credit-suisse Environmental Report 1997/1998 Unabridged version - Presentation Transcript
NOVEMBER 1998
CREDIT GROUP
SUISSE
ENVIRONMENTAL REPORT
1997/98
Unabridged version 7.12.1998 http://www.csg.ch/ecoreport98
CONTENTS
ALL THE TOPICS COVERED IN OUR REPORT
FOREWORD Page 3
PORTRAIT OF CREDIT SUISSE GROUP 4
Bank in transition 4
Credit Suisse Group and the environment 5
System limit of this report 5
Key figures 5
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT 6
Environmental policy 7
Planning 10
Implementation 13
Milestones 14
Monitoring 16
Benefits 17
Communication 18
Future and trends 19
PRODUCT ECOLOGY 20
Environmental risks are business risks 21
Environmental risks associated with the granting of loans and with real estate business 22
Environmental risks relating to project financing 23
Environmental risks in relation to third-party liability and property insurance and real estate business 23
Risk management in the environmental sector environmental liability 25
Environmental aspects of investment business 26
Eco Efficiency 26
Fellowship Trust 28
Sustainable Performance Group goes public 29
Niche products in the environmental sector 30
WinCAT catastrophe bond (Cat bond) 30
Energy contracting 30
Recycling of car components at Winterthur 31
Future and trends 32
Annex: Flow chart for checking credit risks 33
OPERATIONAL ECOLOGY 34
Ecology reflected by the reorientation 34
Environmental performance evaluation of Credit Suisse Group (Switzerland) 1996/97 36
Overview of our analyses 37
Future and trends 38
Key environmental figures significance of comparisons 38
COMMUNICATIONS 40
External communications and commitments 40
Sponsorship and contributions 40
Internal communications 41
Our environmental standpoint 42
Our most important affiliations 42
Publications and literature 43
GLOSSARY 44
LINKS TO ENVIRONMENT-RELATED INTERNET PAGES 46
INFORMATION AND CONTACTS 47
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group
Page 2
FOREWORD
CONTINUING COMMITMENT TO ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
Dear Reader,
In our second environmental report, we provide our staff, customers and shareholders, as well
as ecologically-oriented investors and interested members of the public, with information on
our commitment to the environment. In April 1997 we were awarded the ISO 14001 environ-
mental certificate for our Environmental Management System at our Swiss bank sites. As the
first Swiss bank and the first major bank anywhere in the world to receive environmental certi-
fication we know that this distinction is helping to strengthen our good reputation among our
stakeholders.
CSG is one of the first financial service providers to have committed itself to comprehensive
environmental protection and we want to continue to play a pioneering role in the future. Our
aim is to find ways of integrating environmental considerations into our banking and insurance
business. Having already achieved a good number of successes in the field of operational
ecology, we shall increasingly be turning our attention to product ecology and the new risks
and opportunities that exist in the field of climate change. We want to utilise the major growth
potential that exists in the field of ecologically-oriented asset management. The very good
performance of our two environmental funds Eco Efficiency and Fellowship Trust shows that
we are on the right track in this respect. A special challenge that we need to address is the
evaluation of ecological risks in the context of project financing.
As regards expanding our Environmental Management System and introducing new cost-cut-
Our strengths, weaknesses ting measures, we shall increasingly focus on our major sites outside Switzerland as well. Ex-
and near-term objectives perience has shown that efficient use of energy and materials can also result in lower costs.
To give you a quick overview, a text A process of transformation is taking place not just within Credit Suisse Group (CSG), but
box in the margin of each chapter throughout the whole media landscape. We have therefore decided to break new ground with
will provide a brief summary of our our environmental report: in addition to this electronic version of the unabridged text, we are
strengths, weaknesses and near- also publishing a 12-page summary in English, French, German and Italian. As well as saving
term objectives in the area in ques- paper, this approach also ensures that you always have access to our most up-to-date infor-
tion. mation.
Environmental protection is an ongoing process. This report tells you about our successes to
date and our ambitious targets. We would like to thank everyone who has helped produce this
environmental report. We would also be interested to hear your views and constructive criti-
cisms; we look forward to your feedback.
Lukas Mühlemann Peter Lienhart
Chief Executive Officer of Member of the CS Executive Board
Credit Suisse Group Environmental Officer of CSG
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group Page 3
PORTRAIT
CREDIT SUISSE GROUP
Credit Suisse Group (CSG) is a global financial services company offering a compre-
hensive range of banking and insurance products. Represented on all continents and in all
major financial centres, it comprises four banking business units and one insurance business
unit, each of which is geared to specific customer groups and markets:
Credit Suisse (CS) Corporate and individual customer
banking in Switzerland
Credit Suisse Private Banking (CSPB) Services for Swiss and international
private investors
Credit Suisse First Boston (CSFB) Global investment banking
Credit Suisse Asset Management (CSAM) Services for institutional investors
worldwide
Winterthur Insurance Global insurance business
Bank in transition
Since it published its first environmental report in 1996, Credit Suisse Group has undergone
a fundamental change. On 1 January 1997, CS Holding, as it was then known - and which
consisted primarily of the two full-service banks Credit Suisse (CS) and Swiss Volksbank
(SVB) and the investment bank CS First Boston - became Credit Suisse Group.
A separate environmental performance evaluation carried out to assess the environmental
impact of the restructuring revealed that in the medium term the quantitatively measurable
impact was roughly equivalent to that of one week of normal banking operations.
Credit Suisse Group merged with Winterthur Insurance in the autumn of 1997, although
Winterthur remains an operationally independent insurance company.
In the context of the restructuring process, various operations with an environmental impact
were outsourced to external contractors subject to agreements laying down ecological con-
straints; these operations include, in particular, building management and storage and distri-
bution in the material management sector.
CSG organisation chart: position as at 1 January 1998. Insurance sites abroad only include
national and company head offices
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group
Page 4
PORTRAIT
OUR KEY FIGURES
Credit Suisse Group and the environment
About 20 years ago, an Environmental Management System (EMS) was set up in the various
companies comprising what is today Credit Suisse Group. As part of the reorientation of the
Group, it was decided to use the EMS of Credit Suisse the most sophisticated in the Group
at the time for the entire CSG.
The Environmental Management System of the Swiss banking sites is certified to
ISO 14001.
Environmental focal points In addition to its environmental efforts on the operational front
(primarily aimed at cutting energy consumption), CSG focuses mainly on checking environ-
mental risks when granting credit or insurance cover. Increasingly, major earnings potential
and opportunities are also emerging in the products sector.
System limit of this report
Unless otherwise indicated, this environmental report refers to the whole of CSG including
Winterthur. The environmental performance evaluation referred to in the operational ecology
section covers CSGs banking sites in Switzerland and does not include Winterthur (reference
date 1 January 1997).
Key figures
Key financial figures in CHF m CSG 1997 Credit Suisse (group) 1995
Balance sheet total: 689 568 m 245 000 m
Annual profit: 397 m 1 230 m
Key staff figures
Staff 62 242 26 200
- in Switzerland: Bank 21 442 21 800
Insurance 7 108
- outside Switzerland: Bank 13 235 4 400
Insurance 20 457
Branches
Total 1 166
- in Switzerland: Bank 304 430
Insurance 694
- outside Switzerland: Bank 118 106
Insurance* 50
*National and company head offices only
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group Page 5
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
CERTIFIED TO ISO 1400
In April 1997, Credit Suisse Group became the first Swiss bank and the first major bank anywhere in the
world to be awarded the ISO standard 14001 environmental certificate. The certification process provides
independent confirmation of the fact that the Environmental Management System complies with this
standard and that ongoing improvement in environmental performance has been provided for. This was
also confirmed by the first control audit conducted in June 1998. Our EMS will be steadily expanded and
extended along the lines of a modular system. The environmental certificate paves the way for our inclu-
sion in portfolios of environmentally-oriented investors. Along with cost-savings and risk reductions, this
represents the added value which we have created for our shareholders by taking account of environmen-
tal considerations. The signing of the UNEP statements on the environment for both financial institutions
and the insurance industry confirms this stance.
The main aims of environmental management
An Environmental Management System (EMS) conforming to ISO 14001 is designed to
achieve the following objectives:
Compliance with all relevant environmental laws and regulations
n
Commitment to the steady improvement of corporate environmental performance through
n
the formulation and implementation of defined objectives
Steady improvement of corporate environmental performance of CSG
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group
Page 6
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
BASIC FEATURES OF OUR ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY
The EMS is a feedback loop designed to achieve ongoing improvement. The various phases
of the loop can be subdivided into environmental policy, planning, implementation, monitoring
(certification, internal audits and review by senior management), as shown in the diagram on
page 6. The following chapter is subdivided according to the same individual phases.
1 Environmental policy
Uses and function of environmental policy Environmental policy defines the priority
assigned to environmental protection within CSG, as well as representing a commitment to
environmental protection vis-à-vis personnel, customers (private and corporate alike) and
other stakeholders. Some of the important functions required of environmental policy are:
To underline the importance that CSG attaches to environmental protection
n
Commitment to observe relevant environmental legislation
n
For further information on UNEP,
Commitment to continuous improvement of environmental performance
n
see links on page 46
To take account of the demands of internal and external stakeholders
n
Environmental policy based on the UNEP statements for financial
service providers In signing the UNEP statements for financial institutions and the in-
surance industry, CSG has committed itself to the systematic incorporation of environmental
considerations into all areas of its business activities. In 1992, the then Credit Suisse be-
came the first signatory of the UNEP Statement by Financial Institutions and in 1995,
Winterthur signed the UNEP Statement by the Insurance Industry. The signatories (110
Strengths
banks + 70 insurers by May 1998) endorse the principles laid down in the two statements
and strive to promote environmental interests and sustainable development in their business ISO 14001 certification of all CSGs
n
policies and operations. Swiss banking sites since April 1997
Environmental policy extended to
n
Review of environmental policy In the autumn of 1998, our environmental policy was
Winterthur
updated and approved by the Chief Executive Officer of CSG. Key changes are the inclusion
of Winterthur and the commitment to remaining environmentally certifiable. Maintenance of
Outsourcing: ecological targets
n
conformity with environmental legislation was included as an explicit goal.
agreed
The environmental policy will be reviewed every three years, at the latest in the autumn of
2001.
Weaknesses
The text of the environmental policy is reproduced on the following two pages.
Systematic environmental manage-
n
ment so far only introduced in Swit-
zerland
Organisational structures and pro-
n
cedures in environmental manage-
ment still tied strongly to specific
individuals
Next steps / objectives
Maintenance of eligibility for certifica-
n
tion
Extension of Environmental Manage-
n
ment System to sites outside Switzer-
land and subsidiaries
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group Page 7
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
OUR ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY
1. Corporate leadership and management We are actively committed to environ-
Environmental mission
mental protection. Our commitment stems from the belief that our future depends on the
statement / objectives
conservation of natural resources.
We support efforts to protect the envi- We strive to be among the most progressive companies in terms of environmental manage-
ronment and ease pressure on natural ment and we maintain an environmental management system in compliance with the relevant
resources. By acting in an environmen- standards. We always seek to use the most ecologically sound technology wherever this is
tally responsible fashion we wish to economically viable. We are committed to satisfying the regional, national and international
contribute to sustainability and there- environmental standards applicable to our business operations and services and our commit-
fore create added value for our com- ments under the UNEP and ICC Declarations. We use a systematic eco-monitoring strategy
pany, our customers and the environ- to manage, evaluate and document the progress of our work.
ment.
2. Human resources work and organisation All employees of our bank are respon-
sible for protection of the environment in their particular area of activity. They are supported
by internal or external experts.
We take measures to ensure that staff recognise their ecological responsibility and act ac-
cordingly; activities which have an impact on the environment should also be assessed from
the ecological point of view.
3. Communications and marketing Our bank is an environmentally conscious com-
pany. We therefore conduct an open dialogue both inside the company and outside. Our en-
vironmental data are accessible. We co-operate actively with external environmental organi-
sations.
Meeting our ecological responsibilities forms part of our strategy to secure long-term earn-
ings and sustainable corporate development.
4. Banking and insurance products We aim to include environmental considerations
in existing and new products and services in order to avoid ecological risks. We take account
of such risks in evaluating lending and insurance transactions and provide support for our
clients in dealing with risks and claims. Moreover, we aim to identify and avoid risks likely to
harm the reputation of our institute.
We are open to the development of new banking and insurance instruments for assessing
ecological opportunities and risks and support research in this area. We promote efforts to
demonstrate environmental costs and benefits and to evaluate ecological aspects in
stockmarket analysis, both through our own developments and through active co-operation in
research groups.
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group
Page 8
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
OUR ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY
5. Production and operations We ensure our high environmental and safety
standards by continuously improving our environmental performance. Both in back-
office operations and in the production process, we are committed to ensuring that our
services are performed in the safest and most environmentally friendly manner possi-
ble. We closely involve our procurement, management and logistics partners. We place
particular emphasis on minimising electricity consumption and conserving resources,
particularly in the processing of our standardised retail business.
By systematically measuring, recording and monitoring energy and resource consump-
tion, emissions, waste and environmental risks, we are paving the way for continuous
improvements.
We take measures to prevent environmentally harmful accidents and to contain the
potential repercussions.
6. Infrastructure and facilities All available environmental data on design, mate-
rials, operational matters and energy consumption are taken into account in the plan-
ning and construction of new premises and facilities.
We involve our contractors and suppliers in our efforts to protect the environment in
order to ensure that they apply our environmental standards and codes of practice. In
this context, we request information on potentially harmful building materials and other
substances and on the impact of products supplied to us.
7. Implementation of the environmental policy To implement the environ-
mental policy, we continue to pursue our internal corporate process aimed at promoting
environmentally conscious behaviour at all levels. We attach great importance to the
environmental policy being taken into account in all environmentally relevant decisions.
Lukas Mühlemann Peter Lienhart
Chief Executive Officer of Member of the Executive Board Credit Suisse
Credit Suisse Group Environment Officer of Credit Suisse Group
The current environmental policy was
approved on 27 November 1998. It
will be reviewed at least every three
years and adapted where necessary.
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group Page 9
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
PLANNING
2 Planning
Dealing with the restructuring process and corresponding system changes
The operations of a global financial services group involve a wide range of environmental
considerations. CSGs ever stronger and more global network is making the environmental
sphere more complex. Piecemeal approaches to improving environmental performance are no
longer adequate; the issue itself needs to be integrated into management.
On the way to ISO certification, CSG had to surmount the hurdle of ongoing restructuring and
system changes. Outsourcing measures are attributable to CSGs concentration on its core
business. However, the reorientation is also of environmental relevance. The following impor-
tant services have been outsourced:
Services Contractor
Building management MIB AG
n
Decentralised IT systems IT Services
n
Catering Amongst others SV-Service
n
(CSGs biggest catering contractor)
Storage and distribution of office supplies, Mühlebach AG Logistic
n
printed matter and advertising materials
In the following we set out our approaches to finding solutions:
Agreements with companies in charge of outsourced areas Contracts and
agreements were concluded which commit the contractors MIB AG, IT Services, SV-Service
and Mühlebach AG Logistic to continuous improvement of their environmental performance
and to compliance with CSGs strict environmental standards. Among other things, these
contractors are required to endorse CSGs environmental policy and energy guidelines and to
establish their own environmental management system. Open communication and co-opera-
tion on environmental issues plays an important part in this.
Whenever any service was contracted out, an important objective was to enable CSG to influ-
ence environmentally-relevant decisions taken by the contractors concerned. The environ-
mental standard of the outsourced services was to be maintained or improved. Through its
contracts and agreements, CSG is still able to exert influence over environmental matters and
its business partners benefit from CSGs experience of environmental management.
Reform of environmental organisation of CSG Within CSG, environmental activities
are co-ordinated by the environmental management unit. Focal points include maintaining an
Environmental Management System eligible for certification through the use of environmental
controlling and environmental performance evaluations and internal and external communica-
tion by means of environmental reports and the drafting of statements. Specific technical re-
sponsibility and the implementation of environmental measures are largely matters for the
various line and specialist units; a number of full-time specialists are employed both in the
Environmental Risk Unit in the Credit Management area of Credit Suisse and in Winterthurs
environmental unit for third-party liability risk. CSG also has its own specialist units for en-
ergy/building ecology, safety, operational ecology and ergonomics. In addition, in the fields of
cleaning/waste disposal and catering, among other sectors, we can count on the specialists
of the partner firms mentioned above. In a number of areas with an environmental impact, we
can also turn to specific contact persons responsible for environmental issues.
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group
Page 10
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
PLANNING
In the field of environmental investment, which is of increasing interest and at the same time
complex, CSG can rely on close co-operation with the Zurich-based company Sustainable
Asset Management AG. The whole environmental sector is controlled by the Environmental
Executive Board, which handles strategic and business policy tasks. Chaired by CSGs
Environmental Officer, the Environmental Executive Board includes representatives from all
business units and from the Environmental Management unit.
Shift in important environmental aspects For a long time, environmental protection
was only regulated by laws and binding technical provisions. This meant that companies ac-
tivities were confined to eliminating and alleviating environmental effects after the event. Ac-
cordingly, environmental measures were mainly aimed at areas of operational ecology such as
saving energy or reducing waste. To promote sustainable development, the approach should
be targeted at the causes of the environmental effects. As a result of the growing environ-
mental awareness of stakeholders (investors, shareholders, NGOs), the focus is now also on
the indirect environmental impact of products. However, if environmental issues are to be
given the consideration they deserve, comprehensive environmental management is essential.
Thus, over the past few years, the main focus of environmental concern among providers of
financial services has shifted to ecological risks, particularly in the third-party liability and prop-
erty insurance business and in the credit sector. The more recent widening of this focus to
include product ecology has also affected the investment sector, encouraging the emergence
of niche products. This has been reinforced by increased communication with our
stakeholders on environmental issues.
Objectives and specific targets In line with the structure of this environmental report,
our objectives and individual targets have been subdivided into EMS, product ecology, opera-
tional ecology and communications targets. In each case, the concrete targets are listed in
the insets enumerating strengths, weaknesses and near-term objectives.
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group Page 11
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
PLANNING
Operative areas and partners of Credit Suisse Group
The chart below shows:
in which business unit the co-ordination unit for the whole group is situated
n
which environmentally-relevant specialist or line units with specialist responsibilty exist in
n
the different business units and who they work for in addition
which partners and contractors with a high level of environmental relevance have their own
n
environmental units and which business unit is responsible for this third-party-relationship
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group
Page 12
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
IMPLEMENTATION
3 Implementation
Putting environmental policy into practice In implementing environmental manage-
ment measures, CSG intends to adhere to the environmental policy obligations it has as-
sumed. Components of the implementation phase include:
Environmental controlling
n
Environmental standards
n
Training of personnel
n
Environmental report
n
Implementing environmental policy is the task of the Environmental Management unit of
CSG. CSGs Environmental Management System is modular in structure. For a number of
years, CSGs environmental commitment has been pursued in accordance with ISO stand-
ards. In the following, we enumerate the principal milestones in this process. To highlight the
implementation of our environmental policy more effectively, we have assigned the individual
milestones to the components of environmental policy.
Environmental controlling As an important process in our Environmental Management
System, environmental controlling involves systematically planning, recording, controlling and
monitoring CSGs impact on the environment. With a view to fulfilling our environmental tar-
gets, over 100 measures have been defined for 1997/98. In addition, environmental
controlling has been extended to include product ecology.
Environmental standards We depend on the active support of our staff to ensure that
CSG continues to improve its environmental performance. Since 1995, environmental stand-
ards have been distributed to provide staff with guidance on their environmental conduct both
at work and in their private lives. Since autumn 1998, the new updated edition of practical
tips is being issued to all employees in Switzerland in the form of a bookmark.
Training of personnel The personnel concerned are provided with training in environ-
mental matters by means of blocks of lectures on the environment as part of apprentice train-
ing, seminars for university graduates and internal audits in environment-related areas. Per-
sonnel with specialist responsibilities are offered practical basic and ongoing training (e.g.
energy management and building ecology in property management). In the field of product
ecology, the Environmental Risk unit provides credit specialists with special training in identi-
fying environmental opportunities and risks.
Environmental report This second environmental report follows on from our first publi-
cation (1995/96 environmental report). In the current edition, the product ecology chapter
forms the main focus for the first time. The structure of the report is based on the VfU (Asso-
ciation for Environmental Management in Banks, Savings Banks and Insurance Companies)
guide to environmental reporting for financial service providers.
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group Page 13
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
MILESTONES ON THE WAY TO IMPLEMENTATION
Year Milestones Aspect of
environmental policy
Implementation of environ. policy
Banking and insurance products
Communications and marketing
Infrastructure and facilities
Production and operations
HR and organisation
Management
1976-79 Planning and construction of the Uetlihof in Zurich: pioneering decisions in # ##
terms of thermal insulation, environmentally-friendly construction, furniture,
and eco-planting of buildings and environs; repositioning of train and tram
stops for more convenient use of public transport.
# ##
1977 Launch of ten-year energy-saving programme throughout Switzerland, featur-
ing action to remedy areas of high energy consumption, energy competitions
and janitor training. By 1989, specific heat consumption per m² had been cut
by 33%. Institutionalisation of energy accounting.
1989 Creation of post of full-time environmental officer. # # #
1990 Environmental protection becomes an explicit part of corporate philosophy #
within the Credit Suisse guiding principles
#
Introduction of investment fund oriented towards environmental technology
1991 Formation of Credit Suisse & Environment Working Group, chaired by a # # #
member of the Executive Board, underscores importance of environmental
protection for Credit Suisse
A further indication of the continuous improvement of environmental performance is the assignment of the individual milestones
to the seven aspects of the environmental policy (see pages 8 and 9). The steadily increasing environmental commitment is
also apparent from the growing number of crosses in the right-hand columns. This shows that we are actually implementing our
environmental policy.
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group
Page 14
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
MILESTONES ON THE WAY TO IMPLEMENTATION
Year Milestones Aspect of
environmental policy
Implementation of environ. policy
Banking and insurance products
Communications and marketing
Infrastructure and facilities
Production and operations
HR and organisation
Management
1992 Credit Suisse signs the International Chamber of Commerce Charter for long-term # ## #
sustainable development (ICC Charter) and the UNEP Statement by Banks on
the Environment and Sustainable Development
First directive issued on lending business: environmental risks in lending # # ##
1993 Credit Suisse is awarded the City of Zurichs Green Prize for the nature- # # ##
compatible design of roofs, facades and environs at its Uetlihof site
# # ##
1994 Establishment of Environmental Risk unit at Credit Suisse
# # ## ##
Establishment of Environmental unit at Winterthur
# # # ##
1995 Environmental performance evaluations in Zurich and Geneva
Executive Board approves environmental policy, energy guidelines and environ- # # ## ## #
mental standards
Signing of UNEP Statement by the Insurance Sector on the Environment and # ## # #
Sustainable Development
# # ## ## #
1996 Credit Suisse implements environmental controlling concept
# # ## ## #
Credit Suisse publishes 1995/96 environmental report
1997 Credit Suisse Group (banking sites in Switzerland) becomes the first major bank # # ## ## #
to obtain ISO 14001 certification, documenting the introduction and application of
an Environmental Management System conforming to the ISO 14001 standard.
# ## #
Repositioning of the Eco Efficiency environmental fund
Contracts and agreements concluded with suppliers and service partners # # # ## #
(MIB AG, IT Services, SV-Service and Mühlebach AG Logistic)
# # ## ## #
CSG merges with Winterthur
1998 1996/97 environmental performance evaluation of Credit Suisse Group Switzer- # # # ## #
land (all banking sites)
# # ## ## #
First control audit passed
# # # #
Uetlihof receives award from Foundation for Nature and the Economy (Stiftung
Natur und Wirtschaft)
# # # ## #
Revised environmental standards sent to all bank personnel of CSG Switzerland
# # ## ## #
Revision of environmental policy and environmental organisation
# # ## ## #
Credit Suisse publishes 1997/98 environmental report
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group Page 15
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
MONITORING
4 Monitoring
Our motivation in seeking certification An external inspection enhances the credibil-
ity of our Environmental Management System and gives CSG the confirmation that it is oper-
ating a functioning EMS. We see this as having the following advantages for us:
CSG can be evaluated more simply and effectively by environmentally-oriented investors.
n
In terms of environmental management, CSG can position itself as a progressive provider
n
of financial services.
Presentation of CSG as a company that is aware of its responsibilities gains credibility in
n
the eyes of the public and CSG personnel
More detailed first-hand knowledge of the facts when performing credit analysis of certi-
n
fied corporate customers.
The Executive Board of CSG has evidence to show that its own Environmental Manage-
n
ment System is performing effectively and efficiently.
SGS-ICS [Société Générale de Surveillance International Certification Services AG], a sub-
sidiary of SGS, the worlds biggest testing, inspection and quality assurance organisation, was
commissioned to carry out the inspection.
Internal audits Over 25 sector-specific checklists were prepared for internal audits. In
individual cases, external specialists were also brought in to carry out checks. Remedial
measures are integrated in environmental controlling.
Certification process The certification audit took place in April 1997. The focus was on
the practical implementation of the environmental commitment on the part of the line organi-
sation. The auditors questioned 50 key environmentally-relevant personnel at head office in
Zurich (from environmental risk, personnel, training, communication, construction & real es-
tate, computer centres, evaluation, procurement, maintenance and disposal of computer
equipment, building management, waste disposal, transport/travel service, material purchas-
ing and catering), in four regions (Geneva-Lancy, Berne-Murifeld, Basel and St. Gallen) and
in certain branches (Uster and Wädenswil).
The audit report produced by the certifying company (SGS-ICS) confirms the success of
CSGs environmental management. As well as bearing out the evidence of steady improve-
ment, the report also lists remedial measures.
The certificate is valid for three years providing that the annual monitoring audits are com-
pleted successfully. The Group passed the first audit in June 1998.
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group
Page 16
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
BENEFITS
Benefits of certified environmental management
So far, certified environmental management has brought benefits to CSG in several areas:
Areas of benefit Description of benefit
Inclusion in environmentally-oriented portfolios Inclusion of CSG registered shares in environmentally-oriented portfolios
n
Competitive advantages Environmental performance is relevant as an additional indicator of successful
n
(commercial) corporate management and therefore shareholder value
Cost savings Enhancement of environmentally-significant resource efficiency
n
Reduction in environmental impact and in costs caused by waste and emissions
n
Support in cost and revenue-oriented management of real estate portfolio
n
Recognition of potential for optimisation (e.g. videoconferencing instead
n
of air travel)
Compliance with environmental legislation Systematic testing and monitoring procedures
n
Assurance of compliance with current and foreseeable environmental
n
legislation (legal compliance)
Risk avoidance and reduction Systematic recording of all environmental risks associated with CSGs business
n
activities
Increasing the awareness of staff and training them in relation to high-risk
n
activities
Credibility through external assessment External assessment of CSGs Environmental Management System enhances
n
credibility
Synergies External communication facilitated
n
Integration of EMS into higher-ranking management system promotes integration
n
of measures where crucial business processes are planned and controlled
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group Page 17
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
COMMUNICATIONS
Internal communications supported by the Intranet CSG sets great store by
internal communication. In addition to conventional channels such as the staff magazine and
local notices, the Intranet is also becoming very important. Both the Environmental Manage-
ment sector and various environmentally-oriented specialist units have their own homepages
providing access to their services, missions, general information, checklists, publications, links
to other important homepages, a glossary and contact addresses.
Dialogue with our business partners CSGs own experience with environmental man-
agement makes it more competent in assessing the problems and implications of certification
for other companies. Ideas and experience gained from its own Environmental Management
System are passed on to interested, innovative companies. This exchange is targeted prima-
rily at smaller and medium-sized companies.
Publication series: Credit Suisse Orientierung 106: issue 106 of this series of publica-
n
tions portrays comprehensive bases for establishing integrated management systems. This
issue of the guide is primarily intended to assist small and medium-sized enterprises to
establish their own management systems. It lists all necessary information on
ISO standard models and total quality management, as well as specific instructions on
how to establish a quality, environmental and occupational safety system.
Customer events: CSG is eager to encourage its customers to embrace environmental
n
protection. For example, in December 1997 it organised a customer event in Berne on
the topic of environmental management systems. Over fifty small and medium-sized
companies were invited and provided with information on the various aspects of environ-
mental management systems and ISO 14001.
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group
Page 18
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
FUTURE AND TRENDS
Future and trends
Validated environmental performance evaluations and certificated environmental management
systems are increasingly important in assessing whether a company is best-in-class. Accord-
ingly, central importance is attached to questions from environmentally-oriented investors
concerning the introduction of environmental management systems and their possible certifi-
cation, as well as management involvement and endorsement and questions concerning
product ecology. The following aspects will become increasingly important:
Highlighting the benefits of an EMS
n
Social compatibility international standards are emerging in relation to this
n
issue (e.g. SA 8000). CSG is seeking to address this consideration through the intro-
duction of integrated health management (comprehensive occupational medicine, health
promotion, welfare counselling and ergonomics).
David Nelson, President and CEO,
EnviroSearch International, Salt
Lake City, USA:
Sophisticated companies are now
adopting environmental management
systems as a crucial business manage-
ment tool. Such companies understand
the increasing pressure of regulatory
regimes, international environmental
agreements and treaties, shareholder
demand, environmental organisations as
well as public demand, requirements of
development agencies, and new interna-
tional environmental management stand-
ards such as ISO 14000. The compa-
nies who understand this increasingly
diverse agenda and genuinely respond to
these forces with sound management
practices will benefit economically, so-
cially and ethically.
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group Page 19
PRODUCT ECOLOGY
ENVIRONMENTAL ASPECTS OF SERVICES AND PRODUCTS
In the field of environmental policy, we have committed ourselves to gradually incorporating the environment factor
into new and existing services and products. The main focus of our efforts in the field of product ecology is on risk
management both in the context of granting credit and of providing third-party liability insurance cover. We see earn-
ings potential and opportunities in the sector of environmentally-oriented financial investments and niche products.
Eco-efficient commercial management leads to long-term success and is rewarded by the financial markets in the
form of higher valuations. The growing number of environmentally-oriented investors bears witness to this.
Ecology in the products sector
Strengths
CSGs environmental activities in the products sector can be classified into credit business,
Risk management in the context of
n
insurance business, investment business and new financial products (see table below). At the
granting credits and of third-party
same time, the classification may vary depending on how the area is viewed. For example,
liability and property insurance
the product WinCAT could be regarded as coming under the heading of investment business
Two powerful special funds: Eco Effi-
n rather than that of niche products. Moreover, the distinction between environmental risks and
ciency (Lux) and Fellowship Trust investment business will inevitably be blurred since environmental risks are incontestably also
(UK) playing an increasingly important role in this area of business.
Open for innovative, environmentally-
n
oriented products, such as WinCAT
and energy contracting
Weaknesses
Sector Business unit Product/Service Chapter
Training and support material in in-
n
vestment business still too piecemeal
Review of environmental risks and Lending business CS Credit checking and 1 Environmental risks
n
n
real estate valuation
opportunities in project financing so
far not adequately systematised Energy contracting 3 Niche products
n
CSFB Project financing operations 1 Environmental risks
n
Next steps / objectives
Insurance Winterthur Risk examination 1 Environmental risks
n
Greater sensitisation and information
n
WinCAT 3 Niche products
n
concerning products with an environ-
EnviroWin 1 Environmental risks
n
mental impact
Recycling of car components 3 Niche products
n
Structured procedure for assessing
n
environmental risks and opportunities
Investment CSAM, CSPB, CS Eco Efficiency (Lux) 2 Investment business
n
in project financing
business CSAM Fellowship Trust (UK) 2 Investment business
n
CSFB Listing of SPG shares 2 Investment business
n
Winterthur Unit-linked life policy 2 Investment business
n
of CS Life (see Eco Eff.)
New financial CSFB Marketable 4 Future/trends
n
products emission certificates
Financing of environmentally- 4 Future/trends
n
oriented products
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group
Page 20
PRODUCT ECOLOGY
INNOVATIONS
Innovations in product ecology since the last environmental report
Since the publication of the last environmental report (1996), our bank has witnessed a
number of innovations.
In 1997, the Environmental Technology equity fund introduced in 1990 was aligned on the
concept of eco-efficiency and repositioned.
More and more environmentally-oriented funds are emerging around the world (a volume of
around 1 billion Swiss francs was invested in environmentally-oriented funds and investment
foundations in Switzerland in 1998; this is equivalent to roughly half a percent of the total
fund capital. In the United States, every tenth dollar is currently invested according to at least
one ethical-environmental criterion [Bernadette Calonego, Der Standard, 23 March 1998]).
In the UK, too, Credit Suisse Asset Management has been offering a successful ethical-
environmental country fund since 1986.
The fact that CSG is increasingly being considered for inclusion in portfolios of environmen-
tally-oriented investors shows that its environmental performance is gaining recognition. In
the niche products sector, a number of products have been developed that show potential,
including WinCAT and Energy Contracting.
1 Environmental risks
Companies that neglect environmental factors (such as environmental risks) may be putting
Example illustrating
their profitability or value at risk. For a company and its insurer or lending bank, it is therefore
environmental risks
important to be familiar with the facts and to respond to environmental risks as appropriately
as possible. This not only enables the environmental impact to be reduced but also avoids A discarded cigarette causes a major
costly remediation measures, depreciations and write-offs. Moreover, this area of activity also fire in the warehouse of a chemical
opens up attractive commercial opportunities such as technical assistance in tackling con- factory. Because the warehouse floor
taminated site remediation and the financing of such measures. is not sealed in accordance with regu-
lations, toxic liquids seep into the soil
while the fire is being extinguished.
Environmental risks are business risks Environmental risks stem from a variety of
After the fire, the site, which previ-
causes. The cost of cleaning up a contaminated site can be enough to bankrupt a company.
ously had an estimated value of
So-called liability risks arise where the bank takes over the ownership of real estate, e.g. in
15 million Swiss francs, is only worth
the context of bankruptcy proceedings. In Switzerland, if the bank owns the land, it is obliged
5 million Swiss francs.
to pay for the clean-up.
If the operating risk had been estab-
Commercial risks relating to environmental factors arise where real estate or plant facilities
lished by our specialist Environmental
plummet in value as a result of environmental pollution or degradation. The causes could, for
Risk unit when the loan was granted,
example, lie in the incorrect storage of hazardous substances, an incident or a shift in public
the company would have been alerted
opinion or legal requirements. Risks to a companys reputation, or risks arising from its links
to the shortcomings in the warehouse.
with an associated entity (i.e. where the banks reputation is compromised by its connections
This could have prevented the liquids
with a business partner responsible for environmental damage or through its representation
from escaping and the resulting drop
on the board of such a company) are currently becoming increasingly important.
in the sites value.
Environmental risks are likely to be encountered in the following three areas of business:
A Granting of loans and real estate ownership (Credit Suisse)
B Project financing (Credit Suisse First Boston )
C Third-party liability and property insurance and real estate ownership (Winterthur)
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group Page 21
PRODUCT ECOLOGY
ENVIRONMENTAL RISKS
A Environmental risks associated with the granting of loans and with
real estate business
Credit Suisse only conducts business with corporate customers in Switzerland. Since 1992, it
has been systematically analysing all loan applications (whether for new loans, extensions of
existing loans, or increases in limits) for environmental risks. Here, Credit Suisse is also meet-
ing an obligation assumed when it signed the UNEP statement. The procedure for examining
credit risks can be found in the Annex on page 33. Environmental hazards inherited from the
past can be an important factor not only in the field of loans but also in the valuation of real
estate forming part of real estate funds.
If there are any signs of danger, credit specialists enter into discussions with the customer to
try to establish what environmental risks exist, what their extent is and whether they can be
covered by insurance. To arrive at an assessment, our credit specialists consult both internal
working instruments and the official land registry of sites where a contamination is suspected.
The former identify vulnerable sectors and indicate which environmental risks in particular
need to be taken into account.
Where necessary, the specialist Environmental Risk unit assists our credit specialists in their
evaluation and in recommending measures. In addition to this support function, the activities
of Credit Suisses specialist Environmental Risk unit also include holding numerous internal
and external training events.
In recent years, the specialist unit has become more important. Consideration of environmen-
tal risks has come to form an integral part of any credit check. In this way, we also create
added value for many of our customers: in the context of the background documentation and
information required for credit checks, environmental issues are systematically reviewed in
order to pinpoint environmental risks at an early stage. If a problem arises, the bank is avail-
able to the customer as a competent partner with contacts with specialists and the authori-
ties.
Facilitation of environmental assessment in the business sector Our own
experience in environmental management puts us in a better position to assess the signifi-
cance of a customers certification. Lending banks or insurers are concerned first and fore-
most with environmental aspects that can become credit or insurance risks, with the market
opportunities created representing an additional secondary interest.
At present, however, the significance of certified EMS systems is difficult to assess in terms
of the impact of environmental management on the balance sheet and earnings situation. For
example, the fact that a company holds a certificate does not give any indication of its envi-
ronmental performance. Furthermore, issues relating to the choice of site and process, liabil-
ity risks, the extent of insurance cover, safety at work and contaminated sites are not primary
considerations in certification. Nonetheless, from the banks vantage point, a customer with
an EMS certificate does have a number of advantages:
The environmentally-relevant information has been obtained and the environmental aware-
n
ness of the companys management has greater credibility
Use of innovative and progressive management instruments
n
Particularly in environmentally-vulnerable industries, in which environmental risks account
n
for a large proportion of financial risks, a bank knows that the company is meeting its en-
vironmental responsibilities, is aware of its risks and intends to deal with them on a profes-
sional basis.
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group
Page 22
PRODUCT ECOLOGY
ENVIRONMENTAL RISKS
However, for the lending bank the decisive factor is always the overall perspective in terms of
risks and opportunities. After all, when granting a loan, it is not so much the borrower that is
assessed, but the loan and its general conditions.
Certification makes it easier for the bank to examine environmental risks relating to the cus-
tomer since specific environmentally-relevant information, validated by the certification, is al-
ready available and the persons responsible for environmental matters are named. However,
certification does not replace verification. Even where a certificate is held, Credit Suisse al-
ways checks loan applications for environmental risks.
B Environmental risks relating to project financing
Environmental risks may also arise in connection with project financing. This mainly affects
Credit Suisse First Boston in its role as a financing partner. In most cases the financing is
undertaken with other banks acting jointly with the World Bank; in examining the risks, their
environmental standards are applied accordingly.
For CSG, the assessment of the borrowers quality continues to play a central part in the fi-
nancing of projects. However, environmental considerations can affect that quality.
CSG realises that environmental risks are becoming increasingly important in assessing
credit quality. Such risks may have a legal or a political basis:
Legal factors relate to the site and operation: e.g. environmental liability.
n
Political factors may arise from public opposition. These environmental risks can have a
n
significant adverse impact on project earnings, real estate values, the project timetable
and the lenders equity.
The following instruments are used to avoid such risks, depending on the project: due dili-
gence checks, enquiries to clarify the legal context and insurance cover.
In international business Credit Suisse First Boston consults external specialists, where nec-
essary, to enable it to tailor its response to differing operating conditions and legal frame-
works in the countries in question.
We are working on more systematic ways of recording, assessing and weighting these very
specific risks in the future.
C Environmental risks in third-party liability and property insurance and
in relation to real estate business
The environmental issue affects virtually the entire range of insurance products offered by
Winterthur. Thus, cover components in which environmental factors play a part are to be
found in the comprehensive motor vehicle insurance sector (e.g. hail damage), in the building
or property insurance sector (for example storm damage, cover for clean-up and decontami-
nation costs), in company and product liability insurance (cover for personal injury and dam-
age to property and for damage prevention costs resulting from environmental degradation)
and in compulsory liability insurance for subsidiaries (exclusion of losses resulting from envi-
ronmental degradation).
Natural disasters and global climate change Winterthur is expecting the property
insurance sector to be particularly severely affected by global climate changes. It is therefore
recording its risk exposure in this area on a targeted basis by calculating claims forecasts for
various disaster scenarios on the basis of portfolio analyses. Winterthur uses the results of
such studies to review and adjust its underwriting policy.
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group Page 23
PRODUCT ECOLOGY
ENVIRONMENTAL RISKS
One of Winterthurs main interests lies in overcoming the consequences of natural disasters
from a technical underwriting point of view. However, it would also like to gain a better
understanding of the climatic context and of the repercussions of human activities on the cli-
mate. In this context, Winterthur is not only interested in current environmental factors, but
also attempts, on the basis of the data collected and with the aid of models, to anticipate
what the environment might be like in the future.
Even today, the biggest insured losses are already attributable to climate events. However,
if non-insured losses are also taken into account, earthquakes exact the heaviest economic
toll. For example, the property damage caused by the Kobe earthquake in Japan is estimated
at USD 100 billion. Losses totalling around USD 2.5 billion were insured.
As an insurance company with global operations, Winterthur bears a proportion of such
losses. The cost of the losses in each case depends on the value of the property insured (i.e.
risks) in the area affected.
Event Date Country Loss in USD bn
24.8.92 USA 15.5
Hurricane Andrew
n
7.1.94 USA 12.5
Northridge earthquake
n
27.9.91 Japan 5.2
Typhoon Mireille
n
25.1.90 Europe 4.6
Winter gale Daria
n
5.9.89 USA 4.1
Hurricane Hugo
n
25.2.90 Europe 3.2
Winter gale Vivian
n
17.1.95 Japan 2.5
Kobe earthquake
n
4.10.95 USA 2.1
Hurricane Opal
n
10.3.93 USA 1.8
Winter gale Fridolin
n
20.10.91 USA 1.7
Oakland forest fire
n
The ten biggest natural disasters in terms of losses to the insurance industry.
Looking ahead to the future, Winterthur must focus on what changes might occur and where.
In many parts of the world, civilisation has advanced into areas previously considered unin-
habitable. They have been rendered habitable by the construction of protective structures and
infrastructure facilities such as dams, drainage systems, avalanche barriers, power lines etc.,
which are all designed to cope with current known climatic conditions in the regions con-
cerned. We can expect any shift in climate zone boundaries to increase the climate strain on
some of these structures and reduce it on others. Overall, there are likely to be more cases in
which structures are subjected to greater strain; this will mean an increase in the number of
claims, which will in turn increase the claims burden on insurers.
Efforts by the insurance industry to raise public awareness and highlight the possible connec-
tions represents an initial step towards avoiding future problems. In addition to publications on
this subject, the presentation of initiatives and policy documents at international conferences
on the environment and climate change (as held in Kyoto or Geneva) represents a contribu-
tion on the part of the insurance industry to making the (adverse) effects of human activity on
the environment less ecologically damaging in the future.
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group
Page 24
PRODUCT ECOLOGY
RISK MANAGEMENT IN THE ENVIRONMENTAL SECTOR
Risk management in the environmental sector environmental liability The
environmental aspects of the insurance products referred to above and of other insurance
products not only compel Winterthur to pay close attention to natural events and environmen-
tal risks, but also to advise its customers before and above all after they take out their poli-
cies. When calling on customers, (environmental) engineers discuss a wide range of environ-
mental aspects, highlighting weak points and risks.
Thus, by establishing a link between environmental considerations and insurance products,
policyholders can be encouraged to behave in a more environmentally-friendly manner. How-
ever, the insurance industry does not see itself as an environmental police force, but rather as
the partner of private individuals, trade and industry. Accordingly, in risk-prone, environmen-
tally-sensitive areas, e.g. risks affecting landfill sites, Winterthur attempts to find solutions
that go beyond classic insurance cover (risk transfer).
Since 1994, Winterthur has had access to the Environmental Unit (part of Winterthur Risk
Engineering since 1 January 1998), a unit involved in a wide range of tasks relating to prod-
uct development, underwriting support in connection with environmental risks and the devel-
opment of tools for assessing such risks. The unit also advises the claims departments in the
event of new or serious forms of environmental damage. In addition, it assists the business
units in providing training on environmental issues and conducts PR work in the form of lec-
tures and publications. However, apart from the Environmental Unit, Winterthur also has
other units concerned with environmental issues. One of these is Group Risk Management,
which addresses such questions as the global climate problems referred to in our opening
remarks.
As explained above, the insurance industry has already been taking the subject of environ-
mental liability seriously for many years. Winterthur has risen to the challenge and, in this
actuarially-sensitive area, has devised a solution - the EnviroWin concept - that gives the cus-
tomer insurance cover over and above the standard market coverage while keeping
Winterthurs risk at a reasonable level. One of the key features of this environmental liability
product is insurance cover for environmental damage resulting from normal operations which
could not have been foreseen given current state-of-the-art in technology and science. Such
cover is only provided if the customer takes the necessary preventive safety measures.
Instruments for assessing and evaluating environmental risks form the second key feature of
the concept. Among these instruments, which have been developed by Winterthur itself, the
EnviroWin Index takes pride of place. Using this index, the customer is given an initial envi-
ronmental risk rating based on sector-specific risk characteristics. If the index indicates
heightened risks, a risk dialogue is initiated. On a confidential basis, engineers and scien-
tists from Winterthur analyse and evaluate environmentally-relevant information which the
customer furnishes by completing a questionnaire. Where appropriate, an inspection is
carried out on site. In the course of this risk dialogue, Winterthur also proposes measures
to improve the situation and indicates how such measures would affect premiums.
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group Page 25
PRODUCT ECOLOGY
ENVIRONMENTAL ASPECTS OF INVESTMENT BUSINESS
2 Environmental aspects of investment business
Eco Efficiency (security number 349 511)
In 1990, CSG became the first Swiss bank to launch an environmental technology fund
(Oeko Protec). In common with virtually all environmental funds in the first half of the 1990s,
the funds performance lagged behind the stock market average owing to a variety of factors
Which customers does the
(mainly one-sided concentration on environmental technology, recession and a weaker
Eco Efficiency Fund appeal to?
dollar).
Investors who are convinced that
n
In the spring of 1997, a new fund management reviewed the investment concept and reposi-
eco-efficient companies will have a
tioned the equity fund under the name Credit Suisse Equity Fund (Lux) Eco Efficiency.
future strategic advantage.
Clients who would like to invest in a
n
Aim of the fund The fund offers investors an environmentally-compatible investment in-
globally diversified equity fund that
strument geared to sustainability, combined with attractive long-term earnings. The fund in-
mainly gives consideration to eco-
vests in the shares of companies whose value-added processes and range of products and
efficient blue chips. Also included are
services are already optimised in terms of integrating ecological and social criteria alongside
small to medium-sized companies
economic considerations. By gearing their operations to sustainability, they are able to reduce
that are outstanding for their ecologi-
their risks and translate opportunities into market successes at an early stage.
cally innovative services, products or
new technologies and exhibit above-
average growth potential. Rating system The fund invests worldwide in leading-edge and pioneering companies
that are successfully implementing the concept of eco-efficiency. The leaders include compa-
nies that are at the forefront of their industries and use eco-efficient production techniques.
The pioneers are smaller to medium-sized companies with outstanding credentials in terms of
environmentally innovative services, products or new technologies and with above-average
growth potential.
Sustainable Asset Management (SAM) AG, Zurich, seeks out eco-efficient companies on the
basis of a rating system which it has developed itself and which includes ecological and social
components (SAM Sustainability Rating). With an international network, SAM boasts one of
Europes most experienced research teams.
Eco-efficiency gives companies throughout the world competitive advantages, and in the
longer term this will be reflected in their share price. Various studies show that companies
Credit Suisse Asset Management
that take account of eco-efficiency are also more innovative than their competitors in other
posts outstanding performance
areas. Competitive advantages correlate positively with eco-efficiency in a variety of ways.
For the third time in a row, in 1997
Standard & Poors Micropal judged
Credit Suisse Asset Management to be Stock selection The stocks proposed by SAM undergo final selection taking account of
the Best Management Group i.e. the the usual fund principles at Credit Suisse Asset Management (CSAM) in a multistage proc-
no. 1 fund management company in the ess. In this way, CSAM invests worldwide in listed companies in all sectors that stand out by
category of major Swiss asset managers. virtue of their above-average environmental and financial performance. The largest fund posi-
tions can be reviewed by accessing the website link shown on p. 46.
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group
Page 26
PRODUCT ECOLOGY
ECO EFFICIENCY
Promotion Ecologically-aware policyholders can also factor environmental considerations
into their life insurance policies. Winterthur offers the fund-linked life insurance policy CS
Life. Customers can invest in various funds, including the Eco Efficiency Fund. The Eco Effi-
ciency Fund still accounts for a very limited proportion of the Life Fund. CSAM and SAM
support CS and CSFB in selling the fund.
Performance The yield outlook is highly promising: since the funds repositioning, it has
posted above-average performance in international terms. Measured against traditional funds,
its market share is still marginal.
Links to websites providing up-to-date information on the performance of the fund can be
found on the links page in the Appendix.
Services performed by SAM AG
Management of individual mandates
n
for institutional investors on the basis
of sustainability criteria
Individual advice and assistance for
n
private customers on the basis of
sustainability criteria
Portfolio analyses and screenings
n
(for further information, see links on
page 46)
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group Page 27
PRODUCT ECOLOGY
FELLOWSHIP TRUST
Fellowship Trust
In the UK and the USA, ethically/environmentally-oriented funds have been established for
some time. In the Credit Suisse Fellowship Trust Fund of Credit Suisse Asset Management
Funds (UK) Limited, CSG has a fund which has won several awards on the strength of such
criteria. The Fellowship Trust, which is only available in the UK, is a country-specific fund that
has been investing in selected small and medium-sized companies since 1986.
Stock selection Stocks are selected according to both positive and negative (exclusion)
criteria. The fund managers invest in companies that are committed to environmental and so-
cial issues, while avoiding companies involved in activities that have a negative impact on
health, the environment or human dignity (e.g. arms, pornography, tobacco, pesticides).
Performance The Fellowship Trust comprises a total volume of over 200 million Swiss
francs (July 1998) and has established a position in the UK equity growth unit trust sector:
over the past three years its performance has ranked 10th (out of 134 funds) and over the
Criteria for stock selection
past five years it has ranked 18th (out of 125 funds). Its success shows that ethically/environ-
Positive criteria
mentally-oriented funds are meeting a market need.
Companies with good environmental
n
Up-to-date information can be accessed online by following the website link on page 46.
track records
Companies that make a positive so-
n
cial contribution (mainly in relation to
their employees and their local area)
Companies that engage in energy
n
conservation, waste reduction
through recycling and efficient waste
management
Companies that offer alternatives to
n
products tested on animals
Exclusion criteria
Companies involved in the sale or
n
manufacture of arms and manufactur-
ers of goods or services for military
use
Companies that have attracted ad-
n
verse attention as a result of environ-
mental pollution in the past
Companies known to be distributing
n
pesticides in the UK that contain sub-
stances banned in other countries.
Tobacco producers or companies that
n
derive over 10% of their reported
annual turnover from the sale of to-
bacco products
Companies that make profits from
n
gambling
Companies that print, publish or dis-
n
tribute pornography
Manufacturers of alcoholic beverages
n
or companies that derive over 10% of
their reported annual turnover from
the sale of such beverages
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group
Page 28
PRODUCT ECOLOGY
INVESTMENT IN SUSTAINABILITY
Sustainable Performance Group goes public
SPG shares were floated on the stock market by Credit Suisse First Boston in the summer of
1997. SPG is an investment company listed on the Swiss Exchange. It successfully invests
in companies whose products and services generate economic, environmental and social
benefits and in doing so achieve competitive advantages. This is the core concept of
sustainability.
Credit Suisse First Boston is consulted for financial analysis.
SPGs aim and investment strategy: Bruno Letsch, Head of Investment
Center Europe, Swiss Re:
Investment in 20 to 25 companies with pioneering and leading-edge credentials in the
n
field of sustainability. The portfolio is broadly diversified in terms of sectors, countries and We firmly believe that companies man-
currencies. aged on a sustainable basis are attractive
investments.
Investment at an early stage in innovative pioneering companies offering new system so-
n
lutions and operating in sectors that benefit from the growth of lasting megatrends in
such areas as mobility, energy or nutrition.
Investment in leading-edge companies that integrate sustainability into their strategies to
n
a high degree and in doing so achieve sustainable competitive advantages.
Risk-optimised weighting of pioneering and leading-edge companies with a view to
n
achieving a balanced ratio of opportunities to risks in the portfolio.
Performance In addition to its printed quarterly report, SPG also publishes information on
its own homepage (see Internet links on page 46).
For current prices, please see the website links on page 46.
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group Page 29
PRODUCT ECOLOGY
NICHE PRODUCTS IN THE ENVIRONMENTAL SECTOR
3 Niche products in the environmental sector
WinCAT catastrophe bond (Cat Bond)
Innovative financial products allow the insurance industry to hedge against environmental risks
on a broader basis. An example of such a product is Winterthurs Cat Bond, launched with
great success in 1997. The Cat Bond is a convertible bond with a very special additional con-
dition attached: the annual coupon payment is not paid in years in which hail or storm damage
is on a scale serious enough for Winterthur to receive more than 6,000 claims for damaged
vehicles. To compensate for this risk, in years with less hail damage, investors receive a cou-
pon bearing a higher rate of interest. This means that investors assume an insurance risk tra-
ditionally borne by (re)insurance companies.
Such investments offer investors a unique opportunity to diversify their portfolios. Since the
risk of natural disasters bears no relation to other financial market risks, there is only a slight
danger of simultaneously sustaining losses both on the traditional markets and on the catas-
trophe bonds. By including catastrophe bonds in a portfolio, the degree of risk can be re-
duced without any change in the anticipated overall yield.
In this way, Winterthur, Switzerlands biggest motor insurer, and Credit Suisse First Boston,
the innovative investment bank lead-managing the issue, have familiarised a wider Swiss pub-
lic with the securitisation of insurance risks (i.e. the practice of passing on such risks to inves-
tors in the form of a marketable security) for the first time. By incorporating environmental
factors into financial market products, this bond creates new opportunities for customers and
financial institutions alike.
For up-to-date information on WinCAT,
access the link given on page 46.
Energy contracting
This financing and operating model involves commissioning a specialist outside firm to supply
energy and maintain facilities. Instead of buying oil, gas and electricity, the energy user pur-
chases heat, refrigeration, light or steam in other words energy services.
This enables companies to avoid expensive investments, for example in modern heating sys-
tems, while on the supply side economies of scale and technical expertise can be system-
atically exploited to supply heat on an energy- and cost-efficient basis. In the context of the
Swiss Federal Governments Energy 2000 investment programme, Credit Suisse offers
contract-leasing models. For larger investments, we also examine project financing solutions.
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group
Page 30
PRODUCT ECOLOGY
NICHE PRODUCTS IN THE ENVIRONMENTAL SECTOR
Recycling of car components at Winterthur
As Switzerlands biggest motor insurer, Winterthur has addressed the question of what to do
with the hundreds of vehicles written off as a result of accidents because they are either
beyond repair or no longer worth repairing. In co-operation with representatives of the body-
work industry, for nearly 25 years Winterthur has been running the car component recycling
company Auto-Bestandteile-Wiederverwertungs AG (ABW) in Grolley (Canton of Fribourg) as
an eco-efficient and commercially attractive project and is regarded as a pioneer in this field.
ABW collects over 200,000 components for a wide range of vehicle types.
Parts that can still be used are removed, stored and resold at reasonable prices. Parts that
cannot be used, such as fluids, oils and acids are siphoned off and disposed of in an environ-
mentally-compatible manner or sent for reprocessing.
The recyclable components are tested original parts and do not impair the safety of the vehi-
cles they are used in. By fitting used parts, vehicle owners can be offered repairs identical in
quality to repairs carried out using new parts, but at substantially lower cost.
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group Page 31
PRODUCT ECOLOGY
FUTURE AND TRENDS
4 Future and trends
Emission certificates
The securitisation of environmental and health risks will become increasingly common.
One example of this trend is emission certificates. These certificates are securities that
entitle their holders to emit set quantities of pollutants into the environment over a given pe-
riod of time. They are sold (or issued) to individual companies by the government or an inde-
pendent national or international authority and can subsequently be traded. Depending on the
reduction target for the economy as a whole, the authority in question can influence the
quantity of emission certificates through purchases. Accordingly, providers of financial ser-
vices are called upon to establish a market and train market participants for this market.
Emission certificates (e.g. for limiting greenhouse gases, especially CO2) are characterised by
high environmental target attainment levels on the basis of free market mechanisms.
For banks, the trading of certificates also opens up new business opportunities.
Development of new ecologically-oriented financial products
We are actively involved in research and discussion aimed at developing ecologically-
oriented financial products.
There is a huge need for finance to fund the implementation of international environmental
agreements (Convention on Climate Change, Biodiversity Convention). For financial service
providers, this means growing opportunities to participate in the financing of environmental
projects or projects of benefit to the environment in close co-operation with multilateral
banks. CSG wants to tap into the opportunities in these business areas.
Electronic banking saves paper
Credit Suisse is Switzerlands leading
provider of electronic banking services
(exchange of data by telephone, the
Internet, phone banking etc.). As such, it
is playing a pioneering role in showing
how banking transactions can be per-
formed more efficiently but with a mini-
mum of paper by using new media.
Since mid-1998, around 500,000 trans-
actions per month have been dealt with
via the Internet. Similarly, over 15% of
Credit Suisses securities trading orders
are issued electronically.
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group
Page 32
PRODUCT ECOLOGY
ANNEX: FLOW CHART FOR CHECKING CREDIT RISKS
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group Page 33
OPERATIONAL ECOLOGY
REFLECTED BY THE REORIENTATION
Our company has stepped up its efforts in operational ecology even during the restructuring of CSG.Our
extended 1996/97 environmental performance evaluation for Credit Suisse Group (Switzerland) shows a
welcome fall in paper consumption but a further rise in the consumption of power and heat. In addition,
the evaluation revealed a number of areas where improvements could be made in the collection of data.
These will be addressed in collaboration with our external building management contractor. One of the
next important steps must be to ensure that the environmental targets set for our contractual partners are
adhered to and implemented.
What is operational ecology?
Operational ecology is concerned with the environmental impact of a companys business op-
erations. In the case of a financial service provider such as CSG, the main focus is on high
energy and paper consumption.
The aim of our endeavours in respect of operational ecology is to minimise the consumption
of resources through appropriate savings measures. This will enable us to substantially reduce
our financial expenditure as well as our impact on the environment. For example, in 1996 the
use of videoconferencing as an alternative to business flights saved around one million air
kilometres and resulted in savings of around CHF 750,000; there is still potential for further
savings.
As a management, control and monitoring instrument, operational ecology uses what is
known as environmental controlling. On the basis of the findings that emerge from the envi-
ronmental performance evaluations, environmental objectives are defined and their implemen-
tation is ensured. In this way, environmental controlling plays a central part in the environ-
mental management system.
Ecology reflected by the reorganisation
Since the publication of our last environmental report in 1996, CSG has undergone several
major changes of significant environmental relevance. Following the reorientation of our bank-
ing business on 1 January 1997, August 1997 saw CSG merge with Winterthur. This in-
Strengths creased the size of our workforce and real estate holdings both within Switzerland and in par-
ticular abroad.
Expansion of the environmental per-
n
formance evaluation in terms of
breadth and depth: extension of the Environmental performance evaluation of the reorientation process A separate
system and improvement of method environmental performance evaluation was prepared on the environmental repercussions of
Reduction in paper consumption the reorientation of our banking business. In the process, we were able to calculate the
n
medium-term expenditure incurred. The expenditure was roughly equivalent to 1% of the an-
nual environmental impact generated by CSG. The restructuring process had less impact on
Weaknesses
the environment than one week of ordinary banking operations. At this point in time, any
Increased consumption of heat and statement about the long-term impact of the restructuring process would be premature.
n
electricity
The increase in changes of responsibilities and personnel, together with changes in the
Reorientation made data collection branch network, have made it more difficult both to co-ordinate environmental management
n
and comparison more difficult and to collect environmental data.
Next steps / objectives
Environmental controlling to be in-
n
creasingly geared to energy saving
measures
Improved data management
n
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group
Page 34
OPERATIONAL ECOLOGY
CO-OPERATION WITH OUR PARTNERS
Outsourcing of the building service In the context of the restructuring process, a
number of ecologically significant technical functions were contracted out to external
firms. Thus, from January 1998, our contractual partner Merkur Immobilien Bewirtschaftungs
AG (MIB AG) took over our building management operations, an area which we had previ-
ously handled ourselves in Switzerland. To guarantee monitoring and control of operational
ecology in the future, CSG needs to be able to rely on the co-operation of the building man-
agement company. Under its contract, MIB AG has undertaken to steadily reduce energy
consumption levels and to actively co-operate in the implementation of the environmental
targets through systematic environmental controlling, as well as by other means. MIB AG has
therefore contractually undertaken to comply with CSGs strict environmental standards.
These include the endorsement of our environmental policy and energy guidelines, the
gradual establishment of MIB AGs own certifiable Environmental Management System and
open communication and co-operation on environmental issues. A further focal point is the
training of relevant personnel in environmentally-compatible behaviour.
Since the summer of 1998, MIB AG has also been servicing properties occupied by
Winterthur in Switzerland. This means that the same environmental requirements apply as for
the properties of the banking business units.
IT Services takes over computer systems In 1997, IT Services, which belongs to
CSG, took over the management of our decentralised computer systems which consist of
around 43,000 computers, 15,000 printers and 1,400 networks in Switzerland alone. As
well as being responsible for installation and maintenance, IT Services also sees to the
evaluation and disposal of equipment. To ensure that sound environmental procedures are
followed IT Services, like MIB AG, is required to adhere to strict standards and liaise
regularly with our specialist environmental units.
Environmentally-aware catering partners CSGs staff restaurants in Switzerland are
operated by several environmentally-aware catering firms. One of the firms in question is SV-
Service, a pioneer in the field of environmentally-aware catering. SV-Service increasingly
gives preference to seasonal Swiss produce obtained from monitored organic sources. As
Switzerlands biggest industrial caterer, it operates its own progressive Environmental Man-
agement System and maintains close contact with CSGs environmental specialists.
Operational ecology: our environmental objectives*
Sector Savings target (1994 as baseline) Target to be achieved by
Electricity 10% reduction to 110 kWh/m² p.a. 2004
Heat 10% reduction to 80 kWh/m² p.a.
3% from renewable energy sources 2004
Water 15% reduction to 460 litres/m² p.a. 2004
Traffic Consumption of less than 14 litres/100 km for goods vehicles
Consumption of less than 7 litres/100 km for passenger vehicles 2004
Paper 15% reduction 2004
60% recycled grade 2004
proportion of chlorine-bleached grade <5% 2004
15% recycling rate for copier paper 2004
* based on our energy guidelines, which are to be reviewed in 1999 and adapted as necessary
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group Page 35
OPERATIONAL ECOLOGY
EXTENDED ENVIRONMENTAL PERFORMANCE EVALUATION
Environmental targets for storage and distribution Since 1997, Mühlebach AG
Logistic has been in charge of the storage and distribution of CSGs printed matter, office
supplies and advertising materials throughout Switzerland. The use of environmentally-sound
storage and transport facilities forms part of the contractual obligation, as does a packaging
strategy based on reusable containers and the systematic separation of waste. Drivers are
sent on regular training courses to ensure that their driving techniques are optimised for fuel
economy.
For further information, see
links on page 46
Environmental performance evaluation
of Credit Suisse Group (Switzerland) 1996/97
Corporate environmental performance evaluations are management tools that quantify the
companys own impact on the environment. They cover all environmentally-relevant flows of
materials and energy entering or leaving the company over a given period.
The following details are taken from our report on the 1996/97 environmental performance
evaluation.
Extended system limit Our first environmental performance evaluation in 1994 covered
a total of 30 Credit Suisse (CS) buildings in Zurich and Geneva (8,000 staff, 400,000 m² of
energy reference area). They accounted for 60% of the energy reference area of the then
Credit Suisse (parent company). The second (1997/98) environmental performance evalua-
tion of Credit Suisse Group Switzerland, covers the whole of CSG in Switzerland, with the
exception of Winterthur (reference date 1.1.1997). This system covers around 470 sites with
an energy reference area of 1,200,000 m² and 20,700 employees.
Fire extinguishing and cooling agents also covered Our first survey of stocks of fire
extinguishing and cooling agents (halon and freons) at all our fixed installations brought to
light an accumulation of freon losses. Remedial measures have been initiated.
Environmental scarcity method For our evaluation we used the environmental scarcity
method (EIP methodology) according to Braunschweig and Müller-Wenk.
When collecting the data, an improvement in data quality was found to be both necessary and
possible in the waste disposal sector in particular. Appropriate steps have since been taken.
Changes since the 1994 environmental performance evaluation
As a result of the new corporate structure and the extended system limit of the environmental
performance evaluation, direct comparisons between the 1994 and 1996 performance evalu-
ations are not always appropriate. Nonetheless, certain trends are emerging.
As a result of the expansion of our business activities and the increasing penetration of tech-
nology into new areas, there was an increase in the consumption of electricity, heat and water
in absolute terms. The reduction in paper consumption is mainly attributable to steps taken to
encourage the use of electronic media.
The lions share of CSGs direct environmental impact still stems from the provision and con-
sumption of electricity and heat. Accordingly, our medium-term priorities in the field of opera-
tional ecology focus on reducing these energy flows.
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group
Page 36
OPERATIONAL ECOLOGY
PAPER CONSUMPTION REDUCED
Overview of our analyses
Electricity consumption rising on account of increased use of technology In
1996, our electricity consumption continued to rise in absolute terms, reaching 155 million
kWh. This is equivalent to the annual consumption of 28,000 average Swiss households.
The main reason for the 17% rise compared with 1994 was a marked increase in IT memory
requirements: between 1980 and 1996, memory capacity at our computer centres expanded
270-fold.
Heat: networked systems cut costs In 1996, our banks heat consumption totalled
116 million kWh. The slight increase is attributable to an expansion of floorspace occupied as
a result of the merger with Swiss Volksbank and Neue Argauer Bank. As our floorspace ex-
panded more than our heat consumption, our specific consumption rate fell by one third to
97 kWh/m².
The use of networked heating systems is enabling us to achieve significant annual savings in Credit Suisses Uetlihof:
the quantities of oil and gas we consume. As well as cutting emissions of air pollutants, this Nature reserve of the Swiss
also reduces our expenditure on heating and air conditioning systems. The installation of a business world
combined heat and power plant in the Uetlihof Centre in Zurich has enabled us to achieve
In June 1998, the Foundation for Nature
annual savings of CHF 600,000.
and Business (Stiftung Natur und Wirt-
schaft) awarded Credit Suisses Uetlihof
Three quarters of travel above the clouds In 1996, we calculated the amount of centre in Zurich the title of Nature re-
business travel generated by all our Swiss sites for the first time. The total came to just under serve of the Swiss business world in
35 million km per year, or 1,700 km per employee. Air travel alone accounted for more than recognition of the natural vegetation
75% of the total. Our flights departing from Switzerland gave rise to emissions of 5,100 cover adorning its roofs and facades and
tonnes of carbon dioxide (CO2), one of the atmospheric pollutants implicated in the green- the landscaping of its grounds. Designed
house effect. The use of videoconferencing facilities enabled us to save around one million to approximate natural conditions as
air kilometres, as well as costs totalling CHF 750,000. closely as possible, the landscaping of
the total of 77,000m² of green areas
The reorientation of our bank resulted in the relocation of several thousand jobs. We there-
features a small lake, several ponds and
fore decided not to attempt to update our analysis of commuter traffic. Our 1994 study
wildflower meadows. In designing the
showed that our employees commute 47 million km per year, with public transport account-
interior courtyards, roofs and environs,
ing for 30 million km of the total.
care was taken to encourage the eco-
logical coexistence of humans and indig-
Paper consumption cut by 10% In 1996, our paper consumption came to just under enous fauna and flora. Numerous native
5,000 tonnes, which is equivalent to a 10% reduction compared with 1995. This fall is attrib- species of birds can be observed at the
utable to the major expansion of electronic access to internal lists and documents (internal Uetlihof site. Twelve colonies of bees
bank lists and continuous stationery account for over half our total paper consumption). While also find abundant sources of food
substituting electronic access for paper is reducing our paper consumption, it is leading to a among the profusion of flowering plants.
further increase in the amount of electricity we consume. Several sheep graze on the meadows,
eliminating the need for mowing.
The Uetlihof site was awarded the City of
Waste: more transparency needed For the first time, total quantities of rubbish, paper
Zurichs Green Prize back in 1993.
and cardboard were calculated for all CSG buildings in Switzerland. In 1996, our sites gener-
ated a total of around 6,000 tonnes of waste, or roughly 290 kg per employee. The slight Further information can be found in the
increase is partly attributable to the restructuring; branch closures involved disposing of ex- brochure, Semi-natural landscaping
tensive stocks of materials. the Uetlihof administrative centre,
Zurich.
The targets set in our 1995-96 environmental report have not yet been achieved every-
where. Action needs to be taken in terms of data collection and cost transparency and we
will be addressing this in co-operation with MIB AG.
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group Page 37
OPERATIONAL ECOLOGY
OUR MEASURES AND OBJECTIVES
Future and trends
The co-ordination and responsibilities of the two operational ecology programmes run by
Credit Suisse and Winterthur will be aligned on the new organisation. By sharing common
logistics platforms, we aim to exploit as many synergies as possible. So far, no operational
ecology organisation has been established for the many sites outside Switzerland, most of
which are small. In the longer term, in addition to the Swiss system, we also aim to include
sites outside Switzerland that are relevant in terms of operational ecology. This plan affects
mainly Winterthur, which employs more personnel abroad than within Switzerland.
Reducing consumption of resources Our environmental aims envisage reducing our
consumption of energy and resources for materials and services. We give preference to the
use of durable, upgradable materials and products and aim to increase recycling of the items
used. To this end, when procuring materials, we not only examine their environmental com-
patibility but also, increasingly, the manufacturers ecological commitment.
Key environmental figures significance of comparisons
Differences in data quality From one bank to the next, key environmental figures differ
greatly and exhibit considerable inconsistencies in terms of standards. The fact that compari-
sons of key data do not take account of important background information on the bank con-
cerned means there is room for improvement in terms of the significance of comparisons with
existing key figures. Such background information includes types of business activity, levels of
computerisation, sizes of computer centres and types of buildings.
This was the conclusion that emerged from a comparison of the first set of key environmental
data on 16 banks in the German-speaking countries reported on the basis of the VfU stand-
ard (VfU = the Association for Environmental Management in Banks, Savings Banks and In-
surance Companies). The figures were compared in a diploma dissertation written by Thomas
Frei in 1997 at the Institute of Business Administration of the Swiss Federal Institute of Tech-
nology (ETH) in Zurich.
Key environmental figures for Credit Suisse Group (Switzerland) in 1996,
based on the VfU standard
emp. = employees
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group
Page 38
OPERATIONAL ECOLOGY
INTERPRETATION OF KEY ENVIRONMENTAL FIGURES
VfU defines key figures for operational ecology The VfU has published guidelines
on environmental reporting. In 1996, a working group agreed on a selection of 11 key fig-
ures relating to operational ecology which express the environmental performance of financial
service providers. These key figures defined by the VfU relate solely to the field of opera-
tional ecology. Key figures relating to product ecology (lending and investment business) or
management have not yet been defined. Meanwhile, a number of banks in German-speaking
countries have applied the VfU standard and collected corresponding environmental data in
accordance with the VfU guidelines.
Interpretation of key figures The study showed that comparisons of key figures with
those of other financial institutions (e.g. in terms of paper consumption) only revealed indica-
tive information and trends. This indicative information
enables the plausibility of the key figures to be verified.
Such comparisons allow banks to assess whether their 350
key figures are within a reasonable range. The following
example of paper consumption illustrates these possibili- 300
ties.
260 kg/emp.
The chart opposite shows, for example, that CSG con- 250
sumes paper on roughly the same scale as other big Difference 130 kg/emp.
banks. All the smaller and medium-sized banks and sav- 200
ings banks surveyed show a far smaller relative paper
consumption per employee (on average 130 kg/em-
150
ployee). All banks within this group consume paper on the 130 kg/emp.
same scale. One conclusion is that such comparisons are
100
only meaningful among banks of similar size and with
similar business operations. It is difficult to apply such
comparisons to the specialist banks since their business 50
activities can differ widely. The nature of the business ac-
tivity engaged in is therefore a very important factor. The 0
A B C D E F G H I CSG J K L M N
key figures are not suitable as a basis for statements such CH
Specialist banks
Smaller and medium-sized banks and savings banks in Germany Medium-sized banks and big banks in Switzerland
as this bank is better than the others.
The study has brought to light several deficiencies in key environmental figures:
Insufficient information on the origin of the key figures (understanding of system not uni-
n
versally guaranteed)
Cause and effect not apparent
n
Widely differing quality of data from one bank to the next
n
Choice of reference value not ideal (among other things, very susceptible to system
n
changes)
When considering key figures, these shortcomings should be taken into account and appro-
priate improvements aimed for. Moreover, key figures alone cannot completely cover the
complex decisions in the field of environmental management. The quality of environmental
management depends on making appropriate use of all management instruments.
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group Page 39
COMMUNICATIONS
GREATER USE OF ELECTRONIC MEDIA
Through direct contact with our internal and external partners, Credit Suisse Group strengthens
environmental awareness. Through an exchange of experience and data, we also support the
environmental efforts of the business and research communities. Because of this commitment,
Credit Suisse Group is recognised by the public as an environmentally-aware company. In future,
we shall be redoubling our training and communication efforts. These include our presence on
the Internet.
External communications and commitments
CSG is actively involved in numerous national and international bodies concerned with envi-
ronmental protection, including the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) and the
Swiss Bankers Associations Working Group on the Environment. We organise events and
lectures on environmentally-relevant topics such as environmental management and credit
risks for corporate customers. We also publish articles in specialist journals.
Since the summer of 1998, we have been communicating via the Internet as well as in
printed form.
In contact with scientific bodies and environmental organisations CSG sup-
ports scientific research by offering placements for practical work experience and for students
studying for diplomas or doctorates and by giving free access to its data. We value our links
with environmental organisations and other interest groups.
Sponsorship and contributions
CSG does not regard its social and environmental commitment as sponsorship in the sense of
Strengths a marketing instrument but as a core component of its corporate culture. Our active involve-
ment in environmental causes is not normally accompanied by explicit PR activities.
Use of the Internet for our internal and
n
external communications Where CSG sponsors a project, it makes available its environmental expertise and facilitates
environmentally-compatible measures. Examples include the Swiss Bankers Association and
Positive media response to our envi-
n
UNEP checklists on environmental management in banks or the partial reimbursement of
ronmental activities
travelling expenses incurred by persons travelling to the Swiss orienteering championships by
Active involvement in environmental
n
public transport.
bodies
Weaknesses
Environmental awareness still insuffi-
n
cient in certain areas
Next steps / objectives
Strengthen communication by use of
n
electronic media
Formulate and implement training
n
concept
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group
Page 40
COMMUNICATION
FOSTERING ENVIRONMENTAL AWARENESS
Were backing wind power In the context of its support for environmentally-friendly
technologies, Winterthur provides support for Juvent SA. With its modern wind-power plant
on Mont Crosis in the Canton of Berne, Juvent SA has become the first company in Switzer-
land to generate electricity from wind energy on a significant scale. Comprising three power-
ful wind turbines with a maximum output of 600 kilowatts (kW) each, the plant generates an
annual total of around 1.8 million kilowatt hours (kWh) of electricity under average wind con-
ditions. This output is sufficient to meet the annual needs of around 600 households.
As the suppliers first major customer, Winterthur has committed itself to consuming 200,000
kWh per year over the next ten years at an additional cost of CHF 30,000 per annum and to
using the power to supply electricity for its building in Neuchâtel. Given sufficient demand,
the plan is to expand the wind-power plant. Juvent SA sells the electricity at cost price. We
are prepared to pay twice the usual electricity price for investment in this environmentally-
friendly, renewable energy.
Internal communications
A company actively involved in environmental issues relies on its employees having a high
level of environmental awareness. Our ecological aims can only be implemented and
achieved if everyone is familiar with these aims, creating a corresponding corporate culture.
The basis for such a culture is dialogue, together with regular information and training on the
subject of the environment. In our efforts, we encourage the individuals we are addressing to
act in an environmentally-aware manner in their private lives as well.
Environmental Circle The steadily growing Environmental Circle, a forum for staff
interested in environmental issues, makes a key contribution toward achieving this aim. Its
members, who now number 1,300, receive information on environmental tips and issues
from the environmental management unit; events are also organised from time to time. Our
aim in setting up this informal network is to anchor environmental awareness on as broad a
basis as possible.
We also provide information in the form of articles in various staff magazines and external
trade publications. In order to foster environmentally-compatible conduct in the workplace,
we distribute copies of our environmental standards recently issued in the form of a handy
bookmark to all personnel.
Further training We attach importance to training our personnel in environmentally-sound
behaviour. To date, training events have been staged covering the areas of building and ma-
terials management, catering and transport. New graduate recruits are provided with informa-
tion explaining the impact of our business activities on the environment and are given tips on
sound environmental conduct in the workplace. We also train our loan specialists to identify
environmental risks.
We will be expanding our training strategy in order to strengthen our in-house training.
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group Page 41
COMMUNICATION
OUR ENVIRONMENTAL STANDPOINT
Our environmental standpoint
CSG maintains contacts with authorities and associations. This enables us to introduce as-
pects which are important for the financial sector into new standards at an early stage, as well
as allowing us to counter regulation which overshoots the mark.
In principle, we are in favour of using economic instruments for ecological purposes. How-
ever, the precondition is that such instruments should be environmentally justified, neutral in
their impact on foreign trade and government quotas, reasonable and amenable to planning.
Discriminating evaluation of environmental initiatives On the basis of such con-
siderations, we are in favour of Switzerlands proposed CO2 law in the framework of the envi-
ronmental tax reform. This incentive tax is emission-related and encourages the use of envi-
ronmentally-sound production methods. However, we reject the solar energy initiative and the
energy/environment initiative on the grounds that both involve resource taxes that put up the
cost of manufacturing and place Switzerland at a disadvantage as a location for business.
What is more, neither of these political initiatives are neutral in terms either of government
quotas or of redistribution.
As a major electricity consumer, CSG is in favour of the opening of the Swiss electricity mar-
ket envisaged in the Swiss electricity market law. This liberalisation will lead to a reduction in
subsidies and therefore in the long term to lower electricity prices that will increasingly incor-
porate external costs (e.g. for environmental damage). It can therefore be assumed that re-
newable forms of energy will become more competitive.
We are in favour of using emission certificates as an efficient market-economic
instrument of environmental policy. The introduction of such certificates should be amenable
to planning, and the certificates must be issued in sufficient numbers. Any government in-
come from the sale of certificates must be returned to consumers and companies (neutrality
in terms of impact on government quotas).
Our most important affiliations
National affiliations
Swiss Bankers Association Working Group on Banks and the Environment
n
Energy 2000 (energy saving programme of the Swiss Federal Government)
n
FHE (Fachgesellschaft für Haustechnik und Energie im Bauwesen association for building technology and
n
energy in the construction sector)
IPB (Interessengemeinschaft privater professioneller Bauherren association of private professional
n
builders; publishes regular recommendations for environmentally friendly building)
öbu (Schweizerische Vereinigung für ökologisch bewusste Unternehmensführung Swiss association for
n
environmentally-aware corporate management)
SIA (Schweizerische Ingenieur- und Architektenverein Swiss Society of Engineers and Architects)
n
Energy Model Zurich
n
International affiliations
UNEP (United Nations Environment Programme)
n
Association for Environmental Management in Banks, Savings Banks and Insurance Companies
n
(VfU Verein für Umweltmanagement in Banken, Sparkassen und Versicherungen e.V.)
ICC (International Chamber of Commerce)
n
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group
Page 42
COMMUNICATIONS
PUBLICATIONS AND LITERATURE
Publications (see also page 46)
Environmental Report 1997/98, CREDIT SUISSE GROUP, Zurich,1998
n
Umweltbericht 1997/98, CREDIT SUISSE GROUP, Zurich,1998
n
Rapport Environnemental 1997/98, CREDIT SUISSE GROUP, Zurich,1998
n
Rapporto Ambientale 1997/98, CREDIT SUISSE GROUP, Zurich,1998
n
Environmental Report 1995/96 (four-page summary), CREDIT SUISSE, Zurich, 1996
n
Umweltbericht 1995/96 Schweizerische Kreditanstalt, CREDIT SUISSE, Zurich, 1996
n
Rapport Environnemental 1995/96, CREDIT SUISSE, Zurich, 1996
n
Eco Performance Switzerland 1996/97, CREDIT SUISSE GROUP, Zurich, 1998
n
Ökobilanz Schweiz 1996/97, CREDIT SUISSE GROUP, Zurich ,1998
n
Écobilan Suisse 1996/97, CREDIT SUISSE GROUP, Zurich, 1998
n
Ecobilancio Svizzera 1996/97, CREDIT SUISSE GROUP, Zurich, 1998
n
Ökobilanz 1994 SKA Zürich, CREDIT SUISSE, Zurich, 1995
n
Ecobilan 1994 CS Genève, CREDIT SUISSE, Geneva, 1995
n
Our Guiding Principles on Energy Use, CREDIT SUISSE, Zurich, 1995
n
Energieleitbild, CREDIT SUISSE, Zurich, 1995
n
Charte énergétique du Groupe CS, Geneva, 1995
n
Direttive energetiche del Gruppo CS, Zurich, 1995
n
Literature
Bewertung in Ökobilanzen mit der Methode der ökologischen Knappheit Ökofaktoren
n
1997 (Evaluation in eco performances using the environmental scarcity method; not
available in English); BUWAL-Schriftenreihe Umwelt Nr. 297, Berne 1998
Association for Environmental Management in Banks, Saving Banks and Insurance Com-
n
panies (Verein für Umweltmanagement in Banken, Sparkassen und Versicherungen e.V.
[VfU]), Environmental Reporting of Financial Service Providers. A guide to content, struc-
ture and performance ratios of environmental reports for banks and savings banks,
Augsburg and Bonn, 1996
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group Page 43
GLOSSARY
DEFINITION AND EXPLANATION OF TERMS
Compliance with environmental law
Adherence to relevant environmental laws and regulations.
Convertible bond
A bond which can be converted into a fixed number of equity securities within a specified
period of time at a specific price.
Coupon
Entitlement to annual interest on bonds.
Due diligence
Examination of risks of environmental liability and/or environmental compliance in the context
of the purchase or sale of a new company or of parts of a company. An examination of due
diligence also encompasses essential measures to reduce environmental risks or to contain
them at a low level.
Eco-efficiency
We define eco-efficiency as the systematic focus on a mode of production that avoids deplet-
ing resources and reduces environmental impact as far as possible. Criteria for identifying
eco-efficient companies include:
Energy-intensive and material-intensive nature of processes, emissions
n
Recyclability
n
Product service life
n
Use of renewable energy sources
n
Eco-efficiency is a measure of a companys environmental as well as its economic impact.
The aim of environmentally-compatible economic behaviour must be to maximise commercial
added value while minimising the environmental impact.
Emission certificates
Negotiable certificates which grant the owner the right to release a specific quantity of pollut-
ants into the environment. If the amount of pollutants emitted exceeds the amount specified,
additional certificates must be bought on the market.
Energy reference area (ERA)
The area of a property which is heated or cooled. Corresponds to 85% of the gross floor area
excluding lift shafts, basement areas, etc.
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group
Page 44
GLOSSARY
DEFINITION AND EXPLANATION OF TERMS
Environmental controlling
Environmental controlling is a key component of the environmental management system. It
includes collecting data, preparing and implementing measures and achieving objectives.
Environmental performance evaluation
Corporate environmental performance evaluations are management instruments that quantify
the environmental impact generated by a company. They cover all environmentally-relevant
flows of materials and energy entering or leaving the company over a given period. Through
environmental controlling, the environmental performance evaluation helps to identify poten-
tial for improvement and cut costs.
ICC Charter
Declaration of sustainability of the International Chamber of Commerce in Paris
ISO 14001
The International Organization for Standardization (ISO) is a global organisation of national
standards institutions. ISO standards can be described as globally recognised standards for
voluntary self-monitoring. The ISO 14000ff standards series shows companies how to imple-
ment an Environmental Management System and seeks to provide organisations with the
components of an effective Environmental Management System which can be combined with
other management requirements to help such organisations achieve both ecological and eco-
nomic objectives (cf. ISO DIN EN 14001, 1996). Further information on ISO 14001 can be
obtained using the website links on page 46.
MIB AG
Merkur Immobilien Bewirtschaftungs AG, building management contractor engaged by CSG.
Sustainability
Sustainability characterises processes that maintain or enhance business value creation with-
out jeopardising economic, ecological or social systems in the longer term. Sustainability is a
forward-looking concept, in which consumer aspirations for a better quality of life are satis-
fied without depleting resources.
UNEP
United Nations Environment Programme. For link to UNEP homepage, see page 46.
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group Page 45
LINKS
TO ENVIRONMENT-RELATED INTERNET PAGES
Environmental Performance Evaluation Credit Suisse Group (Switzerland) 1996/97
Environmental Performance Evaluation: http://www.csg.ch/eco_performance_97
Information on Credit Suisse Equity Fund (Lux) Eco Efficiency
http://www.csam.com/funds.html
Information on the performance of the fund can be found at:
http://www.finanzplatz.ch or
http://www.swissquote.ch
Information on the Fellowship Trust of Credit Suisse Asset Management Funds (UK):
http://www.csamfunds.co.uk
Homepage of Winterthur Insurance
http://www.winterthur.com
Information on ISO 14001
The structure of the series of standards is given on the ISO homepage http://www.iso.ch.
Lists of certified companies can be found at http://www.iso14001.com or
http://www.unisg.ch/~iwoe/index.html
UNEP homepage
http://www.unep.ch
Homepage of Sustainable Asset Management AG
http://www.samswiss.ch
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group
Page 46
INFORMATION
CONTACTS
For further information and to order additional copies:
Credit Suisse
Environmental Management, CCU
P.O. Box 100
CH-8070 Zurich
Tel. ++ 41 -(0)1-333 73 33
Fax ++ 41 -(0)1-333 76 33
e-mail: csg.eco@csg.ch
Homepage: http://www.csg.ch/ecoreport98
Project team
Otti Bisang, Patrik Burri, Thomas Frei, Nick Marolf, Bernd Schanzenbächer
(Environmental Management)
With the invaluable support of all our environmentally-relevant departments.
Less waste, more information: if you print this report out, we would be grateful if you could
pass it on to others or circulate it within your office. You are welcome to copy or quote from
this report: we would appreciate notification or a specimen copy of your article.
For reasons of convenience (faster downloading), we have not incorporated graphics in this
report.
Validation by SGS-ICS AG
We have verified the correctness of the
statements in the 1998 environmental
report of Credit Suisse Group and,
where necessary, have requested that
proof be presented.
We hereby confirm that the report has
been prepared with the necessary care,
that its contents are correct, that it de-
scribes the essential aspects of the Envi-
ronmental Management System at
Credit Suisse Group and that it reflects
the Groups actual practices and proce-
dures.
Elvira Bieri and Dr Franz Heinzer
Zurich, 19 October 1998
CCUE 11.98
Environmental Report 1997/98 Credit Suisse Group Page 47
0 comments
Post a comment