This brief argues that Nina Arroyo-Lee's sculpture "Spring Awakening" is a work of recognized stature under VARA, and that Warwick Environmental Preservation Association violated VARA when it intentionally destroyed the sculpture. The brief asserts that "Spring Awakening" possesses artistic merit, as supported by testimony from both parties' experts and articles praising the work. The brief also argues that the sculpture gained recognition from art experts, members of the artistic community, and the general public through displays in a public park and a celebratory ceremony, satisfying the Carter test for recognized stature. The district court erred in finding otherwise, according to the brief.
Este documento describe 4 alimentos que ayudan a equilibrar las hormonas y aclarar la piel. Explica que las hormonas controlan muchos aspectos de la salud y que comer los nutrientes adecuados es importante para su producción y equilibrio. Luego enumera los 4 grupos de alimentos recomendados: 1) buenas proteínas como nueces, frijoles y huevos; 2) grasas saludables como aceite de coco, aguacate y mantequilla; 3) vegetales ricos en antioxidantes; y 4) hierbas y especias
SEBI notify Listing Obligations & Disclosure RequirementsGAURAV KR SHARMA
The document outlines regulations from the Securities and Exchange Board of India regarding listing obligations and disclosure requirements for listed entities. It defines key terms, specifies the applicability of the regulations to different types of listed securities, and establishes principles for disclosures, obligations, and corporate governance that listed entities must comply with. These include protecting shareholder rights, ensuring timely and equitable disclosure, recognizing stakeholder interests, and establishing board responsibilities.
Las Tecnologías de la Información y Comunicación (TICs) facilitan el intercambio de información entre usuarios y ordenadores, fortaleciendo el proceso de enseñanza y aprendizaje a través del cambio constante y la generación de nuevos conocimientos. Las redes de aprendizaje permiten la conexión entre dos o más tecnologías sin barreras de tiempo o espacio, mejorando la respuesta e impulsando el aprendizaje remoto a través de recursos digitales. Además, las TICs permiten el trabajo en grupo y el
This document provides photos credited to various photographers and suggests that the reader may be inspired to create their own Haiku Deck presentation on SlideShare. It includes photos from ®DS, ROSS HONG KONG, and SammCox and encourages the user to get started making their own presentation.
1. A software development team at LogicaCMG adopted Extreme Programming (XP) practices to address issues with their mature product set such as high costs, complex configuration management, and lack of innovation due to long development cycles and QA testing.
2. They implemented XP practices like offshore development for maintenance, intensive training, iterative development, test-first practices, continuous integration, and onsite customers.
3. This resulted in benefits like releasing their first new product within 3 months, 50% fewer defects, test cycles reduced from 2 months to zero, and delivering working software frequently which allowed for continuous feedback.
Las Tecnologías de la Información y Comunicación (TICs) son una estrategia importante en la educación porque permiten a los docentes mantenerse actualizados y usar herramientas como signos e imágenes para comunicar mensajes de manera más efectiva.
This document outlines penalties for non-compliance with various provisions of the Companies Act for both companies and individuals. It lists the section violated, brief description of the violation, penalty to the company in terms of fine amounts, and penalties to other persons like directors or officers which can include fines and imprisonment. Penalties to individuals range from fines between Rs. 5,000 to 5 lakhs and imprisonment from 1 month to 7 years depending on the severity and nature of the violation.
El documento habla sobre el maquillaje. Explica que el maquillaje se ha usado desde la antigüedad para mejorar la apariencia y que actualmente se usa como arma de seducción. Luego describe diferentes técnicas de maquillaje natural, de noche, de verano y tips rápidos de maquillaje en 3 minutos o menos.
Este documento describe 4 alimentos que ayudan a equilibrar las hormonas y aclarar la piel. Explica que las hormonas controlan muchos aspectos de la salud y que comer los nutrientes adecuados es importante para su producción y equilibrio. Luego enumera los 4 grupos de alimentos recomendados: 1) buenas proteínas como nueces, frijoles y huevos; 2) grasas saludables como aceite de coco, aguacate y mantequilla; 3) vegetales ricos en antioxidantes; y 4) hierbas y especias
SEBI notify Listing Obligations & Disclosure RequirementsGAURAV KR SHARMA
The document outlines regulations from the Securities and Exchange Board of India regarding listing obligations and disclosure requirements for listed entities. It defines key terms, specifies the applicability of the regulations to different types of listed securities, and establishes principles for disclosures, obligations, and corporate governance that listed entities must comply with. These include protecting shareholder rights, ensuring timely and equitable disclosure, recognizing stakeholder interests, and establishing board responsibilities.
Las Tecnologías de la Información y Comunicación (TICs) facilitan el intercambio de información entre usuarios y ordenadores, fortaleciendo el proceso de enseñanza y aprendizaje a través del cambio constante y la generación de nuevos conocimientos. Las redes de aprendizaje permiten la conexión entre dos o más tecnologías sin barreras de tiempo o espacio, mejorando la respuesta e impulsando el aprendizaje remoto a través de recursos digitales. Además, las TICs permiten el trabajo en grupo y el
This document provides photos credited to various photographers and suggests that the reader may be inspired to create their own Haiku Deck presentation on SlideShare. It includes photos from ®DS, ROSS HONG KONG, and SammCox and encourages the user to get started making their own presentation.
1. A software development team at LogicaCMG adopted Extreme Programming (XP) practices to address issues with their mature product set such as high costs, complex configuration management, and lack of innovation due to long development cycles and QA testing.
2. They implemented XP practices like offshore development for maintenance, intensive training, iterative development, test-first practices, continuous integration, and onsite customers.
3. This resulted in benefits like releasing their first new product within 3 months, 50% fewer defects, test cycles reduced from 2 months to zero, and delivering working software frequently which allowed for continuous feedback.
Las Tecnologías de la Información y Comunicación (TICs) son una estrategia importante en la educación porque permiten a los docentes mantenerse actualizados y usar herramientas como signos e imágenes para comunicar mensajes de manera más efectiva.
This document outlines penalties for non-compliance with various provisions of the Companies Act for both companies and individuals. It lists the section violated, brief description of the violation, penalty to the company in terms of fine amounts, and penalties to other persons like directors or officers which can include fines and imprisonment. Penalties to individuals range from fines between Rs. 5,000 to 5 lakhs and imprisonment from 1 month to 7 years depending on the severity and nature of the violation.
El documento habla sobre el maquillaje. Explica que el maquillaje se ha usado desde la antigüedad para mejorar la apariencia y que actualmente se usa como arma de seducción. Luego describe diferentes técnicas de maquillaje natural, de noche, de verano y tips rápidos de maquillaje en 3 minutos o menos.
Formas principales de intoxicación y los primeros auxilios que se deben brindar en esta, refiere algunas formas de como desintoxicar a los pacientes que han ingerido por las diferentes vias, el manejo adecuado en primeros auxilios en la principal ayuda, ya que contribuye a que cuando el paciente llegue al centro asistencial la salud no se deteriore completamente.
Este documento presenta la información sobre el temario y competencias para el submódulo 2 de gestión de información mediante hojas de cálculo. Incluye los objetivos de evaluar el desarrollo de competencias profesionales y genéricas de manera integral aplicando prácticas que generen evidencias para la presentación de un portafolio. También presenta los temas a cubrir como las partes de la ventana de Excel, tipos de datos, errores comunes y las funciones.
Contribution of Muslims in Science & technologyShakiluzJAhmed
The document provides biographies of several notable Muslim scientists and their contributions to fields like physics, aerospace engineering, ornithology, and structural engineering. It discusses Abdul Kalam's work on missile development in India. It also mentions Muhammad Abdus Salam winning the Nobel Prize for electroweak unification theory. Fazlur Rahman Khan revolutionized tall building design with his tube-structure concept. Other scientists profiled include ornithologist Salim Ali, nuclear engineers Munir Khan and Sameera Moussa, physicist Ali Javan who co-invented the gas laser, and astronaut Sultan bin Salman who was the first Muslim in space. The document highlights the significant contributions Muslims have made to science
This document outlines the units and topics covered in a course on Design and Analysis of Algorithms. It includes definitions of key algorithm concepts like time complexity, asymptotic notation, and algorithm design approaches. Data structures like arrays, binary search trees, AVL trees, and red-black trees are discussed. Specific algorithms like quicksort, dynamic programming, greedy algorithms, and minimum spanning trees are covered. The document also introduces computational complexity classes like P, NP, NP-complete and NP-hard and some famous unsolved problems in computer science.
Guide to Green Business Social Media Success by Taiga CompanyTaiga Company
Are you a small or mid-sized business marketer? Do you own or promote a green / sustainable business? Taiga Company's guide can help you kick start a successful social media program and generate easy social media success.
This document outlines regulations from the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India regarding voluntary liquidation of corporate persons. It discusses the initiation of voluntary liquidation through declarations and resolutions, the effect on corporate status, eligibility and remuneration of liquidators, and key powers and functions of liquidators such as maintaining books and registers, preparing reports, and appointing professionals. The purpose is to provide a framework for orderly voluntary liquidation of corporate persons under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code of India.
Formas principales de intoxicación y los primeros auxilios que se deben brindar en esta, refiere algunas formas de como desintoxicar a los pacientes que han ingerido por las diferentes vias, el manejo adecuado en primeros auxilios en la principal ayuda, ya que contribuye a que cuando el paciente llegue al centro asistencial la salud no se deteriore completamente.
Este documento presenta la información sobre el temario y competencias para el submódulo 2 de gestión de información mediante hojas de cálculo. Incluye los objetivos de evaluar el desarrollo de competencias profesionales y genéricas de manera integral aplicando prácticas que generen evidencias para la presentación de un portafolio. También presenta los temas a cubrir como las partes de la ventana de Excel, tipos de datos, errores comunes y las funciones.
Contribution of Muslims in Science & technologyShakiluzJAhmed
The document provides biographies of several notable Muslim scientists and their contributions to fields like physics, aerospace engineering, ornithology, and structural engineering. It discusses Abdul Kalam's work on missile development in India. It also mentions Muhammad Abdus Salam winning the Nobel Prize for electroweak unification theory. Fazlur Rahman Khan revolutionized tall building design with his tube-structure concept. Other scientists profiled include ornithologist Salim Ali, nuclear engineers Munir Khan and Sameera Moussa, physicist Ali Javan who co-invented the gas laser, and astronaut Sultan bin Salman who was the first Muslim in space. The document highlights the significant contributions Muslims have made to science
This document outlines the units and topics covered in a course on Design and Analysis of Algorithms. It includes definitions of key algorithm concepts like time complexity, asymptotic notation, and algorithm design approaches. Data structures like arrays, binary search trees, AVL trees, and red-black trees are discussed. Specific algorithms like quicksort, dynamic programming, greedy algorithms, and minimum spanning trees are covered. The document also introduces computational complexity classes like P, NP, NP-complete and NP-hard and some famous unsolved problems in computer science.
Guide to Green Business Social Media Success by Taiga CompanyTaiga Company
Are you a small or mid-sized business marketer? Do you own or promote a green / sustainable business? Taiga Company's guide can help you kick start a successful social media program and generate easy social media success.
This document outlines regulations from the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India regarding voluntary liquidation of corporate persons. It discusses the initiation of voluntary liquidation through declarations and resolutions, the effect on corporate status, eligibility and remuneration of liquidators, and key powers and functions of liquidators such as maintaining books and registers, preparing reports, and appointing professionals. The purpose is to provide a framework for orderly voluntary liquidation of corporate persons under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code of India.
1. IN THE
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT
___________
No. 12-2345
Nina Arroyo-Lee,
Appellant/Cross-Appellee,
v.
Warwick Environmental Preservation Association, Inc.,
Appellee/Cross-Appellant.
___________
ON APPEAL FROM THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE
EASTERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
BRIEF FOR APPELLANT/CROSS-APPELLEE, NINA ARROYO-LEE
2052.Section4D.Brief2
185 W. Broadway
New York, NY 10013
(212) 431-2100
Attorneys for the Appellant/Cross-Appellee
2. QUESTION PRESENTED
1. Whether “Spring Awakening,” a sculpture that has been praised by art experts, members of
the artistic community, and members of the general public, is a work of recognized stature under
The Visual Artists Rights Act of 1990 (17 U.S.C. § 106A).
2
3. ARGUMENT
I. WEPA ACTED IN VIOLATION OF VARA WHEN IT INTENTIONALLY
DESTROYED MS. ARROYO-LEE’S SCULPTURE “SPRING AWAKENING”
BECAUSE IT IS A WORK OF RECOGNIZED STATURE
The Visual Artists Rights Act of 1990 (17 U.S.C. § 106A), or VARA, was enacted to
help artists prevent third parties from destroying, modifying, or claiming ownership of certain
visual works of art. These protected works may include a “painting, drawing, print, or
sculpture....” More specifically, 17 U.S.C. § 106A(a)(3)(B) provides that an artist has the right
“to prevent any destruction of a work of recognized stature.”
There is no definition of “recognized stature” within 17 U.S.C. § 106A. The leading case
on this issue is Carter v. Helmsley-Spear, 861 F. Supp. 303 (2d Cir. 1995). The court in Carter
stated that the provision is “preservative in nature: Congress was concerned that the destruction
of works of art represented a significant societal loss.” (Id.) To determine whether a work was of
“recognized stature,” the Carter court applied a two-tiered test: (1) the art must possess "stature,”
or artistic “merit,” and (2) “this stature [must be] recognized by art experts, other members of the
artistic community, or by some cross-section of society.” (Id.) “Spring Awakening” was clearly
protected by VARA because it possessed artistic merit and was sufficiently recognized.
A. The Evidence on Record, Including Expert Testimony and Newspaper Article Excerpts,
Undeniably Demonstrates That “Spring Awakening” Is a Work That Had Inherent
Artistic Merit
3
4. In accordance with the finding that VARA was intended to be preservative in nature, the
court in Carter stated that a work of visual art does not need to be “equal in stature to that
created by artists such as Picasso, Chagall, or Giacometti” to qualify for VARA protection.
(Carter, at 325). Furthermore, although expert testimony will “generally” be provided to
demonstrate that a work possesses stature, it is not “inevitably” needed. (Id.)
The District Court made several errors in determining that “Spring Awakening” was not
artistically meritorious. First, the court misinterpreted and misapplied the testimony of both art
experts. Jonah Peters, an art historian who has 25 years of experience and membership in the
Mayor’s Advisory Committee on Art and Culture in Warwick, testified for Ms. Arroyo-Lee and
stated that “Spring Awakening” was “striking” and showed “that the artist has maturity and
vision.” (Peters Test. 44-51). Mr. Peters also called the sculpture an “avant-garde piece” that
captured “the spirit of the Arab Spring Movement.” (Id.). Even the defendant’s expert, Sharon
Rhodes, conceded that the sculpture had merit. She testified that the sculpture “from a technical
standpoint is well done.” (Rhodes Test. 76-7). She further admitted that it was “innovative to
connect a human rights activist to the mission of the organization through the sculptural form.”
(Id. at 77-9). She also conceded that “Spring Awakening” was “well-constructed.” (Id. at 92).
In its decision, the District Court reached erroneous conclusions because it did not
consider the entire body of testimony. It mistakenly construed Mr. Peters’ testimony to mean that
he had “concluded that virtually all art has merit.” (Op. p. 4). There is no statement in Mr.
Peters’ testimony that wholly supports the court’s assertion. While Mr. Peters did testify that a
“person is an artist when he creates art,” this statement is not supportive of the court’s finding.
The court also mistakenly ignored statements made by the defendant’s expert that clearly
supported a finding of inherent artistic merit.
4
5. In addition, the court erred in that it failed to consider other types of evidence that could
have supported a finding of intrinsic merit. In Martin v. City of Indianapolis, 982 F. Supp. 625
(S.D. Ind. 1997), the court utilized several sources to determine whether a sculpture had “artistic
merit,” including newspaper articles. (Martin). The court explained that these articles were
valuable for two reasons: 1) they offered proof of positive statements made by members of the
artistic community about the artist’s work, and 2) their mere existence demonstrated the
“newsworthiness” of the artist’s work, which was another indicator of its merit. (Id., at 630).
In this case, the District Court made no reference to the contents of the “Brooklyn Rail”
article provided by Ms. Arroyo-Lee. The article, which had the inherently positive title: “Avant-
Garde Artistic Celebration of Women and Democracy,” contained supportive statements made
by Madeline Faber, a professor of fine arts. (Brooklyn Rail, p. 2). Ms. Faber labeled the sculpture
“technically proficient” and “a profound tribute.” (Id.). Furthermore, Ms. Arroyo-Lee produced
another news article in which arts editor Allison Haverford stated: “Arroyo-Lee’s an artist to
watch. Spring Awakening is a striking example of the potential for art to awaken the senses.”
(Arroyo-Lee Test. #2, 84-9). These statements, in combination with the testimony of both
experts, is overwhelming evidence of the intrinsic artistic merit of “Spring Awakening.”
B. “Spring Awakening” Is A Work of Recognized Stature Because, In Addition To
Possessing Intrinsic Artistic Merit, It Had Achieved Significant Recognition From Art
Experts, Members of The Artistic Community, and a Cross-Section of Society
Once it has been successfully shown that a work has intrinsic artistic merit, the plaintiff is
required to demonstrate that it also has received recognition from “art experts, other members of
5
6. the artistic community, or... some cross-section of society.” (Carter v. Helmsley-Spear, at 325.)
Although the reputation of the artist can sometimes aid a finding of recognized stature, “it is the
artwork that is the subject of the litigation that must have acquired this stature.” (Scott v. Dixon,
309 F. Supp. 2d 395 (E.D.N.Y. 2004)). Furthermore, in Pollara v. Seymour, 150 F. Supp. 2d 393
(N.D.N.Y. 2001), the court favored a broad interpretation in which “prior recognition” is not
even “a necessary precondition to the existence of a cause of action under VARA.” (Id.)
Although the two-tiered Carter test requires that proof of recognition need only be based
on one of three potential sources, Ms. Arroyo-Lee has produced evidence of recognition from all
of them. As discussed previously, both parties’ experts testified about her sculpture’s intrinsic
merit, which leads to a conclusion that both experts have “recognized” it as well. Madeline Faber
and Allison Haverford, members of the artistic community, also extolled the virtues of “Spring
Awakening” in the news articles on record. (Brooklyn Rail p. 2; Arroyo-Lee Test. #2, 84-9).
Finally, Dylan Shaw admitted that he had often received “compliments” about it from park-
goers, a group of people that may satisfactorily be called a cross-section of society. (Id. at p. 1).
Although some complaints about “Spring Awakening” were detailed in the article, the court in
Carter noted that the work need not be “aesthetically pleasing” in order it to attain recognition.
(Id., at 325.)
Furthermore, the facts of Ms. Arroyo-Lee’s case compare favorably to the facts in
Pollara v. Seymour (150 F. Supp. 2d 393). In Pollara, the plaintiff painted a mural for display in
a public building, but the mural was destroyed before the public could see it. Even though the
public never saw it, the court still found that her painting was “not excluded from the statutory
definition of ‘work of recognized stature’ merely because it [had] not previously been exhibited
to art critics or the general public.” (Id.)
6
7. In Ms. Arroyo-Lee’s case, the public had ample opportunity to view “Spring
Awakening.” The sculpture was completed in August 2011 (Arroyo-Lee Test. #1, 89-90) and
intentionally destroyed in May of 2012. (Compl. ¶ 12). In addition, WEPA held a ribbon-cutting
ceremony to commemorate its completion. (Shaw Test. #1, 91-3). Unlike the mural in Pollara,
which still may have attained recognized stature despite a total lack of public viewership,
“Spring Awakening” was on display in a public park for approximately nine months and was
even the subject of a celebratory ceremony.
Finally, Ms. Arroyo-Lee’s reputation as an artist is not a relevant factor in this analysis; it
is the piece itself that must have attained stature. (Scott v. Dixon, 309 F. Supp. 2d 395.) The
District Court noted that Ms. Arroyo-Lee “has not sold any work other than the sculpture at issue
here,” but this observation is irrelevant and should not have factored into the court’s decision.
(Op. p. 4).
It is quite clear that the evidence weighs in favor of a finding that “Spring Awakening”
was a work of recognized stature. The work’s inherent artistic merit is so undeniable that even
the defendant’s expert testified to its existence, and this merit has been sufficiently recognized
over a period of nine months by both art critics and the general public.
7