Case Study- Shutter Island
i ShutterIslandisa psychological Thrillerfilm, directedby
Martin Scorsese and writtenbyLaeta Kalogridis.Itisproducedby
ParamountPictures,Phoenix PicturesandSikeliaProductions.It
was filmedinthe USA,and releasedon12th
March 2010 (UK).The
filmhasgrossedan estimate total of $293 million, makingit
Scorsese’smostsuccessful filmyet. LeonardoDiCaprioandMark
Ruffalostarin thisfilmadaptationof DennisLehanes’novel,of the
same name. Surprisingly,the filmwasonlynominatedforone
award,TeenChoice,Horror/Thriller,despite the majorityof
audience receptionbeingpositive. The bookwasalsowell received
as a novel,anaward winningauthorwhoisalsoknownforwriting
some of the episodesof TheWire, a popularAmericanTV drama
series.
ii ShutterIsland wasoriginallymeanttobe releasedinthe USon Octoberthe 2nd
, however
due to Paramountbeingunsure aboutthe economyatthat time,theypushedthe release date back
to February19th
, inthe hope that the adultaudience will be ina
betterfinancial situation.The film hashadmixedresponsesfrom
criticsand audiences,althoughmostare positive.RottenTomatoes
criticsgave it a Freshscore of 6.6/10, while IMDbgave it a score of
8/10, as thischart shows,fromthe IMDb website,thatalmost95% of
usersvotedthe filmasbeingover5 stars out of 10.
Thisbar chart, also fromIMDb, showsthat actuallyunder
18 year oldmaleswere the voterstogive the highest
ratings.Overall,people agedbetweenu-18and29 gave the
highestscores,the lowestscoresbeinggivenbyTop1000
voters,people aged45+,and Men aged45+.
JohnPuccioof DVDtown.comsaid‘acreepypsychological
thriller...shortonpsychology,characterization,suspense,
tension,orthrills.’Howeverthe majorityof critics’ reviews
are mostlypositive,asone critic,AndreaChase of Killer
Movie Reviewssays‘Scorsesedeliversthe tensionfromfirstframe tolastwitha deliberatelylow-key
moodthat amps upthe eeriness.Itimbueseventhe mostbenignactionswithasinisterambiguity.’
Critical Outcastsaid‘It isgorgeousto lookat,fascinatingtoabsorb andwill keepyouguessing.Thisis
a filmmade bya directorwhoknowsexactlywhathe isdoingandwithan actor who keepsgetting
better.Thisisnot to be missed.’
iii ShutterIslandhasitsown independentwebsite,featuringvideos,informationaboutthe
film,directorandactors, and downloads.Italsohasa linkthat allowsyoubuythe filmdirectlyoff
the internet.Thishasdefinitelyincreasedaudience knowledge of the filmbecauseitallowspeople
to getextrainformationabout,andthe website isdesignedinaway thatmakesyou want to see the
film.Thisisa screenshotof the website,andasyou can see,ithas the filmtrailerplaying
automaticallywhenyougotothe website inone corner.Itis advertisingthe DVDof the filmin
another,andhas several linksthatallowyoutonavigate
aroundthe website. The backgroundisananimatedversionof the officialfilmposter,makingit
easilyreferable andrecognisable,withthe special featureof the fogmovingslowlyacrossthe
screen,the lighthouselightrotatinground,asif searchingforsomething(orsomeone,asthe tagline
suggests‘Someoneismissing’) andthe candlelightflickeringacrossDiCaprio’sface.Thismakesthe
well knownposterimage more exclusivetothe website,alsocreatinganeerie effect,andalso
conformingto thrillerconventionsof darknessandshadows.DiCaprioisalsoportrayedasa
detective,insinuatinghe ispossiblyahero,ora good character,a personalitytypealsoof the thriller
convention. The website hassoundeffectsof the sea,washingagainst rocks.The seamovementis
quite heavy,suggestingitisveryrough,andaddedwiththe picture of the isolatedisland,we getthe
impressionthatitisveryhard to leave the island.
iv As the filmopens,we are ledtobelieve thatthisfilmisnomore thanan entertaining
detective mysteryfilm.Howeverasthe filmcontinues,itbeginstogetmore andmore surreal,
dramaticand unsolved.We are ledtobelieveone storyfromthe start of the film, yetlaterthisis
turnedon itsheadas we don’tknowwhat to believe.The filmhasmostlytraditional thriller
characters (althoughthischangeslaterinthe film) We have the Hero,Teddy,andhisassistant
Chuck,whichlaterinthe filmwe wonderif he isinfact a double agent,
inon the conspiracyof the island.The victimchanges,yetatthe
beginningof the film, we thinkitisRachel,butas the filmdevelopsour
perceptionchangessympathytowardsTeddy.Cawleyseemsthe bad
character, butis laterto be revealedasa goodcharacter. We also
thinkthat Laeddisisthe psychopathcharacter,althoughitisrevealedthathe doesnotexist.Teddy’s
wife canbe speculatedon,asshe seemstobe a guidance character.ShutterIslandfeaturesseveral
plottwists,a typical thrillertheme.The filmalsohasmanythrillersymbols,suchasshadows,bars&
entrapment,isolationandrural location,there isalsoashowerscene inwhichthe cameralooksup
at the showerasthe wateris running,notdissimilartothe famousone in Psycho. Runningwateris
alsoa typical thrillertheme,signifyingdangerandtime runningout.
The narrative ismostlylinear,althoughthe maincharacterTeddyoftenhas very shortflashbacks,
whichdevelopintoastoryof whenhe was a soldierduringthe war,whichisexplainedfullyaround
halfwaythroughthe filmwhenhe tellsChuck.There isalsoanotherflashbackrightatthe endwhich
explainswhatreallyhappenedtoTeddyandhiswife.Thisstructure definitelystrengthensthe film,
as it givesthe audience aninsighttoTeddy’sbackgroundsowe canunderstandhimduringthe rest
of the film.
The two characters at the backare wearing traditional detective
clothes;suit & tie, hats, and long beige overcoats. Withthese costumes,
we automaticallyknow what their professionis, and therefore assume
theyare good characters. Theyare mostlywearing light colours, which
in the Thriller genre we see as being Good, except the man onthe left,
who is wearinga darksuit, possiblymeaning he is not all good, and has
something to hide. The manin front is wearing a securityguard
uniform, which althoughis alsoa darkcolour, we know themto
generallybe goodcharacters.
The highbrickwalls
surroundingthe
characters show that
theyare prettymuch
trapped. There is a big
gate at the entrance,
possiblythe onlywayin
or out, we can faintly
see barbedwire on top
of the wall inthe far
right corner of the
picture. The lackof
sceneryaround them,
just one tree, a car
(which is oldfashioned,
signifying time period)
and also if we look at
the gate behindthe
characters, all we can
see is the overcast sky,
giving us the impression
that there is no world
outside these tall brick
walls.
The characters seem to be approaching
what theyare walking towards with
warilyexpression ontheir faces. They
seemto be walkingcautiously, while the
securityguardis striding withanair of
authority. We know that the hierarchy
of the police force that detectives are
above securityguards, yet inthis image
it seems that inthis place the guardhas
more control. We start to questionthe
systemof the institution where theyare,
as the combination ofthe highwallsand
lack of authoritymakes these characters
very venerable.

Case study Shutter Island

  • 1.
    Case Study- ShutterIsland i ShutterIslandisa psychological Thrillerfilm, directedby Martin Scorsese and writtenbyLaeta Kalogridis.Itisproducedby ParamountPictures,Phoenix PicturesandSikeliaProductions.It was filmedinthe USA,and releasedon12th March 2010 (UK).The filmhasgrossedan estimate total of $293 million, makingit Scorsese’smostsuccessful filmyet. LeonardoDiCaprioandMark Ruffalostarin thisfilmadaptationof DennisLehanes’novel,of the same name. Surprisingly,the filmwasonlynominatedforone award,TeenChoice,Horror/Thriller,despite the majorityof audience receptionbeingpositive. The bookwasalsowell received as a novel,anaward winningauthorwhoisalsoknownforwriting some of the episodesof TheWire, a popularAmericanTV drama series. ii ShutterIsland wasoriginallymeanttobe releasedinthe USon Octoberthe 2nd , however due to Paramountbeingunsure aboutthe economyatthat time,theypushedthe release date back to February19th , inthe hope that the adultaudience will be ina betterfinancial situation.The film hashadmixedresponsesfrom criticsand audiences,althoughmostare positive.RottenTomatoes criticsgave it a Freshscore of 6.6/10, while IMDbgave it a score of 8/10, as thischart shows,fromthe IMDb website,thatalmost95% of usersvotedthe filmasbeingover5 stars out of 10. Thisbar chart, also fromIMDb, showsthat actuallyunder 18 year oldmaleswere the voterstogive the highest ratings.Overall,people agedbetweenu-18and29 gave the highestscores,the lowestscoresbeinggivenbyTop1000 voters,people aged45+,and Men aged45+. JohnPuccioof DVDtown.comsaid‘acreepypsychological thriller...shortonpsychology,characterization,suspense, tension,orthrills.’Howeverthe majorityof critics’ reviews are mostlypositive,asone critic,AndreaChase of Killer Movie Reviewssays‘Scorsesedeliversthe tensionfromfirstframe tolastwitha deliberatelylow-key moodthat amps upthe eeriness.Itimbueseventhe mostbenignactionswithasinisterambiguity.’ Critical Outcastsaid‘It isgorgeousto lookat,fascinatingtoabsorb andwill keepyouguessing.Thisis a filmmade bya directorwhoknowsexactlywhathe isdoingandwithan actor who keepsgetting better.Thisisnot to be missed.’
  • 2.
    iii ShutterIslandhasitsown independentwebsite,featuringvideos,informationaboutthe film,directorandactors,and downloads.Italsohasa linkthat allowsyoubuythe filmdirectlyoff the internet.Thishasdefinitelyincreasedaudience knowledge of the filmbecauseitallowspeople to getextrainformationabout,andthe website isdesignedinaway thatmakesyou want to see the film.Thisisa screenshotof the website,andasyou can see,ithas the filmtrailerplaying automaticallywhenyougotothe website inone corner.Itis advertisingthe DVDof the filmin another,andhas several linksthatallowyoutonavigate aroundthe website. The backgroundisananimatedversionof the officialfilmposter,makingit easilyreferable andrecognisable,withthe special featureof the fogmovingslowlyacrossthe screen,the lighthouselightrotatinground,asif searchingforsomething(orsomeone,asthe tagline suggests‘Someoneismissing’) andthe candlelightflickeringacrossDiCaprio’sface.Thismakesthe well knownposterimage more exclusivetothe website,alsocreatinganeerie effect,andalso conformingto thrillerconventionsof darknessandshadows.DiCaprioisalsoportrayedasa detective,insinuatinghe ispossiblyahero,ora good character,a personalitytypealsoof the thriller convention. The website hassoundeffectsof the sea,washingagainst rocks.The seamovementis quite heavy,suggestingitisveryrough,andaddedwiththe picture of the isolatedisland,we getthe impressionthatitisveryhard to leave the island. iv As the filmopens,we are ledtobelieve thatthisfilmisnomore thanan entertaining detective mysteryfilm.Howeverasthe filmcontinues,itbeginstogetmore andmore surreal, dramaticand unsolved.We are ledtobelieveone storyfromthe start of the film, yetlaterthisis turnedon itsheadas we don’tknowwhat to believe.The filmhasmostlytraditional thriller characters (althoughthischangeslaterinthe film) We have the Hero,Teddy,andhisassistant Chuck,whichlaterinthe filmwe wonderif he isinfact a double agent, inon the conspiracyof the island.The victimchanges,yetatthe beginningof the film, we thinkitisRachel,butas the filmdevelopsour perceptionchangessympathytowardsTeddy.Cawleyseemsthe bad character, butis laterto be revealedasa goodcharacter. We also thinkthat Laeddisisthe psychopathcharacter,althoughitisrevealedthathe doesnotexist.Teddy’s wife canbe speculatedon,asshe seemstobe a guidance character.ShutterIslandfeaturesseveral plottwists,a typical thrillertheme.The filmalsohasmanythrillersymbols,suchasshadows,bars& entrapment,isolationandrural location,there isalsoashowerscene inwhichthe cameralooksup at the showerasthe wateris running,notdissimilartothe famousone in Psycho. Runningwateris alsoa typical thrillertheme,signifyingdangerandtime runningout.
  • 3.
    The narrative ismostlylinear,althoughthemaincharacterTeddyoftenhas very shortflashbacks, whichdevelopintoastoryof whenhe was a soldierduringthe war,whichisexplainedfullyaround halfwaythroughthe filmwhenhe tellsChuck.There isalsoanotherflashbackrightatthe endwhich explainswhatreallyhappenedtoTeddyandhiswife.Thisstructure definitelystrengthensthe film, as it givesthe audience aninsighttoTeddy’sbackgroundsowe canunderstandhimduringthe rest of the film. The two characters at the backare wearing traditional detective clothes;suit & tie, hats, and long beige overcoats. Withthese costumes, we automaticallyknow what their professionis, and therefore assume theyare good characters. Theyare mostlywearing light colours, which in the Thriller genre we see as being Good, except the man onthe left, who is wearinga darksuit, possiblymeaning he is not all good, and has something to hide. The manin front is wearing a securityguard uniform, which althoughis alsoa darkcolour, we know themto generallybe goodcharacters. The highbrickwalls surroundingthe characters show that theyare prettymuch trapped. There is a big gate at the entrance, possiblythe onlywayin or out, we can faintly see barbedwire on top of the wall inthe far right corner of the picture. The lackof sceneryaround them, just one tree, a car (which is oldfashioned, signifying time period) and also if we look at the gate behindthe characters, all we can see is the overcast sky, giving us the impression that there is no world outside these tall brick walls. The characters seem to be approaching what theyare walking towards with warilyexpression ontheir faces. They seemto be walkingcautiously, while the securityguardis striding withanair of authority. We know that the hierarchy of the police force that detectives are above securityguards, yet inthis image it seems that inthis place the guardhas more control. We start to questionthe systemof the institution where theyare, as the combination ofthe highwallsand lack of authoritymakes these characters very venerable.