Nic Thomas, Wiltshire
Sean Anstee, Devon & Torbay CA
PAS: Liz Hobden, Steve Barker,
Rachel Jones, Beccy Moberly, Garreth Bruff
Local Government Reorganisation
and Devo workshop
Overview of the Session
• Quick overview of Local Government Reform – what’s here
and what’s coming?
• New Unitary Experience – Nic Thomas, Director of
Planning, Wiltshire Council
• Combined Authority Perspective and Planning – Sean
Anstee, Director, Devon and Torbay Combined County
Authority
• Workshops on your Table – How to keep planning in a time
of change – discuss Combined Authorities Or New Unitaries
• Round up and close
Quick LGR Overview
Background
• Existing Combined Authorities and Devo Deals – from 2011
• Devo and LGR White Paper published Dec 24
• Government objectives
• Full strategic authority coverage proposed by end of Parliament
• Replacement of two-tier local government system in this Parliament
Combined Authorities – the
story so far
Four types of CA/Strategic Authority –
through a strategic planning lens
• Existing Combined Authorities with
Planning powers – GLA, Manchester and
Liverpool (black)
• Existing CAs – Elections May 25, SDS by end
of Parliament (2029)
• Priority Combined Mayoral Authorities
(green)
• Undecided – will be looked at on case by
case basis (yellow) – potential intervention
What are Strategic
Authorities?
The Devo White Paper proposes to replace CAs and CCAs with
Strategic Authorities – All have duty to prepare SDS:
No elected mayor, devolution deal limited
Mayoral CAs will automatically begin as
this unless they have been designated as
Established. For those with an elected mayor,
a range of powers will be devolved
Those mayoral authorities meeting additional
governance requirements unlock access to
further devolution powers such as integrated
settlement. E.g. GLA and Greater Manchester
Foundation Strategic Authority
Mayoral Strategic Authority
Established Mayoral Authority
New Unitary Councils
• English Devo Bill – Dec 24 – proposals to replace two tier system with
unitary councils
• SoS announcement on 5 Feb 25 – invited all councils to develop
‘Unitary Proposals’ by 26 Sept 2025
• April 2027 - Priority Programme Mayoral CA Unitaries in place
• April 2028 - Remaining Unitaries in place
PAS at 20 Conference Feb 2025
Local Government Re-organisation
Nic Thomas, Director of Planning
The Wiltshire path to Unitary
• Council formed in 2009
• Five into one - four districts, one county council
• Created fourth largest unitary council in England
• Vision – create stronger and more resilient communities
• Our case was based on devolution and working locally
• Established 18 Area Boards - influence local service delivery and
empower communities
• In Planning …
– Harmonisation of structures, services, pay and roles
– No immediate changes to committee structure
– Four schemes of delegation
– Four back-office ICT systems
– Overnight change in staff numbers, skills, capacity, backlog
– Multiple Local Plans at various stages
– Drive to make significant savings under-pinned all the work
Lessons learned
• Too long spent trying to maintain the status quo
• Assumption that bringing teams together would just work
• Lost opportunity to make radical changes – needed dealing with from day 1
• Single ICT system is essential – became a barrier for consistency, monitoring
performance and often the ‘excuse’ for not coming together
• One team culture – need to bring people together physically is essential
• Members loss of power was replaced by Planning Committees. Need to address early
or won’t ever get buy-in
• Performance previously only looked at team level – not as a service overview
• Regular staff surveys - give staff chance to have their say
• Transparency – in performance, decision making and engagement
• Don’t spread senior management too thin (e.g. five to one DM Head of Service)
• Don’t assume district officers / managers capable of dealing with unitary issues
“As long as decisions are
going out, we are not
concerned in how we do it”
Top tips
• Culture and vision is the most important area to invest time in
• Sufficient visible leadership to manage the critical relationships and demonstrably
‘champion’ the change
• It’s the people who will make this work – invest in them and identify your change advocates
• Be brave, short-term pain will give long term results
• Invest in time working with Members – don’t let them establish into old habits
• Strong, consistent and effective communications (staff and stakeholders)
• Proper robust programme management to deliver a major change programme
• Build performance and challenge into all aspects of planning.
• Embed a one council culture
• Have transparency in performance for the whole service
Wiltshire Performance
Management Cycle
Business
planning and
strategic
objectives
Appraisals
and 1:1’s
Team and
individual
capability and
development
planning
Talent
management
and
succession
planning
Performance
measurement
Resilience and
Future-proofing
(critical roles)
Team and individual
objectives
Workforce Strategy
Our Identity
POBs and POGs
Employment
Engagement survey data
360 reviews
Business Plan
What this means for Planning – high level
• Quarterly performance outcome board meetings (POB) (directors / cabinet member)
• Corporate Performance board chaired by Leader and CLT – Constructive challenge.
More than performance indicators – culture, staff, customer service, resilience, risks
• Monthly budget forecasting. Extended Leadership Team challenge and scrutiny
• Managing Performance and High Performing Teams is included in the planning
leadership and management development programme
• Performance issues part of staff induction and corporate leadership training
• Transparent performance reporting and management
• Culture of promoting benchmarking and networking
• Stretching targets
• Building risk management into operational decision making
• Live performance data is available to
all via dashboard in Arcus
• Arcus Dashboard
• Everyone can see the workloads for
the entire service at any time
• Officers all have their own dashboard
• Performance is discussed at Planning
SMT, and all Team Meetings
• Issues are at operational level,
individual performance
• We know that we need to improve –
but we have the tools to do it
What this means for Planning – Operationally
Talent Management
Talent management is the
• identification
• development
• engagement
• retention
• deployment
of individuals who are valuable to an organisation, because of their potential or the
critical role they have.
• Good recruitment and selection
• Good induction for new and internal staff
• 1:1’s, 9 Box Grid, Wiltshire Leader
Programme
• Training, development, coaching and
mentoring
• Purpose, clarity, autonomy, feedback,
recognition
• One Council approach to prioritising and
supporting agile deployment
9 Box Grid
Final thoughts….
• This is a major change programme and needs time, resource and the right people
• First 12 months - best opportunity deliver lasting change
• Developing a culture of ‘one council’ working, high performance, and continuous
improvement is key
Local Government
Reorganisation
and Planning
28 February 2025
PAS Conference
Our journey towards devolution
• Our journey started in February 2022, as
part of the Levelling Up White Paper
• Agreement for a Devon and Torbay
devolution deal reached in January 2024
• Wide ranging powers covering housing
and land, transport, net zero and climate
change, and economic development
• Covers the two-tier county of Devon and
Torbay Council with the CCA formally
came into being on 5 February 2025
Our ambitions
Maximising
our Economic
Potential
Addressing
our Housing
Pressures
Improving
Local
Transport
Meeting our
Net Zero
Ambitions
Delivering
investment in
Devon and
Torbay
Strong and
Sustainable
Local
Economy
Planning for growth
• Delivering a stronger partnership with
Homes England by establishing a shared
development pipeline
• Duty to prepare an economic assessment
for Devon and Torbay
• Housing Advisory Group established so
our Housing Authorities can collaborate
• Convening power to bring key
stakeholders together to take forward
funding and investment opportunities
Working collaboratively
• The challenges and opportunities will be
present whatever the outcome of LGR
• Building competence, building trust and
building relationships central pillars of
CCA activity.
• Supporting elected members to deliver
their commitments and demonstrate
impact
• Looking beyond our existing framework to
identify new opportunities to work
together
What next?
In the context of the English Devolution White Paper and its impact on
planning – lets discuss!
LGR and Planning
Workshop
• Work on Tables – no more than 8 per table
• Choose one from the two main themes for discussion:
• Combined Authorities and SDSs or
• New Unitary Councils
• Discuss and capture
• Opportunities
• Challenges
• Actions – include ideas for PAS Support
Closing and Next Steps
• We’ll take-away your points
• Inform PAS Programme of Support for next year
• Please complete feedback forms
• Useful LGA documents and advice
• Combined Authorities – A Plain English Guide
• Devolution and Local Government Reorganisation - FAQs
• THANK YOU!

Day 2 Seminar Local Government Reorganisation and Planning Seminar_web.pptx

  • 1.
    Nic Thomas, Wiltshire SeanAnstee, Devon & Torbay CA PAS: Liz Hobden, Steve Barker, Rachel Jones, Beccy Moberly, Garreth Bruff Local Government Reorganisation and Devo workshop
  • 2.
    Overview of theSession • Quick overview of Local Government Reform – what’s here and what’s coming? • New Unitary Experience – Nic Thomas, Director of Planning, Wiltshire Council • Combined Authority Perspective and Planning – Sean Anstee, Director, Devon and Torbay Combined County Authority • Workshops on your Table – How to keep planning in a time of change – discuss Combined Authorities Or New Unitaries • Round up and close
  • 3.
    Quick LGR Overview Background •Existing Combined Authorities and Devo Deals – from 2011 • Devo and LGR White Paper published Dec 24 • Government objectives • Full strategic authority coverage proposed by end of Parliament • Replacement of two-tier local government system in this Parliament
  • 4.
    Combined Authorities –the story so far Four types of CA/Strategic Authority – through a strategic planning lens • Existing Combined Authorities with Planning powers – GLA, Manchester and Liverpool (black) • Existing CAs – Elections May 25, SDS by end of Parliament (2029) • Priority Combined Mayoral Authorities (green) • Undecided – will be looked at on case by case basis (yellow) – potential intervention
  • 5.
    What are Strategic Authorities? TheDevo White Paper proposes to replace CAs and CCAs with Strategic Authorities – All have duty to prepare SDS: No elected mayor, devolution deal limited Mayoral CAs will automatically begin as this unless they have been designated as Established. For those with an elected mayor, a range of powers will be devolved Those mayoral authorities meeting additional governance requirements unlock access to further devolution powers such as integrated settlement. E.g. GLA and Greater Manchester Foundation Strategic Authority Mayoral Strategic Authority Established Mayoral Authority
  • 6.
    New Unitary Councils •English Devo Bill – Dec 24 – proposals to replace two tier system with unitary councils • SoS announcement on 5 Feb 25 – invited all councils to develop ‘Unitary Proposals’ by 26 Sept 2025 • April 2027 - Priority Programme Mayoral CA Unitaries in place • April 2028 - Remaining Unitaries in place
  • 7.
    PAS at 20Conference Feb 2025 Local Government Re-organisation Nic Thomas, Director of Planning
  • 8.
    The Wiltshire pathto Unitary • Council formed in 2009 • Five into one - four districts, one county council • Created fourth largest unitary council in England • Vision – create stronger and more resilient communities • Our case was based on devolution and working locally • Established 18 Area Boards - influence local service delivery and empower communities • In Planning … – Harmonisation of structures, services, pay and roles – No immediate changes to committee structure – Four schemes of delegation – Four back-office ICT systems – Overnight change in staff numbers, skills, capacity, backlog – Multiple Local Plans at various stages – Drive to make significant savings under-pinned all the work
  • 9.
    Lessons learned • Toolong spent trying to maintain the status quo • Assumption that bringing teams together would just work • Lost opportunity to make radical changes – needed dealing with from day 1 • Single ICT system is essential – became a barrier for consistency, monitoring performance and often the ‘excuse’ for not coming together • One team culture – need to bring people together physically is essential • Members loss of power was replaced by Planning Committees. Need to address early or won’t ever get buy-in • Performance previously only looked at team level – not as a service overview • Regular staff surveys - give staff chance to have their say • Transparency – in performance, decision making and engagement • Don’t spread senior management too thin (e.g. five to one DM Head of Service) • Don’t assume district officers / managers capable of dealing with unitary issues “As long as decisions are going out, we are not concerned in how we do it”
  • 10.
    Top tips • Cultureand vision is the most important area to invest time in • Sufficient visible leadership to manage the critical relationships and demonstrably ‘champion’ the change • It’s the people who will make this work – invest in them and identify your change advocates • Be brave, short-term pain will give long term results • Invest in time working with Members – don’t let them establish into old habits • Strong, consistent and effective communications (staff and stakeholders) • Proper robust programme management to deliver a major change programme • Build performance and challenge into all aspects of planning. • Embed a one council culture • Have transparency in performance for the whole service
  • 11.
    Wiltshire Performance Management Cycle Business planningand strategic objectives Appraisals and 1:1’s Team and individual capability and development planning Talent management and succession planning Performance measurement Resilience and Future-proofing (critical roles) Team and individual objectives Workforce Strategy Our Identity POBs and POGs Employment Engagement survey data 360 reviews Business Plan
  • 12.
    What this meansfor Planning – high level • Quarterly performance outcome board meetings (POB) (directors / cabinet member) • Corporate Performance board chaired by Leader and CLT – Constructive challenge. More than performance indicators – culture, staff, customer service, resilience, risks • Monthly budget forecasting. Extended Leadership Team challenge and scrutiny • Managing Performance and High Performing Teams is included in the planning leadership and management development programme • Performance issues part of staff induction and corporate leadership training • Transparent performance reporting and management • Culture of promoting benchmarking and networking • Stretching targets • Building risk management into operational decision making
  • 13.
    • Live performancedata is available to all via dashboard in Arcus • Arcus Dashboard • Everyone can see the workloads for the entire service at any time • Officers all have their own dashboard • Performance is discussed at Planning SMT, and all Team Meetings • Issues are at operational level, individual performance • We know that we need to improve – but we have the tools to do it What this means for Planning – Operationally
  • 14.
    Talent Management Talent managementis the • identification • development • engagement • retention • deployment of individuals who are valuable to an organisation, because of their potential or the critical role they have. • Good recruitment and selection • Good induction for new and internal staff • 1:1’s, 9 Box Grid, Wiltshire Leader Programme • Training, development, coaching and mentoring • Purpose, clarity, autonomy, feedback, recognition • One Council approach to prioritising and supporting agile deployment
  • 15.
  • 16.
    Final thoughts…. • Thisis a major change programme and needs time, resource and the right people • First 12 months - best opportunity deliver lasting change • Developing a culture of ‘one council’ working, high performance, and continuous improvement is key
  • 17.
  • 18.
    Our journey towardsdevolution • Our journey started in February 2022, as part of the Levelling Up White Paper • Agreement for a Devon and Torbay devolution deal reached in January 2024 • Wide ranging powers covering housing and land, transport, net zero and climate change, and economic development • Covers the two-tier county of Devon and Torbay Council with the CCA formally came into being on 5 February 2025
  • 19.
    Our ambitions Maximising our Economic Potential Addressing ourHousing Pressures Improving Local Transport Meeting our Net Zero Ambitions Delivering investment in Devon and Torbay Strong and Sustainable Local Economy
  • 20.
    Planning for growth •Delivering a stronger partnership with Homes England by establishing a shared development pipeline • Duty to prepare an economic assessment for Devon and Torbay • Housing Advisory Group established so our Housing Authorities can collaborate • Convening power to bring key stakeholders together to take forward funding and investment opportunities
  • 21.
    Working collaboratively • Thechallenges and opportunities will be present whatever the outcome of LGR • Building competence, building trust and building relationships central pillars of CCA activity. • Supporting elected members to deliver their commitments and demonstrate impact • Looking beyond our existing framework to identify new opportunities to work together
  • 22.
    What next? In thecontext of the English Devolution White Paper and its impact on planning – lets discuss!
  • 23.
    LGR and Planning Workshop •Work on Tables – no more than 8 per table • Choose one from the two main themes for discussion: • Combined Authorities and SDSs or • New Unitary Councils • Discuss and capture • Opportunities • Challenges • Actions – include ideas for PAS Support
  • 24.
    Closing and NextSteps • We’ll take-away your points • Inform PAS Programme of Support for next year • Please complete feedback forms • Useful LGA documents and advice • Combined Authorities – A Plain English Guide • Devolution and Local Government Reorganisation - FAQs • THANK YOU!

Editor's Notes

  • #4 Map key Black - Strategic authority: existing mayoral devolution, possibly on track to secure an integrated settlement Green - Priority programme: working towards establishing strategic authority for mayoral elections in May 2026 – priority programme – 6 mayoral CAs – Cheshire and Warrington; Cumbria, Norfolk and Suffolk; Greater Essex; Sussex and Brighton; and Hampshire and the Solent Light grey - Foundational devolution: non-mayoral combined authority, previously known as ‘level two’ deals Yellow - Discussions ongoing: proposals have come forward and need to be agreed locally or with government Brown Devo island: council not signed up to deal but may be in talks with neighbours Orange - Reorganisation fast track: Granted permission to cancel this May’s election with a view to creating new unitary councils as quickly as possible
  • #5 Responsibilities Appendix 1 Functions devolved to a Foundation Strategic Authority …… Housing and Strategic Infrastructure • A duty to produce a Spatial Development Strategy • Homes England compulsory purchase powers (held concurrently) …..   Appendix 2 Functions devolved to a Mayoral Strategic Authority …… Housing and strategic planning • A duty to produce a Spatial Development Strategy • Strategic development management powers (once the Spatial Development Strategy is in place) • Ability to raise a Mayoral Community Infrastructure Levy to fund strategic infrastructure (once the Spatial Development Strategy is in place) • Ability to make Mayoral Development Orders • Ability to establish Mayoral Development Corporations • Homes England compulsory purchase powers (held concurrently) • Devolution of wider grant funding to support regeneration and housing delivery • Strategic Place Partnership with Homes England
  • #11 10.27 – (5 mins) The Framework – context within the wider organisation - JVP
  • #14 11.40 Slides 22/23 10 mins
  • #15 To refer to if needed.
  • #18 Devon, Plymouth and Torbay was one of nine areas invited by Government, as part of the February 2022 Levelling Up White Paper, to agree a devolution deal. Plymouth City Council decided on 17 November 2023 to withdraw from the negotiations towards a proposed devolution deal. The devolution deal for Devon and Torbay was announced by the Secretary of State for Levelling Up, Homes and Communities on 25 January 2024. The deal covers: Governance Finance and investment Skills and education Housing and land Transport Net zero and climate change Culture and tourism Digital Innovation, trade, and investment Sector development Public service reform Resilience and public safety 3. Eight city, borough and district councils, two national parks, the county council and Torbay Council – a lot of opinions! But through hard work and determination we made it. Only to be disrupted by the English Devolution White Paper. And on our day of establishment did not put Devon and Torbay into the DPP or LGR fast track. Creates challenges, but having a CCA will help us.
  • #19 A very growth focused set of ambitions, which if you take each in turn is enabled by a planning and pro-growth and decision making environment.
  • #20 The powers and the transfer of Government funding included in the devolution deal will bring greater control to Devon and Torbay to help tackle local priorities, including the need for: new training and retraining opportunities; improved coordination of public transport; more affordable housing and investment to support local business, green jobs to increase productivity and pay. We will be developing – a clarity of vision. A single vision for Devon and Torbay, credible and supported. An entity Government can do business with on behalf of all our constituent and non-constituent authorities. In a time of LGR and future devolution, this is critical. TO be determined with members but will absolutely be focused in growing the economy of Devon and Torbay (improving our connectivity, securing investment, being affordable) and a place to be born, stay and thrive (skills, jobs, health) Our enabling strategies will support delivery: Local Growth, Devon Housing Commission, Climate and Net Zero, Transport and Skills – coherence between them and partnerships to make them happen. The CCA with its partners being an enabler of that.
  • #21 What are the areas we need to wait for Government, versus what we can achieve today? Spatial planning and joint working arrangements. Members and politics – drawing on previous experience