SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 57
rWay
          ou
      y, Y y Way
My Wa     av
    th eN
and
rW        ay
          ou
      y, Y y Way
My Wa      av bbie R. Bailey
    th e N Bo idley, LLC
and         e Ma
                r tin &
                        R
         om
          ard R
       How
key
                  e ry
                   e
                           1. Nav
               Cas
            thre e
             to ev
                                 y Kn
                          2. Nav owledge
                                y Co
                         3. Nav
       Nav y

                                    ntrol
      e nts
     e a re




                               yC          hoic
                                               es
 e lem
Th er




                     Bobb
                          i
                     Rom e R. Bai
                        e Ma     le
                            rtin y, Howa
                                & Ri
                                    dley rd
                                        , LLC
i rms
                         one
                      Navy
                            .”
                                     1. Fran
                     erts
                 ti ffs f


                                              cis B
                                    2. Will
                  use

                                                   urge
                                                         r
              f ou r

                                            iam
                                   3. Arn
            “E xp
                                                 Lowe
                                                       ll
           ral ly
          Pl ai n




                                          old M
                                  4. And          oore
       o) of



                                         re           w Ot
                                                           t
     ge ne
(o r tw




                               Bobb
                                    i
                              Rom e R. Baile
                                  e Ma
                                      rtin & y, Howar
                                             Ridle     d
                                                  y, LL
                                                        C
Y
       DGE
      NAV         Whe
                        n did
                 first
                       lear n the U.S. N
               there         or w        avy
   WLE
                        were      ar n t
              asso            haza      hat
                     ciate
              A sb e       d wit rds
                     stos       h the
KNO


                          on it
                               s shi use of
                                    ps?


           Bobb
                i
          Rom e R. Baile
              e Ma
                  rtin & y, Howar
                         Ridle     d
                              y, LL
                                    C
FRANCIS BURGER, (Page 96:8 to 96:13)
                                                                       96
                               8 Q. Okay. Do you know when the Navy first warned




                is
               er
                               9 of the asbestos -- the hazards associated with asbestos?

           ra nc              10    A. The first warnings that I'm aware of began in
                              11 the late -- early 1970s where the Navy directed that


         B urg
                              12 they remove asbestos materials from their purchase
                              13 orders, from their requirements.
    ta in F
Cap




                  Bobb
                       i
                 Rom e R. Baile
                     e Ma
                         rtin & y, Howar
                                Ridle     d
                                     y, LL
                                           C
FRANCIS BURGER, (Page 285:3 to 285:13)
                                                                         285
                               3 Q. Well, are you aware that approximately around
                               4 1971, Puget Sound Naval Shipyard implemented certain
                               5 procedures for wearing respirators and protective gear




                is
                               6 to protect individuals from asbestos?




               er
                               7    A. I have read testimony to the effect that they
           ra nc               8 started to implement procedures about the time that


         B urg
                               9 OSHA -- or subsequent to the time that OSHA issued
                              10 their instructions. That I can testify to.
                              11       But to what extent that they did and for
                              12 what -- for what level of protection that they were
    ta in F

                              13requiring, I -- I can't tell you. I don't know.
                              14 Q. Are you aware they also supplied warnings
                              15 about asbestos at the shipyard?
                              16    A. The first time that I can remember seeing any
                              17 warnings posted in the shipyard was in the early
                              18 '80s. I do not remember seeing any warnings before
                              19 that. But, again, I was not a -- a daily visitor to
Cap




                              20 the shipyard, and I did not work there at that time.




                  Bobb
                       i
                 Rom e R. Baile
                     e Ma
                         rtin & y, Howar
                                Ridle     d
                                     y, LL
                                           C
CAPTAIN LOWELL, (Pages 63:23 to 64:10)
                                                             63
                          23   Q. When did you first become aware of the
                          24 hazards of asbestos?
                          25    A. Mid- to late '60s.




          am
           ll
                                                                  64




    Lowe
                           1      Q. And was that while you were serving in
                           2   the Naval Reserves?
    W illi
                           3       A. Bath Iron Works.
                           4       Q. You learned of the hazards of asbestos
                           5   through the Iron Works?
                           6       A. Through the Harvard medical study.
                           7       Q. Okay. And what did you learn at that
      ai n


                           8   time?
                           9       A. That asbestos could be hazardous to
                          10   your health.
Ca pt




              Bobb
                   i
             Rom e R. Baile
                 e Ma
                     rtin & y, Howar
                            Ridle     d
                                 y, LL
                                       C
CAPTAIN LOWELL, (Page 64:18 to 64:21)



          am
                                                                 64




           ll
                          18 Q. Do you know when the Navy first became



    Lowe
                          19 aware of the hazards of asbestos?
    W illi
                          20    A. I'm not fully privy to what the Navy
                          21 knew and when they knew it.
      ai n
Ca pt




              Bobb
                   i
             Rom e R. Baile
                 e Ma
                     rtin & y, Howar
                            Ridle     d
                                 y, LL
                                       C
WILLIAM LOWELL, (Page 115:3 to 115:13)



          am
                                                                 115




           ll
                           3 Q. Very good. From 1965 to 1967, did Bath



    Lowe
                           4 Iron Works ever put a visible warning on any of its
    W illi
                           5 ships discussing the hazards of asbestos?
                           6    A. I don't know.
                           7    Q. Did you see it?
                           8    A. I don't remember one right now in the '66,
                           9 '67 time frame.
      ai n


                          10    Q. Did you rely on the Navy to warn their
                          11 sailors?
                          12    A. I don't know what the Navy was telling
                          13 their sailors at that time.
Ca pt




              Bobb
                   i
             Rom e R. Baile
                 e Ma
                     rtin & y, Howar
                            Ridle     d
                                 y, LL
                                       C
WILLIAM LOWELL, (Pages 115:20 to 116:8)



          am
                                                                115




           ll
                          20 Q. Okay. You knew that using



    Lowe
                          21 asbestos-containing insulation was hazardous; is
    W illi
                          22 that correct?
                          23    A. I knew there was a problem in 1966, yes,
                          24 sir.
                          25    Q. And was it your understanding that the
      ai n


                                                                   116
                           1   Navy would take care of its own personnel with
                           2   regard to the ships that you were building that had
                           3   asbestos in them?
Ca pt




                           4        MR. XXXXXXX: Objection; vague and
                           5   ambiguous.
                           6        THE DEPONENT: I didn't know really what
                           7   the Navy was doing after ships commissioned. I --
                           8   I am not -- I just don't know.


              Bobb
                   i
             Rom e R. Baile
                 e Ma
                     rtin & y, Howar
                            Ridle     d
                                 y, LL
                                       C
g
                        ,
                  T im e
                 , L on
           L on g
In a L Up on a

             –
        Ago
      a nd
  On ce




                             Bobb
                                  i
                            Rom e R. Baile
                                e Ma
                                    rtin & y, Howar
                                           Ridle     d
                                                y, LL
                                                      C
November, 1922
                     Occupation Hazards and Diagnostic Signs
  A guide to impairments to be looked for in hazardous occupations




                                                    Lists asbestos
                                                     workers as a
                                                      hazardous
                                                      occupation




   by Lois I. Dublin, Ph.D. and Phillip Leiboff
U.S. Department of Labor Bureau of Labor Statistics Bulletin No. 306
November, 1922
                   Occupation Hazards and Diagnostic Signs
A guide to impairments to be looked for in hazardous occupations




                                             There are four
                                          effective methods
                                         that may be used to
                                              prevent the
                                           inhalation of dust
                                           generated during
                                         industrial processes.
November, 1922
                             Occupation Hazards and Diagnostic Signs
          A guide to impairments to be looked for in hazardous occupations



1. The use of
water to dampen
the dust and thus
prevent it from
rising and filling
the atmosphere

                                                         2. The use of
                                                         exhaust systems
                                                         which remove
                                                         dust at the
                                                         point of origin
November, 1922
                               Occupation Hazards and Diagnostic Signs
           A guide to impairments to be looked for in hazardous occupations




3. The use of
enclosing
chambers in
which the dust-
producing                                        4. The use of
processes are                                    respirators and
confined, being                                  helmets. In many cases
regulated from                                   it may be necessary to
the outside                                      combine several of
                                                 these measures
                                                 effectively to prevent
                                                 the inhalation of dust
                                                 by the worker.
1939 Annual Report Surgeon General,
         U.S. Navy Hazard of Asbestosis



                              Asbestosis is an industrial
                              Asbestosis is an industrial
                                  disease of the lungs
                                  disease of the lungs
                              incident to the inhalation
                               incident to the inhalation
                                  of asbestos dust for
                                  of asbestos dust for
                              prolonged periods, and is
                               prolonged periods, and is
                              distinct from silicosis. The
                              distinct from silicosis. The
                                  development of the
                                  development of the
                              disease depends upon the
                              disease depends upon the
                              concentration of the dust,
                              concentration of the dust,
                                  the size of the dust
                                   the size of the dust
                               particles, and the length
                                particles, and the length
                                      of exposure.
                                      of exposure.

 Bobb
      i
Rom e R. Baile
    e Ma
        rtin & y, Howar
               Ridle     d
                    y, LL
                          C
1939 Annual Report Surgeon General,
         U.S. Navy Hazard of Asbestosis




                                The workers in the Pipe Covering
                                The workers in the Pipe Covering
                              and Insulating Shop are exposed to
                              and Insulating Shop are exposed to
                              the insulation of the asbestos dust
                              the insulation of the asbestos dust
                              incident to the cutting of asbestos
                               incident to the cutting of asbestos
                              insulating felt in the fabrication of
                               insulating felt in the fabrication of
                               covers for flanges, valve bonnets,
                                covers for flanges, valve bonnets,
                                  and high temperature steam
                                   and high temperature steam
                               turbines. The material falls under
                               turbines. The material falls under
                                 the trade name of “Amosite.”
                                  the trade name of “Amosite.”



 Bobb
      i
Rom e R. Baile
    e Ma
        rtin & y, Howar
               Ridle     d
                    y, LL
                          C
Gen on
                                eral,
                                 os is
                                  e
                             S urg                                          The following
                                                                            The following

                          be st
                                                                     recommendation made
                                                                      recommendation made
                      po r t

                     of As                                        jointly by the medical officer
                                                                  jointly by the medical officer
                                                                    of the Yard and the safety
                                                                    of the Yard and the safety
                 al Re



                                                                     engineer was approved;
                                                                     engineer was approved;
                                                                    Install an exhaust blower
              az ard


                                                                    Install an exhaust blower
                                                                      over work table in the
                                                                       over work table in the
          Annu




                                                                         Pipe Covering and
                                                                         Pipe Covering and
       av y H




                                                                         Insulating Shop to
                                                                         Insulating Shop to
                                                                      remove asbestos dust
                                                                      remove asbestos dust
    1939




                                                                          at the source as a
                                                                          at the source as a
U.S. N




                                                                        protective measure
                                                                        protective measure
                                                                        against the hazards
                                                                        against the hazards
                                                                             of asbestos.
                                                                              of asbestos.
                                     Bobb
                                          i
                                    Rom e R. Baile
                                        e Ma
                                            rtin & y, Howar
                                                   Ridle     d
                                                        y, LL
                                                              C
U.S. Navy Knowledge
     1939: Navy Hospital Manual – Aware of Asbestos-Containing
                            Insulation


Q: What precautions                                         At all navy yards, the
are exercised to                                            Commandant is the
prevent damage from                                         head of the
pipecovering                                                organization. ….He is
compounds? What                                             familiar with the
asbestos hazards                                            nature of the work
exist?                                                      being performed and…
                                                            the health and
A: Masks for asbestos                                       accidents presented.
workers.



  The Government, having passed such [health and safety] laws must therefore lead
  the way in protecting its own employees. The United States Navy is one of the
  largest of the industries maintained by this Government. An organization has
  been set up in the Navy to protect its personnel, both civilian and naval.
Minimum Requirements for Safety and Industrial
                Health in Contract Shipyards



                                            Approved U.S. Navy
                                              January 20, 1943

                                              Approved U.S.
                                                  Maritime
                                                Commission
                                              February 9, 1943


               Bobb
                    i
              Rom e R. Baile
                  e Ma
                      rtin & y, Howar
                             Ridle     d
                                  y, LL
                                        C
Minimum Requirements for Safety and Industrial
                Health in Contract Shipyards




     …it is simply good common sense
     that as much care and attention be
     given to protecting the human
     factors in the war production
     program as is given machines.
                      Bobb
                           i
                     Rom e R. Baile
                         e Ma
                             rtin & y, Howar
                                    Ridle     d
                                         y, LL
                                               C
Minimum Requirements
                                         S-6. Employee Safety Training


6.4 All Employees shall be instructed in
their specific duties by their immediate
supervisor and they shall be made
familiar with the hazards of the job and
instructed carefully in how to avoid
them. It shall further be the duty of the
supervisor to constantly check all
employees so unsafe working practices
may be corrected before accidents
occur.




                            Bobb
                                 i
                           Rom e R. Baile
                               e Ma
                                   rtin & y, Howar
                                          Ridle     d
                                               y, LL
                                                     C
Navy Safety Review: July 1947
Department of the Navy Bureau of Medicine and Surgery
                             Bumed Instruction 6270.3
                                    November 7, 1955




                                        Purpose: To establish as a basic
                                      reference the threshold limit values
                                       of toxic materials, adopted by the
                                            American Conference of
                                      Governmental Industrial Hygienists,
                                      and to provide guidance toward the
                                          reduction of potential health
                                       hazards encountered in industrial
                                       environment for both military and
                                            naval civilian personnel.



         Bobb
              i
        Rom e R. Baile
            e Ma
                rtin & y, Howar
                       Ridle     d
                            y, LL
                                  C
U.S. Navy (Formally) Adopts 5 mppcf as TLV
                       for Asbestos – 1955
U.S. Navy (Formally) Adopts 5 mppcf as TLV
                       for Asbestos – 1955
From


             L
                                 the m

         TRO
                         enlis
                               tmen oment o
                        cont          t – on        f
                             ract            ce t h
                       Navy        was             e
                                         si g n
     C ON
                              p
                      the n ractical           ed –
                            ew e          ly ow the
                     and           nliste        ned
                           Soul           e “H
                                .”              e ar t
NAVY




              Bobb
                   i
             Rom e R. Baile
                 e Ma
                     rtin & y, Howar
                            Ridle     d
                                 y, LL
                                       C
T he
                 n ual
            MP –
          ts’ M a
       T CA
     jacke
  B OO
Blue




                     Bobb
                          i
                    Rom e R. Baile
                        e Ma
                            rtin & y, Howar
                                   Ridle     d
                                        y, LL
                                              C
on
                d in
              191 8
             Ed iti
         li sh e
     Six th
     pu b
Th e
wa s




                      Bobb
                           i
                     Rom e R. Baile
                         e Ma
                             rtin & y, Howar
                                    Ridle     d
                                         y, LL
                                               C
1. Wou
                      k
                                       ld
                                    me t you agr

                  p ert
                  o As                   hat t
                                                he E  ee w
                                    Cont
                                        ract        nlistm ith
            y Ex                   Emp          was         ent
                                                    NOT
           o ns t

                                       loym
                                   a. A S e n t a t W
                                         ai l o         ill?
                                          “qui r who d
      y Na v


                                               t”          e
                                         disci the Nav cided to
     ue sti



                                              pl i ne     y wo
                                        inclu         d–u      uld b
                                              ding        p to       e
                                       – de                    a nd
                                            pend the death
                                      circu         in         p
                                            msta g on the enalty
 Ever
Ten Q




                                                   nc es
                                                        .

                      Bobb
                           i
                     Rom e R. Baile
                         e Ma
                             rtin & y, Howar
                                    Ridle     d
                                         y, LL
                                               C
2. W
                                       ould
                                     me t you agr

                      k
                  p ert
                                          hat t       ee w
                  o As              Emp
                                         loyer
                                                he         ith
                                   relat        /
            y Ex                        ionsh employe
                                                         e
           o ns t

                                  dem          ip wa
                                       ocra         s no
                                   a. A     cy?          ta
      y Na v

                                             S ai l o
                                         all la r who fa
     ue sti



                                                w             i
                                        disci ful orde led to ob
                                               p            rs    e
                                       inclu lined – u would b y
                                              d             p     e
                                      – de ing the d to and
                                            pe              e
 Ever
Ten Q




                                     circu nding o ath pena
                                            msta          n     lty
                                                    nces the
                                                        .
                      Bobb
                           i
                     Rom e R. Baile
                         e Ma
                             rtin & y, Howar
                                    Ridle     d
                                         y, LL
                                               C
3.
                                                             Wou
                                                                   ld yo
                                                            agre          u
                                                                   e w it
                                                           me t          h
                                                                 hat t

                      k
                                                           Navy       he


                  p ert
                  o As                                    Sailo
                                                                rs
                                                                  told
            y Ex                                         onbo
                                                               ard
           o ns t

                                 a. Wh                  ship
                                                             :
                                         en t o
                                b. Wh           wake
      y Na v

                                       en to
                               c. Wh           show
     ue sti



                                      en to         er
                               d. Wh         ea t
                                     en to
                             e. Wh         smok
                                                  e
 Ever
Ten Q




                                    en to
                            f . Wh        repo
                                                rt to
                                   en to              work
                           g. Wh         relax
                      Bobb
                                  en       n to g
                           i
                     Rom e R. Baile              o to
                         e Ma
                             rtin & y, Howar
                                                      b ed.
                                    Ridle     d
                                         y, LL
                                               C
4. W
                                        ould
                                     me t you agr

                      k
                                          hat t
                                                he N ee with

                  p ert
                  o As              Sailo
                                         rs on
                                                boar
                                                     avy t
                                                           o ld
            y Ex                     a. Ho             d shi
                                    b.
                                          w to              p:
           o ns t
                                               take
                                          How       as          show
                                                 to dr                 er
                                  c.     How
                                                        ess
                                               to m
                                 d.
      y Na v

                                                       ake t
     ue sti



                                        How                  hei r
                                             to sh                  b eds
                                e.     How
                                                     i ne t
                                                           heir
                                            to cu                 shoe
                               f.     How
                                                    t the
                                                          ir h a
                                                                         s
                                           to f o                ir/sh
                              g.
 Ever
Ten Q




                                                  ld th                 ave
                                     How                ei r c
                                         /Wh                   lothe
                                               ere t                  s
                                                      o go
                                                             to be
                      Bobb                                          d.
                           i
                     Rom e R. Baile
                         e Ma
                             rtin & y, Howar
                                    Ridle     d
                                         y, LL
                                               C
5.     Wou
                                                     l
                                               the N d you ag
                                              cont avy mai ree with


                      k
                                                   r         n
                                             sailo ol of the tained s me that



                  p ert
                  o As                       a. S
                                                   r on
                                                    choo
                                                             t         t
                                                        ship raining o rict
                                                            ? Inc
                                                                  ludin f every
                                                         ls
            y Ex                                1)
                                                 Firef
                                                                       g:
           o ns t
                                         2) W ighting
                                        3) M elding
                                       4) B achinist Mate
      y Na v

                                               oiler
                                      5) E            Tend
     ue sti



                                              lectr        er
                                     6) H           ician
                                   b. C ull Repair/
                                                          D
                                  c. O orrespondenc amage Contr
 Ever
Ten Q




                                  d. N n the job train e courses        ol
                                      AVSH              ing
                                     Man    IPS(B
                                        uals      USHI
                                                         PS) T
                                                              echn
                                                                   ical
                      Bobb
                           i
                     Rom e R. Baile
                         e Ma
                             rtin & y, Howar
                                    Ridle     d
                                         y, LL
                                               C
k
                  p ert
                  o As
            y Ex
           o ns t
      y Na v
     ue sti
 Ever
Ten Q




                      Bobb
                           i
                     Rom e R. Baile
                         e Ma
                             rtin & y, Howar
                                    Ridle     d
                                         y, LL
                                               C
k
                  p ert
                  o As
            y Ex
           o ns t
      y Na v
     ue sti
 Ever
Ten Q




                      Bobb
                           i
                     Rom e R. Baile
                         e Ma
                             rtin & y, Howar
                                    Ridle     d
                                         y, LL
                                               C
k
                  p ert
                  o As
            y Ex
           o ns t
      y Na v
     ue sti
 Ever
Ten Q




                      Bobb
                           i
                     Rom e R. Baile
                         e Ma
                             rtin & y, Howar
                                    Ridle     d
                                         y, LL
                                               C
k
                  p ert
                  o As
            y Ex
           o ns t
      y Na v
     ue sti
 Ever
Ten Q




                      Bobb
                           i
                     Rom e R. Baile
                         e Ma
                             rtin & y, Howar
                                    Ridle     d
                                         y, LL
                                               C
7. W
                                              o uld


                      k
                                                    you a


                  p ert
                                           that
                  o As                          the N     gree
                                          stric       avy m with m
                                               tc                   e
                                         envi ontrol o aintained
            y Ex                              ronm         f
                                        Inclu        ent o the work
           o ns t

                                              ding        n s hi
                                        a           :           p?
                                      . Ven
                                    b. To tilation
      y Na v
     ue sti



                                            o
                                   c. Eq ls
                                           u
                                   d. Te ipment
                                         mpe
                                  e. Pe       ratur
 Ever
Ten Q




                                                   e
                                        rs         onne
                                                        l/Ma
                                                             nnin
                                                                  g
                      Bobb
                           i
                     Rom e R. Baile
                         e Ma
                             rtin & y, Howar
                                    Ridle     d
                                         y, LL
                                               C
k
                  p ert
                  o As
            y Ex
           o ns t
      y Na v
     ue sti




                                                               i
 Ever
Ten Q




                                                              p
                                                             s

                                                         t
                                                        h
                                                       r
                      Bobb                            o
                           i
                     Rom e R. Baile                  u
                         e Ma
                             rtin & y, Howar        g
                                    Ridle     d    h
                                         y, LL
                                               C
                                                   a
Ty p
                                        ica l M
                                                il ita r
                              Cen t
                                    Sp ec
                                          ifica          y
                                   rifu g       tio ns
                               Mag       a l Pu         :
                                     ne si a mp s;
                                             Blo c
                                                    k




 Bobb
      i
    e Ma
Rom e R. Baile
               Ridle
        rtin & y, Howar
                    y, LL
                         d
                          C
9. W

                      k
                  p ert
                                            ould
                  o As                  that
                                              if an
                                                   you a
                                                    equi
                                                           gree
                                                                 with
                                        man                pme        me
            y Ex                             ufact               nt
                                       want         urer
           o ns t

                                             ed t o        or a
                                      to a p        make vendo
                                             rodu            a cha    r
                                     Milit
                                           ary S ct covere nge
      y Na v


                                    that          pe c i        d by
     ue sti



                                         they           fi
                                   proc         woul cations
                                         eed          d ha
                                  chan         throu        ve to
                                        nels?         gh N
                                                            avy
 Ever
Ten Q




                      Bobb
                           i
                     Rom e R. Baile
                         e Ma
                             rtin & y, Howar
                                    Ridle     d
                                         y, LL
                                               C
10.W
                                            ou l d
                                            me t        you a


                      k
                                                 h at t        g
                                                        he P ree with


                  p ert
                  o As                     Safe
                                          prim
                                                ty w
                                                      as N
                                                             e rs o
                                                                    n
                                                            OT th nel
                                                ary m               e
            y Ex                         Navy           issio
                                                W              n of
           o ns t

                                        fact t arship               a
                                              he o          – and
                                       prec         rder            in
                                             e de n       of
      y Na v


                                    1)The           ce w
                                                          as :
     ue sti




                                          Miss
                                   2)The       ion;
                                         Ship
                                  3)The      ;
 Ever
Ten Q




                                        M          en.
                      Bobb
                           i
                     Rom e R. Baile
                         e Ma
                             rtin & y, Howar
                                    Ridle     d
                                         y, LL
                                               C
ES
                            T he
                                 Unit
                           – No       ed S
        HO I C             man
                                t equ
                                      ipme
                                           tates
                                                 Navy
                               ufact        n
                          vend       urers t
                               ors –        or
                         choi
                              ces. made th
    Y C


                                               e
NAV




                 Bobb
                      i
                Rom e R. Baile
                    e Ma
                        rtin & y, Howar
                               Ridle     d
                                    y, LL
                                          C
FRANCIS BURGER- Vol. I, (Page 189:1 to 189:8)
                                                                    189
                           1 Isn't it true, though, that the Navy had the final




                is
                           2 say about what equipment went on that ship?




               er
                           3    MS. XXXXXXX: Vague; overbroad.
           ra nc           4    THE WITNESS: That's incorrect. The company had the
                           5 final say. This was a new type of contracting that was

         B urg
                           6 under Mr. McNamara, and we were -- we were -- oh, they
                           7 could make life difficult for us, but they did not have
                           8 the final say.
    ta in F
Cap




                  Bobb
                       i
                 Rom e R. Baile
                     e Ma
                         rtin & y, Howar
                                Ridle     d
                                     y, LL
                                           C
FRANCIS BURGER, (Page 347:13 to 347:22)
                                                                        347
                              13 Q. Sir, when the Navy used insulation for
                              14 protection of personnel, it was the Navy that made the
                              15 choice of what insulation it wanted to use, be it




                is
               er
                              16 elastomeric or cork or any other external insulation; is
                              17 that correct?
           ra nc              18    A. I don't believe so, no. I think that choice


         B urg
                              19 would have been the vendors' choice. The Navy would
                              20 have only dictated insofar as the temperatures and
                              21 fulfillment of the military specifications for either
                              22 ship construction or equipment construction.
    ta in F
Cap




                  Bobb
                       i
                 Rom e R. Baile
                     e Ma
                         rtin & y, Howar
                                Ridle     d
                                     y, LL
                                           C
l of
                                      Duri


              rer s
                                              ng W
                                     when            orld
                                               most        War
           ntro
                                    Ship               of th    II,
                                          s inv
                                                  olve e Navy
       fa ctu                      asbe
                                          s t os        d in
                                  bein           litiga
                                         g bu            t
                                                ilt, th ion were
    Y Co


                                 exer                  e Na
                                        cised                vy
                                 Man             Cont
 M an u


                                       ufact
                                Vend          urers rol over
                                       ors i           a
                                              n a n nd
NAV




                                ways
                                     .               u mb
                                                           er of


                    Bobb
                         i
                   Rom e R. Baile
                       e Ma
                           rtin & y, Howar
                                  Ridle     d
                                       y, LL
                                             C
l of
              rer s
           ntro
       fa ctu
    Y Co
 M an u
NAV




                    Bobb
                         i
                   Rom e R. Baile
                       e Ma
                           rtin & y, Howar
                                  Ridle     d
                                       y, LL
                                             C
December 19, 1941 U.S. Office of Production
                       Management Bulletin:

                              “Where there is a refusal to recognize a
                              priority rating on an order placed by…the


                l of
                              Secretary of the Navy…the plant may be


              rer s
           ntro               seized by the United States and heavy fines
                              enacted.”
       fa ctu
    Y Co
 M an u
NAV




                    Bobb
                         i
                   Rom e R. Baile
                       e Ma
                           rtin & y, Howar
                                  Ridle     d
                                       y, LL
                                             C
of
                   s
           t ure r
          n tro l
     u fa c
    Y Co
 Ma n
N AV




                    Bobb
                         i
                   Rom e R. Baile
                       e Ma
                           rtin & y, Howar
                                  Ridle     d
                                       y, LL
                                             C
August 20, 1943 War Production Board
Compliance Order:

    “Compliance with orders and
    regulations with the War
    Production Board may be
    enforced by criminal prosecution
    and civil injunction proceedings…
    criminal or civil prosecution
    under the Second War Powers
    Act shall be the customary
    method of enforcing
    compliance.”
                             Bobb
                                  i
                            Rom e R. Baile
                                e Ma
                                    rtin & y, Howar
                                           Ridle     d
                                                y, LL
                                                      C
November 4, 1943 War Production Board
                       Memo:

                              “…there has been a steady
                              decline in production in
                              essential components [like
                              Asbestos]….These components
                              are essential to the completion
                              of all ships whether war or
                              cargo…in fact the entire
                              mechanized economy of the
                              country both war and civilian.”

 Bobb
      i
Rom e R. Baile
    e Ma
        rtin & y, Howar
               Ridle     d
                    y, LL
                          C
uc ts
                  fort
                                         December 12, 1943 Memo to Secretary of
                                         the Navy:
           P rod
           a r Ef                                  “Amosite blankets and
                                                   pipecovering…[are] the only
                                                   flexible material which has
   a nd W
   e st os



                                                   proven satisfactory under high
                                                   temperature….
                                                   [production] facilities are
                                                   considered to be of sufficient
Asb




                                                   importance to the War Effort to
                                                   justify Governmental
                      Bobb
                                                   financing.”
                           i
                     Rom e R. Baile
                         e Ma
                             rtin & y, Howar
                                    Ridle     d
                                         y, LL
                                               C
•Asb
                                                         e s t os
                                                •Asb              Board
                                                       estos                (NAV
                                                                 Paper             SPEC

                             d at
                                               •Asb                       ( N AV             17-I-
                                                      estos                                         6 d)



             g P ro b est os-
                                             •Asb               Fiber             SPEC
                                                                                          17-I-




                          s f or
                                                    e s t os             (NAV                    9)
                                                                                SPEC




                              e
                                           •Asb                Ro d P                   17-I-
                                                   estos                ackin                  29)
                                                             Sheet            g (NA




                       d Us
                                         •Asb
        lea st pe ci fie
                                                 estos                 (NAV           VSPE
                                                           C lo t h           SPEC             C HH
                                        •Hig                         ( N AV           32 - A           -P-36
                                                h Tem                        SPEC             -3)             b)
                    du ct              •Asb
                                               estos
                                                          p . Ce
                                                                   ment
                                                                           (NAV
                                                                                     32- C
                                                                                            -11)
                                     •Asb              Finis                      SPEC
                                                                h i ng
                 bo ar                       estos
                35 A s

                                                      F e lt (          Ceme              32-C
                                    •Asb                        NAV            nt (N              -14a/
                                           e s to s                     S P EC       AVS                 h)
                                   •Blo              M i l lb                                PEC
                                         ck an                 oard             32-F-               32-C
                                                                      (NAV            1 a /b )            - 16)
             av y S




                                 •Asb             d Pi p                      SPEC
                                        e s t os           ecove
                                                 Plaste             ring (            32-M
                                •Hig                                        NAV               -1a/f)
           Ship

                                       h Tem                r (NA                 SPEC
                                                 perat               VSPE                 32-M
                                                         ur e B              C 32 -                -2a/b
                              •Cor                                lock,             P-2a/                )
                                    rugat                                 Pipec            b)
                                                                                 overi
    t ai ni n




                             •Pipe          ed As                                      n g , an
    U.S. N




                                    c ove r           besto                                     d Cem
                                            ing (N             s Pap                                     ent
                            •Asb                                       er (N
                                  estos                AVS                   AVS
                                          Paper                 PEC                PEC
                           •Insu                     and T              32-P-             32-P-
                                 lating                        ape (N         6)                  4)
                          •Insu           Therm                          AVS
                                lating               al Ta                     PEC
                                         Therm                pe (N                  32-P-
                                                                       AVS
Co n




                                                    al Blo                   PEC             9)
                                                              ck (N                32-T-
                                                                       AVS                1)
                                                                             P EC
                        Bobb                                                       32-I-
                             ie R.                                                       3)
                        Ridle       B
                              y, LL ailey, Ho
                                   C         ward
                                                  Rom
                                                      eM             artin
                                                                           &
•Asb
                                                             es t o s
                                                   •Asb                Cloth
                                                           e stos                 G as k
                                                                                          e t s (N


                               t
                                                 •Asb                M itt e                         A VS
                       f ie d a                                                n s (N


                         stos-
                                                          e st os                       A VS                PEC




        Sh ip b cts fo r
                                               •Asb                 G as k                       PEC                33
                                                        es t o s            et s , E                    HH-M -G-2a/g)




                        U se
                                             •Asb                  Gask              n cas e                      -3 9
                                                                                                d (NA
                                                       e stos
                                                                 G as k
                                                                          ets, S
                                                                                    piral                VSPE 1b)
                                           •Spi                          et s , M            (N A V               C 33
                                                   ra l G                          etalli              SPEC              -G-4
                                          •She              as k e t                                            3 3 -G          a)
                 Asb e
                                                  et Pa              s f or                 c (NA                       -5 )
                                                           ck i n g           B oil e                  VSPE
                 p eci

                                                                                       rs (N

                 o ard
                                         •Clo                         (N A V                     A VS          C 33
                                                th Str                           SPEC                   PEC           -G -8
                                                          a nds                                                               )
                od u
                                       •Asb                         (M IL                  3 3- P              3 3 -G
                                               es t o s                     -C-12                   -2c)               -1 1 )
                                     •Asb                 Pack                        07)
                                             es t o s              ing C
                                                        Shee               loth (
                                    •Asb                         t, Ha              MIL-
                                           e st os
          a vy S




                                                                        rd (M                 P-12
            t 35



                                                     , B lo                                           33)
         ng P r


                                                             ck a n               IL-A
                                                                       d P ip             -1383
                                  •Pac                                          e-Co                 )
                                        k in g                                          v er i n
                                                 M at e                                          g, up
                                                          ri a l , A                                     t o 75
                                                                     s b es t                                   0°F (
      le as




                               •Pac                                           os, M                                     NA V
                                     king;                                             et al l i                                SPEC
                                              Asb e
   U.S. N




                              •Tap                      s to s,                                  c Cl o
                                    e , In s                      Shee                                  th, Sh
   taini




                             •Gas            u l at i n                  t, Co                                   e et a n
                                   kets,                g, As                     mpre                                    d Tap
                            •Ele           Boile                  besto                   s s ed                                 e
                                 ctrica              r, Me               s ( NA                    (N A V
                                         l A sb               tallic               VSPE                     SPEC
                           •Gas                   e stos               -A s b                 C 17                    H H -P
                                kets (                      Boar               es t o s                T14)                    -46b)
                                        NA V                         d ( NA              (N A V
Con




                                                  SPEC                          VSPE               SPEC
                                                             33-G                         C 17               3 3 -G
                                                                      -2 )                        -I-6)              -11)
                         Bobb
                              i
                        Ridle e R. Baile
                             y, LL      y, Ho
                                  C          ward
                                                  Rom
                                                      eM                artin
                                                                              &
1. The
                                      Na
                                       Abou avy Kne
                                      Near t Asbest w More
                   key
                  e ry
                                                       o
                                    Ame ly Every s Than
                          2.               rica        Entit

                   e
                                                            y in
               Cas
                                   The
            thre e
             to ev
                                          Navy
                                  Cont
                                  Emp     rol O Exercise
                                         loyee ver its d Strict
       Nav y
                                Supp
                                        liers s, Vendo
                         3.
      e nts
     e a re




                              T he                       rs a n
                                      Navy                     d
                             of its          W
                                      O w n a s t he M
 e lem




                           C hoi
                                    ces i Destiny. aster
Th er




                          Were             n Th
                        The         T he         ese C The
                                  Unite Sole Pro ases
                                          d Sta      vince
                                                tes N       o
                     Bobb
                     Rom
                          ie R.                       avy. f
                         e Ma Bailey,
                              rti
                              n&R     How
                                          a
                                    idley rd
                                         , LLC

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

2006 a wrist-worn_integrated_health_monitoring_instrument_with_a_tele-reporti...
2006 a wrist-worn_integrated_health_monitoring_instrument_with_a_tele-reporti...2006 a wrist-worn_integrated_health_monitoring_instrument_with_a_tele-reporti...
2006 a wrist-worn_integrated_health_monitoring_instrument_with_a_tele-reporti...Gaurav Butail
 
Patho physiology of pain
Patho physiology of painPatho physiology of pain
Patho physiology of painsunenasomani
 
Teoria del desarrollo psicosocial de erikson
Teoria del desarrollo psicosocial de erikson Teoria del desarrollo psicosocial de erikson
Teoria del desarrollo psicosocial de erikson Maria Lusiana Duran Petit
 
Executive Education and Corporate Training
Executive Education and Corporate TrainingExecutive Education and Corporate Training
Executive Education and Corporate TrainingFaisal Faruqui
 
Ciri ciri pembentukan-kurikulum (3)
Ciri ciri pembentukan-kurikulum (3)Ciri ciri pembentukan-kurikulum (3)
Ciri ciri pembentukan-kurikulum (3)ani91_yahoo
 

Viewers also liked (8)

2006 a wrist-worn_integrated_health_monitoring_instrument_with_a_tele-reporti...
2006 a wrist-worn_integrated_health_monitoring_instrument_with_a_tele-reporti...2006 a wrist-worn_integrated_health_monitoring_instrument_with_a_tele-reporti...
2006 a wrist-worn_integrated_health_monitoring_instrument_with_a_tele-reporti...
 
Nxt ejercicios 6,7 y 8
Nxt ejercicios 6,7 y 8Nxt ejercicios 6,7 y 8
Nxt ejercicios 6,7 y 8
 
I Did it My Way
I Did it My WayI Did it My Way
I Did it My Way
 
triki
trikitriki
triki
 
Patho physiology of pain
Patho physiology of painPatho physiology of pain
Patho physiology of pain
 
Teoria del desarrollo psicosocial de erikson
Teoria del desarrollo psicosocial de erikson Teoria del desarrollo psicosocial de erikson
Teoria del desarrollo psicosocial de erikson
 
Executive Education and Corporate Training
Executive Education and Corporate TrainingExecutive Education and Corporate Training
Executive Education and Corporate Training
 
Ciri ciri pembentukan-kurikulum (3)
Ciri ciri pembentukan-kurikulum (3)Ciri ciri pembentukan-kurikulum (3)
Ciri ciri pembentukan-kurikulum (3)
 

Navy Knowledge Choices

  • 1. rWay ou y, Y y Way My Wa av th eN and
  • 2. rW ay ou y, Y y Way My Wa av bbie R. Bailey th e N Bo idley, LLC and e Ma r tin & R om ard R How
  • 3. key e ry e 1. Nav Cas thre e to ev y Kn 2. Nav owledge y Co 3. Nav Nav y ntrol e nts e a re yC hoic es e lem Th er Bobb i Rom e R. Bai e Ma le rtin y, Howa & Ri dley rd , LLC
  • 4. i rms one Navy .” 1. Fran erts ti ffs f cis B 2. Will use urge r f ou r iam 3. Arn “E xp Lowe ll ral ly Pl ai n old M 4. And oore o) of re w Ot t ge ne (o r tw Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 5. Y DGE NAV Whe n did first lear n the U.S. N there or w avy WLE were ar n t asso haza hat ciate A sb e d wit rds stos h the KNO on it s shi use of ps? Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 6. FRANCIS BURGER, (Page 96:8 to 96:13) 96 8 Q. Okay. Do you know when the Navy first warned is er 9 of the asbestos -- the hazards associated with asbestos? ra nc 10 A. The first warnings that I'm aware of began in 11 the late -- early 1970s where the Navy directed that B urg 12 they remove asbestos materials from their purchase 13 orders, from their requirements. ta in F Cap Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 7. FRANCIS BURGER, (Page 285:3 to 285:13) 285 3 Q. Well, are you aware that approximately around 4 1971, Puget Sound Naval Shipyard implemented certain 5 procedures for wearing respirators and protective gear is 6 to protect individuals from asbestos? er 7 A. I have read testimony to the effect that they ra nc 8 started to implement procedures about the time that B urg 9 OSHA -- or subsequent to the time that OSHA issued 10 their instructions. That I can testify to. 11 But to what extent that they did and for 12 what -- for what level of protection that they were ta in F 13requiring, I -- I can't tell you. I don't know. 14 Q. Are you aware they also supplied warnings 15 about asbestos at the shipyard? 16 A. The first time that I can remember seeing any 17 warnings posted in the shipyard was in the early 18 '80s. I do not remember seeing any warnings before 19 that. But, again, I was not a -- a daily visitor to Cap 20 the shipyard, and I did not work there at that time. Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 8. CAPTAIN LOWELL, (Pages 63:23 to 64:10) 63 23 Q. When did you first become aware of the 24 hazards of asbestos? 25 A. Mid- to late '60s. am ll 64 Lowe 1 Q. And was that while you were serving in 2 the Naval Reserves? W illi 3 A. Bath Iron Works. 4 Q. You learned of the hazards of asbestos 5 through the Iron Works? 6 A. Through the Harvard medical study. 7 Q. Okay. And what did you learn at that ai n 8 time? 9 A. That asbestos could be hazardous to 10 your health. Ca pt Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 9. CAPTAIN LOWELL, (Page 64:18 to 64:21) am 64 ll 18 Q. Do you know when the Navy first became Lowe 19 aware of the hazards of asbestos? W illi 20 A. I'm not fully privy to what the Navy 21 knew and when they knew it. ai n Ca pt Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 10. WILLIAM LOWELL, (Page 115:3 to 115:13) am 115 ll 3 Q. Very good. From 1965 to 1967, did Bath Lowe 4 Iron Works ever put a visible warning on any of its W illi 5 ships discussing the hazards of asbestos? 6 A. I don't know. 7 Q. Did you see it? 8 A. I don't remember one right now in the '66, 9 '67 time frame. ai n 10 Q. Did you rely on the Navy to warn their 11 sailors? 12 A. I don't know what the Navy was telling 13 their sailors at that time. Ca pt Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 11. WILLIAM LOWELL, (Pages 115:20 to 116:8) am 115 ll 20 Q. Okay. You knew that using Lowe 21 asbestos-containing insulation was hazardous; is W illi 22 that correct? 23 A. I knew there was a problem in 1966, yes, 24 sir. 25 Q. And was it your understanding that the ai n 116 1 Navy would take care of its own personnel with 2 regard to the ships that you were building that had 3 asbestos in them? Ca pt 4 MR. XXXXXXX: Objection; vague and 5 ambiguous. 6 THE DEPONENT: I didn't know really what 7 the Navy was doing after ships commissioned. I -- 8 I am not -- I just don't know. Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 12. g , T im e , L on L on g In a L Up on a – Ago a nd On ce Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 13. November, 1922 Occupation Hazards and Diagnostic Signs A guide to impairments to be looked for in hazardous occupations Lists asbestos workers as a hazardous occupation by Lois I. Dublin, Ph.D. and Phillip Leiboff U.S. Department of Labor Bureau of Labor Statistics Bulletin No. 306
  • 14. November, 1922 Occupation Hazards and Diagnostic Signs A guide to impairments to be looked for in hazardous occupations There are four effective methods that may be used to prevent the inhalation of dust generated during industrial processes.
  • 15. November, 1922 Occupation Hazards and Diagnostic Signs A guide to impairments to be looked for in hazardous occupations 1. The use of water to dampen the dust and thus prevent it from rising and filling the atmosphere 2. The use of exhaust systems which remove dust at the point of origin
  • 16. November, 1922 Occupation Hazards and Diagnostic Signs A guide to impairments to be looked for in hazardous occupations 3. The use of enclosing chambers in which the dust- producing 4. The use of processes are respirators and confined, being helmets. In many cases regulated from it may be necessary to the outside combine several of these measures effectively to prevent the inhalation of dust by the worker.
  • 17. 1939 Annual Report Surgeon General, U.S. Navy Hazard of Asbestosis Asbestosis is an industrial Asbestosis is an industrial disease of the lungs disease of the lungs incident to the inhalation incident to the inhalation of asbestos dust for of asbestos dust for prolonged periods, and is prolonged periods, and is distinct from silicosis. The distinct from silicosis. The development of the development of the disease depends upon the disease depends upon the concentration of the dust, concentration of the dust, the size of the dust the size of the dust particles, and the length particles, and the length of exposure. of exposure. Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 18. 1939 Annual Report Surgeon General, U.S. Navy Hazard of Asbestosis The workers in the Pipe Covering The workers in the Pipe Covering and Insulating Shop are exposed to and Insulating Shop are exposed to the insulation of the asbestos dust the insulation of the asbestos dust incident to the cutting of asbestos incident to the cutting of asbestos insulating felt in the fabrication of insulating felt in the fabrication of covers for flanges, valve bonnets, covers for flanges, valve bonnets, and high temperature steam and high temperature steam turbines. The material falls under turbines. The material falls under the trade name of “Amosite.” the trade name of “Amosite.” Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 19. Gen on eral, os is e S urg The following The following be st recommendation made recommendation made po r t of As jointly by the medical officer jointly by the medical officer of the Yard and the safety of the Yard and the safety al Re engineer was approved; engineer was approved; Install an exhaust blower az ard Install an exhaust blower over work table in the over work table in the Annu Pipe Covering and Pipe Covering and av y H Insulating Shop to Insulating Shop to remove asbestos dust remove asbestos dust 1939 at the source as a at the source as a U.S. N protective measure protective measure against the hazards against the hazards of asbestos. of asbestos. Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 20. U.S. Navy Knowledge 1939: Navy Hospital Manual – Aware of Asbestos-Containing Insulation Q: What precautions At all navy yards, the are exercised to Commandant is the prevent damage from head of the pipecovering organization. ….He is compounds? What familiar with the asbestos hazards nature of the work exist? being performed and… the health and A: Masks for asbestos accidents presented. workers. The Government, having passed such [health and safety] laws must therefore lead the way in protecting its own employees. The United States Navy is one of the largest of the industries maintained by this Government. An organization has been set up in the Navy to protect its personnel, both civilian and naval.
  • 21. Minimum Requirements for Safety and Industrial Health in Contract Shipyards Approved U.S. Navy January 20, 1943 Approved U.S. Maritime Commission February 9, 1943 Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 22. Minimum Requirements for Safety and Industrial Health in Contract Shipyards …it is simply good common sense that as much care and attention be given to protecting the human factors in the war production program as is given machines. Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 23. Minimum Requirements S-6. Employee Safety Training 6.4 All Employees shall be instructed in their specific duties by their immediate supervisor and they shall be made familiar with the hazards of the job and instructed carefully in how to avoid them. It shall further be the duty of the supervisor to constantly check all employees so unsafe working practices may be corrected before accidents occur. Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 24. Navy Safety Review: July 1947
  • 25. Department of the Navy Bureau of Medicine and Surgery Bumed Instruction 6270.3 November 7, 1955 Purpose: To establish as a basic reference the threshold limit values of toxic materials, adopted by the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists, and to provide guidance toward the reduction of potential health hazards encountered in industrial environment for both military and naval civilian personnel. Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 26. U.S. Navy (Formally) Adopts 5 mppcf as TLV for Asbestos – 1955
  • 27. U.S. Navy (Formally) Adopts 5 mppcf as TLV for Asbestos – 1955
  • 28. From L the m TRO enlis tmen oment o cont t – on f ract ce t h Navy was e si g n C ON p the n ractical ed – ew e ly ow the and nliste ned Soul e “H .” e ar t NAVY Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 29. T he n ual MP – ts’ M a T CA jacke B OO Blue Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 30. on d in 191 8 Ed iti li sh e Six th pu b Th e wa s Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 31. 1. Wou k ld me t you agr p ert o As hat t he E ee w Cont ract nlistm ith y Ex Emp was ent NOT o ns t loym a. A S e n t a t W ai l o ill? “qui r who d y Na v t” e disci the Nav cided to ue sti pl i ne y wo inclu d–u uld b ding p to e – de a nd pend the death circu in p msta g on the enalty Ever Ten Q nc es . Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 32. 2. W ould me t you agr k p ert hat t ee w o As Emp loyer he ith relat / y Ex ionsh employe e o ns t dem ip wa ocra s no a. A cy? ta y Na v S ai l o all la r who fa ue sti w i disci ful orde led to ob p rs e inclu lined – u would b y d p e – de ing the d to and pe e Ever Ten Q circu nding o ath pena msta n lty nces the . Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 33. 3. Wou ld yo agre u e w it me t h hat t k Navy he p ert o As Sailo rs told y Ex onbo ard o ns t a. Wh ship : en t o b. Wh wake y Na v en to c. Wh show ue sti en to er d. Wh ea t en to e. Wh smok e Ever Ten Q en to f . Wh repo rt to en to work g. Wh relax Bobb en n to g i Rom e R. Baile o to e Ma rtin & y, Howar b ed. Ridle d y, LL C
  • 34. 4. W ould me t you agr k hat t he N ee with p ert o As Sailo rs on boar avy t o ld y Ex a. Ho d shi b. w to p: o ns t take How as show to dr er c. How ess to m d. y Na v ake t ue sti How hei r to sh b eds e. How i ne t heir to cu shoe f. How t the ir h a s to f o ir/sh g. Ever Ten Q ld th ave How ei r c /Wh lothe ere t s o go to be Bobb d. i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 35. 5. Wou l the N d you ag cont avy mai ree with k r n sailo ol of the tained s me that p ert o As a. S r on choo t t ship raining o rict ? Inc ludin f every ls y Ex 1) Firef g: o ns t 2) W ighting 3) M elding 4) B achinist Mate y Na v oiler 5) E Tend ue sti lectr er 6) H ician b. C ull Repair/ D c. O orrespondenc amage Contr Ever Ten Q d. N n the job train e courses ol AVSH ing Man IPS(B uals USHI PS) T echn ical Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 36. k p ert o As y Ex o ns t y Na v ue sti Ever Ten Q Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 37. k p ert o As y Ex o ns t y Na v ue sti Ever Ten Q Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 38. k p ert o As y Ex o ns t y Na v ue sti Ever Ten Q Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 39. k p ert o As y Ex o ns t y Na v ue sti Ever Ten Q Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 40. 7. W o uld k you a p ert that o As the N gree stric avy m with m tc e envi ontrol o aintained y Ex ronm f Inclu ent o the work o ns t ding n s hi a : p? . Ven b. To tilation y Na v ue sti o c. Eq ls u d. Te ipment mpe e. Pe ratur Ever Ten Q e rs onne l/Ma nnin g Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 41. k p ert o As y Ex o ns t y Na v ue sti i Ever Ten Q p s t h r Bobb o i Rom e R. Baile u e Ma rtin & y, Howar g Ridle d h y, LL C a
  • 42. Ty p ica l M il ita r Cen t Sp ec ifica y rifu g tio ns Mag a l Pu : ne si a mp s; Blo c k Bobb i e Ma Rom e R. Baile Ridle rtin & y, Howar y, LL d C
  • 43. 9. W k p ert ould o As that if an you a equi gree with man pme me y Ex ufact nt want urer o ns t ed t o or a to a p make vendo rodu a cha r Milit ary S ct covere nge y Na v that pe c i d by ue sti they fi proc woul cations eed d ha chan throu ve to nels? gh N avy Ever Ten Q Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 44. 10.W ou l d me t you a k h at t g he P ree with p ert o As Safe prim ty w as N e rs o n OT th nel ary m e y Ex Navy issio W n of o ns t fact t arship a he o – and prec rder in e de n of y Na v 1)The ce w as : ue sti Miss 2)The ion; Ship 3)The ; Ever Ten Q M en. Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 45. ES T he Unit – No ed S HO I C man t equ ipme tates Navy ufact n vend urers t ors – or choi ces. made th Y C e NAV Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 46. FRANCIS BURGER- Vol. I, (Page 189:1 to 189:8) 189 1 Isn't it true, though, that the Navy had the final is 2 say about what equipment went on that ship? er 3 MS. XXXXXXX: Vague; overbroad. ra nc 4 THE WITNESS: That's incorrect. The company had the 5 final say. This was a new type of contracting that was B urg 6 under Mr. McNamara, and we were -- we were -- oh, they 7 could make life difficult for us, but they did not have 8 the final say. ta in F Cap Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 47. FRANCIS BURGER, (Page 347:13 to 347:22) 347 13 Q. Sir, when the Navy used insulation for 14 protection of personnel, it was the Navy that made the 15 choice of what insulation it wanted to use, be it is er 16 elastomeric or cork or any other external insulation; is 17 that correct? ra nc 18 A. I don't believe so, no. I think that choice B urg 19 would have been the vendors' choice. The Navy would 20 have only dictated insofar as the temperatures and 21 fulfillment of the military specifications for either 22 ship construction or equipment construction. ta in F Cap Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 48. l of Duri rer s ng W when orld most War ntro Ship of th II, s inv olve e Navy fa ctu asbe s t os d in bein litiga g bu t ilt, th ion were Y Co exer e Na cised vy Man Cont M an u ufact Vend urers rol over ors i a n a n nd NAV ways . u mb er of Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 49. l of rer s ntro fa ctu Y Co M an u NAV Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 50. December 19, 1941 U.S. Office of Production Management Bulletin: “Where there is a refusal to recognize a priority rating on an order placed by…the l of Secretary of the Navy…the plant may be rer s ntro seized by the United States and heavy fines enacted.” fa ctu Y Co M an u NAV Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 51. of s t ure r n tro l u fa c Y Co Ma n N AV Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 52. August 20, 1943 War Production Board Compliance Order: “Compliance with orders and regulations with the War Production Board may be enforced by criminal prosecution and civil injunction proceedings… criminal or civil prosecution under the Second War Powers Act shall be the customary method of enforcing compliance.” Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 53. November 4, 1943 War Production Board Memo: “…there has been a steady decline in production in essential components [like Asbestos]….These components are essential to the completion of all ships whether war or cargo…in fact the entire mechanized economy of the country both war and civilian.” Bobb i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 54. uc ts fort December 12, 1943 Memo to Secretary of the Navy: P rod a r Ef “Amosite blankets and pipecovering…[are] the only flexible material which has a nd W e st os proven satisfactory under high temperature…. [production] facilities are considered to be of sufficient Asb importance to the War Effort to justify Governmental Bobb financing.” i Rom e R. Baile e Ma rtin & y, Howar Ridle d y, LL C
  • 55. •Asb e s t os •Asb Board estos (NAV Paper SPEC d at •Asb ( N AV 17-I- estos 6 d) g P ro b est os- •Asb Fiber SPEC 17-I- s f or e s t os (NAV 9) SPEC e •Asb Ro d P 17-I- estos ackin 29) Sheet g (NA d Us •Asb lea st pe ci fie estos (NAV VSPE C lo t h SPEC C HH •Hig ( N AV 32 - A -P-36 h Tem SPEC -3) b) du ct •Asb estos p . Ce ment (NAV 32- C -11) •Asb Finis SPEC h i ng bo ar estos 35 A s F e lt ( Ceme 32-C •Asb NAV nt (N -14a/ e s to s S P EC AVS h) •Blo M i l lb PEC ck an oard 32-F- 32-C (NAV 1 a /b ) - 16) av y S •Asb d Pi p SPEC e s t os ecove Plaste ring ( 32-M •Hig NAV -1a/f) Ship h Tem r (NA SPEC perat VSPE 32-M ur e B C 32 - -2a/b •Cor lock, P-2a/ ) rugat Pipec b) overi t ai ni n •Pipe ed As n g , an U.S. N c ove r besto d Cem ing (N s Pap ent •Asb er (N estos AVS AVS Paper PEC PEC •Insu and T 32-P- 32-P- lating ape (N 6) 4) •Insu Therm AVS lating al Ta PEC Therm pe (N 32-P- AVS Co n al Blo PEC 9) ck (N 32-T- AVS 1) P EC Bobb 32-I- ie R. 3) Ridle B y, LL ailey, Ho C ward Rom eM artin &
  • 56. •Asb es t o s •Asb Cloth e stos G as k e t s (N t •Asb M itt e A VS f ie d a n s (N stos- e st os A VS PEC Sh ip b cts fo r •Asb G as k PEC 33 es t o s et s , E HH-M -G-2a/g) U se •Asb Gask n cas e -3 9 d (NA e stos G as k ets, S piral VSPE 1b) •Spi et s , M (N A V C 33 ra l G etalli SPEC -G-4 •She as k e t 3 3 -G a) Asb e et Pa s f or c (NA -5 ) ck i n g B oil e VSPE p eci rs (N o ard •Clo (N A V A VS C 33 th Str SPEC PEC -G -8 a nds ) od u •Asb (M IL 3 3- P 3 3 -G es t o s -C-12 -2c) -1 1 ) •Asb Pack 07) es t o s ing C Shee loth ( •Asb t, Ha MIL- e st os a vy S rd (M P-12 t 35 , B lo 33) ng P r ck a n IL-A d P ip -1383 •Pac e-Co ) k in g v er i n M at e g, up ri a l , A t o 75 s b es t 0°F ( le as •Pac os, M NA V king; et al l i SPEC Asb e U.S. N •Tap s to s, c Cl o e , In s Shee th, Sh taini •Gas u l at i n t, Co e et a n kets, g, As mpre d Tap •Ele Boile besto s s ed e ctrica r, Me s ( NA (N A V l A sb tallic VSPE SPEC •Gas e stos -A s b C 17 H H -P kets ( Boar es t o s T14) -46b) NA V d ( NA (N A V Con SPEC VSPE SPEC 33-G C 17 3 3 -G -2 ) -I-6) -11) Bobb i Ridle e R. Baile y, LL y, Ho C ward Rom eM artin &
  • 57. 1. The Na Abou avy Kne Near t Asbest w More key e ry o Ame ly Every s Than 2. rica Entit e y in Cas The thre e to ev Navy Cont Emp rol O Exercise loyee ver its d Strict Nav y Supp liers s, Vendo 3. e nts e a re T he rs a n Navy d of its W O w n a s t he M e lem C hoi ces i Destiny. aster Th er Were n Th The T he ese C The Unite Sole Pro ases d Sta vince tes N o Bobb Rom ie R. avy. f e Ma Bailey, rti n&R How a idley rd , LLC