This document summarizes the rise of augmented reality (AR) technologies and discusses how they will significantly impact laws and society. AR allows digital data to be superimposed on the physical world through devices like smartphones and glasses. Current AR apps overlay information on locations or objects in real-time. Widespread use of AR glasses will truly transform how people interact with information and each other. As with past technological changes, this will necessitate adjustments to legal systems to account for the new realities. The author aims to anticipate these changes through their blog on AR's legal implications.
Existential Risk Prevention as Global PriorityKarlos Svoboda
This document discusses existential risk, which is defined as risks that could cause human extinction or permanently and drastically curtail the potential of humanity. The author makes the case that existential risk reduction should be a top global priority for the following reasons:
1) Even small reductions in existential risk have enormous expected value due to the astronomical potential for future human life and development.
2) The largest existential risks are anthropogenic and linked to potential future technologies like advanced biotech, nanotech, and AI.
3) A moral argument can be made that existential risk reduction is more important than any other global issue due to the infinite value of the future of humanity.
4) Efforts should
A rights based model of governance - the case of human enhancementKarlos Svoboda
The current development of technology and scientificresearch may give rise to several
applications on human beings. In this context, emerging technologies can further foster
the applications on human beings and pave the way for new and incisive research towards human enhancement (HE).
2
Thanks to emerging technologies, HE can be more
effective and represent a concrete challenge for present societies, also in Europe. Scientists of the Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, for instance, recently created a brain-synthesized estrogen that influences the synaptic structure,
function and cognitive processes by augmenting the networks among neurons (Svrivastava et al. 2010). Thus it could be a case of future brain-doping.
Brain computer interaction and medical access to the brainKarlos Svoboda
This paper discusses current clinical applications and possible future uses of brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) as a means for communication, motor control and entertainment. After giving a brief account of the various approaches to direct brain-computer interaction, the paper will address individual, social and ethical implications of BCI technology to extract signals from the brain.
These include reflections on medical and psychosocial benefits and risks, user control, informed consent, autonomy and privacy as well as ethical and social issues implicated in putative future developments with focus on human self-understanding and the idea of man. BCI use which involves direct interrelation and mutual interdependence between human brains and technical
devices raises anthropological questions concerning self-perception and the technicalization of the human body.
Human abilities such as vision, hearing, strength and mobility are extremely limited and obsolete without tools. Various machines and technologies have surpassed and continue to surpass human capabilities in many areas. Robotic systems can see better over longer distances, hear a wider range of frequencies, lift far greater weights, move faster and with more endurance than humans. While humans invented sophisticated tools, those tools are now transforming what it means to be human as society relies on machines for most tasks.
This document summarizes the rise of augmented reality (AR) technologies and discusses how they will significantly impact laws and society. AR allows digital data to be superimposed on the physical world through devices like smartphones and glasses. Current AR apps overlay information on locations or objects in real-time. Widespread use of AR glasses will truly transform how people interact with information and each other. As with past technological changes, this will necessitate adjustments to legal systems to account for the new realities. The author aims to anticipate these changes through their blog on AR's legal implications.
Existential Risk Prevention as Global PriorityKarlos Svoboda
This document discusses existential risk, which is defined as risks that could cause human extinction or permanently and drastically curtail the potential of humanity. The author makes the case that existential risk reduction should be a top global priority for the following reasons:
1) Even small reductions in existential risk have enormous expected value due to the astronomical potential for future human life and development.
2) The largest existential risks are anthropogenic and linked to potential future technologies like advanced biotech, nanotech, and AI.
3) A moral argument can be made that existential risk reduction is more important than any other global issue due to the infinite value of the future of humanity.
4) Efforts should
A rights based model of governance - the case of human enhancementKarlos Svoboda
The current development of technology and scientificresearch may give rise to several
applications on human beings. In this context, emerging technologies can further foster
the applications on human beings and pave the way for new and incisive research towards human enhancement (HE).
2
Thanks to emerging technologies, HE can be more
effective and represent a concrete challenge for present societies, also in Europe. Scientists of the Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, for instance, recently created a brain-synthesized estrogen that influences the synaptic structure,
function and cognitive processes by augmenting the networks among neurons (Svrivastava et al. 2010). Thus it could be a case of future brain-doping.
Brain computer interaction and medical access to the brainKarlos Svoboda
This paper discusses current clinical applications and possible future uses of brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) as a means for communication, motor control and entertainment. After giving a brief account of the various approaches to direct brain-computer interaction, the paper will address individual, social and ethical implications of BCI technology to extract signals from the brain.
These include reflections on medical and psychosocial benefits and risks, user control, informed consent, autonomy and privacy as well as ethical and social issues implicated in putative future developments with focus on human self-understanding and the idea of man. BCI use which involves direct interrelation and mutual interdependence between human brains and technical
devices raises anthropological questions concerning self-perception and the technicalization of the human body.
Human abilities such as vision, hearing, strength and mobility are extremely limited and obsolete without tools. Various machines and technologies have surpassed and continue to surpass human capabilities in many areas. Robotic systems can see better over longer distances, hear a wider range of frequencies, lift far greater weights, move faster and with more endurance than humans. While humans invented sophisticated tools, those tools are now transforming what it means to be human as society relies on machines for most tasks.
Ethics of security and surveillance technologies opinion 28Karlos Svoboda
This document discusses the ethics of security and surveillance technologies in the European Union. It summarizes numerous EU directives, regulations, communications and proposals related to data protection, communications surveillance, aviation security, border control, and law enforcement. It establishes the EGE's role in advising the EU on these issues and ensuring technologies respect fundamental rights and ethics.
Ethical aspect of ICT Implants in the Human bodyKarlos Svoboda
The document discusses ethical aspects of implanting information and communication technology (ICT) devices in the human body. It summarizes Opinion No. 20 issued by the European Group on Ethics in Science and New Technologies, which examines the ethical issues arising from ICT implants. The opinion addresses concerns regarding threats to human dignity, autonomy and privacy from implants that can permanently track individuals or remotely change the information contained. It notes some implants require special precaution due to risks of being difficult to remove, influencing psychic functions, or enabling social surveillance and manipulation.
Emerging Technoethics of Human Interaction with Communication, Bionic and Rob...Karlos Svoboda
AHS may be that f... system
In this deliverable, the protection and promotion of human rights is explored in connection with various case-studies in robotics, bionics, and AI agent technologies. This is done along various dimensions, prominently including human dignity, autonomy, responsibility, privacy,liberty, fairness, justice, and personal identity.
Ethical case-studies in robotics concern learning robots, unmanned combat air vehicles,robot companions, surgery robots, and a robotic street cleaning system. Case-studies illustrating current developments of the field with imminent potential applications comprise the robotic street cleaning system, surgery robots, and the unmanned air vehicles. Robots making extensive use of learning capabilities and robots acting as companions to human
beings represent somewhat more distant possibilities, enabling one to connect in meaningful ways an analysis of short-term ethical issues in robotics with a pro-active interest in longterm ethical issues.
The bionics case-studies considered here concern specific kinds of implants in the human body, investing the human peripheral or central nervous system, and other kinds of noninvasive brain-computer interfaces. These case-studies are closely related to the robotics case-studies, insofar as these bionic technologies enable one to connect to and often control robotic effectors and sensors. Ethical issues examined in connection with these technologies concern both a short-term perspective, mostly arising from their therapeutic uses, and a longterm perspective, mostly arising from the possibility of extending communication, control, cognitive, and perceptual capabilities of both disabled and non-disabled individuals.
This networking of humans with both robotic and computer-based information systems motivates the inclusion of a case-study about AI agent technologies in this report, concerning systems that have been with us for quite a while, that is, adaptive hypermedia systems for
educational applications. These technologies enable one to design and implement software agents that are similar to robotic agents, also from an ethical standpoint, insofar as they are capable of, e.g., autonomous action, reasoning, perception, and planning.
Ethical issues examined in this report will be amplified from the convergence of softbot and robotic technologies directly interacting with human beings and other biological systems by means of bionic interfaces. This long-term perspective shows that the case-studies examined here - which are significant in their own right from the isolated perspectives of robotics,bionics, and AI - can soon become parts of broader ethical problems that we will have to address and come with in the near future.
Some futurists and artificial intelligence experts envision credible scenarios in which synthetic brains will, within this century, extend the functionality of our own brains to the point where they will rival and then surpass the power of an or-ganic human brain. At the same time, humans seem to have no limitations when it comes to finding ways to attack the computerized devices that others have invent-ed. Attackers have successfully compromised computers, mobile phones, ATMs, telephone networks, and even networked power grids. If neural devices fulfill the promise of treatment, and enhance our quality of lives and functionality—which appears likely, given the preliminary clinical success demonstrated from neuropros-thetics— their use and adoption will likely grow in the future. When this happens, inevitably, a wide variety of legal, security, and public policy concerns will follow. We will begin this article with an overview of brain implants and neural devic-es and their likely uses in the future. We will then discuss the legal issues that will arise from the intersection among neural devices, information security, cybercrime, and the law.
Nanotechnology, ubiquitous computing and the internet of thingsKarlos Svoboda
The aim of this report is to provide a review of current developments in nanotechnology, ubiquitous
computing and what is increasingly being referred to as “domotics” – the integration of domestic architectures (domus) with information systems and devices (imformatics). The report will also provide a preliminary analysis of the potential impacts of these developments on the right to privacy and to data protection.
These areas of technological development represent the convergence of two domains of current research – nanoscience and distributed computing. Much of the existing literature suggests that advances in nanotechnology are likely to operate as a underlying suite of techniques that will enable the development of miniaturised and distributed information systems and the integration of informatics devices into a range of everyday consumer goods and household architectures. As we outline below the convergence of nanotechnology and research in ubiquitous and distributed systems is likely to result in the development of a range of new sensor technologies and advances in surveillance and monitoring techniques, deployed in civilian, military and security contexts. For these reasons advances in nanotechnology and ubiquitous computing are likely to intensify existing concerns associated with data collection and the right to privacy.
In order to provide some background to our review of these issues in this section of the report we outline definitions of the field and current trends in surveillance, data-mining and monitoring.
Identity REvolution multi disciplinary perspectivesKarlos Svoboda
The identity [r]evolution is happening. Who are
you, who am I in the information society ?
In recent years, the convergence of several factors – technological, political, economic –
has accelerated a fundamental change in our networked world. On a technological level, information
becomes easier to gather, to store, to exchange
and to process. The belief that more information
brings more security has been a strong political
driver to promote information gathering since September 11. Profiling intends to transform information into knowledge in order to anticipate one’s behaviour, or needs, or preferences. It can lead to
categorizations according to some specific risk criteria, for example, or to direct and personalized
marketing. As a consequence, new forms of identities appear. They are not necessarily related to our
names anymore. They are based on information,
on traces that we leave when we act or interact,
when we go somewhere or just stay in one place,
or even sometimes when we make a choice. They
are related to the SIM cards of our mobile phones,
to our credit card numbers, to the pseudonyms
that we use on the Internet, to our email addresses,
to the IP addresses of our computers, to our profiles… Like traditional identities, these new forms of
identities can allow us to distinguish an individual
within a group of people, or describe this person as
belonging to a community or a category.
MBAN medical body area network - first report and orderKarlos Svoboda
This document from the Federal Communications Commission establishes rules to permit new Medical Body Area Network (MBAN) devices to operate in the 2360-2400 MHz band. It adopts rules allowing secondary, non-interference based MBAN operations under a license-by-rule framework. It also establishes a registration and coordination process for MBAN users in the 2360-2390 MHz portion of the band to address compatibility with incumbent operations. The document proposes criteria for designating a frequency coordinator to manage these registration and coordination activities.
Intimate technology - the battle for our body and behaviourKarlos Svoboda
The document discusses how technology is becoming more intimate through devices that are inside our bodies, between us, that know information about us, and mimic human behaviors and traits. It explores how this is leading to humans being viewed more as machines that can be improved, machines taking on more human-like qualities, and changes to human interactions. Key questions raised include how close technology can and should get to us and whether intimacy and technology can truly be compatible concepts.
For ages, humans have developed cures for diseases and devised techniques which make the hardships of life more endurable. All these were believed to make human life more
humane, i.e. to help humans to live out their inherent (natural, God-given) potentiality to a fuller extent. Recent technology, known as human enhancement, challenges this 'natural'normativity: going beyond restoring wellbeing and optimizing human potentiality, enhancement also develops capacities which can, in a sense, be called new. Chemicals have become available that increase physical performance in, for example the field of sports. Other chemicals enhance psychological endurance, mood, and cognition. Work is in progress on developing functional implants within the body, such as computer chips
integrated in the brain, with the aim of enhancing performance beyond what humans are naturally capable of. Changes are being made to body cells and systems, and techniques are being discussed to change human genes. Finally, techniques are being developed, and in part already applied, which extend the human life-span. Human Enhancement is about trying to make changes to minds and bodies – to characteristics, abilities, emotions
and capacities – beyond what we currently regard as normal.
Making perfect life european governance challenges in 21st Century Bio-engine...Karlos Svoboda
The STOA project ‘Making Perfect Life’ looked into four fields of 21st century bioengineering: engineering of living artefacts, engineering of the body, engineering
of the brain, and engineering of intelligent artefacts. This report describes the main results of the project.
The report shows how developments in the four fields of bio-engineering are shaped by two megatrends: “biology becoming technology” and “technology becoming biology”. These developments result in a broadening of the bioengineering debate in our society. The report addresses the long term viewsthat are inspiring this debate and
discusses a multitude of ethical, legal and social issues that arise from bioengineering developments in the fields described. Against this background four specific developments are studied in more detail: the rise of human genome sequencing, the market introduction of neurodevices, the capturing by information technology of the psychological and physiological states of users, and
the pursuit of standardisation in synthetic biology. These developments are taken in this report as a starting point for an analysis of some of the main European governance challenges in 21st century bio-engineering.
Ambient Intelligence is a future vision where technology is integrated into people's environments and can understand and respond to their needs and behaviors. This report examines how Ambient Intelligence could impact healthcare. It identifies five levels of increasing intelligence - from embedding sensors to anticipating needs. Interviews with healthcare stakeholders explored opportunities and challenges around personalized care, like who has access to health data and for what purposes. Collective agreements are needed to ensure Ambient Intelligence enhances rather than threatens patient interests. The report aims to start a debate on these issues.
GRAY MATTERS Integrative Approaches for Neuroscience, Ethics, and SocietyKarlos Svoboda
This document discusses the importance of integrating ethics into neuroscience research. It notes that while neuroscience research raises many common ethical issues around privacy, consent and risk minimization, it also raises unique issues around privacy of thoughts, threats to personal volition and self-determination. Neuroscience highlights the complex relationships between human thought, emotion and action. The document emphasizes that integrating ethics into neuroscience research from the start can help address these issues and ensure research considers its societal implications. It provides recommendations to guide effective integration of ethics in neuroscience.
This document discusses concerns about government use of neuroscience techniques to read people's minds against their will. It argues that while mind reading has long been possible through analyzing facial expressions and behavior, recent advances in neuroimaging techniques like fMRI have generated fears that governments could soon directly access people's private thoughts. However, the document cautions against overstating the current capabilities of neuroscience, noting that tools like fMRI are not true "mind readers." It argues we should thoughtfully examine how constitutional protections could apply to involuntary neuroimaging, rather than panicking about hypothetical mind reading abilities. An important question is how the law should treat certain government-compelled neuroscience evidence.
Biotechnology and science probing the mindKarlos Svoboda
This document discusses issues around the use of neuroscience evidence in legal cases. It describes two main types of neuroscience evidence - brain scans used for lie detection and determining cognitive ability. While this technology is promising, there are still many challenges around reliability and getting such evidence admitted in court. A key open question is whether brain scans should be considered a search of physical brain cells under the 4th Amendment or a statement of information from the individual under the 5th Amendment right against self-incrimination. This characterization could have significant legal implications as laws have not kept pace with advancing neuroscience technology.
This document is the table of contents for a book titled "Values and Ethics for the 21st Century". The book is divided into five parts covering various topics related to ethics in a globalized world, including ethics in business, finance, science/technology, development/poverty/environment, and other global issues. It contains introductions and summaries for each chapter from numerous authors on subjects like global economic ethics, global governance, immigration, human enhancement, environmental ethics, and more. The goal is to discuss how universal ethical principles can help address the major challenges of the 21st century in an era of rapid globalization and technological change.
The above discussion focused on compensation (or restitution) through
providing medical care or the funds to remunerate participants in human
subjects research for the direct costs of medical care for injuries that have
proximately resulted from their participation in research.
This document from the British Medical Association discusses the ethical aspects of cognitive enhancements. It explores various methods of cognitive enhancement including nutrition, pharmaceuticals, brain stimulation, and genetics. It examines the potential benefits and harms, issues of equity and coercion, and implications for human identity and society. It considers whether different enhancement methods raise different moral issues. It discusses whether limits should be placed on individual choice and whether regulation is needed. It concludes by posing key questions to facilitate public debate on how society should respond to advances in cognitive enhancement technologies.
Brain machine interface and limb reanimationKarlos Svoboda
This document summarizes recent advances in brain machine interface (BMI) and limb reanimation technologies that aim to restore function after spinal cord injury. BMI systems analyze brain signals to command external devices, while limb reanimation technologies like intraspinal microstimulation activate neuronal pathways below the injury. The ultimate goal is to integrate these approaches into a bypass system. Key challenges include developing asynchronous BMI systems for safe, independent home use and optimizing intraspinal microstimulation electrode design and parameters. Overcoming these challenges could realize the goal of restoring limb movement through a cortical signal-driven spinal cord bypass.
Brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) acquire brain signals, analyze them, and translate them into commands to control devices. BCIs do not use normal motor pathways. The goal is to restore function for people with disabilities. Early BCIs demonstrated spelling and device control using EEG and single neuron signals. Current BCIs can control cursors, robotic arms, wheelchairs using EEG, ECoG, and intracortical signals. Future advances depend on improved signal acquisition, validation of BCIs for real-world use, and improved reliability approaching natural function.
Human level artificial general intelligence agiKarlos Svoboda
This document discusses different scenarios for the future development of artificial general intelligence (AGI). It begins by contrasting narrow AI, which focuses on solving specific problems, with AGI, which would involve a system that can understand itself, generalize knowledge across domains, and transfer skills like humans. The document then outlines several possible scenarios using the framework of scenario analysis: 1) steady incremental progress of narrow AI eventually reaching AGI, 2) narrow AI continues successfully but AGI is not achieved, and 3) AGI is developed, rapidly improves itself, and leads to a technological singularity transforming society in unpredictable ways. It discusses these scenarios and their implications in more detail.
Ethics of security and surveillance technologies opinion 28Karlos Svoboda
This document discusses the ethics of security and surveillance technologies in the European Union. It summarizes numerous EU directives, regulations, communications and proposals related to data protection, communications surveillance, aviation security, border control, and law enforcement. It establishes the EGE's role in advising the EU on these issues and ensuring technologies respect fundamental rights and ethics.
Ethical aspect of ICT Implants in the Human bodyKarlos Svoboda
The document discusses ethical aspects of implanting information and communication technology (ICT) devices in the human body. It summarizes Opinion No. 20 issued by the European Group on Ethics in Science and New Technologies, which examines the ethical issues arising from ICT implants. The opinion addresses concerns regarding threats to human dignity, autonomy and privacy from implants that can permanently track individuals or remotely change the information contained. It notes some implants require special precaution due to risks of being difficult to remove, influencing psychic functions, or enabling social surveillance and manipulation.
Emerging Technoethics of Human Interaction with Communication, Bionic and Rob...Karlos Svoboda
AHS may be that f... system
In this deliverable, the protection and promotion of human rights is explored in connection with various case-studies in robotics, bionics, and AI agent technologies. This is done along various dimensions, prominently including human dignity, autonomy, responsibility, privacy,liberty, fairness, justice, and personal identity.
Ethical case-studies in robotics concern learning robots, unmanned combat air vehicles,robot companions, surgery robots, and a robotic street cleaning system. Case-studies illustrating current developments of the field with imminent potential applications comprise the robotic street cleaning system, surgery robots, and the unmanned air vehicles. Robots making extensive use of learning capabilities and robots acting as companions to human
beings represent somewhat more distant possibilities, enabling one to connect in meaningful ways an analysis of short-term ethical issues in robotics with a pro-active interest in longterm ethical issues.
The bionics case-studies considered here concern specific kinds of implants in the human body, investing the human peripheral or central nervous system, and other kinds of noninvasive brain-computer interfaces. These case-studies are closely related to the robotics case-studies, insofar as these bionic technologies enable one to connect to and often control robotic effectors and sensors. Ethical issues examined in connection with these technologies concern both a short-term perspective, mostly arising from their therapeutic uses, and a longterm perspective, mostly arising from the possibility of extending communication, control, cognitive, and perceptual capabilities of both disabled and non-disabled individuals.
This networking of humans with both robotic and computer-based information systems motivates the inclusion of a case-study about AI agent technologies in this report, concerning systems that have been with us for quite a while, that is, adaptive hypermedia systems for
educational applications. These technologies enable one to design and implement software agents that are similar to robotic agents, also from an ethical standpoint, insofar as they are capable of, e.g., autonomous action, reasoning, perception, and planning.
Ethical issues examined in this report will be amplified from the convergence of softbot and robotic technologies directly interacting with human beings and other biological systems by means of bionic interfaces. This long-term perspective shows that the case-studies examined here - which are significant in their own right from the isolated perspectives of robotics,bionics, and AI - can soon become parts of broader ethical problems that we will have to address and come with in the near future.
Some futurists and artificial intelligence experts envision credible scenarios in which synthetic brains will, within this century, extend the functionality of our own brains to the point where they will rival and then surpass the power of an or-ganic human brain. At the same time, humans seem to have no limitations when it comes to finding ways to attack the computerized devices that others have invent-ed. Attackers have successfully compromised computers, mobile phones, ATMs, telephone networks, and even networked power grids. If neural devices fulfill the promise of treatment, and enhance our quality of lives and functionality—which appears likely, given the preliminary clinical success demonstrated from neuropros-thetics— their use and adoption will likely grow in the future. When this happens, inevitably, a wide variety of legal, security, and public policy concerns will follow. We will begin this article with an overview of brain implants and neural devic-es and their likely uses in the future. We will then discuss the legal issues that will arise from the intersection among neural devices, information security, cybercrime, and the law.
Nanotechnology, ubiquitous computing and the internet of thingsKarlos Svoboda
The aim of this report is to provide a review of current developments in nanotechnology, ubiquitous
computing and what is increasingly being referred to as “domotics” – the integration of domestic architectures (domus) with information systems and devices (imformatics). The report will also provide a preliminary analysis of the potential impacts of these developments on the right to privacy and to data protection.
These areas of technological development represent the convergence of two domains of current research – nanoscience and distributed computing. Much of the existing literature suggests that advances in nanotechnology are likely to operate as a underlying suite of techniques that will enable the development of miniaturised and distributed information systems and the integration of informatics devices into a range of everyday consumer goods and household architectures. As we outline below the convergence of nanotechnology and research in ubiquitous and distributed systems is likely to result in the development of a range of new sensor technologies and advances in surveillance and monitoring techniques, deployed in civilian, military and security contexts. For these reasons advances in nanotechnology and ubiquitous computing are likely to intensify existing concerns associated with data collection and the right to privacy.
In order to provide some background to our review of these issues in this section of the report we outline definitions of the field and current trends in surveillance, data-mining and monitoring.
Identity REvolution multi disciplinary perspectivesKarlos Svoboda
The identity [r]evolution is happening. Who are
you, who am I in the information society ?
In recent years, the convergence of several factors – technological, political, economic –
has accelerated a fundamental change in our networked world. On a technological level, information
becomes easier to gather, to store, to exchange
and to process. The belief that more information
brings more security has been a strong political
driver to promote information gathering since September 11. Profiling intends to transform information into knowledge in order to anticipate one’s behaviour, or needs, or preferences. It can lead to
categorizations according to some specific risk criteria, for example, or to direct and personalized
marketing. As a consequence, new forms of identities appear. They are not necessarily related to our
names anymore. They are based on information,
on traces that we leave when we act or interact,
when we go somewhere or just stay in one place,
or even sometimes when we make a choice. They
are related to the SIM cards of our mobile phones,
to our credit card numbers, to the pseudonyms
that we use on the Internet, to our email addresses,
to the IP addresses of our computers, to our profiles… Like traditional identities, these new forms of
identities can allow us to distinguish an individual
within a group of people, or describe this person as
belonging to a community or a category.
MBAN medical body area network - first report and orderKarlos Svoboda
This document from the Federal Communications Commission establishes rules to permit new Medical Body Area Network (MBAN) devices to operate in the 2360-2400 MHz band. It adopts rules allowing secondary, non-interference based MBAN operations under a license-by-rule framework. It also establishes a registration and coordination process for MBAN users in the 2360-2390 MHz portion of the band to address compatibility with incumbent operations. The document proposes criteria for designating a frequency coordinator to manage these registration and coordination activities.
Intimate technology - the battle for our body and behaviourKarlos Svoboda
The document discusses how technology is becoming more intimate through devices that are inside our bodies, between us, that know information about us, and mimic human behaviors and traits. It explores how this is leading to humans being viewed more as machines that can be improved, machines taking on more human-like qualities, and changes to human interactions. Key questions raised include how close technology can and should get to us and whether intimacy and technology can truly be compatible concepts.
For ages, humans have developed cures for diseases and devised techniques which make the hardships of life more endurable. All these were believed to make human life more
humane, i.e. to help humans to live out their inherent (natural, God-given) potentiality to a fuller extent. Recent technology, known as human enhancement, challenges this 'natural'normativity: going beyond restoring wellbeing and optimizing human potentiality, enhancement also develops capacities which can, in a sense, be called new. Chemicals have become available that increase physical performance in, for example the field of sports. Other chemicals enhance psychological endurance, mood, and cognition. Work is in progress on developing functional implants within the body, such as computer chips
integrated in the brain, with the aim of enhancing performance beyond what humans are naturally capable of. Changes are being made to body cells and systems, and techniques are being discussed to change human genes. Finally, techniques are being developed, and in part already applied, which extend the human life-span. Human Enhancement is about trying to make changes to minds and bodies – to characteristics, abilities, emotions
and capacities – beyond what we currently regard as normal.
Making perfect life european governance challenges in 21st Century Bio-engine...Karlos Svoboda
The STOA project ‘Making Perfect Life’ looked into four fields of 21st century bioengineering: engineering of living artefacts, engineering of the body, engineering
of the brain, and engineering of intelligent artefacts. This report describes the main results of the project.
The report shows how developments in the four fields of bio-engineering are shaped by two megatrends: “biology becoming technology” and “technology becoming biology”. These developments result in a broadening of the bioengineering debate in our society. The report addresses the long term viewsthat are inspiring this debate and
discusses a multitude of ethical, legal and social issues that arise from bioengineering developments in the fields described. Against this background four specific developments are studied in more detail: the rise of human genome sequencing, the market introduction of neurodevices, the capturing by information technology of the psychological and physiological states of users, and
the pursuit of standardisation in synthetic biology. These developments are taken in this report as a starting point for an analysis of some of the main European governance challenges in 21st century bio-engineering.
Ambient Intelligence is a future vision where technology is integrated into people's environments and can understand and respond to their needs and behaviors. This report examines how Ambient Intelligence could impact healthcare. It identifies five levels of increasing intelligence - from embedding sensors to anticipating needs. Interviews with healthcare stakeholders explored opportunities and challenges around personalized care, like who has access to health data and for what purposes. Collective agreements are needed to ensure Ambient Intelligence enhances rather than threatens patient interests. The report aims to start a debate on these issues.
GRAY MATTERS Integrative Approaches for Neuroscience, Ethics, and SocietyKarlos Svoboda
This document discusses the importance of integrating ethics into neuroscience research. It notes that while neuroscience research raises many common ethical issues around privacy, consent and risk minimization, it also raises unique issues around privacy of thoughts, threats to personal volition and self-determination. Neuroscience highlights the complex relationships between human thought, emotion and action. The document emphasizes that integrating ethics into neuroscience research from the start can help address these issues and ensure research considers its societal implications. It provides recommendations to guide effective integration of ethics in neuroscience.
This document discusses concerns about government use of neuroscience techniques to read people's minds against their will. It argues that while mind reading has long been possible through analyzing facial expressions and behavior, recent advances in neuroimaging techniques like fMRI have generated fears that governments could soon directly access people's private thoughts. However, the document cautions against overstating the current capabilities of neuroscience, noting that tools like fMRI are not true "mind readers." It argues we should thoughtfully examine how constitutional protections could apply to involuntary neuroimaging, rather than panicking about hypothetical mind reading abilities. An important question is how the law should treat certain government-compelled neuroscience evidence.
Biotechnology and science probing the mindKarlos Svoboda
This document discusses issues around the use of neuroscience evidence in legal cases. It describes two main types of neuroscience evidence - brain scans used for lie detection and determining cognitive ability. While this technology is promising, there are still many challenges around reliability and getting such evidence admitted in court. A key open question is whether brain scans should be considered a search of physical brain cells under the 4th Amendment or a statement of information from the individual under the 5th Amendment right against self-incrimination. This characterization could have significant legal implications as laws have not kept pace with advancing neuroscience technology.
This document is the table of contents for a book titled "Values and Ethics for the 21st Century". The book is divided into five parts covering various topics related to ethics in a globalized world, including ethics in business, finance, science/technology, development/poverty/environment, and other global issues. It contains introductions and summaries for each chapter from numerous authors on subjects like global economic ethics, global governance, immigration, human enhancement, environmental ethics, and more. The goal is to discuss how universal ethical principles can help address the major challenges of the 21st century in an era of rapid globalization and technological change.
The above discussion focused on compensation (or restitution) through
providing medical care or the funds to remunerate participants in human
subjects research for the direct costs of medical care for injuries that have
proximately resulted from their participation in research.
This document from the British Medical Association discusses the ethical aspects of cognitive enhancements. It explores various methods of cognitive enhancement including nutrition, pharmaceuticals, brain stimulation, and genetics. It examines the potential benefits and harms, issues of equity and coercion, and implications for human identity and society. It considers whether different enhancement methods raise different moral issues. It discusses whether limits should be placed on individual choice and whether regulation is needed. It concludes by posing key questions to facilitate public debate on how society should respond to advances in cognitive enhancement technologies.
Brain machine interface and limb reanimationKarlos Svoboda
This document summarizes recent advances in brain machine interface (BMI) and limb reanimation technologies that aim to restore function after spinal cord injury. BMI systems analyze brain signals to command external devices, while limb reanimation technologies like intraspinal microstimulation activate neuronal pathways below the injury. The ultimate goal is to integrate these approaches into a bypass system. Key challenges include developing asynchronous BMI systems for safe, independent home use and optimizing intraspinal microstimulation electrode design and parameters. Overcoming these challenges could realize the goal of restoring limb movement through a cortical signal-driven spinal cord bypass.
Brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) acquire brain signals, analyze them, and translate them into commands to control devices. BCIs do not use normal motor pathways. The goal is to restore function for people with disabilities. Early BCIs demonstrated spelling and device control using EEG and single neuron signals. Current BCIs can control cursors, robotic arms, wheelchairs using EEG, ECoG, and intracortical signals. Future advances depend on improved signal acquisition, validation of BCIs for real-world use, and improved reliability approaching natural function.
Human level artificial general intelligence agiKarlos Svoboda
This document discusses different scenarios for the future development of artificial general intelligence (AGI). It begins by contrasting narrow AI, which focuses on solving specific problems, with AGI, which would involve a system that can understand itself, generalize knowledge across domains, and transfer skills like humans. The document then outlines several possible scenarios using the framework of scenario analysis: 1) steady incremental progress of narrow AI eventually reaching AGI, 2) narrow AI continues successfully but AGI is not achieved, and 3) AGI is developed, rapidly improves itself, and leads to a technological singularity transforming society in unpredictable ways. It discusses these scenarios and their implications in more detail.