces. Pocket Parks: The Design Challenge.
London's Green Spaces. Pocket Parks: The Design Challenge.London's Green Spaces. Pocket Parks: The Design Challenge.
London's Green Spaces. Pocket Parks: The Design Challenge.
 
Wellesley application summary brochure
Wellesley application summary brochureWellesley application summary brochure
Wellesley application summary brochure
 
Wellesley Application Summary Brochure
Wellesley Application Summary BrochureWellesley Application Summary Brochure
Wellesley Application Summary Brochure
 
Portfolio 2020
Portfolio 2020Portfolio 2020
Portfolio 2020
 
buttress masterplanning lr
buttress masterplanning lrbuttress masterplanning lr
buttress masterplanning lr
 
James Carr Design Portfolio
James Carr Design PortfolioJames Carr Design Portfolio
James Carr Design Portfolio
 
Garden City.pptx
Garden City.pptxGarden City.pptx
Garden City.pptx
 
Sustainable Urban Neighbourhoods- Nick Falk, URBED
Sustainable Urban Neighbourhoods- Nick Falk, URBEDSustainable Urban Neighbourhoods- Nick Falk, URBED
Sustainable Urban Neighbourhoods- Nick Falk, URBED
 
Manifesto for better public spaces
Manifesto for better public spacesManifesto for better public spaces
Manifesto for better public spaces
 
Rekreators brochure
Rekreators brochureRekreators brochure
Rekreators brochure
 
Portfolio_CLilyBenoit
Portfolio_CLilyBenoitPortfolio_CLilyBenoit
Portfolio_CLilyBenoit
 
Strategic plan poster final
Strategic plan poster finalStrategic plan poster final
Strategic plan poster final
 
Sapa Building System: Reference book volume 2
Sapa Building System: Reference book volume 2Sapa Building System: Reference book volume 2
Sapa Building System: Reference book volume 2
 
Enbe final project
Enbe final project Enbe final project
Enbe final project
 
Barley Portfolio small
Barley Portfolio smallBarley Portfolio small
Barley Portfolio small
 
Creating Residential Communities
Creating Residential CommunitiesCreating Residential Communities
Creating Residential Communities
 

Cabe Report

  • 1. Social Housing Green Space in Europe A CABE Space Design Skills Scholarship “Turning Mean Streets into Green Streets” Noel Murphy 2009 Vauban Freiberg Germany Hammarby Stockholm CABE 1 Kemble Street London WC2B 4AN Tel: 020 7070 6700 Fax: 020 7070 6777 Email: info@cabe.org.uk
  • 2. Social Housing Green Space in Europe | Noel Murphy 20092 Noel Murphy 2009 | Social Housing Green Space in Europe 3 Social Housing landlords in the UK now own and manage large estates and this has increased significantly over the last decade as stock transfers and the creation of ALMOs has taken the Housing stock away from Local Authorities and there is a vast amount of Green Space within these Neighbourhoods which is not particularly well designed or maintained and does not meet the needs of the communities who we expect to live there. My own organisation Places for People Group has over 60,000 social rented properties from Edinburgh to the Isle of White in over 200 local authority areas. We have as much Green Space as a medium sized town or local authority area, and if we can improve the quality of this Green Space and engage the residents at the same time we will have a much better chance of creating sustainable communities with improved Social Cohesion. The Green Spaces in these neighbourhoods give us the opportunity for recreation whether passive or active, this is where people meet and get to know each other. Social housing in Europe accounts for around 15 Million units of the available housing (see table below). Social Housing as a percentage of the housing stock ranges from a high of 35% in the Netherlands to 6% in Germany. There is no single definition of Social Housing across Europe. Also the profile of Social Housing stock differs from countries in terms of age, type of housing and the percentage located on Estates. Providers and funders also vary from country to country as do the type of residents from the very poor to the low paid and middle classes in general the social sector tends to house either the elderly, the poor and a disproportionate number of single parent households. Project Overview Background to Social Housing in Europe Housing Tenure and Size of Sector by Country Social Housing in the UK houses approximately one fifth of the countries inhabitants with some 9 million people living in around 4 Million homes. Very often the Green Spaces in and around these homes are poorly designed and maintained leading to a lack of ownership and usage by the residents. Good design is a key factor in the success of the Landscape of our Neighbourhoods. Too often the Landscaping has been designed without input from the people who are expected to live in these environments and the budgets are vulnerable to being cut as the cost for the building works inevitably overruns. Therefore we are left with inappropriate designs delivered with inadequate budgets, quite often not very well maintained and with no additional funds for improvements or replacement over time. It is not surprising then that Social Housing Neighbourhoods in the UK have some of the poorest quality environments and this contributes to vandalism, anti social behaviour and a general lack of respect for the environment and each other. The Bijlmermeer is an area in the South East district Zuidoost of Amsterdam; The Zuidoost comprises four areas, Gaasperdam, the Bijlmermeer, Driemond and Kantorenpark. The Zuidoost has a population of approximately 80,000 and provides employment for around 50,000 people. The Bijlmermeer was my main area of interest and comprised 9 neighbourhoods in total, 3 low rise, 3 medium rise and three high rise gallery flat blocks. The original layout for the high-rise blocks was an Architects utopian dream and was constructed from 1966 to 1975 and was laid out in Le Corbusier, style designed around the segregation of functions, so that residential, business and traffic and recreation were separated. There are around 12,500 social housing units in 11 storey apartments. The apartments were spacious and there were interior walkways and also rooms with communal facilities. They were constructed in park like surroundings with 80% of the land given over to landscaped green space, separate from cars and traffic. The blocks had a hexagonal honeycomb pattern and the surrounded landscape provided play areas and cycle tracks in a traffic free environment. Residents could park their cars in car parks accessed by elevated roadways then walk home under cover. Shopping centres and social facilities were also part of the design although these took some time to follow on after the residential construction. Originally there was a waiting list of people wanting to move to the Bijlmermeer due to chronic housing shortages within Amsterdam. Straight away there were problems with security, the interior walkways and the public open space were considered unsafe, and the lifts and the waste disposal system did not work properly. Crime rates of drug dealing and robbery Social Housing Green Space in the UK I decided to visit the European countries with the largest stock of Social Housing as identified on the table (below left), I met with a range of stakeholders from senior Town Planning Officers to retired residents, Project Workers and Consultants. My aim was to try to see what lessons could be learnt from successful Neighbourhoods in terms of the design and management of their Green Spaces that we could then apply back in the UK. My Starting point was the Netherlands where I visited three diverse areas, ljborg,Western Garden City and Bijlmermeer.Whilst my purpose was to concentrate on the Green Spaces I was also considering the context of these spaces in relation to the building Architecture, transport links and different social issues that I found to be inherently linked together and I have commented on these also. Study Tour Bijlmermeer, Amsterdam The aim of this study was to bring together good practice in Social Housing Green Space from across Europe to see what lessons could be learned and good practice identified so that we can apply what works to our own Neighbourhoods in the UK. Netherlands 54 11 35 2,400,000 Denmark 52 17 21 530,000 Sweden 59 21 20 780,000 England 70 11 19 3,983,000 France 56 20 17 4,230,000 Germany 46 49 6 1,800,000 Owner Occupied % Private Rented % Social Rented % Number of Social Units
  • 3. Sonder Boulevard in Copenhagen runs for over a kilometre through the city quarter of Vesterbro. This is a dense urban area with little if any Green Space around the high density Housing. It is in situations like this that areas of public open space are very important to the communities that live beside them as they offer the opportunity for recreation outdoors that is so vital to health and well being. The Boulevard has recently been redeveloped to provide a variety of experiences for the community living adjacent to it and those who travel along it. From wildflower and seating areas to ball courts and play facilities the redesigned Boulevard caters for all age groups and sections of the community. Those who live in the apartments close to the Boulevard that have no communal Green Space use the Boulevard as their garden Through a comprehensive community participation process the residents of the area have had the opportunity to place their ideas on the urban space in the form of basket ball courts, seating areas, walks and small peaceful gardens. The residents have determined which activities and uses should be incorporated. This has created inclusive spaces for everyone and amenity values for the whole area. Sonder Boulevard in Copenhagen now directs the traffic in a calmer fashion with reduced speed and widening of the linear recreational space down the centre of the boulevard. A simple arrangement of the space with rows of different tree species along the entire boulevard provides variation, but also allows future uses to be incorporated in the plan. The trees are chosen so they flower, spring into leaf and drop their foliage at different times. Thus the boulevard is always experienced in different ways, and draws the beauty of nature right into the inner city. were high and the neighbourhood spiralled into decline with up to one in four flats unoccupied. Various attempts to improve the situation were attempted and in 1992 a wholesale renovation commenced, this meant demolishing some of the high rise blocks and replacing them with low rise accommodation, renovating some of the high rise blocks, removing the internal walkways, putting the lifts on the outside of the structure, lowering the elevated roads and closing and demolishing some of the car parks. The Green Spaces were originally laid out in the English Landscape Parkland style and accounted for 80% of the land. In certain areas this ratio will stay but in others where the old high-rise blocks have been pulled down this will reduce to 40% of available land so that cars can then be parked in front of homes. Most of the Bijlmerpark approximately 40 hectares is being redeveloped into an urban park with sports facilities, with the remainder being designed as a natural park, some 800 homes are also being constructed around the parks boundary. The redevelopment of the open spaces includes a clear Green Belt area, which is easy to maintain, and where people feel safe, it will also include more private areas for single-family homes. Trees and shrubs have been removed to increase security, create space for play and parking facilities, and the replanting of specimen groups of trees and shrubs. When the original design was conceived there was no provision made for places of worship, so the residents who came to live there made their own, either in the Green Spaces or the car parks. Nine of the twenty-one car parks have now been demolished, and most of the new parking places will be on the streets. There is a strong presence of public art in evidence in the Bijlmermeer, which appears to be well received by the residents and has not been vandalised. Also it is the site of the memorial garden for the people who lost their lives in the early nineties when a cargo plane crashed into one of the high-rise honeycomb blocks. The final death toll has never been known due to the high number of illegal immigrants inhabiting these blocks at the time. There has been a memorial garden created for the people who lost their lives in that accident and this is well maintained and respected by the residents. The footprint of the honeycomb block that was hit by the plane also remains as a memorial. Charlotte Garden is a housing complex comprising around 200 units adjacent to Nordhavn Station in a suburb of Copenhagen. Residents and people who live in the local area use the garden, as a meeting place, and to bring their families to use the play facilities. The design of this space is quite stunning and the impact is striking particularly when you consider it is based on a dune style of landscape planted mostly with grass species, the idea behind the design is to reflect the proximity of the sea and to create movement through the planting and the contours of the design. It has the sensation of a large outdoor room, when viewed from one of the surrounding apartment windows the landscape is constantly changing and unusually for gardens this far North there is also year round colour as the grasses change from blue and green to more golden tones. The quality of materials used in the construction is impressive with steel up stands used to form the elaborate curves that are a key feature of the garden. The different and changing spaces are held together by a series of paths crossing the garden, whilst the different elements of the garden are accentuated by a change in materials. The garden was constructed in 2004 at a cost of 1.1 million Euros. The garden has become a place and an outdoor room loved by the surrounding community. Bijlmermeer, Amsterdam (continued) Western Garden City, Amsterdam Charlotte Garden, Copenhagen Denmark Social Housing Green Space in Europe | Noel Murphy 20094 In the west of Amsterdam 130.000 people live in 54.000 dwellings. 10.000 Of these dwellings will be torn down in the following years. Taking until 2015 17,500 new dwellings will be built instead. Within this city transformation are a number of innovative housing projects, which attempt to develop a contemporary image of the garden city. The Western Garden Suburbs are characterised by broad avenues, waterways, open space, and dwellings in green surroundings. Tall blocks of flats, dwellings with shared entrance halls and stairways, and houses with gardens predominate. Open building blocks are a common feature. Despite the idyllic layout, the garden suburbs no longer meet current Housing standards. The district is currently undergoing a large-scale restructuring. The task is sizeable, a quarter of the existing stock of 41,000 rental dwellings will be demolished and replaced by privately owned homes. In addition, 11,000 dwellings will be built. Social and economic renewal will lead to new programmes, and improving public space is a priority. An urban- rather than garden-suburb character has been opted for. Noel Murphy 2009 | Social Housing Green Space in Europe 5 Sonder Boulevard, Copenhagen Denmark
  • 4. Hammarby Sjostad, Stockholm, Sweden Augustenborg, Malmo, Sweden Hammarby is a city district of Stockholm set around a lake in the South of the city, eventually up to 20,000 people will live there as it is currently under construction and should be completed around the middle of the next decade. Hammarby is a truly inspirational place which has brought together the best in design and sustainable development. The design of the district places a strong emphasis on the environment and sustainability. Throughout the development runs a network of small parks and Green Spaces. Use of native species like birch and oak trees along the lake side give structure to this newly developed site. The whole development has been designed along principles of working in harmony with nature alongside the contemporary architecture of the buildings. There is a strong green infrastructure permeating throughout the district where it is possible to walk through large sections of the estate without coming into contact with traffic.. It is a mixed tenure development which is aiming for a 50 - 50 split between owned and rented properties. The district is characterised by a sense of being close to nature due to the lake and the large amount of Green infrastructure, and around each different block the landscape provided a different experience, whether this was play, allotment gardening or areas for quiet relaxation, all interests appeared to be catered for. There is a high number of allotment gardens within the blocks and these all appeared to be in cultivation and well maintained, this was in contrast with the contemporary architecture but at the same time did not appear out of place, . I visited the district on late midsummer afternoon 2009 which is a time of year that Scandinavian countries particularly celebrate. There where families picnicking and barbequing in the Green Spaces and a real sense of family celebration. A number of schemes that I visited across Europe catered for impromptu celebrations and events by having communal facilities within the Green Spaces, such as barbeques, large tables and seating, table tennis tables and this feature must help to encourage people out of doors to partake in parties and gatherings and help with social cohesion. Public art again was very much in evidence throughout the district which was again another feature in many of the Green Spaces. Reading the background to the planning and development of the district the local authority have been very much the driving force that have shaped the development with strong leadership aligned to sustainable design principles, again this is a common factor across the successful European housing schemes that I have seen. Augustenborg is district of the city of Malmo in Sweden. There are currently around 1800 properties there owned and managed by MKB Housing Association. It was originally built in the 1950s and in the beginning it was a successful mixture of housing, employment and social facilities. However in the 1970s the 32-hectare neighbourhood was failing. There were problems with damp affecting the buildings and the drainage system could not handle the storm water. The problem of annual flooding from an overwhelmed sewage system also led to further problems for residents, with disruption and damage to cars and private property. The estate continued to suffer a spiral of decline as more people moved out, flats remained unoccupied and the remaining residents became marginalised with a high level of unemployment storm water system has gone through a major change. Augustenborg now is a model of sustainability with excellent initiatives around Green Roofs and water harvesting with open storm water channels leading into ponds have stopped the flooding in the area and have created a beautiful environment and a richer biodiversity. There are a total of 6km canals and water channels in Augustenborg. 90 % of the storm water from roofs and hard surfaces is led into the open storm-water system in the housing area. The aim the project was that 70 % of all storm-water should be captured for the whole of Augustenborg. As well as Green Roofs and sustainable drainage systems there is also solar hot water systems and geo thermal heating systems in place. The Neighbourhood is very attractive now with any available accommodation quickly being taken. I was told by one of the housing managers that there can be as many as 300 people wanting each property as they become available Barnistan Project, Malmo, Sweden Close to Augustenberg is one of the most notorious Neighbourhoods in Sweden with at its centre the Sevedsplan square. In the past this was a high crime area with lots of drug related crime and conflict in the Neighbourhood between the Somalian community and the established Swedish community. Much work has been done to try and improve social cohesion in this area and the most inspiring project that I saw was Barnistan, This is a Somalian funded project which aims to bring greater understanding between the different groups of residents through small scale Horticultural projects such as fruit and vegetable growing, establishing a community centre and café and public art. The idea is to increase understanding between the young Somalian children and youths and the ageing Swedish residents who have the Horticultural skills, by growing fruit that the Somalian children can recognise. To create planting areas they have taken up sections of pavement as well as creating raised beds and containers out of weld mesh. This project has had a positive effect on crime in the area, and the community has held events which have further improved understanding and respect between all sections of the community. Social Housing Green Space in Europe | Noel Murphy 20096 Noel Murphy 2009 | Social Housing Green Space in Europe 7
  • 5. Tingbjerg, Denmark Tingjberg is a large Housing Project designed and built from 1950 – 1972 by the famous Danish Architect Steen Eiler Rasmussen it is located 6km North West of Copenhagen Denmark. The area is isolated from the rest of Copenhagen with the road leading to Tingbjerg being essentially a dead end. It does have many Green areas and is surrounded by the Vestvolden and Uttersley Mose which are large Green Spaces. The residents are a mixture of Danes and immigrants with 6,500 inhabitants 42% are Danes, 37% are immigrants and 21% are Danes with immigrant parents. The area has just undergone major improvement works both to the properties and the Green Spaces and public realm. The improvements to the Green Spaces are characterised by very high quality street furniture and hard landscaping materials, natural play provision and public artwork. Berlin I was particularly interested in the six Housing Estates in the suburbs of Berlin which are on the UNESCO world heritage list. These Estates were constructed in the 1920s and are still vibrant and vital and attractive places to live. In the UK we are demolishing estates that we have built in the 1960s and even more recently than this, we have estates that we have built and then had to demolish without anyone ever living in some of the properties, due to bad planning and social problems. This cannot be allowed to happen, and is a terrible waste of resources and the worst example of unsustainable practice. Berlin Modernism Housing Estates. consist of six housing estates that testify to innovative housing policies from 1910 to 1933, especially during the Weimar Republic, when the city of Berlin was particularly progressive socially, politically and culturally. The property is an outstanding example of the building reform movement that contributed to improving housing and living conditions for people with low incomes through novel approaches to town planning, architecture and garden design. The estates also provide exceptional examples of new urban and architectural typologies, featuring fresh design solutions, as well as technical and aesthetic innovations. Bruno Taut, Martin Wagner and Walter Gropius were among the leading architects of these projects which exercised considerable influence on the development of housing around the world. These housing estates in the Berlin Modern Style provide outstanding testimony to the implementation of housing policies during the period 1910 – 1933 and especially during the Weimar Republic, when the city of Berlin was characterised by its political, social, cultural and technical progressiveness. The housing estates reflect, with the highest degree of quality, the combination of urbanism, architecture, garden design and aesthetic research typical of early 20th century modernism, as well as the application of new hygienic and social standards. Some of the most prominent leading architects of German modernism were involved in the design and construction of the properties; they developed innovative urban, building and flat typologies, technical solutions and aesthetic achievements. The six Berlin housing estates provide an outstanding expression of a broad housing reform movement that made a decisive Freiburg,Vauban, Germany Freiburg is a suburb of Vauban in the South West of Germany, it is a new Neighbourhood created on the site of a former military base, the Neighbourhood has been completed over the last 10 years and houses around 5,000 people. From the planning stages the idea was to create a truly sustainable development based around public transport and energy conservation. The citizens were actively encouraged to partake in the design process and the developers were encouraged to adopt an ecological approach and the planning process allowed for learning while developing so that new ideas and proposals could be incorporated as the project developed. The first thing that strikes you when you visit Vauban is the absence of cars, there are excellent public transport networks with the tram running through the Neighbourhood with trams into the town every 10 minutes. Car ownership was also discouraged by making it prohibitively expensive to purchase a parking space in one of the public car parks costing around 40,000 euro. Car sharing is encouraged and free public transport is available to those who participate in the car sharing scheme. There are some car parking spaces within the estate but these have been designed so as to minimise the sight and presence of cars. This all contributes to the Green feel of the estate with excellent use of plants particularly climbers up the built structures. There are also larger Green Spaces and Green Corridors running through the estate with play facilities and climbing walls as well as facilities for very young children. There is a vibrant shopping area and well equipped cycle repair shop centred in the Neighbourhood. Vauban is an excellent example of a new development that is based upon a sustainable model with a great deal of resident participation. Strong leadership and vision have also been a vital element to producing this exemplar development. Social Housing Green Space in Europe | Noel Murphy 20098 Noel Murphy 2009 | Social Housing Green Space in Europe 9
  • 6. Berlin (continued...) Aalborg, Denmark, City project Malakoff, Nantes, France contribution to improving housing and living conditions in Berlin. Their quality of urban, architectural and garden design, as well as the housing standards developed during the period, served as guidelines for social housing constructed since then, both in and outside Germany. The six Berlin housing estates are exceptional examples of new urban and architectural typologies, designed in the search for improved social living conditions. Fresh design solutions and technical and aesthetic innovations were incorporated by the leading modern architects who participated in their design and construction. The six properties were selected out of the ensemble of housing estates of the period existing in the city, on the basis of their historical, architectural, artistic and social significance and the fact that, due to their location, they suffered little damage during World War II. Even though minor reconstruction and interior changes were carried out in the post war period, restoration works within the framework of the protection law of 1975 and their current state of conservation achieve a high standard of integrity and authenticity. Adequate protection is ensured by the legislation in place, especially by the Berlin Law on the Preservation of Historic Places and Monuments (1995). The properties, buildings and open spaces, are in a good state of conservation. The blocks are typically arranged around a Green centre which in some cases has been turned into allotment gardens for the residents which were attractive to look down on and were obviously well tended by the residents. Social Housing Green Space in Europe | Noel Murphy 200910 Aalborg East was planned and developed in the mid-1960s as a greenfield development some 6-8 kilometers to the southeast of the Aalborg city centre. The area was planned in the modernist tradition with separate zones for social housing, detached housing, shopping, services, sports and recreation, and industry, separated by extensive green areas. The dominant housing type in Aalborg East is two-storey social housing blocks, which in combination with atrium houses make up two thirds of the area's present day housing. The rest of the housing stock is detached housing and low rise-high density student housing. As a 60s development, Aalborg East has a highly segregated traffic system with a hierarchy of roads from arteries to housing lanes and bicycle and footpaths which cross the roads at split- level. While the major roads constitute barriers between the different zones of development, the paths constitute the only direct connections between them. While the majority of the workplaces in Aalborg East are light industrial and administrative, there is only very little commerce and services and the area has no distinct commercial or shopping area. Most of the people working in Aalborg East live outside the area. The 15.000 inhabitants of Aalborg East therefore have to go outside of the area for working and shopping. Aalborg East contains three primary schools, 15 kindergartens, a number of youth clubs and sports facilities, a public library, a cultural facility, and a number of community buildings. There is a number of social facilities, such as a retirement home, serviced homes for the elderly, and daycare facilites for the mentally ill. South of the area lies the Aalborg University main campus. Demographically, the child and youth population of Aalborg East is above the average of the Municipality of Aalborg, and so is the number of single parent households. It also has a highly culturally mixed population with many immigrant residents, including refugees, particularly from Somalia, who make up 7- 8% of the residents. The suburb of Malakoff is directly adjacent to the city centre of Nantes but has suffered from effectively being cut off from the rest of the city by the river, the high speed TGV, line and a main road. This has led to the area becoming disconnected from the main City and the general decline of the area as it became an undesirable place to live and increasingly ghettoised. The area is now undergoing a complete re modelling both of the 6,500 mostly high rise properties and also the Landscaping of the entire estate, the planners and designers have ensured that there is a significant amount of Green Space in and around the development and through extensive consultation with the residents have designed an appropriate landscape that caters for all sections of the community. Including areas for active play and passive recreation. The designers have specified large specimen planting which gives structure and maturity to the new Landscape, although costly there is less risk of damage from vandalism and the planting has an instant impact. Noel Murphy 2009 | Social Housing Green Space in Europe 11
  • 7. Le Plessis Robinson, France Le Plessis Robinson is a suburb about 6 km South West of Paris. It has undergone a transformation over the last decade to improve the quality of life for the residents whilst at the same time managing resources to achieve a sustainable development working towards carbon neutrality. The first thing that strikes you when you visit this area is the high quality planning and maintenance of the public realm which is truly outstanding. The mixed tenure development caters for around 20% Social Housing in one of the most attractive Housing environments that it is possible to create. There are seven parks and 50 hectares of Green Space which gives the development a rural feel within an urban setting. There is a theme of water running through the development and the original wetland habitat of the area has been preserved with stunning landscape architecture. This truly is an inspirational development and shows what can be achieved when the right principles are adopted and due consideration is given to the impact that such a development can bring. The attention to detail in the hard landscape materials used is truly remarkable as well as the inspirational planting schemes. The district is an attractive place to live and work and has excellent transport links to Paris being only 20 minutes away. There is also a vibrant commercial sector within the neighbourhood providing jobs and attractive propositions for businesses as the land prices are cheaper than being in Paris itself. This appears to be a truly sustainable development from the drawing board up as well as being a desirable place to live both for social housing and home owners. A lot of this is about how the place looks and feels to walk through, and this is the challenge for the designer and the planners to try to recreate a similar effect in Salford or Newcastle, which we know is possible. Social Housing Green Space in Europe | Noel Murphy 200912 Each country and scheme had it’s own unique reason for being special but I was able to identify some common themes which I felt could apply to all the schemes that I visited. These were: • Visionary and strong leadership • Thorough and appropriate consultation • Find the “Glue People” • Robust design with quality materials • Sustainability • Innovation • High standard of maintenance Visionary and strong leadership has been a common factor in the majority of the schemes I visited, from the Berlin schemes of the 1920s to Augustenborg in Malmo there had been resistance to the ideas behind the developments and the driving force behind these projects whether a Local Authority, Architect or Town Planner had to overcome considerable resistance to see the project to fruition. Thorough and appropriate consultation is also a key factor in the success of these Estates. It is probably the most difficult element of the planning process and this is why it is so often not done well resulting in designs that are not sustainable or owned by the community and therefore do not last much beyond the first couple of years after completion. One of the terms used by NIRAS Consultants in Denmark who are experts in Green Space consultation was the term “Glue People” these are the natural born community leaders who have respect from the community in which they live and who are very influential in getting the community to accept new ideas and who “Glue” the community together. It is very important that these people are identified in the consultation process and that their skills are harnessed to cascade the information and ideas down through the community. Social Housing Estates in any country can be challenging environments for plants and hard Landscape materials and features, it is important that the materials specified are robust and of the best quality if the design has a chance of survival. Some of the newly planted schemes I visited such as Hammerby and Malakoff had utilised large specimen plants and trees, as well as giving instant impact they can also withstand vandalism better than smaller specimens. The play equipment and street furniture, benches etc was also of the highest quality meaning that it would last longer and even though initially more expensive would present better value for money over time. Sustainability had also been addressed on many of the schemes from the green roofs and water harvesting schemes in Augustenborg Sweden, to solar power and energy efficient design in Freiburg as well as the many community gardening and allotments that were present on these schemes. The Green Spaces on these Estates provided many opportunities for sustainable living as well as the benefits to community cohesion that these activities also brought. In particular community gardening and public art had been used as hooks to engage the community and delivered many benefits over and Lessons Learnt Noel Murphy 2009 | Social Housing Green Space in Europe 13 When planning my itinerary and choosing the schemes that I wanted to visit I was hoping to find the magic ingredients that make these places so special and loved by the communities that they serve, and then to be able to apply this information through my own work to improve the Green Spaces for our residents back in the UK.
  • 8. above the physical or aesthetic gains that these features or activities had brought to these Estates. Innovation was also a feature in the design of these schemes right through from innovative consultation techniques to the Universty of Aalborg and their work on GPS tracking of people to understand how they use and move around Green Spaces. Dr. Thomas Randrup from NIRAS associates in Copenhagen has also developed a formula for valuing Green Spaces dependant on the scale and experiences that an individual Green Space can bring. As you can probably see from the photographs all of the schemes I visited were maintained to very high standards, whether this was undertaken by external Contractors or the Housing organisations in-house workforce, or there was evidence of residents involvement is maintenance as in Augustenborg where the residents were offered a reduction in their service charges if the maintained areas of the estate. Maintenance is a very important consideration if the Estates are kept looking their best the residents also have more respect for their environment. Managers need to ensure that there are sufficient budgets available to keep these areas maintained to the highest standard and also that there has been consideration given to future replanting and repairs to hard Landscaping. How will I promote my findings and how will I bring good practice to my industry? I am currently bringing forward a comprehensive Green Space strategy for my organisation, Places for People. This will draw on my experiences gained from the CABE scholarship and guide our Green Space policy for the next ten years. I have also become involved in the early design stages of our development programme in influencing the design of the Green Spaces around our new build portfolio. These are significant schemes, in Brooklands on the outskirts of Milton Keynes we are building a development of 2,500 units including a school and a community centre. We also have a site in early planning stages in Harlow which will eventually see the construction of over 20,000 properties in a mixed tenure community and I will be involved in the planning stage as this project develops over the next ten years. I am keen to share the best practice that I have seen, aligned with what I think will be the first Green Spaces strategy for a Housing organisation that I hope will be adopted by others to raise the standards of design and maintenance of Green Space for a significant proportion of the UK population. The most important factor that I think I can bring is improved social cohesion by involving the local communities in this process. Many thanks to all that assisted me with this study, including; Mathew Frith London Wildlife Trust Noel Farrer Landscape Architect Sarah Gaventa CABE space Helen Beck CABE space Lasse Flygare [lasse@barnistan.info] Sille Askefrø Bjørn (SAB) [SAB@niraskon.dk] Sille Askefrø Bjørn chefkonsulent arkitekt maa telefon 8732 3203 mobil 2920 7449 e-mail sab NIRAS Konsulenterne Åboulevarden 80 8100 Århus C www.niraskon.dk Camilla Richter-Friis van Deurs [Camilla.Deurs@karch.dk] Camilla Richter-Friis van Deurs Ph.D. studerende, arkitekt MAA Center for Byrumsforskning Kunstakademiets Arkitektskole Philip de Langes Allé 10 1435 København K Tlf.: 32 68 66 48 / 32 68 66 67 http://www.karch.dk Åse Dannestam [Ase.Dannestam@mkbfastighet.se] MKB Fastighets AB (publ) Box 50405 202 14 MALMÖ Besöksadress: Augustenborgsgatan 3 Tel vx: 040-31 33 00 Fax: 040-31 34 80 www.mkbfastighet.se Thomas Barfoed Randrup (TRA) [TRA@niraskon.dk] Petter Åkerblom [petter.akerblom@sol.slu.se] Martin Søberg [mas@sla.dk] Martin Søberg Head of Communications Art Historian Mag.Art. Arne Juul (AJU) [AJU@niraskon.dk] Oord C.V. van der [C.vanderOord@dro.amsterdam.nl] Haan (PVB), Joop de [HaanJde@zuidoost.amsterdam.nl] F.Blom@wonen.amsterdam.nl Morten Weeke Borup [mwb@ghb-landskab.dk] Morten Weeke Borup Arkitekt MAA Partner GHB Landskabsarkitekter a/s Frederiksholms Kanal 18 A 1220 København K Tlf.: +45 33123738 juliane [juliane.bailly@gmail.com] Simon @ Supersonic Travel London Experiences from GPS tracking of visitors in three Public Parks in Denmark based on GPS technologies Paper presented at the International workshop SPM2008 in Tartu, Estonia http://www.ut.ee/spm2008 Lessons Learnt (continued...) References and Acknowledgements Social Housing Green Space in Europe | Noel Murphy 200914 Noel Murphy 2009 | Social Housing Green Space in Europe 15