The song is about a past relationship between the singer and someone named Tallulah. In the first verse, the singer recalls fond memories they had looking at sunsets together, but now Tallulah wants to rethink their relationship. In the following verses, the singer expresses sadness over the end of the relationship and sees Tallulah with someone new. The singer still has feelings for Tallulah and wants a second chance to win her back, though acknowledges it will be difficult. The song explores the pain of a lost love and the singer's longing to reconnect with Tallulah.