On Governance… (Part 1) Gini Courter UUA Moderator http://justgini.blogspot.com/

Democracy Definition : government by the people in which the supreme power is vested in the people and exercised directly by them or by their elected agents under a free electoral system Abraham Lincoln : "of the people, by the people, and for the people" There are two broad types of democracy – direct democracy and representative democracy.

Definition : government by the people in which the supreme power is vested in the people and exercised directly by them or by their elected agents under a free electoral system

Abraham Lincoln : "of the people, by the people, and for the people"

Direct Democracy New England Town Meetings Small Congregations Any Small Group In direct democracy, everyone is involved in decision making. All members discuss and debate and vote. Direct democracy works well for small groups. It works best when everyone really wants to be involved in making all decisions, and is both willing and able to invest the time necessary to be well informed about and reflect on the issues.

New England Town Meetings

Small Congregations

Any Small Group

Representative Democracy Larger groups Larger congregations With representative democracy, we elect people to make decisions on our behalf. The use of the democratic process is one of our core principles. When we elect board members in our congregations (or districts or to the board of the UUA), we are engaging in a sacred act, authorizing and entrusting the people we elect to make decisions on our behalf.

Larger groups

Larger congregations

Representative Democracy Boards are authorized to make decisions on behalf of the whole congregation. Therefore, it’s vital that we choose board members who focus not one program or area, but on the health and well being of the entire congregation.

Representative Democracy One of the benefits of representative democracy is that we get to take turns being decision makers. I can spend a few years on my congregation’s board and when my term is up, I know that someone else will take my place and exercise the same level of care and concern that I exercised during my service. While the work of the board continues, I can be a youth advisor or serve on a committee.

UU Congregations Use Both Types Almost all UU congregations use both types of democracy. Direct democracy is typically used for a limited number of important actions: calling a minister, changing the name of the congregation, or engaging in an activity that dramatically changes congregational life (like buying a new building.)

UU Congregations Use Both Types Other decisions are made by the congregation’s elected representatives: either the board, or the minister (who is “elected” by being called by the a vote of the entire congregation). In Unitarian Universalism, a congregation uses a democratic process – voting – to delegate its authority to a board and a minister.

Committees In every congregation, there are committees that make decisions and do work on behalf of the congregation. Most committees aren’t elected. They’re a group of volunteers with a passion for a specific aspect of church life: religious education, finance, facilities, and so on.

Committees One of the challenges is continuously connecting the disparate, specialized committees to the mission of the whole congregation, to set up lines of authority and accountability to the board or staff and therefore, back to the congregation.

Committees Committees may be doing excellent work, but what’s best for a specific program may not be what’s best for the congregation as a whole. If the congregation is not clear about how they delegate their authority (election and call), disagreements between committees and the board or committees and minister can turn into conflicts.

AUTHORIZATION

How Congregations Authorize Boards are authorized through election. Ministers are authorized through call. Committees need to be authorized by the board or the minister. In smaller congregations, most committees should receive authorization from the board. In larger congregations, and in congregations of all sizes that use policy governance, most committees should receive authorization from the minister.

Boards are authorized through election.

Ministers are authorized through call.

Committees need to be authorized by the board or the minister.

In smaller congregations, most committees should receive authorization from the board.

In larger congregations, and in congregations of all sizes that use policy governance, most committees should receive authorization from the minister.

ROLES & AUTHORIZATION Committees, Boards, and Staff

Committees, Boards, and Staff

Boards and Committees BOARD If? What? Elected by “the people” Accountable to “the people” Elected/replaced by “the people” COMMITTEES How? Appointed by the Board Accountable to the board* Elected/replaced by the board* * In policy governance, or large congregations regardless of governance style, many committees are accountable to the staff rather than the Board

BOARD

If? What?

Elected by “the people”

Accountable to “the people”

Elected/replaced by “the people”

COMMITTEES

How?

Appointed by the Board

Accountable to the board*

Elected/replaced by the board*

Governance Process Board is Mission driven Outwardly focused Accountable to membership Advocate of future direction – what should be done, how organization should respond Responsible for stewardship – best use of resources

Board is

Mission driven

Outwardly focused

Accountable to membership

Advocate of future direction – what should be done, how organization should respond

Responsible for stewardship – best use of resources

Implementation Process Committees are Aligned to mission Task focused Accountable to board* Determiners of how tasks should be done Responsible for planning, completing, evaluating tasks * In policy governance, or large congregations regardless of governance style, many committees are accountable to the staff rather than the Board

Committees are

Aligned to mission

Task focused

Accountable to board*

Determiners of how tasks should be done

Responsible for planning, completing, evaluating tasks

SHARED MINISTRY Notes on

Notes on

Shared Ministry Responsibility for the ministry of the congregation is shared by elected lay leaders (Board) and called religious professionals (Minister) Both Board and Minister are accountable to the congregation Shared ministry isn’t having a one lay service every month, or having lay people do other work of a religious professional. Shared ministry is lay people doing the work of governance, while ministers do the work of professional ministry. If both the laity and clergy are doing their work excellently, the result is an excellent shared ministry.

Responsibility for the ministry of the congregation is shared by elected lay leaders (Board) and called religious professionals (Minister)

Both Board and Minister are accountable to the congregation

Shared Ministry Requires clear boundaries Freedom of the pulpit, freedom of the pew Shared ministry is a partnership. The minister guarantees the laity freedom of the pew. The congregation guarantees the minister freedom of the pulpit. It is the job of the laity – not the clergy -- to defend freedom of the pulpit.

Requires clear boundaries

Freedom of the pulpit, freedom of the pew