1. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 1
Frank van Tuijl – Program Coordinator
SmartLighting conference 2015
Berlin
Energy efficient & intelligent lighting systems
EnLight
A distributed, rules based lighting control
system demonstrates significant energy
savings with optimal user comfort
2. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 2
Content
1. Project introduction
2. Key innovation areas
3. Architectural choices
4. Intelligent Luminaire
5. Demonstration Pilots
6. Energy saving & comfort results
7. Conclusions
3. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 3
Project aim
To reduce energy consumption by 40% compared
to LED retrofit systems by:
• Energy efficient light source: -20%
– Electrical efficiency – Integrated drivers
– Power supply
– Communication & control
– Optical efficiency – Higher LOR
– Thermal efficiency – Lower Tj
• Intelligent control: -20%:
– The right light,
– at the right amount
– at the right place
– at the right time
Applications & energy
saving strategies:
Control
system
4. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 4
Consortium
27 Partners
3½ Years, Jun 2011- Nov 2014
ENAS,
IIS/EAS
IZM
5. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 5
Distributed intelligence
The paradigm of ‘Control by configuration’:
• Luminaires act autonomously instead of being instructed
• Sensors inform luminaires instead of controlling them
• The luminaire’s behavior (set of rules) is configured, not hard-coded
Individual Luminaires make their own lighting decisions based upon:
• Presence or ambient light level information from embedded sensors
• Events from other nodes (external sensors, luminaires, user controls, …)
6. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 6
Modular intra-luminaire architecture
.
Modular intra-luminaire architecture with standard Plug-and-play bus interface
to decouple lifecycles of independent technologies.
Enables market players to contribute, differentiate and compete.
7. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 7
Architectural choices
Project Objectives
- Reduce energy consumption
- Improve user comfort
- Easy to install/maintain
Requirements
- Granular control
- Granular sensing
- Reconfigurable application
- Wireless/wired connectivity
- Reliable operation
- Color control
- Data collection
- Low cost
-
Choices
- Autonomous luminaires
- Local control
- Local sensing
- Local monitoring
- Priority driven control
- Rule base behavior
- Publish/Subscribe
- ZigBee/IP
- MySQL database
To arbitrate
between different
control strategies
Effective with low
footprint
Loose coupling,
scalable network
8. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 8
Why distributed control?
• Scalability:
– Investments, complexity and intelligence grow linear with number of nodes
• Modularity and extensibility:
– Nodes can be easily added, changed and (re-)configured
– Enables luminaire differentiation in functionality and performance
• Effectiveness and reduced complexity:
– Less complex commissioning when using local embedded sensors
– Granular sensing and control increase overall energy efficiency
• Robustness:
– No single point of failure but graceful degradation when node fails
• Cost effective:
– Marginal cost increase for digital connected luminaire (Moore’s law)
– Eliminates the need for central lighting controller and area/group controllers
Note 1: A distributed control architecture does not prohibit centralized control
Note 2: Lighting management remains centralized
9. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 9
Power supply
LED Light Engines
PIR/LL sensors 3D sensor
Bolometer Radar sensor Smart device Switches
Buck driver
Boost driver
Embedded PIR/LL/temp sensors
Controller
Level:
1. System
2. Fixture
3. Module
Intelligent
Luminaires
External sensors
local user controls
Building blocks
10. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 10
Highlight ILB modules
• LED drivers: Compact 3- and 4-channel
based on NXP’s UBA3070 (buck) and
UBA3077 (boost), >95% efficiency,
expandable
• Embedded controller based on NXP’s existing
Jennic processor family (JN5168)
• Embedded sensors: Combined PIR, light level
and temperature sensors
• Power-supplies: 20W and 75W with high
efficiency up to 94% over dimming range,
+24V+5V, galvanic isolation, standby power
mode
11. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 11
Intelligent PowerBalance
4-channel concept:
CW/WW/Blue/Amber
16x
2x3ch
WW
A
CW
B Intra-luminaire
bus
12. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 12
Intelligent Luminaire features
• Local rule based engine
– 250 rules
– Programmable over the air
• 250 presets, 16 priority levels
• Independent Color control and Dimming
• Multiple independent LED light engines
• Sensors: PIR / Light Level / Temperature
• Closed loop light level control
• ZigBee
• Local logging of presence and energy consumption (24 hours)
• Intra-luminaire bus ready
Intra-luminaire
bus
13. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 13
Luminaires examples
• Intelligent (mini) PowerBalance
– Recessed luminaire
– 4-channel LED strings (CW/WW/Amber/Blue)
for tunable white applications
– Integrated PIR/light level/temperature sensor
• Wedge
– Expandable RGBW decorative tile
– Independent control per tile
• Intelligent Glow
– Suspended luminaire
– Independent task and ambient light (RGBW)
– Integrated PIR/light level/temperature sensor
.
14. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 14
Demonstrations
• Office1 @Philips Lighting, Eindhoven
– Areas: Corridor, Open Office, meeting room
• Office2 @VTT, Oulu
– Multi-functional area: Office, meeting
room, demonstration space
• Hospitality @ Osram, Garching
– Hotel room: bedroom, bathroom, corridor
15. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 15
• Circadian rhythm (CCT adaptation)
Demonstration - Open office
ssssssssssssssss
ssssssssssssssss
• Room occupancy detection
• Automated on/off is default setting to activate ambient light
• Desk presence/activity detection
• Automatic task light activation per desk
• Create light bubble with neighboring luminaires
• Task light tuning
• Use of Desk lights reduce overall power consumption
while keeping minimum required lighting levels.
• Daylight regulation (constant Lux-level)
16. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 16
Demonstration – Corridor
• Background light triggered by any presence sensor
– Ends of the corridor brighter
– Neighboring rooms trigger background light
• Light bubble (follow me)
– Smooth transition to background to make
the bubble invisible
• Part of the corridor is triggered by the entrance presence
sensor (never see a dark corridor)
• Circadian rhythm
17. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 17
Energy savings – Corridor
Traditional PIR control : 5.9 kWh/day
Enlight, light bubble : 4.1 kWh/day
Savings due to control : 30%
100%
71% 71%
47%
20%
presence
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
0 5 10 15 20 25
Traditional
Enlight
Presence
Energy savings
from ‘bubble’
18. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 18
Validation results
• 30% energy savings compared to LED state-of-the-art in Office
– Gain from granular control strategies (bubbles, daylight)
• 45% .. 80% energy savings compared to LED retrofit,
– Office 1&2: 45%
– Hospitality: 80%, more gain in luminaire efficiency, more absence time
• Results exceed the global building energy performance
benchmarks (ie. LEED 18 credit pnts, ASHRAE, Title24, …)
• Equal or even increased user comfort compared to baselines.
Over 80% of the users prefer Enlight system
EnLight Energy Saving target (40%) well surpassed
19. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 19
Energy saving results (vs LED SotA)
-34%
-30%
-26%
-30%
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Open Office Corridor Meeting Room Total Building
LED non-retrofit
2012
Enlight 2012
LENIKWh/m2,a
Overall , Enlight 2012 system is 30% more energy efficient than the
baseline LED state-of-the –art system with standard room control
20. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 20
Open Office efficiency breakdown
34 %
Combined
34 %
Combined
+4 %
Desklights
+4 %
Desklights
-1 %
Luminous
Effiicacy
-1 %
Luminous
Effiicacy
-37 %
Granular occupancy
and daylight control
-37 %
Granular occupancy
and daylight control
-4 %
illuminance
correction
-4 %
illuminance
correction
+4 %
Standby
Power
+4 %
Standby
Power
21. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 21
Corridor efficiency breakdown
32 %
Combined
32 %
Combined
+5 %
Standby
Power
+5 %
Standby
Power
-21 %
Illuminance
correction
-21 %
Illuminance
correction
-27 %
‚‘Bubble‘
control
-27 %
‚‘Bubble‘
control
+7 %
Luminous
efficacy
+7 %
Luminous
efficacy
+3 %
Wedge
+3 %
Wedge
-32%
0,0
2,0
4,0
6,0
8,0
10,0
12,0
Corridor
KWh/m2,a
22. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 22
Validation results
• 30% energy savings compared to LED state-of-the-art in Office
– Gain from granular control strategies (bubbles, daylight)
• 45% .. 80% energy savings compared to LED retrofit,
– Office 1&2: 45%
– Hospitality: 80%, more gain in luminaire efficiency, more absence time
• Results exceed the global building energy performance
benchmarks (ie. LEED 18 credit pnts, ASHRAE, Title24, …)
• Equal or even increased user comfort compared to baselines.
Over 80% of the users prefer Enlight system
EnLight Energy Saving target (40%) well surpassed
23. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 23
22,3
12,4
0
5
10
15
20
25
Office
20%
luminaire design
30%
intelligent
control
44%
EnLightLEDRetrofitw.standardcontrol
Enlight
LENI[kWh/m2,a]
Office energy saving results
24. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 24
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
LENI[kWh/(a·m2
)]
81 %
EnLight
Retrofitw/ocontrol
EnLightw/ocontrol
42 %
luminaire design
67 %
intelligent control
67 %
intelligent controlEnLight
Hospitality energy saving results
25. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 25
Validation results
• 30% energy savings compared to LED state-of-the-art in Office
– Gain from granular control strategies (bubbles, daylight)
• 45% .. 80% energy savings compared to LED retrofit,
– Office 1&2: 45%
– Hospitality: 80%, more gain in luminaire efficiency, more absence time
• Results exceed the regional building energy performance
benchmarks (ie. LEED 18 credit pnts, ASHRAE, Title24, …)
• Equal or even increased user comfort compared to baselines.
Over 80% of the users prefer Enlight system
EnLight Energy Saving target (40%) well surpassed
26. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 26
EN15193 Office**Ashrae90.1
Ashrae90.1
Ashrae90.1
Title24
Title24
Title24
LEDretrofit2014
LEDretrofit2014
LEDretrofit2014
LEDretrofit2014
Enlight2014
Enlight2014
Enlight2014
Enlight2014
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
Open Office Corridor Meeting room Total Building
EN15193 Office**
Ashrae 90.1
Title 24
LED retrofit 2014
Enlight 2014
LENI[KWh/m2,a]
18pt
LENI Benchmarks
EnLight2014
Best-in-class energy efficiency results compared to global building
energy performance benchmarks
EnLight2014
EnLight2014
EnLight2014
18pt
18pt
0pt
0pt
0pt
27. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 27
Validation results
• 30% energy savings compared to LED state-of-the-art in Office
– Gain from granular control strategies (bubbles, daylight)
• 45% .. 80% energy savings compared to LED retrofit,
– Office 1&2: 45%
– Hospitality: 80%, more gain in luminaire efficiency, more absence time
• Results exceed the global building energy performance
benchmarks (ie. LEED 18 credit pnts, ASRAE, Title24, …)
• Equal or even increased user comfort compared to baselines.
Over 80% of the users prefer Enlight system
EnLight Energy Saving target (40%) well surpassed
28. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 28
User comfort validation results
• The energy saving of the Enlight system does not diminish the
(visual) comfort of the office employees during their daily work.
• 80% prefers the energy saving EnLight system over state-of-the-art
LED reference system due to energy savings.
Good communication and awareness of the benefits are important to introduce new
lighting control systems.
• Smooth fading times are essential.
Noticeable changes of light are disturbing.
• People like to have control over changes in light.
Desk light is well appreciated to have control over the amount of light.
29. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 29
Summary
• EnLight explored a next generation distributed, rule-based lighting control
system and a modular Plug-and-Play intra-luminaire bus architecture
• EnLight proved that significant value can be added to the luminaire by
distributing the central control function over the individual luminaires
• In pilots, EnLight system with its inherent granular lighting control has
demonstrated energy savings from 30% for office applications to 60% for
hospitality applications while providing the same or a better level of user
comfort as today’s standard LED solutions
• Energy efficiency results exceed the best in class scores of the regional
building energy performance benchmarks (i.e. EN15193, ASHRAE,Title24,
LEED)
30. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 30
Thank you
www.enlight-project.eu
31. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 31
Questions
www.enlight-project.eu
32. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 32
Enlight won the ENIAC 2014
Innovation Award
33. Smart Lighting Conference | Berlin | Frank van Tuijl | Public | 20 May 2015 | Slide 33
LED Professional Magazine, Apr 2015