Jimmy Gentry and Gary Trennepohl present "Digging Deeper: Goodwill and Pro Forma" during Reynolds Business Journalism Week 2013.
Reynolds Business Journalism Week is an all-expenses-paid seminar for journalists looking to enhance their business coverage, and professors looking to enhance or create business journalism courses.
For more information about business journalism training, please visit businessjournalism.org.
2. Donald W. Reynolds National Center
for Business Journalism
at Arizona State University
Strictly Financials 2
3. n James K. Gentry, Ph.D.
n Clyde M. Reed Teaching Professor
n School of Journalism and Mass Communications
n University of Kansas
n jgentry@ku.edu
Strictly Financials 3
4. n Gary Trennepohl, Ph.D.
n ONEOK Chair and President’s Council Professor of Finance
n Oklahoma State University
n Trustee, Oklahoma Teachers Retirement System
n Member, OSU Foundation Investment Committee
n gary.trennepohl@okstate.edu
Strictly Financials 4
5. Topics
n Goodwill, impairment
n Pro forma
n Bank financials
n Comparing companies: A Changing
Industry
n The concepts and your companies
Strictly Financials 5
7. Goodwill
n Difference between what a firm pays to buy
another company and the book value (total
assets minus total liabilities) of that company.
n Has been written off over time, typically 40
years
n No longer amortize
n Other intangible assets will continue to be
amortized over useful lives.
Strictly Financials 7
8. Impairment
n Instead of writing off over time, now use
“impairment testing”
n The impairment is expensed on the
income statement.
Strictly Financials 8
9. Examples
n Crocs
n McClatchy
n Gannett
n New York Times
n HP
Strictly Financials 9
11. Pro Forma Results
n Critics: Selectively defined earnings
n Expenses against earnings are not
standardized across an industry.
n SEC’s Regulation G (1/03) states that
non-GAAP numbers used in an
earnings release must be accompanied
by, and reconciled with, the “most
directly comparable GAAP number.”
Strictly Financials 11
12. Pro Forma Results
n Recommendation: GAAP results should
precede pro forma results in earnings
releases.
n Headlines should show GAAP earnings.
n Many firms say pro forma has value.
n Common form: EBITDA. Also, OIBDA.
n “As a matter of form”
Strictly Financials 12
14. Bank Financial Statements
1. The business of a bank
2. The balance sheet
3. The income statement
4. Some key financial ratios
5. Sources of bank data
15. The Business of a Bank
n Banks are a “financial intermediary,”
taking in money from “savers” and
loaning it out to “investors” - they buy
and sell money.
n For most banks, the majority of their
earnings come from interest income on
loans, and interest earned on securities.
Strictly Financials 15
16. The Business of a Bank
n Banks also earn fee income for
services.
n Banks’ two main risks are:
n Interest-rate risk
n “credit risk”
Strictly Financials 16
17. The Income Statement
Net interest Income
- Provision for loan losses
= Net Income after PLL
+/- Net non-interest income
= Net Income Before Taxes
- Taxes (many small banks are S corps)
= Net Income
Strictly Financials 17
18. The Bank Balance Sheet
Assets = Liabilities + Capital
n Cash + n Deposits
Primary Reserve Fed Funds loaned
n
n Demand Deposits
n Securities n Savings Deposits
Secondary Res. n U.S. Governments n Now/Money Market Accts.
n Loans n CDs, Time Deposits
n Real Estate n Non-deposit Borrowings
n Commercial n Fed Funds purchased
n Consumer n Repo agreements
n Premises- Fixed n Long term debt
Asset n Equity Capital
n Misc. Assets
Strictly Financials 18
19. Three Key Ratios
n Return on Assets = Net Income/(Avg. Total Assets)
n Typically runs around 1.0% to 1.5%
n Averages 4 quarters of total assets for the
denominator to smooth effect of asset swings
n Return on Equity = (Net Income)/(Equity capital)
n Will be different for publicly traded banks versus
private banks
n Capitalization Ratio = Equity/(Total Avg. Assets)
n Tier 1 Capital should be ≥10%
Strictly Financials 19
20. The Texas Ratio
n Texas Ratio = (non-performing loans+OREO)
Equity + Loan loss Reserves
n Think of it as the ratio of troubled loans to “capital”
n OREO is Other Real Estate Owned
n Early-warning system to measure a bank’s potential for
failure.
n Banks tend to fail as TR approaches 100% (troubled bank)
n Don’t get a mortgage loan from a troubled bank.
n Data to calculate at http://www2.fdic.gov/sdi/main.asp. Use
“non-performing assets and bank real estate owned/equity
and loss reserves”
Strictly Financials 20
21. Key Issues for Banks in 2013
n True form and impact of Dodd/Frank Bill
n CFPB begins life January 2013, and most rules still being
written.
n CFPB answers only to Fed.
n Banks are either OCC; Fed or State/FDIC regulated. How
will these regulators interact with CFPB?
n “TAG” =Transaction Account Guaranty expires in
2012.
n FDIC-insurance limits revert to $250,000 maximum.
n Will consumers withdraw funds from local banks now?
n Basel III - More new and complicated rules for calculating
“risk-based” capital
Strictly Financials 21
22. Sources of Banking Data
n The Uniform Bank Performance Report
(UBPR) is provided by federal
regulators so analysts can compare
bank performance against peer groups.
n Web link:
n www.ffiec.gov
n Another source for large banks is:
n www.BankRegData.com
Strictly Financials 22
23. Doing Comparisons
n Common-size analysis is an excellent
tool for comparing companies,
regardless of size.
n Companies in the same industry might
have similar or widely differing
statements. Common size brings out
those similarities and differences.
Strictly Financials 23
26. Model Is Changing
n Business models are changing
everywhere.
n Pharmacies have been quietly changing
for the past several years. Now, a
somewhat new entrant poses a big
threat.
Strictly Financials 26
27. A “Disruptive Technology”?
n Express Scripts
n How will it change, and how will its
model change the business?
n Is this an example of a “disruptive
technology” in the Clayton Christensen
sense?
Strictly Financials 27
28. The Concepts and
Your Companies
n What issues do you want to discuss?
Strictly Financials 28