Recent Payment Card Industry Hacks
Techniques used; & possible Defense

         Muhammad Faisal Naqvi
         CISSP, CISA, ISO27K LA & MI, ISO20K I, AMBCI
         ACMA inter, MS E-Commerce (Gold)
Agenda
• MOM Analysis (Motives, Opportunities & Means)
   • International Incidents
   • Regional Incidents
• Statistics about Payment Card Industry Hacks
   • Who are the Culprits?
   • What are the Motives?
   • What are the Means?
   • Which Assets are under Attack?
• What could be Possible Defense?
International Incidents
Banking data stolen from Millions
• News Date: 04 April 2012
• Country: UK
• Means: Trojans e.g. Zeus & Spyeye to collect personal
  details
• Opportunity: Social Engineering
• Motive: Fun, curiosity, or pride ($3,800 in 20 Months)
• Source: www.theregister.co.uk
Attack on one-time-passwords on mobile
•   News Date: 15 March 2012
•   Country: USA
•   Means:
    1. Used Gozi Trojan to steal IMEI # of Account Holder
    2. Report about lost/ stolen device & new SIM request
    3. All one-time-passwords will come on new SIM
•   Opportunity: partner’s weak processes
•   Source: www.computerworld.com
Millions customers of famous Bank at
             risk NFC attack
• News Date: 23 March 2012
• Country: UK
• Means: Contactless readers in mobile phones
  to extract card data even through wallets or bags
• Opportunity:
   • Excessive card details
   • Weak merchant process
• Motive: Online Shopping
• Source: www.channel4.com
Gang of 50 steals at least $7 million
• News Date: 11 May 2012
• Country: Canada
• Means: Installing Skimmers on stolen POS Machines in
  < 1 Hr.
• Opportunity:
   • Physical Security
   • Lack of Monitoring
• Motive: $7 million
• Source: www.wired.com
111 Arrested In Identity Theft Probe
•   News Date: 10 October 2011
•   Country: USA
•   Means: bank tellers, retail workers, waiters
•   Opportunity: Weak processes
•   Motive: $13m in 16 Months
•   Source: www.bbc.co.uk



          Thermal Image showing
          sequence of keys
          pressed
Hackers Skim Customers’ Credit Cards
             via Self-Checkout
•   News Date: 7 December 2011
•   Country: USA
•   Means: Skimmers
•   Opportunity: Physical Security
•   Motive: Financial gain
•   Source: news.cnet.com
Gang Used 3D Printers for Skimmers
•   News Date: 20 September 2011
•   Country: USA
•   Means: 3D Printed Skimmers
•   Opportunity: Physical Security
•   Motive: $400,000
•   Source: krebsonsecurity.com
Adult web site breached 40,000 Cards
                     data
• News Date: 12 March 2012
• Country: USA
• Means: Server Hack
• Opportunity: ?
• Motive: 40,000 CC numbers, expiry dates, security
  codes along with user IDs, email addresses, passwords.
• Source: www.scmagazine.com
More than 10 million cards may have
            been compromised
• News Date: 30 March 2012
• Country: USA
• Means: Servers Hacked
• Opportunity: ?
• Motive: Track 2 data (card's primary account number,
  expiration date, service code, PIN and CVV number)
• Source: www.bbc.com
Gang stole $13 million in a day
• News Date: 26 August 2011
• Country: USA, Greece, Russia, Spain, Sweden,
  Ukraine, UK
• Means: Remote Access to prepaid cards database

  update cards set bal = 10000 where ccno=12345678910

• Opportunity: Stolen credentials
• Motive: $13 million
• Source: www.msnbc.msn.com
Simple URL manipulation affected over
            360,000 cards & $2.7M
• News Date: 27 June 2011
• Country: USA
• Means: script
• Opportunity: Insecure Direct Object References
  https://www.onlinebank.com/user?acct=6065
• Motive: $2.7M
• Source: www.informationweek.com
Regional Incidents
Saudi (claimed) Hackers Expose 15,000
             Israelis' Credit Cards
•   News Date: 01 January 2012
•   Country: Israel
•   Means: Sports Web Site
•   Opportunity: ?
•   Motive: Hacktivism
•   Source: www.israelnationalnews.com
•   Hacker died just after 2 days of getting Govt. Job
•   www.emirates247.com
Two hospital employees arrested on
          credit card fraud charges
•   News Date: April 10, 2012
•   Country: UAE
•   Means: Online Shopping
•   Opportunity: Visible Credit Card Information
•   Motive: Dh9,300
•   Source: gulfnews.com
Police arrest suspect for credit card
                    forgery
•   News Date: 26 April 2011
•   Country: UAE
•   Means: Expired cards, card copier, card data from web
•   Opportunity:
•   Motive: Financial
•   Source: gulfnews.com
Statistics about Payment Card Industry Hacks
 Source: 2012 Data Breach Investigation Report
Culprits




     Source: 2012 Data Breach Investigation Report
External Culprits




         Source: 2012 Data Breach Investigation Report
Internal Culprits




         Source: 2012 Data Breach Investigation Report
Motives




    Source: 2012 Data Breach Investigation Report
Means




   Source: 2012 Data Breach Investigation Report
Assets




    Source: 2012 Data Breach Investigation Report
Hacks                  Possible Defense

• Social engineering         • Automated social pen
                               testing

• Fake Online Transactions   • Balance between Business
                               & Security

• POS Skimming               • Disconnection logs
                               Bar-coded tamper evident
                               seals

• ATM Skimming               • Anti skimming solutions

• Servers/Applications/DBs   • Information Security, Pen
                               testing & Audits
Questions
faisal.naqvi@msn.com

http://ae.linkedin.com/in/mfaisalnaqvi
Thank
 You

Recent PCI Hacks

  • 1.
    Recent Payment CardIndustry Hacks Techniques used; & possible Defense Muhammad Faisal Naqvi CISSP, CISA, ISO27K LA & MI, ISO20K I, AMBCI ACMA inter, MS E-Commerce (Gold)
  • 2.
    Agenda • MOM Analysis(Motives, Opportunities & Means) • International Incidents • Regional Incidents • Statistics about Payment Card Industry Hacks • Who are the Culprits? • What are the Motives? • What are the Means? • Which Assets are under Attack? • What could be Possible Defense?
  • 3.
  • 4.
    Banking data stolenfrom Millions • News Date: 04 April 2012 • Country: UK • Means: Trojans e.g. Zeus & Spyeye to collect personal details • Opportunity: Social Engineering • Motive: Fun, curiosity, or pride ($3,800 in 20 Months) • Source: www.theregister.co.uk
  • 5.
    Attack on one-time-passwordson mobile • News Date: 15 March 2012 • Country: USA • Means: 1. Used Gozi Trojan to steal IMEI # of Account Holder 2. Report about lost/ stolen device & new SIM request 3. All one-time-passwords will come on new SIM • Opportunity: partner’s weak processes • Source: www.computerworld.com
  • 6.
    Millions customers offamous Bank at risk NFC attack • News Date: 23 March 2012 • Country: UK • Means: Contactless readers in mobile phones to extract card data even through wallets or bags • Opportunity: • Excessive card details • Weak merchant process • Motive: Online Shopping • Source: www.channel4.com
  • 7.
    Gang of 50steals at least $7 million • News Date: 11 May 2012 • Country: Canada • Means: Installing Skimmers on stolen POS Machines in < 1 Hr. • Opportunity: • Physical Security • Lack of Monitoring • Motive: $7 million • Source: www.wired.com
  • 8.
    111 Arrested InIdentity Theft Probe • News Date: 10 October 2011 • Country: USA • Means: bank tellers, retail workers, waiters • Opportunity: Weak processes • Motive: $13m in 16 Months • Source: www.bbc.co.uk Thermal Image showing sequence of keys pressed
  • 9.
    Hackers Skim Customers’Credit Cards via Self-Checkout • News Date: 7 December 2011 • Country: USA • Means: Skimmers • Opportunity: Physical Security • Motive: Financial gain • Source: news.cnet.com
  • 10.
    Gang Used 3DPrinters for Skimmers • News Date: 20 September 2011 • Country: USA • Means: 3D Printed Skimmers • Opportunity: Physical Security • Motive: $400,000 • Source: krebsonsecurity.com
  • 11.
    Adult web sitebreached 40,000 Cards data • News Date: 12 March 2012 • Country: USA • Means: Server Hack • Opportunity: ? • Motive: 40,000 CC numbers, expiry dates, security codes along with user IDs, email addresses, passwords. • Source: www.scmagazine.com
  • 12.
    More than 10million cards may have been compromised • News Date: 30 March 2012 • Country: USA • Means: Servers Hacked • Opportunity: ? • Motive: Track 2 data (card's primary account number, expiration date, service code, PIN and CVV number) • Source: www.bbc.com
  • 13.
    Gang stole $13million in a day • News Date: 26 August 2011 • Country: USA, Greece, Russia, Spain, Sweden, Ukraine, UK • Means: Remote Access to prepaid cards database update cards set bal = 10000 where ccno=12345678910 • Opportunity: Stolen credentials • Motive: $13 million • Source: www.msnbc.msn.com
  • 14.
    Simple URL manipulationaffected over 360,000 cards & $2.7M • News Date: 27 June 2011 • Country: USA • Means: script • Opportunity: Insecure Direct Object References https://www.onlinebank.com/user?acct=6065 • Motive: $2.7M • Source: www.informationweek.com
  • 16.
  • 17.
    Saudi (claimed) HackersExpose 15,000 Israelis' Credit Cards • News Date: 01 January 2012 • Country: Israel • Means: Sports Web Site • Opportunity: ? • Motive: Hacktivism • Source: www.israelnationalnews.com • Hacker died just after 2 days of getting Govt. Job • www.emirates247.com
  • 18.
    Two hospital employeesarrested on credit card fraud charges • News Date: April 10, 2012 • Country: UAE • Means: Online Shopping • Opportunity: Visible Credit Card Information • Motive: Dh9,300 • Source: gulfnews.com
  • 19.
    Police arrest suspectfor credit card forgery • News Date: 26 April 2011 • Country: UAE • Means: Expired cards, card copier, card data from web • Opportunity: • Motive: Financial • Source: gulfnews.com
  • 20.
    Statistics about PaymentCard Industry Hacks Source: 2012 Data Breach Investigation Report
  • 21.
    Culprits Source: 2012 Data Breach Investigation Report
  • 22.
    External Culprits Source: 2012 Data Breach Investigation Report
  • 23.
    Internal Culprits Source: 2012 Data Breach Investigation Report
  • 24.
    Motives Source: 2012 Data Breach Investigation Report
  • 25.
    Means Source: 2012 Data Breach Investigation Report
  • 26.
    Assets Source: 2012 Data Breach Investigation Report
  • 27.
    Hacks Possible Defense • Social engineering • Automated social pen testing • Fake Online Transactions • Balance between Business & Security • POS Skimming • Disconnection logs Bar-coded tamper evident seals • ATM Skimming • Anti skimming solutions • Servers/Applications/DBs • Information Security, Pen testing & Audits
  • 28.
  • 29.