MEMORIA TANQUE ELEVADO

1. MEMORIA DE CALCULO TANQUE ELEVADO
PROYECTO:
“CREACION DE LOS SERVICIOS DEPORTIVOS DEL
ESTADIO MUNICIPAL EN LA LOCALIDAD DE CEBADA
LOMA DEL DISTRITO DE CHAGLLA - PROVINCIA DE
PACHITEA - DEPARTAMENTO DE HUANUCO "
1. ANTECEDENTES
El presente trabajo se realiza a solicitud de la MUNICIPALIDAD PROVINCIAL
DE PACHITEA, el cual comprende realizar el análisis y diseño del tanque elevado que
abastecerá agua para consumo humano del estadio a una población aproximada de 21
000.
2. REGLAMENTACIÓN Y NORMAS DE DISEÑO
Las normas utilizadas para el análisis y diseño son las siguientes:
⇒ NORMA E - 020 - CARGAS
⇒ NORMA E - 050 - SUELOS Y CIMENTACIÓN
⇒ NORMA E - 060 - CONCRETO ARMADO
⇒ NORMA E - 030 - DISEÑO SISMO RESISTENTE
⇒ NORMA E - 070 - ALBAÑILERÍA
⇒ NORMA E – 090 -ESTRUCTURAS METALICAS
Los estándares utilizados son:
⇒ Reglamento ACI-318-99
3. ESTRUCTURACIÓN
Como obras complementarias a la tribuna oriente y sur se tiene un tanque
elevado de concreto armado el cual tiene una capacidad de almacenamiento de
23 m3, la estructura tiene una altura de 22.38 m. conformado por cuatro
columnas de 0.40m x 0.80 m estas están unidas por seis vigas de 0.40m x 0.40m a lo
largo de toda la altura de las columnas separadas proporcionalmente, a la mitad de la
altura de las columnas se encuentra una viga pared alrededor de las cuatro
columnas de 3.0 m de altura, de un espesor de 0.20 a modo ornamental que
obedece al diseño arquitectónico. En la parte superior de las columnas se encuentra
el depósito de agua de concreto armado, y la cobertura de la misma es una cáscara
de concreto de un espesor de 7.000 cm.
Este depósito es sujetado por la cuatro columnas que a esta altura se abren
radicalmente hacia el exterior.

3. 4. CARGAS DE DISEÑO
Las cargas de diseño que han sido consideradas son las siguientes:
Carga muerta:
Peso específico del concreto armado = 2400 kg/m3
Peso específico de los tabiques = 1600 kg/m3
Peso específico del acero = 7850 kg/m3
Carga viva:
Techo = 50 kg/m2
Carga sísmica:
Según reglamento.
5. PARÁMETROS DE ANALISIS SISMICO
La norma Sismo-resistente limita los desplazamientos laterales de las estructuras por lo
que las estructuras construidas no deben superar los siguientes desplazamientos
máximos relativos.
Para Elementos de Concreto Armado (Dy/hei)< 0,70 %
Para el espectro de respuesta de aceleración, según reglamento (ZUSC/R), se ha
utilizado los parámetros sísmicos siguientes:
Parámetros de Sitio
Coeficiente de aceleración gravitacional:
G = 9,81 m/s2
1) Zonificación:
Considerando la ubicación de la Edificación dentro del Mapa de Zonificación
Sísmica, según NTE-030, el distrito de chaglla se encuentra ubicada en la Zona 2. Z
=0,40 Factor de Zona
2) Condiciones Geotécnicas
Las propiedades mecánicas del suelo, espesor del estrato, velocidad de propagación
de ondas de corte y características ubican a nuestro suelo dentro del perfil S2
(Suelo Intermedio) según el Informe Técnico elaborado por el Ing. BECQUER
ESPINOZA SAMANIEGO, con Registro del Colegio de Ingenieros Nº 143610,
en base a los Ensayos realizados por el Laboratorio de Mecánica de Suelos de
la Facultad de Ingeniería

4. Civil de la Universidad Nacional Hermilio Valdizan, para determinar la
Capacidad Portante del Terreno materia del presente Estudio.
S =1,20 Factor de Suelo (Suelo tipo 2 según EMS)
Tp=0,60
Profundidad de desplante Df= 1.80 m.
La Capacidad admisible es:
Para Zapatas Cuadradas
Factor de Seguridad
Asentamientos inmediatos esperados
Qa=1.41 kg/cm2
F.S.=4
Pi=1,30 cm.
No hay evidencias de cloruros o sulfatos.
3) Factor de Amplificación Sísmica
Corresponde al factor de amplificación de la respuesta estructural respecto a la
aceleración en el suelo.
C = 2,5 (Tp/T) => C=2,5 Factor de Amplificación Sísmica (A. Estático)
Para el Análisis Dinámico:
Tx=0,3787 seg. Periodo fundamental Sentido X
Ty=0.3787 seg. Periodo fundamental Sentido Y
4) Categoría de la Edificación
De acuerdo a la utilización de la edificación, se utilizará el coeficiente de
importancia.
U = 1.30 Factor de Uso (Edificación Categoría “B”)
Z= 0.4 U= 1.5 S=1.2 Ts=0.6seg
Y además:
El factor de reducción (R) se ha considerado igual a 7
6. PARÁMETROS ESTRUCTURALES
Para el acero se ha considerado la resistencia dada por el fabricante, y el concreto de
los elementos estructurales se ha considerado de f´c = 210 kg/cm2
Estas características se resumen en:
Acero:
Esfuerzo de Fluencia del Acero Fy = 4200 Kg/cm2
Módulo de Elasticidad del Acero Es = 2,0 x106
Kg/cm2
Concreto
Resistencia Característica del Concreto f´c = 210 Kg/cm2

5. Módulo de Elasticidad del Concreto Ec = 217370.65Kg/cm2 (=15000(f´c)0.5
)
Módulo de Corte del Concreto G = 81 195 Kg/cm2 (=Ec / (2(1+v)) )
Módulo de Poisson v = 0,15
7. ESTUDIO ESTRUCTURAL
El Análisis Estructural se ha realizado por métodos elásticos utilizando el Método de
las Rigideces y el de Los Elementos Finitos, desarrollado por procedimientos
matriciales, aplicados en el software SAP2000 (Structural Analysis Programs)
V.14.
8. SOLICITACIONES DE CARGAS SISMICAS
Análisis Sísmico
El Análisis Sísmico se ha efectuado utilizando las solicitaciones sísmicas reducidas, es
decir una fracción de la solicitación sísmica máxima elástica de acuerdo a lo estipulado
en la Norma E.030.
Peso de la Edificación
El Peso de (P) se calculó adicionando a la carga permanente un 50% de la sobrecarga o
carga viva, por tratarse de una Edificación Categoría “A” (Norma E.030).

6. 9. CARGAS APLICADAS
Detalle De Las Cargas Aplicadas En El Tanque Elevado
10. DETERMINACION DEL DESPLAZAMIENTO MAXIMO DEL TANQUE
El desplazamiento máximo es menor a la permitida en el reglamento

7. Desplazamiento Máximo

8. 11. ESSFUERZOS
Esfuerzo De Momento Flector

9. 12. DIAGRAMA DE INTERACCIÓN DE COLUMNA

11. 13. RESULTADOS.

12. SAP2000 v10.0.4
Table: Element Forces Frames,
Frame Station OutputCase CaseType P V2 V3 T M2 M3
Text m Text Text Ton Ton Ton Ton-m Ton-m Ton-m
29 0 DEAD LinStatic -19.0335 -0.0207 -2.1325 0.00834 -6.04776 -0.02605
29 1.965 DEAD LinStatic -17.5227 -0.0207 -2.1325 0.00834 -1.85735 0.01467
29 3.93 DEAD LinStatic -16.0118 -0.0207 -2.1325 0.00834 2.33306 0.05538
29 0 COMB1 Combination -34.2603 -0.0373 -3.8385 0.01501 -10.88596 -0.04688
29 1.965 COMB1 Combination -31.5408 -0.0373 -3.8385 0.01501 -3.34323 0.0264
29 3.93 COMB1 Combination -28.8212 -0.0373 -3.8385 0.01501 4.19951 0.09968
30 0 DEAD LinStatic -15.305 -0.0619 -3.229 -0.01078 -4.95645 -0.08992
30 1.34 DEAD LinStatic -14.2747 -0.0619 -3.229 -0.01078 -0.62959 -0.00695
30 2.68 DEAD LinStatic -13.2444 -0.0619 -3.229 -0.01078 3.69727 0.07603
30 0 COMB1 Combination -27.549 -0.1115 -5.8122 -0.01941 -8.9216 -0.16186
30 1.34 COMB1 Combination -25.6945 -0.1115 -5.8122 -0.01941 -1.13326 -0.0125
30 2.68 COMB1 Combination -23.8399 -0.1115 -5.8122 -0.01941 6.65509 0.13685
31 0 DEAD LinStatic -12.5376 -0.055 -2.8302 -0.00072 -3.92428 -0.0718
31 1.32 DEAD LinStatic -11.5227 -0.055 -2.8302 -0.00072 -0.18835 0.00079
31 2.64 DEAD LinStatic -10.5077 -0.055 -2.8302 -0.00072 3.54757 0.07339
31 0 COMB1 Combination -22.5677 -0.099 -5.0944 -0.0013 -7.06371 -0.12925
31 1.32 COMB1 Combination -20.7408 -0.099 -5.0944 -0.0013 -0.33904 0.00142
31 2.64 COMB1 Combination -18.9139 -0.099 -5.0944 -0.0013 6.38563 0.1321
32 0 DEAD LinStatic -9.801 -0.0567 -2.5433 0.00031 -3.32258 -0.07416
32 1.3 DEAD LinStatic -8.8014 -0.0567 -2.5433 0.00031 -0.01629 -0.00052
32 2.6 DEAD LinStatic -7.8019 -0.0567 -2.5433 0.00031 3.29001 0.07313
32 0 COMB1 Combination -17.6417 -0.102 -4.5779 0.00056 -5.98065 -0.13349
32 1.3 COMB1 Combination -15.8425 -0.102 -4.5779 0.00056 -0.02932 -0.00093
32 2.6 COMB1 Combination -14.0433 -0.102 -4.5779 0.00056 5.92201 0.13163
33 0 DEAD LinStatic -7.0951 -0.0628 -2.3353 -0.00141 -2.58811 -0.0746
33 1.175 DEAD LinStatic -6.1916 -0.0628 -2.3353 -0.00141 0.15586 -0.00082
33 2.35 DEAD LinStatic -5.2882 -0.0628 -2.3353 -0.00141 2.89984 0.07297
33 0 COMB1 Combination -12.7711 -0.113 -4.2035 -0.00254 -4.6586 -0.13428
33 1.175 COMB1 Combination -11.1449 -0.113 -4.2035 -0.00254 0.28056 -0.00147
33 2.35 COMB1 Combination -9.5187 -0.113 -4.2035 -0.00254 5.21971 0.13134
34 0 DEAD LinStatic -4.5814 -0.0624 -1.8409 0.00619 -1.83773 -0.07502
34 1.17 DEAD LinStatic -3.6818 -0.0624 -1.8409 0.00619 0.31611 -0.002
34 2.34 DEAD LinStatic -2.7822 -0.0624 -1.8409 0.00619 2.46996 0.07102
34 0 COMB1 Combination -8.2465 -0.1123 -3.3136 0.01114 -3.30792 -0.13504
34 1.17 COMB1 Combination -6.6272 -0.1123 -3.3136 0.01114 0.56901 -0.0036
34 2.34 COMB1 Combination -5.008 -0.1123 -3.3136 0.01114 4.44593 0.12784
35 0 DEAD LinStatic -2.0754 -0.1228 -1.5304 -0.01147 -0.82975 -0.07761
35 0.89 DEAD LinStatic -1.3911 -0.1228 -1.5304 -0.01147 0.53227 0.03168
35 1.78 DEAD LinStatic -0.7068 -0.1228 -1.5304 -0.01147 1.89428 0.14096
35 0 COMB1 Combination -3.7357 -0.221 -2.7546 -0.02064 -1.49356 -0.13969
35 0.89 COMB1 Combination -2.504 -0.221 -2.7546 -0.02064 0.95808 0.05702
35 1.78 COMB1 Combination -1.2722 -0.221 -2.7546 -0.02064 3.40971 0.25373
38 0 DEAD LinStatic 43.1916 5.5468 -1.25E-13 9.22E-14 -3.33E-13 19.97991
38 1.965 DEAD LinStatic 44.7025 5.5468 -1.25E-13 9.22E-14 -8.74E-14 9.08053
38 3.93 DEAD LinStatic 46.2133 5.5468 -1.25E-13 9.22E-14 1.58E-13 -1.81885
38 0 COMB1 Combination 77.7449 9.9842 -2.25E-13 1.66E-13 -5.99E-13 35.96383
38 1.965 COMB1 Combination 80.4645 9.9842 -2.25E-13 1.66E-13 -1.57E-13 16.34495
38 3.93 COMB1 Combination 83.184 9.9842 -2.25E-13 1.66E-13 2.85E-13 -3.27393
39 0 DEAD LinStatic 34.5591 3.7491 -1.69E-13 8.94E-14 -2.50E-13 6.81572
39 1.34 DEAD LinStatic 35.5894 3.7491 -1.69E-13 8.94E-14 -2.34E-14 1.79195
39 2.68 DEAD LinStatic 36.6197 3.7491 -1.69E-13 8.94E-14 2.03E-13 -3.23181
39 0 COMB1 Combination 62.2063 6.7483 -3.04E-13 1.61E-13 -4.49E-13 12.2683
39 1.34 COMB1 Combination 64.0609 6.7483 -3.04E-13 1.61E-13 -4.21E-14 3.22552
39 2.68 COMB1 Combination 65.9154 6.7483 -3.04E-13 1.61E-13 3.65E-13 -5.81726
40 0 DEAD LinStatic 24.7983 3.4948 -1.58E-13 7.99E-14 -2.12E-13 5.28546
40 1.32 DEAD LinStatic 25.8132 3.4948 -1.58E-13 7.99E-14 -2.88E-15 0.67239
40 2.64 DEAD LinStatic 26.8281 3.4948 -1.58E-13 7.99E-14 2.06E-13 -3.94069
40 0 COMB1 Combination 44.6369 6.2906 -2.85E-13 1.44E-13 -3.81E-13 9.51384
40 1.32 COMB1 Combination 46.4638 6.2906 -2.85E-13 1.44E-13 -5.19E-15 1.2103
40 2.64 COMB1 Combination 48.2906 6.2906 -2.85E-13 1.44E-13 3.70E-13 -7.09324
41 0 DEAD LinStatic 16.2012 3.12 -1.41E-13 6.22E-14 -1.70E-13 3.77541
41 1.3 DEAD LinStatic 17.2008 3.12 -1.41E-13 6.22E-14 1.30E-14 -0.28065
41 2.6 DEAD LinStatic 18.2003 3.12 -1.41E-13 6.22E-14 1.96E-13 -4.33671
41 0 COMB1 Combination 29.1622 5.6161 -2.53E-13 1.12E-13 -3.06E-13 6.79574
41 1.3 COMB1 Combination 30.9614 5.6161 -2.53E-13 1.12E-13 2.35E-14 -0.50517
41 2.6 COMB1 Combination 32.7606 5.6161 -2.53E-13 1.12E-13 3.52E-13 -7.80608
42 0 DEAD LinStatic 9.2597 2.6619 -1.01E-13 2.07E-14 -8.78E-14 2.17913
42 1.175 DEAD LinStatic 10.1631 2.6619 -1.01E-13 2.07E-14 3.09E-14 -0.94861
42 2.35 DEAD LinStatic 11.0666 2.6619 -1.01E-13 2.07E-14 1.50E-13 -4.07635
42 0 COMB1 Combination 16.6674 4.7914 -1.82E-13 3.73E-14 -1.58E-13 3.92244
42 1.175 COMB1 Combination 18.2936 4.7914 -1.82E-13 3.73E-14 5.56E-14 -1.70749
42 2.35 COMB1 Combination 19.9198 4.7914 -1.82E-13 3.73E-14 2.69E-13 -7.33743
43 0 DEAD LinStatic 4.0164 2.4967 -1.36E-14 -3.23E-14 7.34E-15 1.12206
43 1.17 DEAD LinStatic 4.916 2.4967 -1.36E-14 -3.23E-14 2.32E-14 -1.79907

13. SAP2000 v10.0.4
Table: Element Forces Frames,
Frame Station OutputCase CaseType P V2 V3 T M2 M3
Text m Text Text Ton Ton Ton Ton-m Ton-m Ton-m
43 2.34 DEAD LinStatic 5.8156 2.4967 -1.36E-14 -3.23E-14 3.91E-14 -4.7202
43 0 COMB1 Combination 7.2296 4.494 -2.44E-14 -5.81E-14 1.32E-14 2.01971
43 1.17 COMB1 Combination 8.8489 4.494 -2.44E-14 -5.81E-14 4.18E-14 -3.23833
43 2.34 COMB1 Combination 10.4681 4.494 -2.44E-14 -5.81E-14 7.03E-14 -8.49636
44 0 DEAD LinStatic 1.1998 0.5469 -3.81E-14 -7.78E-15 -2.93E-14 -1.2491
44 0.89 DEAD LinStatic 1.8841 0.5469 -3.81E-14 -7.78E-15 4.62E-15 -1.73579
44 1.78 DEAD LinStatic 2.5684 0.5469 -3.81E-14 -7.78E-15 3.86E-14 -2.22249
44 0 COMB1 Combination 2.1596 0.9843 -6.87E-14 -1.40E-14 -5.28E-14 -2.24837
44 0.89 COMB1 Combination 3.3914 0.9843 -6.87E-14 -1.40E-14 8.31E-15 -3.12443
44 1.78 COMB1 Combination 4.6231 0.9843 -6.87E-14 -1.40E-14 6.94E-14 -4.00049
45 0 DEAD LinStatic -19.0335 0.0207 -2.1325 -0.00834 -6.04776 0.02605
45 1.965 DEAD LinStatic -17.5227 0.0207 -2.1325 -0.00834 -1.85735 -0.01467
45 3.93 DEAD LinStatic -16.0118 0.0207 -2.1325 -0.00834 2.33306 -0.05538
45 0 COMB1 Combination -34.2603 0.0373 -3.8385 -0.01501 -10.88596 0.04688
45 1.965 COMB1 Combination -31.5408 0.0373 -3.8385 -0.01501 -3.34323 -0.0264
45 3.93 COMB1 Combination -28.8212 0.0373 -3.8385 -0.01501 4.19951 -0.09968
46 0 DEAD LinStatic -15.305 0.0619 -3.229 0.01078 -4.95645 0.08992
46 1.34 DEAD LinStatic -14.2747 0.0619 -3.229 0.01078 -0.62959 0.00695
46 2.68 DEAD LinStatic -13.2444 0.0619 -3.229 0.01078 3.69727 -0.07603
46 0 COMB1 Combination -27.549 0.1115 -5.8122 0.01941 -8.9216 0.16186
46 1.34 COMB1 Combination -25.6945 0.1115 -5.8122 0.01941 -1.13326 0.0125
46 2.68 COMB1 Combination -23.8399 0.1115 -5.8122 0.01941 6.65509 -0.13685
47 0 DEAD LinStatic -12.5376 0.055 -2.8302 0.00072 -3.92428 0.0718
47 1.32 DEAD LinStatic -11.5227 0.055 -2.8302 0.00072 -0.18835 -0.00079
47 2.64 DEAD LinStatic -10.5077 0.055 -2.8302 0.00072 3.54757 -0.07339
47 0 COMB1 Combination -22.5677 0.099 -5.0944 0.0013 -7.06371 0.12925
47 1.32 COMB1 Combination -20.7408 0.099 -5.0944 0.0013 -0.33904 -0.00142
47 2.64 COMB1 Combination -18.9139 0.099 -5.0944 0.0013 6.38563 -0.1321
48 0 DEAD LinStatic -9.801 0.0567 -2.5433 -0.00031 -3.32258 0.07416
48 1.3 DEAD LinStatic -8.8014 0.0567 -2.5433 -0.00031 -0.01629 0.00052
48 2.6 DEAD LinStatic -7.8019 0.0567 -2.5433 -0.00031 3.29001 -0.07313
48 0 COMB1 Combination -17.6417 0.102 -4.5779 -0.00056 -5.98065 0.13349
48 1.3 COMB1 Combination -15.8425 0.102 -4.5779 -0.00056 -0.02932 0.00093
48 2.6 COMB1 Combination -14.0433 0.102 -4.5779 -0.00056 5.92201 -0.13163
49 0 DEAD LinStatic -7.0951 0.0628 -2.3353 0.00141 -2.58811 0.0746
49 1.175 DEAD LinStatic -6.1916 0.0628 -2.3353 0.00141 0.15586 0.00082
49 2.35 DEAD LinStatic -5.2882 0.0628 -2.3353 0.00141 2.89984 -0.07297
49 0 COMB1 Combination -12.7711 0.113 -4.2035 0.00254 -4.6586 0.13428
49 1.175 COMB1 Combination -11.1449 0.113 -4.2035 0.00254 0.28056 0.00147
49 2.35 COMB1 Combination -9.5187 0.113 -4.2035 0.00254 5.21971 -0.13134
50 0 DEAD LinStatic -4.5814 0.0624 -1.8409 -0.00619 -1.83773 0.07502
50 1.17 DEAD LinStatic -3.6818 0.0624 -1.8409 -0.00619 0.31611 0.002
50 2.34 DEAD LinStatic -2.7822 0.0624 -1.8409 -0.00619 2.46996 -0.07102
50 0 COMB1 Combination -8.2465 0.1123 -3.3136 -0.01114 -3.30792 0.13504
50 1.17 COMB1 Combination -6.6272 0.1123 -3.3136 -0.01114 0.56901 0.0036
50 2.34 COMB1 Combination -5.008 0.1123 -3.3136 -0.01114 4.44593 -0.12784
51 0 DEAD LinStatic -2.0754 0.1228 -1.5304 0.01147 -0.82975 0.07761
51 0.89 DEAD LinStatic -1.3911 0.1228 -1.5304 0.01147 0.53227 -0.03168
51 1.78 DEAD LinStatic -0.7068 0.1228 -1.5304 0.01147 1.89428 -0.14096
51 0 COMB1 Combination -3.7357 0.221 -2.7546 0.02064 -1.49356 0.13969
51 0.89 COMB1 Combination -2.504 0.221 -2.7546 0.02064 0.95808 -0.05702
51 1.78 COMB1 Combination -1.2722 0.221 -2.7546 0.02064 3.40971 -0.25373
52 0 DEAD LinStatic -81.2587 5.5882 -2.51E-14 9.17E-14 -9.73E-14 20.032
52 1.965 DEAD LinStatic -79.7478 5.5882 -2.51E-14 9.17E-14 -4.80E-14 9.05119
52 3.93 DEAD LinStatic -78.237 5.5882 -2.51E-14 9.17E-14 1.37E-15 -1.92961
52 0 COMB1 Combination -146.2656 10.0588 -4.52E-14 1.65E-13 -1.75E-13 36.0576
52 1.965 COMB1 Combination -143.5461 10.0588 -4.52E-14 1.65E-13 -8.63E-14 16.29215
52 3.93 COMB1 Combination -140.8265 10.0588 -4.52E-14 1.65E-13 2.47E-15 -3.4733
53 0 DEAD LinStatic -65.1691 3.8729 -7.10E-14 9.05E-14 -1.25E-13 6.99556
53 1.34 DEAD LinStatic -64.1388 3.8729 -7.10E-14 9.05E-14 -3.01E-14 1.80585
53 2.68 DEAD LinStatic -63.1085 3.8729 -7.10E-14 9.05E-14 6.51E-14 -3.38387
53 0 COMB1 Combination -117.3044 6.9713 -1.28E-13 1.63E-13 -2.26E-13 12.59201
53 1.34 COMB1 Combination -115.4498 6.9713 -1.28E-13 1.63E-13 -5.42E-14 3.25053
53 2.68 COMB1 Combination -113.5953 6.9713 -1.28E-13 1.63E-13 1.17E-13 -6.09096
54 0 DEAD LinStatic -49.8735 3.6047 -7.14E-14 7.93E-14 -1.04E-13 5.42907
54 1.32 DEAD LinStatic -48.8586 3.6047 -7.14E-14 7.93E-14 -9.34E-15 0.6708
54 2.64 DEAD LinStatic -47.8436 3.6047 -7.14E-14 7.93E-14 8.49E-14 -4.08746
54 0 COMB1 Combination -89.7723 6.4885 -1.29E-13 1.43E-13 -1.87E-13 9.77233
54 1.32 COMB1 Combination -87.9454 6.4885 -1.29E-13 1.43E-13 -1.68E-14 1.20745
54 2.64 COMB1 Combination -86.1185 6.4885 -1.29E-13 1.43E-13 1.53E-13 -7.35743
55 0 DEAD LinStatic -35.8032 3.2333 -5.60E-14 5.91E-14 -7.57E-14 3.92373
55 1.3 DEAD LinStatic -34.8036 3.2333 -5.60E-14 5.91E-14 -2.90E-15 -0.27962
55 2.6 DEAD LinStatic -33.804 3.2333 -5.60E-14 5.91E-14 6.99E-14 -4.48297
55 0 COMB1 Combination -64.4457 5.82 -1.01E-13 1.06E-13 -1.36E-13 7.06272
55 1.3 COMB1 Combination -62.6465 5.82 -1.01E-13 1.06E-13 -5.21E-15 -0.50331

14. SAP2000 v10.0.4
Table: Element Forces Frames,
Frame Station OutputCase CaseType P V2 V3 T M2 M3
Text m Text Text Ton Ton Ton Ton-m Ton-m Ton-m
55 2.6 COMB1 Combination -60.8473 5.82 -1.01E-13 1.06E-13 1.26E-13 -8.06935
56 0 DEAD LinStatic -23.4498 2.7875 -5.79E-14 2.36E-14 -8.05E-14 2.32833
56 1.175 DEAD LinStatic -22.5464 2.7875 -5.79E-14 2.36E-14 -1.25E-14 -0.94698
56 2.35 DEAD LinStatic -21.6429 2.7875 -5.79E-14 2.36E-14 5.56E-14 -4.22229
56 0 COMB1 Combination -42.2096 5.0175 -1.04E-13 4.25E-14 -1.45E-13 4.191
56 1.175 COMB1 Combination -40.5834 5.0175 -1.04E-13 4.25E-14 -2.25E-14 -1.70456
56 2.35 COMB1 Combination -38.9573 5.0175 -1.04E-13 4.25E-14 1.00E-13 -7.60012
57 0 DEAD LinStatic -13.1792 2.6215 -1.20E-13 -3.41E-14 -1.29E-13 1.2721
57 1.17 DEAD LinStatic -12.2796 2.6215 -1.20E-13 -3.41E-14 1.07E-14 -1.79507
57 2.34 DEAD LinStatic -11.38 2.6215 -1.20E-13 -3.41E-14 1.51E-13 -4.86224
57 0 COMB1 Combination -23.7226 4.7187 -2.15E-13 -6.14E-14 -2.33E-13 2.28979
57 1.17 COMB1 Combination -22.1033 4.7187 -2.15E-13 -6.14E-14 1.93E-14 -3.23113
57 2.34 COMB1 Combination -20.4841 4.7187 -2.15E-13 -6.14E-14 2.71E-13 -8.75204
58 0 DEAD LinStatic -5.3506 0.7924 -1.57E-14 -4.84E-15 2.01E-14 -1.09389
58 0.89 DEAD LinStatic -4.6663 0.7924 -1.57E-14 -4.84E-15 3.40E-14 -1.79915
58 1.78 DEAD LinStatic -3.982 0.7924 -1.57E-14 -4.84E-15 4.80E-14 -2.50441
58 0 COMB1 Combination -9.6311 1.4264 -2.82E-14 -8.72E-15 3.62E-14 -1.96899
58 0.89 COMB1 Combination -8.3993 1.4264 -2.82E-14 -8.72E-15 6.13E-14 -3.23847
58 1.78 COMB1 Combination -7.1676 1.4264 -2.82E-14 -8.72E-15 8.64E-14 -4.50794
59 0 DEAD LinStatic 1.0189 -6.5339 -0.0189 0.21773 -0.00956 -5.47493
59 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic 1.0189 -6.3572 -0.0189 0.21773 -0.00089 -2.51242
59 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic 1.0189 -6.1805 -0.0189 0.21773 0.00779 0.36888
59 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic 1.0189 -6.0038 -0.0189 0.21773 0.01646 3.16897
59 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic 1.0189 -5.8271 -0.0189 0.21773 0.02513 5.88784
59 0 COMB1 Combination 1.8341 -11.7611 -0.034 0.39191 -0.01721 -9.85487
59 0.45962 COMB1 Combination 1.8341 -11.443 -0.034 0.39191 -0.0016 -4.52235
59 0.91924 COMB1 Combination 1.8341 -11.125 -0.034 0.39191 0.01402 0.66399
59 1.37886 COMB1 Combination 1.8341 -10.8069 -0.034 0.39191 0.02963 5.70414
59 1.83848 COMB1 Combination 1.8341 -10.4888 -0.034 0.39191 0.04524 10.59811
60 0 DEAD LinStatic 1.0189 5.8271 0.0189 -0.21773 0.02513 5.88784
60 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic 1.0189 6.0038 0.0189 -0.21773 0.01646 3.16897
60 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic 1.0189 6.1805 0.0189 -0.21773 0.00779 0.36888
60 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic 1.0189 6.3572 0.0189 -0.21773 -0.00089 -2.51242
60 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic 1.0189 6.5339 0.0189 -0.21773 -0.00956 -5.47493
60 0 COMB1 Combination 1.8341 10.4888 0.034 -0.39191 0.04524 10.59811
60 0.45962 COMB1 Combination 1.8341 10.8069 0.034 -0.39191 0.02963 5.70414
60 0.91924 COMB1 Combination 1.8341 11.125 0.034 -0.39191 0.01402 0.66399
60 1.37886 COMB1 Combination 1.8341 11.443 0.034 -0.39191 -0.0016 -4.52235
60 1.83848 COMB1 Combination 1.8341 11.7611 0.034 -0.39191 -0.01721 -9.85487
61 0 DEAD LinStatic -0.9607 5.8271 0.0189 -0.21773 0.00956 5.26944
61 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic -0.9607 6.0038 0.0189 -0.21773 0.00089 2.55057
61 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic -0.9607 6.1805 0.0189 -0.21773 -0.00779 -0.24951
61 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic -0.9607 6.3572 0.0189 -0.21773 -0.01646 -3.13081
61 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic -0.9607 6.5339 0.0189 -0.21773 -0.02513 -6.09332
61 0 COMB1 Combination -1.7292 10.4888 0.034 -0.39191 0.01721 9.485
61 0.45962 COMB1 Combination -1.7292 10.8069 0.034 -0.39191 0.0016 4.59103
61 0.91924 COMB1 Combination -1.7292 11.125 0.034 -0.39191 -0.01402 -0.44912
61 1.37886 COMB1 Combination -1.7292 11.443 0.034 -0.39191 -0.02963 -5.63546
61 1.83848 COMB1 Combination -1.7292 11.7611 0.034 -0.39191 -0.04524 -10.96798
62 0 DEAD LinStatic -0.9607 -6.5339 -0.0189 0.21773 -0.02513 -6.09332
62 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic -0.9607 -6.3572 -0.0189 0.21773 -0.01646 -3.13081
62 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic -0.9607 -6.1805 -0.0189 0.21773 -0.00779 -0.24951
62 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic -0.9607 -6.0038 -0.0189 0.21773 0.00089 2.55057
62 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic -0.9607 -5.8271 -0.0189 0.21773 0.00956 5.26944
62 0 COMB1 Combination -1.7292 -11.7611 -0.034 0.39191 -0.04524 -10.96798
62 0.45962 COMB1 Combination -1.7292 -11.443 -0.034 0.39191 -0.02963 -5.63546
62 0.91924 COMB1 Combination -1.7292 -11.125 -0.034 0.39191 -0.01402 -0.44912
62 1.37886 COMB1 Combination -1.7292 -10.8069 -0.034 0.39191 0.0016 4.59103
62 1.83848 COMB1 Combination -1.7292 -10.4888 -0.034 0.39191 0.01721 9.485
63 0 DEAD LinStatic -0.049 -6.6175 0.0045 0.15245 0.00503 -5.64624
63 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic -0.049 -6.4408 0.0045 0.15245 0.00297 -2.64531
63 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic -0.049 -6.2641 0.0045 0.15245 0.00092 0.27439
63 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic -0.049 -6.0874 0.0045 0.15245 -0.00114 3.11289
63 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic -0.049 -5.9107 0.0045 0.15245 -0.0032 5.87017
63 0 COMB1 Combination -0.0883 -11.9115 0.0081 0.27441 0.00905 -10.16323
63 0.45962 COMB1 Combination -0.0883 -11.5934 0.0081 0.27441 0.00535 -4.76157
63 0.91924 COMB1 Combination -0.0883 -11.2754 0.0081 0.27441 0.00165 0.49391
63 1.37886 COMB1 Combination -0.0883 -10.9573 0.0081 0.27441 -0.00205 5.6032
63 1.83848 COMB1 Combination -0.0883 -10.6393 0.0081 0.27441 -0.00575 10.56631
64 0 DEAD LinStatic -0.049 5.9107 -0.0045 -0.15245 -0.0032 5.87017
64 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic -0.049 6.0874 -0.0045 -0.15245 -0.00114 3.11289
64 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic -0.049 6.2641 -0.0045 -0.15245 0.00092 0.27439
64 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic -0.049 6.4408 -0.0045 -0.15245 0.00297 -2.64531
64 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic -0.049 6.6175 -0.0045 -0.15245 0.00503 -5.64624
64 0 COMB1 Combination -0.0883 10.6393 -0.0081 -0.27441 -0.00575 10.56631

15. SAP2000 v10.0.4
Table: Element Forces Frames,
Frame Station OutputCase CaseType P V2 V3 T M2 M3
Text m Text Text Ton Ton Ton Ton-m Ton-m Ton-m
64 0.45962 COMB1 Combination -0.0883 10.9573 -0.0081 -0.27441 -0.00205 5.6032
64 0.91924 COMB1 Combination -0.0883 11.2754 -0.0081 -0.27441 0.00165 0.49391
64 1.37886 COMB1 Combination -0.0883 11.5934 -0.0081 -0.27441 0.00535 -4.76157
64 1.83848 COMB1 Combination -0.0883 11.9115 -0.0081 -0.27441 0.00905 -10.16323
65 0 DEAD LinStatic 0.0392 5.9107 -0.0045 -0.15245 -0.00503 5.43717
65 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic 0.0392 6.0874 -0.0045 -0.15245 -0.00297 2.67989
65 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic 0.0392 6.2641 -0.0045 -0.15245 -0.00092 -0.1586
65 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic 0.0392 6.4408 -0.0045 -0.15245 0.00114 -3.07831
65 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic 0.0392 6.6175 -0.0045 -0.15245 0.0032 -6.07924
65 0 COMB1 Combination 0.0706 10.6393 -0.0081 -0.27441 -0.00905 9.78691
65 0.45962 COMB1 Combination 0.0706 10.9573 -0.0081 -0.27441 -0.00535 4.8238
65 0.91924 COMB1 Combination 0.0706 11.2754 -0.0081 -0.27441 -0.00165 -0.28549
65 1.37886 COMB1 Combination 0.0706 11.5934 -0.0081 -0.27441 0.00205 -5.54096
65 1.83848 COMB1 Combination 0.0706 11.9115 -0.0081 -0.27441 0.00575 -10.94263
66 0 DEAD LinStatic 0.0392 -6.6175 0.0045 0.15245 0.0032 -6.07924
66 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic 0.0392 -6.4408 0.0045 0.15245 0.00114 -3.07831
66 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic 0.0392 -6.2641 0.0045 0.15245 -0.00092 -0.1586
66 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic 0.0392 -6.0874 0.0045 0.15245 -0.00297 2.67989
66 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic 0.0392 -5.9107 0.0045 0.15245 -0.00503 5.43717
66 0 COMB1 Combination 0.0706 -11.9115 0.0081 0.27441 0.00575 -10.94263
66 0.45962 COMB1 Combination 0.0706 -11.5934 0.0081 0.27441 0.00205 -5.54096
66 0.91924 COMB1 Combination 0.0706 -11.2754 0.0081 0.27441 -0.00165 -0.28549
66 1.37886 COMB1 Combination 0.0706 -10.9573 0.0081 0.27441 -0.00535 4.8238
66 1.83848 COMB1 Combination 0.0706 -10.6393 0.0081 0.27441 -0.00905 9.78691
67 0 DEAD LinStatic 0.0317 -6.0202 5.87E-05 0.14514 0.00052 -5.1074
67 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic 0.0317 -5.8435 5.87E-05 0.14514 0.00049 -2.38099
67 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic 0.0317 -5.6668 5.87E-05 0.14514 0.00046 0.26421
67 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic 0.0317 -5.4901 5.87E-05 0.14514 0.00044 2.8282
67 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic 0.0317 -5.3135 5.87E-05 0.14514 0.00041 5.31097
67 0 COMB1 Combination 0.057 -10.8364 1.06E-04 0.26125 0.00093 -9.19332
67 0.45962 COMB1 Combination 0.057 -10.5184 1.06E-04 0.26125 0.00088 -4.28578
67 0.91924 COMB1 Combination 0.057 -10.2003 1.06E-04 0.26125 0.00083 0.47558
67 1.37886 COMB1 Combination 0.057 -9.8823 1.06E-04 0.26125 0.00078 5.09075
67 1.83848 COMB1 Combination 0.057 -9.5642 1.06E-04 0.26125 0.00074 9.55974
68 0 DEAD LinStatic 0.0317 5.3135 -5.87E-05 -0.14514 0.00041 5.31097
68 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic 0.0317 5.4901 -5.87E-05 -0.14514 0.00044 2.8282
68 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic 0.0317 5.6668 -5.87E-05 -0.14514 0.00046 0.26421
68 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic 0.0317 5.8435 -5.87E-05 -0.14514 0.00049 -2.38099
68 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic 0.0317 6.0202 -5.87E-05 -0.14514 0.00052 -5.1074
68 0 COMB1 Combination 0.057 9.5642 -1.06E-04 -0.26125 0.00074 9.55974
68 0.45962 COMB1 Combination 0.057 9.8823 -1.06E-04 -0.26125 0.00078 5.09075
68 0.91924 COMB1 Combination 0.057 10.2003 -1.06E-04 -0.26125 0.00083 0.47558
68 1.37886 COMB1 Combination 0.057 10.5184 -1.06E-04 -0.26125 0.00088 -4.28578
68 1.83848 COMB1 Combination 0.057 10.8364 -1.06E-04 -0.26125 0.00093 -9.19332
69 0 DEAD LinStatic -0.0293 5.3135 -5.87E-05 -0.14514 -0.00052 4.89874
69 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic -0.0293 5.4901 -5.87E-05 -0.14514 -0.00049 2.41597
69 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic -0.0293 5.6668 -5.87E-05 -0.14514 -0.00046 -0.14802
69 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic -0.0293 5.8435 -5.87E-05 -0.14514 -0.00044 -2.79322
69 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic -0.0293 6.0202 -5.87E-05 -0.14514 -0.00041 -5.51963
69 0 COMB1 Combination -0.0528 9.5642 -1.06E-04 -0.26125 -0.00093 8.81773
69 0.45962 COMB1 Combination -0.0528 9.8823 -1.06E-04 -0.26125 -0.00088 4.34874
69 0.91924 COMB1 Combination -0.0528 10.2003 -1.06E-04 -0.26125 -0.00083 -0.26643
69 1.37886 COMB1 Combination -0.0528 10.5184 -1.06E-04 -0.26125 -0.00078 -5.02779
69 1.83848 COMB1 Combination -0.0528 10.8364 -1.06E-04 -0.26125 -0.00074 -9.93534
70 0 DEAD LinStatic -0.0293 -6.0202 5.87E-05 0.14514 -0.00041 -5.51963
70 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic -0.0293 -5.8435 5.87E-05 0.14514 -0.00044 -2.79322
70 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic -0.0293 -5.6668 5.87E-05 0.14514 -0.00046 -0.14802
70 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic -0.0293 -5.4901 5.87E-05 0.14514 -0.00049 2.41597
70 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic -0.0293 -5.3135 5.87E-05 0.14514 -0.00052 4.89874
70 0 COMB1 Combination -0.0528 -10.8364 1.06E-04 0.26125 -0.00074 -9.93534
70 0.45962 COMB1 Combination -0.0528 -10.5184 1.06E-04 0.26125 -0.00078 -5.02779
70 0.91924 COMB1 Combination -0.0528 -10.2003 1.06E-04 0.26125 -0.00083 -0.26643
70 1.37886 COMB1 Combination -0.0528 -9.8823 1.06E-04 0.26125 -0.00088 4.34874
70 1.83848 COMB1 Combination -0.0528 -9.5642 1.06E-04 0.26125 -0.00093 8.81773
71 0 DEAD LinStatic 0.089 -5.1771 -0.0016 0.11475 -0.00086 -4.37566
71 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic 0.089 -5.0004 -0.0016 0.11475 -0.0001 -2.03676
71 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic 0.089 -4.8237 -0.0016 0.11475 0.00065 0.22092
71 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic 0.089 -4.647 -0.0016 0.11475 0.00141 2.39739
71 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic 0.089 -4.4703 -0.0016 0.11475 0.00217 4.49265
71 0 COMB1 Combination 0.1601 -9.3188 -0.003 0.20654 -0.00155 -7.8762
71 0.45962 COMB1 Combination 0.1601 -9.0008 -0.003 0.20654 -0.00019 -3.66618
71 0.91924 COMB1 Combination 0.1601 -8.6827 -0.003 0.20654 0.00118 0.39766
71 1.37886 COMB1 Combination 0.1601 -8.3647 -0.003 0.20654 0.00254 4.31531
71 1.83848 COMB1 Combination 0.1601 -8.0466 -0.003 0.20654 0.0039 8.08677
72 0 DEAD LinStatic 0.089 4.4703 0.0016 -0.11475 0.00217 4.49265

16. SAP2000 v10.0.4
Table: Element Forces Frames,
Frame Station OutputCase CaseType P V2 V3 T M2 M3
Text m Text Text Ton Ton Ton Ton-m Ton-m Ton-m
72 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic 0.089 4.647 0.0016 -0.11475 0.00141 2.39739
72 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic 0.089 4.8237 0.0016 -0.11475 0.00065 0.22092
72 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic 0.089 5.0004 0.0016 -0.11475 -0.0001 -2.03676
72 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic 0.089 5.1771 0.0016 -0.11475 -0.00086 -4.37566
72 0 COMB1 Combination 0.1601 8.0466 0.003 -0.20654 0.0039 8.08677
72 0.45962 COMB1 Combination 0.1601 8.3647 0.003 -0.20654 0.00254 4.31531
72 0.91924 COMB1 Combination 0.1601 8.6827 0.003 -0.20654 0.00118 0.39766
72 1.37886 COMB1 Combination 0.1601 9.0008 0.003 -0.20654 -0.00019 -3.66618
72 1.83848 COMB1 Combination 0.1601 9.3188 0.003 -0.20654 -0.00155 -7.8762
73 0 DEAD LinStatic -0.0803 4.4703 0.0016 -0.11475 0.00086 4.16674
73 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic -0.0803 4.647 0.0016 -0.11475 0.0001 2.07148
73 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic -0.0803 4.8237 0.0016 -0.11475 -0.00065 -0.10499
73 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic -0.0803 5.0004 0.0016 -0.11475 -0.00141 -2.36267
73 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic -0.0803 5.1771 0.0016 -0.11475 -0.00217 -4.70157
73 0 COMB1 Combination -0.1445 8.0466 0.003 -0.20654 0.00155 7.50014
73 0.45962 COMB1 Combination -0.1445 8.3647 0.003 -0.20654 0.00019 3.72867
73 0.91924 COMB1 Combination -0.1445 8.6827 0.003 -0.20654 -0.00118 -0.18898
73 1.37886 COMB1 Combination -0.1445 9.0008 0.003 -0.20654 -0.00254 -4.25281
73 1.83848 COMB1 Combination -0.1445 9.3188 0.003 -0.20654 -0.0039 -8.46283
74 0 DEAD LinStatic -0.0803 -5.1771 -0.0016 0.11475 -0.00217 -4.70157
74 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic -0.0803 -5.0004 -0.0016 0.11475 -0.00141 -2.36267
74 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic -0.0803 -4.8237 -0.0016 0.11475 -0.00065 -0.10499
74 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic -0.0803 -4.647 -0.0016 0.11475 0.0001 2.07148
74 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic -0.0803 -4.4703 -0.0016 0.11475 0.00086 4.16674
74 0 COMB1 Combination -0.1445 -9.3188 -0.003 0.20654 -0.0039 -8.46283
74 0.45962 COMB1 Combination -0.1445 -9.0008 -0.003 0.20654 -0.00254 -4.25281
74 0.91924 COMB1 Combination -0.1445 -8.6827 -0.003 0.20654 -0.00118 -0.18898
74 1.37886 COMB1 Combination -0.1445 -8.3647 -0.003 0.20654 0.00019 3.72867
74 1.83848 COMB1 Combination -0.1445 -8.0466 -0.003 0.20654 0.00155 7.50014
75 0 DEAD LinStatic -0.1122 -4.2318 0.0043 0.08894 0.0038 -3.54356
75 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic -0.1122 -4.0551 0.0043 0.08894 0.00183 -1.63913
75 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic -0.1122 -3.8785 0.0043 0.08894 -0.00013 0.18409
75 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic -0.1122 -3.7018 0.0043 0.08894 -0.0021 1.9261
75 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic -0.1122 -3.5251 0.0043 0.08894 -0.00407 3.58689
75 0 COMB1 Combination -0.202 -7.6173 0.0077 0.1601 0.00684 -6.3784
75 0.45962 COMB1 Combination -0.202 -7.2993 0.0077 0.1601 0.0033 -2.95043
75 0.91924 COMB1 Combination -0.202 -6.9812 0.0077 0.1601 -0.00024 0.33137
75 1.37886 COMB1 Combination -0.202 -6.6632 0.0077 0.1601 -0.00378 3.46698
75 1.83848 COMB1 Combination -0.202 -6.3451 0.0077 0.1601 -0.00732 6.4564
76 0 DEAD LinStatic -0.1122 3.5251 -0.0043 -0.08894 -0.00407 3.58689
76 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic -0.1122 3.7018 -0.0043 -0.08894 -0.0021 1.9261
76 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic -0.1122 3.8785 -0.0043 -0.08894 -0.00013 0.18409
76 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic -0.1122 4.0551 -0.0043 -0.08894 0.00183 -1.63913
76 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic -0.1122 4.2318 -0.0043 -0.08894 0.0038 -3.54356
76 0 COMB1 Combination -0.202 6.3451 -0.0077 -0.1601 -0.00732 6.4564
76 0.45962 COMB1 Combination -0.202 6.6632 -0.0077 -0.1601 -0.00378 3.46698
76 0.91924 COMB1 Combination -0.202 6.9812 -0.0077 -0.1601 -0.00024 0.33137
76 1.37886 COMB1 Combination -0.202 7.2993 -0.0077 -0.1601 0.0033 -2.95043
76 1.83848 COMB1 Combination -0.202 7.6173 -0.0077 -0.1601 0.00684 -6.3784
77 0 DEAD LinStatic 0.1117 3.5251 -0.0043 -0.08894 -0.0038 3.33427
77 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic 0.1117 3.7018 -0.0043 -0.08894 -0.00183 1.67348
77 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic 0.1117 3.8785 -0.0043 -0.08894 0.00013 -0.06853
77 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic 0.1117 4.0551 -0.0043 -0.08894 0.0021 -1.89175
77 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic 0.1117 4.2318 -0.0043 -0.08894 0.00407 -3.79618
77 0 COMB1 Combination 0.2011 6.3451 -0.0077 -0.1601 -0.00684 6.00168
77 0.45962 COMB1 Combination 0.2011 6.6632 -0.0077 -0.1601 -0.0033 3.01226
77 0.91924 COMB1 Combination 0.2011 6.9812 -0.0077 -0.1601 0.00024 -0.12335
77 1.37886 COMB1 Combination 0.2011 7.2993 -0.0077 -0.1601 0.00378 -3.40514
77 1.83848 COMB1 Combination 0.2011 7.6173 -0.0077 -0.1601 0.00732 -6.83312
78 0 DEAD LinStatic 0.1117 -4.2318 0.0043 0.08894 0.00407 -3.79618
78 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic 0.1117 -4.0551 0.0043 0.08894 0.0021 -1.89175
78 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic 0.1117 -3.8785 0.0043 0.08894 0.00013 -0.06853
78 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic 0.1117 -3.7018 0.0043 0.08894 -0.00183 1.67348
78 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic 0.1117 -3.5251 0.0043 0.08894 -0.0038 3.33427
78 0 COMB1 Combination 0.2011 -7.6173 0.0077 0.1601 0.00732 -6.83312
78 0.45962 COMB1 Combination 0.2011 -7.2993 0.0077 0.1601 0.00378 -3.40514
78 0.91924 COMB1 Combination 0.2011 -6.9812 0.0077 0.1601 0.00024 -0.12335
78 1.37886 COMB1 Combination 0.2011 -6.6632 0.0077 0.1601 -0.0033 3.01226
78 1.83848 COMB1 Combination 0.2011 -6.3451 0.0077 0.1601 -0.00684 6.00168
79 0 DEAD LinStatic 0.5877 -3.0147 -0.0132 0.04675 -0.00883 -2.4851
79 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic 0.5877 -2.838 -0.0132 0.04675 -0.00276 -1.14008
79 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic 0.5877 -2.6613 -0.0132 0.04675 0.00331 0.12372
79 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic 0.5877 -2.4846 -0.0132 0.04675 0.00938 1.30631
79 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic 0.5877 -2.3079 -0.0132 0.04675 0.01545 2.40769
79 0 COMB1 Combination 1.0579 -5.4265 -0.0238 0.08415 -0.01589 -4.47317

17. SAP2000 v10.0.4
Table: Element Forces Frames,
Frame Station OutputCase CaseType P V2 V3 T M2 M3
Text m Text Text Ton Ton Ton Ton-m Ton-m Ton-m
79 0.45962 COMB1 Combination 1.0579 -5.1084 -0.0238 0.08415 -0.00497 -2.05214
79 0.91924 COMB1 Combination 1.0579 -4.7904 -0.0238 0.08415 0.00595 0.2227
79 1.37886 COMB1 Combination 1.0579 -4.4723 -0.0238 0.08415 0.01688 2.35137
79 1.83848 COMB1 Combination 1.0579 -4.1543 -0.0238 0.08415 0.0278 4.33384
80 0 DEAD LinStatic 0.5877 2.3079 0.0132 -0.04675 0.01545 2.40769
80 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic 0.5877 2.4846 0.0132 -0.04675 0.00938 1.30631
80 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic 0.5877 2.6613 0.0132 -0.04675 0.00331 0.12372
80 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic 0.5877 2.838 0.0132 -0.04675 -0.00276 -1.14008
80 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic 0.5877 3.0147 0.0132 -0.04675 -0.00883 -2.4851
80 0 COMB1 Combination 1.0579 4.1543 0.0238 -0.08415 0.0278 4.33384
80 0.45962 COMB1 Combination 1.0579 4.4723 0.0238 -0.08415 0.01688 2.35137
80 0.91924 COMB1 Combination 1.0579 4.7904 0.0238 -0.08415 0.00595 0.2227
80 1.37886 COMB1 Combination 1.0579 5.1084 0.0238 -0.08415 -0.00497 -2.05214
80 1.83848 COMB1 Combination 1.0579 5.4265 0.0238 -0.08415 -0.01589 -4.47317
81 0 DEAD LinStatic -0.5023 2.3079 0.0132 -0.04675 0.00883 2.27491
81 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic -0.5023 2.4846 0.0132 -0.04675 0.00276 1.17353
81 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic -0.5023 2.6613 0.0132 -0.04675 -0.00331 -0.00906
81 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic -0.5023 2.838 0.0132 -0.04675 -0.00938 -1.27286
81 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic -0.5023 3.0147 0.0132 -0.04675 -0.01545 -2.61788
81 0 COMB1 Combination -0.9042 4.1543 0.0238 -0.08415 0.01589 4.09483
81 0.45962 COMB1 Combination -0.9042 4.4723 0.0238 -0.08415 0.00497 2.11236
81 0.91924 COMB1 Combination -0.9042 4.7904 0.0238 -0.08415 -0.00595 -0.01631
81 1.37886 COMB1 Combination -0.9042 5.1084 0.0238 -0.08415 -0.01688 -2.29115
81 1.83848 COMB1 Combination -0.9042 5.4265 0.0238 -0.08415 -0.0278 -4.71218
82 0 DEAD LinStatic -0.5023 -3.0147 -0.0132 0.04675 -0.01545 -2.61788
82 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic -0.5023 -2.838 -0.0132 0.04675 -0.00938 -1.27286
82 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic -0.5023 -2.6613 -0.0132 0.04675 -0.00331 -0.00906
82 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic -0.5023 -2.4846 -0.0132 0.04675 0.00276 1.17353
82 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic -0.5023 -2.3079 -0.0132 0.04675 0.00883 2.27491
82 0 COMB1 Combination -0.9042 -5.4265 -0.0238 0.08415 -0.0278 -4.71218
82 0.45962 COMB1 Combination -0.9042 -5.1084 -0.0238 0.08415 -0.01688 -2.29115
82 0.91924 COMB1 Combination -0.9042 -4.7904 -0.0238 0.08415 -0.00595 -0.01631
82 1.37886 COMB1 Combination -0.9042 -4.4723 -0.0238 0.08415 0.00497 2.11236
82 1.83848 COMB1 Combination -0.9042 -4.1543 -0.0238 0.08415 0.01589 4.09483
83 0 DEAD LinStatic -0.3832 -1.991 0.0079 0.06854 0.00573 -1.50768
83 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic -0.3832 -1.8143 0.0079 0.06854 0.0021 -0.63319
83 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic -0.3832 -1.6376 0.0079 0.06854 -0.00154 0.16009
83 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic -0.3832 -1.4609 0.0079 0.06854 -0.00518 0.87215
83 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic -0.3832 -1.2842 0.0079 0.06854 -0.00882 1.503
83 0 COMB1 Combination -0.6898 -3.5838 0.0142 0.12337 0.01032 -2.71382
83 0.45962 COMB1 Combination -0.6898 -3.2657 0.0142 0.12337 0.00377 -1.13973
83 0.91924 COMB1 Combination -0.6898 -2.9477 0.0142 0.12337 -0.00278 0.28816
83 1.37886 COMB1 Combination -0.6898 -2.6296 0.0142 0.12337 -0.00933 1.56987
83 1.83848 COMB1 Combination -0.6898 -2.3116 0.0142 0.12337 -0.01588 2.7054
84 0 DEAD LinStatic -0.3832 1.2842 -0.0079 -0.06854 -0.00882 1.503
84 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic -0.3832 1.4609 -0.0079 -0.06854 -0.00518 0.87215
84 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic -0.3832 1.6376 -0.0079 -0.06854 -0.00154 0.16009
84 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic -0.3832 1.8143 -0.0079 -0.06854 0.0021 -0.63319
84 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic -0.3832 1.991 -0.0079 -0.06854 0.00573 -1.50768
84 0 COMB1 Combination -0.6898 2.3116 -0.0142 -0.12337 -0.01588 2.7054
84 0.45962 COMB1 Combination -0.6898 2.6296 -0.0142 -0.12337 -0.00933 1.56987
84 0.91924 COMB1 Combination -0.6898 2.9477 -0.0142 -0.12337 -0.00278 0.28816
84 1.37886 COMB1 Combination -0.6898 3.2657 -0.0142 -0.12337 0.00377 -1.13973
84 1.83848 COMB1 Combination -0.6898 3.5838 -0.0142 -0.12337 0.01032 -2.71382
85 0 DEAD LinStatic 0.2096 1.2842 -0.0079 -0.06854 -0.00573 1.30833
85 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic 0.2096 1.4609 -0.0079 -0.06854 -0.0021 0.67748
85 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic 0.2096 1.6376 -0.0079 -0.06854 0.00154 -0.03458
85 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic 0.2096 1.8143 -0.0079 -0.06854 0.00518 -0.82786
85 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic 0.2096 1.991 -0.0079 -0.06854 0.00882 -1.70235
85 0 COMB1 Combination 0.3772 2.3116 -0.0142 -0.12337 -0.01032 2.35499
85 0.45962 COMB1 Combination 0.3772 2.6296 -0.0142 -0.12337 -0.00377 1.21947
85 0.91924 COMB1 Combination 0.3772 2.9477 -0.0142 -0.12337 0.00278 -0.06225
85 1.37886 COMB1 Combination 0.3772 3.2657 -0.0142 -0.12337 0.00933 -1.49014
85 1.83848 COMB1 Combination 0.3772 3.5838 -0.0142 -0.12337 0.01588 -3.06422
86 0 DEAD LinStatic 0.2096 -1.991 0.0079 0.06854 0.00882 -1.70235
86 0.45962 DEAD LinStatic 0.2096 -1.8143 0.0079 0.06854 0.00518 -0.82786
86 0.91924 DEAD LinStatic 0.2096 -1.6376 0.0079 0.06854 0.00154 -0.03458
86 1.37886 DEAD LinStatic 0.2096 -1.4609 0.0079 0.06854 -0.0021 0.67748
86 1.83848 DEAD LinStatic 0.2096 -1.2842 0.0079 0.06854 -0.00573 1.30833
86 0 COMB1 Combination 0.3772 -3.5838 0.0142 0.12337 0.01588 -3.06422
86 0.45962 COMB1 Combination 0.3772 -3.2657 0.0142 0.12337 0.00933 -1.49014
86 0.91924 COMB1 Combination 0.3772 -2.9477 0.0142 0.12337 0.00278 -0.06225
86 1.37886 COMB1 Combination 0.3772 -2.6296 0.0142 0.12337 -0.00377 1.21947
86 1.83848 COMB1 Combination 0.3772 -2.3116 0.0142 0.12337 -0.01032 2.35499

18. SAP2000 v10.0.4
Joint Reactions
Joint OutputCase CaseType F1 F2 F3 M1 M2 M3
Text Text Text Ton Ton Ton Ton-m Ton-m Ton-m
33 DEAD LinStatic -2.1325 0.0207 19.0335 -0.02605 -6.04776 -0.00834
33 COMB1 Combination -3.8385 0.0373 34.2603 -0.04688 -10.88596 -0.01501
44 DEAD LinStatic -5.5468 1.25E-13 -43.1916 -3.33E-13 -19.97991 -9.22E-14
44 COMB1 Combination -9.9842 2.25E-13 -77.7449 -5.99E-13 -35.96383 -1.66E-13
52 DEAD LinStatic -2.1325 -0.0207 19.0335 0.02605 -6.04776 0.00834
52 COMB1 Combination -3.8385 -0.0373 34.2603 0.04688 -10.88596 0.01501
60 DEAD LinStatic -5.5882 2.51E-14 81.2587 -9.73E-14 -20.032 -9.17E-14
60 COMB1 Combination -10.0588 4.52E-14 146.2656 -1.75E-13 -36.0576 -1.65E-13