SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 16
1
Joanne Pan
ENGL493
Dr. Maher
April 18, 2016
Housing Choice Voucher Program
The HousingChoice VoucherProgram, knownas Section8, isa federally-fundedhousing
assistance programcreatedinthe 1970s intendedtohelpimpoverishedfamiliesandotherswith
disabilitiesfindaffordablehousing. ForBaltimore,apredominantlyAfrican-Americancity,the program
has allowedsome familiestofindhousing.However,thosesame familiesare the mostaffectedbythe
program because of landlords, lackof mobilityandsegregatedneighborhoods haskeptthemin
impoverishedneighborhoodsandata higherriskof stayinginimpoverishedneighborhoods.Although
the UnitedStatesDepartmentof HousingandUrban Development(HUD) hastriedto make some
reform,itismet withskepticismandfears thatpovertywillspread,propertyvalueswill decrease,and
white flightwill becomemore common. Otherproblemsinclude the lackof transportationandsocial
mobility,the suppressionof impoverishedneighborhoodstocertainareasandpolicychangestothe
program.
In 1974, Congresspassedthe Section8 program, whichwas“developedbyHUDto provide
rental subsidiesforeligible tenantfamilies(includingsinglepersons) residinginnewlyconstructed,
rehabilitatedandexistingrental andcooperative apartmentprojects(UnitedStates.Departmentof
HousingandUrban Development.“Section8ProgramBackgroundInformation.”N.d.Web.2May 2016),
whichwas thenbrokendowninto“NewConstruction”,“Substantial Rehabilitation”and“Loan
ManagementSet-Aside (LMSA) programs”(UnitedStates.Departmentof HousingandUrban
Development.“Section8ProgramBackground Information.”N.d.Web.2 May 2016), and each program
2
focusesonone aspectof housingtroublesthateligible familiesface,especiallyinapredominantly
African-Americancity.
The program affectsBaltimore because asapredominantlyAfrican-Americancity,muchof the
cityis on the program butare inareas where crime ratesare highand completionof educationislow.
Whenwe read Katz’s“Ethicsof Expediency”,we notedthatwhenthingsneedtobe done fast,we often
sacrifice ourmoralsand ethicsinorderto getwhat we want(Katz,1992). For example,the policiesthat
were intendedtohelplow-incomefamiliesbackfiredandhelpedtoperpetuatethe povertycycle.As The
Atlantic journalistAlanaSemuelsexplains,Section8
...ispoorlydesigned.Itworkslike this:Familiesluckyenoughtogetoff lengthywaitinglistsare
allowedtolookforapartmentsupto a certainrent,whichvariesforeach metroregion.This
figure iscalledthe ‘fairmarketrent,’andiscalculatedbyHUD everyyearforeach metroarea.
The tenantpays about30 percentof hisincome,andthe vouchercoversthe restof the rent
(thisisbasedonthe ideathatfamiliesshouldnotspendmore thanone-thirdof theirincomeon
rent).Butthe fairmarketrent cut-off pointoftenconsignsvoucher-holderstoimpoverished
neighborhoods.Thisisinpartbecause of how thatnumberiscalculated:HUD draws the line at
the 40th percentile of rentsfor‘typical’unitsoccupiedby‘recentmovers’inanentire
metropolitanarea,whichincludesfar-flungsuburbswithlongcommutesand,asa result,makes
the Fair Market Rentrelativelylow.
As a resultof poor policyand otherfactors,voucherholdersare predominantlylivinginareas
where crime andpovertyratesare high,whichcanhave lastingeffectsonchildren. Forexample,one
house onthe GoSection8.comwebsite showsthata “3 Bed1 Bath Townhome/Villa”nearFederal Street
isgoingfor $1,350/month, whichis highfora housingdevelopmentinthe program.The majorityof
voucherholdershave notransportation, andthe house isina neighborhoodnon-voucherholderswould
feel comfortablein. Otherhousingoptionsavailabletovoucherholdershave the same problem-high
rent,seedyneighborhoods,andalack of mobility available,andalthoughthe programtriestoshowthe
house as a traditional house forfamilies,manytimesextendedfamiliesmove intogethertosave onrent
and a house withonlythree bedroomsandone bathroomcan’tholdmulti-generational families
because of the lack of available space.
3
3 Bed/1Bath Townhome Villafor$1,350/month
1630 NorthBond St.
Credit:Google Maps
Credit:Google Maps
4
3 Bed,1.5 Bath Townhome/Villafor$1,499/Month
3632 RobertsPl.
Credit:Google Maps
Credit:Google Maps
5
3 Bed,2.5 Bath House for$1,500/Month
626 N RobinsonSt.
Credit:Google
Credit:Google Maps
6
Whenwe lookedatthe three examplesof the housesinthe program onthe presentation,we
foundthat the houseswere inareasthatwere consideredunsafe.However,asBaltimore’sHousing
Authorityisconsideringrevisingitspolicies,anarticle inthe Baltimore Sunreportedthata“court-
orderedrelocationprogram”allowsforAfrican-Americanfamiliestomove intowealthierandwhiter
suburbs(“HousingPoliciesStill PinPoorinBaltimore,ButSome Escape to Suburbs.”2015). Other
reasonsonhow housingisa formof discriminationinBaltimore isthe lackof mobility-socially,
economically,andthroughtransportation.Inclass,we discussedBaltimore’spublictransportation
issues,andhowmultipleCityDataforumstell horrorstoriesof how muchof a messit is,and how the
closure of the Red Line byGovernorHogan affectedinner-cityneighborhoods,whichwouldhave
broughtin much-needed federal revenue,awayfor those livinginthatareaa wayto get to theirjobs,
allowedthemsocial andeconomicmobilityandaway to escape the povertysurroundingthem.
Housinghasalwaysbeenanissue withinBaltimoreandde jure segregationandde facto
segregationhave beenimplicit.De jure housingsegregationiswhenthe lawsare codifiedinwhere
people canstay,and de facto housingsegregationiswhenthe lawsaren’tcodifiedbutare anunspoken
rule as to where people canlive.Forexample,the BaltimoreSunreportsthatthe “AmericanCivil
LibertiesUnionof MarylandsuedHUD, sayingthatit demolishedoldpublichousinghigh-riseswhere
mostlyAfrican-Americanslived-onlytomove the residentstoequallysegregatedhousingandpoor
conditions inotherpartsof the city”(WalkerandKnezevich,2012).Thiswas a case that wasopenedin
1995, andonlybeingdealtwithnowwiththe passingof the HousingOpportunitiesMade Equal (HOME)
Act, which“prohibitslandlordsandotherpropertyownersfrom discriminatingagainstpersonsseeking
housingbasedsolelyontheir‘source of income’”(PublicJustice,2012). Accordingto the Sun,“Attorneys
representingcurrentandformerpublichousingresidentsfiledthe settlement…andhope the agreement
withthe federal Departmentof HousingandUrban Developmentwill finallyendmore than70 yearsof
housingsegregation”(Walker,AndreaK.andKnezevich,Alison.“SettlementinDecades-OldFairHousing
7
Case.”The Baltimore Sun.The Baltimore Sun,25August2012. Web.7 May 2016). By allowingamixture
of people fromdifferentsocioeconomicclasses,itwill have apositiveeffectonthose livinginpoverty
and strugglingtofinda wayout.
Landlordsare one of the biggestproblemswithinthe program.Currently,landlordshave to
registertheirpropertywithGoSection8.com, the websitewhere homesunderthe programare located.
However,landlordsoftentake the voucherholdersto “disadvantagedneighborhoods,perpetuating
housingsegregationandlimitingsocial mobility.Baltimore hasalonghistoryof segregation,buttoday,
it persistswithinone of the veryprogramsdesignedtodismantle the problem:housingvouchers”
(Rosen,Eva.“The Powerof Landlords.” The Atlantic. The Atlantic.9June 2015. 10 April 2016). Inorder
to combat landlordsandtheirpowerinthe program, Marylandlegislationpassedabill thatdealtwithit;
however,itistoosoonto say howeffectiveithasbeenorwill be.
In 2012, Maryland legislationpassedabill knownasthe MarylandHousingOpportunitiesMade
Equal (HOME) Act. Accordingtothe PublicJustice Center,the legislation“Prohibitslandlordsandother
propertyownersfromdiscriminatingagainstpersonsseekinghousingbasedsolelyontheir ‘sourceof
income.’ (MarylandGeneral Assembly.“HousingOpportunitiesMade Equal Act.”PublicJustice.org.n.d
Web.2 May 2016). Historically,landlordshave beenanintegral partof the program.In orderto qualify
theirpropertyforthe program,the landlordsmustpassthrougha seriesof checksdone bythe
Baltimore HousingAuthorityinordertomake sure that the rent isreasonable andthe dwellingisin
goodcondition.However,landlordsmayuse tacticssuch as raisingrentor onlyallowingpropertyin
inner-cityorlow-income areastobe rentedoutto voucherholders.EvaRosen,ajournalistfor The
Atlantic, arguesthat “Landlords…are salesmenaimingtopersuade potentialrenters,”butBaltimore is
differentbecause they“lure renterstodisadvantagedneighborhoods,perpetuatinghousingsegregation
and limitingsocial mobility.Baltimorehasalonghistoryof segregation,buttoday,itpersistswithinone
of the veryprogramsdesignedtodismantlethe problem:housingvouchers”(Rosen,Eva.2015). In
8
anotherSunarticle,Dr. DeLuca suggestedthat“landlordsrefuse torenttopeople withSection8
housingbecause theyare unfairlyprejudicedagainstthose prospective tenants”(Gatton,James.2013)
whichtiesintoBaltimore’shousingpoliciesof the 50s and 60s, whensegregationwasrampantaround
the country.
Landlordsmayalso raise rentforvoucherholders. Althoughthe voucherprogramissupposedto
decrease the amountof rentbecause it’ssubsidizedbythe federal departmentunderthe Housingand
Urban Developmentdepartment,rentmayincrease.Accordingtoan investigationdone byEvaRosenin
The Atlantic, landlordshave aset of “tricks” theyuse to getprogram holdersinsidethe property.Rosen
wrote “One landlordImethad two identical unitsinthe same building:The third-floorapartmentwas
rentedtoa familywithavoucherandwentfor $250 more than the identical unitonthe fourth”(Rosen,
Eva. “The Powerof Landlords.”TheAtlantic. The Atlantic.9 June 2015. 10 April 2016). However,because
voucherholderstendtobe low-incomeandhave limitedoptionsformobility,transportationisanother
issue.
Because the program targets low-incomefamiliesorthose withdisabilities,housingtends
centeredinareaswhere publictransportationisn’tserved,whichincreasesthe likelihoodof voucher
holderstolive inimpoverishedneighborhoods.Forexample,Baltimore canceledthe RedLine,which
wouldhave givenfamiliesin the neighborhoodswhere the line wastobe builtaccessto careersand
more mobility. AccordingtoalawsuitfiledbyBaltimore againstthe “State of Maryland,Maryland
Departmentof Transportation,MarylandTransitAdministration,andMarylandState Highway
Administration”underTitle VIof the Civil RightsActof 1964, respondentsarguedthat the cancellation
of the RedLine wouldimpactAfrican-Americansthe most,citing
…more than thirty percentof residentsspendingmore thanforty-fiveminutestravelingtowork
each day.Forty-fourpercentof householdsinthe RedLine corridorlacka vehicle;andinsome
9
neighborhoods,amajorityof householdshave novehicleandare entirelydependent onbuses
for travel.Despite the significantreliance onthem, busestoooftenrunslowly,withspeedsfrom
EdmonsonVillage todowntownof onlynine miles-per-hourduringpeaktravel times…TheRed
Line wouldalsohave servedasthe necessarylinkconnectedWestBaltimore’spredominantly
African-Americanneighborhoodstojobcenters. (“Baltimore RegionalInitiative Development
Genuine Equality,Inc.,andEarl Andrewsvs.State of Maryland,MarylandDepartmentof
transportation,MarylandTransitAdministration,andMarylandState HighwayAdministration.”
N.d.Web.2 May 2016).
The lack of mobilityhascontributedtothe increase of those livingonthe voucherprogram,and
increasesthe likelihoodof livinginbadneighborhoods,whichcanhave lastingeffectsonchildren. A
Baltimore Suninvestigationfoundthat
Amongthe Baltimore region’sroughly25,000 voucherholders,more than60 percent-orabout
14,664 households-live inareasdeemed“low opportunity”,basedonmeasuresincluding
education,povertyandcrime,accordingtoa reportissuedlastyearby the Baltimore
MetropolitanCouncil (Sherman,Natalie.“HUDConsidersChange toSection8 Rents.”The
Baltimore Sun. The Baltimore Sun.10 June 2015. Web.10 April 2016.)
As a result,Baltimore hasbecome one of the mosthousing-segregatedneighborhoods, witha
Baltimore Suneditorial arguingthat“Baltimore remainshome tosome of the mostdeeplysegregated
pocketsof povertyinthe nation”, withmore affluentcitizensarguingandprotestingthattheywant
voucherholderstostaywhere theyare because theywill bringdownpropertyvalue.Althoughthe
Supreme Courthasdeemedsegregationunconstitutional,de factosegregationandpoliciesthatdonot
favorthe African-Americanpopulationensuresthattheystayinimpoverishedconditions.
AnotherproblemwithSection8is that housingisspreadingandaffluentcitizens aren’thappy
aboutit, especiallythe more affluentresidentsinsurroundingcounties. Accordingtoa Baltimore Sun
report,housingauthoritieshadspent“$12 milliontopurchase nearly30 housesinBaltimore Countyand
16 in Anne Arundel,HarfordandHowardcounties”andhad provided“$51 millioninrentsubsidiesto
nearly3,100 familieswhohave movedfromcitypublichousingtoprivate apartmentsorhousesin
prosperoussuburbanneighborhoods,primarilyinHowardandBaltimore counties”(Donovan,Doug.
10
“CityHousingProgramStirs FearsinBaltimore County.”The Baltimore Sun.The Baltimore Sun,14
December2015, Web.7 May 2016). Past Baltimore Sunarticlesandresearchdone bythinktankUrban
Institute inWashington,D.C.showthatthe more affluentresidentswishtokeepthe poorinbad
neighborhoodsandkeptinareaswithlimitedopportunitiesratherthanspreadthem.However,
researchshowsthatif theyare giventhese opportunities,povertyratesdropdown.Accordingtoa
Baltimore Suneditorial,the “Baltimoreregionhasapoor track recordwhenit comesto acceptance of
policiesdesignedtohelplow-income,inner-cityresidentsmove tothe suburbs”,withacountyofficial
callingthem“‘freeloaders’andnot‘qualitypeople’”(“HUDImperilsthe ColumbiaDream.”The
Baltimore Sun.The Baltimore Sun,25 September2015. Web.7 May 2016).
In complete contrast,MontgomeryCounty, one of the wealthiercountiesinMaryland,doesn’t
have thisproblem.AccordingtoDavidRusk,the countyhas “one of the nation’smostcomprehensive
and balancedlocal housingprogram”bycreatingthe “Moderately-PricedDwellingUnit(MPDU)”which
allowedforamixture of differentsocioeconomicclassescomingtogether.The formulacreatedbythe
program wasthat
85 percentof all unitswill be ‘marketrate’-thatis,soldorrentedtowhateverincome groupthe
developeristargeting.10percentmustbe ‘affordable’-thatis,atpurchase pricesorrental levelsthat
representnomore than30 percentof the income of householdsearningnomore than 80 percentof the
county’smedianhouseholdincome…mostsignificantly,5percentmustbe made available fordirect
purchase or rental bythe county’sHousingOpportunitiesCommissionforplacementof deep-subsidy
households.
Doingso allowsfora mixture of differentsocioeconomicclassesandallowsforimpoverished
familiestogainsocial andeconomicmobility. Anotherproblemthe programdealswithisthe lackof
housingavailableforpeopleonthe list.Anarticle inAfromagazine foundthatin2014, the listwouldbe
openforthe firsttime inmore thanten yearsbecause of the lack of housing(Special,Roberto.2014). In
a Baltimore Sunarticle,apersonwhowas on the vouchersince Julyandhasn’tbeenable tofindhousing
11
because of landlordsandclaimsof discriminatingon“potential tenantsbasedontheirsourcesof
income”(Knezevich,Alison.2011). The Sundida deeperinvestigationintothe program, andfoundthat
signupsforthe waitlisthave endeduntil 2020 withalmost74,000 applicants(Wenger,Yvonne.2014).
In return,the opinionsectionandreadersrespondsectionof the Sunshotback,sayingthat if
theyopenuppropertyto tenantstheylose money.Forexample,landlordJamesGattonexplainsthat“I
experiencedfirsthandthe lossof two weeksSection8rental income overabustedplasticknobona
range” (Gatton,James.2016), and othershave claimedthatthe paperworkandfilingitappropriate
applicationsare anightmare.InanotherSunarticle, a readerwrote inresponse to Dr. DeLuca’s
suggestion that“landlordsrefusetorenttopeople withSection8housingbecause theyare unfairly
prejudicedagainstthose prospective tenants”(Gatton,James.2013).JamesGatton, a landlordinthe
program,explainedthatthe “prejudice of landlords isdirectednotagainstthe people butagainstthe
nightmare bureaucracythatSection8 rentalsentail”(Gatton,James.2013).
WhenHUD SecretaryJulianCastro“announcedalandmarkchange inpolicydesignedtoreduce
residentialsegregation”(“HUDImperilsthe ColumbiaDream.”The Baltimore Sun.The Baltimore Sun,25
September2015. Web.7 May 2016), not much has beendone yet. One factorinthe problemisthe lack
of fundsandCongressional limitationsonadministrative costs.Currently,the programpoliciesare
debatedona city bycity scale,andhousingauthoritiesare the final decisionsindecidingthe voucher
program.In a 2014 article in The Atlantic, journalistAlanaSemuels,foundthatBaltimorehasmore than
16,000 vacant homesandabout 30,000 people willexperience homelessness.Inherresearch,she found
that organizationssuchasHousingOur NeighborsandHousingisaHuman RightRoundtable,are fixing
up these vacantlotsand turningthemintoaffordable homesforlow-incomeresidents.Inour
presentation,Jesslookedatthe StationNorthneighborhood,wheregentrificationiscausingrenttorise,
whichthenhas an effectonhousingthroughoutthe city.If the housingpricesinone areagohome,it
12
slowlyspreadsoutandpushesmore low-income residentsandfamiliesintoareaswhere povertyis
more widespreadandcausesextendedfamiliestolive incrampedhousesthatmaynotbe sanitaryor
hygienicforfamilieswithyoungchildren.The grouparguesthat“those homesshouldbe turnedinto
affordable housing”(Semuels,Alana.2014),and whenpairedwithhousingpolicychangeswouldallow
for more people togetonthe waitlistforhousing,andformore socioeconomicmobilityforpeople on
the program.
Thiscouldbe a potential solutiontothe currentone of allowingpoorpeople intowealthier
neighborhoods,whichthe affluentcitizenshave complainedabout.Althoughmultiplestudiesshowthat
whena childisexposedtodifferentsocioeconomicgroups,theyare more likelytolive inhigher-income
neighborhoods,finisheducationandgoontohighereducation.Multiple Sunarticlesshow thatthe
affluentcitizensthatsurroundBaltimore don’twantthese poorpeopletocome inbecause theyhaven’t
workedforit or they’re leechingoff of federal help.However,manyof these familiesonfederal
assistance andstate assistance programsare what’sconsidered“deservingpoor”,orthose that work
and don’tmake enoughtomake endsmeetsotheyrelyon governmentassistance forhelp.
As a citythat has facedsegregationinmultiple forms,housingisthe latestwaytobenefitthose
inpower.ThinktankUrban Institute foundthatthe lackof social mobility,highrent,landlordswho
don’thave theirrentersbestinterestsatheartandpoliciesall conspire tocreate a situationwhere it’s
difficultforvoucherholderstomove up.The Baltimore Sunhasdone investigationsaboutthe situation,
and wheneveranarticle comesoutit showsthatpotential situationspassedbyCongressorbythe
Marylandlegislature have beendebatedonandarguedabout.Unsurprisingly,thosewhohave more
powerwiththeirrepresentativestendtobe wealthierandwhiter,andare oftenthe onesthatdon’t
wantpoor African-Americansintheirneighborhoodsbecause thatwill bringdown propertyvaluesand
continue tobelievethattheyare there intheirneighborhoodsonlybecauseof governmentassistance.
13
However,it’snotjustBaltimore facingthese problems.Othermajorcitiesacrossthe countryare
facingthe shortage of Section8 housing.Forexample,inAustin,Texasthere were “plentyof apartments
aroundthe citythat voucher-holderscouldafford.Butonlyasmall portionof those apartmentswould
rentto voucher-holders”(Semuels,Aana,2015).Similarly,inBaltimore there are vacanthousesthat
couldbe usedfor housingthe homelessandvoucherholders.
The program has beenconsideredafailure,butif itspoliciesare revised,the distributionof
wealthisspreadmore equallywithamixture of low andhigh-income familieslivingtogether,landlords
are heldaccountable fortheirpropertiesandnotdiscriminatingbasedonrace,havingalargerbudget
for HUD, and allowingfamiliestolive inhigher-incomeneighborhoodsandallow themthe chance to
findhigher-income jobs,thentheirmobilitywill increase andthenthe HousingChoice VoucherProgram
may findsuccessinprograms.AlthoughBaltimoremaynotbe similartoMontgomeryCountyinits
wealthdistribution,the wayMontgomeryCountyhasitshousingauthoritysetupisa way that
Baltimore couldimitate tofindsuccessinitshousingprogram.
14
Bibliography
“Baltimore’sHousingChoiceVoucherHomeownershipProgram.”HousingAuthorityof Baltimore.
Departmentof HousingandCommunityDevelopment.N.d.Web.10 April 2016.
DeLuca,Stefanie.“Whatisthe Role of HousingPolicy?ConsideringChoice andSocial Science Evidence.”
Journalof Urban Affairs. Vol.34Issue 1: (2012): 21-28. Web.10 April 2016.
Donovan,Doug.“CityHousingProgramStirs FearsinBaltimore County.”The Baltimore Sun.The
Baltimore Sun,14 December2015, Web.7 May 2016).
“HUD Imperilsthe ColumbiaDream.”The Baltimore Sun.The Baltimore Sun,25September2015. Web.
7 May 2016.
Galvez,Martha M. “What Do We KnowAboutHousingChoice VoucherProgramLocationOutcomes?”
Urban Institute.August2010. Web.10 April 2016.
Gatton, JamesW.“Fix Section8 and LandlordsWill StepUp.” The BaltimoreSun. The Baltimore Sun,3
June 2013. Web. 15 May 2016.
Gatton, JamesW.“Section8 Housingisa Nightmare forLandlords.” TheBaltimore Sun. The Baltimore
Sun.12 May 2013. Web.15 May 2016.
“GoSection8.”Go Section8 Housing.N.d.Web.10 April 2016.
Katz,StevenB.“The Ethic of Expediency: Classical Rhetoric,Technology,andthe Holocaust.”College
English.54:3 (1992): 255-275. Web.
15
Knezevich,Alison.“Measure WouldProhibitLandlordsfromDiscriminatingAgainstSection8.” The
Baltimore Sun.The Baltimore Sun.9 December2011, Web. 15 May 2016.
Newman,SandraJ.“Low-EndRental Housing:The ForgottenStoryinBaltimore’sHousingBoom.”N.d.
Web.10 April 2016.
“PropertyManagers.”HousingAuthorityof Baltimore.Departmentof HousingandCommunity
Development.N.d.Web.10April 2016.
Rosen,Eva.“The Powerof Landlords.” TheAtlantic. The Atlantic.9 June 2015. 10 April 2016.
Rusk,David.“Baltimore Unbound:A StrategyforRegional Renewal.”Baltimore:JohnsHopkins
UniversityPress,1995. Print.
Semuels,Alana.“HowHousingPolicyisFailingAmerica’sPoor.”TheAtlantic. The Atlantic,24 June 2015.
Web.15 May 2016.
Sherman,Natalie.“HUDConsidersChange toSection8Rents.” The Baltimore Sun. The Baltimore Sun.10
June 2015. Web. 10 April 2016.
Special,RobertoAlejandro.“Baltimore’sSection8WaitingListto OpenforFirst Time inOver10 Years.”
Afro.6 October2014. Web.15 May 2016.
Turner,Margery Austin.“StrengthsandWeaknessesof the HousingVoucherProgram.”UrbanInstitute.
17 June 2003. Web.10 April 2016.
Turner,Margery Austin,Popkin,SusanJ.,Cunningham, MaryK.“Section8 MobilityandNeighborhood
Health.”Urban Institute.1April 2000. 10 April 2016.
16
UnitedStates.Departmentof HousingandUrban Development.“Section8ProgramBackground
Information.”N.d.Web.2May 2016).
UnitedStatesDepartmentof Transportation.2015. ComplaintPursuantToTitle VIOf The Civil RightsAct
of 1964. Baltimore:MarylandDepartmentof Transportation.
Walker,AndreaK.and Knezevich,Alison.“SettlementinDecades-OldFairHousingCase.”The Baltimore
Sun.The Baltimore Sun,25 August2012. Web.7 May 2016).
Wenger,Yvonne.“Nearly74,000 SignUp forBaltimore’sSection8WaitList.” The BaltimoreSun. The
Baltimore Sun,31 October2014. Web.15 May 2016.

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Libro Arquitectura pública e innovación social - Taller de Diseño EDU
Libro Arquitectura pública e innovación social - Taller de Diseño EDULibro Arquitectura pública e innovación social - Taller de Diseño EDU
Libro Arquitectura pública e innovación social - Taller de Diseño EDU
Empresa de Desarrollo Urbano, EDU
 

Viewers also liked (8)

Working with your shadow - a tool for working with people or groups of people...
Working with your shadow - a tool for working with people or groups of people...Working with your shadow - a tool for working with people or groups of people...
Working with your shadow - a tool for working with people or groups of people...
 
Blue Ribbon Committee Mtg I Final Draft 010709
Blue Ribbon Committee Mtg I   Final Draft 010709Blue Ribbon Committee Mtg I   Final Draft 010709
Blue Ribbon Committee Mtg I Final Draft 010709
 
Informe de Gestión 2012-2015 ||::.. Empresa de Desarrollo Urbano - EDU
Informe de Gestión 2012-2015 ||::.. Empresa de Desarrollo Urbano - EDUInforme de Gestión 2012-2015 ||::.. Empresa de Desarrollo Urbano - EDU
Informe de Gestión 2012-2015 ||::.. Empresa de Desarrollo Urbano - EDU
 
Face negotiation theory
Face negotiation theoryFace negotiation theory
Face negotiation theory
 
Programa Mejoramiento Integral de Barrios (MIB), EDU
Programa Mejoramiento Integral de Barrios (MIB), EDUPrograma Mejoramiento Integral de Barrios (MIB), EDU
Programa Mejoramiento Integral de Barrios (MIB), EDU
 
Libro Arquitectura pública e innovación social - Taller de Diseño EDU
Libro Arquitectura pública e innovación social - Taller de Diseño EDULibro Arquitectura pública e innovación social - Taller de Diseño EDU
Libro Arquitectura pública e innovación social - Taller de Diseño EDU
 
Aprender la numeración. números naturales... 12
Aprender la numeración. números naturales... 12Aprender la numeración. números naturales... 12
Aprender la numeración. números naturales... 12
 
Pathways To Happiness for Social Support - how government can foster feeling ...
Pathways To Happiness for Social Support - how government can foster feeling ...Pathways To Happiness for Social Support - how government can foster feeling ...
Pathways To Happiness for Social Support - how government can foster feeling ...
 

Similar to Pan_Final Paper

Long-Form Essay on Ending Homelessness
Long-Form Essay on Ending HomelessnessLong-Form Essay on Ending Homelessness
Long-Form Essay on Ending Homelessness
Matthew J Weiner
 

Similar to Pan_Final Paper (20)

Syr03062013a01
Syr03062013a01Syr03062013a01
Syr03062013a01
 
Ohio State Bateman Competition
Ohio State Bateman Competition Ohio State Bateman Competition
Ohio State Bateman Competition
 
Fair Credit and Fair Housing in the Wake of the Subprime and Foreclosure Crisis
Fair Credit and Fair Housing in the Wake of the Subprime and Foreclosure CrisisFair Credit and Fair Housing in the Wake of the Subprime and Foreclosure Crisis
Fair Credit and Fair Housing in the Wake of the Subprime and Foreclosure Crisis
 
Structural Racialization and the Subprime Mortgage Crisis
Structural Racialization and the Subprime Mortgage CrisisStructural Racialization and the Subprime Mortgage Crisis
Structural Racialization and the Subprime Mortgage Crisis
 
Conference keynote 2010
Conference keynote 2010Conference keynote 2010
Conference keynote 2010
 
Conference keynote 2010
Conference keynote 2010Conference keynote 2010
Conference keynote 2010
 
Remarks from HUD Secretary Shaun Donovan
Remarks from HUD Secretary Shaun DonovanRemarks from HUD Secretary Shaun Donovan
Remarks from HUD Secretary Shaun Donovan
 
Long-Form Essay on Ending Homelessness
Long-Form Essay on Ending HomelessnessLong-Form Essay on Ending Homelessness
Long-Form Essay on Ending Homelessness
 
Latagia Copeland-Tyronce's ASFA Policy Analysis Paper 1
Latagia Copeland-Tyronce's ASFA Policy Analysis Paper 1Latagia Copeland-Tyronce's ASFA Policy Analysis Paper 1
Latagia Copeland-Tyronce's ASFA Policy Analysis Paper 1
 
Latagia Copeland-Tyronce's Research Paper on Women and Prescription Opioids
Latagia Copeland-Tyronce's Research Paper on Women and Prescription OpioidsLatagia Copeland-Tyronce's Research Paper on Women and Prescription Opioids
Latagia Copeland-Tyronce's Research Paper on Women and Prescription Opioids
 
School Essay In Marathi Language
School Essay In Marathi LanguageSchool Essay In Marathi Language
School Essay In Marathi Language
 
Storybook: Who Broke the Economy? by Melissa Chadburn of Good Jobs LA
Storybook: Who Broke the Economy? by Melissa Chadburn of Good Jobs LAStorybook: Who Broke the Economy? by Melissa Chadburn of Good Jobs LA
Storybook: Who Broke the Economy? by Melissa Chadburn of Good Jobs LA
 
Beyond Post-Racialism, Toward Opportunity and Social Justice
Beyond Post-Racialism, Toward Opportunity and Social Justice Beyond Post-Racialism, Toward Opportunity and Social Justice
Beyond Post-Racialism, Toward Opportunity and Social Justice
 
Fair Credit and Fair Housing in the Wake of the Subprime and Foreclosure Crisis
Fair Credit and Fair Housing in the Wake of the Subprime and Foreclosure CrisisFair Credit and Fair Housing in the Wake of the Subprime and Foreclosure Crisis
Fair Credit and Fair Housing in the Wake of the Subprime and Foreclosure Crisis
 
Housing First
Housing FirstHousing First
Housing First
 
Too-Big-to-Ignore
Too-Big-to-IgnoreToo-Big-to-Ignore
Too-Big-to-Ignore
 
Write Introduction Essay Examples - ENG 1 1 Introductions
Write Introduction Essay Examples - ENG 1 1 IntroductionsWrite Introduction Essay Examples - ENG 1 1 Introductions
Write Introduction Essay Examples - ENG 1 1 Introductions
 
CHAP 5 HOUSING THEORY.pptx
CHAP 5 HOUSING THEORY.pptxCHAP 5 HOUSING THEORY.pptx
CHAP 5 HOUSING THEORY.pptx
 
Mapping Inequality:How does the historical practice of redlining relate to co...
Mapping Inequality:How does the historical practice of redlining relate to co...Mapping Inequality:How does the historical practice of redlining relate to co...
Mapping Inequality:How does the historical practice of redlining relate to co...
 
Serving GLBT library customers: Partnerships Programs
Serving GLBT library customers: Partnerships ProgramsServing GLBT library customers: Partnerships Programs
Serving GLBT library customers: Partnerships Programs
 

More from Joanne Pan

history hindu ppt revised
history hindu ppt revisedhistory hindu ppt revised
history hindu ppt revised
Joanne Pan
 
report section 3
report section 3report section 3
report section 3
Joanne Pan
 
report section 2
report section 2report section 2
report section 2
Joanne Pan
 
report section 1
report section 1report section 1
report section 1
Joanne Pan
 
Fern Shen Baltimore Brew Talk
Fern Shen Baltimore Brew TalkFern Shen Baltimore Brew Talk
Fern Shen Baltimore Brew Talk
Joanne Pan
 
ges435 final presentation
ges435 final presentationges435 final presentation
ges435 final presentation
Joanne Pan
 
Group Presentation Ted Talk GES400
Group Presentation Ted Talk GES400Group Presentation Ted Talk GES400
Group Presentation Ted Talk GES400
Joanne Pan
 
Patuxent Oral Presentation
Patuxent Oral PresentationPatuxent Oral Presentation
Patuxent Oral Presentation
Joanne Pan
 
critical project paper
critical project papercritical project paper
critical project paper
Joanne Pan
 
GES330 writing prompt
GES330 writing promptGES330 writing prompt
GES330 writing prompt
Joanne Pan
 
final project essay
final project essayfinal project essay
final project essay
Joanne Pan
 
Balancing the Economy and the Environment The Keystone Pipeline
Balancing the Economy and the Environment The Keystone PipelineBalancing the Economy and the Environment The Keystone Pipeline
Balancing the Economy and the Environment The Keystone Pipeline
Joanne Pan
 
presentation essay
presentation essaypresentation essay
presentation essay
Joanne Pan
 

More from Joanne Pan (15)

history hindu ppt revised
history hindu ppt revisedhistory hindu ppt revised
history hindu ppt revised
 
Final Project
Final ProjectFinal Project
Final Project
 
report section 3
report section 3report section 3
report section 3
 
report section 2
report section 2report section 2
report section 2
 
report section 1
report section 1report section 1
report section 1
 
Alcohol in East Asia and the United States: A Comparison
Alcohol in East Asia and the United States: A ComparisonAlcohol in East Asia and the United States: A Comparison
Alcohol in East Asia and the United States: A Comparison
 
Fern Shen Baltimore Brew Talk
Fern Shen Baltimore Brew TalkFern Shen Baltimore Brew Talk
Fern Shen Baltimore Brew Talk
 
ges435 final presentation
ges435 final presentationges435 final presentation
ges435 final presentation
 
Group Presentation Ted Talk GES400
Group Presentation Ted Talk GES400Group Presentation Ted Talk GES400
Group Presentation Ted Talk GES400
 
Patuxent Oral Presentation
Patuxent Oral PresentationPatuxent Oral Presentation
Patuxent Oral Presentation
 
critical project paper
critical project papercritical project paper
critical project paper
 
GES330 writing prompt
GES330 writing promptGES330 writing prompt
GES330 writing prompt
 
final project essay
final project essayfinal project essay
final project essay
 
Balancing the Economy and the Environment The Keystone Pipeline
Balancing the Economy and the Environment The Keystone PipelineBalancing the Economy and the Environment The Keystone Pipeline
Balancing the Economy and the Environment The Keystone Pipeline
 
presentation essay
presentation essaypresentation essay
presentation essay
 

Pan_Final Paper

  • 1. 1 Joanne Pan ENGL493 Dr. Maher April 18, 2016 Housing Choice Voucher Program The HousingChoice VoucherProgram, knownas Section8, isa federally-fundedhousing assistance programcreatedinthe 1970s intendedtohelpimpoverishedfamiliesandotherswith disabilitiesfindaffordablehousing. ForBaltimore,apredominantlyAfrican-Americancity,the program has allowedsome familiestofindhousing.However,thosesame familiesare the mostaffectedbythe program because of landlords, lackof mobilityandsegregatedneighborhoods haskeptthemin impoverishedneighborhoodsandata higherriskof stayinginimpoverishedneighborhoods.Although the UnitedStatesDepartmentof HousingandUrban Development(HUD) hastriedto make some reform,itismet withskepticismandfears thatpovertywillspread,propertyvalueswill decrease,and white flightwill becomemore common. Otherproblemsinclude the lackof transportationandsocial mobility,the suppressionof impoverishedneighborhoodstocertainareasandpolicychangestothe program. In 1974, Congresspassedthe Section8 program, whichwas“developedbyHUDto provide rental subsidiesforeligible tenantfamilies(includingsinglepersons) residinginnewlyconstructed, rehabilitatedandexistingrental andcooperative apartmentprojects(UnitedStates.Departmentof HousingandUrban Development.“Section8ProgramBackgroundInformation.”N.d.Web.2May 2016), whichwas thenbrokendowninto“NewConstruction”,“Substantial Rehabilitation”and“Loan ManagementSet-Aside (LMSA) programs”(UnitedStates.Departmentof HousingandUrban Development.“Section8ProgramBackground Information.”N.d.Web.2 May 2016), and each program
  • 2. 2 focusesonone aspectof housingtroublesthateligible familiesface,especiallyinapredominantly African-Americancity. The program affectsBaltimore because asapredominantlyAfrican-Americancity,muchof the cityis on the program butare inareas where crime ratesare highand completionof educationislow. Whenwe read Katz’s“Ethicsof Expediency”,we notedthatwhenthingsneedtobe done fast,we often sacrifice ourmoralsand ethicsinorderto getwhat we want(Katz,1992). For example,the policiesthat were intendedtohelplow-incomefamiliesbackfiredandhelpedtoperpetuatethe povertycycle.As The Atlantic journalistAlanaSemuelsexplains,Section8 ...ispoorlydesigned.Itworkslike this:Familiesluckyenoughtogetoff lengthywaitinglistsare allowedtolookforapartmentsupto a certainrent,whichvariesforeach metroregion.This figure iscalledthe ‘fairmarketrent,’andiscalculatedbyHUD everyyearforeach metroarea. The tenantpays about30 percentof hisincome,andthe vouchercoversthe restof the rent (thisisbasedonthe ideathatfamiliesshouldnotspendmore thanone-thirdof theirincomeon rent).Butthe fairmarketrent cut-off pointoftenconsignsvoucher-holderstoimpoverished neighborhoods.Thisisinpartbecause of how thatnumberiscalculated:HUD draws the line at the 40th percentile of rentsfor‘typical’unitsoccupiedby‘recentmovers’inanentire metropolitanarea,whichincludesfar-flungsuburbswithlongcommutesand,asa result,makes the Fair Market Rentrelativelylow. As a resultof poor policyand otherfactors,voucherholdersare predominantlylivinginareas where crime andpovertyratesare high,whichcanhave lastingeffectsonchildren. Forexample,one house onthe GoSection8.comwebsite showsthata “3 Bed1 Bath Townhome/Villa”nearFederal Street isgoingfor $1,350/month, whichis highfora housingdevelopmentinthe program.The majorityof voucherholdershave notransportation, andthe house isina neighborhoodnon-voucherholderswould feel comfortablein. Otherhousingoptionsavailabletovoucherholdershave the same problem-high rent,seedyneighborhoods,andalack of mobility available,andalthoughthe programtriestoshowthe house as a traditional house forfamilies,manytimesextendedfamiliesmove intogethertosave onrent and a house withonlythree bedroomsandone bathroomcan’tholdmulti-generational families because of the lack of available space.
  • 3. 3 3 Bed/1Bath Townhome Villafor$1,350/month 1630 NorthBond St. Credit:Google Maps Credit:Google Maps
  • 4. 4 3 Bed,1.5 Bath Townhome/Villafor$1,499/Month 3632 RobertsPl. Credit:Google Maps Credit:Google Maps
  • 5. 5 3 Bed,2.5 Bath House for$1,500/Month 626 N RobinsonSt. Credit:Google Credit:Google Maps
  • 6. 6 Whenwe lookedatthe three examplesof the housesinthe program onthe presentation,we foundthat the houseswere inareasthatwere consideredunsafe.However,asBaltimore’sHousing Authorityisconsideringrevisingitspolicies,anarticle inthe Baltimore Sunreportedthata“court- orderedrelocationprogram”allowsforAfrican-Americanfamiliestomove intowealthierandwhiter suburbs(“HousingPoliciesStill PinPoorinBaltimore,ButSome Escape to Suburbs.”2015). Other reasonsonhow housingisa formof discriminationinBaltimore isthe lackof mobility-socially, economically,andthroughtransportation.Inclass,we discussedBaltimore’spublictransportation issues,andhowmultipleCityDataforumstell horrorstoriesof how muchof a messit is,and how the closure of the Red Line byGovernorHogan affectedinner-cityneighborhoods,whichwouldhave broughtin much-needed federal revenue,awayfor those livinginthatareaa wayto get to theirjobs, allowedthemsocial andeconomicmobilityandaway to escape the povertysurroundingthem. Housinghasalwaysbeenanissue withinBaltimoreandde jure segregationandde facto segregationhave beenimplicit.De jure housingsegregationiswhenthe lawsare codifiedinwhere people canstay,and de facto housingsegregationiswhenthe lawsaren’tcodifiedbutare anunspoken rule as to where people canlive.Forexample,the BaltimoreSunreportsthatthe “AmericanCivil LibertiesUnionof MarylandsuedHUD, sayingthatit demolishedoldpublichousinghigh-riseswhere mostlyAfrican-Americanslived-onlytomove the residentstoequallysegregatedhousingandpoor conditions inotherpartsof the city”(WalkerandKnezevich,2012).Thiswas a case that wasopenedin 1995, andonlybeingdealtwithnowwiththe passingof the HousingOpportunitiesMade Equal (HOME) Act, which“prohibitslandlordsandotherpropertyownersfrom discriminatingagainstpersonsseeking housingbasedsolelyontheir‘source of income’”(PublicJustice,2012). Accordingto the Sun,“Attorneys representingcurrentandformerpublichousingresidentsfiledthe settlement…andhope the agreement withthe federal Departmentof HousingandUrban Developmentwill finallyendmore than70 yearsof housingsegregation”(Walker,AndreaK.andKnezevich,Alison.“SettlementinDecades-OldFairHousing
  • 7. 7 Case.”The Baltimore Sun.The Baltimore Sun,25August2012. Web.7 May 2016). By allowingamixture of people fromdifferentsocioeconomicclasses,itwill have apositiveeffectonthose livinginpoverty and strugglingtofinda wayout. Landlordsare one of the biggestproblemswithinthe program.Currently,landlordshave to registertheirpropertywithGoSection8.com, the websitewhere homesunderthe programare located. However,landlordsoftentake the voucherholdersto “disadvantagedneighborhoods,perpetuating housingsegregationandlimitingsocial mobility.Baltimore hasalonghistoryof segregation,buttoday, it persistswithinone of the veryprogramsdesignedtodismantle the problem:housingvouchers” (Rosen,Eva.“The Powerof Landlords.” The Atlantic. The Atlantic.9June 2015. 10 April 2016). Inorder to combat landlordsandtheirpowerinthe program, Marylandlegislationpassedabill thatdealtwithit; however,itistoosoonto say howeffectiveithasbeenorwill be. In 2012, Maryland legislationpassedabill knownasthe MarylandHousingOpportunitiesMade Equal (HOME) Act. Accordingtothe PublicJustice Center,the legislation“Prohibitslandlordsandother propertyownersfromdiscriminatingagainstpersonsseekinghousingbasedsolelyontheir ‘sourceof income.’ (MarylandGeneral Assembly.“HousingOpportunitiesMade Equal Act.”PublicJustice.org.n.d Web.2 May 2016). Historically,landlordshave beenanintegral partof the program.In orderto qualify theirpropertyforthe program,the landlordsmustpassthrougha seriesof checksdone bythe Baltimore HousingAuthorityinordertomake sure that the rent isreasonable andthe dwellingisin goodcondition.However,landlordsmayuse tacticssuch as raisingrentor onlyallowingpropertyin inner-cityorlow-income areastobe rentedoutto voucherholders.EvaRosen,ajournalistfor The Atlantic, arguesthat “Landlords…are salesmenaimingtopersuade potentialrenters,”butBaltimore is differentbecause they“lure renterstodisadvantagedneighborhoods,perpetuatinghousingsegregation and limitingsocial mobility.Baltimorehasalonghistoryof segregation,buttoday,itpersistswithinone of the veryprogramsdesignedtodismantlethe problem:housingvouchers”(Rosen,Eva.2015). In
  • 8. 8 anotherSunarticle,Dr. DeLuca suggestedthat“landlordsrefuse torenttopeople withSection8 housingbecause theyare unfairlyprejudicedagainstthose prospective tenants”(Gatton,James.2013) whichtiesintoBaltimore’shousingpoliciesof the 50s and 60s, whensegregationwasrampantaround the country. Landlordsmayalso raise rentforvoucherholders. Althoughthe voucherprogramissupposedto decrease the amountof rentbecause it’ssubsidizedbythe federal departmentunderthe Housingand Urban Developmentdepartment,rentmayincrease.Accordingtoan investigationdone byEvaRosenin The Atlantic, landlordshave aset of “tricks” theyuse to getprogram holdersinsidethe property.Rosen wrote “One landlordImethad two identical unitsinthe same building:The third-floorapartmentwas rentedtoa familywithavoucherandwentfor $250 more than the identical unitonthe fourth”(Rosen, Eva. “The Powerof Landlords.”TheAtlantic. The Atlantic.9 June 2015. 10 April 2016). However,because voucherholderstendtobe low-incomeandhave limitedoptionsformobility,transportationisanother issue. Because the program targets low-incomefamiliesorthose withdisabilities,housingtends centeredinareaswhere publictransportationisn’tserved,whichincreasesthe likelihoodof voucher holderstolive inimpoverishedneighborhoods.Forexample,Baltimore canceledthe RedLine,which wouldhave givenfamiliesin the neighborhoodswhere the line wastobe builtaccessto careersand more mobility. AccordingtoalawsuitfiledbyBaltimore againstthe “State of Maryland,Maryland Departmentof Transportation,MarylandTransitAdministration,andMarylandState Highway Administration”underTitle VIof the Civil RightsActof 1964, respondentsarguedthat the cancellation of the RedLine wouldimpactAfrican-Americansthe most,citing …more than thirty percentof residentsspendingmore thanforty-fiveminutestravelingtowork each day.Forty-fourpercentof householdsinthe RedLine corridorlacka vehicle;andinsome
  • 9. 9 neighborhoods,amajorityof householdshave novehicleandare entirelydependent onbuses for travel.Despite the significantreliance onthem, busestoooftenrunslowly,withspeedsfrom EdmonsonVillage todowntownof onlynine miles-per-hourduringpeaktravel times…TheRed Line wouldalsohave servedasthe necessarylinkconnectedWestBaltimore’spredominantly African-Americanneighborhoodstojobcenters. (“Baltimore RegionalInitiative Development Genuine Equality,Inc.,andEarl Andrewsvs.State of Maryland,MarylandDepartmentof transportation,MarylandTransitAdministration,andMarylandState HighwayAdministration.” N.d.Web.2 May 2016). The lack of mobilityhascontributedtothe increase of those livingonthe voucherprogram,and increasesthe likelihoodof livinginbadneighborhoods,whichcanhave lastingeffectsonchildren. A Baltimore Suninvestigationfoundthat Amongthe Baltimore region’sroughly25,000 voucherholders,more than60 percent-orabout 14,664 households-live inareasdeemed“low opportunity”,basedonmeasuresincluding education,povertyandcrime,accordingtoa reportissuedlastyearby the Baltimore MetropolitanCouncil (Sherman,Natalie.“HUDConsidersChange toSection8 Rents.”The Baltimore Sun. The Baltimore Sun.10 June 2015. Web.10 April 2016.) As a result,Baltimore hasbecome one of the mosthousing-segregatedneighborhoods, witha Baltimore Suneditorial arguingthat“Baltimore remainshome tosome of the mostdeeplysegregated pocketsof povertyinthe nation”, withmore affluentcitizensarguingandprotestingthattheywant voucherholderstostaywhere theyare because theywill bringdownpropertyvalue.Althoughthe Supreme Courthasdeemedsegregationunconstitutional,de factosegregationandpoliciesthatdonot favorthe African-Americanpopulationensuresthattheystayinimpoverishedconditions. AnotherproblemwithSection8is that housingisspreadingandaffluentcitizens aren’thappy aboutit, especiallythe more affluentresidentsinsurroundingcounties. Accordingtoa Baltimore Sun report,housingauthoritieshadspent“$12 milliontopurchase nearly30 housesinBaltimore Countyand 16 in Anne Arundel,HarfordandHowardcounties”andhad provided“$51 millioninrentsubsidiesto nearly3,100 familieswhohave movedfromcitypublichousingtoprivate apartmentsorhousesin prosperoussuburbanneighborhoods,primarilyinHowardandBaltimore counties”(Donovan,Doug.
  • 10. 10 “CityHousingProgramStirs FearsinBaltimore County.”The Baltimore Sun.The Baltimore Sun,14 December2015, Web.7 May 2016). Past Baltimore Sunarticlesandresearchdone bythinktankUrban Institute inWashington,D.C.showthatthe more affluentresidentswishtokeepthe poorinbad neighborhoodsandkeptinareaswithlimitedopportunitiesratherthanspreadthem.However, researchshowsthatif theyare giventhese opportunities,povertyratesdropdown.Accordingtoa Baltimore Suneditorial,the “Baltimoreregionhasapoor track recordwhenit comesto acceptance of policiesdesignedtohelplow-income,inner-cityresidentsmove tothe suburbs”,withacountyofficial callingthem“‘freeloaders’andnot‘qualitypeople’”(“HUDImperilsthe ColumbiaDream.”The Baltimore Sun.The Baltimore Sun,25 September2015. Web.7 May 2016). In complete contrast,MontgomeryCounty, one of the wealthiercountiesinMaryland,doesn’t have thisproblem.AccordingtoDavidRusk,the countyhas “one of the nation’smostcomprehensive and balancedlocal housingprogram”bycreatingthe “Moderately-PricedDwellingUnit(MPDU)”which allowedforamixture of differentsocioeconomicclassescomingtogether.The formulacreatedbythe program wasthat 85 percentof all unitswill be ‘marketrate’-thatis,soldorrentedtowhateverincome groupthe developeristargeting.10percentmustbe ‘affordable’-thatis,atpurchase pricesorrental levelsthat representnomore than30 percentof the income of householdsearningnomore than 80 percentof the county’smedianhouseholdincome…mostsignificantly,5percentmustbe made available fordirect purchase or rental bythe county’sHousingOpportunitiesCommissionforplacementof deep-subsidy households. Doingso allowsfora mixture of differentsocioeconomicclassesandallowsforimpoverished familiestogainsocial andeconomicmobility. Anotherproblemthe programdealswithisthe lackof housingavailableforpeopleonthe list.Anarticle inAfromagazine foundthatin2014, the listwouldbe openforthe firsttime inmore thanten yearsbecause of the lack of housing(Special,Roberto.2014). In a Baltimore Sunarticle,apersonwhowas on the vouchersince Julyandhasn’tbeenable tofindhousing
  • 11. 11 because of landlordsandclaimsof discriminatingon“potential tenantsbasedontheirsourcesof income”(Knezevich,Alison.2011). The Sundida deeperinvestigationintothe program, andfoundthat signupsforthe waitlisthave endeduntil 2020 withalmost74,000 applicants(Wenger,Yvonne.2014). In return,the opinionsectionandreadersrespondsectionof the Sunshotback,sayingthat if theyopenuppropertyto tenantstheylose money.Forexample,landlordJamesGattonexplainsthat“I experiencedfirsthandthe lossof two weeksSection8rental income overabustedplasticknobona range” (Gatton,James.2016), and othershave claimedthatthe paperworkandfilingitappropriate applicationsare anightmare.InanotherSunarticle, a readerwrote inresponse to Dr. DeLuca’s suggestion that“landlordsrefusetorenttopeople withSection8housingbecause theyare unfairly prejudicedagainstthose prospective tenants”(Gatton,James.2013).JamesGatton, a landlordinthe program,explainedthatthe “prejudice of landlords isdirectednotagainstthe people butagainstthe nightmare bureaucracythatSection8 rentalsentail”(Gatton,James.2013). WhenHUD SecretaryJulianCastro“announcedalandmarkchange inpolicydesignedtoreduce residentialsegregation”(“HUDImperilsthe ColumbiaDream.”The Baltimore Sun.The Baltimore Sun,25 September2015. Web.7 May 2016), not much has beendone yet. One factorinthe problemisthe lack of fundsandCongressional limitationsonadministrative costs.Currently,the programpoliciesare debatedona city bycity scale,andhousingauthoritiesare the final decisionsindecidingthe voucher program.In a 2014 article in The Atlantic, journalistAlanaSemuels,foundthatBaltimorehasmore than 16,000 vacant homesandabout 30,000 people willexperience homelessness.Inherresearch,she found that organizationssuchasHousingOur NeighborsandHousingisaHuman RightRoundtable,are fixing up these vacantlotsand turningthemintoaffordable homesforlow-incomeresidents.Inour presentation,Jesslookedatthe StationNorthneighborhood,wheregentrificationiscausingrenttorise, whichthenhas an effectonhousingthroughoutthe city.If the housingpricesinone areagohome,it
  • 12. 12 slowlyspreadsoutandpushesmore low-income residentsandfamiliesintoareaswhere povertyis more widespreadandcausesextendedfamiliestolive incrampedhousesthatmaynotbe sanitaryor hygienicforfamilieswithyoungchildren.The grouparguesthat“those homesshouldbe turnedinto affordable housing”(Semuels,Alana.2014),and whenpairedwithhousingpolicychangeswouldallow for more people togetonthe waitlistforhousing,andformore socioeconomicmobilityforpeople on the program. Thiscouldbe a potential solutiontothe currentone of allowingpoorpeople intowealthier neighborhoods,whichthe affluentcitizenshave complainedabout.Althoughmultiplestudiesshowthat whena childisexposedtodifferentsocioeconomicgroups,theyare more likelytolive inhigher-income neighborhoods,finisheducationandgoontohighereducation.Multiple Sunarticlesshow thatthe affluentcitizensthatsurroundBaltimore don’twantthese poorpeopletocome inbecause theyhaven’t workedforit or they’re leechingoff of federal help.However,manyof these familiesonfederal assistance andstate assistance programsare what’sconsidered“deservingpoor”,orthose that work and don’tmake enoughtomake endsmeetsotheyrelyon governmentassistance forhelp. As a citythat has facedsegregationinmultiple forms,housingisthe latestwaytobenefitthose inpower.ThinktankUrban Institute foundthatthe lackof social mobility,highrent,landlordswho don’thave theirrentersbestinterestsatheartandpoliciesall conspire tocreate a situationwhere it’s difficultforvoucherholderstomove up.The Baltimore Sunhasdone investigationsaboutthe situation, and wheneveranarticle comesoutit showsthatpotential situationspassedbyCongressorbythe Marylandlegislature have beendebatedonandarguedabout.Unsurprisingly,thosewhohave more powerwiththeirrepresentativestendtobe wealthierandwhiter,andare oftenthe onesthatdon’t wantpoor African-Americansintheirneighborhoodsbecause thatwill bringdown propertyvaluesand continue tobelievethattheyare there intheirneighborhoodsonlybecauseof governmentassistance.
  • 13. 13 However,it’snotjustBaltimore facingthese problems.Othermajorcitiesacrossthe countryare facingthe shortage of Section8 housing.Forexample,inAustin,Texasthere were “plentyof apartments aroundthe citythat voucher-holderscouldafford.Butonlyasmall portionof those apartmentswould rentto voucher-holders”(Semuels,Aana,2015).Similarly,inBaltimore there are vacanthousesthat couldbe usedfor housingthe homelessandvoucherholders. The program has beenconsideredafailure,butif itspoliciesare revised,the distributionof wealthisspreadmore equallywithamixture of low andhigh-income familieslivingtogether,landlords are heldaccountable fortheirpropertiesandnotdiscriminatingbasedonrace,havingalargerbudget for HUD, and allowingfamiliestolive inhigher-incomeneighborhoodsandallow themthe chance to findhigher-income jobs,thentheirmobilitywill increase andthenthe HousingChoice VoucherProgram may findsuccessinprograms.AlthoughBaltimoremaynotbe similartoMontgomeryCountyinits wealthdistribution,the wayMontgomeryCountyhasitshousingauthoritysetupisa way that Baltimore couldimitate tofindsuccessinitshousingprogram.
  • 14. 14 Bibliography “Baltimore’sHousingChoiceVoucherHomeownershipProgram.”HousingAuthorityof Baltimore. Departmentof HousingandCommunityDevelopment.N.d.Web.10 April 2016. DeLuca,Stefanie.“Whatisthe Role of HousingPolicy?ConsideringChoice andSocial Science Evidence.” Journalof Urban Affairs. Vol.34Issue 1: (2012): 21-28. Web.10 April 2016. Donovan,Doug.“CityHousingProgramStirs FearsinBaltimore County.”The Baltimore Sun.The Baltimore Sun,14 December2015, Web.7 May 2016). “HUD Imperilsthe ColumbiaDream.”The Baltimore Sun.The Baltimore Sun,25September2015. Web. 7 May 2016. Galvez,Martha M. “What Do We KnowAboutHousingChoice VoucherProgramLocationOutcomes?” Urban Institute.August2010. Web.10 April 2016. Gatton, JamesW.“Fix Section8 and LandlordsWill StepUp.” The BaltimoreSun. The Baltimore Sun,3 June 2013. Web. 15 May 2016. Gatton, JamesW.“Section8 Housingisa Nightmare forLandlords.” TheBaltimore Sun. The Baltimore Sun.12 May 2013. Web.15 May 2016. “GoSection8.”Go Section8 Housing.N.d.Web.10 April 2016. Katz,StevenB.“The Ethic of Expediency: Classical Rhetoric,Technology,andthe Holocaust.”College English.54:3 (1992): 255-275. Web.
  • 15. 15 Knezevich,Alison.“Measure WouldProhibitLandlordsfromDiscriminatingAgainstSection8.” The Baltimore Sun.The Baltimore Sun.9 December2011, Web. 15 May 2016. Newman,SandraJ.“Low-EndRental Housing:The ForgottenStoryinBaltimore’sHousingBoom.”N.d. Web.10 April 2016. “PropertyManagers.”HousingAuthorityof Baltimore.Departmentof HousingandCommunity Development.N.d.Web.10April 2016. Rosen,Eva.“The Powerof Landlords.” TheAtlantic. The Atlantic.9 June 2015. 10 April 2016. Rusk,David.“Baltimore Unbound:A StrategyforRegional Renewal.”Baltimore:JohnsHopkins UniversityPress,1995. Print. Semuels,Alana.“HowHousingPolicyisFailingAmerica’sPoor.”TheAtlantic. The Atlantic,24 June 2015. Web.15 May 2016. Sherman,Natalie.“HUDConsidersChange toSection8Rents.” The Baltimore Sun. The Baltimore Sun.10 June 2015. Web. 10 April 2016. Special,RobertoAlejandro.“Baltimore’sSection8WaitingListto OpenforFirst Time inOver10 Years.” Afro.6 October2014. Web.15 May 2016. Turner,Margery Austin.“StrengthsandWeaknessesof the HousingVoucherProgram.”UrbanInstitute. 17 June 2003. Web.10 April 2016. Turner,Margery Austin,Popkin,SusanJ.,Cunningham, MaryK.“Section8 MobilityandNeighborhood Health.”Urban Institute.1April 2000. 10 April 2016.
  • 16. 16 UnitedStates.Departmentof HousingandUrban Development.“Section8ProgramBackground Information.”N.d.Web.2May 2016). UnitedStatesDepartmentof Transportation.2015. ComplaintPursuantToTitle VIOf The Civil RightsAct of 1964. Baltimore:MarylandDepartmentof Transportation. Walker,AndreaK.and Knezevich,Alison.“SettlementinDecades-OldFairHousingCase.”The Baltimore Sun.The Baltimore Sun,25 August2012. Web.7 May 2016). Wenger,Yvonne.“Nearly74,000 SignUp forBaltimore’sSection8WaitList.” The BaltimoreSun. The Baltimore Sun,31 October2014. Web.15 May 2016.