MODELS of
READING
To be able to teach reading, it is important
to understand what happens when we
read.
The READING PROCESS
• Reading basically involves
transforming a text, which is a
graphic representation, into
thought, or meaning.
However, over the last thirty years,
psychologists and linguists, using a variety of
experimental techniques, have discovered
that things are much more complex.
BOTTOM-UP READING MODEL
• It is a reading model that emphasizes the
written or printed text.
• It emphasizes the ability to decode or put into
sound what is seen in the text.
• Readers derive meaning in a linear manner.
• Behaviorist based= Skills-driven
• Top Researcher Today= P.Gough
• Key features:
1. Letter name, shapes
2. Letter relationships
3. Words meaning
BOTTOM-UP
BOTTOM-UP
Materials/methods:
Drills, skills
Practice in isolation
Reader learns to decode then can attend to meaning
Each word must be recognized for meaning
BOTTOM-UP
Assessment:
Accuracy in skills, word identification
Problems:
Inability to decode
TOP-DOWN READING MODEL
• It is a model in which TOP is the higher order
mental and BOTTOM as the physical text on
the page. It is where meaning takes
precedence over structure.
TOP-DOWN
• Cognitive based=Meaning-driven
• Top Researcher= K.Goodman
• Key Features:
1. Meaning does not require 100% word
identification
2. Read, write, speak, listen
3. Meaning is important
TOP-DOWN
Materials/ Methods:
Predictable books, songs, rhymes, language experience
Assessment:
Knowledge constructed through meaning
Problems:
Lack of experience with words, text or activities
INTERACTIVE READING MODEL
• Combination of Bottom-up and Top-down
processes.
• Good readers are both good decoders and
good interpreters of the text.
INTERACTIVE
• Constructivist based=use of cueing systems
• Researcher=Tierney
• Key Features:
1. Develop skills & strategies in meaningful context
2. Word identification contributes to meaning
INTERACTIVE
Materials/ Methods:
Multiple methods text features
Spelling patterns
Authentic reasons for reading and writing
Assessment:
drives instruction
Problems:
Over reliance on either top down or bottom up method
EMERGING READING
MODELS
RUMELHART MODEL (1977)
• States that successful reading is both a
PERCEPTUAL and a COGNITIVE process.
Orthograhic knowledge
Lexical, Syntactic and Semantic
knowledge
STANOVICH MODEL (1980)
• Interactive-compensatory reading model.
• Readers who rely on both Bottom-up and
Top-down processes are depending on:
reading purpose
motivation
schema
knowledge of the subject
ANDERSON and PEARSON
SCHEMA-THEORETIC VIEW
• It focuses on the role of schemata (knowledge
stored in memory) in text comprehension.
• SCHEMA THEORY
a. relationships among components
b. role of inference
c. reliance on knowledge of the content
PEARSON and TIERNEY R/W
MODEL
• considers PRAGMATIC THEORIES which state
that: « utterance is an action ».
• CONTEXT is important.
• INTERACTIVE ROLES:
--Planner, composer, editor, monitor
MATHEWSON’s MODEL OF
ATTITUDE INFLUENCE
• attitude toward reading may be modified by a
change in reader’s goal.
• attitude has tri-componential construct:
--cognitive component
--affective component
--conative component
• Maintains that feedback may affect attitude and
motivation during the reading process.
1. Satisfaction with affect developed through
reading
2. Satisfaction with ideas developed through
reading.
3. Feeling generated during the reading process.
4. Ideas constructed from the information read.
5. How the reading affects the values, goals, and
self-concepts.
References:
http://www.learningwithjamesgentry.com/Reading%20Models.html
http://people.ucalgary.ca/~mpeglar/models.html
Thank You!

Models of Reading

  • 1.
    MODELS of READING To beable to teach reading, it is important to understand what happens when we read.
  • 2.
    The READING PROCESS •Reading basically involves transforming a text, which is a graphic representation, into thought, or meaning.
  • 3.
    However, over thelast thirty years, psychologists and linguists, using a variety of experimental techniques, have discovered that things are much more complex.
  • 4.
    BOTTOM-UP READING MODEL •It is a reading model that emphasizes the written or printed text. • It emphasizes the ability to decode or put into sound what is seen in the text. • Readers derive meaning in a linear manner.
  • 5.
    • Behaviorist based=Skills-driven • Top Researcher Today= P.Gough • Key features: 1. Letter name, shapes 2. Letter relationships 3. Words meaning BOTTOM-UP
  • 6.
    BOTTOM-UP Materials/methods: Drills, skills Practice inisolation Reader learns to decode then can attend to meaning Each word must be recognized for meaning
  • 7.
    BOTTOM-UP Assessment: Accuracy in skills,word identification Problems: Inability to decode
  • 8.
    TOP-DOWN READING MODEL •It is a model in which TOP is the higher order mental and BOTTOM as the physical text on the page. It is where meaning takes precedence over structure.
  • 9.
    TOP-DOWN • Cognitive based=Meaning-driven •Top Researcher= K.Goodman • Key Features: 1. Meaning does not require 100% word identification 2. Read, write, speak, listen 3. Meaning is important
  • 10.
    TOP-DOWN Materials/ Methods: Predictable books,songs, rhymes, language experience Assessment: Knowledge constructed through meaning Problems: Lack of experience with words, text or activities
  • 12.
    INTERACTIVE READING MODEL •Combination of Bottom-up and Top-down processes. • Good readers are both good decoders and good interpreters of the text.
  • 13.
    INTERACTIVE • Constructivist based=useof cueing systems • Researcher=Tierney • Key Features: 1. Develop skills & strategies in meaningful context 2. Word identification contributes to meaning
  • 14.
    INTERACTIVE Materials/ Methods: Multiple methodstext features Spelling patterns Authentic reasons for reading and writing Assessment: drives instruction Problems: Over reliance on either top down or bottom up method
  • 15.
  • 16.
    RUMELHART MODEL (1977) •States that successful reading is both a PERCEPTUAL and a COGNITIVE process. Orthograhic knowledge Lexical, Syntactic and Semantic knowledge
  • 17.
    STANOVICH MODEL (1980) •Interactive-compensatory reading model. • Readers who rely on both Bottom-up and Top-down processes are depending on: reading purpose motivation schema knowledge of the subject
  • 18.
    ANDERSON and PEARSON SCHEMA-THEORETICVIEW • It focuses on the role of schemata (knowledge stored in memory) in text comprehension. • SCHEMA THEORY a. relationships among components b. role of inference c. reliance on knowledge of the content
  • 19.
    PEARSON and TIERNEYR/W MODEL • considers PRAGMATIC THEORIES which state that: « utterance is an action ». • CONTEXT is important. • INTERACTIVE ROLES: --Planner, composer, editor, monitor
  • 20.
    MATHEWSON’s MODEL OF ATTITUDEINFLUENCE • attitude toward reading may be modified by a change in reader’s goal. • attitude has tri-componential construct: --cognitive component --affective component --conative component
  • 21.
    • Maintains thatfeedback may affect attitude and motivation during the reading process. 1. Satisfaction with affect developed through reading 2. Satisfaction with ideas developed through reading. 3. Feeling generated during the reading process. 4. Ideas constructed from the information read. 5. How the reading affects the values, goals, and self-concepts.
  • 22.

Editor's Notes

  • #3 It is used to be thought that this was simply a matter of combining letters in words, words into sentences and sentences into meanings.
  • #4 Several models of the reading process have been put forward to account for the experimental findings.
  • #12 Newer research seems to indicate that both elements play important parts in reading.