This document summarizes a bankruptcy court ruling on confirmation of a reorganization plan for Horsehead Holding Corp. The court found that while the plan was proposed in good faith, the lack of a market check meant the only evidence of value was competing expert testimony. The court determined that equity holders' valuation of $842 million using a discounted cash flow method was reasonable. However, the court had not yet made a final determination on whether the plan satisfied the absolute priority rule's requirement that creditors not receive more than full repayment, thereby impairing junior creditors and equity holders.