This book review summarizes Juliano Zaiden Benvindo's book "On the Limits of Constitutional Adjudication: Deconstructing Balancing and Judicial Activism". The book challenges the dominant approach of balancing values and principles in constitutional law and the rise of judicial activism. Through discussions of cases in Brazil and Germany, Benvindo argues that balancing dissolves boundaries between law and politics. The book analyzes how proportionality and balancing emerged as meta-principles, transforming constitutional courts into more activist bodies. By drawing on Derrida and Habermas, Benvindo offers a critique of limited rationality in constitutional adjudication.
El documento describe las principales características y herramientas de Windows y Microsoft Project. Explica que Windows es un sistema operativo desarrollado por Microsoft que utiliza una interfaz gráfica de ventanas. También describe las principales herramientas de Windows como el explorador, el panel de control y las herramientas de aplicaciones. Resume que Microsoft Project es un software de gestión de proyectos que permite planificar tareas, asignar recursos, hacer un seguimiento del progreso y gestionar presupuestos.
Brochure Sotosoft - Desarrollo de Software Bucaramanga ColombiaSotosoftco
Quienes somos:
SOTOSOFT es una empresa que nace a partir de las necesidades de los empresarios de controlar de una manera eficaz sus negocios. Somos una empresa que tiene como objetivo principal ofrecer servicio personalizado y de calidad a todas aquellas empresas que requieran de Sistemas de Información eficientes e integrados. Contamos con la capacidad para llevar a cabo proyectos de alta calidad que permita a nuestros clientes contar con herramientas que satisfagan todas sus necesidades.
Misión:
Somos una empresa que brinda servicios profesionales en desarrollo de Software, redes y suministro de hardware que unida con nuestra experiencia y el apoyo de nuestro talento humano satisface de manera eficaz y eficiente los requerimientos de nuestros clientes, permitiéndoles obtener resultados en corto tiempo en el desempeño de las aplicaciones.
Visión:
Ser una empresa reconocida en Colombia y el mundo en la prestación de servicios profesionales relacionados con la asesoría y el desarrollo de Software, redes y suministro de hardware, orientada a la satisfacción de las necesidades de nuestros clientes, basados en la experiencia y profesionalismo de nuestro talento humano.
Lo que nos diferencia:
En SOTOSOFT diseñamos software a la medida de cada uno de nuestros clientes dando siempre precios competitivos, adaptados a las necesidades y situación personal de cada uno, manteniendo siempre la relación calidad/precio en sus niveles más altos.
SOTOSOFT sigue unos patrones de calidad adaptados a la normativa actual, ya que uno de nuestros objetivos es conseguir la certificación ISO. De ahí que estemos en condiciones de ofrecer una garantía total y de responder siempre a los servicios y productos contratados por nuestros clientes.
La evaluación del estado de nutrición involucra métodos antropométricos, bioquímicos, clínicos y dietéticos para determinar el estado nutricional de un individuo. Estos métodos miden factores como la composición corporal, el consumo y absorción de nutrientes, signos de deficiencias o excesos, y la ingesta de alimentos. La información obtenida a través de estas evaluaciones permite diagnosticar posibles problemas nutricionales y desarrollar intervenciones para mejorar el estado de nutrición.
La iglesia de Santa María del Puerto en Santoña, Cantabria data del siglo XIII y es de estilo protogótico. Fue declarada monumento nacional en 1931 y contiene retablos e imágenes religiosas de los siglos XVIII y XIX, incluyendo la Virgen de Puerto, patrona de la iglesia. La arquitectura muestra rasgos románicos como arcos de medio punto y capiteles decorados con escenas bíblicas e históricas.
Los numerales ordinales expresan el orden o posición de un elemento dentro de una serie ordenada, a diferencia de los cardinales que cuantifican elementos. Generalmente son adjetivos que pueden ir antepuestos o pospuestos al sustantivo, y presentan variación de género y número. El documento proporciona ejemplos de uso de los ordinales y recomienda seguir las reglas ortográficas al escribirlos, incluyendo la acentuación de esdrújulas.
El documento presenta una discusión sobre diferentes teorías de la motivación humana en el trabajo. Brevemente describe las teorías de Maslow sobre la jerarquía de necesidades, Herzberg sobre los factores higiénicos y motivacionales, McClelland sobre las tres necesidades (logro, poder y afiliación), Vroom sobre las expectativas, Adams sobre la equidad, Locke sobre la fijación de metas y Rousseau sobre los contratos psicológicos. El documento ofrece una evolución histórica de las creencias sobre la motivación y los componentes e influencias
El documento describe las principales características y herramientas de Windows y Microsoft Project. Explica que Windows es un sistema operativo desarrollado por Microsoft que utiliza una interfaz gráfica de ventanas. También describe las principales herramientas de Windows como el explorador, el panel de control y las herramientas de aplicaciones. Resume que Microsoft Project es un software de gestión de proyectos que permite planificar tareas, asignar recursos, hacer un seguimiento del progreso y gestionar presupuestos.
Brochure Sotosoft - Desarrollo de Software Bucaramanga ColombiaSotosoftco
Quienes somos:
SOTOSOFT es una empresa que nace a partir de las necesidades de los empresarios de controlar de una manera eficaz sus negocios. Somos una empresa que tiene como objetivo principal ofrecer servicio personalizado y de calidad a todas aquellas empresas que requieran de Sistemas de Información eficientes e integrados. Contamos con la capacidad para llevar a cabo proyectos de alta calidad que permita a nuestros clientes contar con herramientas que satisfagan todas sus necesidades.
Misión:
Somos una empresa que brinda servicios profesionales en desarrollo de Software, redes y suministro de hardware que unida con nuestra experiencia y el apoyo de nuestro talento humano satisface de manera eficaz y eficiente los requerimientos de nuestros clientes, permitiéndoles obtener resultados en corto tiempo en el desempeño de las aplicaciones.
Visión:
Ser una empresa reconocida en Colombia y el mundo en la prestación de servicios profesionales relacionados con la asesoría y el desarrollo de Software, redes y suministro de hardware, orientada a la satisfacción de las necesidades de nuestros clientes, basados en la experiencia y profesionalismo de nuestro talento humano.
Lo que nos diferencia:
En SOTOSOFT diseñamos software a la medida de cada uno de nuestros clientes dando siempre precios competitivos, adaptados a las necesidades y situación personal de cada uno, manteniendo siempre la relación calidad/precio en sus niveles más altos.
SOTOSOFT sigue unos patrones de calidad adaptados a la normativa actual, ya que uno de nuestros objetivos es conseguir la certificación ISO. De ahí que estemos en condiciones de ofrecer una garantía total y de responder siempre a los servicios y productos contratados por nuestros clientes.
La evaluación del estado de nutrición involucra métodos antropométricos, bioquímicos, clínicos y dietéticos para determinar el estado nutricional de un individuo. Estos métodos miden factores como la composición corporal, el consumo y absorción de nutrientes, signos de deficiencias o excesos, y la ingesta de alimentos. La información obtenida a través de estas evaluaciones permite diagnosticar posibles problemas nutricionales y desarrollar intervenciones para mejorar el estado de nutrición.
La iglesia de Santa María del Puerto en Santoña, Cantabria data del siglo XIII y es de estilo protogótico. Fue declarada monumento nacional en 1931 y contiene retablos e imágenes religiosas de los siglos XVIII y XIX, incluyendo la Virgen de Puerto, patrona de la iglesia. La arquitectura muestra rasgos románicos como arcos de medio punto y capiteles decorados con escenas bíblicas e históricas.
Los numerales ordinales expresan el orden o posición de un elemento dentro de una serie ordenada, a diferencia de los cardinales que cuantifican elementos. Generalmente son adjetivos que pueden ir antepuestos o pospuestos al sustantivo, y presentan variación de género y número. El documento proporciona ejemplos de uso de los ordinales y recomienda seguir las reglas ortográficas al escribirlos, incluyendo la acentuación de esdrújulas.
El documento presenta una discusión sobre diferentes teorías de la motivación humana en el trabajo. Brevemente describe las teorías de Maslow sobre la jerarquía de necesidades, Herzberg sobre los factores higiénicos y motivacionales, McClelland sobre las tres necesidades (logro, poder y afiliación), Vroom sobre las expectativas, Adams sobre la equidad, Locke sobre la fijación de metas y Rousseau sobre los contratos psicológicos. El documento ofrece una evolución histórica de las creencias sobre la motivación y los componentes e influencias
This document discusses objectives for a summer peak driving session, including the role of the LCP (leadership coaching program), team management versus accountability, and generating hype. It provides details on the roles of various LCP positions like JDLCP, TL, and CEO. It also gives tips for LCVPs (leadership coaching vice presidents) on culture communication, functional touchpoints, and role modeling the MCVP. Other sections provide the presenter's learnings and tips on team management versus accountability, focusing on strengths and priorities, and tracking performance. Charts on NPS, IGV, OGV and other metrics are also included.
Gaurav Kumar Pandit discusses pollution and its effects on human health. Pollution is defined as the presence of dangerous, unnatural ingredients that cause ecosystem imbalances and health hazards. Pollution can be classified as point source or nonpoint source. Three factors determine a pollutant's severity: its chemical nature, concentration, and persistence. Pollution enters the human body through inhalation, skin contact, and ingestion. It is processed and either stored or eliminated from the body. Particulate matter and vehicle emissions are linked to increased heart attacks. Chronic pollution exposure raises risks of early death and respiratory/cardiovascular diseases. Controlling pollution remains an ongoing challenge.
La iglesia de Santa María de Puerto en Santoña, Cantabria data del siglo XIII y fue declarada Monumento Nacional en 1931. Sus portadas principales y laterales contienen esculturas y símbolos románicos como pájaros, hojas de acanto y un campesino con un mulo. En el interior se encuentra una pila bautismal gótica con leones y escenas bíblicas, así como varios retablos renacentistas de los siglos XVI que contienen imágenes religiosas e historias bíblicas.
La iglesia de Santoña impresionó al autor con sus adornos exteriores y su interior, que incluye una pila bautismal, retablo mayor y altar; la gente cristiana acude regularmente a rezar allí.
Este documento describe diferentes roles en Moodle como administrador del sitio, manager, creador de curso, profesor, invitado y usuario autenticado. Los administradores tienen permiso completo, mientras que los managers tienen poderes amplios pero con capacidad de editar permisos. Los creadores de curso pueden crear nuevos cursos. Los profesores pueden realizar la mayoría de tareas dentro de un curso. Los invitados solo tienen acceso de lectura.
O documento apresenta 10 questões de física e suas respectivas resoluções. A primeira questão trata de um diagrama de posição versus tempo de dois corpos A e B, e pergunta em que instante o corpo A iniciou seu movimento em relação a B. A resolução mostra que a resposta é opção b, 5,0 s. A segunda questão trata do movimento da sombra de uma bola rolando sobre uma superfície de vidro, e a resolução indica que o movimento da sombra é uniforme nos dois trechos com velocidades diferentes, opção c
El documento habla sobre el día de la primavera y la juventud que se celebra el 23 de setiembre. Describe cómo la primavera representa el renacimiento de la naturaleza y la juventud representa la energía y el optimismo. También menciona que el Perú está pasando por su mejor primavera con crecimiento económico y consolidación de la identidad nacional. Finalmente, destaca las ciudades de Trujillo y Chiclayo por representar la eterna primavera y la amistad respectivamente.
This document provides information about purchasing a 3Com 3C590-COMBO ethernet adapter from Launch 3 Telecom. It describes the product, details payment and shipping options, and discusses the warranty and additional services offered by Launch 3 Telecom such as repairs, maintenance contracts, and equipment deinstallation.
Este documento presenta notas del programa "El Nuevo Administrador Multicultural del Conocimiento: Más Allá de la Etnicidad y los Idiomas" impartido por Mary Yoko Brannen. Las notas explican conceptos clave como cultura, cultura negociada y variaciones dentro de las culturas. También ofrece guías prácticas para que los administradores funcionen de manera efectiva en entornos multiculturales, como escuchar activamente, presentar objetivos de manera integral y enfatizar puntos en común. El objetivo es preparar a los administ
Este documento presenta 36 ejercicios de matemáticas para 4o básico, organizados en torno a ejes temáticos como números, geometría y estadística. Los ejercicios incluyen problemas aritméticos, cálculos con números enteros y decimales, interpretación de gráficos y tablas, y resolución de problemas de la vida real relacionados con distancias, tiempo y dinero.
Le unità terminali sono terminali di emissione attraverso i quali passa il fluido termovettore che permette il riscaldamento od il raffrescamento in ogni locale in cui sono posizionati. Le unità terminali si suddividono in:
1) unità a prevalente scambio termico convettivo: radiatori, termoconvettori, piastre radianti (convezione naturale) e ventilconvettori, aerotermi (convezione forzata);
2) unità a prevalente scambio termico radiativi: pannelli radianti;
3) unità per il condizionamento dell’aria o split (trattamento estivo ed invernale).
This document outlines the requirements and guidelines for students completing an internship as part of their architectural studies. It details the log sheet that must be completed to record weekly experiences in areas like schematic design, permitting, and contract documentation. Students must submit the log sheets and a 1000-1500 word report summarizing their overall internship experience, responsibilities on projects, and lessons learned. The report should be certified by the supervising architect and follow the specified electronic submission format.
This document discusses a lecture given by Richard H. Helmholz on the topic of Magna Carta and the law of nature. The lecture explores possible connections between Magna Carta, which was enacted in 1215, and principles of natural law as understood at that time and for centuries afterward. While recent scholarship has been skeptical of portraying Magna Carta as guaranteeing broad human rights or natural law, the lecture examines whether the enactment of Magna Carta could be connected to contemporary understandings of justice and natural law. The lecture acknowledges limitations in proving conclusions definitively but aims to reasonably infer connections from evidence in Magna Carta's clauses based on natural law perspectives current at the time, rather than an
Jurisprudence is the study of law and legal concepts. It has value in better understanding legal complexities and solving problems. There are several schools of jurisprudence including natural law, imperative theory, and legal realism. Jurisprudence is interrelated with other social sciences like sociology, psychology, ethics, economics, history, and political science. Understanding these relationships provides context to legal concepts. Jurisprudence helps with effective interpretation and application of law.
Judge Posner provides a concise primer on the interpretation of legislation. He discusses Aristotle's view of "imaginative reconstruction" as the method of interpreting statutes in a way that achieves justice rather than literal meaning. Posner also explains how the separation of powers model in the US constitution, which aims to prevent any branch from becoming dominant, influenced the role of courts in interpreting statutes. Finally, he presents his model of the legislative process, which assumes rational behavior from political actors, and differentiates between direct and representative democracies.
This article discusses the proposal of a redevelopment of the judicial enforcement step mainly in regards of public interest litigation. That is to say whenever the judiciary has before itself the responsibility to provide an answer for the claims to the accomplishment of public policies, it must focus on ensuring the contradictory as a co-participation one. The constitutional proceedings require from the judiciary a new approach with regards to dealing with old and new litigations. As for public interest litigations it is necessary to rebuild the foundation of mainstream judicial proceeding theory so that it can go beyond the debate between liberal and socializing stances and thus enable a discoursive formation of the decision and of its enforcement. Basing on 5º paragraph of the article 461 from Brazilian Civil Procedures Code, this article argues that it should be created a procedure in the judicial enforcement step whereby the parties (and others) may settle about its form, timing and scheduling, supported by an expert mediator, who would be supposed to technically assist the parties' settlement efforts. In this way, the enforcement of public interest litigation acquires a “soft character” as it becomes more effective since it allows that its form will not come from a monocratic doer, but from the deliberation of the very ones affected by the claimed public police, and thus the enforcement has better chances to succeed.
The legality of human rights law in the lives of 'originals' in india.Devarshi Sen Deka
The 'legalization of a human right norm into Human rights in International Law at the backdrop of UNDRIP and 'Right to Development' in the lives of the Originals in India.'
A People S Constitution The Everyday Life Of Law In The Indian Republic By R...Suzanne Simmons
This review summarizes Rohit De's book "A People's Constitution: The Everyday Life of Law in the Indian Republic". The book uses detailed ethnographies to show how ordinary citizens have defended their rights through landmark constitutional cases, deepening India's constitutional culture. It argues this demonstrates the emergence of a "People's Constitution". However, the review notes that while the case studies are compelling, the book does not fully define what it means by "the people" or clearly explain how the cases represent the people of India as a whole. It discusses some of the dimensions through which De characterizes the people, such as statistically by the rising caseload, but says more conceptual clarity on who constitutes "the people" would have
This document discusses objectives for a summer peak driving session, including the role of the LCP (leadership coaching program), team management versus accountability, and generating hype. It provides details on the roles of various LCP positions like JDLCP, TL, and CEO. It also gives tips for LCVPs (leadership coaching vice presidents) on culture communication, functional touchpoints, and role modeling the MCVP. Other sections provide the presenter's learnings and tips on team management versus accountability, focusing on strengths and priorities, and tracking performance. Charts on NPS, IGV, OGV and other metrics are also included.
Gaurav Kumar Pandit discusses pollution and its effects on human health. Pollution is defined as the presence of dangerous, unnatural ingredients that cause ecosystem imbalances and health hazards. Pollution can be classified as point source or nonpoint source. Three factors determine a pollutant's severity: its chemical nature, concentration, and persistence. Pollution enters the human body through inhalation, skin contact, and ingestion. It is processed and either stored or eliminated from the body. Particulate matter and vehicle emissions are linked to increased heart attacks. Chronic pollution exposure raises risks of early death and respiratory/cardiovascular diseases. Controlling pollution remains an ongoing challenge.
La iglesia de Santa María de Puerto en Santoña, Cantabria data del siglo XIII y fue declarada Monumento Nacional en 1931. Sus portadas principales y laterales contienen esculturas y símbolos románicos como pájaros, hojas de acanto y un campesino con un mulo. En el interior se encuentra una pila bautismal gótica con leones y escenas bíblicas, así como varios retablos renacentistas de los siglos XVI que contienen imágenes religiosas e historias bíblicas.
La iglesia de Santoña impresionó al autor con sus adornos exteriores y su interior, que incluye una pila bautismal, retablo mayor y altar; la gente cristiana acude regularmente a rezar allí.
Este documento describe diferentes roles en Moodle como administrador del sitio, manager, creador de curso, profesor, invitado y usuario autenticado. Los administradores tienen permiso completo, mientras que los managers tienen poderes amplios pero con capacidad de editar permisos. Los creadores de curso pueden crear nuevos cursos. Los profesores pueden realizar la mayoría de tareas dentro de un curso. Los invitados solo tienen acceso de lectura.
O documento apresenta 10 questões de física e suas respectivas resoluções. A primeira questão trata de um diagrama de posição versus tempo de dois corpos A e B, e pergunta em que instante o corpo A iniciou seu movimento em relação a B. A resolução mostra que a resposta é opção b, 5,0 s. A segunda questão trata do movimento da sombra de uma bola rolando sobre uma superfície de vidro, e a resolução indica que o movimento da sombra é uniforme nos dois trechos com velocidades diferentes, opção c
El documento habla sobre el día de la primavera y la juventud que se celebra el 23 de setiembre. Describe cómo la primavera representa el renacimiento de la naturaleza y la juventud representa la energía y el optimismo. También menciona que el Perú está pasando por su mejor primavera con crecimiento económico y consolidación de la identidad nacional. Finalmente, destaca las ciudades de Trujillo y Chiclayo por representar la eterna primavera y la amistad respectivamente.
This document provides information about purchasing a 3Com 3C590-COMBO ethernet adapter from Launch 3 Telecom. It describes the product, details payment and shipping options, and discusses the warranty and additional services offered by Launch 3 Telecom such as repairs, maintenance contracts, and equipment deinstallation.
Este documento presenta notas del programa "El Nuevo Administrador Multicultural del Conocimiento: Más Allá de la Etnicidad y los Idiomas" impartido por Mary Yoko Brannen. Las notas explican conceptos clave como cultura, cultura negociada y variaciones dentro de las culturas. También ofrece guías prácticas para que los administradores funcionen de manera efectiva en entornos multiculturales, como escuchar activamente, presentar objetivos de manera integral y enfatizar puntos en común. El objetivo es preparar a los administ
Este documento presenta 36 ejercicios de matemáticas para 4o básico, organizados en torno a ejes temáticos como números, geometría y estadística. Los ejercicios incluyen problemas aritméticos, cálculos con números enteros y decimales, interpretación de gráficos y tablas, y resolución de problemas de la vida real relacionados con distancias, tiempo y dinero.
Le unità terminali sono terminali di emissione attraverso i quali passa il fluido termovettore che permette il riscaldamento od il raffrescamento in ogni locale in cui sono posizionati. Le unità terminali si suddividono in:
1) unità a prevalente scambio termico convettivo: radiatori, termoconvettori, piastre radianti (convezione naturale) e ventilconvettori, aerotermi (convezione forzata);
2) unità a prevalente scambio termico radiativi: pannelli radianti;
3) unità per il condizionamento dell’aria o split (trattamento estivo ed invernale).
This document outlines the requirements and guidelines for students completing an internship as part of their architectural studies. It details the log sheet that must be completed to record weekly experiences in areas like schematic design, permitting, and contract documentation. Students must submit the log sheets and a 1000-1500 word report summarizing their overall internship experience, responsibilities on projects, and lessons learned. The report should be certified by the supervising architect and follow the specified electronic submission format.
This document discusses a lecture given by Richard H. Helmholz on the topic of Magna Carta and the law of nature. The lecture explores possible connections between Magna Carta, which was enacted in 1215, and principles of natural law as understood at that time and for centuries afterward. While recent scholarship has been skeptical of portraying Magna Carta as guaranteeing broad human rights or natural law, the lecture examines whether the enactment of Magna Carta could be connected to contemporary understandings of justice and natural law. The lecture acknowledges limitations in proving conclusions definitively but aims to reasonably infer connections from evidence in Magna Carta's clauses based on natural law perspectives current at the time, rather than an
Jurisprudence is the study of law and legal concepts. It has value in better understanding legal complexities and solving problems. There are several schools of jurisprudence including natural law, imperative theory, and legal realism. Jurisprudence is interrelated with other social sciences like sociology, psychology, ethics, economics, history, and political science. Understanding these relationships provides context to legal concepts. Jurisprudence helps with effective interpretation and application of law.
Judge Posner provides a concise primer on the interpretation of legislation. He discusses Aristotle's view of "imaginative reconstruction" as the method of interpreting statutes in a way that achieves justice rather than literal meaning. Posner also explains how the separation of powers model in the US constitution, which aims to prevent any branch from becoming dominant, influenced the role of courts in interpreting statutes. Finally, he presents his model of the legislative process, which assumes rational behavior from political actors, and differentiates between direct and representative democracies.
This article discusses the proposal of a redevelopment of the judicial enforcement step mainly in regards of public interest litigation. That is to say whenever the judiciary has before itself the responsibility to provide an answer for the claims to the accomplishment of public policies, it must focus on ensuring the contradictory as a co-participation one. The constitutional proceedings require from the judiciary a new approach with regards to dealing with old and new litigations. As for public interest litigations it is necessary to rebuild the foundation of mainstream judicial proceeding theory so that it can go beyond the debate between liberal and socializing stances and thus enable a discoursive formation of the decision and of its enforcement. Basing on 5º paragraph of the article 461 from Brazilian Civil Procedures Code, this article argues that it should be created a procedure in the judicial enforcement step whereby the parties (and others) may settle about its form, timing and scheduling, supported by an expert mediator, who would be supposed to technically assist the parties' settlement efforts. In this way, the enforcement of public interest litigation acquires a “soft character” as it becomes more effective since it allows that its form will not come from a monocratic doer, but from the deliberation of the very ones affected by the claimed public police, and thus the enforcement has better chances to succeed.
The legality of human rights law in the lives of 'originals' in india.Devarshi Sen Deka
The 'legalization of a human right norm into Human rights in International Law at the backdrop of UNDRIP and 'Right to Development' in the lives of the Originals in India.'
A People S Constitution The Everyday Life Of Law In The Indian Republic By R...Suzanne Simmons
This review summarizes Rohit De's book "A People's Constitution: The Everyday Life of Law in the Indian Republic". The book uses detailed ethnographies to show how ordinary citizens have defended their rights through landmark constitutional cases, deepening India's constitutional culture. It argues this demonstrates the emergence of a "People's Constitution". However, the review notes that while the case studies are compelling, the book does not fully define what it means by "the people" or clearly explain how the cases represent the people of India as a whole. It discusses some of the dimensions through which De characterizes the people, such as statistically by the rising caseload, but says more conceptual clarity on who constitutes "the people" would have
This document provides an overview of comparative constitutional law methodology. It discusses key concepts like constitutionalism, levels of comparison, and the importance of theoretical frameworks. The author argues that comparative analysis requires understanding both the causal forces that influence legal systems as well as the motivations and agendas of political elites. Effective comparison examines a legal system's history, culture, economics and politics.
Relation between international law and municipal lawVishvendu pandey
This document discusses the debate between dualists and monists regarding the relationship between international law and municipal law. Dualists believe that municipal law prevails in cases of conflict, while monists believe international law prevails. While the disputants may not differ greatly in practical solutions, they differ in their underlying theories. Some arguments made are that international law is not a fully developed legal system, that it depends on state consent, and that states are sovereign over individuals under municipal law. However, the document also notes that states do not typically claim exemption from international law or assert the primacy of municipal law in diplomatic discussions.
This editorial summarizes new features of the second volume of the European Journal of Legal Studies, including an improved website, changes to the linguistic policy, and the addition of a book review section. It then previews several of the articles in the issue, which examine emerging areas of legal normativity from various perspectives, including theoretical, philosophical, and strictly legal approaches. The articles analyze concepts like sovereignty, jurisdiction, and universal jurisdiction as they relate to new "spaces of normativity".
This document discusses the history of legal pluralism from medieval times to the present. It makes three key points:
1) Medieval Europe was characterized by a high degree of legal pluralism, with multiple coexisting legal systems including local customs, feudal law, canon law, merchant law, and revived Roman law. This created uncertainty around which laws applied in different situations.
2) During the early modern period, European states consolidated power and centralized legal authority to establish themselves as the primary lawmakers. This reduced legal pluralism within their territories over time.
3) Contemporary legal pluralism combines the legacy of this past with more recent developments from globalization, resulting in diversity between legal authorities at different levels from local
The document discusses judicial activism and restraint. It provides examples of Supreme Court cases where judicial activism or restraint was used, such as Roe v. Wade and Brown v. Board of Education. Supporters of judicial activism believe judges should make policy decisions, while restraint supporters believe judges should interpret the law literally. The document also discusses criticisms of both philosophies and how judicial decisions can influence public policy.
This document discusses Duncan Kennedy's theory of "The Three Globalizations of Law" and how it relates to legal developments in Latin America. It argues that Kennedy's framework helps challenge oversimplified views of Latin American law as merely imitating Western models. The document analyzes how different aspects of legal thought were "globalized" at different times and then adapted to varied local contexts and political projects. It also explores how prevailing narratives of Latin American law's failures have sometimes aligned with instrumental objectives to promote certain legal and economic reforms.
The document discusses the legal debates around culture wars issues before the European Court of Human Rights. It outlines some of the key cases the ECtHR has addressed regarding abortion, same-sex marriage, Islam, and religious groups' autonomy. It also discusses the court's use of concepts like margin of appreciation, consensus, autonomous concepts, and a living instrument in balancing rights in these complex cases that often pit one right against another.
The document discusses the legal debates around culture wars issues before the European Court of Human Rights. It outlines some of the key cases the ECtHR has addressed regarding abortion, same-sex marriage, Islam, and religious groups' autonomy. It also discusses the court's use of concepts like margin of appreciation, consensus, autonomous concepts, and interpreting the European Convention on Human Rights as a "living instrument" adapted to current conditions. Finally, it notes the court faces a "countermajoritarian dilemma" in balancing competing legal and moral values in tragic cases where no satisfactory solution exists.
This summary provides an overview of the first document in 3 sentences:
The document discusses a lecture given by Jürgen Habermas on law and morality. It summarizes Max Weber's view that the legitimacy of legal systems is based on their perceived legality, and that introducing morality into law undermines its rationality. Habermas critiques Weber's assumptions, arguing that the formal properties of law cited by Weber cannot alone legitimize state power and require a moral foundation.
This document discusses recent debates around the concept of legal pluralism. It examines literature from before the 1980s that discussed legal pluralism, focusing on the works of three writers - Gilissen, Vanderlinden, and Hooker. Gilissen recognized non-state law and state law pluralism. Vanderlinden also recognized non-state law and state law pluralism, and defined legal pluralism as different legal mechanisms applying to identical situations within a society. Hooker recognized non-state law and state law pluralism, and defined legal pluralism as different laws interacting. The document provides an analysis of each writer's conception of legal pluralism.
An Intersectional Approach To Homelessness Discrimination And CriminalizationJoe Andelija
This document summarizes an article that analyzes homelessness through an intersectional lens. It first explains the theory of intersectionality and how it was originally applied to analyze discrimination against black women. It then discusses how more recent intersectionality theories focus on structural discrimination and power relationships rather than rigid identity categories. The document uses Canadian case law as an example of how courts have applied an intersectional approach. It argues that homelessness meets the criteria to be considered a ground of discrimination due to the stereotypes, stigma, and discrimination faced by homeless individuals. The document examines laws that criminalize behaviors associated with homelessness and argues they result in direct and indirect discrimination.
This article analyzes and critiques a Harvard Law Review article by Professor Akhil Amar that discusses the Supreme Court case Texas v. Johnson, which ruled that burning the American flag is protected free speech. The author argues that most constitutional law scholarship, including Amar's article, is actually advocacy disguised as scholarship. The goal of scholarship should be seeking truth, but modern legal scholarship often aims to justify political judgments rather than engage in objective analysis. By examining Amar's discussion of Texas v. Johnson through the lens of a "person sitting in darkness" unfamiliar with legal concepts, the author aims to shed light on how legal education can obscure important truths about the relationship between law, politics, and normative judgments.
Common Law Constitutional Interpretation Author(s) David LynellBull52
Common Law Constitutional Interpretation
Author(s): David A. Strauss
Source: The University of Chicago Law Review , Summer, 1996, Vol. 63, No. 3 (Summer,
1996), pp. 877-935
Published by: The University of Chicago Law Review
Stable URL: https://www.jstor.org/stable/1600246
REFERENCES
Linked references are available on JSTOR for this article:
https://www.jstor.org/stable/1600246?seq=1&cid=pdf-
reference#references_tab_contents
You may need to log in to JSTOR to access the linked references.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
https://about.jstor.org/terms
The University of Chicago Law Review is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and
extend access to The University of Chicago Law Review
This content downloaded from
��������������142.66.3.62 on Fri, 04 Dec 2020 23:05:25 UTC��������������
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
https://www.jstor.org/stable/1600246
https://www.jstor.org/stable/1600246?seq=1&cid=pdf-reference#references_tab_contents
https://www.jstor.org/stable/1600246?seq=1&cid=pdf-reference#references_tab_contents
The University of Chicago
Law Review
Volume 63 Summer 1996 Number 3
? 1996 by The University of Chicago
Common Law Constitutional Interpretation
David A. Strausst
The Constitution of the United States is a document drafted
in 1787, together with the amendments that have been adopted
from time to time since then. But in practice the Constitution of
the United States is much more than that, and often much
different from that. There are settled principles of constitutional
law that are difficult to square with the language of the docu-
ment, and many other settled principles that are plainly inconsis-
tent with the original understandings. More important, when
people interpret the Constitution, they rely not just on the text
but also on the elaborate body of law that has developed, mostly
through judicial decisions, over the years. In fact, in the day-to-
day practice of constitutional interpretation, in the courts and in
general public discourse, the specific words of the text play at
most a small role, compared to evolving understandings of what
the Constitution requires.
877
t Harry N. Wyatt Professor of Law, The University of Chicago. I thank Bruce
Ackerman, Douglas Baird, Richard Fallon, Charles Fried, Elizabeth Garrett, Elena
Kagan, Dan Kahan, Larry Lessig, Michael McConnell, Martha Nussbaum, Jeffrey Rosen,
Louis Michael Seidman, Geoffrey Stone, Peter Strauss, Cass Sunstein, and the partici-
pants in workshops at Columbia Law School ...
The presentation deals with the concept of Right to Default Bail laid down under Section 167 of the Code of Criminal Procedure 1973 and Section 187 of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita 2023.
A Critical Study of ICC Prosecutor's Move on GAZA WarNilendra Kumar
ICC Prosecutor Karim Khan's proposal to its judges seeking permission to prosecute Israeli leaders and Hamas commanders for crimes against the law of war has serious ramifications and calls deep scrutiny.
1. ARTICLES // ARTIGOS
GÜNTHER TEUBNER, MARCUS FARO DE CASTRO,
RITA LAURA SEGATO, HAUKE BRUNKHORST, ANA LUIZA
PINHEIRO FLAUZINA, RICARDO JACOBSEN GLOECKNER
e DAVID LEAL DA SILVA, JOÃO COSTA NETO
REVIEW ESSAYS // ARTIGOS-RESENHA
ALEXANDRE ARAÚJO COSTA
CASE NOTES AND COMMENTARIES // COMENTÁRIOS
DE JURISPRUDÊNCIA
LUÍS ROBERTO BARROSO, LEONARDO MARTINS,
LENIO LUIZ STRECK
BOOK REVIEWS // RESENHAS
GILBERTO GUERRA PEDROSA, CARINA CALABRIA,
GABRIEL REZENDE DE SOUZA PINTO
University of Brasília Law Journal
Revista de Direito da Universidade de Brasília
V. 01, I. 01
january – june 2014
2. University of Brasília Law Journal
Revista de Direito da Universidade de Brasília
Journal of the Graduate Program in Law of
the University of Brasilia
january – june, 2014, volume 1, issue 1
Editorial Board
Editor-in-Chief
Marcelo Neves Universidade de Brasília, Brazil
Editors
Alexandre Veronese Universidade de Brasília, Brazil
George Rodrigo Bandeira Galindo Universidade de Brasília, Brazil
Juliano Zaiden Benvindo Universidade de Brasília, Brazil
Associate Editors
Ana Lúcia Sabadell Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Ángel Oquendo University of Connecticut, Estados Unidos
Emilios Christodoulidis University of Glasgow, Scotland
José Octávio Serra Van-Dúnem Universidade Agostinho Neto, Angola
Leonel Severo Rocha Universidade do Vale do Rio dos Sinos, Brazil
Masayuski Murayama Meiji University, Japan
René Fernando Urueña Hernandez Universidad de Los Andes, Colombia
Miguel Nogueira de Brito University of Lisbon, Portugal
Nelson Juliano Cardoso Matos Universidade Federal do Piauí, Brazil
Paulo Weyl Universidade Federal do Pará, Brazil
Thomas Vesting Johann Wolfgang Goethe University, Germany
Virgílio Afonso da Silva Universidade de São Paulo, Brazil
Executive Secretary
Carina Calabria
Executive Aides
Gabriel Rezende de Souza Pinto; José Nunes de Cerqueira Neto;
Matheus Barra de Souza
Text Reviewers
Ana Luiza Almeida e Silva, Bethânia I. A. Arifa,
Camilla de Magalhães, Carolina Lemos, Clarice Calixto,
Douglas Zaidan, Fabrício Noronha, Gilberto Guerra Pedrosa,
Guilherme Del Negro, Hector L. C. Vieira, Kelton de Oliveira Gomes,
Luciana Silva Garcia, Maria Celina Gordilho, Paulo Soares Sampaio,
Nara Vilas Boas Bueno e Tédney Moreira
GRAPHIC DESIGN
André Maya Monteiro
Esteban Pinilla
3. University of Brasília Law Journal
Revista de Direito da Universidade de Brasília
V. 01, I. 01
january – june 2014
4. EDITORIAL // NOTA EDITORIAL
Articles // ARTIGOS
THE LAW BEFORE ITS LAW: FRANZ KAFKA ON THE (IM)POSSIBILITY
OF LAW’S SELF REFLECTION
// O DIREITO DIANTE DE SUA LEI: SOBRE A (IM)POSSIBILIDADE DE AUTORREFLEXÃO
COLETIVA DA MODERNIDADE JURÍDICA
Günther Teubner
NEW LEGAL APPROACHES TO POLICY REFORM IN BRAZIL
// NOVAS PERSPECTIVAS JURÍDICAS SOBRE
A REFORMA DE POLÍTICAS PÚBLICAS NO BRASIL
Marcus Faro de Castro
MAY EVERY PEOPLE WEAVE THE THREADS OF THEIR OWN HISTORY: JURIDICAL
PLURALISM IN DIDACTICAL DIALOGUE WITH LEGISLATORS
// QUE CADA POVO TEÇA OS FIOS DA SUA HISTÓRIA: O PLURALISMO JURÍDICO EM
DIÁLOGO DIDÁTICO COM LEGISLADORES
Rita Laura Segato
THE BEHEADING OF THE LEGISLATOR: THE EUROPEAN CRISIS – PARADOXES OF
CONSTITUTIONALIZING DEMOCRATIC CAPITALISM
// A DECAPITAÇÃO DO LEGISLADOR: A CRISE EUROPEIA – PARADOXOS DA
CONSTITUCIONALIZAÇÃO DO CAPITALISMO DEMOCRÁTICO
Hauke Brunkhorst
THE RACIAL BOUNDARIES OF GENOCIDE
// AS FRONTEIRAS RACIAIS DO GENOCÍDIO
Ana Luiza Pinheiro Flauzina
CRIMINAL COMPLIANCE, CONTROL AND ACTUARIAL LOGIC:
THE RELATIVIZATION OF THE NEMO TENETUR SE DETEGERE
// CRIMINAL COMPLIANCE, CONTROLE E LÓGICA ATUARIAL:
A RELATIVIZAÇÃO DO NEMO TENETUR SE DETEGERE
Ricardo Jacobsen Gloeckner e David Leal da Silva
HUMAN DIGNITY, SOCIAL SECURITY AND MINIMUM LIVING WAGE: THE
DECISION OF THE BUNDESVERFASSUNGSGERICHT THAT DECLARED THE
UNCONSTITUTIONALITY OF THE BENEFIT AMOUNT PAID TO ASYLUM SEEKERS
// DIGNIDADE HUMANA, ASSISTÊNCIA SOCIAL E MÍNIMO EXISTENCIAL: A DECISÃO
DO BUNDESVERFASSUNGSGERICHT QUE DECLAROU A INCONSTITUCIONALIDADE DO
VALOR DO BENEFÍCIO PAGO AOS ESTRANGEIROS ASPIRANTES A ASILO
João Costa Neto
11–30
31–61
62–88
89–112
113–139
140–163
164–188
06–09
10–188
5. Review Essays // ARTIGOS-RESENHA
MORAL THEOLOGY FOR HEDGEHOGS:
RONALD DWORKIN’S THEORY OF JUSTICE
// TEOLOGIA MORAL PARA OURIÇOS:
A TEORIA DA JUSTIÇA DE RONALD DWORKIN
Alexandre Araújo Costa
Case Notes & Commentaries // COMENTÁRIOS DE JURISPRUDÊNCIA
SAME-SEX UNIONS: LEGAL RECOGNITION
OF COMMON LAW UNIONS BETWEEN SAME-SEX PARTNERS
// UNIÕES HOMOAFETIVAS: RECONHECIMENTO JURÍDICO
DAS UNIÕES ESTÁVEIS ENTRE PARCEIROS DO MESMO SEXO
Luís Roberto Barroso
THE RECOGNITION OF STABLE CIVIL UNIONS BETWEEN SAME SEX PARTNERS AS
A FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT BY CONSTITUTIONAL JUSTICE
// RECONHECIMENTO DA UNIÃO ESTÁVEL HOMOAFETIVA COMO DIREITO
FUNDAMENTAL PELA JUSTIÇA CONSTITUCIONAL
Leonardo Martins
THE CASE ADPF 132: IS DEFENDING THE CONSTITUTIONAL TEXT
A POSITIVIST (OR ORIGINALIST) ATTITUDE?
// O CASO DA ADPF 132: DEFENDER O TEXTO DA CONSTITUIÇÃO
É UMA ATITUDE POSITIVISTA (OU “ORIGINALISTA”)?
Lenio Luiz Streck
Book Reviews // RESENHAS
[THE DIGNITY OF THE HUMAN BEING IN CONTEMPORARY CONSTITUTIONAL LAW:
THE CONSTRUCTION OF A LEGAL CONCEPT UNDER THE LIGHT OF THE WORLD’S
case law]
// A DIGNIDADE DA PESSOA HUMANA NO DIREITO CONSTITUCIONAL
CONTEMPORÂNEO: A CONSTRUÇÃO DE UM CONCEITO JURÍDICO À LUZ DA
JURISPRUDÊNCIA MUNDIAL
Gilberto Guerra Pedrosa
[LEGAL ABSTRACTIONS AND SOCIAL CHANGE: INTERACTIONS BETWEEN THE
LAW, PHILOSOPHY, POLITICS AND THE ECONOMY]
// FORMAS JURÍDICAS E MUDANÇA SOCIAL: INTERAÇÕES ENTRE O DIREITO,
A FILOSOFIA, A POLÍTICA E A ECONOMI
Carina Calabria
ON THE LIMITS OF CONSTITUTIONAL ADJUDICATION:
DECONSTRUCTING BALANCING AND JUDICIAL ACTIVISM
// [OS LIMITES DA JURISDIÇÃO CONSTITUCIONAL: DESCONSTRUINDO O
BALANCEAMENTO E O ATIVISMO JUDICIAL]
Gabriel Rezende de Souza Pinto
211–234
235–269
270–293
295–300
301–306
307–312
190–209
189–209
210–293
294–312
6. Direito.UnB, january – june, 2014, v. 01, i.01 307
BENVINDO, JULIANO ZAIDEN (2010). ON THE
LIMITS OF CONSTITUTIONAL ADJUDICATION:
DECONSTRUCTING BALANCING AND JUDICIAL
ACTIVISM. HEIDELBERG: SPRINGER.
// BENVINDO, JULIANO ZAIDEN (2010). [OS
LIMITES DA JURISDIÇÃO CONSTITUCIONAL:
DESCONSTRUINDO O BALANCEAMENTO E O
ATIVISMO JUDICIAL]. HEIDELBERG: SPRINGER.
Gabriel Rezende de Souza Pinto
7. Direito.UnB, january – june, 2014, v. 01, i.01 308
ABOUT THE AUTHOR // SOBRE O AUTOR
PhD Candidate in Law at Universidade de Brasília. // Doutorando em
Direito pela Universidade de Brasília.
>>
Benvindo, Juliano (2010). On the Limits of constitutional adjudication [...], p. 307 – 312
8. Direito.UnB, january – june, 2014, v. 01, i.01 309
It’s common that book reviews are opened with a kind of compliment
that highlights the importance of a certain work to the field of study
where it belongs. This is not exactly what one can say about On the limits
of constitutional adjudication: deconstructing balancing and judicial activ-
ism, by Juliano Zaiden Benvindo. Not without a complication; not with-
out the notion of field having already been complicated for at least two
reasons. Firstly, although the book, which is a result of the doctoral thesis
defended both at Universidade de Brasília and at Humboldt University,
Berlin, announces itself as a study of constitutional law, it becomes most
promptly clear to the reader that those limits are dissolved before the
naturalness and consistency of Benvindo’s journey through some of the
most complex philosophical debates of the second half of the 20th
century.
Notably on what is organized around the names of Jacques Derrida and
Jürgen Habermas. Secondly, the idea of field is harmed because the entire
proposal of the work is nothing more than a strong critique to the hege-
monic movement that informs contemporary constitutional law – both
Brazilian and German versions. Therefore, Benvindo’s work does not
derive its importance from a so-called importance to the filed, but instead
from how it challenges the strength of that common sense, taking part
on its deconstruction.
If the object of the investigation is already displayed on the subti-
tle, that is, a certain objection to balancing (values, principles, maybe
values-principles) and to judicial activism, it becomes thinkable through
a certain course, a path where one sees the concept of limited rationali-
ty coming. Trail and treading in which the becoming of balancing and of
judicial activism unfolds as one thing only; one same movement combin-
ing intention to rationality and centralization of major political deci-
sions on constitutional courts. One circulates, somehow, around what
Jean de la Fontaine would say on the fable The wolf and the lamb: “the
reason of the strongest is always the best”. Benvindo will demonstrate it,
“subsequently”, on the threefold division of the book.
In the first chapter it is discussed the presence of the principle of
proportionality as a dominant method of adjudication and, on its inside,
balancing, logical finishing line of this historical proceeding. Three
cases are underlined to this matter: the Crucifix case, the Cannabis case
and the Ellwanger case. Having this last one been ruled by the Brazilian
Supreme Court (STF) and the two others by the German Federal Consti-
tutional Tribunal (BVG), the outlines of hegemony that crosses both
juridical cultures investigated by Benvindo are established: balancing as
definitive entrance of values in the form-of-law. Dissolving the boundar-
ies of this form, the balancing designs the transposition of the political
reasoning of reaching common good to the typical space of constitution-
al courts activities.
This is exactly what Benvindo intends to oppose. The two chapters that
follow analyze historically the emergence of the principles of propor-
tionality and balancing to the condition of constitutional meta-prin-
ciples. This movement introduces a clear guidance: the change in BVG
and STF auto-comprehension towards a model of judicial activism. The
Benvindo, Juliano (2010). On the Limits of constitutional adjudication [...], p. 307 – 312
9. Direito.UnB, january – june, 2014, v. 01, i.01 310
constitutional tribunals would then franchise the conversion of funda-
mental rights as subjective rights to their conception in terms of objective
principles of a total legal order. Under such terms, the subjective right no
longer functions as trump against the will of political majorities, being
put in relation to the order of values that the principles would shape. The
totality of the legal order is now the totality of the objective principles
and every political question may be handled as a question of optimizing
fundamental rights. If principles are indeed maxims, the constitution-
al courts may now describe themselves as the lawful path to the enforce-
ment of values.
Benvindo supports the interesting thesis that, both in Brazil and in
Germany, the change towards judicial activism was related to the need
to respond to antidemocratic legacies. Saying “never more” to Nazism
and to the military dictatorship involved, beforehand, distrusting legis-
lative institutions and the executive power, considered responsible for
the devastating authoritarian practices or, at least, incapable of standing
against them. One foresaw the indispensability of a strong power that
would endure the task of defending the values of constitutional democ-
racy and enforcing fundamental rights. Autoimmunity: that which is
built to protect democracy risks destroying it. Balancing becomes hege-
monic in this context because it is capable of opening two different paths
of legitimation: on one hand, it allowed treating rights as if they were
values, widening the scope and nature of judicial activity in accomplish-
ing its new task – even if this meant disregarding the traditional limits of
the notion of division of powers; on the other hand, it allowed justifying
judicial activism by granting it an aura of rationality. Through innumer-
ous examples and a wide historical reconstruction of the role of BVG and
STF in emerging German and Brazilian democracies, Benvindo demon-
strates how balancing accompanies the rising centrality of constitution-
al courts erasing the borders between law and justice at the exact same
time it emphasizes the rationality of its methodology.
The second part of the book is dedicated to the debate about the ratio-
nality of balancing. After all, what is weird about its emergence to the
condition of guardian of the place of jurisdictional rationality? The forth
chapter elects Robert Alexy’s theoretical model as locus to the discus-
sion and seeks to highlight the features of its main axioms. On the well-
known special case thesis, developed on Theory of Legal Argumentation,
it is already seen the problematic dissolution of the limits of law on a
discourse in which the objectives of a given community may prevail over
constitutional guarantees. On his Theory of Fundamental Rights, Alexy
translates this logic into a method that would supposedly control the
risks of irrationality on normative collisions. The principle of propor-
tionality and, on its inside, balancing constitute a rational methodology
to times of judicial activism.
Chapters 5 and 6 will attack these premises. Benvindo adopts a strate-
gy somehow heterodox and, for this reason, really courageous: to oppose
balancing by using a concept of limited rationality created through the
productive tension between Jacques Derrida’s différance and Jürgen
Benvindo, Juliano (2010). On the Limits of constitutional adjudication [...], p. 307 – 312
10. Direito.UnB, january – june, 2014, v. 01, i.01 311
Habermas’ proceduralism. As if replicating the former’s reply to the invi-
tation to a discussion proposed by the latter in 1999 – “it’s time, we hope it’s
not too late” –, Benvindo makes the two philosophers dialogue before his
need to confront and face balancing. With Derrida, he drafts a thought of
justice that makes justice to the other. Law is, therefore, assimilated into
the double bind, into the aporia between constitutionalism and democ-
racy. Understanding that the law is properly de-constructible and that
justice is the de-construction means realizing the indispensability of
both and the fact that a decision worthy of the name is always the one
that resides on undecidability– to be infinitely distinguished from inde-
cision – on differentiation and on differing the presence of its content, on
its irreducibility to any set of rules. This dynamic of infinite negotiations
is poorly adjusted to a methodological ruling that intends to be rational
precisely in controlling the différance. There is something extremely logo-
centric in balancing.
With Habermas, Benvindo searches a kind of therapy to the problem
of law’s indetermination and, therefore, of adjudication in the context of
post-conventional societies. One may, then, develop a critique to balanc-
ing through the emphasis on proceedings oriented to mutual under-
standing. The Habermasian idea of intersubjectivity and its consequenc-
es to the motivation of a judicial activity that does not resort to previous
methodologies sustain his critique. Benvindo is not limited to pointing
out, from this critique, how balancing includes valorative elements in
adjudication or how its criterion of discretionarity reduces rights of the
minority, but he also disapproves the supposed heuristic capacity of its
method of controlling knowledge.
The concept of limited rationality, finally discussed in depth on the
third and last part of the work, tries to account for a possible dialogue
between différance and intersubjectivity and, ergo, between a symmet-
ric justice and another asymmetric. The thesis supported is that, as hard
and improbable as this approximation may be, there is a game of comple-
mentarity and compatibility between them. If any translation is at the
same time possible and impossible, then one has to turn the reflection to
a resolution without resolution: the productive tension upon its horizon
of (un)translatability. Benvindo bets on a kind of approximation between
Derrida and Habermas’ philosophizing about more concrete institution-
al matters, such as adjudication. The limited rationality does not only put
itself on this place, but makes room for these issues to irrupt on a dynam-
ic of searching for justice. The last chapter operates a return to the three
judicial cases studied at the beginning of the work in order to reconsid-
er them in light of this rationality that recognizes itself as limited. Three
axioms on its approach are noticeable: a) focus on the singularity of the
concrete case beyond the simplifying previous formula; b) reconstruc-
tion of institutional history to maintaining the consistency of the system
of rights; c) a adjudication that asserts the otherness of the other.
This is how Benvindo proposes as an alternative to balancing a
renewed connection between “the empirical world” and a limited reason.
On the limit, a matter of limits. In this manner, rationality also invites to
Benvindo, Juliano (2010). On the Limits of constitutional adjudication [...], p. 307 – 312
11. Direito.UnB, january – june, 2014, v. 01, i.01 312
think the porosity of its limitation, what crosses it, what undoes the pure
boundaries. Whatever the answer may be, before the limen, it’s necessary
to read On the limits of constitutional adjudication.
Benvindo, Juliano (2010). On the Limits of constitutional adjudication [...], p. 307 – 312
12. Direito.UnB. Revista de Direito da Universidade de Brasília.
Programa de Pós-Graduação em Direito – Vol.1, N.1 (jan./jul 2014) –
Brasília, DF: Universidade de Brasília, Faculdade de Direito.
Semestral. 2014.
ISSN 2357-8009 (versão on-line)
ISSN 2318-9908 (versão impressa)
Bilíngue (Português/Inglês)
1. Direito – periódicos. I. Universidade de Brasília,
Faculdade de Direito.
CDU 340