SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 10
Download to read offline
Page 1 of 10
ZACHMAN ARCHITECTURE-BASED EDUCATION SERVICE
DELIVERY
1
ALEJANDRO DOMÍNGUEZ
JADOMING@MAIL.UNITEC.MX
School of Postgraduate Studies
Universidad TecnolĂłgica de MĂ©xico, www.unitec.mx
Marina Nacional 500, Colonia AnĂĄhuac
C.P. 11320, MĂ©xico City
MÉXICO
Keywords: Education, policies, service, Zachman architecture, 5WH scheme.
ABSTRACT
Education service delivery represents a challenge for any academic institution since there must satisfy
academically and administratively both students and lecturers. In delivering this kind of service, academic
institution personnel must have a sort of particular expertise to guarantee education excellence, otherwise service
delivered would be limited to certain activities. This is not the case if expertise of institution in a particular level
is either poor or null. So the main question to be answered in delivering education service is what an institution
of education should do to implement, operate, monitor, supervise, and control service in order to pass from the
achievement of opening requirements to satisfy students’ expectations. Answering this question also lets
institution satisfy the accreditation criteria of external entities (when required) as well as standardise education
service when implemented and operated in other sites.
One way of proceeding to answer such a question is firstly to identify a set of functional institution areas that are
directly related to service delivering. These functional areas have to be identified precisely in order to establish
their participation in planning, implementing, and operating education service. As a second step, each area is
fully described if it is used a 5WH scheme (What, Where, Who, When, Why, and How). This description leads
to a Zachman architecture (matrix) for education service, in which rows represent functional areas and columns
represent elements of the 5WH scheme. After filling each Zachman matrix cell and analysing each column as a
whole it is derived a set of representative policies to deliver education service. In order to illustrate an
application of method and policies so derived to a real case, an example of the corresponding policies is shown
for a postgraduate education service in a Mexican private university.
EDUCATION SERVICE IN PERSPECTIVE
Students are and must be the main reason of being for any institution dedicated to provide education at any level.
For higher education institutions this reason is vitally important since in them students are provided of
knowledge, and acquire abilities and capabilities to develop successfully their professional life. Without students
there is no reason for having lecturers, syllabus, courses, classrooms, laboratories, technology, and staff. On the
basis of this perspective, education service must be understood as the result of the actions of the institution, and
their composite functional areas, to satisfy the requirements of academic formation of its students.
In order to offer this education service, an institution has to satisfy a set of preliminary requirements which
depend on if the institution is either public or private based. These requirements are, in any case, related to
people, information, processes, and infrastructure and technology.
Once the institution has satisfied these requirements, the responsibility of implementation and operation of
educative service depends on the actions of some functional areas which have a direct contact with students.
Although implementation and operation are monitored, supervised, and controlled by the institution, results are
1
This paper was presented at Product and Operation Management Society – College of Service Operations Conference; London Business
School; July 12-13 2007. www.poms.org/2007/03/poms_college_of_service_operat_1.html#more
Page 2 of 10
visualised when students and alumni either promote or not education service offered. A more concrete way of
visualising results of the provided education service is when the institution is subject to a self-evaluation and
then to an evaluation by external certification entities.
In any case, once the institution receives feed-back, it has to perform modifications and corrections
recommended. In This way, the main question to be answered is:
What should an institution of education do to implement, operate, monitor, supervise, and
control its provided education service in order to pass from the achievement of opening
requirements to satisfy students’ expectations, and consequently also satisfy the accreditation
criteria of external entities?
In such a situation, an answer to this question is to develop a theoretical and practical based model to deliver
education service and, from it derive a set of policies in order to have a first approach to education service
activities standardisation. In fact, some authors point out (Álvarez Torres, p.27) that “every institution, either
conscious or not, are ruled by written or not written policies”.
However in many institutions of education that set of policies do not always exist. Moreover, in some cases
when these policies exist, they are not always built on a solid structure, and in another cases they are not attached
to service requirements.
OBJECTIVES
From discussion so far, in order to deliver education service it is necessary to carry out the following objectives:
 To abstract from reality and to create an appropriate model to offer education service.
 To write a set of general policies to offer education service.
Both model and policies derived from it acquire more value if they are put in practice for a particular case; even
more, if they are easy to transfer to similar environments. Thus a third objective is:
 To show an example of the corresponding policies for a postgraduate education service.
A MODEL TO OFFER EDUCATION SERVICE
Before defining the model to be used as a basis for enouncing education service policies, it is necessary to
identify entities (people, departments or functional areas) and their corresponding responsibilities related to
service. Reconsidering ideas given by John Zachman (Zachman) for education service case, in an education
institution may be distinguished entities described in Table 1.
Table 1. Entities for education service.
ENTITY DESCRIPTION
ACADEMIC PLANNING
ENTITY
It detects the society requirements related to education service and also defines its scope when service is on
implementation and operation phases.
ACADEMIC DEVELOPMENT
ENTITY
It conceptualises, defines, and develops education model to be put in practice when the service is on
implementation and operation phases.
IMPLEMENTATION ENTITY It defines the logic to offer education service when it is on implementation and operation phases.
ACADEMIC COORDINATION
ENTITY
It defines how education service is operated in practice
LECTURERS It offers directly education service and is in contact with the user of this service.
STUDENTS It uses education service.
Functions performed by these entities is completely established if for each one can be defined all participation
aspects on education service. For it, it must define the following question indicators (Álvarez Torres p.32,
Page 3 of 10
Zachman) given by the well known 5WH scheme: What (data), How (processes), Where (place), Who (entities,
infrastructure, technology), When (time), and Why (motivation). Description of them is shown in Table 2.
Table 2. Question indicators: 5WH scheme.
QUESTION INDICATOR DESCRIPTION
WHAT (DATA) It is data to define and understand education service requirements.
HOW (PROCESSES)
They are processes to translate education service requirements into more detailed implementation and
operation definitions.
WHERE (PLACE)
It is related to physical distribution of places where education service will be implemented and
operated.
WHO (ENTITIES, INFRASTRUCTURE,
AND TECHNOLOGY)
It defines who is related to education service, and also defines infrastructure and technology required
to implement and to operate it.
WHEN (TIME) It describes how time perturbs education service.
WHY (MOTIVATION) It translates education service strategies and objectives into specific meaning.
If both entities and question indicators are arranged as a matrix where rows represent entities and columns
represent questions indicators, then it is obtained a model containing information to be present in education
service delivery. This is shown in Figure 1.
It is important to notice that in this model (DVA-US):
 Every row represents a different view of education service.
 Every column is complementary to each other.
 Every cell is unique and complementary to each other.
 Combination of cells on a row is a complete description of each education service view.
Filling cells is not an easy task and requires having a complete view of education service. If not, it may be a
problem to define the required policies; in fact, it may be obtained a partial or misinterpreted set of policies. For
filling cells it is invoked author expertise and ideas established in DVA-US, Hay-a y Zachman. This filling is
shown in Figure 1.
It is important to notice that information contained in each cell may be considered as a minimum unit of
information to be used to create policies and it has the following properties:
 It is common for any education service offering.
 It generates new information about education service.
 It is time independent.
 It is replicable on other contexts with no lose of meaning.
Thus, according with Richard Dawkins’ definition (Wikipedia-Meme), each cell may be considered a “meme”.
Hence, model of Figure 1 allows to:
 Visualise information to be integrated in the offering of education service.
 Give a fine detail of responsibilities of each participating entity in the offering of education service
(Hay-b).
 Provide distinctive views of education service (Hay-b).
Page 4 of 10
Figure 1. Model to offer education service.
WHAT
(DATA)
HOW
(PROCESSES)
WHERE
(PLACE)
WHO
(ENTITIES,
INFRASTRUCTURE,
TECHNOLOGY)
WHEN
(TIME)
WHY
(MOTIVATION)
ACADEMIC
PLANNING
ENTITY
(CONTEXTUAL
MODEL)
List of society
requirements
important to
define education
service
List of general
processes to
offer education
service
List of places
where education
services will be
implemented
and operated
List of participating
and significant
entities,
infrastructure, and
technology to offer
education service
List of
significant
events to
offer
education
service
List of
objectives and
strategies to
offer education
service
ACADEMIC
DEVELOPMENT
ENTITY
(CONCEPTUAL
MODEL)
Semantic model
of requirements
to offer
education
service
(Programme
Plan and
Syllabus)
Process model
to offer
education
service
Relational
model among
places where
education
service will be
implemented
and operated
Workflow model to
offer education
service
Event model
to offer
education
service
Plan to offer
education
service
IMPLEMENTATION
MODEL
(LOGIC MODEL)
List of general
internal
requirements to
offer education
service
Application
architecture to
offer education
service
Distribution
architecture of
places where
education
service will be
implemented
and operated
Interaction
architecture among
participants in
offering education
service
Event
architecture
to offer
education
service
Rules model to
offer education
service
ACADEMIC
COORDINATION
MODEL
(PHYSICAL
MODEL)
List of specific
internal
requirements to
offer education
service
Implementation
and operation
navigation
diagrams to
offer education
service
Relationship
diagram of
places where
operation
service will be
implemented
Interaction diagram
among participants
in offering education
service
Event
diagram to
offer
education
service
Rule design to
offer education
service
LECTURERS
(DETAILED
MODEL)
Requirements
fulfil
Detailed
process to
implement and
operate
syllabus
components
Places versus
lecturer
assignation
List of lecturers, lab
equipment, and
technology
Time-table
Objectives of
courses
MEETING POINT OF EDUCATION SERVICE
STUDENTS
Reception and
assimilation of
course topics
Processes to
develop
assignments,
task, and lab
practices
Attend
classrooms,
labs, library and
other facilities
Interaction with
classrooms, labs,
library and other
facilities
Attend time-
table
Need of
education
service
Rows in Figure 1 represent points of view of different participating entities in education service delivery, while
columns represent different aspects of this delivery. The view of each entity is (Hay-b) shown in Table 3.
Table 3. Views of participating entities to offer education service.
ENTITY EDUCATION SERVICE VIEWS
ACADEMIC PLANNING ENTITY
(CONTEXTUAL MODEL)
It is the strategic view of education service. It is needed to establish the context of any offering service
effort.
ACADEMIC DEVELOPMENT ENTITY
(CONCEPTUAL MODEL)
In terms of education service, this view defines the nature of service, including its structure, functions
and organisation.
IMPLEMENTATION ENTITY (LOGIC
MODEL)
It describes the conceptual model in a logic way.
ACADEMIC COORDINATION MODEL
(PHYSICAL MODEL)
It describes how resources are to be used according to information obtained from previous models.
LECTURERS (DETAILED MODEL)
It translates academic programmes and relationships among them into information understood by
students.
STUDENTS It is the user’s view of education service.
Page 5 of 10
POLICIES TO OFFER EDUCATION SERVICE
As it was pointed out above, policies have to include information from each cell in Figure 1. However either this
information is not always explicitly present on daily basis or, when present, is on a number of documents
belonging to different functional areas.
On the other side, it is important to notice that the responsibility at the moment of offering education service is
not the same for each participating entity (see Table 1). In fact, this responsibility vanishes gradually from
Lecturers to Academic Planning entities. Thus policies must be controlled by the academic authority closer to
students. In this case such an entity is Academic Coordination Entity, and supervised by Implementation Entity.
Since Academic Coordination agglutinates policies information and, at the same time, is responsible of
implementation and operation of models derived from other entities, it is very important that the Academic
Coordination Entity generates a unique manual containing these policies. Three more reasons to create this
manual are:
 In case there is a doubt about how to manage a problem related to education service; manual can be
consulted, look on it for policy or policies related to the problem, and then apply them.
 Manual can be used as a tool to behave and proceed when similar cases come out.
 Manual can be used as a reference to standardise education service when implemented and operated on
other locations.
Of course, manual structure must have a more logical order than that of structure shown in Figure 1. In fact, in
looking up policies, it is more convenient if they have an order according to implementation and operation in
time of education service. Hence, columns (question indicators) must be ordered starting with Motivation (Why),
and followed by Data (What), Places (Where), Time (When), Entities (Who), and then Processes (How). This
order and its associated derived policies are shown in Table 4. It is important to point out that in derivation of
policies associated to a same column, they have to be complementary among them and their description must be
at the same level of complexity.
Table 4. Question Indicators and policies.
QUESTION INDICATOR ASSOCIATED SET OF POLICIES
WHY (MOTIVATION) Policies related to type, mission, and vision of education service.
WHAT (DATA)
Policies related to public information of education service.
Policies related to promotion of education service.
WHERE (PLACE) Policies related to where education service is offered.
WHEN (TIME) Policies related to when education service is offered.
WHO (ENTITIES, INFRASTRUCTURE,
AND TECHNOLOGY)
Policies related to who manage academic coordination.
Policies related to student candidates, and students.
Policies related to lecturer candidates, and lecturers.
Policies related to requirements and use of infrastructure and technology.
HOW (PROCESSES)
Policies related to programme management, courses and syllabus.
Policies related to monitor and control of education service.
Policies related to finishing education service.
Policies related to other academic processes.
In practice, policies must be written using a straightforward, homogeneous and plain language style. Moreover,
for some of them there should be attached documents providing more information about their meaning. Of
course, policies manual must contain some paragraphs containing about their context, control, and general
management (Álvarez Torres). This last information is important since provides an application and use
framework.
Page 6 of 10
MODEL FEATURES
Matrix obtained by crossing entities with questions indicators is known in literature as Zachman Architecture
(Zachman) and it has been documented widely (AdCom, DVA-US, Hay-a, Hay-b, Zachman). There are a
number of applications of it; some of them are Health Care, Municipal Government, Logistics, and Information
Technology (AdCom). However, nowadays it seems there is no documented application of it to create a model to
deliver education service and its associated policies.
A Zachman-type architecture, like that shown in Figure 1, has many features. Some of them are (AdCom):
 It communicates. It allows communication among participants related to education service.
 It agglutinates. It allows making components of education service stay glued together as a whole.
 It is simple. Its structure is not technical but logical: go from basic notions to detail description and use.
 It is expressive. It helps communicating in a non-technical precise way complex concepts about
education service.
 It helps planning. It allows taking better decisions in planning education service.
 It is a problem solving tool. It enables abstraction and simplification without neglecting the
complexity of the education service as a whole.
 It is “product” neutral. It does not depend on any methodologies or tools.
Notice that these features are inherited to rows, columns, and cells. Moreover, these features allows concluding
that if there is not policies to deliver education service, there may exists conflicts, misunderstandings,
preferences, and restlessness inside Academic Coordination and Implementation Entities since there could be a
particular interpretation of some “over-understood policies”.
POLICY MANUAL EXAMPLE
A simplified example of policy manual is shown on Appendix below. Such a manual was created for delivering
education service on postgraduate level in a Mexican private university. Structure of this manual is shown in
Table 5 (according with Table 4). An early version of it helped performing a self-assessment on postgraduate
area, as well as to approve a certification evaluation performed by an external entity. Moreover, manual has been
used as a reference to standardise education service when implemented and operated in other university campi.
Table 5. Manual structure example: Policies to deliver postgraduate programmes.
1. Policy context
2. Policy control
2.1. Controlling functional area
2.2. Review controls
3. Policy management
3.1. Policies application functional areas
3.2. Policies purpose and scope
3.3. Policies application responsible
3.4. Distribution list
3.5. Preliminary definitions
4. Policy statements
4.1. Policies related to type, mission, and vision of postgraduate programmes
4.2. Policies related to public information of postgraduate programmes
4.3. Policies related to promotion of postgraduate programmes
4.4. Policies related to where postgraduate programmes are offered
4.5. Policies related to when postgraduate programmes are offered
4.6. Policies related to academic coordination manager
4.7. Policies related to student candidates, and students
4.8. Policies related to lecturer candidates, and lecturers
4.9. Policies related to requirements and use of infrastructure and information technology
4.10. Policies related to postgraduate programmes management, courses and syllabus
4.11. Policies related to operate, monitor and control of postgraduate programmes
4.12. Policies related to finishing postgraduate programme studies
4.13. Policies related to other academic processes
Page 7 of 10
As usual, application of these policies has permitted to revise them, to assess them, and improve them.
Particularly, policies have permitted to that Mexican university:
 Acquire criteria to act in similar events occurring when offering education service.
 Make easy to take decisions on recurrent events when offering education service.
 Act as a self-defined entity when offering education service.
 Accelerate and improve quality in activities related to education service.
During implementation and use of policies, Academic Coordination Entity have adopted a disciplined attitude,
and in cases where logic and reason command to take action in a different way as policies say, both entities agree
what to do in such cases, always avoiding repeat similar actions to same people or entity.
Finally, and in order to save space and go directly to statement of policies, example described in Appendix omits
account from point 1 to point 3.
CONCLUSION
Delivering education service is not an easy task if there are no policies to guarantee a minimum of
accomplishment. In most of cases, policies are created once that experience is gained by an education institution.
However in order to gain this experience a considerable number of trials and amount of time is required. A more
effective and efficient way of creating policies for education service is to derive them from a proved and
documented model.
Although it seems that Zachman Architecture model has not been used yet to deliver education service, it has
been proved to be useful to deliver other kind of services, such as those related to information technology. Its
usefulness is due to it is based on well established organisational and practical views as well as on 5WH scheme,
which in turn helps describing precisely any abstract or concrete entity.
Thus, as it was shown herein, using a Zachman-based model helps reducing misunderstandings and setbacks in
producing a set of policies useful to delivering and standardising education service in any education institution,
and particularly in those offering postgraduate programmes.
REFERENCES
AdCom (Administrative Computing Services). Zachman Framework Applied to Administrative Computing
Services. http://apps.adcom.uci.edu/EnterpriseArch/Zachman. Visited on April 2006.
Álvarez Torres, M. Manual para Elaborar Manuales de Políticas y Procedimientos. Editorial Panorama. México,
2001.
DVA-US (United States Department of Veteran Affairs). A Tutorial on the Zachman Framework for Enterprise
Architecture. http://apps.adcom.uci.edu/EnterpriseArch/Zachman/Resources/ZachmanTutorial.ppt. Visited
in april 2006.
Hay-a, D. C. A Different Kind of Life Cycle: The Zachman Framework.
www.essentialstrategies.com/documents/zachman2000.pdf. Visited in april 2006.
Hay-b, D. C. The Zachman Framework: An Introduction. www.tdan.com/i001fe01.htm. Visited on April 2006.
Wikipedia-Meme. Meme. http://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meme. Visited on April 2006.
Zachman, J.A. A framework for Information Systems Architecture. IBM Systems Journal, Vol. 26, No. 3, 1987.
Page 8 of 10
APPENDIX: POLICIES TO DELIVER POSTGRADUATE PROGRAMMES
1. POLICY CONTEXT
Omitted
2. POLICY CONTROL
Omitted
3. POLICY MANAGEMENT
Omitted
4. POLICY STATEMENTS
4.1. POLICIES RELATED TO TYPE, MISSION, AND VISION OF POSTGRADUATE PROGRAMMES
1. All of entities (Academic Planning, Academic Development, Implementation, Academic Coordination,
and Lecturers) participating in delivering postgraduate programmes must have a copy and read the
document “Type, Mission, and Vision of Postgraduate Programmes” which state:
 Type of Postgraduate Programmes offered by the University according to Government
classification.
 Mission and Vision of Postgraduate School.
2. All of entities participating in delivering postgraduate programmes must have a copy and read the
document “Postgraduate Regulations Handbook”.
4.2. POLICIES RELATED TO PUBLIC INFORMATION OF POSTGRADUATE PROGRAMMES
3. There must be soft (electronic) and hard (paper) public information related to postgraduate programmes.
4. Soft information (electronic) for each postgraduate programme must be accessed from the main
university Internet site.
5. Hard information (paper) for each postgraduate programme must be printed in a brochure.
6. Both soft and hard information must be coincident for each postgraduate programme.
4.3. POLICIES RELATED TO PROMOTION OF POSTGRADUATE PROGRAMMES
7. There must be a term promotion plan to offer postgraduate programmes which must be described in
document “Term Promotion Plan to Postgraduate Programmes”.
8. Promotion plan must consider promotion through the following media:
 Electronic mail.
 Specialised periodic journal.
 Newspapers.
 Kiosks in fairs related to postgraduate programmes.
4.4. POLICIES RELATED TO WHERE POSTGRADUATE PROGRAMMES ARE OFFERED
9. Postgraduate programmes can only be offered in campi previously approved by the Postgraduate
University Board (Academic Planning, Academic Development, Academic Director and Academic
Coordinator entities) and by the Government Education Authority.
Page 9 of 10
4.5. POLICIES RELATED TO WHEN POSTGRADUATE PROGRAMMES ARE OFFERED
10. Postgraduate programmes must be offered in time terms approved and defined by Postgraduate
University Board.
4.6. POLICIES RELATED TO ACADEMIC COORDINATION MANAGER
11. Postgraduate Academic Coordination Manager must agree to requirements established in document
“Postgraduate Academic Coordination Manager Job Description”.
4.7. POLICIES RELATED TO STUDENT CANDIDATES, AND STUDENTS
12. Postgraduate student candidates must fulfil requirements established in document “Criteria and
Requirements to be Accepted as Postgraduate Students”
13. The registry process to a postgraduate programme must be performed without setbacks and, when
needed, Academic Coordination Manager must help solving arisen problems.
14. All of postgraduate students (accepted postgraduate candidates) must have a copy and read the
document “Type, Mission, and Vision of Postgraduate Programmes”.
15. All of postgraduate students must have a copy and read the document “Postgraduate Regulations
Handbook”.
16. In course choosing, students must be advised by Academic Coordination Manager.
4.8. POLICIES RELATED TO LECTURER CANDIDATES, AND LECTURERS
17. All of postgraduate lecturer candidates must fulfil requirements established in document “Criteria and
Requirements to be Accepted as Lecturer”
18. Academic Coordination Manager must interview with lecturer candidates. In this interview Academic
Coordination Manager must:
 Provide the syllabus of course to be lectured
 Evaluate knowledge and attitude based on a question-answer method related to course to be
lectured. Points to be addressed are
o Academic status of postgraduate studies (degree obtained and university where studied).
o Academic lecturing experience at postgraduate level.
o General knowledge about topics of course to be lectured.
o Professional experiences about topics of course to be lectured.
o Knowledge and experience of new topics about course to be lectured.
o Knowledge about classical and new bibliographical references about course to be lectured.
o Knowledge and use of information technology related to course to be lectured.
19. Academic Coordination Manager must guarantee that each course has an assigned lecturer.
20. All of lecturers must have a copy and read the document “Type, Mission, and Vision of Postgraduate
Programmes”.
21. All of lecturers must have a copy and read the document “Postgraduate Regulations Handbook”.
4.9. POLICIES RELATED TO REQUIREMENTS AND USE OF INFRASTRUCTURE AND INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY
22. Infrastructure and information technology for postgraduate programmes must hold requirements
established in document “Infrastructure and Information Technology Description for Postgraduate
Programmes”.
4.10. POLICIES RELATED TO POSTGRADUATE PROGRAMMES MANAGEMENT, COURSES AND SYLLABUS
23. Academic Coordination Manager must plan with lecturers the use of infrastructure and technology
associated to the respective course. This planning must be aligned with objective established in each
postgraduate programme as well as the course syllabus.
Page 10 of 10
24. At the beginning of each academic period, Academic Coordination Manager must organise a welcome
and induction to postgraduate programmes short session to new students, and in it there must be present
Academic Director, Academic Coordination Manager, and Lecturers.
25. As part of welcome and induction session, Academic Coordination Manager must explain and deliver to
students the following documents: “Induction to University”, “Induction to Postgraduate
Programmes”, “Postgraduate Regulations Handbook”, and the corresponding “Programme Course
Syllabus”.
26. Before the first lecture of each academic period, Academic Coordination Manager must organise a
previous meeting with lecturers in order to clarify any topic about courses and other related topics. In
this meeting Academic Coordination Manager must deliver to each lecturer a preliminary list of
students.
27. At the first lecture of each course, Academic Coordination Manager must introduce lecturer to students.
28. At the first lecture of each course, lecturer must deliver to students a copy of topics to be covered in the
course and the way they will be assessed.
4.11. POLICIES RELATED TO OPERATE, MONITOR AND CONTROL OF POSTGRADUATE PROGRAMMES
29. Academic Coordination Manager is responsible for operating, monitoring, and controlling postgraduate
education service.
30. Academic Coordination Manager must monitor continuously the delivery of academic and
administrative aspects of postgraduate programmes. Academic monitoring is to:
 Prevent and detect any setbacks limiting performance of lecturers and students.
 Propose, agree and follow course improving actions.
31. Before ending each term, Academic Coordinator Manager must invite students to assess performance of
lecturers using the document “Template for Assessment of Lecturers”.
32. If a lecturer obtains a low qualification, then (s)he must not be included for lecturing next term.
4.12. POLICIES RELATED TO FINISHING POSTGRADUATE PROGRAMME STUDIES
33. If required by postgraduate programme:
 Before ending postgraduate programme studies, Academic Coordination Manager must help
students choosing a thesis supervisor according with thesis topic to be developed.
 In developing thesis document, Academic Coordination Manager and elected student’s supervisor
must assure student follows guidelines indicated in documents “Postgraduate Thesis Creation
Handbook” (related to theoretical and experimental topics), “Style Guide to Creation and
Presentation of Postgraduate Thesis” (related to writing aspects), and “Format Guide to
Creation of Thesis” (related to format aspects).
 Before ending postgraduate programme, Academic Coordination Manager must assure that all of
students finish the corresponding postgraduate thesis.
34. Academic Coordination Manager must deliver to students a copy of the following document:
“Requirements and Process to Obtain Postgraduate Degree”.
4.13. POLICIES RELATED TO OTHER ACADEMIC PROCESSES
35. Academic Coordination Manager and lecturers must agree other academic activities such as:
conferences, publication of development and research papers, and link with professional associations
and universities.
***** End of Policies *****

More Related Content

What's hot

The students’ acceptance of learning management systems in Saudi Arabian Univ...
The students’ acceptance of learning management systems in Saudi Arabian Univ...The students’ acceptance of learning management systems in Saudi Arabian Univ...
The students’ acceptance of learning management systems in Saudi Arabian Univ...IJECEIAES
 
CCBA Research paper
CCBA Research paperCCBA Research paper
CCBA Research paperNo Limit
 
Competency based learning: State of the U.S. K-12 market
Competency based learning: State of the U.S. K-12 marketCompetency based learning: State of the U.S. K-12 market
Competency based learning: State of the U.S. K-12 marketNewSchools Ignite
 
IC DMU 2016 The Direction of Maritime Education and Training development A Co...
IC DMU 2016 The Direction of Maritime Education and Training development A Co...IC DMU 2016 The Direction of Maritime Education and Training development A Co...
IC DMU 2016 The Direction of Maritime Education and Training development A Co...CINEC Campus
 

What's hot (6)

The students’ acceptance of learning management systems in Saudi Arabian Univ...
The students’ acceptance of learning management systems in Saudi Arabian Univ...The students’ acceptance of learning management systems in Saudi Arabian Univ...
The students’ acceptance of learning management systems in Saudi Arabian Univ...
 
CCBA Research paper
CCBA Research paperCCBA Research paper
CCBA Research paper
 
Dubai 2013 faculty full paper
Dubai 2013 faculty full paperDubai 2013 faculty full paper
Dubai 2013 faculty full paper
 
Competency based learning: State of the U.S. K-12 market
Competency based learning: State of the U.S. K-12 marketCompetency based learning: State of the U.S. K-12 market
Competency based learning: State of the U.S. K-12 market
 
Active labour market policies in Ireland: What works?
Active labour market policies in Ireland: What works?Active labour market policies in Ireland: What works?
Active labour market policies in Ireland: What works?
 
IC DMU 2016 The Direction of Maritime Education and Training development A Co...
IC DMU 2016 The Direction of Maritime Education and Training development A Co...IC DMU 2016 The Direction of Maritime Education and Training development A Co...
IC DMU 2016 The Direction of Maritime Education and Training development A Co...
 

Viewers also liked

AcreditaciĂłn en informĂĄtica y computaciĂłn
AcreditaciĂłn en informĂĄtica y computaciĂłnAcreditaciĂłn en informĂĄtica y computaciĂłn
AcreditaciĂłn en informĂĄtica y computaciĂłnAlejandro DomĂ­nguez Torres
 
The limiting absorption principle for the elastic equations
The limiting absorption principle for the elastic equationsThe limiting absorption principle for the elastic equations
The limiting absorption principle for the elastic equationsAlejandro DomĂ­nguez Torres
 
El riesgo de no considerar la gestiĂłn de riesgos
El riesgo de no considerar la gestiĂłn de riesgosEl riesgo de no considerar la gestiĂłn de riesgos
El riesgo de no considerar la gestiĂłn de riesgosAlejandro DomĂ­nguez Torres
 
A competency based human resources architecture
A competency based human resources architectureA competency based human resources architecture
A competency based human resources architectureAlejandro DomĂ­nguez Torres
 
A historical note on schwartz space and test or bump functions
A historical note on schwartz space and test or bump functionsA historical note on schwartz space and test or bump functions
A historical note on schwartz space and test or bump functionsAlejandro DomĂ­nguez Torres
 

Viewers also liked (20)

AcreditaciĂłn en informĂĄtica y computaciĂłn
AcreditaciĂłn en informĂĄtica y computaciĂłnAcreditaciĂłn en informĂĄtica y computaciĂłn
AcreditaciĂłn en informĂĄtica y computaciĂłn
 
A short note on the history of B-splines
A short note on the history of B-splinesA short note on the history of B-splines
A short note on the history of B-splines
 
The limiting absorption principle for the elastic equations
The limiting absorption principle for the elastic equationsThe limiting absorption principle for the elastic equations
The limiting absorption principle for the elastic equations
 
El riesgo de no considerar la gestiĂłn de riesgos
El riesgo de no considerar la gestiĂłn de riesgosEl riesgo de no considerar la gestiĂłn de riesgos
El riesgo de no considerar la gestiĂłn de riesgos
 
Calidad en el desarrollo de proyectos
Calidad en el desarrollo de proyectosCalidad en el desarrollo de proyectos
Calidad en el desarrollo de proyectos
 
A competency based human resources architecture
A competency based human resources architectureA competency based human resources architecture
A competency based human resources architecture
 
Es usted un lĂ­der de proyectos
Es usted un lĂ­der de proyectosEs usted un lĂ­der de proyectos
Es usted un lĂ­der de proyectos
 
Tomando el control del ruido organizacional
Tomando el control del ruido organizacionalTomando el control del ruido organizacional
Tomando el control del ruido organizacional
 
AnalogĂ­as para el desarrollo de ti
AnalogĂ­as para el desarrollo de tiAnalogĂ­as para el desarrollo de ti
AnalogĂ­as para el desarrollo de ti
 
Liderando proyectos de it
Liderando proyectos de itLiderando proyectos de it
Liderando proyectos de it
 
Fundamentos para el desarrollo de proyectos
Fundamentos para el desarrollo de proyectosFundamentos para el desarrollo de proyectos
Fundamentos para el desarrollo de proyectos
 
Representaciones de Fibonacci
Representaciones de FibonacciRepresentaciones de Fibonacci
Representaciones de Fibonacci
 
Los hackers con Ă©tica
Los hackers con Ă©ticaLos hackers con Ă©tica
Los hackers con Ă©tica
 
Un emprendedor nunca deja de capacitarse
Un emprendedor nunca deja de capacitarseUn emprendedor nunca deja de capacitarse
Un emprendedor nunca deja de capacitarse
 
GestiĂłn del cambio caso de estudio
GestiĂłn del cambio   caso de estudioGestiĂłn del cambio   caso de estudio
GestiĂłn del cambio caso de estudio
 
La ingeniera social y la seguridad en ti
La ingeniera social y la seguridad en tiLa ingeniera social y la seguridad en ti
La ingeniera social y la seguridad en ti
 
La mejora de procesos en las empresas
La mejora de procesos en las empresasLa mejora de procesos en las empresas
La mejora de procesos en las empresas
 
A historical note on schwartz space and test or bump functions
A historical note on schwartz space and test or bump functionsA historical note on schwartz space and test or bump functions
A historical note on schwartz space and test or bump functions
 
El colapso de los proyectos
El colapso de los proyectosEl colapso de los proyectos
El colapso de los proyectos
 
Carreras con futuro
Carreras con futuroCarreras con futuro
Carreras con futuro
 

Similar to Education service delivery

MARKETING SEGMENTATION AND PRODUCT DEFINITION 1.docx
MARKETING SEGMENTATION AND PRODUCT DEFINITION                    1.docxMARKETING SEGMENTATION AND PRODUCT DEFINITION                    1.docx
MARKETING SEGMENTATION AND PRODUCT DEFINITION 1.docxinfantsuk
 
Developing strategic planning in a special education service
Developing strategic planning in a special education serviceDeveloping strategic planning in a special education service
Developing strategic planning in a special education serviceLira Lei Ann Bondoc
 
Keystone College Students’ Perceptions of Career Development and Use of Caree...
Keystone College Students’ Perceptions of Career Development and Use of Caree...Keystone College Students’ Perceptions of Career Development and Use of Caree...
Keystone College Students’ Perceptions of Career Development and Use of Caree...Joseph Croft
 
Running Head COMMUNICATION TRAINING PLANCOMMUNICATION TR.docx
Running Head COMMUNICATION TRAINING PLANCOMMUNICATION TR.docxRunning Head COMMUNICATION TRAINING PLANCOMMUNICATION TR.docx
Running Head COMMUNICATION TRAINING PLANCOMMUNICATION TR.docxtodd271
 
Research Proposal M Torres Vargas - Chyung's comments
Research Proposal M Torres Vargas - Chyung's commentsResearch Proposal M Torres Vargas - Chyung's comments
Research Proposal M Torres Vargas - Chyung's commentsMaria Isabel Torres, M.S.
 
Running Head COMMUNICATION TRAINING PLAN1COMMUNICATION T.docx
Running Head COMMUNICATION TRAINING PLAN1COMMUNICATION T.docxRunning Head COMMUNICATION TRAINING PLAN1COMMUNICATION T.docx
Running Head COMMUNICATION TRAINING PLAN1COMMUNICATION T.docxtodd271
 
Running Head COMMUNICATION TRAINING PLANCOMMUNICATION TR.docx
Running Head COMMUNICATION TRAINING PLANCOMMUNICATION TR.docxRunning Head COMMUNICATION TRAINING PLANCOMMUNICATION TR.docx
Running Head COMMUNICATION TRAINING PLANCOMMUNICATION TR.docxhealdkathaleen
 
Masters Thesis
Masters ThesisMasters Thesis
Masters ThesisJohn Morrison
 
1322891 634638298705391250
1322891 6346382987053912501322891 634638298705391250
1322891 634638298705391250Santosh R H Santosh
 
A Critical Review of The Future SACE Review Report
A Critical Review of The Future SACE Review Report A Critical Review of The Future SACE Review Report
A Critical Review of The Future SACE Review Report Ronglin Yao
 
How to Develop a Response to Intervention Model
How to Develop a Response to Intervention ModelHow to Develop a Response to Intervention Model
How to Develop a Response to Intervention ModelAmy Robertson
 
Perception and Expectation of Students Towards Service Quality
Perception and Expectation of Students Towards Service QualityPerception and Expectation of Students Towards Service Quality
Perception and Expectation of Students Towards Service QualityAsma Muhamad
 
A Novel Expert Evaluation Methodology Based On Fuzzy Logic
A Novel Expert Evaluation Methodology Based On Fuzzy LogicA Novel Expert Evaluation Methodology Based On Fuzzy Logic
A Novel Expert Evaluation Methodology Based On Fuzzy LogicLeslie Schulte
 
Gilbert ed7212 u10a1_final_paper
Gilbert ed7212 u10a1_final_paperGilbert ed7212 u10a1_final_paper
Gilbert ed7212 u10a1_final_paperlolafrancis
 
Adult Education For Work
Adult Education For WorkAdult Education For Work
Adult Education For Workmmingle
 
Reason For Referral, Special Education Services And...
Reason For Referral, Special Education Services And...Reason For Referral, Special Education Services And...
Reason For Referral, Special Education Services And...Diana Oliva
 
"Public to Public" Civil Service Career Pathways
"Public to Public" Civil Service Career Pathways"Public to Public" Civil Service Career Pathways
"Public to Public" Civil Service Career PathwaysDr. Jeffrey Mrizek, Ed.D, MBA
 
Lit review (Recovered)
Lit review (Recovered)Lit review (Recovered)
Lit review (Recovered)Summer Griffin
 

Similar to Education service delivery (20)

Ll credit guide
Ll credit guideLl credit guide
Ll credit guide
 
MARKETING SEGMENTATION AND PRODUCT DEFINITION 1.docx
MARKETING SEGMENTATION AND PRODUCT DEFINITION                    1.docxMARKETING SEGMENTATION AND PRODUCT DEFINITION                    1.docx
MARKETING SEGMENTATION AND PRODUCT DEFINITION 1.docx
 
Education service delivery presentation
Education service delivery   presentationEducation service delivery   presentation
Education service delivery presentation
 
Developing strategic planning in a special education service
Developing strategic planning in a special education serviceDeveloping strategic planning in a special education service
Developing strategic planning in a special education service
 
Keystone College Students’ Perceptions of Career Development and Use of Caree...
Keystone College Students’ Perceptions of Career Development and Use of Caree...Keystone College Students’ Perceptions of Career Development and Use of Caree...
Keystone College Students’ Perceptions of Career Development and Use of Caree...
 
Running Head COMMUNICATION TRAINING PLANCOMMUNICATION TR.docx
Running Head COMMUNICATION TRAINING PLANCOMMUNICATION TR.docxRunning Head COMMUNICATION TRAINING PLANCOMMUNICATION TR.docx
Running Head COMMUNICATION TRAINING PLANCOMMUNICATION TR.docx
 
Research Proposal M Torres Vargas - Chyung's comments
Research Proposal M Torres Vargas - Chyung's commentsResearch Proposal M Torres Vargas - Chyung's comments
Research Proposal M Torres Vargas - Chyung's comments
 
Running Head COMMUNICATION TRAINING PLAN1COMMUNICATION T.docx
Running Head COMMUNICATION TRAINING PLAN1COMMUNICATION T.docxRunning Head COMMUNICATION TRAINING PLAN1COMMUNICATION T.docx
Running Head COMMUNICATION TRAINING PLAN1COMMUNICATION T.docx
 
Running Head COMMUNICATION TRAINING PLANCOMMUNICATION TR.docx
Running Head COMMUNICATION TRAINING PLANCOMMUNICATION TR.docxRunning Head COMMUNICATION TRAINING PLANCOMMUNICATION TR.docx
Running Head COMMUNICATION TRAINING PLANCOMMUNICATION TR.docx
 
Masters Thesis
Masters ThesisMasters Thesis
Masters Thesis
 
1322891 634638298705391250
1322891 6346382987053912501322891 634638298705391250
1322891 634638298705391250
 
A Critical Review of The Future SACE Review Report
A Critical Review of The Future SACE Review Report A Critical Review of The Future SACE Review Report
A Critical Review of The Future SACE Review Report
 
How to Develop a Response to Intervention Model
How to Develop a Response to Intervention ModelHow to Develop a Response to Intervention Model
How to Develop a Response to Intervention Model
 
Perception and Expectation of Students Towards Service Quality
Perception and Expectation of Students Towards Service QualityPerception and Expectation of Students Towards Service Quality
Perception and Expectation of Students Towards Service Quality
 
A Novel Expert Evaluation Methodology Based On Fuzzy Logic
A Novel Expert Evaluation Methodology Based On Fuzzy LogicA Novel Expert Evaluation Methodology Based On Fuzzy Logic
A Novel Expert Evaluation Methodology Based On Fuzzy Logic
 
Gilbert ed7212 u10a1_final_paper
Gilbert ed7212 u10a1_final_paperGilbert ed7212 u10a1_final_paper
Gilbert ed7212 u10a1_final_paper
 
Adult Education For Work
Adult Education For WorkAdult Education For Work
Adult Education For Work
 
Reason For Referral, Special Education Services And...
Reason For Referral, Special Education Services And...Reason For Referral, Special Education Services And...
Reason For Referral, Special Education Services And...
 
"Public to Public" Civil Service Career Pathways
"Public to Public" Civil Service Career Pathways"Public to Public" Civil Service Career Pathways
"Public to Public" Civil Service Career Pathways
 
Lit review (Recovered)
Lit review (Recovered)Lit review (Recovered)
Lit review (Recovered)
 

More from Alejandro DomĂ­nguez Torres

La estrategia de Wile E. Coyote para atrapar al Correcaminos
La estrategia de Wile E. Coyote para atrapar al CorrecaminosLa estrategia de Wile E. Coyote para atrapar al Correcaminos
La estrategia de Wile E. Coyote para atrapar al CorrecaminosAlejandro DomĂ­nguez Torres
 
CĂłmo no crear una oficina de direcciĂłn de proyectos
CĂłmo no crear una oficina de direcciĂłn de proyectosCĂłmo no crear una oficina de direcciĂłn de proyectos
CĂłmo no crear una oficina de direcciĂłn de proyectosAlejandro DomĂ­nguez Torres
 
TeorĂ­a y tendencias actuales de la administraciĂłn
TeorĂ­a y tendencias actuales de la administraciĂłnTeorĂ­a y tendencias actuales de la administraciĂłn
TeorĂ­a y tendencias actuales de la administraciĂłnAlejandro DomĂ­nguez Torres
 
ÂżTodos los PMPs pueden ser directores de proyectos?
ÂżTodos los PMPs pueden ser directores de proyectos?ÂżTodos los PMPs pueden ser directores de proyectos?
ÂżTodos los PMPs pueden ser directores de proyectos?Alejandro DomĂ­nguez Torres
 
La profesionalizaciĂłn de la direcciĂłn de proyectos
La profesionalizaciĂłn de la direcciĂłn de proyectosLa profesionalizaciĂłn de la direcciĂłn de proyectos
La profesionalizaciĂłn de la direcciĂłn de proyectosAlejandro DomĂ­nguez Torres
 
El valor profesional y organizacional de la direcciĂłn de proyectos
El valor profesional y organizacional de la direcciĂłn de proyectosEl valor profesional y organizacional de la direcciĂłn de proyectos
El valor profesional y organizacional de la direcciĂłn de proyectosAlejandro DomĂ­nguez Torres
 
Aplicaciones de los sistemas ecuaciones a la electricidad
Aplicaciones de los sistemas ecuaciones a la electricidadAplicaciones de los sistemas ecuaciones a la electricidad
Aplicaciones de los sistemas ecuaciones a la electricidadAlejandro DomĂ­nguez Torres
 
Webminar herramientas y técnicas para planear la calidad
Webminar   herramientas y técnicas para planear la calidadWebminar   herramientas y técnicas para planear la calidad
Webminar herramientas y técnicas para planear la calidadAlejandro Domínguez Torres
 

More from Alejandro DomĂ­nguez Torres (20)

CĂłmo elegir un posgrado webinar
CĂłmo elegir un posgrado   webinarCĂłmo elegir un posgrado   webinar
CĂłmo elegir un posgrado webinar
 
La estrategia de Wile E. Coyote para atrapar al Correcaminos
La estrategia de Wile E. Coyote para atrapar al CorrecaminosLa estrategia de Wile E. Coyote para atrapar al Correcaminos
La estrategia de Wile E. Coyote para atrapar al Correcaminos
 
Problemas actuales en la educaciĂłn
Problemas actuales en la educaciĂłnProblemas actuales en la educaciĂłn
Problemas actuales en la educaciĂłn
 
Vida Después de la Universidad
Vida Después de la UniversidadVida Después de la Universidad
Vida Después de la Universidad
 
CĂłmo no crear una oficina de direcciĂłn de proyectos
CĂłmo no crear una oficina de direcciĂłn de proyectosCĂłmo no crear una oficina de direcciĂłn de proyectos
CĂłmo no crear una oficina de direcciĂłn de proyectos
 
Después de una carrera técnica
Después de una carrera técnicaDespués de una carrera técnica
Después de una carrera técnica
 
TeorĂ­a y tendencias actuales de la administraciĂłn
TeorĂ­a y tendencias actuales de la administraciĂłnTeorĂ­a y tendencias actuales de la administraciĂłn
TeorĂ­a y tendencias actuales de la administraciĂłn
 
CĂłmo conseguir empleo
CĂłmo conseguir empleoCĂłmo conseguir empleo
CĂłmo conseguir empleo
 
La vida después de la universidad
La vida después de la universidadLa vida después de la universidad
La vida después de la universidad
 
ÂżTodos los PMPs pueden ser directores de proyectos?
ÂżTodos los PMPs pueden ser directores de proyectos?ÂżTodos los PMPs pueden ser directores de proyectos?
ÂżTodos los PMPs pueden ser directores de proyectos?
 
La profesionalizaciĂłn de la direcciĂłn de proyectos
La profesionalizaciĂłn de la direcciĂłn de proyectosLa profesionalizaciĂłn de la direcciĂłn de proyectos
La profesionalizaciĂłn de la direcciĂłn de proyectos
 
El valor profesional y organizacional de la direcciĂłn de proyectos
El valor profesional y organizacional de la direcciĂłn de proyectosEl valor profesional y organizacional de la direcciĂłn de proyectos
El valor profesional y organizacional de la direcciĂłn de proyectos
 
Aplicaciones de los sistemas ecuaciones a la electricidad
Aplicaciones de los sistemas ecuaciones a la electricidadAplicaciones de los sistemas ecuaciones a la electricidad
Aplicaciones de los sistemas ecuaciones a la electricidad
 
Applications of analytic geometry
Applications of analytic geometryApplications of analytic geometry
Applications of analytic geometry
 
Plan estratégico de la calidad
Plan estratégico de la calidadPlan estratégico de la calidad
Plan estratégico de la calidad
 
Calidad en la empresa - curso
Calidad en la empresa - cursoCalidad en la empresa - curso
Calidad en la empresa - curso
 
Aplicaciones de los nĂșmeros complejos
Aplicaciones de los nĂșmeros complejosAplicaciones de los nĂșmeros complejos
Aplicaciones de los nĂșmeros complejos
 
Recursos humanos y capital humano
Recursos humanos y capital humanoRecursos humanos y capital humano
Recursos humanos y capital humano
 
Webminar herramientas y técnicas para planear la calidad
Webminar   herramientas y técnicas para planear la calidadWebminar   herramientas y técnicas para planear la calidad
Webminar herramientas y técnicas para planear la calidad
 
Webminar la elecciĂłn de una maestrĂ­a
Webminar    la elecciĂłn de una maestrĂ­aWebminar    la elecciĂłn de una maestrĂ­a
Webminar la elecciĂłn de una maestrĂ­a
 

Education service delivery

  • 1. Page 1 of 10 ZACHMAN ARCHITECTURE-BASED EDUCATION SERVICE DELIVERY 1 ALEJANDRO DOMÍNGUEZ JADOMING@MAIL.UNITEC.MX School of Postgraduate Studies Universidad TecnolĂłgica de MĂ©xico, www.unitec.mx Marina Nacional 500, Colonia AnĂĄhuac C.P. 11320, MĂ©xico City MÉXICO Keywords: Education, policies, service, Zachman architecture, 5WH scheme. ABSTRACT Education service delivery represents a challenge for any academic institution since there must satisfy academically and administratively both students and lecturers. In delivering this kind of service, academic institution personnel must have a sort of particular expertise to guarantee education excellence, otherwise service delivered would be limited to certain activities. This is not the case if expertise of institution in a particular level is either poor or null. So the main question to be answered in delivering education service is what an institution of education should do to implement, operate, monitor, supervise, and control service in order to pass from the achievement of opening requirements to satisfy students’ expectations. Answering this question also lets institution satisfy the accreditation criteria of external entities (when required) as well as standardise education service when implemented and operated in other sites. One way of proceeding to answer such a question is firstly to identify a set of functional institution areas that are directly related to service delivering. These functional areas have to be identified precisely in order to establish their participation in planning, implementing, and operating education service. As a second step, each area is fully described if it is used a 5WH scheme (What, Where, Who, When, Why, and How). This description leads to a Zachman architecture (matrix) for education service, in which rows represent functional areas and columns represent elements of the 5WH scheme. After filling each Zachman matrix cell and analysing each column as a whole it is derived a set of representative policies to deliver education service. In order to illustrate an application of method and policies so derived to a real case, an example of the corresponding policies is shown for a postgraduate education service in a Mexican private university. EDUCATION SERVICE IN PERSPECTIVE Students are and must be the main reason of being for any institution dedicated to provide education at any level. For higher education institutions this reason is vitally important since in them students are provided of knowledge, and acquire abilities and capabilities to develop successfully their professional life. Without students there is no reason for having lecturers, syllabus, courses, classrooms, laboratories, technology, and staff. On the basis of this perspective, education service must be understood as the result of the actions of the institution, and their composite functional areas, to satisfy the requirements of academic formation of its students. In order to offer this education service, an institution has to satisfy a set of preliminary requirements which depend on if the institution is either public or private based. These requirements are, in any case, related to people, information, processes, and infrastructure and technology. Once the institution has satisfied these requirements, the responsibility of implementation and operation of educative service depends on the actions of some functional areas which have a direct contact with students. Although implementation and operation are monitored, supervised, and controlled by the institution, results are 1 This paper was presented at Product and Operation Management Society – College of Service Operations Conference; London Business School; July 12-13 2007. www.poms.org/2007/03/poms_college_of_service_operat_1.html#more
  • 2. Page 2 of 10 visualised when students and alumni either promote or not education service offered. A more concrete way of visualising results of the provided education service is when the institution is subject to a self-evaluation and then to an evaluation by external certification entities. In any case, once the institution receives feed-back, it has to perform modifications and corrections recommended. In This way, the main question to be answered is: What should an institution of education do to implement, operate, monitor, supervise, and control its provided education service in order to pass from the achievement of opening requirements to satisfy students’ expectations, and consequently also satisfy the accreditation criteria of external entities? In such a situation, an answer to this question is to develop a theoretical and practical based model to deliver education service and, from it derive a set of policies in order to have a first approach to education service activities standardisation. In fact, some authors point out (Álvarez Torres, p.27) that “every institution, either conscious or not, are ruled by written or not written policies”. However in many institutions of education that set of policies do not always exist. Moreover, in some cases when these policies exist, they are not always built on a solid structure, and in another cases they are not attached to service requirements. OBJECTIVES From discussion so far, in order to deliver education service it is necessary to carry out the following objectives:  To abstract from reality and to create an appropriate model to offer education service.  To write a set of general policies to offer education service. Both model and policies derived from it acquire more value if they are put in practice for a particular case; even more, if they are easy to transfer to similar environments. Thus a third objective is:  To show an example of the corresponding policies for a postgraduate education service. A MODEL TO OFFER EDUCATION SERVICE Before defining the model to be used as a basis for enouncing education service policies, it is necessary to identify entities (people, departments or functional areas) and their corresponding responsibilities related to service. Reconsidering ideas given by John Zachman (Zachman) for education service case, in an education institution may be distinguished entities described in Table 1. Table 1. Entities for education service. ENTITY DESCRIPTION ACADEMIC PLANNING ENTITY It detects the society requirements related to education service and also defines its scope when service is on implementation and operation phases. ACADEMIC DEVELOPMENT ENTITY It conceptualises, defines, and develops education model to be put in practice when the service is on implementation and operation phases. IMPLEMENTATION ENTITY It defines the logic to offer education service when it is on implementation and operation phases. ACADEMIC COORDINATION ENTITY It defines how education service is operated in practice LECTURERS It offers directly education service and is in contact with the user of this service. STUDENTS It uses education service. Functions performed by these entities is completely established if for each one can be defined all participation aspects on education service. For it, it must define the following question indicators (Álvarez Torres p.32,
  • 3. Page 3 of 10 Zachman) given by the well known 5WH scheme: What (data), How (processes), Where (place), Who (entities, infrastructure, technology), When (time), and Why (motivation). Description of them is shown in Table 2. Table 2. Question indicators: 5WH scheme. QUESTION INDICATOR DESCRIPTION WHAT (DATA) It is data to define and understand education service requirements. HOW (PROCESSES) They are processes to translate education service requirements into more detailed implementation and operation definitions. WHERE (PLACE) It is related to physical distribution of places where education service will be implemented and operated. WHO (ENTITIES, INFRASTRUCTURE, AND TECHNOLOGY) It defines who is related to education service, and also defines infrastructure and technology required to implement and to operate it. WHEN (TIME) It describes how time perturbs education service. WHY (MOTIVATION) It translates education service strategies and objectives into specific meaning. If both entities and question indicators are arranged as a matrix where rows represent entities and columns represent questions indicators, then it is obtained a model containing information to be present in education service delivery. This is shown in Figure 1. It is important to notice that in this model (DVA-US):  Every row represents a different view of education service.  Every column is complementary to each other.  Every cell is unique and complementary to each other.  Combination of cells on a row is a complete description of each education service view. Filling cells is not an easy task and requires having a complete view of education service. If not, it may be a problem to define the required policies; in fact, it may be obtained a partial or misinterpreted set of policies. For filling cells it is invoked author expertise and ideas established in DVA-US, Hay-a y Zachman. This filling is shown in Figure 1. It is important to notice that information contained in each cell may be considered as a minimum unit of information to be used to create policies and it has the following properties:  It is common for any education service offering.  It generates new information about education service.  It is time independent.  It is replicable on other contexts with no lose of meaning. Thus, according with Richard Dawkins’ definition (Wikipedia-Meme), each cell may be considered a “meme”. Hence, model of Figure 1 allows to:  Visualise information to be integrated in the offering of education service.  Give a fine detail of responsibilities of each participating entity in the offering of education service (Hay-b).  Provide distinctive views of education service (Hay-b).
  • 4. Page 4 of 10 Figure 1. Model to offer education service. WHAT (DATA) HOW (PROCESSES) WHERE (PLACE) WHO (ENTITIES, INFRASTRUCTURE, TECHNOLOGY) WHEN (TIME) WHY (MOTIVATION) ACADEMIC PLANNING ENTITY (CONTEXTUAL MODEL) List of society requirements important to define education service List of general processes to offer education service List of places where education services will be implemented and operated List of participating and significant entities, infrastructure, and technology to offer education service List of significant events to offer education service List of objectives and strategies to offer education service ACADEMIC DEVELOPMENT ENTITY (CONCEPTUAL MODEL) Semantic model of requirements to offer education service (Programme Plan and Syllabus) Process model to offer education service Relational model among places where education service will be implemented and operated Workflow model to offer education service Event model to offer education service Plan to offer education service IMPLEMENTATION MODEL (LOGIC MODEL) List of general internal requirements to offer education service Application architecture to offer education service Distribution architecture of places where education service will be implemented and operated Interaction architecture among participants in offering education service Event architecture to offer education service Rules model to offer education service ACADEMIC COORDINATION MODEL (PHYSICAL MODEL) List of specific internal requirements to offer education service Implementation and operation navigation diagrams to offer education service Relationship diagram of places where operation service will be implemented Interaction diagram among participants in offering education service Event diagram to offer education service Rule design to offer education service LECTURERS (DETAILED MODEL) Requirements fulfil Detailed process to implement and operate syllabus components Places versus lecturer assignation List of lecturers, lab equipment, and technology Time-table Objectives of courses MEETING POINT OF EDUCATION SERVICE STUDENTS Reception and assimilation of course topics Processes to develop assignments, task, and lab practices Attend classrooms, labs, library and other facilities Interaction with classrooms, labs, library and other facilities Attend time- table Need of education service Rows in Figure 1 represent points of view of different participating entities in education service delivery, while columns represent different aspects of this delivery. The view of each entity is (Hay-b) shown in Table 3. Table 3. Views of participating entities to offer education service. ENTITY EDUCATION SERVICE VIEWS ACADEMIC PLANNING ENTITY (CONTEXTUAL MODEL) It is the strategic view of education service. It is needed to establish the context of any offering service effort. ACADEMIC DEVELOPMENT ENTITY (CONCEPTUAL MODEL) In terms of education service, this view defines the nature of service, including its structure, functions and organisation. IMPLEMENTATION ENTITY (LOGIC MODEL) It describes the conceptual model in a logic way. ACADEMIC COORDINATION MODEL (PHYSICAL MODEL) It describes how resources are to be used according to information obtained from previous models. LECTURERS (DETAILED MODEL) It translates academic programmes and relationships among them into information understood by students. STUDENTS It is the user’s view of education service.
  • 5. Page 5 of 10 POLICIES TO OFFER EDUCATION SERVICE As it was pointed out above, policies have to include information from each cell in Figure 1. However either this information is not always explicitly present on daily basis or, when present, is on a number of documents belonging to different functional areas. On the other side, it is important to notice that the responsibility at the moment of offering education service is not the same for each participating entity (see Table 1). In fact, this responsibility vanishes gradually from Lecturers to Academic Planning entities. Thus policies must be controlled by the academic authority closer to students. In this case such an entity is Academic Coordination Entity, and supervised by Implementation Entity. Since Academic Coordination agglutinates policies information and, at the same time, is responsible of implementation and operation of models derived from other entities, it is very important that the Academic Coordination Entity generates a unique manual containing these policies. Three more reasons to create this manual are:  In case there is a doubt about how to manage a problem related to education service; manual can be consulted, look on it for policy or policies related to the problem, and then apply them.  Manual can be used as a tool to behave and proceed when similar cases come out.  Manual can be used as a reference to standardise education service when implemented and operated on other locations. Of course, manual structure must have a more logical order than that of structure shown in Figure 1. In fact, in looking up policies, it is more convenient if they have an order according to implementation and operation in time of education service. Hence, columns (question indicators) must be ordered starting with Motivation (Why), and followed by Data (What), Places (Where), Time (When), Entities (Who), and then Processes (How). This order and its associated derived policies are shown in Table 4. It is important to point out that in derivation of policies associated to a same column, they have to be complementary among them and their description must be at the same level of complexity. Table 4. Question Indicators and policies. QUESTION INDICATOR ASSOCIATED SET OF POLICIES WHY (MOTIVATION) Policies related to type, mission, and vision of education service. WHAT (DATA) Policies related to public information of education service. Policies related to promotion of education service. WHERE (PLACE) Policies related to where education service is offered. WHEN (TIME) Policies related to when education service is offered. WHO (ENTITIES, INFRASTRUCTURE, AND TECHNOLOGY) Policies related to who manage academic coordination. Policies related to student candidates, and students. Policies related to lecturer candidates, and lecturers. Policies related to requirements and use of infrastructure and technology. HOW (PROCESSES) Policies related to programme management, courses and syllabus. Policies related to monitor and control of education service. Policies related to finishing education service. Policies related to other academic processes. In practice, policies must be written using a straightforward, homogeneous and plain language style. Moreover, for some of them there should be attached documents providing more information about their meaning. Of course, policies manual must contain some paragraphs containing about their context, control, and general management (Álvarez Torres). This last information is important since provides an application and use framework.
  • 6. Page 6 of 10 MODEL FEATURES Matrix obtained by crossing entities with questions indicators is known in literature as Zachman Architecture (Zachman) and it has been documented widely (AdCom, DVA-US, Hay-a, Hay-b, Zachman). There are a number of applications of it; some of them are Health Care, Municipal Government, Logistics, and Information Technology (AdCom). However, nowadays it seems there is no documented application of it to create a model to deliver education service and its associated policies. A Zachman-type architecture, like that shown in Figure 1, has many features. Some of them are (AdCom):  It communicates. It allows communication among participants related to education service.  It agglutinates. It allows making components of education service stay glued together as a whole.  It is simple. Its structure is not technical but logical: go from basic notions to detail description and use.  It is expressive. It helps communicating in a non-technical precise way complex concepts about education service.  It helps planning. It allows taking better decisions in planning education service.  It is a problem solving tool. It enables abstraction and simplification without neglecting the complexity of the education service as a whole.  It is “product” neutral. It does not depend on any methodologies or tools. Notice that these features are inherited to rows, columns, and cells. Moreover, these features allows concluding that if there is not policies to deliver education service, there may exists conflicts, misunderstandings, preferences, and restlessness inside Academic Coordination and Implementation Entities since there could be a particular interpretation of some “over-understood policies”. POLICY MANUAL EXAMPLE A simplified example of policy manual is shown on Appendix below. Such a manual was created for delivering education service on postgraduate level in a Mexican private university. Structure of this manual is shown in Table 5 (according with Table 4). An early version of it helped performing a self-assessment on postgraduate area, as well as to approve a certification evaluation performed by an external entity. Moreover, manual has been used as a reference to standardise education service when implemented and operated in other university campi. Table 5. Manual structure example: Policies to deliver postgraduate programmes. 1. Policy context 2. Policy control 2.1. Controlling functional area 2.2. Review controls 3. Policy management 3.1. Policies application functional areas 3.2. Policies purpose and scope 3.3. Policies application responsible 3.4. Distribution list 3.5. Preliminary definitions 4. Policy statements 4.1. Policies related to type, mission, and vision of postgraduate programmes 4.2. Policies related to public information of postgraduate programmes 4.3. Policies related to promotion of postgraduate programmes 4.4. Policies related to where postgraduate programmes are offered 4.5. Policies related to when postgraduate programmes are offered 4.6. Policies related to academic coordination manager 4.7. Policies related to student candidates, and students 4.8. Policies related to lecturer candidates, and lecturers 4.9. Policies related to requirements and use of infrastructure and information technology 4.10. Policies related to postgraduate programmes management, courses and syllabus 4.11. Policies related to operate, monitor and control of postgraduate programmes 4.12. Policies related to finishing postgraduate programme studies 4.13. Policies related to other academic processes
  • 7. Page 7 of 10 As usual, application of these policies has permitted to revise them, to assess them, and improve them. Particularly, policies have permitted to that Mexican university:  Acquire criteria to act in similar events occurring when offering education service.  Make easy to take decisions on recurrent events when offering education service.  Act as a self-defined entity when offering education service.  Accelerate and improve quality in activities related to education service. During implementation and use of policies, Academic Coordination Entity have adopted a disciplined attitude, and in cases where logic and reason command to take action in a different way as policies say, both entities agree what to do in such cases, always avoiding repeat similar actions to same people or entity. Finally, and in order to save space and go directly to statement of policies, example described in Appendix omits account from point 1 to point 3. CONCLUSION Delivering education service is not an easy task if there are no policies to guarantee a minimum of accomplishment. In most of cases, policies are created once that experience is gained by an education institution. However in order to gain this experience a considerable number of trials and amount of time is required. A more effective and efficient way of creating policies for education service is to derive them from a proved and documented model. Although it seems that Zachman Architecture model has not been used yet to deliver education service, it has been proved to be useful to deliver other kind of services, such as those related to information technology. Its usefulness is due to it is based on well established organisational and practical views as well as on 5WH scheme, which in turn helps describing precisely any abstract or concrete entity. Thus, as it was shown herein, using a Zachman-based model helps reducing misunderstandings and setbacks in producing a set of policies useful to delivering and standardising education service in any education institution, and particularly in those offering postgraduate programmes. REFERENCES AdCom (Administrative Computing Services). Zachman Framework Applied to Administrative Computing Services. http://apps.adcom.uci.edu/EnterpriseArch/Zachman. Visited on April 2006. Álvarez Torres, M. Manual para Elaborar Manuales de PolĂ­ticas y Procedimientos. Editorial Panorama. MĂ©xico, 2001. DVA-US (United States Department of Veteran Affairs). A Tutorial on the Zachman Framework for Enterprise Architecture. http://apps.adcom.uci.edu/EnterpriseArch/Zachman/Resources/ZachmanTutorial.ppt. Visited in april 2006. Hay-a, D. C. A Different Kind of Life Cycle: The Zachman Framework. www.essentialstrategies.com/documents/zachman2000.pdf. Visited in april 2006. Hay-b, D. C. The Zachman Framework: An Introduction. www.tdan.com/i001fe01.htm. Visited on April 2006. Wikipedia-Meme. Meme. http://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meme. Visited on April 2006. Zachman, J.A. A framework for Information Systems Architecture. IBM Systems Journal, Vol. 26, No. 3, 1987.
  • 8. Page 8 of 10 APPENDIX: POLICIES TO DELIVER POSTGRADUATE PROGRAMMES 1. POLICY CONTEXT Omitted 2. POLICY CONTROL Omitted 3. POLICY MANAGEMENT Omitted 4. POLICY STATEMENTS 4.1. POLICIES RELATED TO TYPE, MISSION, AND VISION OF POSTGRADUATE PROGRAMMES 1. All of entities (Academic Planning, Academic Development, Implementation, Academic Coordination, and Lecturers) participating in delivering postgraduate programmes must have a copy and read the document “Type, Mission, and Vision of Postgraduate Programmes” which state:  Type of Postgraduate Programmes offered by the University according to Government classification.  Mission and Vision of Postgraduate School. 2. All of entities participating in delivering postgraduate programmes must have a copy and read the document “Postgraduate Regulations Handbook”. 4.2. POLICIES RELATED TO PUBLIC INFORMATION OF POSTGRADUATE PROGRAMMES 3. There must be soft (electronic) and hard (paper) public information related to postgraduate programmes. 4. Soft information (electronic) for each postgraduate programme must be accessed from the main university Internet site. 5. Hard information (paper) for each postgraduate programme must be printed in a brochure. 6. Both soft and hard information must be coincident for each postgraduate programme. 4.3. POLICIES RELATED TO PROMOTION OF POSTGRADUATE PROGRAMMES 7. There must be a term promotion plan to offer postgraduate programmes which must be described in document “Term Promotion Plan to Postgraduate Programmes”. 8. Promotion plan must consider promotion through the following media:  Electronic mail.  Specialised periodic journal.  Newspapers.  Kiosks in fairs related to postgraduate programmes. 4.4. POLICIES RELATED TO WHERE POSTGRADUATE PROGRAMMES ARE OFFERED 9. Postgraduate programmes can only be offered in campi previously approved by the Postgraduate University Board (Academic Planning, Academic Development, Academic Director and Academic Coordinator entities) and by the Government Education Authority.
  • 9. Page 9 of 10 4.5. POLICIES RELATED TO WHEN POSTGRADUATE PROGRAMMES ARE OFFERED 10. Postgraduate programmes must be offered in time terms approved and defined by Postgraduate University Board. 4.6. POLICIES RELATED TO ACADEMIC COORDINATION MANAGER 11. Postgraduate Academic Coordination Manager must agree to requirements established in document “Postgraduate Academic Coordination Manager Job Description”. 4.7. POLICIES RELATED TO STUDENT CANDIDATES, AND STUDENTS 12. Postgraduate student candidates must fulfil requirements established in document “Criteria and Requirements to be Accepted as Postgraduate Students” 13. The registry process to a postgraduate programme must be performed without setbacks and, when needed, Academic Coordination Manager must help solving arisen problems. 14. All of postgraduate students (accepted postgraduate candidates) must have a copy and read the document “Type, Mission, and Vision of Postgraduate Programmes”. 15. All of postgraduate students must have a copy and read the document “Postgraduate Regulations Handbook”. 16. In course choosing, students must be advised by Academic Coordination Manager. 4.8. POLICIES RELATED TO LECTURER CANDIDATES, AND LECTURERS 17. All of postgraduate lecturer candidates must fulfil requirements established in document “Criteria and Requirements to be Accepted as Lecturer” 18. Academic Coordination Manager must interview with lecturer candidates. In this interview Academic Coordination Manager must:  Provide the syllabus of course to be lectured  Evaluate knowledge and attitude based on a question-answer method related to course to be lectured. Points to be addressed are o Academic status of postgraduate studies (degree obtained and university where studied). o Academic lecturing experience at postgraduate level. o General knowledge about topics of course to be lectured. o Professional experiences about topics of course to be lectured. o Knowledge and experience of new topics about course to be lectured. o Knowledge about classical and new bibliographical references about course to be lectured. o Knowledge and use of information technology related to course to be lectured. 19. Academic Coordination Manager must guarantee that each course has an assigned lecturer. 20. All of lecturers must have a copy and read the document “Type, Mission, and Vision of Postgraduate Programmes”. 21. All of lecturers must have a copy and read the document “Postgraduate Regulations Handbook”. 4.9. POLICIES RELATED TO REQUIREMENTS AND USE OF INFRASTRUCTURE AND INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY 22. Infrastructure and information technology for postgraduate programmes must hold requirements established in document “Infrastructure and Information Technology Description for Postgraduate Programmes”. 4.10. POLICIES RELATED TO POSTGRADUATE PROGRAMMES MANAGEMENT, COURSES AND SYLLABUS 23. Academic Coordination Manager must plan with lecturers the use of infrastructure and technology associated to the respective course. This planning must be aligned with objective established in each postgraduate programme as well as the course syllabus.
  • 10. Page 10 of 10 24. At the beginning of each academic period, Academic Coordination Manager must organise a welcome and induction to postgraduate programmes short session to new students, and in it there must be present Academic Director, Academic Coordination Manager, and Lecturers. 25. As part of welcome and induction session, Academic Coordination Manager must explain and deliver to students the following documents: “Induction to University”, “Induction to Postgraduate Programmes”, “Postgraduate Regulations Handbook”, and the corresponding “Programme Course Syllabus”. 26. Before the first lecture of each academic period, Academic Coordination Manager must organise a previous meeting with lecturers in order to clarify any topic about courses and other related topics. In this meeting Academic Coordination Manager must deliver to each lecturer a preliminary list of students. 27. At the first lecture of each course, Academic Coordination Manager must introduce lecturer to students. 28. At the first lecture of each course, lecturer must deliver to students a copy of topics to be covered in the course and the way they will be assessed. 4.11. POLICIES RELATED TO OPERATE, MONITOR AND CONTROL OF POSTGRADUATE PROGRAMMES 29. Academic Coordination Manager is responsible for operating, monitoring, and controlling postgraduate education service. 30. Academic Coordination Manager must monitor continuously the delivery of academic and administrative aspects of postgraduate programmes. Academic monitoring is to:  Prevent and detect any setbacks limiting performance of lecturers and students.  Propose, agree and follow course improving actions. 31. Before ending each term, Academic Coordinator Manager must invite students to assess performance of lecturers using the document “Template for Assessment of Lecturers”. 32. If a lecturer obtains a low qualification, then (s)he must not be included for lecturing next term. 4.12. POLICIES RELATED TO FINISHING POSTGRADUATE PROGRAMME STUDIES 33. If required by postgraduate programme:  Before ending postgraduate programme studies, Academic Coordination Manager must help students choosing a thesis supervisor according with thesis topic to be developed.  In developing thesis document, Academic Coordination Manager and elected student’s supervisor must assure student follows guidelines indicated in documents “Postgraduate Thesis Creation Handbook” (related to theoretical and experimental topics), “Style Guide to Creation and Presentation of Postgraduate Thesis” (related to writing aspects), and “Format Guide to Creation of Thesis” (related to format aspects).  Before ending postgraduate programme, Academic Coordination Manager must assure that all of students finish the corresponding postgraduate thesis. 34. Academic Coordination Manager must deliver to students a copy of the following document: “Requirements and Process to Obtain Postgraduate Degree”. 4.13. POLICIES RELATED TO OTHER ACADEMIC PROCESSES 35. Academic Coordination Manager and lecturers must agree other academic activities such as: conferences, publication of development and research papers, and link with professional associations and universities. ***** End of Policies *****