SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 4
Download to read offline
How '21 contenders can fill their lineup holes
By Mike Petriello @mike_petriello
December 8, 2020
While a few notable moves have been made so far in this nascent offseason, most
contenders still have the same problem areas to address that they did a month ago. More,
actually, depending on who was non-tendered earlier this month. So, as virtual Winter
Meetings week gets going, who are those contenders -- and where are those must-be-filled
weak spots?
Let's start by figuring out who "contenders" even are, lest we write a dozen identical sections
along the lines of "the Orioles need help at seven spots," and "the Rockies need help at five
2:14 6:02
News MLB News
VIDEO SCORES STATS STANDINGS
spots, and so on.
We'll start by eyeballing 2021 projected wins above replacement, based on current depth
charts supplied over at FanGraphs. WAR is hardly infallible, but there's unsurprisingly a
pretty strong relation between "lots of WAR" and "lots of wins." The 2019-20 WAR team
leaders for position players: Dodgers, Astros, Yankees, Twins. For pitchers? Twins, Indians,
Rays, and Dodgers. The top projected 2021 position players? Mike Trout, Fernando Tatis Jr.,
Alex Bregman, Juan Soto, Cody Bellinger and Mookie Betts. Hard to argue with that.
Then what we'll do is draw a line. We'll say that only teams projected to have at least a .475
winning percentage, or the equivalent of at least 77 wins, are "contenders," which cuts out
the bottom eight teams. (Sorry, Orioles, Rockies, Tigers, Pirates, Rangers, Mariners, Marlins
and D-backs. We wouldn't be shocked if one or two of you poke over .500 in 2021, but only
one of you managed it in 2020 -- Miami, barely, at 31-29 -- and the line has to be drawn
somewhere.)
That leaves us with 22 teams. Then, we'll look at the positional breakdowns (as of 8 p.m. ET
Monday) and make a color-coded projected WAR chart that shows red as "good" and blue as
"weak." In the world of WAR, 2 is roughly average, and anything north of 4 is a star, but it's
those handful of 0 WAR areas we're most interested in. If we just look at position players --
every team could use another handful of pitchers -- and ignore DH, due to the uncertain
status of it in the NL next year, we'll find that on our 22 contenders, we have 13 problem
spots, highlighted in dotted boxes below.
Anyway, investigate the chart. Some of these positions just leap off the page at you. (Here's a
larger version.) Not hard to find the bright shining red box that signifies Trout, is it?
A view like this pretty clearly shows how teams like the Nationals (Soto, Trea Turner) and
Rockies (Trevor Story, Nolan Arenado) have two elite stars and not a whole lot else. See that
red spot at third base for the Pirates? The projections love Ke'Bryan Hayes. You know what
else stands out, which might be worthy of further investigation? All of the best teams -- all of
them -- have strength on the left side of the infield, with the Dodgers being an exception only
because they've not yet re-signed or replaced Justin Turner. But just about no one without
Christian Yelich has strength in left field, which increasingly seems not to matter.
Let's focus on contenders, and let's focus on those dark blue "0 WAR" blocks, the 13 big
problems. The thing about these is that the bars here are so low to clear that it's not actually
that difficult to improve; one team that was in the original draft was the White Sox and right
field, but they bumped that up -- not a lot, but enough -- by signing Adam Eaton.
The 13 0-WAR problem spots for contenders
Angels right field
Projected current starter: Jo Adell
Adell was the No. 5 overall prospect in baseball entering the 2020 season, but his Major
League debut was extremely rough. Adell hit just .161/.212/.266, which was literally the
weakest line of any hitter who had at least 130 plate appearances, in part because his 41.7%
strikeout rate was the second-highest of those hitters. He didn't distinguish himself on
defense, either. It was, all in all, a forgettable first impression.
That, as well as a relatively unimpressive half season in Triple-A in 2019, is largely why the
projections look so negatively upon him. We understand yet don't fully agree, because 132
plate appearances in a pandemic season from a 21-year-old aren't exactly enough to give up
on his future, and don't forget that even the great Trout hit only .220/.281/.390 in his 135 plate
appearances in a 2011 cameo.
Possible solutions: Just play Adell. It's not hard to dream on Joc Pederson, Kyle Schwarber,
Eddie Rosario, etc., in an outfield corner, but Adell isn't even 22 until April, so the Angels have
to give him a full season to prove himself -- or not. A veteran lefty backup type like Robbie
Grossman might not be a bad depth reinforcement, though.
Astros left field
Projected current starter: Chas McCormick?
Unlike the Angels, the Astros don't really have an in-house solution here due to the likely
free-agent departures of an entire trio of outfielders in Michael Brantley, George Springer and
Josh Reddick. Kyle Tucker seems likely to man one of the outfield spots -- maybe he ends
up in left, not right, but it doesn't matter that much right now -- and he's certainly not going to
be joined on Opening Day by both McCormick, who hasn't yet made his Major League debut,
and speedy Myles Straw.
Possible solutions: The free-agent market is absolutely stuffed with corner outfielders of
varying shapes and sizes, even excluding the three former Astros. In left field, Schwarber,
Pederson, Rosario or David Dahl would all make sense -- as, possibly, would Marcell Ozuna, if
they wanted to shoot higher. At a lower level, perhaps Adam Duvall, Hunter Renfroe or
Nomar Mazara fit. And since we're here, wouldn't Jackie Bradley Jr. look good in center field?
Why not just bring back Brantley? How about two? They could really use two.
Red Sox left field
Projected current starter: Michael Chavis
Red Sox first base
Projected current starter: Bobby Dalbec
Let's lump these two together. (We've assumed that with Bradley a free agent, left fielder
Andrew Benintendi will slide to center.) Dalbec, 25, hit for some power and struck out a ton in
a brief look. Chavis, also 25, didn't hit for much power but still struck out a ton. Combined,
and this is much more Chavis than Dalbec, they've been worth 0.6 WAR in parts of two
seasons. It's not hard to see either player making a contribution to the 2021 Red Sox, but it is
difficult to see them going into the season with these positions handed to them.

More Related Content

More from John Eilermann St Louis

More from John Eilermann St Louis (20)

Liverpool secure Champions League football with Sadio Mane double against Cry...
Liverpool secure Champions League football with Sadio Mane double against Cry...Liverpool secure Champions League football with Sadio Mane double against Cry...
Liverpool secure Champions League football with Sadio Mane double against Cry...
 
FOOTBALL NEWS LIVE Chelsea vs Man City Champions League final build-up, Konat...
FOOTBALL NEWS LIVE Chelsea vs Man City Champions League final build-up, Konat...FOOTBALL NEWS LIVE Chelsea vs Man City Champions League final build-up, Konat...
FOOTBALL NEWS LIVE Chelsea vs Man City Champions League final build-up, Konat...
 
Buildings that suffered in World War 2
Buildings that suffered in World War 2Buildings that suffered in World War 2
Buildings that suffered in World War 2
 
Glory for Atlético and Lille and sweetrelieffor Juventus – Football Weekly
Glory for Atlético and Lille and sweetrelieffor Juventus – Football WeeklyGlory for Atlético and Lille and sweetrelieffor Juventus – Football Weekly
Glory for Atlético and Lille and sweetrelieffor Juventus – Football Weekly
 
The life and music of Vera Lynn in WW 2
The life and music of Vera Lynn in WW 2The life and music of Vera Lynn in WW 2
The life and music of Vera Lynn in WW 2
 
Madonna and boyfriendAhlamalikWilliams take in her son’s soccer game
Madonna and boyfriendAhlamalikWilliams take in her son’s soccer gameMadonna and boyfriendAhlamalikWilliams take in her son’s soccer game
Madonna and boyfriendAhlamalikWilliams take in her son’s soccer game
 
Live coverage of the NCAA men's college soccer tournament
Live coverage of the NCAA men's college soccer tournamentLive coverage of the NCAA men's college soccer tournament
Live coverage of the NCAA men's college soccer tournament
 
Guide ramount+ Brazil's top soccer league to its live sports
Guide ramount+ Brazil's top soccer league to its live sports Guide ramount+ Brazil's top soccer league to its live sports
Guide ramount+ Brazil's top soccer league to its live sports
 
Fantasy baseball daily notes: Pitcher and hitter rankings for Tuesday
Fantasy baseball daily notes: Pitcher and hitter rankings for TuesdayFantasy baseball daily notes: Pitcher and hitter rankings for Tuesday
Fantasy baseball daily notes: Pitcher and hitter rankings for Tuesday
 
Fantasy Baseball Trade Analyzer: Arms to acquire and bats to deal
Fantasy Baseball Trade Analyzer: Arms to acquire and bats to dealFantasy Baseball Trade Analyzer: Arms to acquire and bats to deal
Fantasy Baseball Trade Analyzer: Arms to acquire and bats to deal
 
We've seen it before: A player comes to the Yankees and shaves their distinctive
We've seen it before: A player comes to the Yankees and shaves their distinctiveWe've seen it before: A player comes to the Yankees and shaves their distinctive
We've seen it before: A player comes to the Yankees and shaves their distinctive
 
The World’s Most Valuable Soccer Teams: Barcelona Edges Real Madrid To Land A...
The World’s Most Valuable Soccer Teams: Barcelona Edges Real Madrid To Land A...The World’s Most Valuable Soccer Teams: Barcelona Edges Real Madrid To Land A...
The World’s Most Valuable Soccer Teams: Barcelona Edges Real Madrid To Land A...
 
Topps Debuts its First MLB Baseball Card NFT Collection With Top
Topps Debuts its First MLB Baseball Card NFT Collection With TopTopps Debuts its First MLB Baseball Card NFT Collection With Top
Topps Debuts its First MLB Baseball Card NFT Collection With Top
 
Fantasy baseball roundtable: What's the best approach to drafting closers in ...
Fantasy baseball roundtable: What's the best approach to drafting closers in ...Fantasy baseball roundtable: What's the best approach to drafting closers in ...
Fantasy baseball roundtable: What's the best approach to drafting closers in ...
 
Fantasy Baseball 2021: Catcher preview
Fantasy Baseball 2021: Catcher previewFantasy Baseball 2021: Catcher preview
Fantasy Baseball 2021: Catcher preview
 
Bellinger pivots: 'I will be a handshake guy'
Bellinger pivots: 'I will be a handshake guy'Bellinger pivots: 'I will be a handshake guy'
Bellinger pivots: 'I will be a handshake guy'
 
Braun 'not currently interested in playing'
Braun 'not currently interested in playing'Braun 'not currently interested in playing'
Braun 'not currently interested in playing'
 
What the new MLS CBA deal means for owners, players and the '26 World Cup
What the new MLS CBA deal means for owners, players and the '26 World CupWhat the new MLS CBA deal means for owners, players and the '26 World Cup
What the new MLS CBA deal means for owners, players and the '26 World Cup
 
Man City, Man United have lost most money on transfer market - CIES report
Man City, Man United have lost most money on transfer market - CIES reportMan City, Man United have lost most money on transfer market - CIES report
Man City, Man United have lost most money on transfer market - CIES report
 
Hat-trick hero: Empty stadiums get blockchain and soccer to play togethe
Hat-trick hero: Empty stadiums get blockchain and soccer to play togetheHat-trick hero: Empty stadiums get blockchain and soccer to play togethe
Hat-trick hero: Empty stadiums get blockchain and soccer to play togethe
 

Recently uploaded

Jual obat aborsi Madiun ( 085657271886 ) Cytote pil telat bulan penggugur kan...
Jual obat aborsi Madiun ( 085657271886 ) Cytote pil telat bulan penggugur kan...Jual obat aborsi Madiun ( 085657271886 ) Cytote pil telat bulan penggugur kan...
Jual obat aborsi Madiun ( 085657271886 ) Cytote pil telat bulan penggugur kan...
ZurliaSoop
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Italy Vs Albania Italy vs Albania Euro 2024 Prediction Can Albania pull off a...
Italy Vs Albania Italy vs Albania Euro 2024 Prediction Can Albania pull off a...Italy Vs Albania Italy vs Albania Euro 2024 Prediction Can Albania pull off a...
Italy Vs Albania Italy vs Albania Euro 2024 Prediction Can Albania pull off a...
 
Italy vs Albania Euro 2024 Prediction Can Albania pull off a major shock.docx
Italy vs Albania Euro 2024 Prediction Can Albania pull off a major shock.docxItaly vs Albania Euro 2024 Prediction Can Albania pull off a major shock.docx
Italy vs Albania Euro 2024 Prediction Can Albania pull off a major shock.docx
 
Jual obat aborsi Madiun ( 085657271886 ) Cytote pil telat bulan penggugur kan...
Jual obat aborsi Madiun ( 085657271886 ) Cytote pil telat bulan penggugur kan...Jual obat aborsi Madiun ( 085657271886 ) Cytote pil telat bulan penggugur kan...
Jual obat aborsi Madiun ( 085657271886 ) Cytote pil telat bulan penggugur kan...
 
Croatia vs Italy Inter Milan Looking to Carry On Success at Euro 2024.pdf
Croatia vs Italy Inter Milan Looking to Carry On Success at Euro 2024.pdfCroatia vs Italy Inter Milan Looking to Carry On Success at Euro 2024.pdf
Croatia vs Italy Inter Milan Looking to Carry On Success at Euro 2024.pdf
 
TAM Sports-IPL 17 Advertising Report- M01 - M55.xlsx - IPL 17 FCT (Commercial...
TAM Sports-IPL 17 Advertising Report- M01 - M55.xlsx - IPL 17 FCT (Commercial...TAM Sports-IPL 17 Advertising Report- M01 - M55.xlsx - IPL 17 FCT (Commercial...
TAM Sports-IPL 17 Advertising Report- M01 - M55.xlsx - IPL 17 FCT (Commercial...
 
Albania Vs Spain South American coaches lead Albania to Euro 2024 spot.docx
Albania Vs Spain South American coaches lead Albania to Euro 2024 spot.docxAlbania Vs Spain South American coaches lead Albania to Euro 2024 spot.docx
Albania Vs Spain South American coaches lead Albania to Euro 2024 spot.docx
 
Trusted Cricket Betting ID Provider In India: Get your Cricket ID Now
Trusted Cricket Betting ID Provider In India: Get your Cricket ID NowTrusted Cricket Betting ID Provider In India: Get your Cricket ID Now
Trusted Cricket Betting ID Provider In India: Get your Cricket ID Now
 
Nirupam Singh on Fan Development, Growth, and the Future of Formula 1
Nirupam Singh on Fan Development, Growth, and the Future of Formula 1Nirupam Singh on Fan Development, Growth, and the Future of Formula 1
Nirupam Singh on Fan Development, Growth, and the Future of Formula 1
 
Luka Modric Elevating Croatia's Stars for Euro Cup 2024.docx
Luka Modric Elevating Croatia's Stars for Euro Cup 2024.docxLuka Modric Elevating Croatia's Stars for Euro Cup 2024.docx
Luka Modric Elevating Croatia's Stars for Euro Cup 2024.docx
 
Genuine 8617370543 Hot and Beautiful 💕 Etah Escorts call Girls
Genuine 8617370543 Hot and Beautiful 💕 Etah Escorts call GirlsGenuine 8617370543 Hot and Beautiful 💕 Etah Escorts call Girls
Genuine 8617370543 Hot and Beautiful 💕 Etah Escorts call Girls
 
Churu Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
Churu Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot GirlsChuru Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
Churu Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
 
basketball evolution History Slides.pdf
basketball evolution  History Slides.pdfbasketball evolution  History Slides.pdf
basketball evolution History Slides.pdf
 
Abortion pills in Jeddah +966572737505 <> buy cytotec <> unwanted kit Saudi A...
Abortion pills in Jeddah +966572737505 <> buy cytotec <> unwanted kit Saudi A...Abortion pills in Jeddah +966572737505 <> buy cytotec <> unwanted kit Saudi A...
Abortion pills in Jeddah +966572737505 <> buy cytotec <> unwanted kit Saudi A...
 
Netherlands Players expected to miss UEFA Euro 2024 due to injury.docx
Netherlands Players expected to miss UEFA Euro 2024 due to injury.docxNetherlands Players expected to miss UEFA Euro 2024 due to injury.docx
Netherlands Players expected to miss UEFA Euro 2024 due to injury.docx
 
JORNADA 6 LIGA MURO 2024TUXTEPECOAXACA.pdf
JORNADA 6 LIGA MURO 2024TUXTEPECOAXACA.pdfJORNADA 6 LIGA MURO 2024TUXTEPECOAXACA.pdf
JORNADA 6 LIGA MURO 2024TUXTEPECOAXACA.pdf
 
Turkiye vs Portugal Turkey's Road to Redemption and Preparation for Euro Cup ...
Turkiye vs Portugal Turkey's Road to Redemption and Preparation for Euro Cup ...Turkiye vs Portugal Turkey's Road to Redemption and Preparation for Euro Cup ...
Turkiye vs Portugal Turkey's Road to Redemption and Preparation for Euro Cup ...
 
UEFA Euro 2024 Clash and Eurovision 2024 Poll Insights.docx
UEFA Euro 2024 Clash and Eurovision 2024 Poll Insights.docxUEFA Euro 2024 Clash and Eurovision 2024 Poll Insights.docx
UEFA Euro 2024 Clash and Eurovision 2024 Poll Insights.docx
 
Belgium Vs Slovakia Belgium at Euro 2024 Teams in group, fixtures, schedule, ...
Belgium Vs Slovakia Belgium at Euro 2024 Teams in group, fixtures, schedule, ...Belgium Vs Slovakia Belgium at Euro 2024 Teams in group, fixtures, schedule, ...
Belgium Vs Slovakia Belgium at Euro 2024 Teams in group, fixtures, schedule, ...
 
Spain to be banned from participating in Euro 2024.docx
Spain to be banned from participating in Euro 2024.docxSpain to be banned from participating in Euro 2024.docx
Spain to be banned from participating in Euro 2024.docx
 
Cricketbitt | Best Cricket Online Betting Id Provider in India
Cricketbitt  | Best Cricket Online Betting Id Provider in IndiaCricketbitt  | Best Cricket Online Betting Id Provider in India
Cricketbitt | Best Cricket Online Betting Id Provider in India
 

How '21 contenders can fill their lineup holes

  • 1. How '21 contenders can fill their lineup holes By Mike Petriello @mike_petriello December 8, 2020 While a few notable moves have been made so far in this nascent offseason, most contenders still have the same problem areas to address that they did a month ago. More, actually, depending on who was non-tendered earlier this month. So, as virtual Winter Meetings week gets going, who are those contenders -- and where are those must-be-filled weak spots? Let's start by figuring out who "contenders" even are, lest we write a dozen identical sections along the lines of "the Orioles need help at seven spots," and "the Rockies need help at five 2:14 6:02 News MLB News VIDEO SCORES STATS STANDINGS
  • 2. spots, and so on. We'll start by eyeballing 2021 projected wins above replacement, based on current depth charts supplied over at FanGraphs. WAR is hardly infallible, but there's unsurprisingly a pretty strong relation between "lots of WAR" and "lots of wins." The 2019-20 WAR team leaders for position players: Dodgers, Astros, Yankees, Twins. For pitchers? Twins, Indians, Rays, and Dodgers. The top projected 2021 position players? Mike Trout, Fernando Tatis Jr., Alex Bregman, Juan Soto, Cody Bellinger and Mookie Betts. Hard to argue with that. Then what we'll do is draw a line. We'll say that only teams projected to have at least a .475 winning percentage, or the equivalent of at least 77 wins, are "contenders," which cuts out the bottom eight teams. (Sorry, Orioles, Rockies, Tigers, Pirates, Rangers, Mariners, Marlins and D-backs. We wouldn't be shocked if one or two of you poke over .500 in 2021, but only one of you managed it in 2020 -- Miami, barely, at 31-29 -- and the line has to be drawn somewhere.) That leaves us with 22 teams. Then, we'll look at the positional breakdowns (as of 8 p.m. ET Monday) and make a color-coded projected WAR chart that shows red as "good" and blue as "weak." In the world of WAR, 2 is roughly average, and anything north of 4 is a star, but it's those handful of 0 WAR areas we're most interested in. If we just look at position players -- every team could use another handful of pitchers -- and ignore DH, due to the uncertain status of it in the NL next year, we'll find that on our 22 contenders, we have 13 problem spots, highlighted in dotted boxes below. Anyway, investigate the chart. Some of these positions just leap off the page at you. (Here's a larger version.) Not hard to find the bright shining red box that signifies Trout, is it?
  • 3. A view like this pretty clearly shows how teams like the Nationals (Soto, Trea Turner) and Rockies (Trevor Story, Nolan Arenado) have two elite stars and not a whole lot else. See that red spot at third base for the Pirates? The projections love Ke'Bryan Hayes. You know what else stands out, which might be worthy of further investigation? All of the best teams -- all of them -- have strength on the left side of the infield, with the Dodgers being an exception only because they've not yet re-signed or replaced Justin Turner. But just about no one without Christian Yelich has strength in left field, which increasingly seems not to matter. Let's focus on contenders, and let's focus on those dark blue "0 WAR" blocks, the 13 big problems. The thing about these is that the bars here are so low to clear that it's not actually that difficult to improve; one team that was in the original draft was the White Sox and right field, but they bumped that up -- not a lot, but enough -- by signing Adam Eaton. The 13 0-WAR problem spots for contenders Angels right field Projected current starter: Jo Adell Adell was the No. 5 overall prospect in baseball entering the 2020 season, but his Major League debut was extremely rough. Adell hit just .161/.212/.266, which was literally the weakest line of any hitter who had at least 130 plate appearances, in part because his 41.7% strikeout rate was the second-highest of those hitters. He didn't distinguish himself on defense, either. It was, all in all, a forgettable first impression. That, as well as a relatively unimpressive half season in Triple-A in 2019, is largely why the projections look so negatively upon him. We understand yet don't fully agree, because 132 plate appearances in a pandemic season from a 21-year-old aren't exactly enough to give up on his future, and don't forget that even the great Trout hit only .220/.281/.390 in his 135 plate appearances in a 2011 cameo. Possible solutions: Just play Adell. It's not hard to dream on Joc Pederson, Kyle Schwarber, Eddie Rosario, etc., in an outfield corner, but Adell isn't even 22 until April, so the Angels have to give him a full season to prove himself -- or not. A veteran lefty backup type like Robbie Grossman might not be a bad depth reinforcement, though.
  • 4. Astros left field Projected current starter: Chas McCormick? Unlike the Angels, the Astros don't really have an in-house solution here due to the likely free-agent departures of an entire trio of outfielders in Michael Brantley, George Springer and Josh Reddick. Kyle Tucker seems likely to man one of the outfield spots -- maybe he ends up in left, not right, but it doesn't matter that much right now -- and he's certainly not going to be joined on Opening Day by both McCormick, who hasn't yet made his Major League debut, and speedy Myles Straw. Possible solutions: The free-agent market is absolutely stuffed with corner outfielders of varying shapes and sizes, even excluding the three former Astros. In left field, Schwarber, Pederson, Rosario or David Dahl would all make sense -- as, possibly, would Marcell Ozuna, if they wanted to shoot higher. At a lower level, perhaps Adam Duvall, Hunter Renfroe or Nomar Mazara fit. And since we're here, wouldn't Jackie Bradley Jr. look good in center field? Why not just bring back Brantley? How about two? They could really use two. Red Sox left field Projected current starter: Michael Chavis Red Sox first base Projected current starter: Bobby Dalbec Let's lump these two together. (We've assumed that with Bradley a free agent, left fielder Andrew Benintendi will slide to center.) Dalbec, 25, hit for some power and struck out a ton in a brief look. Chavis, also 25, didn't hit for much power but still struck out a ton. Combined, and this is much more Chavis than Dalbec, they've been worth 0.6 WAR in parts of two seasons. It's not hard to see either player making a contribution to the 2021 Red Sox, but it is difficult to see them going into the season with these positions handed to them.