Turning Challenges into Opportunities:
Equity, Inclusion, and Sustainability in WASH


         Wednesday, April 25, 2012

              Conference line: +1 (712) 432-0900
                     Passcode: 663392#
Jackie Powell

 Agua para la Salud
 WASH Advocates
Presented by Jackie Powell
    Agua para la Salud
WHO ARE THE POOREST OF THE POOR?
• World Bank’s Answer: less than $1/day
• Doesn’t account for:
  • education
  • health
  • access to infrastructure
  • vulnerability
  • social exclusion
  • access to social capital
AGUA PARA LA SALUD
NEBAJ, EL QUICHE, GUATEMALA

• Indigenous Ixil
• Subsistance maize
  farmers
• Post-conflict
  communities
GEOGRAPHICAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT

•   Nebaj --- “land of
    the springs”
•   Anti-subversive
    strategies
    destroyed water
    systems in the
    1980s
•   No infrastructure
    but lots of water
SUSTAINABLE SOLUTIONS
Circuit Riders
• Organize
• Educate
• Execute
• Follow-up
EMERGING SOLUTIONS
 •   Local Government’s Role
 •   Community Associations
THANK YOU!
jpowell@WASHadvocates.org
Eric Stowe

 a child’s right
Gretchen Wallace

   Global Grassroots
WASH Sustainable Webinar Series
Women travel on
average 10-15 km /
6-9 miles
daily, spending 8+
hours collecting
water.
Girls less than 15
years old are 2
times more likely
than boys to
collect water.
Lack of safe
sanitation facilities
at schools for girls
during
menstruation leads
girls to skip
school, leading to
higher drop-out
rates
Gender Inequality in WASH Initiatives
 Women travel 10-15 km / 6-9 mi daily, spending 8+ hrs collecting
    water
   Women represent more than one half of those with no access to
    safe water
   Girls less than 15 yrs old are 2 x more likely than boys to collect
    water
   Lack of sanitation facilities at schools for girls during
    menstruation leads to missing class and dropping out
   Water collection is source of opportunistic sexual violence, a
    trigger for domestic violence and opportunity for sexual
    exploitation of the vulnerable unable to collect
   Water-borne disease contributes to infant and maternal
    mortality rates
   Women-lead fewer WASH initiatives than men
Social Impact on Women & Girls
                Mothers choose        Girls’ responsibility
                to send girls for     for water collection
                water instead of       and no sanitation
                     school            facilities at school




     Persistence of
 poverty, violence and                               Girls miss class and
  sexual exploitation.                                are more likely to
   Higher infant and                                 drop out of school
maternal mortality rates




                                        Higher risk of
                 Vulnerability of          teenage
                adult women with        pregnancy and
                the responsibility        continued
                of water collection        poverty
WASH initiatives
provide women a
sustainable source
of income
Women become
community
leaders and
iteratively solve
problems or teach
others.
Advantages of Women-led
                WASH Initiatives
 Women have knowledge of location, reliability, seasonality and quality
    of local water sources
   Women are responsible for hygiene in the home
   Women with more time can pursue other economic initiatives
   WASH initiatives provide women a sustainable source of income
   Women will protect access for the most vulnerable
   Girls with access to sanitation facilities complete more education
   Women use water access locations as educational and social service
    intervention points
   Women become community leaders, iteratively solve problems & teach
    others
   Every $1 invested in WASH yields an economic return of $3 -$34
    (WHO)
Policy Changes
 MDGs: Make explicit the critical link between women’s
  rights, wellbeing and opportunity and their access to water and
  sanitation facilities.
 UNWomen: Consider women’s access to clean water a critical
  human right that can serve as a potent lever for advancing
  women’s well-being on many other levels.
 Global NGOs and Environmental Agencies: Do not ignore the
  vested interests of women, and the knowledge base they
  represent.
 National policy: Set goals for gender equity in the
  design, management, investment and innovation around
  access, movement, utilization, conservation and treatment of
  water.
Gender Mainstreaming:
 Consideration & Inclusion of Women
 Consider different needs of and impact on women and men
 Seek gender cooperation, inclusion and fairness
 Eliminate poor and gender inequity in access by targeting low
  income areas, addressing technical and financial
  barriers, collaboration between utilities, CBOs, NGOs
 Guarantee equal opportunity for employment, capacity
  training, educational outreach, decision-making and
  management of WASH systems
 Ensure women and girls benefit economically
 Consider gender in evaluation processes, use sex disaggregrated
  monitoring data and disseminate to women
Engagement & Sustainability:
              Let Women Lead
   Use participatory development processes to engage women and girls
    separately to discuss local WASH issues and priorities
   Engage women & girls in issue diagnosis and solution development
   Provide WASH education and capacity building for self-selected
    groups of women change agents
   Make financial capital available as grants or partial microfinance
   Support women and girls in developing culturally appropriate
    evaluation metrics and carrying out impact assessments
   Incorporate metrics that measure other social impacts on women and
    girls such as violence, safety, education and economics
   Encourage use of water access points as educational and social service
    intervention points
   Build networks for mentorship & exchange, partnerships between local
    government, NGOs, private sector and local groups
Photo by Laya Madsen
                       www.globalgrassroots.org
Questions?
Thank you!
Please take a moment to complete the survey. You can
     hang up your phone while taking the survey.




  Continue the Conversation:
  www.SustainableWASH.org

Turning Challenges into Opportunities Equity, Inclusion and Sustainability in WASH

  • 1.
    Turning Challenges intoOpportunities: Equity, Inclusion, and Sustainability in WASH Wednesday, April 25, 2012 Conference line: +1 (712) 432-0900 Passcode: 663392#
  • 2.
    Jackie Powell Aguapara la Salud WASH Advocates
  • 3.
    Presented by JackiePowell Agua para la Salud
  • 4.
    WHO ARE THEPOOREST OF THE POOR? • World Bank’s Answer: less than $1/day • Doesn’t account for: • education • health • access to infrastructure • vulnerability • social exclusion • access to social capital
  • 5.
    AGUA PARA LASALUD NEBAJ, EL QUICHE, GUATEMALA • Indigenous Ixil • Subsistance maize farmers • Post-conflict communities
  • 6.
    GEOGRAPHICAL AND HISTORICALCONTEXT • Nebaj --- “land of the springs” • Anti-subversive strategies destroyed water systems in the 1980s • No infrastructure but lots of water
  • 7.
    SUSTAINABLE SOLUTIONS Circuit Riders •Organize • Educate • Execute • Follow-up
  • 8.
    EMERGING SOLUTIONS • Local Government’s Role • Community Associations
  • 9.
  • 10.
    Eric Stowe achild’s right
  • 24.
    Gretchen Wallace Global Grassroots
  • 25.
  • 26.
    Women travel on average10-15 km / 6-9 miles daily, spending 8+ hours collecting water.
  • 27.
    Girls less than15 years old are 2 times more likely than boys to collect water.
  • 28.
    Lack of safe sanitationfacilities at schools for girls during menstruation leads girls to skip school, leading to higher drop-out rates
  • 29.
    Gender Inequality inWASH Initiatives  Women travel 10-15 km / 6-9 mi daily, spending 8+ hrs collecting water  Women represent more than one half of those with no access to safe water  Girls less than 15 yrs old are 2 x more likely than boys to collect water  Lack of sanitation facilities at schools for girls during menstruation leads to missing class and dropping out  Water collection is source of opportunistic sexual violence, a trigger for domestic violence and opportunity for sexual exploitation of the vulnerable unable to collect  Water-borne disease contributes to infant and maternal mortality rates  Women-lead fewer WASH initiatives than men
  • 30.
    Social Impact onWomen & Girls Mothers choose Girls’ responsibility to send girls for for water collection water instead of and no sanitation school facilities at school Persistence of poverty, violence and Girls miss class and sexual exploitation. are more likely to Higher infant and drop out of school maternal mortality rates Higher risk of Vulnerability of teenage adult women with pregnancy and the responsibility continued of water collection poverty
  • 31.
    WASH initiatives provide womena sustainable source of income
  • 32.
    Women become community leaders and iterativelysolve problems or teach others.
  • 33.
    Advantages of Women-led WASH Initiatives  Women have knowledge of location, reliability, seasonality and quality of local water sources  Women are responsible for hygiene in the home  Women with more time can pursue other economic initiatives  WASH initiatives provide women a sustainable source of income  Women will protect access for the most vulnerable  Girls with access to sanitation facilities complete more education  Women use water access locations as educational and social service intervention points  Women become community leaders, iteratively solve problems & teach others  Every $1 invested in WASH yields an economic return of $3 -$34 (WHO)
  • 34.
    Policy Changes  MDGs:Make explicit the critical link between women’s rights, wellbeing and opportunity and their access to water and sanitation facilities.  UNWomen: Consider women’s access to clean water a critical human right that can serve as a potent lever for advancing women’s well-being on many other levels.  Global NGOs and Environmental Agencies: Do not ignore the vested interests of women, and the knowledge base they represent.  National policy: Set goals for gender equity in the design, management, investment and innovation around access, movement, utilization, conservation and treatment of water.
  • 35.
    Gender Mainstreaming: Consideration& Inclusion of Women  Consider different needs of and impact on women and men  Seek gender cooperation, inclusion and fairness  Eliminate poor and gender inequity in access by targeting low income areas, addressing technical and financial barriers, collaboration between utilities, CBOs, NGOs  Guarantee equal opportunity for employment, capacity training, educational outreach, decision-making and management of WASH systems  Ensure women and girls benefit economically  Consider gender in evaluation processes, use sex disaggregrated monitoring data and disseminate to women
  • 36.
    Engagement & Sustainability: Let Women Lead  Use participatory development processes to engage women and girls separately to discuss local WASH issues and priorities  Engage women & girls in issue diagnosis and solution development  Provide WASH education and capacity building for self-selected groups of women change agents  Make financial capital available as grants or partial microfinance  Support women and girls in developing culturally appropriate evaluation metrics and carrying out impact assessments  Incorporate metrics that measure other social impacts on women and girls such as violence, safety, education and economics  Encourage use of water access points as educational and social service intervention points  Build networks for mentorship & exchange, partnerships between local government, NGOs, private sector and local groups
  • 38.
    Photo by LayaMadsen www.globalgrassroots.org
  • 39.
  • 40.
    Thank you! Please takea moment to complete the survey. You can hang up your phone while taking the survey. Continue the Conversation: www.SustainableWASH.org

Editor's Notes

  • #6 Why are we choosing to work with this populations? Because no one else is Aren't being reached by the government
  • #7 Obstacles with working with these populations:Hard to get toHard to ID leadership in a very indigenous population
  • #8 Organize: meet with water committee, trouble-shoot issue, suggest and discuss solutionsEducate: water committee communicates plan with communityopportunity to train local masons to increase economic opportunities in the community and have future maintenance issues more quickly addressedduring the project the circuit rider presents topics to entire community: infrastructure process, contamination, health repercussions and preventions, and general maintenance and conservation of WASH systemsTrain water committee to read meters, maintain records, and collect water feesExecute: lack of funding means community provides all labor, room and board for trained masonsthe water committee also organizes this labor schedule according to norms in the communityFollow-up: The circuit rider and water committees stay in contact for any future needs or concerns
  • #9 Lack of local government support---especially difficult in Nebaj. Issues to iron out in the Association: too many players, no initial funding. However large numbers of people does create a space for requesting government support. CGAP: consultative group to assist the poorBrac: