Presentation at the Open Government Data Camp in Warsaw, Oct. 21, 2011

1. Sarah Hinchliff Pearson
Senior Counsel, Creative Commons
October 22, 2011
*
Why legal interoperability alone is
inadequate to create a commons

2. *
*

3. *1. legal
Ask: Is it possible to comply
simultaneously?
*2. practical
Ask: Is it possible to violate and
comply simultaneously?
*

4. *1. sui generis database rights
*

5. SGDR
 Public domain
© license
*

6. SGDR
 Public domain
© license
*

7. *2. license scope
*

8. SGDR
license
 Public domain
©
*

9. *3. extra restrictions
*

10. *1. misrepresentation
*2. privacy
*

11. *1. attribution requirements
*2. license subject matter
*

12. *1. ODC-BY: © and SGDR
*2. OGL: © and SGDR
*3. CC BY (EU ports): © and SGDR
*4. CC BY (unported): ©
*

13. When to attribute?
*1. CC BY: ©
*2. OGL: © + SGDR
*3. ODC BY: © + SGDR + via contract
*

14. How to attribute?
*1. OGL: flexible
*2. CC BY: License notices, otherwise
reasonable manner
*3. ODC BY: © + SGDR + license notices
*

15. Any extras?
*CC BY/OGL + {non-endorsement}
*OGL + {misrepresentation}
{privacy}
*

16. * CC BY * ODC BY * OGL
* 1. attribution * 1. attribution * 1. attribution
* 2. ID derivatives * 2. no misrepresentation
* 3. non-endorsement * 3. non-endorsement
* 4. no privacy breach
*

17. CC BY
other

18. *
*
*
*

19. CC BY
© only
ODC-BY
© and SGDR

20. ODC- BY
via contract
CC-BY
no restrictions
for public
domain

21. OGL
misrepresentation
clause
CC-BY
ID
derivatives, h
onor moral
rights

22. *
Sarah Hinchliff Pearson
October 22, 2011
slideshow licensed CC BY international 3.0