Thinking about Digital Scholarship Martin Weller
Current characteristics What is scholarship? Doing different things or doing things differently What are the  drivers for change? What can we learn from elsewhere? Our relationship with content Identity Online environments
Clay Shirky: Cognitive surplus http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AyoNHIl-QLQ
If true, then society is changing & the same tools impact upon all aspects of scholarship
The Boyer view of scholarship Discovery Integration  Application Teaching
Main question – will the Boyer view be applicable for digital scholarship
3 characteristics of a digital scholar
 
Digital
Network
If true what does it mean for scholarly practice
No change
We do what we did before but in slightly different ways
We do different things
 
Are these new or just different ways? Michael Wesch – database of article summaries Students organising on Facebook prior to starting Students organising OU Tesco protest on Facebook Teaching culturally specific music via Skype Crowdsourcing research iSpot/DarwinTunes/InnoCentive Open courses/conferences
What about…
Heppell (2001)  “we continually make the error of subjugating technology to our present practice rather than allowing it to free us from the tyranny of past mistakes.”
Lanier  “Software sedimentation is a process whereby not only protocols, but the ideas embedded in them become mandatory. An example is the idea of the file.”
Drivers for change
Not net gen
Not some perfect storm
Possibilities for improving what we do
But don’t ignore network weather
Lessons from other sectors
Can’t control digital content People like to share New filters emerge Models based on filters break down Disintermediation http://www.flickr.com/photos/helloeno/530649757/
We are only at the beginning Don’t confuse form with function Unbundling of services Explore different models Alternatives are the killer
Content
When it is as easy to download an entire catalogue as it is one track, our relationship to content undergoes a fundamental change
Research papers Lectures/Teaching content Conferences Data Code Ideas Debate Higher education as long tail production engine
Embrace unpredictability [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=--viB3zTznA]
Identity
Identity Academic identity Distributed Personal/Professional Messier
Learning/research environments
Complexity comes from the network not the app
Your task: Design the scholar of 2030
What will they do on a daily basis? How will they conduct research? How and what will the teach? What will be the key skills they need?

Thoughts on Digital Scholarship

Editor's Notes

  • #27 But a different model applies when it becomes abundant. Talent is still scarce, but locating it is easy, distributing it is free, the content can be reproduced at zero cost. All the previous model which was based on scarcity breaks down
  • #36 The way users interact with the system and create content and communicate generates complexity, not the app itself, so better to have a simple app that fosters a community