2. Journal of Physical Security 14(1), 35-36 (2021)
The following are some possible purposes for the seal that I could think of, including non-
security purposes:
1. Reassure the customer during the pandemic.
2. Detect tampering with the order inside the restaurant.
3. Detect tampering with the order by any delivery driver.
4. Use as a "Vlag" (non-security) seal to indicate to restaurant workers that the order is
complete so as to avoid unnecessary additional handling.
5. Authenticate the order as a legitimate order, i.e., the seal would be more like a tag.
6. Remind restaurant employees to follow good anti-COVID procedures.
7. Some other kind of safety or health function?
8. Literally, a seal to be sure the bag is well closed.
9. For advertising purposes, given that the seal contains the company logo; or perhaps
for otherwise making a connection with the customer.
10. Provide a Vlap to hold the drinking straw.
11. Other?
I emailed a senior public relations ofVicial with the company, and sent a letter to the CEO,
inquiring about which purpose(s) in the above list were their intent. Perhaps
unsurprisingly, I receive no answer.
Possible partial countermeasures for the vulnerabilities with the PSA seal might include
brieVly applying heat to the seal to improve adhesion, using a more aggressive adhesive,
using a frangible seal, or choosing a different bag material. Stapling the top of the bag
through the seal using a digestible staple/rivet might also provide better tamper detection.
Possible partial countermeasures for the bottom of the bag might include using a more
aggressive adhesive, or using a bag made of heat- or ultrasonically-sealed Mylar or other
material that would not require an adhesive to seal the seams. This might be harder to
cosmetically repair after an attack.
Another approach that could potentially improve tamper detection is to print a highly
visible notice on the bag (not the seal!) to encourage customers and employees to visually
check the bag and the seal's presence/appearance to look for evidence of tampering. This,
of course, would involve explicitly admitting that the seal has a security purpose.
References
1. RG Johnston, “Poor Practice Using Pressure-Sensitive Adhesive Seals”, Journal of Physical
Security 12(2), 18-28 (2019), https://jps.rbsekurity.com
2. RG Johnston and JS Warner, “How to Choose and Use Seals”, Army Sustainment 44(4),
54-58 (2012), http://www.almc.army.mil/alog/issues/JulAug12/browse.html
3. RG Johnston, “Tamper-Indicating Seals”, American Scientist 94(6), 515-523 (2005)
36