This document summarizes the challenges and opportunities facing Bulgaria in managing EU structural funds for the 2014-2020 period. It discusses:
1) The main challenges include adhering to strict budget discipline, implementing actual economic and social reforms, and ensuring fund absorption. Bulgaria addresses this through legislation.
2) Lessons from 2007-2013 include a lack of unified management approach. A new Management of ESI Funds Act was adopted in 2015 to address these issues.
3) The new Act provides opportunities like a predictable funding environment, unified procedures, and an administrative law framework recognizing the public nature of fund management.
The financial crisis of 2007-2009 led to a renewed increase in government deficits and debts in many EU countries, causing a full-fledged fiscal crisis in Greece and severe fiscal pressures in other euro-area countries. This has prompted a series of proposals for improving the fiscal framework of the European Monetary Union, the Excessive Deficit Procedure and the Stability and Growth Pact. The first part of this paper reviews the main properties and developments of that framework until 2007. On that basis, it discusses the recent proposals for reform, which range from marginal improvements of the existing framework to the introduction of an explicit framework for managing fiscal crises in the member states, and the expansion of the scope of policy coordination to address macro economic imbalances and the competitiveness of the member states. We find the proposal of a mechanism for dealing with government default most useful. Attempts to suppress current account imbalances and to target national competitiveness positions would most likely result in serious economic losses and do damage to the internal market of the EU. This would increase the wedge between members and non-members of the euro area.
Authored by: Jurgen von Hagen
Published in 2010
Profile of the Audit Office of Lebanon presented at the regional conference for Supreme Audit Institutions of European Neighbourhood South countries, co-organised by the Algerian Court of Accounts and SIGMA in Algiers, 16-17 December 2014
Agenda of the workshop on Public finance management and audit in Jordan, Amman 4-5 November 2014. For further information please contact brian.finn@oecd.org.
This document discusses Bulgaria's challenges and opportunities in joining the Eurozone. It notes that Bulgaria aims to become the 21st Eurozone member but faces political and economic obstacles. While Bulgaria has joined the Banking Union and passed legislation to adopt the Euro, its target date was pushed back from 2024 to 2025 as it did not meet inflation criteria and had legal issues to resolve. The document concludes that Bulgaria must address all obstacles to adopting the Euro in line with EU values and meet necessary convergence and legal criteria.
The European Commission published its annual neighbourhood package on 20 March 2013, which included country reports on developments in 2012 for countries bordering the EU, including the Republic of Moldova. The EU-Moldova political dialogue continued to deepen in 2012 and negotiations of an EU-Moldova Association Agreement made significant progress. However, in early 2013 tensions within Moldova's ruling coalition led to the downfall of the government, calling political stability into question. The report recommends that Moldova continue reforms in justice, law enforcement, fighting corruption, and improving the business environment.
Discussion paper on guidelines for PIFC compliant financial inspection, Joop Vrolijk, SIGMA expert, joint SIGMA-ReSPA PIFC regional conference for EU candidate countries and potential candidates, Skopje, 19 September 2019.
Polityka spójności Unii Europejskiej jest głównym narzędziem modernizacji społecznej
i gospodarczej w państwach Europy Środkowej. Dotyczy to zwłaszcza Polski, która otrzymuje największą pomoc finansową z tego instrumentu spośród wszystkich innych państw członkowskich UE. Celem artykułu jest analiza zmian w polityce spójności pod wpływem kryzysu
w strefie euro oraz ocena tego, w jaki sposób te zmiany mogą wpłynąć na procesy modernizacyjne w najsłabiej rozwijających się państwach UE, a także szerzej – jak wpłyną na sposób
funkcjonowania integracji europejskiej.
The financial crisis of 2007-2009 led to a renewed increase in government deficits and debts in many EU countries, causing a full-fledged fiscal crisis in Greece and severe fiscal pressures in other euro-area countries. This has prompted a series of proposals for improving the fiscal framework of the European Monetary Union, the Excessive Deficit Procedure and the Stability and Growth Pact. The first part of this paper reviews the main properties and developments of that framework until 2007. On that basis, it discusses the recent proposals for reform, which range from marginal improvements of the existing framework to the introduction of an explicit framework for managing fiscal crises in the member states, and the expansion of the scope of policy coordination to address macro economic imbalances and the competitiveness of the member states. We find the proposal of a mechanism for dealing with government default most useful. Attempts to suppress current account imbalances and to target national competitiveness positions would most likely result in serious economic losses and do damage to the internal market of the EU. This would increase the wedge between members and non-members of the euro area.
Authored by: Jurgen von Hagen
Published in 2010
Profile of the Audit Office of Lebanon presented at the regional conference for Supreme Audit Institutions of European Neighbourhood South countries, co-organised by the Algerian Court of Accounts and SIGMA in Algiers, 16-17 December 2014
Agenda of the workshop on Public finance management and audit in Jordan, Amman 4-5 November 2014. For further information please contact brian.finn@oecd.org.
This document discusses Bulgaria's challenges and opportunities in joining the Eurozone. It notes that Bulgaria aims to become the 21st Eurozone member but faces political and economic obstacles. While Bulgaria has joined the Banking Union and passed legislation to adopt the Euro, its target date was pushed back from 2024 to 2025 as it did not meet inflation criteria and had legal issues to resolve. The document concludes that Bulgaria must address all obstacles to adopting the Euro in line with EU values and meet necessary convergence and legal criteria.
The European Commission published its annual neighbourhood package on 20 March 2013, which included country reports on developments in 2012 for countries bordering the EU, including the Republic of Moldova. The EU-Moldova political dialogue continued to deepen in 2012 and negotiations of an EU-Moldova Association Agreement made significant progress. However, in early 2013 tensions within Moldova's ruling coalition led to the downfall of the government, calling political stability into question. The report recommends that Moldova continue reforms in justice, law enforcement, fighting corruption, and improving the business environment.
Discussion paper on guidelines for PIFC compliant financial inspection, Joop Vrolijk, SIGMA expert, joint SIGMA-ReSPA PIFC regional conference for EU candidate countries and potential candidates, Skopje, 19 September 2019.
Polityka spójności Unii Europejskiej jest głównym narzędziem modernizacji społecznej
i gospodarczej w państwach Europy Środkowej. Dotyczy to zwłaszcza Polski, która otrzymuje największą pomoc finansową z tego instrumentu spośród wszystkich innych państw członkowskich UE. Celem artykułu jest analiza zmian w polityce spójności pod wpływem kryzysu
w strefie euro oraz ocena tego, w jaki sposób te zmiany mogą wpłynąć na procesy modernizacyjne w najsłabiej rozwijających się państwach UE, a także szerzej – jak wpłyną na sposób
funkcjonowania integracji europejskiej.
The document summarizes key aspects of the Hellenic Parliament's Parliamentary Budget Office (PBO). It outlines the PBO's legal framework, mission to monitor Greece's state budget and provide assistance to parliamentary committees. It describes the PBO's administration and functioning. The majority of the document discusses the PBO's quarterly reports, including their structure, methodology, sources, special topics covered, and some of the findings presented in past reports from 2013 to 2015 regarding Greece's economic challenges in meeting fiscal targets and implementing reforms.
Profile of the Court of Accounts of Morocco presented at the regional conference for Supreme Audit Institutions of European Neighbourhood South countries, co-organised by the Algerian Court of Accounts and SIGMA in Algiers, 16-17 December 2014
Final draft operational plan ukraine guillotineDan Pasko
This document provides an operational plan for conducting a regulatory guillotine reform in Ukraine to reduce outdated regulations. The plan outlines a comprehensive approach to review over 7,000-10,000 legal norms across all sectors. Key points include coordinating the reform with other economic initiatives, estimating potential annual cost savings of $1-1.3 billion, and completing the reform progressively over 36 months. A special committee and Guillotine Unit would manage the reform process with support from the Prime Minister. The full budget is estimated at $9.96 million over 3 years, with an initial $1.52 million needed to launch the reform while procuring full resources. The plan establishes targets and performance indicators to measure cost reductions and ensure accountability.
Agenda for the Roundtable on Independence of Supreme Audit Institutions organized by SIGMA and the Bosnian State Audit Office in Sarajevo on 8 September 2016.
Budget accessibility to participation in Latvia - Taisa Trubaca, LatviaOECD Governance
This presentation was made by Taisa Trubaca, Latvia, at the 11th Annual Meeting of Central, Eastern and South-eastern Senior Budget Officials (CESEE SBO) held in Warsaw, Poland, on 21-22 May 2015.
This curriculum vitae provides information about Daniel Ioan Dumitrescu, including his professional experience, education, skills, and qualifications. He has over 15 years of experience in financial services, European affairs, and management. Currently, he is the Chief Executive Officer of the Romanian Commodities Exchange and co-founder of the European Center for Services Investment and Financing. He holds a PhD in Cybernetics and Statistics and several professional certificates.
Public economic enterprises (PEEs) played an important role in Turkey's early economic development but have become a drag on the economy in recent decades. PEEs face numerous problems, including political interference in operations, weak personnel policies, insufficient oversight, and inefficient decision-making. They also place a financial burden on the government and limit competitiveness. PEEs are classified as state economic enterprises or institutions and are established, owned, and audited by various government bodies and agencies.
This document discusses the need for greater economic integration and coordination within the European Union to address issues revealed by the sovereign debt crisis. It argues that the EU needs more powers to enforce economic policy coordination and promote convergence between member states. It proposes giving the EU more authority to overrule national economic decisions that violate agreed targets. It also advocates developing an orderly default mechanism for member states and introducing European Debt Certificates. However, it acknowledges that increasing EU powers could exacerbate the democratic deficit, so it is important to also increase the legitimacy and accountability of EU decision-making.
Budgeting in Bulgaria - Emil NURGALIEV, BulgariaOECD Governance
This presentation was made by Emil NURGALIEV, Ministry of Finance, Bulgaria, at the 15th Annual Meeting of OECD-CESEE Senior Budget Officials held in Minsk, Belarus, on 4-5 July 2019
The Organisation of Public Financial Management Architecture by Amal Lahrlid OECD Governance
Presentation by Amal Lahrlid at the 7th annual meeting of the MENA Senior Budget Officials held on 10-11 December 2014. Find more information at http://www.oecd.org/gov/budgeting
Speech by Marta Tomovska, Minister of Information Society and Administration of the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, made at the regional conference on Public Administration Reform Challenges in Western Balkan Countries held at the OECD in Paris, 4 December 2015.
The document analyzes Slovakia's utilization of EU funds (eurofunds) between 2007-2013. It finds that eurofunds have been accompanied by jurisdictional fights and nontransparent allocation that enable corruption and clientelism. Examples of misused funds include overpriced contracts and subsidies for dubious social enterprises linked to political parties. The eurofunds also failed to achieve their goal of reducing regional disparities in unemployment. To curb corruption, the authors recommend more transparent procedures for approving fund applications and eliminating unnecessary bureaucracy.
The document summarizes the recent transformation of Greece's tax administration into an Independent Authority for Public Revenue (IAPR). Key points include:
- The IAPR was established in 2017 to operate autonomously from the Ministry of Finance with its own governance structure and budget.
- The IAPR's core functions of tax and customs administration remain the same, but it has more flexibility in areas like human resources.
- The IAPR aims to modernize operations through reforms like improving IT infrastructure, enhancing taxpayer services, and establishing transparent HR processes.
- Early results show the IAPR exceeded its 2017 revenue target and increased collection of old debt, while new debt creation slowed, reflecting improved
Royal Decree 215/2014, of 28 March, approving the Organic Statute of the Inde...airefcomunicacion
This document approves the Organic Statute of the Independent Authority for Fiscal Responsibility in Spain. The Authority was created to help the government achieve budgetary stability by continuously monitoring public finances and debt. The Statute establishes the Authority as an independent public body with its own governance structure, personnel system, and budget. It will monitor budget execution, economic forecasts, and debt levels and issue reports and recommendations to support fiscal responsibility.
Evolving of PFM for economic policy - game of tools and rules (focus on Slove...OECD Governance
This presentation was made by Irena Rostan, Slovenia, at the 12th Annual Meeting of OECD-CESEE Senior Budget Officials held in Ljubljana, Slovenia, on 28-29 June 2016
This document discusses the rule of law and its connection to the management of EU funds. It notes that the rule of law is a fundamental value of the EU and its member states. Currently, the EU has regulations to protect the EU budget if a member state breaches the rule of law. The document examines how the rule of law relates to shared management of EU funds between the EU and member states. It also discusses trends in Bulgaria relating to rule of law issues and open questions about how rule of law conditionality may affect member state sovereignty.
Independent fiscal institutions (IFIs) have more than tripled in the OECD in the past decade to promote sound fiscal policy. There are different models of IFIs, including fiscal councils, parliamentary budget offices, and those connected to audit institutions. Key to their effectiveness is independence, including in their leadership appointment and funding. While new, evidence suggests IFIs can enhance transparency and accountability when designed according to good practices.
The document summarizes key discussions from the 16th European Corporate Governance Conference that took place in Riga, Latvia on 13 May 2015. The conference focused on using corporate governance as a tool to increase competitiveness in the digital era. Panelists debated taking a principles-based versus rules-based approach. There was also discussion around making shareholder voting cheaper and less bureaucratic to increase engagement, and balancing hard law with soft law guidelines at the national level.
Progressing from budget transparency to accessibility to participation: Croat...OECD Governance
The document discusses budget transparency and citizen participation in Croatia's budget process. It covers Croatia's legal framework for transparency, participation in the Open Government Partnership, and results from the Open Budget Survey. It also describes efforts at the state level, including external experts and public discussions during lawmaking. Participation is more developed at the local level, with some cities creating online applications that educate citizens, gather input on projects, and allow simulation of budget choices.
The document summarizes key aspects of the Hellenic Parliament's Parliamentary Budget Office (PBO). It outlines the PBO's legal framework, mission to monitor Greece's state budget and provide assistance to parliamentary committees. It describes the PBO's administration and functioning. The majority of the document discusses the PBO's quarterly reports, including their structure, methodology, sources, special topics covered, and some of the findings presented in past reports from 2013 to 2015 regarding Greece's economic challenges in meeting fiscal targets and implementing reforms.
Profile of the Court of Accounts of Morocco presented at the regional conference for Supreme Audit Institutions of European Neighbourhood South countries, co-organised by the Algerian Court of Accounts and SIGMA in Algiers, 16-17 December 2014
Final draft operational plan ukraine guillotineDan Pasko
This document provides an operational plan for conducting a regulatory guillotine reform in Ukraine to reduce outdated regulations. The plan outlines a comprehensive approach to review over 7,000-10,000 legal norms across all sectors. Key points include coordinating the reform with other economic initiatives, estimating potential annual cost savings of $1-1.3 billion, and completing the reform progressively over 36 months. A special committee and Guillotine Unit would manage the reform process with support from the Prime Minister. The full budget is estimated at $9.96 million over 3 years, with an initial $1.52 million needed to launch the reform while procuring full resources. The plan establishes targets and performance indicators to measure cost reductions and ensure accountability.
Agenda for the Roundtable on Independence of Supreme Audit Institutions organized by SIGMA and the Bosnian State Audit Office in Sarajevo on 8 September 2016.
Budget accessibility to participation in Latvia - Taisa Trubaca, LatviaOECD Governance
This presentation was made by Taisa Trubaca, Latvia, at the 11th Annual Meeting of Central, Eastern and South-eastern Senior Budget Officials (CESEE SBO) held in Warsaw, Poland, on 21-22 May 2015.
This curriculum vitae provides information about Daniel Ioan Dumitrescu, including his professional experience, education, skills, and qualifications. He has over 15 years of experience in financial services, European affairs, and management. Currently, he is the Chief Executive Officer of the Romanian Commodities Exchange and co-founder of the European Center for Services Investment and Financing. He holds a PhD in Cybernetics and Statistics and several professional certificates.
Public economic enterprises (PEEs) played an important role in Turkey's early economic development but have become a drag on the economy in recent decades. PEEs face numerous problems, including political interference in operations, weak personnel policies, insufficient oversight, and inefficient decision-making. They also place a financial burden on the government and limit competitiveness. PEEs are classified as state economic enterprises or institutions and are established, owned, and audited by various government bodies and agencies.
This document discusses the need for greater economic integration and coordination within the European Union to address issues revealed by the sovereign debt crisis. It argues that the EU needs more powers to enforce economic policy coordination and promote convergence between member states. It proposes giving the EU more authority to overrule national economic decisions that violate agreed targets. It also advocates developing an orderly default mechanism for member states and introducing European Debt Certificates. However, it acknowledges that increasing EU powers could exacerbate the democratic deficit, so it is important to also increase the legitimacy and accountability of EU decision-making.
Budgeting in Bulgaria - Emil NURGALIEV, BulgariaOECD Governance
This presentation was made by Emil NURGALIEV, Ministry of Finance, Bulgaria, at the 15th Annual Meeting of OECD-CESEE Senior Budget Officials held in Minsk, Belarus, on 4-5 July 2019
The Organisation of Public Financial Management Architecture by Amal Lahrlid OECD Governance
Presentation by Amal Lahrlid at the 7th annual meeting of the MENA Senior Budget Officials held on 10-11 December 2014. Find more information at http://www.oecd.org/gov/budgeting
Speech by Marta Tomovska, Minister of Information Society and Administration of the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, made at the regional conference on Public Administration Reform Challenges in Western Balkan Countries held at the OECD in Paris, 4 December 2015.
The document analyzes Slovakia's utilization of EU funds (eurofunds) between 2007-2013. It finds that eurofunds have been accompanied by jurisdictional fights and nontransparent allocation that enable corruption and clientelism. Examples of misused funds include overpriced contracts and subsidies for dubious social enterprises linked to political parties. The eurofunds also failed to achieve their goal of reducing regional disparities in unemployment. To curb corruption, the authors recommend more transparent procedures for approving fund applications and eliminating unnecessary bureaucracy.
The document summarizes the recent transformation of Greece's tax administration into an Independent Authority for Public Revenue (IAPR). Key points include:
- The IAPR was established in 2017 to operate autonomously from the Ministry of Finance with its own governance structure and budget.
- The IAPR's core functions of tax and customs administration remain the same, but it has more flexibility in areas like human resources.
- The IAPR aims to modernize operations through reforms like improving IT infrastructure, enhancing taxpayer services, and establishing transparent HR processes.
- Early results show the IAPR exceeded its 2017 revenue target and increased collection of old debt, while new debt creation slowed, reflecting improved
Royal Decree 215/2014, of 28 March, approving the Organic Statute of the Inde...airefcomunicacion
This document approves the Organic Statute of the Independent Authority for Fiscal Responsibility in Spain. The Authority was created to help the government achieve budgetary stability by continuously monitoring public finances and debt. The Statute establishes the Authority as an independent public body with its own governance structure, personnel system, and budget. It will monitor budget execution, economic forecasts, and debt levels and issue reports and recommendations to support fiscal responsibility.
Evolving of PFM for economic policy - game of tools and rules (focus on Slove...OECD Governance
This presentation was made by Irena Rostan, Slovenia, at the 12th Annual Meeting of OECD-CESEE Senior Budget Officials held in Ljubljana, Slovenia, on 28-29 June 2016
This document discusses the rule of law and its connection to the management of EU funds. It notes that the rule of law is a fundamental value of the EU and its member states. Currently, the EU has regulations to protect the EU budget if a member state breaches the rule of law. The document examines how the rule of law relates to shared management of EU funds between the EU and member states. It also discusses trends in Bulgaria relating to rule of law issues and open questions about how rule of law conditionality may affect member state sovereignty.
Independent fiscal institutions (IFIs) have more than tripled in the OECD in the past decade to promote sound fiscal policy. There are different models of IFIs, including fiscal councils, parliamentary budget offices, and those connected to audit institutions. Key to their effectiveness is independence, including in their leadership appointment and funding. While new, evidence suggests IFIs can enhance transparency and accountability when designed according to good practices.
The document summarizes key discussions from the 16th European Corporate Governance Conference that took place in Riga, Latvia on 13 May 2015. The conference focused on using corporate governance as a tool to increase competitiveness in the digital era. Panelists debated taking a principles-based versus rules-based approach. There was also discussion around making shareholder voting cheaper and less bureaucratic to increase engagement, and balancing hard law with soft law guidelines at the national level.
Progressing from budget transparency to accessibility to participation: Croat...OECD Governance
The document discusses budget transparency and citizen participation in Croatia's budget process. It covers Croatia's legal framework for transparency, participation in the Open Government Partnership, and results from the Open Budget Survey. It also describes efforts at the state level, including external experts and public discussions during lawmaking. Participation is more developed at the local level, with some cities creating online applications that educate citizens, gather input on projects, and allow simulation of budget choices.
Similar to estif_2015_04_Savina Mihaylova-Goleminova.pdf (20)
This document provides information about the Fintech and E-Banking course, which is part of a Master's degree program in Finance, Investments, and Fintech at Sofia University in Bulgaria. The 45-hour course investigates how fintech is transforming financial services globally. It aims to produce specialists for the fintech sector in Southeast Europe. Students will learn about emerging trends like blockchain, AI, and the future of banking. Coursework includes lectures, hackathons, and presentations by fintech professionals. The program is open to graduates and professionals seeking new skills in financial innovation.
Revenue system of local self-governments in Bulgaria.pptxChristinaFortunova
The document summarizes the revenue system of local self-governments in Bulgaria. It discusses the main legal acts governing municipal revenues, the sources of revenues including local taxes, fees and state transfers. It analyzes trends in the structure of municipal revenues from 2015-2020, noting an increasing dependence on state transfers. The document also provides recommendations to increase municipal financial independence such as introducing shared taxes and updating property tax assessments.
This document provides information about international student recruitment and programs at Chungnam National University in Korea. It discusses Korea's higher education system, details about CNU including its international student population and programs. It describes CNU's dual degree programs with partner universities that allow students to earn degrees from both schools. It also outlines Korean government scholarship programs to support international students studying in Korea such as the Global Korea Scholarship. Finally it provides specifics about CNU's College of Economics and Management and the Department of International Trade, including its academic programs, scholarships, and opportunities for research cooperation.
This document provides information about international student recruitment and programs at Chungnam National University in Korea. It discusses Korea's higher education system, details about CNU including its international student population and programs. It describes CNU's dual degree programs with partner universities that allow students to earn degrees from both schools. It also outlines Korean government scholarship programs to support international students studying in Korea such as the Global Korea Scholarship. Finally it provides specifics about CNU's College of Economics and Management and Department of International Trade, including research opportunities and scholarships available.
The document discusses cyber law and conventions regarding online responsibility. It summarizes key Albanian laws related to electronic communications, electronic commerce, data protection, and other areas of cyber law. It also discusses international sources of cyber law like the UNCITRAL Model Law on Electronic Signatures and the EU Directive on Electronic Commerce. Decisions by the European Court of Human Rights are analyzed that relate to the responsibility of online news portals for user comments.
This document summarizes challenges and opportunities related to the management of European Structural and Investment Funds in Bulgaria. It discusses how Bulgaria addresses challenges through legislation and reviews lessons learned from the 2007-2013 programming period. It also examines challenges posed by recent Supreme Administrative Court practice and legal doctrine regarding the nature of relations between managing authorities and beneficiaries. The document analyzes debates around adopting a Management of ESI Funds Act to provide a unified framework and resolve issues like lack of predictability and fragmentation in rules.
This document summarizes challenges and opportunities related to the management of European Structural and Investment Funds in Bulgaria. It discusses how Bulgaria addresses challenges through legislation and reviews lessons learned from the 2007-2013 programming period. It also examines challenges posed by recent Supreme Administrative Court practice and legal doctrine regarding the nature of relations between managing authorities and beneficiaries. The document analyzes debates around adopting a Management of ESI Funds Act to provide a unified framework and resolve issues like lack of predictability and fragmentation in rules.
सुप्रीम कोर्ट ने यह भी माना था कि मजिस्ट्रेट का यह कर्तव्य है कि वह सुनिश्चित करे कि अधिकारी पीएमएलए के तहत निर्धारित प्रक्रिया के साथ-साथ संवैधानिक सुरक्षा उपायों का भी उचित रूप से पालन करें।
Business law for the students of undergraduate level. The presentation contains the summary of all the chapters under the syllabus of State University, Contract Act, Sale of Goods Act, Negotiable Instrument Act, Partnership Act, Limited Liability Act, Consumer Protection Act.
Lifting the Corporate Veil. Power Point Presentationseri bangash
"Lifting the Corporate Veil" is a legal concept that refers to the judicial act of disregarding the separate legal personality of a corporation or limited liability company (LLC). Normally, a corporation is considered a legal entity separate from its shareholders or members, meaning that the personal assets of shareholders or members are protected from the liabilities of the corporation. However, there are certain situations where courts may decide to "pierce" or "lift" the corporate veil, holding shareholders or members personally liable for the debts or actions of the corporation.
Here are some common scenarios in which courts might lift the corporate veil:
Fraud or Illegality: If shareholders or members use the corporate structure to perpetrate fraud, evade legal obligations, or engage in illegal activities, courts may disregard the corporate entity and hold those individuals personally liable.
Undercapitalization: If a corporation is formed with insufficient capital to conduct its intended business and meet its foreseeable liabilities, and this lack of capitalization results in harm to creditors or other parties, courts may lift the corporate veil to hold shareholders or members liable.
Failure to Observe Corporate Formalities: Corporations and LLCs are required to observe certain formalities, such as holding regular meetings, maintaining separate financial records, and avoiding commingling of personal and corporate assets. If these formalities are not observed and the corporate structure is used as a mere façade, courts may disregard the corporate entity.
Alter Ego: If there is such a unity of interest and ownership between the corporation and its shareholders or members that the separate personalities of the corporation and the individuals no longer exist, courts may treat the corporation as the alter ego of its owners and hold them personally liable.
Group Enterprises: In some cases, where multiple corporations are closely related or form part of a single economic unit, courts may pierce the corporate veil to achieve equity, particularly if one corporation's actions harm creditors or other stakeholders and the corporate structure is being used to shield culpable parties from liability.
This document briefly explains the June compliance calendar 2024 with income tax returns, PF, ESI, and important due dates, forms to be filled out, periods, and who should file them?.
The Future of Criminal Defense Lawyer in India.pdfveteranlegal
https://veteranlegal.in/defense-lawyer-in-india/ | Criminal defense Lawyer in India has always been a vital aspect of the country's legal system. As defenders of justice, criminal Defense Lawyer play a critical role in ensuring that individuals accused of crimes receive a fair trial and that their constitutional rights are protected. As India evolves socially, economically, and technologically, the role and future of criminal Defense Lawyer are also undergoing significant changes. This comprehensive blog explores the current landscape, challenges, technological advancements, and prospects for criminal Defense Lawyer in India.
Guide on the use of Artificial Intelligence-based tools by lawyers and law fi...Massimo Talia
This guide aims to provide information on how lawyers will be able to use the opportunities provided by AI tools and how such tools could help the business processes of small firms. Its objective is to provide lawyers with some background to understand what they can and cannot realistically expect from these products. This guide aims to give a reference point for small law practices in the EU
against which they can evaluate those classes of AI applications that are probably the most relevant for them.
Matthew Professional CV experienced Government LiaisonMattGardner52
As an experienced Government Liaison, I have demonstrated expertise in Corporate Governance. My skill set includes senior-level management in Contract Management, Legal Support, and Diplomatic Relations. I have also gained proficiency as a Corporate Liaison, utilizing my strong background in accounting, finance, and legal, with a Bachelor's degree (B.A.) from California State University. My Administrative Skills further strengthen my ability to contribute to the growth and success of any organization.
Sangyun Lee, 'Why Korea's Merger Control Occasionally Fails: A Public Choice ...Sangyun Lee
Presentation slides for a session held on June 4, 2024, at Kyoto University. This presentation is based on the presenter’s recent paper, coauthored with Hwang Lee, Professor, Korea University, with the same title, published in the Journal of Business Administration & Law, Volume 34, No. 2 (April 2024). The paper, written in Korean, is available at <https://shorturl.at/GCWcI>.
Defending Weapons Offence Charges: Role of Mississauga Criminal Defence LawyersHarpreetSaini48
Discover how Mississauga criminal defence lawyers defend clients facing weapon offence charges with expert legal guidance and courtroom representation.
To know more visit: https://www.saini-law.com/
1. EStIF 4|2015 239
Challenges and Opportunities - Management of ESI Funds in Bulgaria
Challenges and Opportunities Facing the Legal
and Institutional Framework for the
Management of ESI Funds in Bulgaria
Savina Mihaylova-Goleminova∗
The report aims to review several current issues related to problematic areas in the system
of management of European Structural and Investment Funds (ESI Funds) in the Republic
of Bulgaria, currently being addressed by representatives of the Government, the Bulgarian
National Assembly, the Supreme Administrative Court (SAC), practitioners and academic
circles. The main concepts serve as basis for the recently adopted Management of ESI Funds
Act, effective as of December 2015. The information, concepts and implications outlined in
the article could contribute to the general understanding of cohesion policy management
and current achievements in Bulgaria.
I. Challenges of the Cohesion Policy
2014-2020
Europeanfundsarecurrentlyoneofthemainsources
of funds for structural reforms aimed at improving
the competitiveness of Bulgarian economy, regional
development and acceleration of convergence
processes. The ‘money for reforms’ principle forces
Bulgarian politicians, economists, members of acad-
emic circles, practicing legal experts, and business
representatives to face the serious challenge of apply-
ing this requirement by carrying out actual econom-
ic and social reforms in order to ensure absorption of
funds allocated to the Republic of Bulgaria under the
European Multiannual Financial Framework (MFF)
for the programming period 2014-2020. The princi-
ple also requires transparent public finances and a
clear vision for the overall development of the country
in all areas. The Cohesion Policy rules for 2014-2020
require unconditional adherence to strict budget dis-
cipline by all constitutional players participating in
the financial system of the Republic of Bulgaria. How
does Bulgaria address the challenges of the current
cohesion policy? Mainly by using legislation as a so-
cial regulator. According to the Regulations, the legal
and institutional framework for management and
control of ESI Funds must be set up in accordance
with the constitutional structure and traditions of
each Member State. The answer to this challenge and
the opportunities for Bulgaria will be reviewed below.
II. Challenges and Opportunities of the
Institutional and Legal Framework
for Management and Control of ESI
Funds in Bulgaria
1. Challenges and Lessons Learnt from
the Programming Period 2007-2013
The idea of a designated Management of ESI Funds
Act is not novel; it was discussed in the course of the
preparations for the 2014-2020 programming period,
with a view of the experience of several other EU
Member States, such as Denmark, Estonia, Greece,
Latvia, Slovakia, Finland, and Sweden. All of these
countries have adopted specific legislation regulat-
ing EU funds. The arguments in support of a specif-
ic Act are that the system of by-laws regulating im-
plementation of programmes for the programming
period 2014-20201
in Bulgaria have so far been char-
acterised by:
∗ Savina Mihaylova-Goleminova holds a Ph.D. in Financial Law.
She has worked as a Counsellor in the Office of the caretaker
Deputy Prime Minister for EU Funds Management (August-
November, 2014). Lecturer in Financial and Tax Law at the Facul-
ty of Law, Department of Administrative Law Studies and the
Faculty of Economics and Business at the St. Kliment Ohridksi
University of Sofia, Bulgaria. She is a member of the Sofia Bar and
the International Fiscal Association.
1 Council of Ministers of the Republic of Bulgaria. EU Structural
Funds. Single Information Portal. See <http://www.eufunds.bg/
programen-period-2014-2020/natcionalna-zakonodatelna-baza>,
accessed 11th November 2015.
2. EStIF 4|2015
240 Challenges and Opportunities - Management of ESI Funds in Bulgaria
– Lack of a unified, flexible, comprehensible, and
easily-applied approach to the management of ESI
Funds’ programmes, the managing authorities of
which tend to use different procedures for project
and programme implementation;
– Multiple exceptions or the inclusion of specific
provisions even where general rules apply, which
results in fragmentation of programme-specific
rules and unnecessary complexity;
– Severe fluctuations and lack of predictability of
the environment.2
A step towards resolution of the above problems was
achieved by the interim government of Bulgaria be-
tween August and November 2014. A special work-
group was brought together to address these issues,
comprising representatives of all stakeholders in the
system of omit management and control of EU funds.
The Deputy Prime Minister responsible for the man-
agement of EU funds delegated four main tasks to
the workgroup: (i) analysis of valid European and na-
tionallegislationwithregardstothemanagementand
control of ESI Funds; (ii) analysis of existing legal
practice and the existing practice of all bodies with-
in the system of EU public funds; (iii) identification
of good practices adopted by other Member States ap-
plying similar acts or laws; (iv) drafting of the Man-
agement of ESI Funds Act regulating the relations be-
tween the different institutions within the EU funds
management system and the provision of adminis-
trative appeal options at national level. The efforts of
the workgroup resulted in outlining of the main as-
pects to be covered by the future legislative act.
Of course, the current government faced the chal-
lenge of bringing to fruition the efforts of the inter-
im government. The draft law was submitted by the
Government to the Parliament in June 2015 and was
adopted by the Parliament on 10th December 2015.3
2. Challenges of the New Practice of
SAC and the Legal Doctrine
In its more recent practice, the SAC has abandoned
its notion of the civil-law nature of relations between
the managing authority / payment agency and ben-
eficiaries. At the same time, representatives of Bulgar-
ian administrative and financial legal doctrine4
share
thethesis thatthestate,representedby its bodies with-
in the system of ESIF public funds (managing author-
ities, certifying authorities, audit authorities)5
, is not
an equal party within public relations in the system
and is not devoid of its imperium.6
(emphasis added)
This vision is in line with Article 4 and Article 317
TFEU as well as Article 59 of Regulation (EU, Eu-
ratom) No 966/2012 of the European Parliament and
of the Council of 25 October 2012 on the financial
rules applicable to the general budget of the Union
and repealing Council Regulation (EC, Euratom) No
1605/2002.
Theabovethesisisalsoupheldinthemotivesquot-
ed by the court in its Decision No 2126/30.03.2015 un-
der administrative case No 8513/2013, reviewed by
the Administrative Court of Sofia, which notes as fol-
lows:
“Regarding admissibility of the appeal:
1. Provision of financial assistance for projects un-
der Operational Programmes (OPs) takes place
in two phases – approval, resp. rejection of the
application, and grant provision. In the first
phase the relations between the parties are en-
tirely administrative in nature and there is no
contradiction in law enforcement in this case.
Ambiguity arises in the classification of the sec-
ond element – contract conclusion and imple-
mentation. This ambiguity should not be re-
solved on the basis of formal assignment of the
arising rights and obligations to contractual law,
but rather on the actual legal situation of the
parties and the specifics of the relations between
them. The managing and contracting authority
under the respective OP are delegated certain
2 Audit Report No 0300001013 of the Audit Agency on “Prepara-
tion for management of funds under the General Strategic Frame-
work of the European Union during the new programming period
2014 – 2020“. Issued on the basis of Order No 060/09.04.2014
of the Chairman of the Audit Agency.
3 Management of ESIF Act, Prom. State Gazette 101, 22 December
2015.
4 Academic circles play an increasingly active role in cohesion
policy management and implementation. An example in this
direction is the Conference on Challenges for the New Cohesion
Policy in 2014 – 2020: An Academic and Policy Debate, Univer-
sity of Latvia, Riga, Latvia, 2015. See <http://ec.europa.eu/
regional_policy/en/conferences/challenges-cp-2014>.
5 See Decision of the Council of Ministers No 792/17.12.2013 on
the determination of management, control, coordination and
audit authorities for European Structural and Investment Funds
and other EU instruments and initiatives during the 2014-2020
period.
6 M. Kostov Financial Legal Relations (Sofia, Bulgarian Academy of
Sciences, 1979); S. Goleminova ‘On suspended operational
programmes for the 2007-2013 programming period and chal-
lenges facing the new 2014-2020 programming period’ (2014)
Obshestvo i Pravo Vol. 10, pp. 3–17.
3. EStIF 4|2015 241
Challenges and Opportunities - Management of ESI Funds in Bulgaria
statutory functions, namely for project approval
and public spending (funds of mixed origin —
in the case of co-funding between state budget,
and Funds from the European Regional Develop-
ment Fund [ERDF]). This combination between
the functions of a state body and budget spend-
ing authority (for both state and European
Funds)definessuchauthorityasasubjectofpub-
lic law — bearer of rights of an administrative
and legal nature regardless of the fact that it has
taken on the ancillary status of a contract par-
ty. … This function of the contract does not af-
fect the nature of the legal relations (analogous
to the theoretical concept for the ‘administrative
contract’, the characteristics of which have, as
yet, not found a legal expression).
2. The fact that the managing authority is an ad-
ministrative authority within the meaning of § 1,
item 1 of the Supplementary Provisions of the Ad-
ministrative Procedure Code (APC) combined
with the nature of the rights exercised thereby,
imparts on the challenged decision the charac-
teristics of an individual administrative act (de-
cision) as per Article 21, para 1 APC. The decision
reflects negatively on the property of the munic-
ipality because the deduction reduces the
amount of the advance payment under the con-
tract of 2012, i.e. the legal consequence of the de-
cision is a direct effect on the rights of the ad-
dressee as an objective element of the adminis-
trative act concept. The proposition for admis-
sibility of legal appeal against decisions im-
posing deduction of amounts under grant
agreements is adopted in more recent SAC
practice7,8
. 9
(emphasis added)
Decision No 10878/19.10.2015 under administrative
case No 1039/2015 SAC, panel 8, notes that: Issues
similar to the reviewed disputable legal issue have al-
readybeendiscussedaspartoftheinterpretativepor-
tion of Interpretative case No 1/2015 of SAC’s Gener-
al Meeting of Civil Divisions under item 1, namely:
"What is the legal nature of decisions made by the
bodies of Agriculture State Fund Paying Agency un-
der Article 26, para 1, item 3 and Article 33 of Ordi-
nance No 9/2008 issued by the Minister of Agriculture
and Forestry and are they appealable under APC?”.10
Although as yet unpublished, a judgement has been
reached under this issue with the majority of judges
in the Supreme Administrative Court being of the
opinion that in this case, which is analogous to the
disputed issue, such acts are subject to appeal under
APC as individual administrative acts.
Interpretive Decision No 8/2015 under Interpre-
tive Case No 1/201511
was issued and published on
the website of the Supreme Administrative Court on
11.12.2015.
3. Opportunities Provided by the New
Legislative Act
The motives underpinning the adoption of the Act
specify that the scope of the Management of ESI
Funds Act includes the ERDF, the European Social
Fund (ESF), the Cohesion Fund (CF), the European
Agricultural Fund for Rural Development (EAFRD)
and the European Maritime and Fisheries Fund
(EMFF), regulating common procedures for absorp-
tion of the funds provided thereunder during pro-
gramming period 2014 – 2020. The main challenge
faced during drafting of the Act was related to the
creation of a predictable and omit effective legal
framework regulating the management of European
funds which could be applied for future program-
ming periods as well. The positive outcomes expect-
ed through adoption of the Act are:
- Creation of a predictable environment for imple-
mentation of programmes funded through ESI
Funds, with clearly defined rights and obligations
for all process participants;
- Elimination of the existing fragmentation in leg-
islation by eliminating the defects of existing by-
laws;
- Codification and unification of implementation
procedures;
7 See, for example, Decision No 10168/18.07.2014 under adminis-
trative case No 8672/2014, ruled under similar proceedings.
8 The same argument is supported in: Decision No 15062/12.12.2014
under administrative case No 14629/2014, 5th panel of the Supreme
Administrative court; Decision No 930/27.01.2015 of the SAC
under administrative case No 13877/2014, panel 3; Decision No
10168/18.07.2014 under administrative case No 8672/2014; Deci-
sion No 5615/18.05.2015 under administrative case No 1150/2015,
panel 3, Division I of SAC; Decision No 13764/16.12.2015 under
administrative case No 7197/2015, panel 7 of SAC.
9 Decision No 2126/30.03.2015, the Supreme Administrative Court
of Bulgaria.
10 Decision No 10878/19.10.2015 under administrative case No
1039/2015 SAC, panel 8, the Supreme Administrative Court of
Bulgaria.
11 SAC, see , <http://www.sac.government.bg/TD_VAS.nsf/
d6397429a99ee2afc225661e00383a86/
ecf531bf0811ca38c2257dd20026f2d6?OpenDocument>.
4. EStIF 4|2015
242 Challenges and Opportunities - Management of ESI Funds in Bulgaria
- Endorsement of the public law regime in the rela-
tions between managing authorities and benefi-
ciaries of financial aid, which corresponds to their
subject – ESI Funds and public funds;
- Introduction of accelerated appeal procedures
which will not impede the process of absorption
of ESI Funds.
In this respect, the New Act will ensure:
– Retaining of the existing institutional framework;
– Strengthening of coordination at all management
and control levels;
– Predictability;
– Transparency and a more comprehensible and ef-
ficient system of EU funds as part of the financial
system of the Republic of Bulgaria;
– Unification and simplification of procedures;
– Grant provision under an administrative contract
or individual administrative act;
– Placing of state receivables from financial correc-
tions due to irregularities on the same footing as
public state receivables for the programming pe-
riods 2007-2013 and 2014-2020;
– Efficient protection of the rights of beneficiaries
before administrative courts and the SAC.
This Act will be special with regards to the APC.
The Act regulates that financial aid will be provided
by managing authorities / payment agency to bene-
ficiaries on the basis of an administrative contract,
which is a relatively new concept, or an individual
administrative act. “Public contract”, “public body”,
“administrative legal relations”, “public interest” —
these are just some of the terms which underlie de-
coding of the legal nature of the “administrative con-
tract”.12
“The grant agreement providing assistance
from EU funds is an administrative contract and must
receive legal protection pursuant to the APC,”13
notes
Sonia Yankulova, a SAC Judge, in her article. “Grant
Agreements for financial assistance from EU Structur-
al and Cohesion Fund are administrative contracts
with which the state implements a large portion of
its objectives related mainly to the provision and op-
eration of public goods via private entities.”14
(em-
phasis added)
In this light, the Council of Ministers, when sub-
mitting the draft, motivates its decision as follows:
„Legal regulation focuses on the establishment of
clearly defined administrative relations between
managing authorities and beneficiaries. These re-
lations arise from two different institutes of ad-
ministrative law: The Administrative contract is
the main form for grant provision; financial cor-
rections, on the other hand, are determined, in
terms of grounds and amounts, by means of an in-
dividual administrative act. As opposed to the in-
dividual administrative act, the administrative
contract is not defined as a legal concept within
the codification of the administrative process, ex-
cept as a variant to the agreement under Article
20 of APC. At the same time the opportunities pro-
vided by this institute have been investigated in
depth by Bulgarian administrative doctrine; it has
been adopted in the positive law of several Euro-
pean countries, where it has found its place as the
regulator of relations arising in the course of pro-
vision of financial support through European
funds. The same legal logic which supports estab-
lishmentanddevelopmentoftherelationsbetween
managing authority and beneficiary along the
plane of administrative relations, is also the cor-
nerstone for clear regulation of the financial cor-
rections procedure. This procedure culminates in
an act which expresses the prerogatives of power
of the administrative authority. With a view of the
requirement of Article 74 Regulation (EC) No
1303/2013, namely that Member States shall en-
sure that effective arrangements for the examina-
tion of complaints concerning the ESI Funds are in
place, the draft introduces clear regulation regard-
ing the right of beneficiaries to protection against
decisions of the administrative bodies, based on
the general provisions of Article 120 of the Consti-
tution of the Republic of Bulgaria. Given the neces-
sity to guarantee efficiency in the absorption of
ESI Funds and to minimise the risk of loss, the draft
envisages several specific rules with regards to
court control over administrative decisions which
12 P. Buchkova ‘On the Administrative Contract in the Republic of
Bulgaria. Theoretic and practical aspects’ (2010) Administrative
Justice Vol. 3. Summing up the arguments put forth in support of
this opinion, Assoc. Prof. D. Zinovieva notes that “the agreement
may be incorporated, as a legal figure, into the category of public
contracts”.
13 S. Yankulova ‘The Grant Agreement regulating financial assistance
from EU Structural and Cohesion funds – a form of exercising
state authority and the right for protection’ (2015) Advokatski
pregled Vol. 1, pp. 8-33.
14 Ibid.
5. EStIF 4|2015 243
Challenges and Opportunities - Management of ESI Funds in Bulgaria
derogate from the general appeal process under
APC.“15
The Act also provides the basis for the establishment
of the Fund of Funds which will function based on
agreements with the managing authorities of the re-
spective OP; sets out special provisions for public pro-
curement and contract award which will be applica-
bletobeneficiariesoutsidethescopeofthePublicPro-
curement Act; and elaborates the rules forapplication
of the Act with regard to grant award, procurement,
irregularities and sanctions, which will be adopted
withinasix-monthperiodoftheAct’sentryintoforce.
Given the above, the Republic of Bulgaria will be
able to respond, by means of the adopted legal and
organisational changes, to all management and con-
trol challenges related to the programmes and the co-
hesion policy rules for 2014-2020.
III. Conclusions
In conclusion, bearing in mind that the budget (Eu-
ropean and national) is at the centre of the system
of public funds from ESI Funds, then simplifica-
tion of processes within the system at national lev-
el has clearly been achieved through adoption of
the new Act. The philosophy of the Act stems from
the idea that simplification at national level re-
quires coordination of public relations for manage-
ment and control of ESI Funds and corresponding
national co-funding by means of legislation as a so-
cial regulator, in compliance with the constitution-
al system, legal traditions and practices of the Mem-
ber State.
15 See more on Motives of the Draft Law on Single Information
Portal of EU Structural Funds of the Council of Ministers of the
Republic of Bulgaria <http://www.strategy.bg/
PublicConsultations/View.aspx?lang=bg-BG&Id=1713>.