SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 14
The value of your building tomorrow, may depend upon your commitment to
sustainability today.
User Effective® Real Estate forFree!
• 10’ x 10’ cubicle or 100SF
• $20 per foot or $2,000 annual rent
• Joe makes $50,000 annually
• Daylight and thermal comfort
increase Joe’s productivity by 4%
• 4% x $50,000 = $2,000 savings
• UE features pay great dividends
10’
10’
Daylight Harvesting
Adaptable Workplace
Privacy
Under Floor Air
Interior Light Shelves
Task Lighting
Exterior Sunshades
Clerestory Windows
Tinted Low-E Windows
Raised Floors
Noise Control
User-Effective®Benefits
User Effective® Elements
• Thermal Control – 5.5% (20 studies)
• Privacy & Interaction – 10.9% (24)
• Ergonomics – 33.3% (70+)
• Land Use & Mobility – MU/TOD, et al
• Systems Flexibility – Plug & Play
• Interior Space Planning – >80% loss
Reprogrammable - UFAD, Moveable walls
Cost / Benefit Analysis
CBA: Mechanical Engineering Example
• List of Sustainable Technologies
• Scope and Price Technologies
•Organize into a Cost/Benefit model
• Determine Categories offsetting Benefits
• Analyze Cost/Benefit relationships
Get the best return on your investment
688 158 22 77 297 97
6300
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
Lifecycle Costs
over 20 years
Building Alterations Moves Telephone Computers O&M Salaries
Calculating Economic Benefits
• Reduces operating costs
• Decreases vacancy, improves retention
• Marketing advantages & free PR
• Optimizes life-cycle economic performance
• Improves productivity
• Reduces absenteeism and turnover
• Providing a healthy workplace improves employee satisfaction
• Reduces liability & compliance risk
• May Increase building valuation (cap rate)
Quantifying “Green” Economic Benefits
The (4)-categories of benefits to Owner with
relative economic value shown as an Environmental
Credit (multiplier):
• Marketing & PR = $0.14/SF
• Operating Expenses = $2.00/SF
• Turn-Over / Maintenance = $0.55/SF
• Obsolescence / L-T Value = $0.56/SF
•Total Potential Economic Benefit = $3.25/SF
Enhanced Marketing & PR :
$0.25/SF Annual Expense
5% Marketing / PR Enhancement
$0.0125 / 0.09 Capitalization Rate
$0.14 Benefit Offset to Initial Costs
Reduced Operating Expenses :
$1.80/SF Annual Utility Expense
10% Enhancement of Utility Efficiency
$0.18 / 0.09 Capitalization Rate
$2.00 Capitalized Benefit
Reduced Capital / Maintenance:
$15/SF Average Turn Cost = $1.50/YR
5% Offset in Tenant Turn-Over
$.075/YR / 0.09 Capitalization Rate
$0.83 Benefit Offset to Initial Costs
$0.25/SF Annual Maintenance Expense
10% Increase in Maintenance Burden
$.025/YR / 0.09 Capitalization Rate
$0.28 Increased Burden
$0.55 Net Benefit to Offset Initial Costs
Reduced Obsolescence =
Extended Long-Term Value:
$0.50/SF Annual Capital Reserves
5% Reduction in Capital Requirements
(Better Systems / Increased Maint. Burd.)
5% Extended Asset Life (Offset Obsol.)
$0.05 / 0.09 Capitalization Rate
$0.56 Benefit Offset to Initial Costs
Worker Productivity :
$40,000/YR Salary
200-SF / Employee
$200/SF Annual Salary Burden
0.25% Increase
$0.50/SF/ per Yr. / 0.09 Cap Rate
$5.56 Benefit Offset to Initial Costs
Sales Revenue :
$300/SF Annual Sales
0.25% Increase in Sales
$0.75 / 0.09 Capitalization Rate
$8.33 Benefit to Tenant
(% Rent to Owner)
The (6)-categories of Benefits to the Owner
and Tenant :
• Marketing & Public Relations = $0.14/SF
• Operating Expenses = $2.00/SF
• Turn-Over Burden / Maintenance = $0.55/SF
• Obsolescence / Long-Term Value = $0.56/SF
• Worker Productivity = $5.56/SF
• Sales Revenue = $8.33/SF
• Total Benefit: $17.14/SF
What if Cap Rates areLower for LEED Certified
Assets?!
50,000-SF building at $18.00 NNN Rent
$900,000 Net Operating Income
$10,000,000 Value @ 9% cap rate
$11,250,000 Value @ 8% cap rate
11.25% Increase in Value b/o cap rate
Per Davis Langdon 2007 report Cost of
Green Revisited, 1.9% increase in cost will
cover premium to achieve LEED-Gold
Can you risk not pursuing LEED certification?!

More Related Content

Similar to User Effective Applications

Financial Realities Of Energy Efficiency For Tourism Businesses
Financial  Realities Of  Energy  Efficiency For  Tourism  BusinessesFinancial  Realities Of  Energy  Efficiency For  Tourism  Businesses
Financial Realities Of Energy Efficiency For Tourism BusinessesMartin Mongiello
 
Bus 7800 week 5 cost allocations
Bus 7800 week 5 cost allocationsBus 7800 week 5 cost allocations
Bus 7800 week 5 cost allocationsOUHainesM
 
How to Build a Great Cloud/SaaS Business Case Analysis for Technology Investment
How to Build a Great Cloud/SaaS Business Case Analysis for Technology InvestmentHow to Build a Great Cloud/SaaS Business Case Analysis for Technology Investment
How to Build a Great Cloud/SaaS Business Case Analysis for Technology InvestmentGotransverse
 
Benchmarking & LEED Certification Benefits
Benchmarking & LEED Certification BenefitsBenchmarking & LEED Certification Benefits
Benchmarking & LEED Certification BenefitsJimmy Carchietta
 
Real ROI: The Business Case for Upgrading to the Latest Release of Oracle’s S...
Real ROI: The Business Case for Upgrading to the Latest Release of Oracle’s S...Real ROI: The Business Case for Upgrading to the Latest Release of Oracle’s S...
Real ROI: The Business Case for Upgrading to the Latest Release of Oracle’s S...Divya Malik
 
Building Logix Presentation for Education
Building Logix Presentation for EducationBuilding Logix Presentation for Education
Building Logix Presentation for EducationMark Bates
 
Renewables presentationv2
Renewables presentationv2Renewables presentationv2
Renewables presentationv2edgeer
 
What Every Small Water System Must Know About Potential Audit Pitfalls and Wh...
What Every Small Water System Must Know About Potential Audit Pitfalls and Wh...What Every Small Water System Must Know About Potential Audit Pitfalls and Wh...
What Every Small Water System Must Know About Potential Audit Pitfalls and Wh...AEP Ohio
 
Financials workshop rs
Financials workshop rsFinancials workshop rs
Financials workshop rsLama K Banna
 
Get Real ROI by Upgrading to the Latest Release of Oracle’s Siebel CRM
Get Real ROI by Upgrading to the Latest Release of Oracle’s Siebel CRMGet Real ROI by Upgrading to the Latest Release of Oracle’s Siebel CRM
Get Real ROI by Upgrading to the Latest Release of Oracle’s Siebel CRMDivya Malik
 
BFH The Path to Net Zero Energy Houses in Cold Climates
  BFH The Path to Net Zero Energy Houses in Cold Climates  BFH The Path to Net Zero Energy Houses in Cold Climates
BFH The Path to Net Zero Energy Houses in Cold ClimatesShawna Henderson
 
Dave Laybourn For CIty Of Industry April 7 2009
Dave Laybourn For CIty Of Industry April 7 2009Dave Laybourn For CIty Of Industry April 7 2009
Dave Laybourn For CIty Of Industry April 7 2009dlaybourn
 
Tim dettlaff presentation fmli nov 13 2014
Tim dettlaff presentation   fmli nov 13 2014Tim dettlaff presentation   fmli nov 13 2014
Tim dettlaff presentation fmli nov 13 2014MikeWorsfold
 
Robin Robins Producers Club, Feb. 2016
Robin Robins Producers Club, Feb. 2016Robin Robins Producers Club, Feb. 2016
Robin Robins Producers Club, Feb. 2016Chris Day
 
Robin Robins Producers Club - Feb 2016
Robin Robins Producers Club - Feb 2016Robin Robins Producers Club - Feb 2016
Robin Robins Producers Club - Feb 2016IT Glue
 
Portfolio_Digital Layout_Master LQ_05.18.16
Portfolio_Digital Layout_Master LQ_05.18.16Portfolio_Digital Layout_Master LQ_05.18.16
Portfolio_Digital Layout_Master LQ_05.18.16Noah Illes
 

Similar to User Effective Applications (20)

Financial Realities Of Energy Efficiency For Tourism Businesses
Financial  Realities Of  Energy  Efficiency For  Tourism  BusinessesFinancial  Realities Of  Energy  Efficiency For  Tourism  Businesses
Financial Realities Of Energy Efficiency For Tourism Businesses
 
Bus 7800 week 5 cost allocations
Bus 7800 week 5 cost allocationsBus 7800 week 5 cost allocations
Bus 7800 week 5 cost allocations
 
How to Build a Great Cloud/SaaS Business Case Analysis for Technology Investment
How to Build a Great Cloud/SaaS Business Case Analysis for Technology InvestmentHow to Build a Great Cloud/SaaS Business Case Analysis for Technology Investment
How to Build a Great Cloud/SaaS Business Case Analysis for Technology Investment
 
Benchmarking & LEED Certification Benefits
Benchmarking & LEED Certification BenefitsBenchmarking & LEED Certification Benefits
Benchmarking & LEED Certification Benefits
 
Lunch and learn 3.19.11 copy
Lunch and learn 3.19.11  copyLunch and learn 3.19.11  copy
Lunch and learn 3.19.11 copy
 
Real ROI: The Business Case for Upgrading to the Latest Release of Oracle’s S...
Real ROI: The Business Case for Upgrading to the Latest Release of Oracle’s S...Real ROI: The Business Case for Upgrading to the Latest Release of Oracle’s S...
Real ROI: The Business Case for Upgrading to the Latest Release of Oracle’s S...
 
Building Logix Presentation for Education
Building Logix Presentation for EducationBuilding Logix Presentation for Education
Building Logix Presentation for Education
 
Renewables presentationv2
Renewables presentationv2Renewables presentationv2
Renewables presentationv2
 
CEE 8.pptx
CEE 8.pptxCEE 8.pptx
CEE 8.pptx
 
What Every Small Water System Must Know About Potential Audit Pitfalls and Wh...
What Every Small Water System Must Know About Potential Audit Pitfalls and Wh...What Every Small Water System Must Know About Potential Audit Pitfalls and Wh...
What Every Small Water System Must Know About Potential Audit Pitfalls and Wh...
 
The Economics of Energy Efficiency
The Economics of Energy EfficiencyThe Economics of Energy Efficiency
The Economics of Energy Efficiency
 
Financials workshop rs
Financials workshop rsFinancials workshop rs
Financials workshop rs
 
Get Real ROI by Upgrading to the Latest Release of Oracle’s Siebel CRM
Get Real ROI by Upgrading to the Latest Release of Oracle’s Siebel CRMGet Real ROI by Upgrading to the Latest Release of Oracle’s Siebel CRM
Get Real ROI by Upgrading to the Latest Release of Oracle’s Siebel CRM
 
Sailing the 7 cs
Sailing the 7 csSailing the 7 cs
Sailing the 7 cs
 
BFH The Path to Net Zero Energy Houses in Cold Climates
  BFH The Path to Net Zero Energy Houses in Cold Climates  BFH The Path to Net Zero Energy Houses in Cold Climates
BFH The Path to Net Zero Energy Houses in Cold Climates
 
Dave Laybourn For CIty Of Industry April 7 2009
Dave Laybourn For CIty Of Industry April 7 2009Dave Laybourn For CIty Of Industry April 7 2009
Dave Laybourn For CIty Of Industry April 7 2009
 
Tim dettlaff presentation fmli nov 13 2014
Tim dettlaff presentation   fmli nov 13 2014Tim dettlaff presentation   fmli nov 13 2014
Tim dettlaff presentation fmli nov 13 2014
 
Robin Robins Producers Club, Feb. 2016
Robin Robins Producers Club, Feb. 2016Robin Robins Producers Club, Feb. 2016
Robin Robins Producers Club, Feb. 2016
 
Robin Robins Producers Club - Feb 2016
Robin Robins Producers Club - Feb 2016Robin Robins Producers Club - Feb 2016
Robin Robins Producers Club - Feb 2016
 
Portfolio_Digital Layout_Master LQ_05.18.16
Portfolio_Digital Layout_Master LQ_05.18.16Portfolio_Digital Layout_Master LQ_05.18.16
Portfolio_Digital Layout_Master LQ_05.18.16
 

User Effective Applications

  • 1. The value of your building tomorrow, may depend upon your commitment to sustainability today.
  • 2. User Effective® Real Estate forFree! • 10’ x 10’ cubicle or 100SF • $20 per foot or $2,000 annual rent • Joe makes $50,000 annually • Daylight and thermal comfort increase Joe’s productivity by 4% • 4% x $50,000 = $2,000 savings • UE features pay great dividends 10’ 10’
  • 3. Daylight Harvesting Adaptable Workplace Privacy Under Floor Air Interior Light Shelves Task Lighting Exterior Sunshades Clerestory Windows Tinted Low-E Windows Raised Floors Noise Control User-Effective®Benefits
  • 4. User Effective® Elements • Thermal Control – 5.5% (20 studies) • Privacy & Interaction – 10.9% (24) • Ergonomics – 33.3% (70+) • Land Use & Mobility – MU/TOD, et al • Systems Flexibility – Plug & Play • Interior Space Planning – >80% loss Reprogrammable - UFAD, Moveable walls
  • 5. Cost / Benefit Analysis CBA: Mechanical Engineering Example • List of Sustainable Technologies • Scope and Price Technologies •Organize into a Cost/Benefit model • Determine Categories offsetting Benefits • Analyze Cost/Benefit relationships
  • 6. Get the best return on your investment 688 158 22 77 297 97 6300 0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 Lifecycle Costs over 20 years Building Alterations Moves Telephone Computers O&M Salaries
  • 7. Calculating Economic Benefits • Reduces operating costs • Decreases vacancy, improves retention • Marketing advantages & free PR • Optimizes life-cycle economic performance • Improves productivity • Reduces absenteeism and turnover • Providing a healthy workplace improves employee satisfaction • Reduces liability & compliance risk • May Increase building valuation (cap rate)
  • 8. Quantifying “Green” Economic Benefits The (4)-categories of benefits to Owner with relative economic value shown as an Environmental Credit (multiplier): • Marketing & PR = $0.14/SF • Operating Expenses = $2.00/SF • Turn-Over / Maintenance = $0.55/SF • Obsolescence / L-T Value = $0.56/SF •Total Potential Economic Benefit = $3.25/SF
  • 9. Enhanced Marketing & PR : $0.25/SF Annual Expense 5% Marketing / PR Enhancement $0.0125 / 0.09 Capitalization Rate $0.14 Benefit Offset to Initial Costs Reduced Operating Expenses : $1.80/SF Annual Utility Expense 10% Enhancement of Utility Efficiency $0.18 / 0.09 Capitalization Rate $2.00 Capitalized Benefit
  • 10. Reduced Capital / Maintenance: $15/SF Average Turn Cost = $1.50/YR 5% Offset in Tenant Turn-Over $.075/YR / 0.09 Capitalization Rate $0.83 Benefit Offset to Initial Costs $0.25/SF Annual Maintenance Expense 10% Increase in Maintenance Burden $.025/YR / 0.09 Capitalization Rate $0.28 Increased Burden $0.55 Net Benefit to Offset Initial Costs
  • 11. Reduced Obsolescence = Extended Long-Term Value: $0.50/SF Annual Capital Reserves 5% Reduction in Capital Requirements (Better Systems / Increased Maint. Burd.) 5% Extended Asset Life (Offset Obsol.) $0.05 / 0.09 Capitalization Rate $0.56 Benefit Offset to Initial Costs
  • 12. Worker Productivity : $40,000/YR Salary 200-SF / Employee $200/SF Annual Salary Burden 0.25% Increase $0.50/SF/ per Yr. / 0.09 Cap Rate $5.56 Benefit Offset to Initial Costs Sales Revenue : $300/SF Annual Sales 0.25% Increase in Sales $0.75 / 0.09 Capitalization Rate $8.33 Benefit to Tenant (% Rent to Owner)
  • 13. The (6)-categories of Benefits to the Owner and Tenant : • Marketing & Public Relations = $0.14/SF • Operating Expenses = $2.00/SF • Turn-Over Burden / Maintenance = $0.55/SF • Obsolescence / Long-Term Value = $0.56/SF • Worker Productivity = $5.56/SF • Sales Revenue = $8.33/SF • Total Benefit: $17.14/SF
  • 14. What if Cap Rates areLower for LEED Certified Assets?! 50,000-SF building at $18.00 NNN Rent $900,000 Net Operating Income $10,000,000 Value @ 9% cap rate $11,250,000 Value @ 8% cap rate 11.25% Increase in Value b/o cap rate Per Davis Langdon 2007 report Cost of Green Revisited, 1.9% increase in cost will cover premium to achieve LEED-Gold Can you risk not pursuing LEED certification?!