Risk Management in Pinisi Relaxation using Analytical Hierarchy Process
RISK MANAGEMENT IN PINISI RELAXATION USINGANALYTICAL HIERARCHY PROCESSWisnumurti RahardjoNIM: 29110412ABSTRACTPinisi Relaxation is a massage parlor that was established in September 2012, and located inthe city of Bandung and Sukabumi. Along with the passage of a new company, there are many eventsthat can cost the company, both in terms of financial and non-financial. To be able to cope with suchevents, Pinisi Relaxation could use framework of AUS/NZ 4360 as a risk management approach, aswell as the use of Analytical Hierarchy Process in selecting alternative needed to mitigate the risks.Risk identification in Pinisi Relaxation divided into business risk, financial risk, operationalrisk, marketing risk, and human resource risk. All risks will be placed in a risk map that reflects theposition of any risks inherent in Pinisi Relaxation. The next process is to mitigate the risks inherent inPinisi Relaxation through analysis of theory and concepts related to conditions in Pinisi Relaxation.Criteria that must be met to handle the risks in Pinisi Relaxation are divided over the cost63%, effectiveness 26%, and time 11%. Through the process of the analysis, there would be thealternatives that required by Pinisi Relaxation to handle the risks, which are price promotion in acertain time, develop reservation system, ask customer’s body condition, relationship with nearbyresidents, provide additional payment methods, daily data online checking, weekly payment plan,reserved cash, contract with supplier, discount when the electricity is off, use drinking water, skip thetreatment process, add safety stock for raw material, raw material checking periodically, usesupporting tools already used, scheduling and checking of employee room duty, periodically checkingthe condition of the room, setting standards of cleanliness, exchange off schedule, provide commonmedicine for employees, giving training to employees, valuable belonging is not company’sresponsibility, adding monthly bonus salary, get in touch with employees, cooperate with otherbusiness field, and add the same gender service concept in each media.Each entity in the company should be able to do the alternatives that have been selected inaccordance with their respective duties. In addition, the risk management process should always bereviewed and controlled in order to avoid the things that could cost the company if it the risktreatment doesn’t run in an appropriate way.Keywords: Pinisi Relaxation, Risk Management, Analytical Hierarchy Process, New VentureBackgroundMassage is an activity that already familiar with Indonesian people, either for the purpose ofrelaxing the body or alternative healing. One of the massage parlors in Indonesia is PinisiRelaxation, which is located in the city of Bandung and Sukabumi. Pinisi Relaxation wasestablished in September 2012, because this company is quite new the role of the owners ofPinisi Relaxation is still high, the system is still developed and adjusted to the work andbusiness condition. The owners also still facing variety of risks related to massage business.
Therefore, companies must be able to know what risks to be faced, analyze, and seek the bestsolution for every risk inside its company, those processes are summarized in detail in aconcept that is risk management. Startup company fail in their first year operation, and 90%of the business failures were due to management inadequacy. Risk management could be asolution for the condition, this will mitigate the risk by find alternatives that capable for eachevent that could be happening. Further there are some tools that could help the decisionmaking process after identified the risks, which one of them is Analytical Hierarchy Process.This research will use collaboration of Risk Management and Analytical Hierarchy Process toidentified and mitigate the business risks at Pinisi Relaxation.Construct BuildingRisk ManagementRisk management used as a tool of control and standards that can be used by the company tobe able to achieve company’s vision and mission. Risks in Pinisi Relaxation divided into fiveparts, which are business risk, financial risk, operational risk, human resource risk, andmarketing risk. On risk management, there is a tool called risk map that are capable to placethe risks into its position.Analytical Hierarchy ProcessThe author use Analytical Hierarchy Process for risk mitigation selection process to fit thecriteria required by the company because Analytical Hierarchy Process could decomposesolutions for a problem into some criteria. The basic concept of AHP is the use of pairwisecomparison matrix togenerate relativeweights among criteria.Criteria will becompared with othercriteria in terms of howimportant to theachievement of goals onit (Saaty, 1990)MethodologyThis research useframework AUS/NZ3460 to become guidefor risk managementprocess in PinisiRelaxation. This usebecausecommunications wouldgive the process of riskmanagement easier toEstablish ContextIdentify RiskBusiness RiskFinancial RiskOperational RiskHuman Resource RiskMarket RiskMonitorandReviewBusiness IssueAnalyse RiskEvaluate RiskTreat RiskCommunicateandConsultBusiness ImplementationBusiness SolutionTheory and ConceptAnalytical HierarchyProcess
be done, especially since Pinisi Relaxation still have a relatively small number of employeesand culture that is applied to Pinisi Relaxation’s employees is familial culture.ResultBased on the observation and interviewed the owners and employees, there are 22 risks thatcan be possibly happen in Pinisi Relaxation, that are also have its likelihood(L) andimpact(I)’s score:Table 1. Risk Identify in Pinisi RelaxationNo Risk L I No Risk L I No Risk L I1 Demand Risk 5 3 9 Risk of electricity 2 5 16 Risk of sick employees 4 32 Capacity Risk 5 2 10 Risk of water discharged 2 4 17Risk of saturatedemployee5 13 Reputation Risk 5 4 11Risk of brokeninstruments3 4 18 Risk of employees crime 5 54 Social Risk 1 5 12Risk of unavailabilityraw materials4 5 19 Salary risk 2 45 Payment risk 4 2 13Risk of unavailabilitysupporting tools4 5 20Risk of hijackedemployees3 36 Accounting risk 5 3 14 Risk of room cleanliness 5 1 21 Promotion risk 3 37 Liquidity risk 3 5 15Risk of absentemployees4 2 22Risk of customerperception3 28Macroeconomicrisk2 3AHP AnalysisFrom the interview, the comparison for the criteria in Pinisi Relaxation is:Table. 2. Pairwise ComparisonCost Effectiveness TimeCost 1 3 5Effectiveness 1/3 1 3Time 1/5 1/3 1The number obtained because the cost of each alternative is moderately more importance tothe effectiveness and strongly more importance to the time needed. The effectiveness criteriais also moderately more importance to the time needed, because the company doesn’t needthe risk to be handled so quickly if it could be more efficient on handling the risk. Theaverage score after divided from the pairwise comparison isTable. 3 Average Score After DividedCost Effectiveness Time Normalized EigenvectorCost 0.65 0.69 0.56 0.63Effectiveness 0.22 0.23 0.33 0.26Time 0.13 0.08 0.11 0.11
The score of λmax from the table is 3.06, and the score of Consistency Index is 0.028. The RItable score for 3 numbers of criteria is 0.56, and the CR score of the table is 0.048. Becausethe CR score is below 0.1, so the pairwise comparison for Pinisi Relaxation is consistent.The next step is to evaluate each alternative which is considered to be able to mitigate anyrisk with a scale from 1 to 5, with a mean level that the greater number, then the alternativegives a better impact for the company. The value of the alternatives will be multiplied withthe normalized eigenvector from each criteria, and the highest total score alternative would bechosen to be the mitigation of the risk. There is also the possibility that a risk have more thanone mitigation if they could be performed together and in accordance with the objective ofmitigating the risk.Summary of AlternativesEach risks has its own alternative to reduce its likelihood, consequences, or both. Thealternatives would be further analysed based on its cost, effectivity, and time needed, andwould be scored from 1 to 5. The highest score means a better condition for the company, so5 in cost would mean very cheap, 5 in effectivity would mean vey effective, and 5 in timewould mean very fast. The score are written based on the analysis from the authors and fromthe discussion with owner and employees. The summary of every alternatives that could betaken by the company to reduce risks in Pinisi Relaxation are:Table 4. Risks Alternatives in Pinisi RelaxationRisk AlternativesCostEffectivenessTimeWeightedScoreDemand RiskCooperate with tour agent 4 5 4 4.26Price promotion in a certain time 5 3 4 4.37Become other companys incentive 3 5 2 3.41Capacity RiskIncrease room capacity 3 5 5 3.74Develop reservation system 5 3 3 4.26More comfortable waiting room 4 4 4 4.00Reputation RiskAsk customer’s body condition 5 4 5 4.74Therapist training periodically 4 4 4 4.00Tell the impact of treatment to the customers 5 3 5 4.48Social RiskChanging the name of the company whensomething goes wrong3 5 3 3.52Cooperate with the media 4 3 5 3.85Relationships with nearby residents 5 4 3 4.52Payment riskProvide additional payment methods 5 4 4 4.63Upfront payment 5 3 5 4.48Double check the price list 5 3 5 4.48Accounting riskManual and computer bookkeeping 5 4 4 4.63Daily data online checking 5 4 5 4.74
The use of accounting software 3 5 5 3.74Liquidity riskWeekly payment plan 5 4 5 4.74Reserved cash 5 4 5 4.74Contract with supplier 4 5 4 4.26Macroeconomic riskPeriodically increase the price 5 3 4 4.37Eliminate unimportant cost 5 4 5 4.74Contract with supplier 5 5 4 4.89Risk of electricityBuy electricity resource 3 5 5 3.74Use devices that do not use electricity 4 2 5 3.59Discount when the electricity off 4 3 5 4.48Risk of waterdischargedBuy bigger water reserve 3 5 4 3.63Use drinking water 4 4 5 4.11Periodically checking water 5 2 4 4.11Risk of broken devicesReserve more devices 3 5 5 3.74Skip the treatment process 5 2 5 4.22Warranty contract with supplier 4 3 3 3.63Risk of unavailabilityraw materialsAdd safety stock 4 5 5 4.37Use substitute raw materials 3 4 5 3.48Raw materials checking periodically 5 3 4 4.37Risk of unavailabilitysupporting toolsAdd safety stock 4 5 4 4.26Use supporting tools already used 5 4 5 4.74Supporting tools checking periodically 5 3 4 4.37Risk of room finenessScheduling and checking of employees roomduty5 4 4 4.63Periodically checking the condition of the room 5 4 4 4.63Setting standards of cleanliness 5 4 4 4.63Risk of employee’sabsentFines on employee absenteeism 5 4 4 4.63Exchange off schedule 5 5 4 4.89Recruite part-time employees 3 4 3 3.26Risk of sick employeesProvision of healthcare money per month 3 5 5 3.74Periodic health checks 3 4 5 3.48Provide common medicines for employees 4 3 5 3.85Risk of saturatedemployeeProvide entertainment facilities for employees 4 4 5 4.11Conduct an annual holiday for all employees 3 5 3 3.52Giving training to employees 4 5 4 4.26Risk of employeescrimePut the customers valuable things on locker 3 5 5 3.74Put the employee charge into the court despite ofcompany4 3 3 3.63Valuable belonging is not company’sresponsibility5 4 4 4.63Salary riskIncrease the percentage variable salary 4 5 5 4.37Conduct overtime 4 5 5 4.37Adding monthly bonus salary 5 5 4 4.89Risk of hijackedemployeesContract with the employees 5 3 4 4.37Standardize massage technique 4 3 4 3.74
Reynolds, P. D., Storey, D. and Westhead, P. (1994). Regional Variations in New FirmFormation. Regional Studies 28: 443–456.Saaty, Thomas L. (1999). Basic Theory of the Analytical Hierarchy Process: How to Make aDecision. Monográfico: Problemas complejos de decisió Vol. 93 No. 4 pp 395-423