5 Rules for Mentoring
New User Experience
Professionals
Bob Thomas
Manager of User Experience, Liberty Mutual

robertl.thomas@libertymutual.com
@bobthomas
What Does It Mean To “Mentor,”
as Opposed to “Teach”?
๏   “to teach or give advice or guidance to
    (someone, such as a less experienced
    person or a child)…
    − Merriam-Webster Dictionary

๏   However, teaching (or coaching) is related
    to tasks and often comes with a specific
    agenda (the teacher’s)

๏   Mentoring is related to personal choice and
    also comes with an agenda (the mentee’s)
What Does Mentoring Mean to Me?
๏   Developing a relationship
    where both mentor and
    mentee benefit
๏   Being a leader
    in our field
User Experience Opportunities




          U                          IA                          D
Usability Research/Testing   Information Architecture   Visual & Interaction Design
Rule #1
๏   Sometimes, your boss can be your mentor
If You Establish a UX Practice,
People Will Seek You Out
Mentors Can Provide Learning
Opportunities for Mentees
Mentors Can Give Mentees Confidence
Rule #2
๏   Sometimes, your boss can’t be your mentor
Performance-Based Objectives
Can Introduce Conflict
If Your Boss Is Your Mentor, Your
Objectives May Not Match Up
Your Boss’s Performance-   Your UX-Based Objectives
Based Objectives for You


            A                         X



            B                         Y



           C                          Z
Rule #3
๏   A mentor is responsible for guiding and
    assisting the mentee, based on a social
    contract
A Mentor Is There For You When
You Have No Right or Wrong
Answer
Rule #4
๏   You can’t mentor a stone
You Cannot Successfully Mentor
Everyone. At Times You Will Fail.
Rule #5
๏   Perspective is additive
Let’s Face It: We Can’t Make
Carbon Copies of Ourselves
Mentors Enable Mentees to Lend
Their Unique Perspectives to the
UX Community
Summary
๏   Rule #1: Sometimes, your boss can be your mentor

๏   Rule #2: Sometimes, your boss can’t be your mentor
             (in other words, find someone else)

๏   Rule #3: A mentor is responsible for guiding and
             assisting the mentee, based on a social contract

๏   Rule #4: You can’t mentor a stone

๏   Rule #5: Perspective is additive
Thank you very much
Bob Thomas
Manager of User Experience
Liberty Mutual

E-mail:
robertl.thomas@libertymutual.com


Twitter:
@bobthomas

Five Rules for Mentoring New User Experience Professionals

  • 1.
    5 Rules forMentoring New User Experience Professionals Bob Thomas Manager of User Experience, Liberty Mutual robertl.thomas@libertymutual.com @bobthomas
  • 2.
    What Does ItMean To “Mentor,” as Opposed to “Teach”? ๏ “to teach or give advice or guidance to (someone, such as a less experienced person or a child)… − Merriam-Webster Dictionary ๏ However, teaching (or coaching) is related to tasks and often comes with a specific agenda (the teacher’s) ๏ Mentoring is related to personal choice and also comes with an agenda (the mentee’s)
  • 3.
    What Does MentoringMean to Me? ๏ Developing a relationship where both mentor and mentee benefit ๏ Being a leader in our field
  • 4.
    User Experience Opportunities U IA D Usability Research/Testing Information Architecture Visual & Interaction Design
  • 5.
    Rule #1 ๏ Sometimes, your boss can be your mentor
  • 6.
    If You Establisha UX Practice, People Will Seek You Out
  • 7.
    Mentors Can ProvideLearning Opportunities for Mentees
  • 8.
    Mentors Can GiveMentees Confidence
  • 9.
    Rule #2 ๏ Sometimes, your boss can’t be your mentor
  • 10.
  • 11.
    If Your BossIs Your Mentor, Your Objectives May Not Match Up Your Boss’s Performance- Your UX-Based Objectives Based Objectives for You A X B Y C Z
  • 12.
    Rule #3 ๏ A mentor is responsible for guiding and assisting the mentee, based on a social contract
  • 13.
    A Mentor IsThere For You When You Have No Right or Wrong Answer
  • 14.
    Rule #4 ๏ You can’t mentor a stone
  • 15.
    You Cannot SuccessfullyMentor Everyone. At Times You Will Fail.
  • 16.
    Rule #5 ๏ Perspective is additive
  • 17.
    Let’s Face It:We Can’t Make Carbon Copies of Ourselves
  • 18.
    Mentors Enable Menteesto Lend Their Unique Perspectives to the UX Community
  • 19.
    Summary ๏ Rule #1: Sometimes, your boss can be your mentor ๏ Rule #2: Sometimes, your boss can’t be your mentor (in other words, find someone else) ๏ Rule #3: A mentor is responsible for guiding and assisting the mentee, based on a social contract ๏ Rule #4: You can’t mentor a stone ๏ Rule #5: Perspective is additive
  • 20.
    Thank you verymuch Bob Thomas Manager of User Experience Liberty Mutual E-mail: robertl.thomas@libertymutual.com Twitter: @bobthomas

Editor's Notes

  • #7 As someone who’s established a UX practice in my company and someone who graduated from Bentley’s program in Human Factors, people do reach out to me(In many cases, people observed a usability test and got excited about it.) “What’s all this usability stuff everybody’s talking about?”
  • #8 As your mentor, I can show you – in 3-6 months - how to run usability tests with participants, which is about 75% of the usability testing work I’ve done You enable your mentees to shadow & observe, then note take. And, after training, moderate sessions by themselves …
  • #9 What you’re ultimately giving your mentees is confidenceSo this relationship can work if both parties concentrate on UX as a *PURE* learning experience. why is this important… because…
  • #11 … because One thing all bosses have to focus on are the overall goals of the company, and these are driven down to employees as performance-based objectives. And you, the mentee, are the performer.These objectives can introduce conflict.
  • #14 A mentee might ask questions like, How can I break into this field? Is now the time to switch careers? Any classes you’d recommend?When there are no right or wrong answers, a mentor is there to present options, based on the goals laid out in the social contract
  • #16  some times the mentee is technophobic, or unable to listen, can’t collaborate, or is incapable of moderating usability sessionsIn these cases, you have to tear up that social contract. As a mentor, you have to be prepared to accept failure.
  • #18 Because Let’s face it: we can’t make carbon copies of ourselves. And anybody who tells you otherwise probably needs his ego re-aligned. …..as a UX community, we benefit celebrating differences. For example, in usability research, Some people want to try new methodologies, while others master tried and true methods.
  • #19 By mentoring, we’re enabling people to share with us their unique points of viewThis collective perspective gives us a better outcome. I wouldn’t be standing up here today if I didn’t learn from my experiences as a mentor and as a mentee
  • #21 Thank you very much. Again, I’m Bob Thomas, Manager of User Experience at Liberty Mutual. You can e-mail me at robertl.thomas@libertymutual.com or contact me on Twitter @bobthomas