Gospel political
•
0 likes•28 views
The document outlines four categories - descriptive, interpretive, normative, and evaluative - for developing gospel-informed political norms. The descriptive category views the kingdom as having spiritual dynamics. The interpretive category takes a providential mindset rather than one of scarcity. The evaluative category aims for unitive goals beyond practical and moral concerns alone. The normative category sees freedom as serving unitive aims in a noncoercive manner, with subsidiarity principles favoring individualization over socialization but not absolutely.
Report
Share
Report
Share
Download to read offline
Recommended
JordanJames_Resume_Blue-2
Jordan James is a musician and composer based in Brooklyn, NY. He has experience in music production for TV shows, as a studio audio technician, and as musical director for dance and theater productions. He holds a Bachelor's and Master's degree in French Horn Performance from The Juilliard School and has performed extensively both as a classical musician and in other genres.
Level 1 - Grundregeln
"Recherche in sozialen Netzwerken" - Seminar an der Akademie für Publizistik. 22. 23. März 2010 Kontakt: m@marcus-boesch.de
Level 01 - Werkzeugkasten
"Recherche in sozialen Netzwerken" - Seminar an der Akademie für Publizistik. 22. - 23. März 2010. Kontakt: m@marcus-boesch.de
Fachartikel in direkt messende tpms TireMoni
tpms - TireMoni Reifendruckkontrolle, direkt messende Systeme kurz erklärt.
Arabic uae e_services_user_manual
The document discusses a new service being launched by Moie Serv to provide document summarization in 3 sentences or less. The service aims to extract the key details and essential information from documents in a concise manner. It can summarize documents from legal, medical, academic and news domains. Customers will be able to access the summarization tool through Moie Serv's website.
Ingles
This document discusses a research project from the Institución Educativa Técnico Industrial Simona Duque in Marinilla, Antioquia, Colombia. The research question aims to improve the wildlife, flora, and water quality in a ravine. The design is focused on improving resources to have a better stream and wildlife in the future. The justification is that this project will purify the water and improve the environment around the stream, which is currently polluted. The general objective is to improve the resources to ultimately have a better stream and wildlife.
Recommended
JordanJames_Resume_Blue-2
Jordan James is a musician and composer based in Brooklyn, NY. He has experience in music production for TV shows, as a studio audio technician, and as musical director for dance and theater productions. He holds a Bachelor's and Master's degree in French Horn Performance from The Juilliard School and has performed extensively both as a classical musician and in other genres.
Level 1 - Grundregeln
"Recherche in sozialen Netzwerken" - Seminar an der Akademie für Publizistik. 22. 23. März 2010 Kontakt: m@marcus-boesch.de
Level 01 - Werkzeugkasten
"Recherche in sozialen Netzwerken" - Seminar an der Akademie für Publizistik. 22. - 23. März 2010. Kontakt: m@marcus-boesch.de
Fachartikel in direkt messende tpms TireMoni
tpms - TireMoni Reifendruckkontrolle, direkt messende Systeme kurz erklärt.
Arabic uae e_services_user_manual
The document discusses a new service being launched by Moie Serv to provide document summarization in 3 sentences or less. The service aims to extract the key details and essential information from documents in a concise manner. It can summarize documents from legal, medical, academic and news domains. Customers will be able to access the summarization tool through Moie Serv's website.
Ingles
This document discusses a research project from the Institución Educativa Técnico Industrial Simona Duque in Marinilla, Antioquia, Colombia. The research question aims to improve the wildlife, flora, and water quality in a ravine. The design is focused on improving resources to have a better stream and wildlife in the future. The justification is that this project will purify the water and improve the environment around the stream, which is currently polluted. The general objective is to improve the resources to ultimately have a better stream and wildlife.
Am mama
Un hijo describe a su madre como la flor más hermosa de su jardín, más bella que un jazmín por su color. La recuerda con amor porque ha sido lo más querido en su vida y la rosa más bella en su jardín florecido.
Levels of consciousness
This document discusses core spiritual experiences through different lenses: intrasubjective integrity, intraobjective identity, intersubjective intimacy, and interobjective indeterminacy. It suggests asking how spiritualities shape one's will, self, other, god, and cosmos through these lenses. Rather than focusing on what root metaphor best describes ontologies and anthropologies, it emphasizes how spiritualities increasingly nuance one's memory to hope, understanding to faith, and will to love. It also references Thomas Merton, Thomas Keating, and Basil Pennington's discussions of levels of consciousness like uroboric, typhonic, and mental-egoic as relating to this topic.
Question 4
The target audience for the media product is males and females aged 16-24. The price of the magazine is kept low at £2.50 since this age group has disposable income but may not earn much. The magazine covers a variety of music genres to appeal to different musical tastes and features acoustic music, as shown by the guitarist on the cover, to attract fans of that style. A soft pink/red cover color is used to appeal more to female readers in addition to the typical male audience of music magazines.
Datos
La carta habla sobre la importancia de creer en uno mismo y perseguir los sueños. Aunque al principio parezca imposible, todo es posible si se combina la imaginación con la acción. Si se imagina ser el mejor y se actúa en consecuencia, se puede lograr grandes cosas sin importar lo grande o pequeño del sueño.
Mensageiro20
Este documento é uma biografia curta do poeta brasileiro Mário Quintana escrita por ele mesmo para uma revista em 1984. Ele fala sobre seu nascimento em Alegrete no Rio Grande do Sul em 1906, sua personalidade modesta e orgulhosa, e inclui várias citações curtas de seus poemas que refletem sobre a vida, o amor e a morte.
Us catholic bishops and abortion part 4
This document discusses multiple strategies for reducing abortion beyond just one's presidential vote. It suggests creating a ranked list of the top 50 most effective strategies across various domains, including political, legislative, financial and directing resources accordingly. While passion is important, the author argues that too many resources have been misdirected to the least effective strategies like rhetoric over actual results. Realism is needed to make a difference on other pro-life issues rather than being ineffective on all of them.
Ein- und Ausgangsverwiegung mit Radlastwaagen von ATP Messtechnik
Für die professionelle Durchführung von Fahrzeugverwiegungen hier im Beispiel die Ein- und Ausgangsverwiegung müssen unterschiedlichen Komponenten zu einem Wiegesystem konfiguriert werden. Zwei Musterkonfigurationen für mobilen und stationären Einsatz sind in der Präsentation dargestellt. Weitere Informationen auf www.atp-waagen.de
Inflation
Printing money and quantitative easing transfers wealth involuntarily from lenders to debtors and from those with cash to those with hard assets and commodities, as it devalues currency. This often benefits those with existing debts that are collateralized by the very same hard assets and commodities that increase in value due to the currency devaluation.
Moral justification of our tragic reality via omnipathy
religious epistemology, axiological epistemology, semiotic pragmatic realism, descriptive sciences, evaluative cultures, normative philosophies, interpretive phenomenologies, meta-interpretive metaphysics and religion, divine attributes, unitary being, unitive striving, unified self, ultimate unicity, intraobjective identity, intersubjective intimacy, interobjective indeterminacy, social and ecclesiological empowerments, historical and eschatological orientations, cultural and sophiological sanctifications, economic and sacramental economies, political and soteriological liberations, theological anthropology, paterology, pneumatology, christology, trinitarian theology, mystical body, cosmic christ, exoteric religion, esoteric religion, logos, pathos, ethos, cosmos, mythos, polydoxic mysticism, orthodoxic spirituality, polypraxic mysticism, orthodoxic spirituality, polypathic mysticism, orthopathic spirituality, lonergan's authenticity as spirituality, sustained authenticity as mysticism
Emerging christianity interfaith account of orthodoxic spi
religious epistemology, axiological epistemology, semiotic pragmatic realism, descriptive sciences, evaluative cultures, normative philosophies, interpretive phenomenologies, meta-interpretive metaphysics and religion, divine attributes, unitary being, unitive striving, unified self, ultimate unicity, intraobjective identity, intersubjective intimacy, interobjective indeterminacy, social and ecclesiological empowerments, historical and eschatological orientations, cultural and sophiological sanctifications, economic and sacramental economies, political and soteriological liberations, theological anthropology, paterology, pneumatology, christology, trinitarian theology, mystical body, cosmic christ, exoteric religion, esoteric religion, logos, pathos, ethos, cosmos, mythos, polydoxic mysticism, orthodoxic spirituality, polypraxic mysticism, orthodoxic spirituality, polypathic mysticism, orthopathic spirituality, lonergan's authenticity as spirituality, sustained authenticity as mysticism
Eucharistic model
religious epistemology, axiological epistemology, semiotic pragmatic realism, descriptive sciences, evaluative cultures, normative philosophies, interpretive phenomenologies, meta-interpretive metaphysics and religion, divine attributes, unitary being, unitive striving, unified self, ultimate unicity, intraobjective identity, intersubjective intimacy, interobjective indeterminacy, social and ecclesiological empowerments, historical and eschatological orientations, cultural and sophiological sanctifications, economic and sacramental economies, political and soteriological liberations, theological anthropology, paterology, pneumatology, christology, trinitarian theology, mystical body, cosmic christ, exoteric religion, esoteric religion, logos, pathos, ethos, cosmos, mythos, polydoxic mysticism, orthodoxic spirituality, polypraxic mysticism, orthodoxic spirituality, polypathic mysticism, orthopathic spirituality, lonergan's authenticity as spirituality, sustained authenticity as mysticism
The missing divine attribute omnipathy
divine omnipotence, divine omniscience, divine omnibenevolence, divine attributes, divine omnipathy, polydoxy, theodicy, problem of evil, miracles, soft power, weak power, the hobbit, the annunciation, the incarnation, ivan karamazov and the grand inquisitor, mary's fiat, the passion of jesus, axis of...
Also found in:miracles, theodicy, the hobbit, divine attributes, the incarnation, the annunciation, polydoxy, soft power, problem of evil, marys fiat, axis of codependency, axis of cocreativity, divine omnipathy, divine omnipotence, divine omniscience, weak power, apathetic indifference, divine omnibenevolence, ivan karamazov and the grand inquisitor, the passion of jesus
In all religions we are invited to dig deeper
Thomas Merton, sophiology, soteriology, polydoxy, orthodoxy, polypathy, orthopathy, orthopraxy, polypraxy, mystical core of organized religion, perennial philosophy, exoteric religion, esoteric religion, self-authenticity, self-transcendence, interreligious dialogue, interfaith dialogue, comparative theology
A soteriological orthodoxy and sophiological polydoxy
soteriology, sophiology, orthodoxy, orthopathy, polydoxy, self-authenticity, self-transcendence, self-actualization, unitary being, unitive striving, unified self, ultimate unicity, intrasubjective integrity, intersubjective intimacy, intraobjective identity, interobjective indeterminacy, interfaith dialogue, interreligious dialogue, comparative theology, philosophical theology, theological anthropology
Deconstructing deconstructionism
radical deconstructionism, postmodernistic, radically deconstructive postmodernism, postmodern faith, john sobert sylvest, pragmatic semiotic realism, religious realism, defense of metaphysics, john caputo, derrida, postmodern christianity, homebrewed christianity
Faith between a naive realism and radical deconstructionism
naive realism, radical deconstructionism, epistemic virtue, normative justification, defense of metaphysics, defense of faith, moral probabilism, epistemic probabilism, scholastic notation, reasonableness of faith
In defense of metaphysics and its meaningfulness
metaphysics, natural theology, philosophical theology, theology of nature, john haught, joseph bracken, philip clayton, david ray griffin, a.n. whitehead, charles sanders peirce, charles hartshorne, john milbank, catherine keller, thomas oord, monica coleman, tripp fuller, panentheism, john caputo, process theology, evolutionary epistemology, fallibilism, john sobert sylvest, malunkyaputta, nominalism, essentialism, univocity of being, analogy of being, god concept, epistemic indeterminacy, ontological undecidability, entropic erasure, problem of induction, godel's incompleteness theorems, infinite semiosis, self authenticity, self transcendence, self actualization, soteriological trajectory, sophiological trajectory, polydoxy, radical orthodoxy, radical hermeneutics, homebrewed christianity
More Related Content
Viewers also liked
Am mama
Un hijo describe a su madre como la flor más hermosa de su jardín, más bella que un jazmín por su color. La recuerda con amor porque ha sido lo más querido en su vida y la rosa más bella en su jardín florecido.
Levels of consciousness
This document discusses core spiritual experiences through different lenses: intrasubjective integrity, intraobjective identity, intersubjective intimacy, and interobjective indeterminacy. It suggests asking how spiritualities shape one's will, self, other, god, and cosmos through these lenses. Rather than focusing on what root metaphor best describes ontologies and anthropologies, it emphasizes how spiritualities increasingly nuance one's memory to hope, understanding to faith, and will to love. It also references Thomas Merton, Thomas Keating, and Basil Pennington's discussions of levels of consciousness like uroboric, typhonic, and mental-egoic as relating to this topic.
Question 4
The target audience for the media product is males and females aged 16-24. The price of the magazine is kept low at £2.50 since this age group has disposable income but may not earn much. The magazine covers a variety of music genres to appeal to different musical tastes and features acoustic music, as shown by the guitarist on the cover, to attract fans of that style. A soft pink/red cover color is used to appeal more to female readers in addition to the typical male audience of music magazines.
Datos
La carta habla sobre la importancia de creer en uno mismo y perseguir los sueños. Aunque al principio parezca imposible, todo es posible si se combina la imaginación con la acción. Si se imagina ser el mejor y se actúa en consecuencia, se puede lograr grandes cosas sin importar lo grande o pequeño del sueño.
Mensageiro20
Este documento é uma biografia curta do poeta brasileiro Mário Quintana escrita por ele mesmo para uma revista em 1984. Ele fala sobre seu nascimento em Alegrete no Rio Grande do Sul em 1906, sua personalidade modesta e orgulhosa, e inclui várias citações curtas de seus poemas que refletem sobre a vida, o amor e a morte.
Us catholic bishops and abortion part 4
This document discusses multiple strategies for reducing abortion beyond just one's presidential vote. It suggests creating a ranked list of the top 50 most effective strategies across various domains, including political, legislative, financial and directing resources accordingly. While passion is important, the author argues that too many resources have been misdirected to the least effective strategies like rhetoric over actual results. Realism is needed to make a difference on other pro-life issues rather than being ineffective on all of them.
Ein- und Ausgangsverwiegung mit Radlastwaagen von ATP Messtechnik
Für die professionelle Durchführung von Fahrzeugverwiegungen hier im Beispiel die Ein- und Ausgangsverwiegung müssen unterschiedlichen Komponenten zu einem Wiegesystem konfiguriert werden. Zwei Musterkonfigurationen für mobilen und stationären Einsatz sind in der Präsentation dargestellt. Weitere Informationen auf www.atp-waagen.de
Inflation
Printing money and quantitative easing transfers wealth involuntarily from lenders to debtors and from those with cash to those with hard assets and commodities, as it devalues currency. This often benefits those with existing debts that are collateralized by the very same hard assets and commodities that increase in value due to the currency devaluation.
Viewers also liked (12)
Ein- und Ausgangsverwiegung mit Radlastwaagen von ATP Messtechnik
Ein- und Ausgangsverwiegung mit Radlastwaagen von ATP Messtechnik
More from johnboy_philothea_net
Moral justification of our tragic reality via omnipathy
religious epistemology, axiological epistemology, semiotic pragmatic realism, descriptive sciences, evaluative cultures, normative philosophies, interpretive phenomenologies, meta-interpretive metaphysics and religion, divine attributes, unitary being, unitive striving, unified self, ultimate unicity, intraobjective identity, intersubjective intimacy, interobjective indeterminacy, social and ecclesiological empowerments, historical and eschatological orientations, cultural and sophiological sanctifications, economic and sacramental economies, political and soteriological liberations, theological anthropology, paterology, pneumatology, christology, trinitarian theology, mystical body, cosmic christ, exoteric religion, esoteric religion, logos, pathos, ethos, cosmos, mythos, polydoxic mysticism, orthodoxic spirituality, polypraxic mysticism, orthodoxic spirituality, polypathic mysticism, orthopathic spirituality, lonergan's authenticity as spirituality, sustained authenticity as mysticism
Emerging christianity interfaith account of orthodoxic spi
religious epistemology, axiological epistemology, semiotic pragmatic realism, descriptive sciences, evaluative cultures, normative philosophies, interpretive phenomenologies, meta-interpretive metaphysics and religion, divine attributes, unitary being, unitive striving, unified self, ultimate unicity, intraobjective identity, intersubjective intimacy, interobjective indeterminacy, social and ecclesiological empowerments, historical and eschatological orientations, cultural and sophiological sanctifications, economic and sacramental economies, political and soteriological liberations, theological anthropology, paterology, pneumatology, christology, trinitarian theology, mystical body, cosmic christ, exoteric religion, esoteric religion, logos, pathos, ethos, cosmos, mythos, polydoxic mysticism, orthodoxic spirituality, polypraxic mysticism, orthodoxic spirituality, polypathic mysticism, orthopathic spirituality, lonergan's authenticity as spirituality, sustained authenticity as mysticism
Eucharistic model
religious epistemology, axiological epistemology, semiotic pragmatic realism, descriptive sciences, evaluative cultures, normative philosophies, interpretive phenomenologies, meta-interpretive metaphysics and religion, divine attributes, unitary being, unitive striving, unified self, ultimate unicity, intraobjective identity, intersubjective intimacy, interobjective indeterminacy, social and ecclesiological empowerments, historical and eschatological orientations, cultural and sophiological sanctifications, economic and sacramental economies, political and soteriological liberations, theological anthropology, paterology, pneumatology, christology, trinitarian theology, mystical body, cosmic christ, exoteric religion, esoteric religion, logos, pathos, ethos, cosmos, mythos, polydoxic mysticism, orthodoxic spirituality, polypraxic mysticism, orthodoxic spirituality, polypathic mysticism, orthopathic spirituality, lonergan's authenticity as spirituality, sustained authenticity as mysticism
The missing divine attribute omnipathy
divine omnipotence, divine omniscience, divine omnibenevolence, divine attributes, divine omnipathy, polydoxy, theodicy, problem of evil, miracles, soft power, weak power, the hobbit, the annunciation, the incarnation, ivan karamazov and the grand inquisitor, mary's fiat, the passion of jesus, axis of...
Also found in:miracles, theodicy, the hobbit, divine attributes, the incarnation, the annunciation, polydoxy, soft power, problem of evil, marys fiat, axis of codependency, axis of cocreativity, divine omnipathy, divine omnipotence, divine omniscience, weak power, apathetic indifference, divine omnibenevolence, ivan karamazov and the grand inquisitor, the passion of jesus
In all religions we are invited to dig deeper
Thomas Merton, sophiology, soteriology, polydoxy, orthodoxy, polypathy, orthopathy, orthopraxy, polypraxy, mystical core of organized religion, perennial philosophy, exoteric religion, esoteric religion, self-authenticity, self-transcendence, interreligious dialogue, interfaith dialogue, comparative theology
A soteriological orthodoxy and sophiological polydoxy
soteriology, sophiology, orthodoxy, orthopathy, polydoxy, self-authenticity, self-transcendence, self-actualization, unitary being, unitive striving, unified self, ultimate unicity, intrasubjective integrity, intersubjective intimacy, intraobjective identity, interobjective indeterminacy, interfaith dialogue, interreligious dialogue, comparative theology, philosophical theology, theological anthropology
Deconstructing deconstructionism
radical deconstructionism, postmodernistic, radically deconstructive postmodernism, postmodern faith, john sobert sylvest, pragmatic semiotic realism, religious realism, defense of metaphysics, john caputo, derrida, postmodern christianity, homebrewed christianity
Faith between a naive realism and radical deconstructionism
naive realism, radical deconstructionism, epistemic virtue, normative justification, defense of metaphysics, defense of faith, moral probabilism, epistemic probabilism, scholastic notation, reasonableness of faith
In defense of metaphysics and its meaningfulness
metaphysics, natural theology, philosophical theology, theology of nature, john haught, joseph bracken, philip clayton, david ray griffin, a.n. whitehead, charles sanders peirce, charles hartshorne, john milbank, catherine keller, thomas oord, monica coleman, tripp fuller, panentheism, john caputo, process theology, evolutionary epistemology, fallibilism, john sobert sylvest, malunkyaputta, nominalism, essentialism, univocity of being, analogy of being, god concept, epistemic indeterminacy, ontological undecidability, entropic erasure, problem of induction, godel's incompleteness theorems, infinite semiosis, self authenticity, self transcendence, self actualization, soteriological trajectory, sophiological trajectory, polydoxy, radical orthodoxy, radical hermeneutics, homebrewed christianity
The role of change in metaphysics not so fast
Aurobindo, Hartshorne, dynamic metaphysic, metaphysics as change, essentialism vs nominalism vs pragmatism, nonstrict identity, no self, empirical self, axis of codependency, axis of co-creativity, pathetic interference, apathetic indifference, sympathetic intervention, empathetic influence, coercion vs persuasion, weak power, emergent reality, emergence, panentheism
Orthodoxy weds polydoxy god as lover
deconstruction, caputo, polydoxy, orthodoxy, religious realism, semiotic realism, radical hermeneutics, soteriological trajectories, sophiological trajectories, comparative theology, perennial philosophy, mystical core of organized religions, unitive striving, analogy of being, god concept, unitary being, univocity of being, ultimate unicity, equivocity of being, panentheism, nominalism vs essentialism, dogmatic concept, theoretic concept, semiotic concept, heuristic concept, mysterium tremendum et fascinans, lonergan's authenticity, sustained authenticity, self-transcendence, self actualization, false self, apophatic theology,
http://homebrewedchristianity.com/2014/03/12/hold-god-loosely-like-a-lover/
To john caputo yes, but
john caputo, brian mclaren, deconstructionism, radical deconstructionism, polydoxy, orthodoxy, polypathy, polypraxy, postmodernism, postmodern religion, comparative theology, perennial philosophy, mystical core of organized religion, propositional religion, logocentrism, pathocentrism
Ontologizing schmontologizing, philosophical or theological
john caputo, theo-ontology, theo-ontological, onto-theology, onto-theological, ontologizing, philosophy of religion, philosophical theology, natural theology, theology of nature, logocentrism, radical deconstruction, radical deconstructionism, postmodern deconstruction, john sobert sylvest, lonergan's authenticity, sustained authenticity, eucharistic celebration, demythologizing
Deconstruct this!
john caputo, jacques derrida, deconstruction, radical deconstruction, postmodern, postmodernism, postmodern critique, pragmatic semiotic realism, david abrams, john sobert sylvest, terry deacon, terrence deacon, symbolic species, emergentism
The (semiotic) failure of logocentrism
mythos, logos, ethos, pathos, interpretive religion, descriptive science, normative philosophy, evaluative culture, non-negotiated dogmatic concepts, negotiated theoretic concepts, non-negotiable semiotic concepts, in-negotiation heuristic concepts,
A look at panentheism from a semiotic vantage point
The document discusses the benefits of exercise for mental health. Regular physical activity can help reduce anxiety and depression and improve mood and cognitive functioning. Exercise boosts blood flow, releases endorphins, and promotes changes in the brain which help regulate emotions and stress levels.
Dorothy day and gospel norms
dorothy day, anarchist, pacifist, anarchism, pacifism, distributism, communitarian, corporal works of mercy, spiritual works of mercy, coercive government, anti-statist, preferential option for the poor, preferential option for the marginalized
Interfaith dialogue as sophiologic gift exchange
interfaith dialogue, sophiologic gift exchange, soteriologic truth claim sort, polydoxy, polypraxy, polypathy, interreligious dialogue, amos yong, brian mclaren, marshall mcluhan, figure ground reversal, unitary being, unitive striving, ultimate unicity, univocity of being, analogy of being
More from johnboy_philothea_net (20)
Moral justification of our tragic reality via omnipathy
Moral justification of our tragic reality via omnipathy
Emerging christianity interfaith account of orthodoxic spi
Emerging christianity interfaith account of orthodoxic spi
A soteriological orthodoxy and sophiological polydoxy
A soteriological orthodoxy and sophiological polydoxy
Faith between a naive realism and radical deconstructionism
Faith between a naive realism and radical deconstructionism
Ontologizing schmontologizing, philosophical or theological
Ontologizing schmontologizing, philosophical or theological
A look at panentheism from a semiotic vantage point
A look at panentheism from a semiotic vantage point
Gospel political
- 1. gospel-informed political norms descriptive = kingdom |interpretive = providential|normative = freedom| evaluative = unitive descriptive kingdom, a dominion w/spiritual dynamics interpretive providential mindset vs scarcity evaluative unitive goals beyond practical & moral concerns normative freedom agenda in the service of unitive aims, hence noncoercive bias subsidiarity principles w/individualized vs socialized bias not absolute default strategic biases and not absolute moral values norms for intervention - frequency/amplitude axes of cocreativty & codependency shortcomings no eschatological vs temporal distinction no personal vocation vs political statecraft distinction compassionate practical accomodation not a theoretical theological capitulation (lawyering) 1