2. NHS Innovations
South East
Fast Forward 2013: Health Apps Collaboration
• NHS Innovations South East - IP
and Innovation Management
Service to NHS Organisations
• NHS services: IP projects with
clear patient benefit or NHS
benefit
• Steady increase in software app
disclosures
• 2012 apps - 35% of new
innovation disclosures from
NHS organisations!
Member of
3. NHS Innovations
South East
• Large acute hospital
• Two main sites
• ½ million
• 4,750 FTE staff
• Proactive innovation
• Keen to tackle health apps use
Fast Forward 2013: Health Apps Collaboration
4. NHS Innovations
South East
Project Objectives
• To understand current barriers and constraints within the healthcare
sector and develop relevant approaches to the commercialisation of
health apps:
– healthcare practitioners eg Mersey Burns App
– Lifestyle apps eg calorie counter app
• To address this growing non-patent IP space and share best practice.
5. NHS Innovations
South East
Views on Commercialisation of
Healthcare Apps
• Very mixed response and experience with apps
• ~40% of organisations contacted or researched had taken one
or more app to market
• ~70% claimed they were currently developing apps
• Some apps were developed to meet a specific unmet need
with no commercialisation interest.
• When are apps medical devices? Mixed experience with
navigating the Medical Devices Directive
• Universal view: “It’s not easy generating revenue from apps!”
• “I struggle to understand the ROI from launching an app and
justifying the use of resources compared with something like
a medical device”
6. NHS Innovations
South East
• Users downloaded 44 million mobile health (mHealth)
apps downloads in 2012
• 142 million mHealth downloads predicted by 2016.*
• Top mHealth publishers: 3 million free and 300,000 paid
downloads in the USA on the iOS platform.
• Wider mobile health market will reach $8 billion by
2018**
Source: *Juniper Research, **Global Data
Proposed Agenda
App Stats!
8. NHS Innovations
South East
Wild West or Gold Rush?
Health App
• 97,000 mHealth applications listed on 62 full
catalogue app stores
• Many apps are unvalidated
Commercialisation of apps need to
consider:
Patient / consumer safety?
Medical Devices?
Data privacy issues?
Security?
• Uptake and expectations are surging
10. NHS Innovations
South East
• Free?
Worldwide mobile advertising is forecast to reach $24.5B by 2016*
• In-app purchasing or freemium?
71% of App store revenue was from in-app purchases in 2013*
• Paid
Users who plan to make app purchases from device*:
iPhone 69% Android 53% BlackBerry 35% Windows 32%
Source: *Localytics.com
Commercialisation Approaches
• Consumers are increasingly reluctant to pay for
apps, particularly when so many apps are available
and appear to be free.
• App sustainability?
• Services or Product business stream
12. NHS Innovations
South East
• Start of a journey managing IP in a fast moving technology
field.
• Far more complex than originally imagined
– Developed Healthcare App roadmap
• Many NHS organisations now reviewing their approach to the
use of apps and are putting into place robust infrastructure
eg Mobile Application Management solutions before
progressing with app development and exploitation.
• Our findings on commercialisation approaches will be
launched at a healthcare app event in Maidstone on 18th
March 2014.
Progress and Next Steps?
13. NHS Innovations
South East
What we do
Thanks to Rhiannon Cox, Dr Alan Kennedy,
Emma Aldrich, Dr Syed Husain
Accelerated Commercialisation of Non-Patent
Intellectual Property Associated with Healthcare Apps
Event: 18th March 2014, Academic Centre, Maidstone
& Tunbridge Wells NHS Trust
Details to follow at http://innovationssoutheast.nhs.uk
Intellectual Property Office is an operating name of the Patent Office
Editor's Notes
NHS Innovations South East one of 7 “innovation organisations” provides a IP and Innovation Management Service to NHS Organisations ranging from early stage innovations to technology adoption supportEstablished in 2004NHS services: Focused on IP projects with clear patient benefit or NHS organisational benefitSeen a steady increase in software app disclosures and requests to secure the IP and assist to marketIn 2012, apps made up approximately 35% of new innovation disclosures from NHS organisations!
Maidstone and Tunbridge Wells NHS Trust is a large acute hospital trust. We provide a full range of general hospital services to around 500,000 people living in the south of west Kent and parts of north east Sussex.Two main sites with very innovative staff generating lots of IP and a supportive executive team.Like other NHS hospitals they were keen to get more involved in the use of lifestyle and practitioner healthcare apps. At the end of the data NHS staff and patients are consumers of apps and mobile devices just like everybody else in this room.
So we are here this evening to talk about mobile apps and a roadmap.Let’s quickly look at some health app stats
So the uptake and use of apps is continuing at pace. Expectations are high. As a dedicated NHS IP and Innovation management service we are inundated with app ideas which probably account for about 35% of our disclosures.This feels like it has all of the signs of the early days of the gold rush but in reality it is more like the lawless wild west. It’s not just me saying this, the academic literature is filled with articles from clinical groups and professional bodies expressing concern regarding the use of apps, quality and clinical safety. The wanted poster shows a picture of the uChek urine analysis app. Users use the phone camera. Take a picture which then is analysed by the app and out pops the analysis on the app to influence clinical treatment. This high profile app (for all of the wrong reasons) fell fowl of the FDA regulator in the US as it was deemed to be medical device and was unvalidatedand no FDA approval was sought. apple has started taking a stronger line on health apps registration in their apps store to the extent that there is evidence suggesting that certain type of health apps will only be accepted if they have been suitably validated and the clinical or pharmaceutical data has been provided from a reliable source.So times are changing!
I’ve put this up just to reinforce that the healthcare community is still getting to grips with the way in which apps are being used. This is an article from the 2014 Postgraduate medical journal describing the way in which junior doctors use their smartphones in clinical practice and the overall usability – so the community is really starting to ask pertinent questions about the way in which mobile devices and apps should be used in day to day practice.