SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 10
Download to read offline
Water & Development Publications - Helsinki University of TechnologyAB 
THE HIDDEN ROLE OF INFORMAL ECONOMY: 
IS INFORMAL ECONOMY INSIGNIFICANT FOR 
PHNOM PENH’S DEVELOPMENT? 
Ulla Heinonen 
Water Resources Laboratory, Helsinki University of Technology, Finland 
Informal economy is often stated as a temporary phenomenon which diminishes along economic growth. 
The sector is regularly taken as granted and its role for development is not properly seen. Around 80 percent 
of the GDP in Cambodia is produced by the informal sector. Informal economy is also important for the 
country’s urban areas and particularly for the country’s capital city. The economic development of Phnom 
Penh, the capital, is combined with a growth in its non-agricultural informal sector. At the same time the 
city’s slum settlements are mushrooming, creating more pressures on the informal sector. As a result, many 
of the city’s informal workers have become working poors. Without proper protection and legalization 
of the informal sector, these poor citizens cannot be lifted up from the poverty trap and the sustainable 
development of the city cannot be achieved. 
In the 1970s informal sector became a common 
topic in international development discussions. 
Informality was identifi ed as a continued existence 
of traditional activities and production methods 
that would disappear along with industrialization 
and modernization (Straub, 2005). The sector 
was seen marginal for growth and separate from 
the formal sector. However, later on the informal 
economy has increased, particularly in the 
Corresponding author: 
Ulla Heinonen 
Water Resources Laboratory 
Helsinki University of Technology - TKK 
P.O. Box 5200, FIN-02015 TKK, Finland 
Email: ulla.heinonen@tkk.fi 
countries where income is not equally distributed, 
and has become an integrated part of the economy 
in many countries (Becker, 2004). Thus, the 
informal economy - the refi ned defi nition of the 
International Labour Organisation (ILO) - could 
no longer be seen as a temporary phenomenon, or 
as a phenomenon that straightforwardly decreases 
with economic growth. 
In the recent decades the sector has grown around 
the world and it is currently the largest “economy” 
in many countries (ILO, 2002). It seems to be 
that if economic growth is not accompanied 
by improvements in employment and income 
distribution, the informal economy does not shrink. 
Instead, it seems to expand, both in urban and in 
1 Introduction to informal economy 
© 2008 TKK & Heinonen ISBN 978-951-22-9102-1 
Kummu, M., Keskinen, M. & Varis, O. (eds.): Modern Myths of the Mekong, pp. 123-132
124 
Modern Myths of the Mekong - Part III: Development 
2 Economy, employment, and 
informality in Cambodia 
2.1 Defi nition of the informal economy in 
Cambodia 
The lack of consistent empirical measurements 
is evident in Cambodia, where the impact and 
volume of the informal economy has not been 
properly analyzed and its role in the country’s 
economy is poorly recognized. In Cambodia, the 
informal economy is defi ned as actions without 
offi cial or solid legal status, regulation or protection 
by state institutions, or as actions that are identifi ed 
with some of the following characteristics (Amin, 
2002; Becker, 2004): 
1. No fi rm or postal address 
2. Employees are self-employed 
or road-side vendors 
3. No data through census survey are available 
or the activities are not recognised 
4. Labour-intensive nature of 
operations and quick turnover 
5. Use of energy input from 
human or animal sources 
6. Non-structured premises without 
regulations, licences, insurance, or taxes 
rural areas. Besides, there exist evident linkages 
between the informal and formal economies. 
The informal sector provides services for formal 
actors, offers a fl exible labour market to absorb 
the surplus labour and has a signifi cant income 
and job generation potential (Becker, 2004). The 
studies of the World Bank (2004) showed that the 
majority of informal services are sold to individual 
customers, commonly to poor and middle-income 
urban dwellers (Bhowmik, 2005). The informal 
sector supplies products and services, which are 
not provided by the formal sector, or are otherwise 
unreachable for the poor citizens (Ishengoma & 
Kappel 2006). 
The informal economy is very heterogeneous in 
terms of actors, activities, and scales (Sethuraman, 
1997). The sector varies between countries, 
economies, and cultures (Thomas, 1995). In some 
countries the term ‘informal economy’ refers 
to the private sector, in some to grey economy 
(Trebilcock, 2005). It is a controversial topic 
and as a result there exist disagreements about 
its defi nition, estimation procedures, and their 
use in economic analysis (Schneider, 2002). 
The current defi nition of the informal economy 
includes a large amount of heterogeneity instead 
of conceptualising the term narrowly (Ishengoma 
& Kappel, 2006). 
Schneider (2002) defi nes informal activities as 
unregistered economic activities that contribute 
to the offi cially calculated (or observed) Gross 
National Product. Thomas (1995) and Trebilcock 
(2005), on the other hand, characterise the 
informal economy as economic activities that, 
for various reasons, are not fully reported in the 
National Income Accounts or are insuffi ciently 
covered by formal arrangements. In other words, 
the informal economy contributes to the country’s 
economy but the activities are informal in terms 
of registration, tax payments, operating licences, 
conditions of employment, or regulations (Becker, 
2004). 
A modest progress in measuring the informal 
economy is achieved and presently there exist 
numerous ways of measurement: working hours, 
share of the labour force, percent of GDP, 
consumption of electricity and currency demand 
(Schneider, 2002). Theoretical understanding of 
the causes and consequences is, nevertheless, still 
lagging in many parts of the world (Straub, 2005). 
Informal activities take place in many forms. The 
work varies from part-time jobs after working 
hours, to work of immigrants who are not allowed 
to work in the formal sector (Schneider, 2002). In 
general, informal activities can be categorised into 
two sections: self-employed and non-permanent 
labour. In all developing countries the self-employed 
labour comprises a greater share of 
informal employment. This sector includes persons 
working as street vendors, taxi drivers, or in home-based 
enterprises. In Asia self-employment covers 
around 60 percent of the total informal sector 
(Becker, 2004).
Heinonen - The hidden role of informal economy 
4500 
4000 
3500 
3000 
2500 
2000 
1500 
1000 
500 
0 
Garment Tourism Agriculture Others 
Million US$/ 
Thousands 
GDP and Labour Force by Subsectors ( 2001) 
Total GDP by Subsectors 
Labour Force 
Formal Informal 
125 
2.2 Employment and informality 
A recent civil war, defi cient infrastructure, political 
instability, and extensive corruption have hindered 
the Cambodian economic development (World 
Bank, 2003; 2004). In 2004 around 35 percent of 
the 14 million Cambodians lived under the poverty 
line (~1,800 riels/person/day) (World Bank, 2006). 
Lately the country’s economy has, however, shown 
signs of recovery, and the economic growth has 
been around 6 percent. Nevertheless, the growth 
has not been stable and inequality remains high. 
Agriculture is a very important sector in Cambodia 
covering 40 percent of the country’s GDP and 
employing 70 percent of the population. Service 
and industrial sectors are less important. Service 
sector employees around 20 percent and industrial 
sector 10 percent of the population (Ministry 
of Planning, 2001). As a poor agrarian country, 
Cambodia is very vulnerable to changes in natural 
resources. Drought and fl oods in the recent years, 
for example, have seriously affected the country’s 
economy. Diminishing agricultural activities and 
unemployment in rural areas have pushed people 
out of their villages in search of employment in 
towns and cities (Heinonen, 2006). Rural migrants 
do not often have the necessary skills or education to 
allow them to fi nd better paid, secure employment 
in the formal sector and hence they often end up 
working informally (Bhowmik, 2005). 
The informal economy provides around 90 percent 
of all employment in Cambodia (Monyrath, 2005). 
The sector employs the majority of the 200,000 to 
250,000 new workers entering the job market each 
year, while the country’s formal sector absorbs only 
15,000 new labourers annually (USG, 2003; World 
Bank, 2004). Agriculture and agro-industry cover 
majority of the employment in the informal sector 
(Figure 1). However, the non-agricultural informal 
sector is twice the size of the formal in terms of 
GDP and labour force. It is also a largest employer 
in the urban areas. The informal sector provides 
around 60 to 80 percent of the Gross Domestic 
Product of the country (Monyrath, 2005; USG, 
2003). Non-agricultural informal activities mostly 
in urban areas cover the greatest share, around 
1,653 million dollars (Figure 1). 
The garment and tourism industries and public 
administration dominate the small formal sector 
(Monyrath, 2005; Bajpai, 2004). Formal jobs 
provided by the government are few and they are 
not well paid (Bhowmik, 2005). Majority of the 
formal employment in Cambodia is very poorly 
paid, which pushes people to do extra work in 
the informal sector. Most of the part-time moto-taxi 
drivers in Phnom Penh, for instance, are 
government employees (USG, 2003). The formal 
private sector in Cambodia is also relatively small 
and limited, facing innumerable transaction costs 
Figure 1 The GDP from the informal sector is four times higher than from the formal sector (USG, 2003).
126 
and barriers to operate (USG, 2003). To start a 
business in Cambodia is very time-consuming and 
costly, compared to the neighbouring countries. 
The taxes and bribes are lower in the informal 
sector and this is often the main reason why people 
do not register their activities (World Bank, 2004; 
Straub, 2005; Ishengoma & Kappel, 2006). 
3 Informal economy in Phnom Penh 
There are three dominant sectors offering 
formal employment in Phnom Penh: public 
administration, garment industry and tourism 
(Monyrath, 2005). It is evident that these sectors 
are not able to offer employment for all of the city’s 
new dwellers that the city is gaining by its 4 percent 
annual growth. In addition, in many cases the 
formal sector is unable to provide enough income 
for its employees. Based on this mismatch majority 
of the Phnom Penh’s citizens work informally, 
at least on a part-time basis (Agnello & Moller, 
2003). 
Even though Cambodian formal sectors are 
primarily located in the towns and cities, 
particularly in Phnom Penh, informality runs the 
city’s economy. The informal economic activities 
– micro- and small enterprises, market sellers, 
non-permanent labour workers, moto-taxi drivers, 
and domestic helpers - have a major role in the 
economic performance of the capital city. 
The informal economy tends also to absorb most 
of the growing labour force related to rural-urban 
migration when the manufacturing industry 
and off-farm activities do not grow with the 
same rapidity. The sector also answers the needs 
of the seasonal migrants coming to the city to 
earn supplementary income particularly in the 
dry season. And it also attracts rural migrants 
to Phnom Penh to provide low-cost goods and 
services for those employed in the formal and 
informal economies (Becker, 2004). The growth 
in the city’s garment industry couple of years 
ago, for instance, led to an increase in informal 
activities such as transportation, food, beverages, 
and accommodation to serve the people working 
in the formal sector. This also encouraged rural 
dwellers to migrate to the city (Monyrath, 2005). 
Modern Myths of the Mekong - Part III: Development 
3.1 Informality and poverty 
Urban poverty and informal employment are 
closely connected. Poor people in developing 
countries are often forced to work in the informal 
economy because of lack of capital and skills, 
gender, or ethnicity, which make them insignifi cant 
for the main labour force (Etherington & Simon, 
1996). The studies of the International Labour 
Organisation show that informal status often 
means a greater likelihood of income variability, 
decline, and insecurity (Trebilcock, 2005). 
Informal economy attracts workforce from diverse 
backgrounds and, as a consequence, the labour 
force is very heterogeneous. Initial capital, gender, 
domicile, education, and contacts all infl uence 
the capabilities of informal employees to survive 
in their jobs. Often the rural migrants tend to fall 
into the lowest category of the informal economy 
(Trebilcock, 2005). 
This is also common in Phnom Penh, where rural 
migrants and poor people dominate the labour 
force of the informal economy. The surveys of 
Etherington& Simon (1996) showed that in Phnom 
Penh the rural migrants often end up working as 
cyclo-drivers or temporary labourers. For example, 
over 70 percent of waste pickers in the city are poor 
rural migrants (Amin, 2002), whereas poor urban 
dwellers more often work as service sector workers 
or street vendors. This kind of division indicates 
that the rural migrants have low social status in the 
city and thus they have problems in exploiting of 
the informal credit systems. 
The informal economy is the most important 
employer for the poor inhabitants of Phnom Penh. 
At present, 80 percent of the city’s 400,000 slum 
dwellers are employed in the informal economy 
(SUPF, 2003; URC, 2004). In addition, many 
children are involved in informal activities, 
working as shoe cleaners, rag pickers, sellers 
or beggars. The customary informal works in 
Phnom Penh are: mototaxi- and cyclo-drivers, 
food, gasoline and vegetable sellers, construction 
workers, electricity and water sellers, motorcycle 
repairers, rubbish collectors, brick workers and 
house servants (USG, 2003). There is an evident 
linkage between the work types in the informal
127 
Heinonen - The hidden role of informal economy 
sector, and the work types of the slum dwellers. 
Hence, relation between poverty and the informal 
economy, as a result of poor working conditions, 
and low income levels, is obvious (Sethuraman, 
1997; Ishengoma & Kappel, 2006). 
Figure 2 presents the obstacles that a poor private 
sector worker faces when trying to reach Phnom 
Penh’s formal sector. Most of the poor workers live 
in slums. They do not have secure tenure, proper 
housing or public services. They need informal 
products and services because they cannot reach 
the formal ones. As rural migrants, the workers 
often have a low social capital and do not have an 
interest in other activities than earning income 
(particularly seasonal migrants). These people 
mostly work in the informal sector because the 
formal jobs are limited and they do not have skills 
for these jobs. In addition, they do not have initial 
capital to start a proper business, the access to 
formal credit services is limited, and they do not 
have know-how about the registration activities 
and the forms that the formal sector could support 
them. 
Informal activities are often targets of extortion and 
harassment by the public authorities. The work of 
the informal workers is disturbed by fi nes, different 
payments (e.g. hygiene), and violations, and due to 
all this emotional stress (Figure 2). Phnom Penh’s 
informal activities are not regulated. However, 
there are many regulations in the places where 
informal workers operate, and not following these 
guidelines (e.g. selling restrictions) leads to fi ning 
(USG, 2003). Bribes for the public authorities are 
also common, particularly for street vendors and 
micro-enterprises. All these stresses have an impact 
on the workers ability to survive in the city. As most 
of the informal workers are rarely organised, this 
hinders their ability to negotiate with the public 
authorities (Monyrath, 2005). 
The regulation jungle drives the informal activities 
out from the authorized structures and, as a result, 
people work in the informal sector. The studies 
of the Urban Sector Group (USG, 2003) among 
Phnom Penh’s informal workers revealed that 
there are: a lack of information about registration 
methods, regulations and costs; not enough 
benefi ts compared to the amount of money that 
is needed for registration; wide opinion that 
small companies cannot be registered; and lack 
of information about where, when and how to 
register. 
Formal Sector 
Formal Services 
Regulations 
Fines 
Payments 
Violations 
Emotional Stress 
Informal Employment 
Formal Employment 
Informal Sector 
Worker 
Lack of: 
Skills 
Capital 
Credit 
Know-how 
Informal Services 
Lack of: 
Secure Tenure 
Proper Housing 
Social Capital 
Figure 2 The informal worker faces many obstacles. Broken lines illustrate the barriers along the way.
60 
50 
40 
30 
20 
10 
0 
Modern Myths of the Mekong - Part III: Development 
water sources and resell it to poor and middle-income 
inhabitants (USG, 2003). The survey 
of the Urban Sector Group (2003) reveals that 
an informal water seller earns roughly 346,000 
riels monthly (87 US$), which is twice the salary 
that the government can offer. However, these 
activities are not regulated, which creates great 
challenges in terms of providing safe water supply 
particularly for the Phnom Penh’s poor citizens 
(Heinonen, 2008). 
Education of the Informal Sector Workers 
in Phnom Penh 
128 
4 Discussion – How to legalise 
informal sector? 
The municipality of Phnom Penh seeks for poverty 
reduction and aims for economic development. 
When aiming to urban poverty reduction the 
problems of the city’s poor informal workers are 
those to be addressed (Monyrath, 2005). Every 
day around 300 000 slum dwellers work in Phnom 
Penh’s informal sector (SUPF, 2003). In addition, 
the slums absorbs majority of the city’s increasing 
population. Addressing this group would thus have 
an infl uence on almost half of the city’s informal 
workers. 
The poor informal workers face many barriers in 
their daily existence and they carry a high risk of 
becoming working poor with earnings insuffi cient 
to raise themselves and their families above the 
3.2 Other side of the coin 
There is also another side in the Phnom Penh’s 
informal economy. And therefore it is too one-dimensional 
to associate informality directly with 
poverty. The studies of Chantly (1999) showed that 
the informal economy also provides employment 
for educated workers with entrepreneurial 
potential and skills (Figure 3). This indicates that 
the formal economy is unable to provide adequate 
employment for educated persons and thus they 
choose the opportunities that the informal sector 
has to offer (Amin, 2002). 
The fi gure below is a clear evidence of inadequate 
governance and regulations, and the fact that the 
Phnom Penh’s formal sector is unable to provide 
enough income for its workers. One of the country’s 
challenges is thus to create productive jobs in the 
formal economy. Otherwise there is little hope for 
city’s sustainable economic growth. Phnom Penh 
cannot afford to lose the capabilities of educated 
citizens with potential skills (Chantly, 1999). 
Phnom Penh’s informal sector also offers a 
playground for private companies that do not 
want to register because of the costs. The city’s 
informal private water services, for example, offer 
employment for thousands of informal workers. 
The private vendors buy water from city water 
offi cials or obtain water from ground or surface 
Figure 3 The informal economy of Phnom Penh also attracts educated people (Chantly, 1999; Amin, 2002).
129 
poverty line (ILO, 2004). Even though the work 
in the informal sector is the way to earn some 
food on the table, the jobs are poorly paid, have 
poor working conditions, no social protection 
and excludes workers form social dialogue and 
decision-making, trapping its workers deeper into 
poverty (Ishengoma & Kappel, 2006). 
To push informal workers from this trap, however, 
is easier said than done. Already, in the Urban 
Poverty Reduction Strategy of Phnom Penh in 1999, 
many good ways to improve the situation of urban 
poor were stated (Municipality of Phnom Penh, 
1999). Nevertheless, the results have been weak. 
The city’s poor informal workers have worked very 
hard, often in unhealthy conditions and facing 
many obstacles. Still they remain poor either 
poorer than before. These workforces have made 
signifi cant contributions to the city’s development. 
The sector has kept down the urbanisation cost 
of the city by promoting fl exible labour market, 
absorbing extra labour from the formal sector and 
promoted the city by services such as water, energy 
and solid waste collection (Amin, 2002; Monyrath, 
2005). But still, the signifi cance of the sector is not 
adequately recognized by the municipality. 
To be able to guide the poor informal workers 
for better achievements and have a real impact 
in their level of livelihood, there is a great need 
for appropriate regulations, laws and policies. 
Regulating the activities of the informal sector, 
however, is an immense challenge. There is no one 
policy intervention that could address such a diverse 
entity. Additionally very often the increasing fi scal 
and regulatory burden leads to the enlargement 
of the informal sector or puts more troubles on 
informal workers activities (Palmade, 2002). To 
be able to legalize and regulate the sector, more 
information and dialogue with the informal sector 
is needed. The regulations need to be sensitive 
so as to be able to increase the productivity, 
quality, and working conditions of the informal 
sector (Becker, 2004). Only by understanding 
the needs and identifying the obstacles, that the 
informal sector is facing, proper and sustainable 
regulations can be established. Just putting extra 
pressure on the informal sector turns development 
in an unwanted direction (Palmade, 2002). The 
regulations cannot be the same for poor informal 
workers and the informal companies that just want 
to avoid the extra burdens of registration. 
The fi rst requirement in integrating Phnom 
Penh’s informal sector into the formal is providing 
land (Amin, 2002). Land and housing are not only 
the place to accommodate, they are often also the 
places to generate income. Hence, including poor 
people in the urban planning both in terms of 
their housing as well as of their income generation 
is vital for legalizing and regulating informal 
activities. The city’s slum settlements as well as 
the informal workers have been excluded from 
Phnom Penh’s development strategies and there 
have not been clear processes of city zoning and 
land use planning, which would also address the 
needs of the urban poor. In addition, the city does 
not have land-banking system for development 
purposes and when the demand for land is high 
due to the growing population and increasing 
investments, the poor have had a little room in 
the development discussions (Sophy, 2002). The 
study on Land Availability for City Development 
(2002) identifi ed, that there is a great need for 
reserving and allocating land for poor as well as set 
up a land development bank for reserving land for 
future community projects and investments. 
The living conditions of the poor do not improve 
without decent work and income (Amin, 2002). 
This is also a reason why many slum upgrading 
processes have not led to long-term development. 
As a consequence, the upgrading processes of poor 
settlements that are taking place in the Phnom 
Penh needs to include also other aspects than just 
upgrading the housing and services (Heinonen, 
2008).The city-wide and bottom-up participation 
approach of Asian Coalition for Housing Rights, 
for instance, could be one effi cient approach to 
also address the Phnom Penh’s informal workers 
(Heinonen, 2008). 
To make the development sustainable in the long 
run, education, training schemes and support to 
workers’ organisations are essential for the capacity 
building of the informal workers. Via workers’ 
Heinonen - The hidden role of informal economy
130 
organisations the informal sectors’ workers will get 
information about the regulations as well as the 
ways of registration. To avoid extra burdens, the 
means of registration need to be clear, transparent 
and simple. Micro-credits and saving groups are 
also essential part of the improvement process, 
which also builds believe and strength among the 
poor citizens. 
The Municipality of Phnom Penh stated in the 
Poverty Reduction Strategy (1999) that they do not 
have enough fi nancial opportunities to support the 
urban poor. Supporting saving groups or micro-credit 
schemes do not, however, need enormous 
funds because already the small seed money can 
have a great impact. In addition, the possibilities of 
the formal private sector need to be search for. 
5 Conclusions 
The informal economy acts as a crucial part of 
the economy in Phnom Penh and it is extremely 
important for the city and its development, 
providing employment, income, and services for 
the majority of the citizens. Around 80 percent of 
the city’s 400,000 slum dwellers earn their income 
from informal sources. The informal economy has 
also attracted educated people when the formal 
sector has been unable to offer proper employment 
and income. This has distorted the balance 
between the informal and formal economies 
and thus informality cannot be straightforwardly 
associated with poverty. 
When trying to identify, legalize and regulate 
the city’s informal economy, there are two 
sides to address. On the other side there is the 
educated pool of workers that are working in the 
Modern Myths of the Mekong - Part III: Development 
informal sector since the formal sector (e.g public 
administration) is unable to pay enough income. 
And, then those who feel that registration of the 
company mean just extra burdens and cost, and 
gives only little in return. Another side of the coin 
is the city’s poor informal workers mostly living in 
slum settlements. These people do not have skills, 
capacities or capital to register their activities. And, 
as a matter of fact these people are disturbed by the 
formal arrangements such as regulations, fi nes and 
emotional stress that hinder their activities and 
possibilities to earn decent income. 
The informal economy is not regulated, which has 
created many obstacles for the city’s development. 
To achieve sustainable development of the city’s 
economy and services, the municipality needs 
to co-operate with the informal sector, develop 
services to support, monitor and regulate informal 
activities, and lighten the registration process. To 
be able to create an effective legal framework for 
informal activities, more information about the 
sector and its needs, obstacles, and behaviours is 
needed. 
The informal sector of the city has a lot of potential 
capabilities, good ideas, entrepreneurial skills, and 
education, which need to be exploited for Phnom 
Penh’s development. 
Acknowledgements 
This study is funded by the Academy of Finland 
(project 211010) and the Helsinki University of 
Technology. I would like to thank Prof. Pertti 
Vakkilainen and Dr. Olli Varis for their good 
comments and fruitful discussions.
131 
References 
Agnello F. & Moller, J., 2003. Cambodia: Women Micro 
Entrepreneurs and Their Business Needs. Urban Research 
Group, Phnom Penh. 
Amin, A.T.M., 2002. The Informal Economy in Asia 
from the Decent Work Perspective. Working Paper on the 
Informal Economy. International Labour Offi ce (ILO), 
Geneva. 
Bajpai, S.P., 2004. Statement for the Council for the 
Development of Cambodia. Seventh Consultative Group 
Meeting on Cambodia 6th and 7th December. Asian 
Development Bank (ADB), Phnom Penh. 
Becker, K., 2004. The Informal Economy: Fact Finding 
Study. SIDA, Stockholm. 
Bhowmik, S.K., 2005. Street Vendors in Asia: A Review. 
Economic and Political Weekly, May 28-June 4. 
Chantly, L., 1999. Strengthening recycling by promoting 
waste separation at source. A case of Phnom Penh 
households and the informal economy. Master’s Thesis, 
Asian Institute of Technology (AIT), Bangkok. 
Etherington, K. & Simon, D., 1996. Para transit 
and employment in Phnom Penh: the dynamics and 
development potential of cyclo-riding. Journal of 
Transport Geography, Vol.4, No.1: 37-53. 
Heinonen, U., 2004. Integrated and Socially Just Water 
Resources Management in the Lower Mekong River 
Region and Cambodia: How to Control Water-Related 
Rural Push Licentiate Thesis. Helsinki University of 
Technology, Espoo. 
Heinonen, U., 2005. Drinking water supplies and quality 
in the poor settlements of Phnom Penh, Cambodia; Case 
study of the fi ve villages 101, Drei Kro Horm, Prek Taroth, 
Kob Kong & Trapeang Chork. Helsinki University of 
Technology, Espoo. 
Heinonen, U., 2006. Environmental impact on migration 
in Cambodia: Water related migration from the Tonle Sap 
Lake Region. International Journal of Water Resources 
Development, Vol.22, No.3, pp.449-462. 
Heinonen, U., 2008. Millennium Development Goals 
and Phnom Penh: Is the City on Track to Meet the Goals? 
The Modern Myths of the Mekong. Helsinki University 
of Technology, Espoo. 
ILO, 2002. Beyond Survival - Organizing the Informal 
Economy. International Labour Organization (ILO), 
Geneva. 
ILO, 2004. Global Employment Trends. International 
Labour Organization (ILO), Geneva. 
Ishengoma, E.K. & Kappel, R., 2006. Economic Growth 
and Poverty: Does Formalisation of Informal Enterprises 
Matter? German Institute of Global and Area Studies 
(GIGA), Hamburg. 
Ministry of Planning, 2001. Cambodia Statistical 
Yearbook 2001. Ministry of Planning, Phnom Penh. 
Monyrath, N., 2005. The Informal Economy in Cambodia: 
An Overview. Economic Institute of Cambodia, Phnom 
Penh. http://www.eicambodia.org/downloads/fi les/ 
ER8_informal_economic.pdf 
Municipality of Phnom Penh, 1999. Urban Poverty 
Reduction Strategy for Phnom Penh. Municipality of 
Phnom Penh, Phnom Penh. 
Palmade, V., 2002. The Importance of Sector Level 
Perspective: Findings and Methodology of the McKinsey 
Global Institute - Draft. World Bank. 
Sethuraman, S.V., 1997. Urban Poverty and the Informal 
Sector. United Nations Development Programme, 
Geneva. 
Schneider, F., 2002. Size and Measurement of the 
Informal Economy in 110 Countries Around the World. 
Paper presented at a Workshop of Australian National 
Tax Centre, ANU, Canberra, Australia, July 17, 2002. 
Straub, S., 2005. Informal economy: The credit market 
channel. Journal of Development Economics 78:299- 
321. 
Sophy, E., 2002. Study on Land Availability for City 
Development in Phnom Penh Metropolitan Area. Asian 
Coalition for Housing Rights, Phnom Penh. 
SUPF, 2003. Phnom Penh: An information booklet of 
the city’s development and the settlements of the urban 
poor. Solidarity for the Urban Poor Federation (SUPF), 
Phnom Penh. 
Thomas, J.J., 1995. Surviving in the City: The Urban 
Informal economy in Latin America. Pluto Press, 
London. 
Trebilcock, A., 2005. Decent Work and the Informal 
Economy. Discussion Paper No. 2005/4. World Institute 
for Development Economics Research (WIDER), 
Geneva. 
URC, 2004. Secure Tenure and Poor Communities in 
Phnom Penh: Pilot Project 2004. Urban Resource Centre 
(URC), Phnom Penh. 
USG, 2003. Report on an Analysis of the Informal 
Economy in Phnom Penh. Urban Sector Group (USG), 
Phnom Penh. 
Heinonen - The hidden role of informal economy
132 
World Bank, 2003. World Development Indicators 2003. 
World Bank Group, Geneva. 
World Bank, 2004. Seizing the Global Opportunity: 
Investment Climate Assessment and Reform Strategy for 
Cambodia. World Bank Group, Geneva. 
World Bank, 2006. Cambodia: Halving Poverty by 2015? 
World Bank, Phnom Penh. 
This publication is available electronically at 
water.tkk.fi /global/publications 
Modern Myths of the Mekong - Part III: Development

More Related Content

What's hot

AS Macro: Introduction to Economic Development
AS Macro: Introduction to Economic DevelopmentAS Macro: Introduction to Economic Development
AS Macro: Introduction to Economic Developmenttutor2u
 
Indicators Of Economic Development
Indicators Of Economic DevelopmentIndicators Of Economic Development
Indicators Of Economic Developmentguest9937d8
 
National income & estimation models
National income  &  estimation modelsNational income  &  estimation models
National income & estimation modelssamcvadavana
 
COVID-19 Epidemics Economic Impact on Migrant Labour Force
COVID-19 Epidemics Economic Impact on Migrant Labour ForceCOVID-19 Epidemics Economic Impact on Migrant Labour Force
COVID-19 Epidemics Economic Impact on Migrant Labour ForceVedat Akman
 
organized and unorganized sector
organized and unorganized sectororganized and unorganized sector
organized and unorganized sectorSonali Kukreja
 
Outreach frontiers of microfinance service development in rural ethiopia a ca...
Outreach frontiers of microfinance service development in rural ethiopia a ca...Outreach frontiers of microfinance service development in rural ethiopia a ca...
Outreach frontiers of microfinance service development in rural ethiopia a ca...Alexander Decker
 
relation between economics and politics
relation between economics and politicsrelation between economics and politics
relation between economics and politicsMegha Chawla
 
Labor migration of sri lanka
Labor migration of sri lankaLabor migration of sri lanka
Labor migration of sri lankaShakthi Fernando
 
Labour Migration between the Developing and the Developed
Labour Migration between the Developing and the DevelopedLabour Migration between the Developing and the Developed
Labour Migration between the Developing and the Developedlcatton
 
The Chinese Economy
The Chinese EconomyThe Chinese Economy
The Chinese EconomySagar M
 
Characteristics of underdeveloped economies
Characteristics of underdeveloped economiesCharacteristics of underdeveloped economies
Characteristics of underdeveloped economiesGeorgi Mathew
 
Economic growth & economic development, underdevelopment
Economic growth & economic development, underdevelopmentEconomic growth & economic development, underdevelopment
Economic growth & economic development, underdevelopmentMk Ghadoliya
 
The Structure Of Crisis, The Crisis of Structure
The Structure Of Crisis, The Crisis of StructureThe Structure Of Crisis, The Crisis of Structure
The Structure Of Crisis, The Crisis of StructureJames Matthew Miraflor
 
The Emerging Pattern of Structural Change
 The Emerging Pattern of Structural Change The Emerging Pattern of Structural Change
The Emerging Pattern of Structural ChangeMd Shaifullar Rabbi
 
Unemployment Problem and Global Financing Related to COVID-19 Epidemic
Unemployment Problem and Global Financing Related to COVID-19 EpidemicUnemployment Problem and Global Financing Related to COVID-19 Epidemic
Unemployment Problem and Global Financing Related to COVID-19 EpidemicVedat Akman
 

What's hot (20)

AS Macro: Introduction to Economic Development
AS Macro: Introduction to Economic DevelopmentAS Macro: Introduction to Economic Development
AS Macro: Introduction to Economic Development
 
Indicators Of Economic Development
Indicators Of Economic DevelopmentIndicators Of Economic Development
Indicators Of Economic Development
 
National income & estimation models
National income  &  estimation modelsNational income  &  estimation models
National income & estimation models
 
COVID-19 Epidemics Economic Impact on Migrant Labour Force
COVID-19 Epidemics Economic Impact on Migrant Labour ForceCOVID-19 Epidemics Economic Impact on Migrant Labour Force
COVID-19 Epidemics Economic Impact on Migrant Labour Force
 
organized and unorganized sector
organized and unorganized sectororganized and unorganized sector
organized and unorganized sector
 
Politics and economy
Politics and economyPolitics and economy
Politics and economy
 
Jobs crisis & shaping an inclusive growth
Jobs crisis & shaping an inclusive growthJobs crisis & shaping an inclusive growth
Jobs crisis & shaping an inclusive growth
 
Outreach frontiers of microfinance service development in rural ethiopia a ca...
Outreach frontiers of microfinance service development in rural ethiopia a ca...Outreach frontiers of microfinance service development in rural ethiopia a ca...
Outreach frontiers of microfinance service development in rural ethiopia a ca...
 
relation between economics and politics
relation between economics and politicsrelation between economics and politics
relation between economics and politics
 
Labor migration of sri lanka
Labor migration of sri lankaLabor migration of sri lanka
Labor migration of sri lanka
 
Labour Migration between the Developing and the Developed
Labour Migration between the Developing and the DevelopedLabour Migration between the Developing and the Developed
Labour Migration between the Developing and the Developed
 
The Chinese Economy
The Chinese EconomyThe Chinese Economy
The Chinese Economy
 
Unleashing rural economies
Unleashing rural economiesUnleashing rural economies
Unleashing rural economies
 
Characteristics of underdeveloped economies
Characteristics of underdeveloped economiesCharacteristics of underdeveloped economies
Characteristics of underdeveloped economies
 
Economic growth & economic development, underdevelopment
Economic growth & economic development, underdevelopmentEconomic growth & economic development, underdevelopment
Economic growth & economic development, underdevelopment
 
Indian Economy
Indian EconomyIndian Economy
Indian Economy
 
Indian economy 1
Indian economy 1Indian economy 1
Indian economy 1
 
The Structure Of Crisis, The Crisis of Structure
The Structure Of Crisis, The Crisis of StructureThe Structure Of Crisis, The Crisis of Structure
The Structure Of Crisis, The Crisis of Structure
 
The Emerging Pattern of Structural Change
 The Emerging Pattern of Structural Change The Emerging Pattern of Structural Change
The Emerging Pattern of Structural Change
 
Unemployment Problem and Global Financing Related to COVID-19 Epidemic
Unemployment Problem and Global Financing Related to COVID-19 EpidemicUnemployment Problem and Global Financing Related to COVID-19 Epidemic
Unemployment Problem and Global Financing Related to COVID-19 Epidemic
 

Viewers also liked

28ème Conférence régional de la FAO pour l'Afrique: Jeunesse Africaine dans l...
28ème Conférence régional de la FAO pour l'Afrique: Jeunesse Africaine dans l...28ème Conférence régional de la FAO pour l'Afrique: Jeunesse Africaine dans l...
28ème Conférence régional de la FAO pour l'Afrique: Jeunesse Africaine dans l...FAO
 
Présentation Agri Familiale
Présentation Agri FamilialePrésentation Agri Familiale
Présentation Agri FamilialeOpenOdyssey
 
Divorzio non colpevole
Divorzio non colpevoleDivorzio non colpevole
Divorzio non colpevoleFilippo Abbate
 
Trabalho de inglês técnico
Trabalho de inglês técnicoTrabalho de inglês técnico
Trabalho de inglês técnicoAndre Quendera
 
2000 turk houses @makli thatta
2000 turk houses @makli thatta2000 turk houses @makli thatta
2000 turk houses @makli thattaIqbal Yousuf
 
Boletin mar12 (1)
Boletin mar12 (1)Boletin mar12 (1)
Boletin mar12 (1)chav95
 
Financing the World's Forests: integrating markets and stakeholders
Financing the World's Forests: integrating markets and stakeholdersFinancing the World's Forests: integrating markets and stakeholders
Financing the World's Forests: integrating markets and stakeholdersE Rivilla
 
читацька родина бібліотеки №2
читацька родина бібліотеки №2читацька родина бібліотеки №2
читацька родина бібліотеки №2tamara54
 
Declaració Universal Dels Drets Humans
Declaració Universal Dels Drets HumansDeclaració Universal Dels Drets Humans
Declaració Universal Dels Drets HumansMiguel Herreros
 
La mesure du bien être des sociétés
La mesure du bien être des sociétésLa mesure du bien être des sociétés
La mesure du bien être des sociétésyoussefmm
 
Professor Nii Quaynor on the Wise Society
Professor Nii Quaynor on the Wise Society Professor Nii Quaynor on the Wise Society
Professor Nii Quaynor on the Wise Society Amos Anyimadu
 
Actualización Económica - Marzo 2012
Actualización Económica - Marzo 2012Actualización Económica - Marzo 2012
Actualización Económica - Marzo 2012Aldesa
 

Viewers also liked (20)

28ème Conférence régional de la FAO pour l'Afrique: Jeunesse Africaine dans l...
28ème Conférence régional de la FAO pour l'Afrique: Jeunesse Africaine dans l...28ème Conférence régional de la FAO pour l'Afrique: Jeunesse Africaine dans l...
28ème Conférence régional de la FAO pour l'Afrique: Jeunesse Africaine dans l...
 
Présentation Agri Familiale
Présentation Agri FamilialePrésentation Agri Familiale
Présentation Agri Familiale
 
Divorzio non colpevole
Divorzio non colpevoleDivorzio non colpevole
Divorzio non colpevole
 
Trabalho de inglês técnico
Trabalho de inglês técnicoTrabalho de inglês técnico
Trabalho de inglês técnico
 
Child friendly version_german_part2
Child friendly version_german_part2Child friendly version_german_part2
Child friendly version_german_part2
 
2000 turk houses @makli thatta
2000 turk houses @makli thatta2000 turk houses @makli thatta
2000 turk houses @makli thatta
 
Boletin mar12 (1)
Boletin mar12 (1)Boletin mar12 (1)
Boletin mar12 (1)
 
Dpg
DpgDpg
Dpg
 
Espacios Serie Digimundo en italiano - Enlaces a blogs de la serie Digimundo
Espacios Serie Digimundo en italiano - Enlaces a blogs de la serie DigimundoEspacios Serie Digimundo en italiano - Enlaces a blogs de la serie Digimundo
Espacios Serie Digimundo en italiano - Enlaces a blogs de la serie Digimundo
 
G. Gallo -
G. Gallo - G. Gallo -
G. Gallo -
 
Financing the World's Forests: integrating markets and stakeholders
Financing the World's Forests: integrating markets and stakeholdersFinancing the World's Forests: integrating markets and stakeholders
Financing the World's Forests: integrating markets and stakeholders
 
читацька родина бібліотеки №2
читацька родина бібліотеки №2читацька родина бібліотеки №2
читацька родина бібліотеки №2
 
Declaració Universal Dels Drets Humans
Declaració Universal Dels Drets HumansDeclaració Universal Dels Drets Humans
Declaració Universal Dels Drets Humans
 
Espacios Serie Digimundo en italiano - Enlaces a blogs de la serie Digimundo
Espacios Serie Digimundo en italiano - Enlaces a blogs de la serie DigimundoEspacios Serie Digimundo en italiano - Enlaces a blogs de la serie Digimundo
Espacios Serie Digimundo en italiano - Enlaces a blogs de la serie Digimundo
 
La mesure du bien être des sociétés
La mesure du bien être des sociétésLa mesure du bien être des sociétés
La mesure du bien être des sociétés
 
Professor Nii Quaynor on the Wise Society
Professor Nii Quaynor on the Wise Society Professor Nii Quaynor on the Wise Society
Professor Nii Quaynor on the Wise Society
 
South south cooperation
South south cooperationSouth south cooperation
South south cooperation
 
Els drets dels_nens
Els drets dels_nensEls drets dels_nens
Els drets dels_nens
 
Actualización Económica - Marzo 2012
Actualización Económica - Marzo 2012Actualización Económica - Marzo 2012
Actualización Económica - Marzo 2012
 
екологія
екологіяекологія
екологія
 

Similar to Informal Economy's Hidden Role in Phnom Penh Development

Poverty in the informal sector of kwara state nigeria
Poverty in the informal sector of kwara state nigeriaPoverty in the informal sector of kwara state nigeria
Poverty in the informal sector of kwara state nigeriaDr Lendy Spires
 
Strategy for reducing unemployment in nigeria the role of informal sector
Strategy for reducing unemployment in nigeria the role of informal sectorStrategy for reducing unemployment in nigeria the role of informal sector
Strategy for reducing unemployment in nigeria the role of informal sectorDr Lendy Spires
 
The unformal sector in sub saharan africa - out of the shadows to forster sus...
The unformal sector in sub saharan africa - out of the shadows to forster sus...The unformal sector in sub saharan africa - out of the shadows to forster sus...
The unformal sector in sub saharan africa - out of the shadows to forster sus...Dr Lendy Spires
 
The informal economy in vietnam
The informal economy in vietnamThe informal economy in vietnam
The informal economy in vietnamDr Lendy Spires
 
The informal economy in the southern african development community (sadc)
The informal economy in the southern african development community (sadc)The informal economy in the southern african development community (sadc)
The informal economy in the southern african development community (sadc)Dr Lendy Spires
 
The State of Employment Sector in the Nigerian Economy
The State of Employment Sector in the Nigerian EconomyThe State of Employment Sector in the Nigerian Economy
The State of Employment Sector in the Nigerian EconomyKunle Areo
 
The Informal Economy: A primer for development professionals on the importanc...
The Informal Economy: A primer for development professionals on the importanc...The Informal Economy: A primer for development professionals on the importanc...
The Informal Economy: A primer for development professionals on the importanc...Dr Lendy Spires
 
The role of small and micro enterprises (sm es) on government
The role of small and micro enterprises (sm es) on governmentThe role of small and micro enterprises (sm es) on government
The role of small and micro enterprises (sm es) on governmentAlexander Decker
 
Some controversies on informal sector operation in ethiopia = problems and pe...
Some controversies on informal sector operation in ethiopia = problems and pe...Some controversies on informal sector operation in ethiopia = problems and pe...
Some controversies on informal sector operation in ethiopia = problems and pe...Dr Lendy Spires
 
Lurking in the Cities: Urbanization and the Informal Economy
Lurking in the Cities: Urbanization and the Informal Economy Lurking in the Cities: Urbanization and the Informal Economy
Lurking in the Cities: Urbanization and the Informal Economy Dr Lendy Spires
 
Zambia's Labor Market with Cross-National Comparisons
Zambia's Labor Market with Cross-National ComparisonsZambia's Labor Market with Cross-National Comparisons
Zambia's Labor Market with Cross-National ComparisonsLuis Ramos
 
An Assessment of revenue generation drive of Lagos state government through e...
An Assessment of revenue generation drive of Lagos state government through e...An Assessment of revenue generation drive of Lagos state government through e...
An Assessment of revenue generation drive of Lagos state government through e...Jeremy Williams
 
The impact of globalisation on the informal sector in africa
The impact of globalisation on the informal sector in africaThe impact of globalisation on the informal sector in africa
The impact of globalisation on the informal sector in africaDr Lendy Spires
 
The impact of globalization on the infromal sctor in africa
The impact of globalization on the infromal sctor in africaThe impact of globalization on the infromal sctor in africa
The impact of globalization on the infromal sctor in africaDr Lendy Spires
 

Similar to Informal Economy's Hidden Role in Phnom Penh Development (20)

Poverty in the informal sector of kwara state nigeria
Poverty in the informal sector of kwara state nigeriaPoverty in the informal sector of kwara state nigeria
Poverty in the informal sector of kwara state nigeria
 
Strategy for reducing unemployment in nigeria the role of informal sector
Strategy for reducing unemployment in nigeria the role of informal sectorStrategy for reducing unemployment in nigeria the role of informal sector
Strategy for reducing unemployment in nigeria the role of informal sector
 
Ijer20110206 nd(3)
Ijer20110206 nd(3)Ijer20110206 nd(3)
Ijer20110206 nd(3)
 
The unformal sector in sub saharan africa - out of the shadows to forster sus...
The unformal sector in sub saharan africa - out of the shadows to forster sus...The unformal sector in sub saharan africa - out of the shadows to forster sus...
The unformal sector in sub saharan africa - out of the shadows to forster sus...
 
The informal economy in vietnam
The informal economy in vietnamThe informal economy in vietnam
The informal economy in vietnam
 
The informal economy in the southern african development community (sadc)
The informal economy in the southern african development community (sadc)The informal economy in the southern african development community (sadc)
The informal economy in the southern african development community (sadc)
 
The State of Employment Sector in the Nigerian Economy
The State of Employment Sector in the Nigerian EconomyThe State of Employment Sector in the Nigerian Economy
The State of Employment Sector in the Nigerian Economy
 
The Informal Economy: A primer for development professionals on the importanc...
The Informal Economy: A primer for development professionals on the importanc...The Informal Economy: A primer for development professionals on the importanc...
The Informal Economy: A primer for development professionals on the importanc...
 
The role of small and micro enterprises (sm es) on government
The role of small and micro enterprises (sm es) on governmentThe role of small and micro enterprises (sm es) on government
The role of small and micro enterprises (sm es) on government
 
Some controversies on informal sector operation in ethiopia = problems and pe...
Some controversies on informal sector operation in ethiopia = problems and pe...Some controversies on informal sector operation in ethiopia = problems and pe...
Some controversies on informal sector operation in ethiopia = problems and pe...
 
Lurking in the Cities: Urbanization and the Informal Economy
Lurking in the Cities: Urbanization and the Informal Economy Lurking in the Cities: Urbanization and the Informal Economy
Lurking in the Cities: Urbanization and the Informal Economy
 
Zambia's Labor Market with Cross-National Comparisons
Zambia's Labor Market with Cross-National ComparisonsZambia's Labor Market with Cross-National Comparisons
Zambia's Labor Market with Cross-National Comparisons
 
lse-uct essay 1
lse-uct essay 1lse-uct essay 1
lse-uct essay 1
 
Youth Unemployment in Nigeria
Youth Unemployment in NigeriaYouth Unemployment in Nigeria
Youth Unemployment in Nigeria
 
Youth Unemployment in Nigeria
Youth Unemployment in NigeriaYouth Unemployment in Nigeria
Youth Unemployment in Nigeria
 
Youth unemployment in nigeria
Youth unemployment in nigeriaYouth unemployment in nigeria
Youth unemployment in nigeria
 
An Assessment of revenue generation drive of Lagos state government through e...
An Assessment of revenue generation drive of Lagos state government through e...An Assessment of revenue generation drive of Lagos state government through e...
An Assessment of revenue generation drive of Lagos state government through e...
 
Making Growth Work for the Poor in Zimbabwe
Making Growth Work for the Poor in ZimbabweMaking Growth Work for the Poor in Zimbabwe
Making Growth Work for the Poor in Zimbabwe
 
The impact of globalisation on the informal sector in africa
The impact of globalisation on the informal sector in africaThe impact of globalisation on the informal sector in africa
The impact of globalisation on the informal sector in africa
 
The impact of globalization on the infromal sctor in africa
The impact of globalization on the infromal sctor in africaThe impact of globalization on the infromal sctor in africa
The impact of globalization on the infromal sctor in africa
 

Informal Economy's Hidden Role in Phnom Penh Development

  • 1. Water & Development Publications - Helsinki University of TechnologyAB THE HIDDEN ROLE OF INFORMAL ECONOMY: IS INFORMAL ECONOMY INSIGNIFICANT FOR PHNOM PENH’S DEVELOPMENT? Ulla Heinonen Water Resources Laboratory, Helsinki University of Technology, Finland Informal economy is often stated as a temporary phenomenon which diminishes along economic growth. The sector is regularly taken as granted and its role for development is not properly seen. Around 80 percent of the GDP in Cambodia is produced by the informal sector. Informal economy is also important for the country’s urban areas and particularly for the country’s capital city. The economic development of Phnom Penh, the capital, is combined with a growth in its non-agricultural informal sector. At the same time the city’s slum settlements are mushrooming, creating more pressures on the informal sector. As a result, many of the city’s informal workers have become working poors. Without proper protection and legalization of the informal sector, these poor citizens cannot be lifted up from the poverty trap and the sustainable development of the city cannot be achieved. In the 1970s informal sector became a common topic in international development discussions. Informality was identifi ed as a continued existence of traditional activities and production methods that would disappear along with industrialization and modernization (Straub, 2005). The sector was seen marginal for growth and separate from the formal sector. However, later on the informal economy has increased, particularly in the Corresponding author: Ulla Heinonen Water Resources Laboratory Helsinki University of Technology - TKK P.O. Box 5200, FIN-02015 TKK, Finland Email: ulla.heinonen@tkk.fi countries where income is not equally distributed, and has become an integrated part of the economy in many countries (Becker, 2004). Thus, the informal economy - the refi ned defi nition of the International Labour Organisation (ILO) - could no longer be seen as a temporary phenomenon, or as a phenomenon that straightforwardly decreases with economic growth. In the recent decades the sector has grown around the world and it is currently the largest “economy” in many countries (ILO, 2002). It seems to be that if economic growth is not accompanied by improvements in employment and income distribution, the informal economy does not shrink. Instead, it seems to expand, both in urban and in 1 Introduction to informal economy © 2008 TKK & Heinonen ISBN 978-951-22-9102-1 Kummu, M., Keskinen, M. & Varis, O. (eds.): Modern Myths of the Mekong, pp. 123-132
  • 2. 124 Modern Myths of the Mekong - Part III: Development 2 Economy, employment, and informality in Cambodia 2.1 Defi nition of the informal economy in Cambodia The lack of consistent empirical measurements is evident in Cambodia, where the impact and volume of the informal economy has not been properly analyzed and its role in the country’s economy is poorly recognized. In Cambodia, the informal economy is defi ned as actions without offi cial or solid legal status, regulation or protection by state institutions, or as actions that are identifi ed with some of the following characteristics (Amin, 2002; Becker, 2004): 1. No fi rm or postal address 2. Employees are self-employed or road-side vendors 3. No data through census survey are available or the activities are not recognised 4. Labour-intensive nature of operations and quick turnover 5. Use of energy input from human or animal sources 6. Non-structured premises without regulations, licences, insurance, or taxes rural areas. Besides, there exist evident linkages between the informal and formal economies. The informal sector provides services for formal actors, offers a fl exible labour market to absorb the surplus labour and has a signifi cant income and job generation potential (Becker, 2004). The studies of the World Bank (2004) showed that the majority of informal services are sold to individual customers, commonly to poor and middle-income urban dwellers (Bhowmik, 2005). The informal sector supplies products and services, which are not provided by the formal sector, or are otherwise unreachable for the poor citizens (Ishengoma & Kappel 2006). The informal economy is very heterogeneous in terms of actors, activities, and scales (Sethuraman, 1997). The sector varies between countries, economies, and cultures (Thomas, 1995). In some countries the term ‘informal economy’ refers to the private sector, in some to grey economy (Trebilcock, 2005). It is a controversial topic and as a result there exist disagreements about its defi nition, estimation procedures, and their use in economic analysis (Schneider, 2002). The current defi nition of the informal economy includes a large amount of heterogeneity instead of conceptualising the term narrowly (Ishengoma & Kappel, 2006). Schneider (2002) defi nes informal activities as unregistered economic activities that contribute to the offi cially calculated (or observed) Gross National Product. Thomas (1995) and Trebilcock (2005), on the other hand, characterise the informal economy as economic activities that, for various reasons, are not fully reported in the National Income Accounts or are insuffi ciently covered by formal arrangements. In other words, the informal economy contributes to the country’s economy but the activities are informal in terms of registration, tax payments, operating licences, conditions of employment, or regulations (Becker, 2004). A modest progress in measuring the informal economy is achieved and presently there exist numerous ways of measurement: working hours, share of the labour force, percent of GDP, consumption of electricity and currency demand (Schneider, 2002). Theoretical understanding of the causes and consequences is, nevertheless, still lagging in many parts of the world (Straub, 2005). Informal activities take place in many forms. The work varies from part-time jobs after working hours, to work of immigrants who are not allowed to work in the formal sector (Schneider, 2002). In general, informal activities can be categorised into two sections: self-employed and non-permanent labour. In all developing countries the self-employed labour comprises a greater share of informal employment. This sector includes persons working as street vendors, taxi drivers, or in home-based enterprises. In Asia self-employment covers around 60 percent of the total informal sector (Becker, 2004).
  • 3. Heinonen - The hidden role of informal economy 4500 4000 3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0 Garment Tourism Agriculture Others Million US$/ Thousands GDP and Labour Force by Subsectors ( 2001) Total GDP by Subsectors Labour Force Formal Informal 125 2.2 Employment and informality A recent civil war, defi cient infrastructure, political instability, and extensive corruption have hindered the Cambodian economic development (World Bank, 2003; 2004). In 2004 around 35 percent of the 14 million Cambodians lived under the poverty line (~1,800 riels/person/day) (World Bank, 2006). Lately the country’s economy has, however, shown signs of recovery, and the economic growth has been around 6 percent. Nevertheless, the growth has not been stable and inequality remains high. Agriculture is a very important sector in Cambodia covering 40 percent of the country’s GDP and employing 70 percent of the population. Service and industrial sectors are less important. Service sector employees around 20 percent and industrial sector 10 percent of the population (Ministry of Planning, 2001). As a poor agrarian country, Cambodia is very vulnerable to changes in natural resources. Drought and fl oods in the recent years, for example, have seriously affected the country’s economy. Diminishing agricultural activities and unemployment in rural areas have pushed people out of their villages in search of employment in towns and cities (Heinonen, 2006). Rural migrants do not often have the necessary skills or education to allow them to fi nd better paid, secure employment in the formal sector and hence they often end up working informally (Bhowmik, 2005). The informal economy provides around 90 percent of all employment in Cambodia (Monyrath, 2005). The sector employs the majority of the 200,000 to 250,000 new workers entering the job market each year, while the country’s formal sector absorbs only 15,000 new labourers annually (USG, 2003; World Bank, 2004). Agriculture and agro-industry cover majority of the employment in the informal sector (Figure 1). However, the non-agricultural informal sector is twice the size of the formal in terms of GDP and labour force. It is also a largest employer in the urban areas. The informal sector provides around 60 to 80 percent of the Gross Domestic Product of the country (Monyrath, 2005; USG, 2003). Non-agricultural informal activities mostly in urban areas cover the greatest share, around 1,653 million dollars (Figure 1). The garment and tourism industries and public administration dominate the small formal sector (Monyrath, 2005; Bajpai, 2004). Formal jobs provided by the government are few and they are not well paid (Bhowmik, 2005). Majority of the formal employment in Cambodia is very poorly paid, which pushes people to do extra work in the informal sector. Most of the part-time moto-taxi drivers in Phnom Penh, for instance, are government employees (USG, 2003). The formal private sector in Cambodia is also relatively small and limited, facing innumerable transaction costs Figure 1 The GDP from the informal sector is four times higher than from the formal sector (USG, 2003).
  • 4. 126 and barriers to operate (USG, 2003). To start a business in Cambodia is very time-consuming and costly, compared to the neighbouring countries. The taxes and bribes are lower in the informal sector and this is often the main reason why people do not register their activities (World Bank, 2004; Straub, 2005; Ishengoma & Kappel, 2006). 3 Informal economy in Phnom Penh There are three dominant sectors offering formal employment in Phnom Penh: public administration, garment industry and tourism (Monyrath, 2005). It is evident that these sectors are not able to offer employment for all of the city’s new dwellers that the city is gaining by its 4 percent annual growth. In addition, in many cases the formal sector is unable to provide enough income for its employees. Based on this mismatch majority of the Phnom Penh’s citizens work informally, at least on a part-time basis (Agnello & Moller, 2003). Even though Cambodian formal sectors are primarily located in the towns and cities, particularly in Phnom Penh, informality runs the city’s economy. The informal economic activities – micro- and small enterprises, market sellers, non-permanent labour workers, moto-taxi drivers, and domestic helpers - have a major role in the economic performance of the capital city. The informal economy tends also to absorb most of the growing labour force related to rural-urban migration when the manufacturing industry and off-farm activities do not grow with the same rapidity. The sector also answers the needs of the seasonal migrants coming to the city to earn supplementary income particularly in the dry season. And it also attracts rural migrants to Phnom Penh to provide low-cost goods and services for those employed in the formal and informal economies (Becker, 2004). The growth in the city’s garment industry couple of years ago, for instance, led to an increase in informal activities such as transportation, food, beverages, and accommodation to serve the people working in the formal sector. This also encouraged rural dwellers to migrate to the city (Monyrath, 2005). Modern Myths of the Mekong - Part III: Development 3.1 Informality and poverty Urban poverty and informal employment are closely connected. Poor people in developing countries are often forced to work in the informal economy because of lack of capital and skills, gender, or ethnicity, which make them insignifi cant for the main labour force (Etherington & Simon, 1996). The studies of the International Labour Organisation show that informal status often means a greater likelihood of income variability, decline, and insecurity (Trebilcock, 2005). Informal economy attracts workforce from diverse backgrounds and, as a consequence, the labour force is very heterogeneous. Initial capital, gender, domicile, education, and contacts all infl uence the capabilities of informal employees to survive in their jobs. Often the rural migrants tend to fall into the lowest category of the informal economy (Trebilcock, 2005). This is also common in Phnom Penh, where rural migrants and poor people dominate the labour force of the informal economy. The surveys of Etherington& Simon (1996) showed that in Phnom Penh the rural migrants often end up working as cyclo-drivers or temporary labourers. For example, over 70 percent of waste pickers in the city are poor rural migrants (Amin, 2002), whereas poor urban dwellers more often work as service sector workers or street vendors. This kind of division indicates that the rural migrants have low social status in the city and thus they have problems in exploiting of the informal credit systems. The informal economy is the most important employer for the poor inhabitants of Phnom Penh. At present, 80 percent of the city’s 400,000 slum dwellers are employed in the informal economy (SUPF, 2003; URC, 2004). In addition, many children are involved in informal activities, working as shoe cleaners, rag pickers, sellers or beggars. The customary informal works in Phnom Penh are: mototaxi- and cyclo-drivers, food, gasoline and vegetable sellers, construction workers, electricity and water sellers, motorcycle repairers, rubbish collectors, brick workers and house servants (USG, 2003). There is an evident linkage between the work types in the informal
  • 5. 127 Heinonen - The hidden role of informal economy sector, and the work types of the slum dwellers. Hence, relation between poverty and the informal economy, as a result of poor working conditions, and low income levels, is obvious (Sethuraman, 1997; Ishengoma & Kappel, 2006). Figure 2 presents the obstacles that a poor private sector worker faces when trying to reach Phnom Penh’s formal sector. Most of the poor workers live in slums. They do not have secure tenure, proper housing or public services. They need informal products and services because they cannot reach the formal ones. As rural migrants, the workers often have a low social capital and do not have an interest in other activities than earning income (particularly seasonal migrants). These people mostly work in the informal sector because the formal jobs are limited and they do not have skills for these jobs. In addition, they do not have initial capital to start a proper business, the access to formal credit services is limited, and they do not have know-how about the registration activities and the forms that the formal sector could support them. Informal activities are often targets of extortion and harassment by the public authorities. The work of the informal workers is disturbed by fi nes, different payments (e.g. hygiene), and violations, and due to all this emotional stress (Figure 2). Phnom Penh’s informal activities are not regulated. However, there are many regulations in the places where informal workers operate, and not following these guidelines (e.g. selling restrictions) leads to fi ning (USG, 2003). Bribes for the public authorities are also common, particularly for street vendors and micro-enterprises. All these stresses have an impact on the workers ability to survive in the city. As most of the informal workers are rarely organised, this hinders their ability to negotiate with the public authorities (Monyrath, 2005). The regulation jungle drives the informal activities out from the authorized structures and, as a result, people work in the informal sector. The studies of the Urban Sector Group (USG, 2003) among Phnom Penh’s informal workers revealed that there are: a lack of information about registration methods, regulations and costs; not enough benefi ts compared to the amount of money that is needed for registration; wide opinion that small companies cannot be registered; and lack of information about where, when and how to register. Formal Sector Formal Services Regulations Fines Payments Violations Emotional Stress Informal Employment Formal Employment Informal Sector Worker Lack of: Skills Capital Credit Know-how Informal Services Lack of: Secure Tenure Proper Housing Social Capital Figure 2 The informal worker faces many obstacles. Broken lines illustrate the barriers along the way.
  • 6. 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 Modern Myths of the Mekong - Part III: Development water sources and resell it to poor and middle-income inhabitants (USG, 2003). The survey of the Urban Sector Group (2003) reveals that an informal water seller earns roughly 346,000 riels monthly (87 US$), which is twice the salary that the government can offer. However, these activities are not regulated, which creates great challenges in terms of providing safe water supply particularly for the Phnom Penh’s poor citizens (Heinonen, 2008). Education of the Informal Sector Workers in Phnom Penh 128 4 Discussion – How to legalise informal sector? The municipality of Phnom Penh seeks for poverty reduction and aims for economic development. When aiming to urban poverty reduction the problems of the city’s poor informal workers are those to be addressed (Monyrath, 2005). Every day around 300 000 slum dwellers work in Phnom Penh’s informal sector (SUPF, 2003). In addition, the slums absorbs majority of the city’s increasing population. Addressing this group would thus have an infl uence on almost half of the city’s informal workers. The poor informal workers face many barriers in their daily existence and they carry a high risk of becoming working poor with earnings insuffi cient to raise themselves and their families above the 3.2 Other side of the coin There is also another side in the Phnom Penh’s informal economy. And therefore it is too one-dimensional to associate informality directly with poverty. The studies of Chantly (1999) showed that the informal economy also provides employment for educated workers with entrepreneurial potential and skills (Figure 3). This indicates that the formal economy is unable to provide adequate employment for educated persons and thus they choose the opportunities that the informal sector has to offer (Amin, 2002). The fi gure below is a clear evidence of inadequate governance and regulations, and the fact that the Phnom Penh’s formal sector is unable to provide enough income for its workers. One of the country’s challenges is thus to create productive jobs in the formal economy. Otherwise there is little hope for city’s sustainable economic growth. Phnom Penh cannot afford to lose the capabilities of educated citizens with potential skills (Chantly, 1999). Phnom Penh’s informal sector also offers a playground for private companies that do not want to register because of the costs. The city’s informal private water services, for example, offer employment for thousands of informal workers. The private vendors buy water from city water offi cials or obtain water from ground or surface Figure 3 The informal economy of Phnom Penh also attracts educated people (Chantly, 1999; Amin, 2002).
  • 7. 129 poverty line (ILO, 2004). Even though the work in the informal sector is the way to earn some food on the table, the jobs are poorly paid, have poor working conditions, no social protection and excludes workers form social dialogue and decision-making, trapping its workers deeper into poverty (Ishengoma & Kappel, 2006). To push informal workers from this trap, however, is easier said than done. Already, in the Urban Poverty Reduction Strategy of Phnom Penh in 1999, many good ways to improve the situation of urban poor were stated (Municipality of Phnom Penh, 1999). Nevertheless, the results have been weak. The city’s poor informal workers have worked very hard, often in unhealthy conditions and facing many obstacles. Still they remain poor either poorer than before. These workforces have made signifi cant contributions to the city’s development. The sector has kept down the urbanisation cost of the city by promoting fl exible labour market, absorbing extra labour from the formal sector and promoted the city by services such as water, energy and solid waste collection (Amin, 2002; Monyrath, 2005). But still, the signifi cance of the sector is not adequately recognized by the municipality. To be able to guide the poor informal workers for better achievements and have a real impact in their level of livelihood, there is a great need for appropriate regulations, laws and policies. Regulating the activities of the informal sector, however, is an immense challenge. There is no one policy intervention that could address such a diverse entity. Additionally very often the increasing fi scal and regulatory burden leads to the enlargement of the informal sector or puts more troubles on informal workers activities (Palmade, 2002). To be able to legalize and regulate the sector, more information and dialogue with the informal sector is needed. The regulations need to be sensitive so as to be able to increase the productivity, quality, and working conditions of the informal sector (Becker, 2004). Only by understanding the needs and identifying the obstacles, that the informal sector is facing, proper and sustainable regulations can be established. Just putting extra pressure on the informal sector turns development in an unwanted direction (Palmade, 2002). The regulations cannot be the same for poor informal workers and the informal companies that just want to avoid the extra burdens of registration. The fi rst requirement in integrating Phnom Penh’s informal sector into the formal is providing land (Amin, 2002). Land and housing are not only the place to accommodate, they are often also the places to generate income. Hence, including poor people in the urban planning both in terms of their housing as well as of their income generation is vital for legalizing and regulating informal activities. The city’s slum settlements as well as the informal workers have been excluded from Phnom Penh’s development strategies and there have not been clear processes of city zoning and land use planning, which would also address the needs of the urban poor. In addition, the city does not have land-banking system for development purposes and when the demand for land is high due to the growing population and increasing investments, the poor have had a little room in the development discussions (Sophy, 2002). The study on Land Availability for City Development (2002) identifi ed, that there is a great need for reserving and allocating land for poor as well as set up a land development bank for reserving land for future community projects and investments. The living conditions of the poor do not improve without decent work and income (Amin, 2002). This is also a reason why many slum upgrading processes have not led to long-term development. As a consequence, the upgrading processes of poor settlements that are taking place in the Phnom Penh needs to include also other aspects than just upgrading the housing and services (Heinonen, 2008).The city-wide and bottom-up participation approach of Asian Coalition for Housing Rights, for instance, could be one effi cient approach to also address the Phnom Penh’s informal workers (Heinonen, 2008). To make the development sustainable in the long run, education, training schemes and support to workers’ organisations are essential for the capacity building of the informal workers. Via workers’ Heinonen - The hidden role of informal economy
  • 8. 130 organisations the informal sectors’ workers will get information about the regulations as well as the ways of registration. To avoid extra burdens, the means of registration need to be clear, transparent and simple. Micro-credits and saving groups are also essential part of the improvement process, which also builds believe and strength among the poor citizens. The Municipality of Phnom Penh stated in the Poverty Reduction Strategy (1999) that they do not have enough fi nancial opportunities to support the urban poor. Supporting saving groups or micro-credit schemes do not, however, need enormous funds because already the small seed money can have a great impact. In addition, the possibilities of the formal private sector need to be search for. 5 Conclusions The informal economy acts as a crucial part of the economy in Phnom Penh and it is extremely important for the city and its development, providing employment, income, and services for the majority of the citizens. Around 80 percent of the city’s 400,000 slum dwellers earn their income from informal sources. The informal economy has also attracted educated people when the formal sector has been unable to offer proper employment and income. This has distorted the balance between the informal and formal economies and thus informality cannot be straightforwardly associated with poverty. When trying to identify, legalize and regulate the city’s informal economy, there are two sides to address. On the other side there is the educated pool of workers that are working in the Modern Myths of the Mekong - Part III: Development informal sector since the formal sector (e.g public administration) is unable to pay enough income. And, then those who feel that registration of the company mean just extra burdens and cost, and gives only little in return. Another side of the coin is the city’s poor informal workers mostly living in slum settlements. These people do not have skills, capacities or capital to register their activities. And, as a matter of fact these people are disturbed by the formal arrangements such as regulations, fi nes and emotional stress that hinder their activities and possibilities to earn decent income. The informal economy is not regulated, which has created many obstacles for the city’s development. To achieve sustainable development of the city’s economy and services, the municipality needs to co-operate with the informal sector, develop services to support, monitor and regulate informal activities, and lighten the registration process. To be able to create an effective legal framework for informal activities, more information about the sector and its needs, obstacles, and behaviours is needed. The informal sector of the city has a lot of potential capabilities, good ideas, entrepreneurial skills, and education, which need to be exploited for Phnom Penh’s development. Acknowledgements This study is funded by the Academy of Finland (project 211010) and the Helsinki University of Technology. I would like to thank Prof. Pertti Vakkilainen and Dr. Olli Varis for their good comments and fruitful discussions.
  • 9. 131 References Agnello F. & Moller, J., 2003. Cambodia: Women Micro Entrepreneurs and Their Business Needs. Urban Research Group, Phnom Penh. Amin, A.T.M., 2002. The Informal Economy in Asia from the Decent Work Perspective. Working Paper on the Informal Economy. International Labour Offi ce (ILO), Geneva. Bajpai, S.P., 2004. Statement for the Council for the Development of Cambodia. Seventh Consultative Group Meeting on Cambodia 6th and 7th December. Asian Development Bank (ADB), Phnom Penh. Becker, K., 2004. The Informal Economy: Fact Finding Study. SIDA, Stockholm. Bhowmik, S.K., 2005. Street Vendors in Asia: A Review. Economic and Political Weekly, May 28-June 4. Chantly, L., 1999. Strengthening recycling by promoting waste separation at source. A case of Phnom Penh households and the informal economy. Master’s Thesis, Asian Institute of Technology (AIT), Bangkok. Etherington, K. & Simon, D., 1996. Para transit and employment in Phnom Penh: the dynamics and development potential of cyclo-riding. Journal of Transport Geography, Vol.4, No.1: 37-53. Heinonen, U., 2004. Integrated and Socially Just Water Resources Management in the Lower Mekong River Region and Cambodia: How to Control Water-Related Rural Push Licentiate Thesis. Helsinki University of Technology, Espoo. Heinonen, U., 2005. Drinking water supplies and quality in the poor settlements of Phnom Penh, Cambodia; Case study of the fi ve villages 101, Drei Kro Horm, Prek Taroth, Kob Kong & Trapeang Chork. Helsinki University of Technology, Espoo. Heinonen, U., 2006. Environmental impact on migration in Cambodia: Water related migration from the Tonle Sap Lake Region. International Journal of Water Resources Development, Vol.22, No.3, pp.449-462. Heinonen, U., 2008. Millennium Development Goals and Phnom Penh: Is the City on Track to Meet the Goals? The Modern Myths of the Mekong. Helsinki University of Technology, Espoo. ILO, 2002. Beyond Survival - Organizing the Informal Economy. International Labour Organization (ILO), Geneva. ILO, 2004. Global Employment Trends. International Labour Organization (ILO), Geneva. Ishengoma, E.K. & Kappel, R., 2006. Economic Growth and Poverty: Does Formalisation of Informal Enterprises Matter? German Institute of Global and Area Studies (GIGA), Hamburg. Ministry of Planning, 2001. Cambodia Statistical Yearbook 2001. Ministry of Planning, Phnom Penh. Monyrath, N., 2005. The Informal Economy in Cambodia: An Overview. Economic Institute of Cambodia, Phnom Penh. http://www.eicambodia.org/downloads/fi les/ ER8_informal_economic.pdf Municipality of Phnom Penh, 1999. Urban Poverty Reduction Strategy for Phnom Penh. Municipality of Phnom Penh, Phnom Penh. Palmade, V., 2002. The Importance of Sector Level Perspective: Findings and Methodology of the McKinsey Global Institute - Draft. World Bank. Sethuraman, S.V., 1997. Urban Poverty and the Informal Sector. United Nations Development Programme, Geneva. Schneider, F., 2002. Size and Measurement of the Informal Economy in 110 Countries Around the World. Paper presented at a Workshop of Australian National Tax Centre, ANU, Canberra, Australia, July 17, 2002. Straub, S., 2005. Informal economy: The credit market channel. Journal of Development Economics 78:299- 321. Sophy, E., 2002. Study on Land Availability for City Development in Phnom Penh Metropolitan Area. Asian Coalition for Housing Rights, Phnom Penh. SUPF, 2003. Phnom Penh: An information booklet of the city’s development and the settlements of the urban poor. Solidarity for the Urban Poor Federation (SUPF), Phnom Penh. Thomas, J.J., 1995. Surviving in the City: The Urban Informal economy in Latin America. Pluto Press, London. Trebilcock, A., 2005. Decent Work and the Informal Economy. Discussion Paper No. 2005/4. World Institute for Development Economics Research (WIDER), Geneva. URC, 2004. Secure Tenure and Poor Communities in Phnom Penh: Pilot Project 2004. Urban Resource Centre (URC), Phnom Penh. USG, 2003. Report on an Analysis of the Informal Economy in Phnom Penh. Urban Sector Group (USG), Phnom Penh. Heinonen - The hidden role of informal economy
  • 10. 132 World Bank, 2003. World Development Indicators 2003. World Bank Group, Geneva. World Bank, 2004. Seizing the Global Opportunity: Investment Climate Assessment and Reform Strategy for Cambodia. World Bank Group, Geneva. World Bank, 2006. Cambodia: Halving Poverty by 2015? World Bank, Phnom Penh. This publication is available electronically at water.tkk.fi /global/publications Modern Myths of the Mekong - Part III: Development