Manchester City defeated Aston Villa 4-1 on Saturday 15th October 2011. Manchester City fans rated manager Roberto Mancini's performance an 8.2/10, the team lineup an 8.4/10, and tactics an 8.2/10. Substitutions received a 7.9/10 rating. The top 3 players Manchester City fans would have liked to start were David Silva at 33%, Samir Nasri at 20%, and Edin Dzeko at 17%. Mario Balotelli was rated Manchester City fans' star of the week at 8.4/10 while Shay Given was rated Aston Villa fans' star at 6.7/10.

1. Manchester City 4 vs 1 Aston Villa
Saturday, 15th October 2011
Manager
(Roberto Mancini): 8.2/10
Team Line up: 8.4/10
Tactics: 8.2/10
Substitutions: 7.9/10
- Players who fans would have liked to start -
1. David Silva 33%
2. Samir Nasri 20%
3. Edin Dzeko 17%

2. Manchester City 4 vs 1 Aston Villa
Saturday, 15th October 2011
HOW MAN CITY FANS RATED THEIR PLAYERS HOW ASTON VILLA FANS RATED THEIR PLAYERS
Joe Hart 8.1/10 6.7/10 Shay Given
Micah Richards 7.7/10 5.3/10 Alan Hutton
Vincent Kompany 8.3/10 5.5/10 Stephen Warnock
Joleon Lescott 7.0/10 5.8/10 Richard Dunne
Gael Clichy 7.3/10 5.1/10 Stephen Ireland
James Milner 8.2/10 5.8/10 Darren Bent
Adam Johnson 8.1/10 6.4/10 Gabriel Agbonlahor
Gareth Barry 7.3/10 5.3/10 Fabian Delph
Nigel De Jong 7.7/10 4.4/10 Emile Heskey
Yaya Toure 7.7/10 5.7/10 Stiliyan Petrov
SUBS Mario Balotelli 8.4/10 5.7/10 Ciaran Clark
SUBS
Kolo Toure 7.0/10 5.7/10 Marc Albrighton
Owen Hargreaves 6.8/10 6.0/10 Barry Bannan
David Silva 7.7/10

3. Manchester City 4 vs 1 Aston Villa
Saturday, 15th October 2011
MAN CITY FANS’ ASTON VILLA FANS’
STAR THIS WEEK STAR THIS WEEK
Mario Balotelli Shay Given
8.4/10 6.7/10
MAN CITY FANS ASTON VILLA FANS ASTON VILLA FANS MAN CITY FANS
GAVE MAN CITY GAVE MAN CITY GAVE ASTON VILLA GAVE ASTON VILLA
8.5/10 7.7/10 4.2/10 4.9/10
15% of all fans asked voted this 6% of all fans asked voted this
the week’s most entertaining game the week’s least entertaining game