Gattaca Comparative Analysis

Gattaca Comparative Analysis
The novel, Never Let Me Go, by Kazuo Ishiguro and the film, Gattaca, directed by Andrew Niccols both explore through structural techniques how
society's expectations and fate can either limit or drive a person's desire to succeed and the unfairness of discrimination. Although the protagonists in
both texts face discrimination due to scientific advances in genetic engineering technology, the way that the characters are shown to cope with
prejudice are vastly different. Both texts employ the positioning of the reader to evoke sympathy, in addition to using narrative structure and plot
development to demonstrate how the influence of society can either impede or stimulate a person's dream. While Ishiguro proposes that the
expectations of society...show more content...
In both texts, fate is considered to be determined by a person's position in the respective social hierarchies. While Ishiguro explains in his novel that
most people accept their fate, Niccols demonstrates through the character of Vincent that each person has the power within themselves to create their
own fate. Ishiguro adopts a non–linear storyline, where the majority of the novel consists of structural flashbacks into Kathy H's life. The novel
begins at the end, where the reader learns that the narrator's name is "Kathy H" and that she has "been a carer now for over eleven years". The fact
that Kathy H explains at the beginning of the novel about her compliance with the cloning program foreshadows how all clones, including herself, will
ultimately "complete". Ishiguro structurally employs this nonmenclature to emphasise the irony of the clones "completing" what they were created to
do in their lives. Contrastingly, at the beginning of Gattaca, Vincent was shown to already be living out his dream career. Niccols uses the structure of
revealing this at the beginning of the film; instead of showing Vincent's progression in a linear storyline, to explain how, dissimilarly to Never Let Me
Go, fate can be changed. This demonstrates how fate is not dependent on a person's social standing, but on the persistence and determination that one
Get more content on HelpWriting.net

Gattaca
Gattaca Questions
Part I (Short Answer)
1) Compare the genetic traits of Vincent and Anton. How are they similar? How are they different? They are tall, brunette and men. They are different
because Jerome does not have a heart condition, where Vincent does. Also, I noticed that Jerome is right handed, and Vincent is left handed; this
provides symmetry.
2) What does the character "German" do for a living? German's character helps invalids do what they are told they cannot by finding people with perfect
DNA, then sells their genetic codes to lesser important people in return for a part of their salary trades identities in the black market
3) What is an "in–valid"? An invalid is a genetically–inferior person.
4) List...show more content...
I think this relates to the swimming scenes between Vincent and Anton because whenever Vincent and Anton would race in the waters to see who
would turn back first, Vincent would always come in second place (silver medal).
3. What name does Jerome choose for himself? Is there any significance to this name? Jerome wants to be called by his middle name: Eugene. With
research on the internet, I have found that Eugene comes from the Greek word meaning "well–born", which is a huge symbol in the movie. Also,
"eugenics" is the science of improving the genetic qualities of a species, which is also very interesting. 4. Do Vincent and Jerome stick to their new
names consistently through the film, or are there moments when they revert to their original names? It is very rare that they use their original names
since Vincent is practically becoming Jerome (taking his identity).
5. As the story unfolds, Jerome's behavior and especially his remarks about himself reveal a great deal . How would you describe his character? In
this movie, the society only valued 'perfect' individuals, which means they had a bright future according to their DNA. Jerome realized he would
never be seen as 'human' again because he became crippled after trying to commit suicide. In a way he was broken, and the only valuable thing about
him was his genetic code,

Gattaca The Movie Essay
Tiarra Ehret
1.A.
There are many cases that apply to the notion of "wisdom of repugnance" other than cloning; a case that jumped out at me that I found on the intranet
that supports a good moral guide is a father and daughter who got married. The 18 year old girl grew up with her mother, who she states was bi–polar
and had other mental health issues. The girl meets her father who was not a part of her life. During the first week they meet the father and daughter
decided they were destined to be together and were going to get married. This supports a good moral guide because it is a social and religious custom
that you do not marry within the family.
A wonderful example is some people do not find the use of aborted baby stem cells to treat...show more content...
The first differences between the three are looking at designing and arranging human genomes. During the movie Gattaca this movie talks about
human genetic modification. Children are pre embedded with genes to allow them to own the finest traits when they are born. These children known
as "valids" (the pre embedded children) are known to have superior cognitive capabilities than those who were born the old traditional way. In the
world of genetic and bio–medical technology scientist still use the traditional birth but test the baby's genes and

Gattaca Essay Topics
How soon, will there be the opportunity to select certain traits from a mother and father to make their ideal child? If so, would society be
accepting of potential parents deciding to create their child in this way? The idea choosing specific traits for people's children has been around
for many of years, but as the years go on and the more research that is being done the closer we are to this reality. If something like this does
happen, society for future generations is more than likely to be drastically different than it is now. Is a world where you have to certain traits in
order just to be considered fit for society, a world that we want our children, grandchildren, etc. to live in? But it could be beneficial to everyone if all
people were the same and no one could dominate over the other and all would actually be created equal....show more content...
Gattaca takes place in the not so distant future where artificial genetic selection is a reality. In this movie a man named Vincent played by Ethan
Hawke was conceived without the help of technology of the future. Since he was created naturally he is considered an "in–valid" along with being
given a life expectancy of 30.2 years probably due to his eradicated physical dysfunctions of a congenital heart defect and myopia. In order to become
a "valid" Vincent must take on the identity of Jerome Eugene Morrow played by Jude

Gattaca: A Philosophical Analysis Essay
Brimming with ultramodern scenery and metaphysical speculation, Gattaca is a profound glimpse into the not–so–distant future of humanity. Vincent,
the main character, is a frustrated 'faith birth' living in a world in which his genetically manipulated peers have succeeded him in every competition.
Motivated by an unquenchable fascination with space, Vincent recruits the chronically petulant but genetically flawless Jerome Morrow, who allows
Vincent to assume his genetic identity in exchange for companionship and free alcohol. As Jerome, Vincent is quickly hired and becomes a celebrated
success at Gattaca, America's leading space station. Poignant and triumphant, Gattaca provides the discerning viewer with a philosophical perspective
of the...show more content...
Exceeding the expected potential of an 'invalid' and embarking on a flight to Titan, Vincent harnesses the power of human will and defies the
constraints of a society restricted by materialistic delusions. Illustrating the triumph of free will over materialist reductionism, Director Josef –
oblivious to Vincent's deception – praises Vincent's work, saying, 'not one error on a million keystrokes! Phenomenal. It's right that someone like you is
taking us to Titan'.
The ethical issues expressed in Gattaca raise multiple philosophical questions about the morality involved in legal dishonesty, the importance of
majority gain, and God's role in determining right and wrong. Relativism states that moral standards change to suit the unique circumstances of every
act (Velasquez 513). Although dishonest, Vincent's identity falsification would not be considered immoral by a relativist, who would view the unjust
genetic discrimination imposed upon Vincent by society as sufficient cause for a necessary deception. Paradoxically, a utilitarian– aiming at the
greatest good for the greatest number – would vouch instead for the morality of 'genoism': while Vincent's genetic flaws did not obstruct his
competence, a utilitarian would classify him as a rare exception to an otherwise efficient and collectively beneficial system (Velasquez 523). The
position maintained by Scriptural Divine Command theory, however, is distinguished by its disregard for consequences in

How Is Gattaca A Utopia
'One man's utopia is another man's dystopia.' This is a famous quote we must often bear in mind when writing about such topics and it is often fairly
accurate. A utopian society, in this essay, will be defined as a "non
–existent society that is described in considerable detail..." (Fitting, 1993, 1) and an
ideal and visionary society that enjoys perfection in various fields such as politics, law and more as seen in Thomas More's famous novel, Utopia. A
positive utopian society is often impossible due to a variety of reasons, primarily human nature and the inevitable inequality found in these idealized
societies. A prime example of how a utopian society is often impossible can be found in Andrew Niccol's film,Gattaca (1997). The film Gattaca
explores a new version of an idealized society, a utopia that revolves heavily around genetic engineering. In Gattaca, an individual's future is delineated
by his or...show more content...
Gone are the days where modern day factors like merit and aptitude dominate. With the rise of genetic engineering as a social norm, congenital
difference now becomes the main discerning factor differentiating the human population as the obsession with perfection grows stronger. This
promotes both genetic stratification and genetic discrimination. Narrated by Vincent Freeman, the story of Gattaca is told through his eyes. Viewers
are able to catch a glimpse of Vincent's life and his struggles in attempting to escape the genetic hierarchical system he was born in. Vincent does so in
order to fulfill his dream of becoming an astronaut, a dream that was never meant to be realized for someone like Vincent. The film utilises many
techniques such as flashbacks, metaphors and relationship dynamics to supplement the film's plot and shows us how a idealized utopian society is
impossible through the story of

Eugene In Gattaca
Niccols questions the idea that one can triumph or fail (make or break) with ambition and is not based on genetics can be examined through the
contrast of Vincent and Eugene in Gattaca. Eugene, a 'valid' ex–swimmer who was 'never meant to be one step down on the podium", is a product of
the crushing weight of the social expectations – failing in his attempts for success. Consequently, he tries to commit suicide by "walking in front of
that car" sober and fails, making him a paraplegic. Arrogant and mildly depressed, Eugene feels as if he "couldn't even get that right" and "if at first
you don't succeed, try and try again!" – enlightening the audience in believing that even though he was born for success, ambition and triumph are not
based

Examples Of Nature In Gattaca
Gattaca, a Classic example of Nature vs Nurture, but in this example a miracle happened where Nurture won, because in the reality of case studies,
Nature often being the side that wins. Gattaca was a great Sci–Fi Thriller movie at it's era. It tells us about how dream of life that comes with a trial,
that You must test and polish yourself in order to face the great challenges of life. Transcend the realm of life and death, and then you will be able
to make your way calmly and safely through any crisis that confronts you (Ueshiba, 1992). Vincent (Nurture), born with a weak body, talentless, and
with a life expectancy of about 30 years, does not accept his fate. He never has. As a child, he had swimming contests with his brother Anton
(Nature), born a superior being who has all the right scores but eventualy lost to Vincent and needs to be saved from drowning. Now Vincent dreams
of becoming a crew member on an expedition to one of the moons of Saturn. With the help of an illegal DNA broker, he makes a deal with a man
named Jerome (Jude Law), who has the right genes...show more content...
Vincent disguised as Jerome gets a job as a programmer, supplies false genetic samples and becomes a finalist for the space shot to saturn.In
Gattaca, it is an act of criminal to be what you are not meant to be, an act of criminal to exceed the limit of your gen capabilities, an act of criminal
to literally defy your fate for higher life purpose, and an act of criminal to fake an identity in a flat, Orderly, Pre–Utopiac, and robotic world of
labourers like Gattaca,yet it shows that the Gods favor the man with the just cause like Vincent(Martin, 1996). In attempting to be a finalist of the
Saturn program, He succeded in becoming an employee, and no longer a

Gattaca Essay
The story of Vincent shows in Gattaca that there is possibility of beating the genetic engineering system. Vincent is one of the last naturally born
babies born into a sterile, genetically enhanced world, where life expectancy and disease likelihood are ascertained at birth. Myopic and due to die
at 30, he has no chance of a career in a society that now discriminates against your genes, instead of your gender, race or religion. Vincent an invalid,
dreams of working within Gattaca and making it into space. He combines with Jerome who was disabled in an accident to take his identity and live his
life to enter the Gattaca Corporation. Vincent is selected for his lifelong desire, a manned mission to Titan.
But did Vincent really beat genetic...show more content...
He gained help from the cleaner which took his cup of water, which was his previous boss when he was a cleaner at Gattaca.
Constantly passing gene tests by diligently using samples of Jerome's hair, skin, blood and urine, his now perfect world is thrown into increasing
desperation, his dream within reach. The mission director is killed and he carelessly loses an eyelash at the scene, which puts Vincent/Jerome at the
scene. Certain that they know the murderer's ID, but unable to track down the former Vincent, the police start to close in, with extra searches, and new
gene tests. With the once in a lifetime launch only days away, Vincent must avoid arousing suspicion, while passing the tests, evading the police, and
not knowing whom he can trust.
But as the film come to an end you could see Vincent's valid perfect world was coming to a discrete stop by his brother trying to convict him of the
fraud at Gattaca. Vincent unwilling tells Anton that it is to far now and that he has beaten the system to let him fly to space. All of Vincent's and
Jerome's effort and hardship been put into this launch, and he would never let his own brother which was a genetically engineered male stop his path
to his life long dream. Jerome shows how elitist the valid are and how they look down on

Essay On Gattaca
Andrew Niccol's movie Gattaca is a film established in 1997, based around the idealistic view of perfection. This film has a variety of underlying
themes and concepts based solely around discrimination and DNA. This film incorporates science fiction and crime fiction to introduce the issue of
genetic manipulation in attempt to eradicate human nature. For my response I have chosen to do a visual to demonstrate my understanding and
knowledge of the films significance in relation to modern society. This piece was influenced by the films techniques and key elements such as
symbolism that is used in the most forthright way. I have used colour, quotes and symbols from the text to reflect on the importance of the films
aspects whilst doing is a new way. The film Gattaca represents a world submerged in a lack of humanity and individuality due to the obsession with
perfection. I have used this visual to demonstrate the society that has been taken over my genetic engineering.
For this assignment I have chosen to use pen and watercolour for my median for this response. I decided to chose a visual for my piece to work to my
advantages and to give the readers a new and creative way of seeing an in–depth view of Gattaca. This response was...show more content...
Discrimination is a key theme in this text, using the visual I have shown that the blood in the bag is from an in–valid human. I have included Eugene's
wheelchair in order to show the issue of once being perfect but an imperfection lowers that status, which is one of the biggest known issue throughout
the film. Because of this issue, Eugene is discriminated by Gattaca and therefore lets Vincent take his place in order to achieve his own goals.
Vincent: "I don't know how to thank you" Jerome: "No, no. I got the better end of the deal. I only lent you my body. You lent me your

Ethical Issues In Gattaca
The movie Gattaca is set in the future, and is a story about a man named Vincent Freeman who dreams of traveling to the stars. In this future, society
has developed categories that each person falls in to depending on their genetic makeup. In the film parents have the ability to choose specific genetic
composition of their children. Vincent Freeman's genetics leave him in the less than favorable category making his dreams of space travel at Gattaca
Corporation impossible. As one of the last natural born babies in a sterile and genetically enhanced world, Vincent had poor eyesight, heart
problems and was not expected to live past the age of 30. Society has determined that people such as Vincent are in an underclass of humans and
are only good for menial jobs simply based on their genotype. Vincent's dreams will not be stifled so he devises a scheme to buy another identity. He
finds Jerome Morrow a former athlete with favorable genetics, and a paraplegic as the result of a tragic car accident. The two become skilled at
deceiving DNA tests as well as urine and blood testing. With Vincent and Jerome's plan in place Vincent finds himself in a position to join a crew
planning to travel to one of Saturn's moons, Titan. Unfortunately...show more content...
An increase in social standards, placing pressure on people to pursue perfection could very well lead to the demise of social integrity. Although
society in the film was sterile and genetically enhancing embryos was necessary, in reality significantly altering nature could very well lead to the
demise of our humanity. We live in a world of freedom and choices, the opportunity to pursue our dreams. It is ethically wrong to limit a person's
potential and oppress their desires simply because of their genetic makeup. We as a society have worked very hard and continue to work hard for
social freedom, equality and the right to

Gattaca (Summary and Analysis) Essay
Gattaca
A Film by Andrew Niccol
Summary and Analysis
Summary
Exactly five seconds after he came into the world, Vincent Freeman was already considered to be a looser. His first genetic test revealed high
probabilities of hyperactivity, sight troubles and serious heart diseases, a life expectancy of 30 years and 2 months and quite low intellectual faculties.
At that time, the artificial insemination of test tube babies selected according to their genetic potential had become for many people "the natural way of
making children". But Vincent's parents had preferred to let the other nature take its course. Of course they regretted it, and for their next child they
went to see a geneticist. A perfect son has been born to them, a son...show more content...
Just when Vincent was about to be sent to undertake a mission on Titan, one of the managers is assassinated in his office. The police went through the
whole company with a fine–tooth comb and found one of Vincent's eyelashes. After a fast analysis, they found out that it belonged to a man who had
worked long ago for the company as a cleaner but who had disappeared years before. The mysterious man was the number one suspect and his picture
was everywhere. But no one matched it with the wrong Jerome. No one but the lieutenant who was no other than his brother, Anton. For him, that was
hard to believe. This brother who had always been inferior to him was then far above in the hierarchy and had become a murderer. At first, he tried to
protect him. Totally puzzled, he wanted to understand how Vincent managed to joinGattaca before he is arrested, so he did everything in order that
the inspector who was in charge of the case could not find him. Irene is an attractive and intelligent woman, also employee at Gattaca. She has got the
same dream as Vincent but she presents an inadmissible risk of heart failure which stops her from going into space. She grew very fond of Vincent but
she thought he would not be interested since she was not as perfect as him. Of course, Vincent does not have the same opinion as her or anybody else
about shortcomings. He

Gattaca Movie Essay
Gattaca Film and Social Position
Social position refers to the class of an individual in the society. It is noted various communities have different ways of measuring the social status of
an individual. For instance, wealth, level of education and genetic character of a person. The paper is critically analyzing a film Gattaca and the social
measurement of the characters in a given community.
Gattaca is a film by Andrew Niccol. The main character Vincent Freeman was considered to be a looser on his arrival to the world. When he was
taken for a genetic test, he revealed body weakness. He had hyperactivity, and his sight had trouble with serious heart diseases. Therefore, he had a
very short life expectancy of 30 years and 2 months. His intellectual faculties were very low, and the parents were very sad. Although many people
preferred test–tube babies, Vincent's parents made a mistake by choosing the artificial way. They regretted, and for their second child they went
artificial way getting a perfect son Anton. He was taller and considered better than Vincent the elder brother. The two used to play at softy game, and
Vincent was always the winner....show more content...
The film argues Vincent had poor genes and fragile health. The parents considered him a failure and never wanted to spend money on him. They took
the initiative to see a gene cist for their second child and gave birth to a perfect child Anton. He was taller and better at anything than his elder brother
and was given priority as the parents were ready to spend on his good education. However, Vincent appeared more soft and intelligent. He worked very
hard despite his father's discouragements. Therefore, the film gives clear evidence that poor genes determine the position of an individual in Gattaca

Gattaca Essay
As a society, each and every one of us possesses an inner strength that aids us to overcome the impediments in life that we may face. This inner strength
is what we call our human spirit.
In the film Gattaca directed by Andrew Niccol the power of the human spirit is exemplified as the prominent theme, presented through the
characterisation of Vincent Freeman, the protagonist of the film. Vincent is a young man living in a world which discriminates against one's genes, and
unfortunately for Vincent he possesses "Inferior Genes". Through the verbal techniques of dialogue and narration and the visual features of camera
angles and lighting Vincent's inferiority is exposed. Through some of these same techniques as well as the technique of...show more content...
Due to his heart condition exercise to Vincent is overbearing, his pain can be seen when he leaves the exercise area only to collapse to the floor of the
changing room with a pounding heart. He is willing to endure such struggle to find his dreams – epitomizing the human spirit.
During his time at Gattaca Niccol again further reminds the audience of his inferiority, to establish the power of the human spirit relative to the extent
of hindrances Vincent faces. Lighting is used by Niccol during a scene where Vincent's real identity is threatened to be exposed. Hiding in the corner of
the alleyway the shadow cast against Vincent's face again replicate that of prison bars. This again suggests Vincent remains trapped behind bars due to
his genetic inferiority. By constantly reminding us Vincent's adversity Niccol heightens the theme regarding the power of the human spirit.
Albeit the adversities Vincent eventually overcomes these sentiments inferiority, and through the strength deemed to him through his human spirit
fulfils his aspiration of going into space. It is in the final sequence that Niccol utilises a conjunction of the techniques which exemplify Vincent's evident
triumph, a success which his undying determination and human sprit has led him, set within the interior of a space shuttle. A close–up shot of
Vincent's face indicate his realisation of his aspiration through the small tears that well up

Gattaca essay
Section 1: Question 1 – The society of Gattaca works to repress rather than to enhance the potential of human beings. Discuss.
In a society where genetic superiority and engineering to create the 'perfect' person is a priority over all else, it would be a normal assumption that
society would be a better place and people would be much happier, but in Gattaca it is quite the opposite. From the beginning of the film we see
haunting images of the uniformity and soulless behaviour of the Gattaca employees. All people regardless of race, gender, class or age should have an
equal opportunity to strive to their full potential if desired, but the society of Gattaca represses the potential of many capable people simply because
they are...show more content...
Jerome is lucky enough to have superior genes, thus giving him the opportunity to achieve his full potential. Throughout his whole life he was
expected to succeed at everything he was faced with, and being an Olympic swimmer, he was expected to win but "for the genetically superior,
success is easier to attain. But is by no means guaranteed. After all, there is no gene for fate." But what does this prove? Genes don't change
personality or fate, they just allocate your future for you in Gattaca.
The society of Gattaca has been destroyed by cruel selfish acts of genoism when if only they could just look past the difference in DNA and accept
human nature then Gattaca could come together as a whole. Vincent is a good demonstration that if you put your mind to it you can achieve anything,
even when 'destiny' is against

Analysis of the Bioethical Issues in Gattaca Biology is the science of life. Technology uses science to solve problems. Our society has progressed in its
understanding of life to the point that we are able to manipulate it on a fundamental level through technology. This has led to profound ethical
dilemmas. The movie Gattaca explores some important bioethical issues that are currently the focus of much dispute. The underlying thematic issue
presented is the question of the extent to which biologically inherent human potential determines the true potential of a person. Perhaps the most
controversial issue in Gattaca is the use of genetic engineering technology in humans to create a more perfect society; this is, essentially, a new...show
more content...
This is shown through the accomplishments of the genetically inferior main character, Vincent. Vincent was naturally conceived and born, leaving
flaws in his genetic code that could have been eliminated through engineering. Notwithstanding, he is able to outperform his genetically engineered
colleagues in the Gattaca space program. The movie is primarily about the difficulties he faces because of discrimination that results from judging a
person's worth based only on their genetic profiles. Many fear that this sort of discrimination could become a reality in our future. Legislation has
already been passed to prevent discrimination based on genetic testing. In the movie this sort of legislation existed but was ignored. Obviously, the plot
would have been much different if such legislation were adequately enforced.
Eugenics is the name given by Francis Galton to a theory for improving humanity through "judicious matings... to give the more suitable races or
strains of blood a better chance of prevailing speedily over the less suitable". However, this process for bettering society through biological
improvement is an indirect method. Through advanced technology, the step of selective breeding could possibly be bypassed. With these technologies
it may be possible to directly and

Gattaca Identity Essay
Another film with a similar message is one named 'Gattaca'. An old theory based film that wraps itself around the concept of the expected future,
contains relevance to identity in majority of its scenes. Vincent, the leading character for this film as he is the only, in 'Gattaca' terms, faith–birth that is
introduced. As stated in the film introduction, Vincent, unlike many others, knows "there is no gene for fate". Knowing this, he never once doubts
his capabilities of making it all the way no matter what it takes, to get what he wants. In the Gattaca world, blood carries no nationality which makes
everyone equally created and modified. A child conceived of love was one not risked as chances of perfection and survival were slim. It wouldn't...show
more content...
In both of these films, identity is shown as a main idea and becomes the source of courage to change the path of oneself. Josie accepted who she is
and her origin as well as ethnic background after she met Jacob. While Vincent accepted what his genes where made of after meeting Irene and never
gave up on proving everyone false. Changed the idea of telling everyone what they can and cannot do as well as limit their capabilities, was the main
concept of both these productions.
One of the most accurate sources, as tradition for centuries, are books that can also be a relevant relation to this particular topic. One short story book
in particular which carries the same reference, is 'Growing up Asian in Australia'. Within this book, there are a series of multiple short stories that all
revolve around the same core, 'identity and belonging'. Some stories, such as 'Sticks and Stones and Such–like' tend to amplify another cultures
struggles and their expectations compared to the world around them. The traditions they are appressed to follow in contrast to generations within
another country they are exposed to, make a difference in

Gattaca Essay
"We were wondering if it's good to leave some things to chance."
In the world of Gattaca, is this a wise course of action?
Gattaca is a science–fiction thriller movie, directed by Andrew Niccol. It presents a story of the future prospect of genetic engineering and how it will
affect human society. Gattaca gives one perspective of how the future of discrimination is no longer determined by social status or the colour of skin
because the discrimination is now down to a science, Vincent: "I belonged to a new underclass, no longer determined by social status or the colour of
your skin. No, we now have discrimination down to a science." The better the genes in your body are the better job you will get. In the future world,
like presented...show more content...
They don't have any dreams or desire. They don't even need to improve themselves to become whatever they want, it is all because their abilities have
all been pre–determined in the laboratory before they were born. Even though Vincent starts to work here as a janitor due to his In–Validity, he keeps
trying to get his dream by finding a "borrowed ladder, Jerome Morrow". Vincent's dream leads him to achieved as well as or better than many people
who have been genetically engineered because of his human spirit. It is one of the things why it is important to leave nothing programmed.
It is better to leave some of a child's abilities unprogrammed. It because natural conception produces humans that have spirits, emotions, and dreams.
The scientist in Gattaca would think that leaving the child's abilities to chance is something stupid and they would not agree of that. However, the
director shows clearly that is wiser to remain human. In this movie, he shows some examples such as Vincent beats Anton at swimming, Irene falls
in love with Vincent even when she discovers that he is not who he says he is. Irene doesn't care who Vincent actually is, she's already fallen in love
with Vincent's personality. Jerome supports Vincent in his dreams and is happy to die when he succeed, "I got the better end of the deal. I only lent
you my body; you lent me your dreams". One more thing

Gattaca
Andrew Niccol's Gattaca portrays a discriminatory society in which status and quality of life is determined solely by a DNA profile. However, it is
against this oppressive regime that Vincent Freeman shines, as Niccol conveys the importance of maintaining individuality В– in those qualities which
deem his protagonist unique. Throughout the film Niccol criticises those who conform and contribute to this, while simultaneously he praises those
valids who do rebel in order to emphasise how pivotal it is that the human race does not succumb to lead the existence portrayed by this "not to distant
future" society.
From an early point in the film, Niccol depicts the environment of the Gattaca corporation. It is a sterile and artificial world...show more content...
Here, this juxtaposition As a child, Anton is seen to possess much arrogance, stating coldly to Vincent "How many astronauts are there anywayВ…I
bet I could be one, if I wanted" and taunting him with comments such as "come on you coward" during their frequent swimming challenges. Hence
Anton can be considered as one who believes that success will be delivered to him solely because he possesses a "far cleaner profile". Yet, here Niccol
reveals Anton's fault in this assumption, as ironically he is in adulthood he is observed working as a "law–enforcement" officer in a position less
respected than Vincent who is a highly esteemed "First–class Navigator". Hence Here, this is perhaps one of the most significant indicators of Niccol's
underlying message to hold onto one's individuality, as Vincent is seen to succeed not due to his superior genetics, but to his persistence and dedication.
Furthermore, Niccol praises the numerous individuals, besides Vincent, who act to rebel against the prejudiced society in which they live. Take
Irene, who initially appears equally preoccupied with science as other valids as she has Vincent "sequenced". In this scene, Niccol emphasises the
shallow ideals on which this society bases love, as the woman alongside Irene casually remarks "I kissed him five minutes agoВ…a real good one"
However, following Irene's discovery of Vincent's

Gattaca Comparative Analysis

Recommended

Recommended

More Related Content

Recently uploaded

Recently uploaded (20)

Featured

Featured (20)

Gattaca Comparative Analysis