SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 8
© 2005 WebMD, Inc. All rights reserved.                                                          ACS Surgery: Principles and Practice
 6 VASCULAR SYSTEM                                                   22 OPEN PROCEDURES FOR RENOVASCULAR DISEASE — 1



22 OPEN PROCEDURES FOR
              RENOVASCULAR DISEASE
Matthew S. Edwards, M.D., Juan Ayerdi, M.D., and Kimberley J. Hansen, M.D., F.A.C.S.




Until comparatively recently, intervention for renovascular disease        Disease] is liberally used as an alternative to open renal artery
focused entirely on hypertension. However, the introduction of             revascularization, but the data currently available suggest that it
potent new antihypertensive agents and percutaneous endovascu-             should be employed selectively.The best results with PTRA alone
lar methods of management has led to substantial changes in atti-          have been achieved with nonostial atherosclerotic renal artery
tudes to and indications for management of renovascular disease.           lesions and medial fibroplasia of the main renal artery. Suboptimal
Today, open surgical repair is commonly reserved for (1) patients          results have been achieved with hypoplastic (i.e., developmental)
who have severe hypertension despite optimal medical therapy, (2)          lesions, fibrodysplasia of the intimal and perimedial variety, ostial
patients in whom percutaneous transluminal renal artery angio-             atherosclerotic renal artery lesions, and renal artery occlusions.
plasty (PTRA) fails or who have disease patterns that are not              For ostial renal artery atherosclerosis, some surgeons have advo-
amenable to PTRA, and (3) patients who have renovascular dis-              cated PTRA with primary endoluminal stenting in an effort to
ease associated with excretory renal insufficiency (i.e., ischemic         improve results; however, the results of PTRA and primary stent-
nephropathy).1                                                             ing in this setting have been inferior to those of open operative
   The experience of our center (Wake Forest University School of          repair. Consequently, in the majority of cases of ostial atheroscle-
Medicine) in the management of more than 850 patients over a               rosis in combination with renal insufficiency, we advise operative
16-year period indicates that atherosclerotic renovascular disease         intervention for good-risk patients.
frequently exists in combination with diffuse extrarenal athero-              These recommendations are not absolute. Decisions regarding
sclerosis and renal insufficiency. In one study, bilateral atheroscle-     therapy for renovascular disease must be individualized. Factors
rotic renal artery lesions were present in two thirds of patients, and     contributing to the choice of treatment include the expected mor-
complete renal artery occlusion was present in more than one               bidity and mortality of operative repair and the presence of pre-
third.2 Although practitioners frequently cite selected data to sup-       dictors of death and dialysis dependence at follow-up. In this
port a particular management scheme in this setting, the question          regard, severe left ventricular dysfunction with clinical congestive
of what constitutes optimal management of atherosclerotic reno-            heart failure, diabetes mellitus, and uncorrectable azotemia have
vascular disease responsible for either hypertension or renal insuf-       all been shown to be significant and independent predictors of
ficiency is still unanswerable.To date, there have been no prospec-        reduced dialysis-free survival.2,3
tive, randomized trials that compare the best medical manage-
ment with PTRA and with open surgical repair.
                                                                           Operative Planning

Preoperative Evaluation                                                    SURGICAL STRATEGY

    Evaluation and diagnosis of renovascular hypertension and reno-          Our use of open surgical methods to treat atherosclerotic reno-
 vascular renal insufficiency (i.e., ischemic nephropathy) are discussed   vascular disease is based on several guiding principles [see Table 1].
 in more detail elsewhere, as are general issues related to the            We consider severe hypertension a prerequisite for open operative
question of medical versus surgical therapy.                               management and do not perform prophylactic renal artery repair


INDICATIONS FOR INTERVENTION

   The recognition of both the progressive nature of the athero-                     Table 1—Recommended Principles for
sclerotic renovascular lesions seen in combination with severe                       Contemporary Surgical Management of
hypertension and the deterioration of renal function seen in select-                        Renovascular Disease10
ed patients who are managed medically lends support to the idea
that renal artery intervention is indicated when either renovascu-             Renal artery repair is done on an empirical, but not prophylactic, basis
lar hypertension or ischemic nephropathy is present. In our view,              Complete renal artery repair is done in one operation when feasible;
                                                                                 bilateral ex vivo reconstruction may be staged
renal artery intervention is appropriate in patients with severe               Direct aortorenal methods of reconstruction are preferred
hypertension and, specifically, in all patients who have severe hy-            Nephrectomy is reserved for nonreconstructable disease in a
pertension in combination with excretory renal insufficiency (i.e.,              nonfunctioning kidney
ischemic nephropathy). Open operative management is preferred                  Combined aortic reconstruction is limited to clinically significant
                                                                                 disease
for children and young adults and for patients with bilateral reno-
                                                                               Intraoperative duplex sonography is performed to assess technical
vascular disease, especially if renal artery occlusion is present.2              success
   PTRA [see 6:16 Endovascular Procedures for Renovascular
© 2005 WebMD, Inc. All rights reserved.                                                     ACS Surgery: Principles and Practice
6 VASCULAR SYSTEM                                                  22 OPEN PROCEDURES FOR RENOVASCULAR DISEASE — 2


           a                                                                 b




                                                                              c




                Figure 1 Aortorenal bypass.8 Technique for end-to-side (a, b) and end-to-end (c) aortorenal bypass
                grafting. The length of arteriotomy is at least three times the diameter of the artery to prevent recur-
                rent anastomotic stenosis. For the anastomosis, 6-0 or 7-0 monofilament polypropylene sutures are
                used in continuous fashion, under loupe magnification. If the apex sutures are placed too deeply or
                with excess advancement, stenosis can be created, posing a risk of late graft thrombosis.


                                                                         Operative Technique
in patients who are not hypertensive. Although we employ renal
vein renin assays to guide management of unilateral lesions in many         Various open surgical techniques are used to correct athero-
cases, we typically perform empirical renal artery repair without        sclerotic renovascular disease; however, no single repair technique
functional studies when the hypertension is severe or uncontrolled       is optimal for all renovascular lesions. The best approach to renal
and when renal artery disease is bilateral or involves a solitary kid-   artery reconstruction in any given case depends on patient char-
ney. We attempt to correct all hemodynamically significant reno-         acteristics, the pattern of renal artery disease, and the presence or
vascular disease in a single operation; we perform staged repair only    absence of associated aortic lesions that may have to be corrected
in cases in which the disease necessitates bilateral ex vivo recon-      simultaneously. The open procedures most commonly performed
struction. Because the lower limit of renal function retrieval is not    to treat renovascular disease are (1) aortorenal bypass, (2) renal
known but improved renal function is known to be the strongest           artery thromboendarterectomy, and (3) renal artery reimplanta-
predictor of dialysis-free survival, we reserve nephrectomy for          tion. In general, aortorenal bypass is the most versatile of these
patients who have an unreconstructable lesion in a renal artery sup-     procedures.Transaortic thromboendarterectomy may be especial-
plying a nonfunctioning kidney (i.e., a kidney providing less than       ly useful when ostial atherosclerosis ends within 1 cm of the origin
10% glomerular filtration on renography).4 In the majority of open       of the renal artery and involves multiple renal arteries. Renal
operative repairs, we employ direct aortorenal reconstruction            artery reimplantation is often particularly appropriate for the cor-
methods; we seldom use indirect (splanchnorenal) methods,                rection of renovascular disease in children and adolescents, in that
because celiac axis stenosis is present in 40% to 50% of patients        concerns regarding graft material are eliminated.
and bilateral repair is required in more than 50%.2 Regardless of           With all of these reconstruction techniques, multiple small
the method of reconstruction employed, we perform intraoperative         doses of mannitol are administered intravenously during perirenal
renal duplex sonography as a completion study to look for any            aortic and renal artery dissection. Mannitol is given both before
technical errors in the repair that might lead to restenosis or occlu-   and after periods of warm renal ischemia up to a total dose of 1
sion. Failed renal artery repair has been associated with a signifi-     g/kg. During cross-clamping of the aorta and the renal artery, the
cant and independent risk of eventual dependence on dialysis.5           patient is given heparin, 100 U/kg, to establish systemic anticoag-
© 2005 WebMD, Inc. All rights reserved.                                                   ACS Surgery: Principles and Practice
6 VASCULAR SYSTEM                                                22 OPEN PROCEDURES FOR RENOVASCULAR DISEASE — 3


ulation. When a purely autogenous reconstruction is performed,         eter of the smallest conduit, and the ends of the conduit should be
antibiotics are unnecessary; however, when a prosthetic graft is       widely spatulated to guard against late suture line stenosis. The
employed, administration of a first-generation cephalosporin is        proximal anastomosis is usually made with a continuous 6-0
begun 2 hours before operation and continued for 24 hours.             monofilament polypropylene suture, and the distal anastomosis is
                                                                       created with a continuous 7-0 or 8-0 monofilament polypropylene
AORTORENAL BYPASS
                                                                       suture.
   Aortorenal bypass [see Figure 1] may be performed with either
                                                                       THROMBOENDARTERECTOMY
an autogenous conduit or a prosthetic graft. If an entirely autoge-
nous repair is possible, we prefer to use a reversed segment of the       Thromboendarterectomy of the renal arteries and the perirenal
greater saphenous vein as the conduit. If the saphenous vein is too    aorta may be performed via either a transrenal or a transaortic
narrow (i.e., < 4 mm in diameter) or of inadequate quality, a 6        approach. When the renal artery atheroma extends 1 cm or less
mm thin-walled polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) graft is used            from the ostium and involves both or multiple renal arteries, the
instead. In either case, the infrarenal aorta is dissected and         transaortic technique [see Figure 2] is especially useful. With both
clamped proximally and distally, and a longitudinal elliptical open-   endarterectomy techniques, extensive aortic exposure is required.
ing is created anterolaterally in the aortic wall (e.g., with two or   The aorta proximal to the origin of the superior mesenteric artery
three applications of a 5.2 mm aortic punch). If required, a local     (SMA) is exposed and controlled. This exposure is facilitated by
endarterectomy at the site of the anastomosis may be performed         partially dividing the aortic crura and controlling the SMA with a
through this opening.                                                  Silastic loop.
   The proximal and distal anastomoses are then created.                  Currently, the majority of aortorenal endarterectomies are per-
Although end-to-side distal renal artery anastomoses were com-         formed through a longitudinal aortotomy extending from a point
monly performed at one time, current aortorenal bypass tech-           2 to 3 cm below the renal arteries to the base of the SMA. A sleeve
niques typically employ end-to-end distal renal artery anasto-         of aortic atheroma is created, then divided sharply at the base of
moses. For both the proximal and the distal anastomosis, the           the SMA proximally and well below the most inferior renal artery
length of the arteriotomy should be at least three times the diam-     distally. After the aortic endarterectomy is completed, an eversion-



                     a                                                        b




                                                                                                                           Left
                                                                                                                           Renal
                                                                                                                           Artery
                                                                       SMA




             SMA



                                                                                                                   IMA




                     Figure 2 Thromboendarterectomy.8 Exposure for a longitudinal transaortic endarterectomy is
                     obtained via the standard transperitoneal approach. The duodenum is mobilized from the aorta later-
                     ally in the standard fashion; alternatively, for more complete exposure, the ascending colon and the
                     small bowel are mobilized. (a) Dotted line shows the location of the aortotomy. (b) The plaque is
                     transected proximally and distally, the renal arteries are everted, and the atherosclerotic plaque is
                     removed from each renal ostium. The aortotomy is typically closed with a continuous 4-0 or 5-0
                     polypropylene suture. (IMA—inferior mesenteric artery)
© 2005 WebMD, Inc. All rights reserved.                                                       ACS Surgery: Principles and Practice
 6 VASCULAR SYSTEM                                                  22 OPEN PROCEDURES FOR RENOVASCULAR DISEASE — 4




                   a                                           b                      c




                                                                          d


                  Figure 3 Renal artery reimplantation.9 (a)
                  When the renal artery is redundant and the
                  disease involves the orifice of the renal artery,
                  it is usually possible to reimplant the vessel at
                  a lower level. Dotted lines indicate the location
                  of the aortotomy and the point where the renal
                  artery is divided. (b) An elliptical opening is
                  created in the aortic wall, and a local
                  endarterectomy is done as required. (c) A
                  monofilament suture is placed in the aortic
                  wall. (d) The native renal artery is ligated,
                  proximally spatulated, and reimplanted.




type endarterectomy is performed for each of the renal arteries.             Although this technique has only limited applicability to the
The surgical assistant retracts the anterior lip of the aortic wall and   treatment of atherosclerotic renovascular disease in adults, it may
inverts the renal artery into the aorta, and the operating surgeon        be particularly useful for this purpose in children and young ado-
retracts the renal artery atheroma while gently pushing the               lescents, who often have congenital or developmental lesions that
remaining renal artery away with a dissector. In this manner, the         involve the renal artery orifice. The main advantage of reimplan-
end point of the endarterectomy can easily be visualized to con-          tation is that it obviates concerns regarding the durability of the
firm that the endarterectomy is complete.The endarterectomy site          renal artery conduit.
is then irrigated with heparinized saline, and the longitudinal aor-
                                                                          SPLANCHNORENAL BYPASS
totomy is closed with a continuous 4-0 or 5-0 monofilament
polypropylene suture.                                                        Indirect, or splanchnorenal, bypass [see Figure 4] is an uncom-
   Both transrenal and transaortic thromboendarterectomy are              mon procedure at our center. In large part, its relative rarity is a
contraindicated if aneurysmal degeneration of the perirenal aorta         reflection of the frequent presence of simultaneous disease of the
is present or if there is transmural calcification at the site of         celiac axis and the frequent need for bilateral renal artery recon-
endarterectomy.                                                           struction in combination with aortic repair. In addition, we believe
                                                                          that this approach does not yield long-term patency equivalent to
RENAL ARTERY REIMPLANTATION
                                                                          that provided by direct aortorenal reconstruction. Consequently,
   In the course of renal artery exposure, the vessel is dissected        these indirect bypass techniques are reserved for a selected sub-
from its aortic origin to its primary bifurcation. On occasion, after     group of high-risk patients.
complete dissection, the vessel is found to have sufficient redun-           Hepatorenal bypass is most frequently performed through a
dancy to allow tension-free reimplantation into the infrarenal            right subcostal incision, splenorenal bypass through a left sub-
aorta [see Figure 3]. As in a renal artery bypass [see Aortorenal         costal incision. In either procedure, the patient is positioned with
Bypass, above], an elliptical section of the aortic wall is resected,     a roll beneath the ipsilateral flank, with the operating table flexed
and a widely spatulated aortorenal anastomosis is fashioned.              and the ipsilateral arm padded and tucked to the side.The incision
© 2005 WebMD, Inc. All rights reserved.                                                      ACS Surgery: Principles and Practice
6 VASCULAR SYSTEM                                                  22 OPEN PROCEDURES FOR RENOVASCULAR DISEASE — 5


may be extended to the contralateral semilunar line and into the         function in 60% of occluded renal arteries that underwent opera-
ipsilateral flank as necessary for exposure. In a hepatorenal bypass,    tive repair.4
a greater saphenous vein graft is usually employed, originating
                                                                         INTRAOPERATIVE RENAL DUPLEX ULTRASONOGRAPHY
from the common hepatic artery and coursing posterior to the
portal triad and anterior to the vena cava before the end-to-end            The surgeon’s technique plays a dominant role in determining
renal artery anastomosis [see Figure 4]. A splenorenal bypass may        patency after renal artery reconstruction. To look for technical
be created either in a similar fashion (i.e., with a greater saphenous   errors at the time of operation, we employ intraoperative renal
vein graft) or by anastomosing the transected splenic artery direct-     duplex ultrasonography. A 10.0/5.0 mHz compact linear array
ly to the left renal artery [see Figure 5]. If the latter approach is    probe with Doppler color-flow capability is placed within a sterile
taken, the collateral circulation to the spleen is sufficient to main-   sheath that has a latex tip containing sterile gel.The operative field
tain splenic viability.                                                  is flooded with warm saline solution, and B-scan images are
                                                                         obtained from the sites of aortic control and of renal artery repair.
NEPHRECTOMY                                                              All defects noted on the B-scan images are then examined in both
   In patients with renovascular renal insufficiency or ischemic         longitudinal and transverse projections. Doppler samples are
nephropathy, an incremental increase in excretory renal function         obtained proximal and distal to the lesions to determine their
after operation is the dominant determinant of dialysis-free sur-        hemodynamic significance.6 In 249 consecutive renal artery
vival. As noted [see Operative Planning, Surgical Strategy, above],      repairs with anatomic follow-up, 10% had a focal increase in peak
we reserve nephrectomy for patients in whom an unrecon-                  systolic velocities consistent with residual stenosis.2 Each defect
structable renal artery is supplying a nonfunctioning kidney.When        was revised immediately, and in each case, a significant defect was
the renal artery is occluded, reconstruction is performed if the dis-    found. At 12 months after operation, primary patency of the renal
tal renal artery is normal at the time of surgical exploration. Past     reconstruction was observed in 97% of repairs.This product-limit
recommendations regarding the management of renal artery oc-             estimate of patency is stable up to 8 years after operation.
clusion have emphasized kidney length, distal renal artery recon-
stitution, and the appearance of a nephrogram during angiography
                                                                         Outcome Evaluation
as criteria for determining whether reconstruction is indicated.
Our practice, however, has been to perform renal artery recon-             Surgical repair of atherosclerotic renovascular disease can be
struction whenever a normal distal renal artery is demonstrated.         accomplished with a high rate of success and sustained long-term
In a study employing this strategy, we reported retrieval of renal       patency. With proper patient selection, the majority of patients




              a                                                                       b




                                                                                       c




             Figure 4 Hepatorenal bypass.9 (a) Shown is exposure of the
             common hepatic artery and the proximal gastroduodenal artery
             in the hepatoduodenal ligament in preparation for hepatorenal
             bypass (typically through a right subcostal skin incision). (b,c)
             The reconstruction is completed by placing a greater saphenous
             vein interposition graft between the side of the hepatic artery
             and the distal end of the transected right renal artery.
© 2005 WebMD, Inc. All rights reserved.                                                         ACS Surgery: Principles and Practice
 6 VASCULAR SYSTEM                                               22 OPEN PROCEDURES FOR RENOVASCULAR DISEASE — 6


                                                                                                             Splenic Artery

                       a                                               b




                                                                                                                     Left Renal
                                                                                                                     Artery




                                                        Figure 5 Splenorenal bypass.9 (a) Shown is exposure of the left renal
                                                        hilum in preparation for splenorenal bypass (typically obtained through
                                                        a left subcostal incision). The pancreas has been mobilized along its
                                                        inferior margin and retracted superiorly. (b) The transected splenic
                                                        artery is anastomosed to the transected left renal artery in an end-to-
                                                        end manner. A splenectomy is not routinely performed.




demonstrate beneficial blood pressure response and renal function       perioperative mortality demonstrated significant and independent
response, albeit with perioperative mortality and morbidity that        associations with advanced age and clinical congestive heart fail-
vary according to the complexity of the procedure.                      ure. The estimated primary patency rate for all 720 renal artery
   In a 2002 report, we reviewed our center’s experience with 500       reconstructions was 97% at 8 years’ follow-up.
consecutive patients who underwent open surgical repair for treat-
ment of atherosclerotic renovascular disease between January            HYPERTENSION RESPONSE
1987 and December 1999.2 These patients included 254 women                 Early blood pressure response was estimated on the basis of
and 246 men, with a mean age of 65 ± 9 years. Each patient had          ambulatory blood pressure values and medication requirements
severe hypertension.The mean preoperative blood pressure for the        determined at least 1 month after operative repair. Among surgi-
group was 200 ± 35/104 ± 21 mm Hg. Most of the patients had             cal survivors, 12% were considered cured, 73% were considered
diffuse extrarenal atherosclerosis. A total of 81% had at least one
                                                                        improved, and 15% were considered failed [see Table 3].
manifestation of cardiac disease; 34% had a history of significant
cerebrovascular disease; and 78% were considered to have at least       RENAL FUNCTION RESPONSE
mild renal insufficiency, as evidenced by a serum creatinine con-
centration of 1.3 mg/dl or greater. Ischemic nephropathy was seen          A significant change in excretory renal function was defined
in 244 patients (49%), including 40 patients who were dependent         as a change of at least 20% in the estimated glomerular filtration
on dialysis before operation.                                           rate (EGFR), measured at least 3 weeks after repair. Of patients
   Angiographic evaluation demonstrated the presence of bilater-
al renal artery disease in 60% of these atherosclerotic patients.The
renal artery lesion was considered ostial in 97% of cases, and 16%          Table 2 Summary of Operative Management of
of renal arteries were completely occluded. A total of 720 renal                 Atherosclerotic Renovascular Disease2
artery reconstructions were performed [see Table 2]. Aortorenal by-
pass was performed in two thirds of the repairs, and two thirds of       Total renal reconstructions                  720
these bypasses were done with venous grafts.Thromboendarterec-             Aortorenal bypass                            384
tomy was performed in almost one third of the cases. Renal artery             Venous graft                                 204
reimplantation was performed in 56 instances, splanchnorenal by-              PTFE graft                                   159
pass in only 13 instances. Although there were 124 renal artery oc-           Dacron graft                                   21
clusions, only 56 of these were treated by means of nephrectomy.          Reimplantation                                  56
   Twenty-three patients (4.6%) died in the hospital or within 30         Thromboendarterectomy                         267
days of renal reconstruction. Mortality varied significantly with         Splanchnorenal bypass                           13
the magnitude of procedure. Mortality after isolated renal artery        Total nephrectomies                           56
repair was substantially lower than mortality after combined aor-
tic and bilateral renal artery repair (0.8% versus 6.9%). Moreover,      Total kidneys operated on                    776
© 2005 WebMD, Inc. All rights reserved.                                                                                                          ACS Surgery: Principles and Practice
           6 VASCULAR SYSTEM                                                                    22 OPEN PROCEDURES FOR RENOVASCULAR DISEASE — 7


                                                                                                                                   100
                                Table 3 Results of Operative Treatment of
                               Atherosclerotic Renovascular Disease among                                                           90
                                          472 Surgical Survivors2
                                                                                                                                    80
                                       Result                             Rate (%)
                                                                                                                                    70




                                                                                                      Dialysis-Free Survival (%)
                Perioperative mortality                                        4.6

                Hypertension response                                                                                               60
                  Cured                                                        12
                  Improved                                                     73                                                   50
                  Failed                                                       15

                Renal function response*                                                                                            40
                  Improved                                                     58
                  Unchanged                                                    35                                                   30
                  Worsened                                                      7
                                                                                                                                    20
 *For 220 patients with preoperative serum creatinine concentrations ≥ 1.8 mg/dl; a
 significant change is defined as a ≥ 20% change in EGFR.
                                                                                                                                    10


                                                                                                                                     0
  with preoperative ischemic nephropathy, 58% showed improve-                                                                            0   20     40      60       80       100   120    140
  ments in renal function, including 30 patients removed from
  dialysis dependence [see Table 3]. In contrast to previous reports                                                                                     Follow-up (months)
  that suggested the existence of a lower limit of renal dysfunction                                                                          EGFR               EGFR               EGFR
  beyond which recovery could not be observed, the percentage of                                                                              Improved           Unchanged          Worsened
  patients who showed improvement rose with increasing preop-                                               Figure 7 Illustrated are product-limit estimates of time to death
  erative serum creatinine concentration. Overall, 75% of dialysis-                                         or dialysis, stratified according to postoperative renal function
  dependent patients were permanently removed from dialysis                                                 response for patients with a preoperative EGFR of 25 ml/min/m2.
  after renal artery repair. In addition, the site of disease and the                                       The interaction between preoperative EGFR and renal function
  extent of repair were found to influence increases in the EGFR.                                           response for dialysis-free survival was significant and independent.2


                             100                                                                             Although each subgroup of patients who underwent operation
                                                                                                             demonstrated some improvement in renal function, the greatest
                              90                                                                             incremental increase in the EGFR was observed in those who
                                                                                                             underwent bilateral renal reconstruction for significant bilateral
                              80                                                                             disease.3,7
                                                                                                             RELATIONSHIP OF HYPERTENSION RESPONSE AND RENAL
                              70
Dialysis-Free Survival (%)




                                                                                                             FUNCTION RESPONSE TO DIALYSIS-FREE SURVIVAL

                              60                                                                                At a mean follow-up of 56 months, 171 patient deaths had
                                                                                                             occurred.When outcomes were considered in terms of the blood
                              50                                                                             pressure response to operative intervention, only hypertension
                                                                                                             cured was found to be significantly and independently associat-
                              40
                                                                                                             ed with survival or dialysis dependence: patients whose hyper-
                                                                                                             tension was cured experienced improved dialysis-free survival
                              30
                                                                                                             [see Figure 6]. In contrast, all outcome categories for the renal
                                                                                                             function response influenced both survival and eventual dialysis
                              20
                                                                                                             dependence. Patients with improved renal function experienced
                                                                                                             a significant increase in dialysis-free survival [see Figure 7].2 For
                                                                                                             patients whose renal function remained unchanged after oper-
                              10
                                                                                                             ation, however, the risk of eventual dialysis dependence and
                                                                                                             death was equivalent to that of patients whose renal function
                               0
                                                                                                             worsened after surgery. Whereas renal function that is un-
                                   0    20       40      60      80     100      120   140      160
                                                                                                             changed after intervention is frequently described as “stabilized”
                               N=472   N=376    N=271   N=184   N=113   N=67    N=30   N=8
                                                                                                             or “preserved,” our experience suggests that patients with ische-
                                                        Follow-up (months)                                   mic nephropathy and atherosclerotic renovascular disease whose
                                                                                                             renal function is unchanged postoperatively remain at increased
                                                Cured             Improved             Failed
                                                                                                             risk for eventual dialysis dependence and death.Whether similar
   Figure 6 Illustrated are product-limit estimates of time to death                                         associations exist for patients treated by means of catheter-based
   or dialysis, stratified according to blood pressure response to oper-                                     methods is unknown, but the question certainly merits future
   ation for atherosclerotic renovascular disease.2                                                          study.
© 2005 WebMD, Inc. All rights reserved.                                                                              ACS Surgery: Principles and Practice
 6 VASCULAR SYSTEM                                                               22 OPEN PROCEDURES FOR RENOVASCULAR DISEASE — 8


References

 1. Dean RH, Benjamin ME, Hansen KJ: Surgical man-              tion. J Vasc Surg 29:140, 1999                           8. Benjamin ME, Dean RH: Techniques in renal
    agement of renovascular hypertension. Curr Probl                                                                        artery reconstruction: part I. Ann Vasc Surg
                                                            5. Hansen KJ, Deitch JS, Oskin TC, et al: Renal artery
    Surg 34:209, 1997                                                                                                       10:306, 1996
                                                               repair: consequence of operative failures. Ann Surg
 2. Cherr GS, Hansen KJ, Craven TE, et al: Surgical            227:678, 1998                                             9. Benjamin ME, Dean RH: Techniques in renal
    management of atherosclerotic renovascular disease.
    J Vasc Surg 35:236, 2002                                6. Hansen KJ, Reavis SW, Dean RH: Duplex scanning               artery reconstruction: part II. Ann Vasc Surg
                                                               in renovascular disease. Geriatr Nephrol Urol 6:89,          10:409, 1996
 3. Hansen KJ, Cherr GS, Craven TE, et al: Manage-
    ment of ischemic nephropathy: dialysis-free survival       1996                                                     10. Hansen KJ,Wong JM: Aortorenal bypass for renovas-
    after surgical repair. J Vasc Surg 32:472, 2000         7. Dean RH,Tribble RW, Hansen KJ, et al: Evolution of           cular hypertension in adults. Current Therapy in Vas-
 4. Oskin TC, Hansen KJ, Deitch JS, et al: Chronic renal       renal insufficiency in ischemic nephropathy. Ann             cular Surgery, 4th ed. Ernst CB, Stanley JC, Eds.
    artery occlusion: nephrectomy versus revasculariza-        Surg 213:446, 1991                                           Harcourt Health Sciences, St Louis, 2000, p 735




Recommended Reading

Deitch JS, Hansen KJ, Craven TE, et al: Renal artery re-   study. J Vasc Surg 36:443, 2002                              sonography: main renal artery versus hilar analysis. J Vasc
pair in African-Americans. J Vasc Surg 26:465, 1997        Hansen KJ, Tribble RW, Reavis SW, et al: Renal duplex        Surg 32:462, 2000
Edwards MS, Hansen KJ, Craven TE, et al: Relationships     sonography: evaluation of clinical utility. J Vasc Surg
between renovascular disease, blood pressure, and renal    12:227, 1990
function in the elderly: a population-based study. Am J    Hunt JC, Strong CG: Renovascular hypertension: mecha-
Kidney Dis 41:990, 2003                                    nisms, natural history and treatment. Am J Cardiol                            Acknowledgment
Hansen KJ, Edwards MS, Craven TE, et al: Prevalence of     32:562, 1973
renovascular disease in the elderly: a population-based    Motew SJ, Cherr GS, Craven TE, et al: Renal duplex           Figures 1 through 4    Alice Y. Chen.

More Related Content

What's hot

Aortoiliac aneurysms evaluation
Aortoiliac aneurysms evaluationAortoiliac aneurysms evaluation
Aortoiliac aneurysms evaluationTapish Sahu
 
Mesenteric diseases
Mesenteric diseasesMesenteric diseases
Mesenteric diseasesAmr Mahmoud
 
Abdominal vascular injuries
Abdominal vascular injuriesAbdominal vascular injuries
Abdominal vascular injuriesAbdulsalam Taha
 
Acute smv thrombosis
Acute smv thrombosisAcute smv thrombosis
Acute smv thrombosisMai Parachy
 
Liver trauma: operative management, 2018, by R. Lunevicius
Liver trauma: operative management, 2018, by R. LuneviciusLiver trauma: operative management, 2018, by R. Lunevicius
Liver trauma: operative management, 2018, by R. LuneviciusRaimundas Lunevicius
 
Acs0407 Open Esophageal Procedures
Acs0407 Open Esophageal ProceduresAcs0407 Open Esophageal Procedures
Acs0407 Open Esophageal Proceduresmedbookonline
 
Resection of vena cava during major hepatectomies
Resection of vena cava during major hepatectomiesResection of vena cava during major hepatectomies
Resection of vena cava during major hepatectomiesMarcel Autran Machado
 
SAFE LAPAROSCOPIC CHOLECYSTECTOMY
SAFE LAPAROSCOPIC CHOLECYSTECTOMYSAFE LAPAROSCOPIC CHOLECYSTECTOMY
SAFE LAPAROSCOPIC CHOLECYSTECTOMYDrAnandUjjwalSingh
 
Glissonian approach for laparoscopic liver resections
Glissonian approach for laparoscopic liver resectionsGlissonian approach for laparoscopic liver resections
Glissonian approach for laparoscopic liver resectionsMarcel Autran Machado
 
Acs0522 Procedures For Benign And Malignant Biliary Tract Disease 2005
Acs0522 Procedures For Benign And Malignant Biliary Tract Disease 2005Acs0522 Procedures For Benign And Malignant Biliary Tract Disease 2005
Acs0522 Procedures For Benign And Malignant Biliary Tract Disease 2005medbookonline
 
Robotic-Assisted Pyeloplasty
Robotic-Assisted PyeloplastyRobotic-Assisted Pyeloplasty
Robotic-Assisted PyeloplastyUrovideo.org
 
Spectrum Of Ct Findings In Rupture And Impendinging Rupture Of AAA
Spectrum Of Ct Findings In Rupture And Impendinging Rupture Of AAASpectrum Of Ct Findings In Rupture And Impendinging Rupture Of AAA
Spectrum Of Ct Findings In Rupture And Impendinging Rupture Of AAAXiu Srithammasit
 
Acute mesenteric arterial disease
Acute mesenteric arterial diseaseAcute mesenteric arterial disease
Acute mesenteric arterial diseaseTapish Sahu
 
Robotic pancreatectomy. Pancreatectomia robótica.
Robotic pancreatectomy. Pancreatectomia robótica.Robotic pancreatectomy. Pancreatectomia robótica.
Robotic pancreatectomy. Pancreatectomia robótica.Marcel Autran Machado
 
15 dec 2019 graft infection
15 dec 2019 graft infection15 dec 2019 graft infection
15 dec 2019 graft infectionMai Parachy
 

What's hot (20)

Aortoiliac aneurysms evaluation
Aortoiliac aneurysms evaluationAortoiliac aneurysms evaluation
Aortoiliac aneurysms evaluation
 
Mesenteric diseases
Mesenteric diseasesMesenteric diseases
Mesenteric diseases
 
Abdominal vascular injuries
Abdominal vascular injuriesAbdominal vascular injuries
Abdominal vascular injuries
 
Acute smv thrombosis
Acute smv thrombosisAcute smv thrombosis
Acute smv thrombosis
 
Liver trauma: operative management, 2018, by R. Lunevicius
Liver trauma: operative management, 2018, by R. LuneviciusLiver trauma: operative management, 2018, by R. Lunevicius
Liver trauma: operative management, 2018, by R. Lunevicius
 
Acs0407 Open Esophageal Procedures
Acs0407 Open Esophageal ProceduresAcs0407 Open Esophageal Procedures
Acs0407 Open Esophageal Procedures
 
Liver trauma
Liver traumaLiver trauma
Liver trauma
 
Resection of vena cava during major hepatectomies
Resection of vena cava during major hepatectomiesResection of vena cava during major hepatectomies
Resection of vena cava during major hepatectomies
 
SAFE LAPAROSCOPIC CHOLECYSTECTOMY
SAFE LAPAROSCOPIC CHOLECYSTECTOMYSAFE LAPAROSCOPIC CHOLECYSTECTOMY
SAFE LAPAROSCOPIC CHOLECYSTECTOMY
 
Glissonian approach for laparoscopic liver resections
Glissonian approach for laparoscopic liver resectionsGlissonian approach for laparoscopic liver resections
Glissonian approach for laparoscopic liver resections
 
Liver Trauma: Classification
Liver Trauma: ClassificationLiver Trauma: Classification
Liver Trauma: Classification
 
Acs0522 Procedures For Benign And Malignant Biliary Tract Disease 2005
Acs0522 Procedures For Benign And Malignant Biliary Tract Disease 2005Acs0522 Procedures For Benign And Malignant Biliary Tract Disease 2005
Acs0522 Procedures For Benign And Malignant Biliary Tract Disease 2005
 
Pancreatic injury
Pancreatic injuryPancreatic injury
Pancreatic injury
 
Aaa
AaaAaa
Aaa
 
Robotic-Assisted Pyeloplasty
Robotic-Assisted PyeloplastyRobotic-Assisted Pyeloplasty
Robotic-Assisted Pyeloplasty
 
Spectrum Of Ct Findings In Rupture And Impendinging Rupture Of AAA
Spectrum Of Ct Findings In Rupture And Impendinging Rupture Of AAASpectrum Of Ct Findings In Rupture And Impendinging Rupture Of AAA
Spectrum Of Ct Findings In Rupture And Impendinging Rupture Of AAA
 
Liver trauma
Liver traumaLiver trauma
Liver trauma
 
Acute mesenteric arterial disease
Acute mesenteric arterial diseaseAcute mesenteric arterial disease
Acute mesenteric arterial disease
 
Robotic pancreatectomy. Pancreatectomia robótica.
Robotic pancreatectomy. Pancreatectomia robótica.Robotic pancreatectomy. Pancreatectomia robótica.
Robotic pancreatectomy. Pancreatectomia robótica.
 
15 dec 2019 graft infection
15 dec 2019 graft infection15 dec 2019 graft infection
15 dec 2019 graft infection
 

Similar to Acs0622 Open Procedures For Renovascular Disease

Acs0623 Endovascular Procedures For Renovascular Disease
Acs0623 Endovascular Procedures For Renovascular DiseaseAcs0623 Endovascular Procedures For Renovascular Disease
Acs0623 Endovascular Procedures For Renovascular Diseasemedbookonline
 
kidney Transplant in lupus nephritis
kidney Transplant in lupus nephritiskidney Transplant in lupus nephritis
kidney Transplant in lupus nephritisPediatric Nephrology
 
Interventional therapies for hypertension
Interventional therapies for hypertensionInterventional therapies for hypertension
Interventional therapies for hypertensionFAARRAG
 
Laparoscopic Partial Nephrectomy of Hilar Tumors with Cold Ischemia
Laparoscopic Partial Nephrectomy of Hilar Tumors with Cold IschemiaLaparoscopic Partial Nephrectomy of Hilar Tumors with Cold Ischemia
Laparoscopic Partial Nephrectomy of Hilar Tumors with Cold Ischemiaguestd58ac53
 
Intimal hyperplasia
Intimal hyperplasiaIntimal hyperplasia
Intimal hyperplasiaMai Parachy
 
The role of ercp in diseases of the biliary tract and pancreas
The role of ercp in diseases of the biliary tract and pancreasThe role of ercp in diseases of the biliary tract and pancreas
The role of ercp in diseases of the biliary tract and pancreasThorsang Chayovan
 
Renal Artery Revascularization: where we are
Renal Artery Revascularization:  where we areRenal Artery Revascularization:  where we are
Renal Artery Revascularization: where we arePAIRS WEB
 
Nss and mit final
Nss and mit finalNss and mit final
Nss and mit finalAhmed Eliwa
 
Consensus on GU Trauma
Consensus on GU TraumaConsensus on GU Trauma
Consensus on GU TraumaSun Yai-Cheng
 
Volume overhydration in dialysis patients
Volume overhydration in dialysis patientsVolume overhydration in dialysis patients
Volume overhydration in dialysis patientsdoremi78
 
Surgery in a Patient with Liver Disease
Surgery in a Patient with Liver DiseaseSurgery in a Patient with Liver Disease
Surgery in a Patient with Liver DiseaseJocelyn Red Red
 
Surgery in a Patient with Liver Disease
Surgery in a Patient with Liver DiseaseSurgery in a Patient with Liver Disease
Surgery in a Patient with Liver DiseaseJocelyn Red Red
 
Venus obstructive outflow
Venus obstructive outflowVenus obstructive outflow
Venus obstructive outflowifrahjaved
 
Changes in the Local Therapy of Primary and Secondary Liver Tumors with Curat...
Changes in the Local Therapy of Primary and Secondary Liver Tumors with Curat...Changes in the Local Therapy of Primary and Secondary Liver Tumors with Curat...
Changes in the Local Therapy of Primary and Secondary Liver Tumors with Curat...semualkaira
 
Changes in the Local Therapy of Primary and Secondary Liver Tumors with Curat...
Changes in the Local Therapy of Primary and Secondary Liver Tumors with Curat...Changes in the Local Therapy of Primary and Secondary Liver Tumors with Curat...
Changes in the Local Therapy of Primary and Secondary Liver Tumors with Curat...semualkaira
 
Changes in the Local Therapy of Primary and Secondary Liver Tumors with Curat...
Changes in the Local Therapy of Primary and Secondary Liver Tumors with Curat...Changes in the Local Therapy of Primary and Secondary Liver Tumors with Curat...
Changes in the Local Therapy of Primary and Secondary Liver Tumors with Curat...semualkaira
 
Acs0621 Renovascular Hypertension And Stenosis
Acs0621 Renovascular Hypertension And StenosisAcs0621 Renovascular Hypertension And Stenosis
Acs0621 Renovascular Hypertension And Stenosismedbookonline
 
Seminar on treatment of renal artery stenosis
Seminar on treatment of renal artery stenosisSeminar on treatment of renal artery stenosis
Seminar on treatment of renal artery stenosisAbid_Kuchay
 

Similar to Acs0622 Open Procedures For Renovascular Disease (20)

Acs0623 Endovascular Procedures For Renovascular Disease
Acs0623 Endovascular Procedures For Renovascular DiseaseAcs0623 Endovascular Procedures For Renovascular Disease
Acs0623 Endovascular Procedures For Renovascular Disease
 
RENOVASCULAR HYPERTENSION
RENOVASCULAR HYPERTENSIONRENOVASCULAR HYPERTENSION
RENOVASCULAR HYPERTENSION
 
kidney Transplant in lupus nephritis
kidney Transplant in lupus nephritiskidney Transplant in lupus nephritis
kidney Transplant in lupus nephritis
 
Interventional therapies for hypertension
Interventional therapies for hypertensionInterventional therapies for hypertension
Interventional therapies for hypertension
 
RVD
RVDRVD
RVD
 
Laparoscopic Partial Nephrectomy of Hilar Tumors with Cold Ischemia
Laparoscopic Partial Nephrectomy of Hilar Tumors with Cold IschemiaLaparoscopic Partial Nephrectomy of Hilar Tumors with Cold Ischemia
Laparoscopic Partial Nephrectomy of Hilar Tumors with Cold Ischemia
 
Intimal hyperplasia
Intimal hyperplasiaIntimal hyperplasia
Intimal hyperplasia
 
The role of ercp in diseases of the biliary tract and pancreas
The role of ercp in diseases of the biliary tract and pancreasThe role of ercp in diseases of the biliary tract and pancreas
The role of ercp in diseases of the biliary tract and pancreas
 
Renal Artery Revascularization: where we are
Renal Artery Revascularization:  where we areRenal Artery Revascularization:  where we are
Renal Artery Revascularization: where we are
 
Nss and mit final
Nss and mit finalNss and mit final
Nss and mit final
 
Consensus on GU Trauma
Consensus on GU TraumaConsensus on GU Trauma
Consensus on GU Trauma
 
Volume overhydration in dialysis patients
Volume overhydration in dialysis patientsVolume overhydration in dialysis patients
Volume overhydration in dialysis patients
 
Surgery in a Patient with Liver Disease
Surgery in a Patient with Liver DiseaseSurgery in a Patient with Liver Disease
Surgery in a Patient with Liver Disease
 
Surgery in a Patient with Liver Disease
Surgery in a Patient with Liver DiseaseSurgery in a Patient with Liver Disease
Surgery in a Patient with Liver Disease
 
Venus obstructive outflow
Venus obstructive outflowVenus obstructive outflow
Venus obstructive outflow
 
Changes in the Local Therapy of Primary and Secondary Liver Tumors with Curat...
Changes in the Local Therapy of Primary and Secondary Liver Tumors with Curat...Changes in the Local Therapy of Primary and Secondary Liver Tumors with Curat...
Changes in the Local Therapy of Primary and Secondary Liver Tumors with Curat...
 
Changes in the Local Therapy of Primary and Secondary Liver Tumors with Curat...
Changes in the Local Therapy of Primary and Secondary Liver Tumors with Curat...Changes in the Local Therapy of Primary and Secondary Liver Tumors with Curat...
Changes in the Local Therapy of Primary and Secondary Liver Tumors with Curat...
 
Changes in the Local Therapy of Primary and Secondary Liver Tumors with Curat...
Changes in the Local Therapy of Primary and Secondary Liver Tumors with Curat...Changes in the Local Therapy of Primary and Secondary Liver Tumors with Curat...
Changes in the Local Therapy of Primary and Secondary Liver Tumors with Curat...
 
Acs0621 Renovascular Hypertension And Stenosis
Acs0621 Renovascular Hypertension And StenosisAcs0621 Renovascular Hypertension And Stenosis
Acs0621 Renovascular Hypertension And Stenosis
 
Seminar on treatment of renal artery stenosis
Seminar on treatment of renal artery stenosisSeminar on treatment of renal artery stenosis
Seminar on treatment of renal artery stenosis
 

More from medbookonline

Acs0522 procedures for benign and malignant biliary tract disease-2005
Acs0522 procedures for benign and malignant biliary tract disease-2005Acs0522 procedures for benign and malignant biliary tract disease-2005
Acs0522 procedures for benign and malignant biliary tract disease-2005medbookonline
 
Acs0525 splenectomy-2005
Acs0525 splenectomy-2005Acs0525 splenectomy-2005
Acs0525 splenectomy-2005medbookonline
 
Hemigastrectomy, billroth I stapled
Hemigastrectomy, billroth I stapledHemigastrectomy, billroth I stapled
Hemigastrectomy, billroth I stapledmedbookonline
 
Hemigastrectomy, billroth I method
Hemigastrectomy, billroth I methodHemigastrectomy, billroth I method
Hemigastrectomy, billroth I methodmedbookonline
 
Closure of perforation
Closure of perforationClosure of perforation
Closure of perforationmedbookonline
 
A C S0103 Perioperative Considerations For Anesthesia
A C S0103  Perioperative  Considerations For  AnesthesiaA C S0103  Perioperative  Considerations For  Anesthesia
A C S0103 Perioperative Considerations For Anesthesiamedbookonline
 
A C S0105 Postoperative Management Of The Hospitalized Patient
A C S0105  Postoperative  Management Of The  Hospitalized  PatientA C S0105  Postoperative  Management Of The  Hospitalized  Patient
A C S0105 Postoperative Management Of The Hospitalized Patientmedbookonline
 
A C S0106 Postoperative Pain
A C S0106  Postoperative  PainA C S0106  Postoperative  Pain
A C S0106 Postoperative Painmedbookonline
 
A C S0104 Bleeding And Transfusion
A C S0104  Bleeding And  TransfusionA C S0104  Bleeding And  Transfusion
A C S0104 Bleeding And Transfusionmedbookonline
 
A C S0812 Brain Failure And Brain Death
A C S0812  Brain  Failure And  Brain  DeathA C S0812  Brain  Failure And  Brain  Death
A C S0812 Brain Failure And Brain Deathmedbookonline
 
Acs0906 Organ Procurement
Acs0906 Organ ProcurementAcs0906 Organ Procurement
Acs0906 Organ Procurementmedbookonline
 

More from medbookonline (20)

Acs0522 procedures for benign and malignant biliary tract disease-2005
Acs0522 procedures for benign and malignant biliary tract disease-2005Acs0522 procedures for benign and malignant biliary tract disease-2005
Acs0522 procedures for benign and malignant biliary tract disease-2005
 
Acs0525 splenectomy-2005
Acs0525 splenectomy-2005Acs0525 splenectomy-2005
Acs0525 splenectomy-2005
 
Gastrostomy
GastrostomyGastrostomy
Gastrostomy
 
Hemigastrectomy, billroth I stapled
Hemigastrectomy, billroth I stapledHemigastrectomy, billroth I stapled
Hemigastrectomy, billroth I stapled
 
Hemigastrectomy, billroth I method
Hemigastrectomy, billroth I methodHemigastrectomy, billroth I method
Hemigastrectomy, billroth I method
 
Gastrostomy
GastrostomyGastrostomy
Gastrostomy
 
Gastrojejunostomy
GastrojejunostomyGastrojejunostomy
Gastrojejunostomy
 
Closure of perforation
Closure of perforationClosure of perforation
Closure of perforation
 
A C S0103 Perioperative Considerations For Anesthesia
A C S0103  Perioperative  Considerations For  AnesthesiaA C S0103  Perioperative  Considerations For  Anesthesia
A C S0103 Perioperative Considerations For Anesthesia
 
A C S0105 Postoperative Management Of The Hospitalized Patient
A C S0105  Postoperative  Management Of The  Hospitalized  PatientA C S0105  Postoperative  Management Of The  Hospitalized  Patient
A C S0105 Postoperative Management Of The Hospitalized Patient
 
A C S0106 Postoperative Pain
A C S0106  Postoperative  PainA C S0106  Postoperative  Pain
A C S0106 Postoperative Pain
 
A C S0104 Bleeding And Transfusion
A C S0104  Bleeding And  TransfusionA C S0104  Bleeding And  Transfusion
A C S0104 Bleeding And Transfusion
 
A C S0812 Brain Failure And Brain Death
A C S0812  Brain  Failure And  Brain  DeathA C S0812  Brain  Failure And  Brain  Death
A C S0812 Brain Failure And Brain Death
 
A C S9906
A C S9906A C S9906
A C S9906
 
Acs9903
Acs9903Acs9903
Acs9903
 
Acs9905
Acs9905Acs9905
Acs9905
 
Acs9904
Acs9904Acs9904
Acs9904
 
Acs0906 Organ Procurement
Acs0906 Organ ProcurementAcs0906 Organ Procurement
Acs0906 Organ Procurement
 
Acs9902
Acs9902Acs9902
Acs9902
 
Acs9901
Acs9901Acs9901
Acs9901
 

Acs0622 Open Procedures For Renovascular Disease

  • 1. © 2005 WebMD, Inc. All rights reserved. ACS Surgery: Principles and Practice 6 VASCULAR SYSTEM 22 OPEN PROCEDURES FOR RENOVASCULAR DISEASE — 1 22 OPEN PROCEDURES FOR RENOVASCULAR DISEASE Matthew S. Edwards, M.D., Juan Ayerdi, M.D., and Kimberley J. Hansen, M.D., F.A.C.S. Until comparatively recently, intervention for renovascular disease Disease] is liberally used as an alternative to open renal artery focused entirely on hypertension. However, the introduction of revascularization, but the data currently available suggest that it potent new antihypertensive agents and percutaneous endovascu- should be employed selectively.The best results with PTRA alone lar methods of management has led to substantial changes in atti- have been achieved with nonostial atherosclerotic renal artery tudes to and indications for management of renovascular disease. lesions and medial fibroplasia of the main renal artery. Suboptimal Today, open surgical repair is commonly reserved for (1) patients results have been achieved with hypoplastic (i.e., developmental) who have severe hypertension despite optimal medical therapy, (2) lesions, fibrodysplasia of the intimal and perimedial variety, ostial patients in whom percutaneous transluminal renal artery angio- atherosclerotic renal artery lesions, and renal artery occlusions. plasty (PTRA) fails or who have disease patterns that are not For ostial renal artery atherosclerosis, some surgeons have advo- amenable to PTRA, and (3) patients who have renovascular dis- cated PTRA with primary endoluminal stenting in an effort to ease associated with excretory renal insufficiency (i.e., ischemic improve results; however, the results of PTRA and primary stent- nephropathy).1 ing in this setting have been inferior to those of open operative The experience of our center (Wake Forest University School of repair. Consequently, in the majority of cases of ostial atheroscle- Medicine) in the management of more than 850 patients over a rosis in combination with renal insufficiency, we advise operative 16-year period indicates that atherosclerotic renovascular disease intervention for good-risk patients. frequently exists in combination with diffuse extrarenal athero- These recommendations are not absolute. Decisions regarding sclerosis and renal insufficiency. In one study, bilateral atheroscle- therapy for renovascular disease must be individualized. Factors rotic renal artery lesions were present in two thirds of patients, and contributing to the choice of treatment include the expected mor- complete renal artery occlusion was present in more than one bidity and mortality of operative repair and the presence of pre- third.2 Although practitioners frequently cite selected data to sup- dictors of death and dialysis dependence at follow-up. In this port a particular management scheme in this setting, the question regard, severe left ventricular dysfunction with clinical congestive of what constitutes optimal management of atherosclerotic reno- heart failure, diabetes mellitus, and uncorrectable azotemia have vascular disease responsible for either hypertension or renal insuf- all been shown to be significant and independent predictors of ficiency is still unanswerable.To date, there have been no prospec- reduced dialysis-free survival.2,3 tive, randomized trials that compare the best medical manage- ment with PTRA and with open surgical repair. Operative Planning Preoperative Evaluation SURGICAL STRATEGY Evaluation and diagnosis of renovascular hypertension and reno- Our use of open surgical methods to treat atherosclerotic reno- vascular renal insufficiency (i.e., ischemic nephropathy) are discussed vascular disease is based on several guiding principles [see Table 1]. in more detail elsewhere, as are general issues related to the We consider severe hypertension a prerequisite for open operative question of medical versus surgical therapy. management and do not perform prophylactic renal artery repair INDICATIONS FOR INTERVENTION The recognition of both the progressive nature of the athero- Table 1—Recommended Principles for sclerotic renovascular lesions seen in combination with severe Contemporary Surgical Management of hypertension and the deterioration of renal function seen in select- Renovascular Disease10 ed patients who are managed medically lends support to the idea that renal artery intervention is indicated when either renovascu- Renal artery repair is done on an empirical, but not prophylactic, basis lar hypertension or ischemic nephropathy is present. In our view, Complete renal artery repair is done in one operation when feasible; bilateral ex vivo reconstruction may be staged renal artery intervention is appropriate in patients with severe Direct aortorenal methods of reconstruction are preferred hypertension and, specifically, in all patients who have severe hy- Nephrectomy is reserved for nonreconstructable disease in a pertension in combination with excretory renal insufficiency (i.e., nonfunctioning kidney ischemic nephropathy). Open operative management is preferred Combined aortic reconstruction is limited to clinically significant disease for children and young adults and for patients with bilateral reno- Intraoperative duplex sonography is performed to assess technical vascular disease, especially if renal artery occlusion is present.2 success PTRA [see 6:16 Endovascular Procedures for Renovascular
  • 2. © 2005 WebMD, Inc. All rights reserved. ACS Surgery: Principles and Practice 6 VASCULAR SYSTEM 22 OPEN PROCEDURES FOR RENOVASCULAR DISEASE — 2 a b c Figure 1 Aortorenal bypass.8 Technique for end-to-side (a, b) and end-to-end (c) aortorenal bypass grafting. The length of arteriotomy is at least three times the diameter of the artery to prevent recur- rent anastomotic stenosis. For the anastomosis, 6-0 or 7-0 monofilament polypropylene sutures are used in continuous fashion, under loupe magnification. If the apex sutures are placed too deeply or with excess advancement, stenosis can be created, posing a risk of late graft thrombosis. Operative Technique in patients who are not hypertensive. Although we employ renal vein renin assays to guide management of unilateral lesions in many Various open surgical techniques are used to correct athero- cases, we typically perform empirical renal artery repair without sclerotic renovascular disease; however, no single repair technique functional studies when the hypertension is severe or uncontrolled is optimal for all renovascular lesions. The best approach to renal and when renal artery disease is bilateral or involves a solitary kid- artery reconstruction in any given case depends on patient char- ney. We attempt to correct all hemodynamically significant reno- acteristics, the pattern of renal artery disease, and the presence or vascular disease in a single operation; we perform staged repair only absence of associated aortic lesions that may have to be corrected in cases in which the disease necessitates bilateral ex vivo recon- simultaneously. The open procedures most commonly performed struction. Because the lower limit of renal function retrieval is not to treat renovascular disease are (1) aortorenal bypass, (2) renal known but improved renal function is known to be the strongest artery thromboendarterectomy, and (3) renal artery reimplanta- predictor of dialysis-free survival, we reserve nephrectomy for tion. In general, aortorenal bypass is the most versatile of these patients who have an unreconstructable lesion in a renal artery sup- procedures.Transaortic thromboendarterectomy may be especial- plying a nonfunctioning kidney (i.e., a kidney providing less than ly useful when ostial atherosclerosis ends within 1 cm of the origin 10% glomerular filtration on renography).4 In the majority of open of the renal artery and involves multiple renal arteries. Renal operative repairs, we employ direct aortorenal reconstruction artery reimplantation is often particularly appropriate for the cor- methods; we seldom use indirect (splanchnorenal) methods, rection of renovascular disease in children and adolescents, in that because celiac axis stenosis is present in 40% to 50% of patients concerns regarding graft material are eliminated. and bilateral repair is required in more than 50%.2 Regardless of With all of these reconstruction techniques, multiple small the method of reconstruction employed, we perform intraoperative doses of mannitol are administered intravenously during perirenal renal duplex sonography as a completion study to look for any aortic and renal artery dissection. Mannitol is given both before technical errors in the repair that might lead to restenosis or occlu- and after periods of warm renal ischemia up to a total dose of 1 sion. Failed renal artery repair has been associated with a signifi- g/kg. During cross-clamping of the aorta and the renal artery, the cant and independent risk of eventual dependence on dialysis.5 patient is given heparin, 100 U/kg, to establish systemic anticoag-
  • 3. © 2005 WebMD, Inc. All rights reserved. ACS Surgery: Principles and Practice 6 VASCULAR SYSTEM 22 OPEN PROCEDURES FOR RENOVASCULAR DISEASE — 3 ulation. When a purely autogenous reconstruction is performed, eter of the smallest conduit, and the ends of the conduit should be antibiotics are unnecessary; however, when a prosthetic graft is widely spatulated to guard against late suture line stenosis. The employed, administration of a first-generation cephalosporin is proximal anastomosis is usually made with a continuous 6-0 begun 2 hours before operation and continued for 24 hours. monofilament polypropylene suture, and the distal anastomosis is created with a continuous 7-0 or 8-0 monofilament polypropylene AORTORENAL BYPASS suture. Aortorenal bypass [see Figure 1] may be performed with either THROMBOENDARTERECTOMY an autogenous conduit or a prosthetic graft. If an entirely autoge- nous repair is possible, we prefer to use a reversed segment of the Thromboendarterectomy of the renal arteries and the perirenal greater saphenous vein as the conduit. If the saphenous vein is too aorta may be performed via either a transrenal or a transaortic narrow (i.e., < 4 mm in diameter) or of inadequate quality, a 6 approach. When the renal artery atheroma extends 1 cm or less mm thin-walled polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) graft is used from the ostium and involves both or multiple renal arteries, the instead. In either case, the infrarenal aorta is dissected and transaortic technique [see Figure 2] is especially useful. With both clamped proximally and distally, and a longitudinal elliptical open- endarterectomy techniques, extensive aortic exposure is required. ing is created anterolaterally in the aortic wall (e.g., with two or The aorta proximal to the origin of the superior mesenteric artery three applications of a 5.2 mm aortic punch). If required, a local (SMA) is exposed and controlled. This exposure is facilitated by endarterectomy at the site of the anastomosis may be performed partially dividing the aortic crura and controlling the SMA with a through this opening. Silastic loop. The proximal and distal anastomoses are then created. Currently, the majority of aortorenal endarterectomies are per- Although end-to-side distal renal artery anastomoses were com- formed through a longitudinal aortotomy extending from a point monly performed at one time, current aortorenal bypass tech- 2 to 3 cm below the renal arteries to the base of the SMA. A sleeve niques typically employ end-to-end distal renal artery anasto- of aortic atheroma is created, then divided sharply at the base of moses. For both the proximal and the distal anastomosis, the the SMA proximally and well below the most inferior renal artery length of the arteriotomy should be at least three times the diam- distally. After the aortic endarterectomy is completed, an eversion- a b Left Renal Artery SMA SMA IMA Figure 2 Thromboendarterectomy.8 Exposure for a longitudinal transaortic endarterectomy is obtained via the standard transperitoneal approach. The duodenum is mobilized from the aorta later- ally in the standard fashion; alternatively, for more complete exposure, the ascending colon and the small bowel are mobilized. (a) Dotted line shows the location of the aortotomy. (b) The plaque is transected proximally and distally, the renal arteries are everted, and the atherosclerotic plaque is removed from each renal ostium. The aortotomy is typically closed with a continuous 4-0 or 5-0 polypropylene suture. (IMA—inferior mesenteric artery)
  • 4. © 2005 WebMD, Inc. All rights reserved. ACS Surgery: Principles and Practice 6 VASCULAR SYSTEM 22 OPEN PROCEDURES FOR RENOVASCULAR DISEASE — 4 a b c d Figure 3 Renal artery reimplantation.9 (a) When the renal artery is redundant and the disease involves the orifice of the renal artery, it is usually possible to reimplant the vessel at a lower level. Dotted lines indicate the location of the aortotomy and the point where the renal artery is divided. (b) An elliptical opening is created in the aortic wall, and a local endarterectomy is done as required. (c) A monofilament suture is placed in the aortic wall. (d) The native renal artery is ligated, proximally spatulated, and reimplanted. type endarterectomy is performed for each of the renal arteries. Although this technique has only limited applicability to the The surgical assistant retracts the anterior lip of the aortic wall and treatment of atherosclerotic renovascular disease in adults, it may inverts the renal artery into the aorta, and the operating surgeon be particularly useful for this purpose in children and young ado- retracts the renal artery atheroma while gently pushing the lescents, who often have congenital or developmental lesions that remaining renal artery away with a dissector. In this manner, the involve the renal artery orifice. The main advantage of reimplan- end point of the endarterectomy can easily be visualized to con- tation is that it obviates concerns regarding the durability of the firm that the endarterectomy is complete.The endarterectomy site renal artery conduit. is then irrigated with heparinized saline, and the longitudinal aor- SPLANCHNORENAL BYPASS totomy is closed with a continuous 4-0 or 5-0 monofilament polypropylene suture. Indirect, or splanchnorenal, bypass [see Figure 4] is an uncom- Both transrenal and transaortic thromboendarterectomy are mon procedure at our center. In large part, its relative rarity is a contraindicated if aneurysmal degeneration of the perirenal aorta reflection of the frequent presence of simultaneous disease of the is present or if there is transmural calcification at the site of celiac axis and the frequent need for bilateral renal artery recon- endarterectomy. struction in combination with aortic repair. In addition, we believe that this approach does not yield long-term patency equivalent to RENAL ARTERY REIMPLANTATION that provided by direct aortorenal reconstruction. Consequently, In the course of renal artery exposure, the vessel is dissected these indirect bypass techniques are reserved for a selected sub- from its aortic origin to its primary bifurcation. On occasion, after group of high-risk patients. complete dissection, the vessel is found to have sufficient redun- Hepatorenal bypass is most frequently performed through a dancy to allow tension-free reimplantation into the infrarenal right subcostal incision, splenorenal bypass through a left sub- aorta [see Figure 3]. As in a renal artery bypass [see Aortorenal costal incision. In either procedure, the patient is positioned with Bypass, above], an elliptical section of the aortic wall is resected, a roll beneath the ipsilateral flank, with the operating table flexed and a widely spatulated aortorenal anastomosis is fashioned. and the ipsilateral arm padded and tucked to the side.The incision
  • 5. © 2005 WebMD, Inc. All rights reserved. ACS Surgery: Principles and Practice 6 VASCULAR SYSTEM 22 OPEN PROCEDURES FOR RENOVASCULAR DISEASE — 5 may be extended to the contralateral semilunar line and into the function in 60% of occluded renal arteries that underwent opera- ipsilateral flank as necessary for exposure. In a hepatorenal bypass, tive repair.4 a greater saphenous vein graft is usually employed, originating INTRAOPERATIVE RENAL DUPLEX ULTRASONOGRAPHY from the common hepatic artery and coursing posterior to the portal triad and anterior to the vena cava before the end-to-end The surgeon’s technique plays a dominant role in determining renal artery anastomosis [see Figure 4]. A splenorenal bypass may patency after renal artery reconstruction. To look for technical be created either in a similar fashion (i.e., with a greater saphenous errors at the time of operation, we employ intraoperative renal vein graft) or by anastomosing the transected splenic artery direct- duplex ultrasonography. A 10.0/5.0 mHz compact linear array ly to the left renal artery [see Figure 5]. If the latter approach is probe with Doppler color-flow capability is placed within a sterile taken, the collateral circulation to the spleen is sufficient to main- sheath that has a latex tip containing sterile gel.The operative field tain splenic viability. is flooded with warm saline solution, and B-scan images are obtained from the sites of aortic control and of renal artery repair. NEPHRECTOMY All defects noted on the B-scan images are then examined in both In patients with renovascular renal insufficiency or ischemic longitudinal and transverse projections. Doppler samples are nephropathy, an incremental increase in excretory renal function obtained proximal and distal to the lesions to determine their after operation is the dominant determinant of dialysis-free sur- hemodynamic significance.6 In 249 consecutive renal artery vival. As noted [see Operative Planning, Surgical Strategy, above], repairs with anatomic follow-up, 10% had a focal increase in peak we reserve nephrectomy for patients in whom an unrecon- systolic velocities consistent with residual stenosis.2 Each defect structable renal artery is supplying a nonfunctioning kidney.When was revised immediately, and in each case, a significant defect was the renal artery is occluded, reconstruction is performed if the dis- found. At 12 months after operation, primary patency of the renal tal renal artery is normal at the time of surgical exploration. Past reconstruction was observed in 97% of repairs.This product-limit recommendations regarding the management of renal artery oc- estimate of patency is stable up to 8 years after operation. clusion have emphasized kidney length, distal renal artery recon- stitution, and the appearance of a nephrogram during angiography Outcome Evaluation as criteria for determining whether reconstruction is indicated. Our practice, however, has been to perform renal artery recon- Surgical repair of atherosclerotic renovascular disease can be struction whenever a normal distal renal artery is demonstrated. accomplished with a high rate of success and sustained long-term In a study employing this strategy, we reported retrieval of renal patency. With proper patient selection, the majority of patients a b c Figure 4 Hepatorenal bypass.9 (a) Shown is exposure of the common hepatic artery and the proximal gastroduodenal artery in the hepatoduodenal ligament in preparation for hepatorenal bypass (typically through a right subcostal skin incision). (b,c) The reconstruction is completed by placing a greater saphenous vein interposition graft between the side of the hepatic artery and the distal end of the transected right renal artery.
  • 6. © 2005 WebMD, Inc. All rights reserved. ACS Surgery: Principles and Practice 6 VASCULAR SYSTEM 22 OPEN PROCEDURES FOR RENOVASCULAR DISEASE — 6 Splenic Artery a b Left Renal Artery Figure 5 Splenorenal bypass.9 (a) Shown is exposure of the left renal hilum in preparation for splenorenal bypass (typically obtained through a left subcostal incision). The pancreas has been mobilized along its inferior margin and retracted superiorly. (b) The transected splenic artery is anastomosed to the transected left renal artery in an end-to- end manner. A splenectomy is not routinely performed. demonstrate beneficial blood pressure response and renal function perioperative mortality demonstrated significant and independent response, albeit with perioperative mortality and morbidity that associations with advanced age and clinical congestive heart fail- vary according to the complexity of the procedure. ure. The estimated primary patency rate for all 720 renal artery In a 2002 report, we reviewed our center’s experience with 500 reconstructions was 97% at 8 years’ follow-up. consecutive patients who underwent open surgical repair for treat- ment of atherosclerotic renovascular disease between January HYPERTENSION RESPONSE 1987 and December 1999.2 These patients included 254 women Early blood pressure response was estimated on the basis of and 246 men, with a mean age of 65 ± 9 years. Each patient had ambulatory blood pressure values and medication requirements severe hypertension.The mean preoperative blood pressure for the determined at least 1 month after operative repair. Among surgi- group was 200 ± 35/104 ± 21 mm Hg. Most of the patients had cal survivors, 12% were considered cured, 73% were considered diffuse extrarenal atherosclerosis. A total of 81% had at least one improved, and 15% were considered failed [see Table 3]. manifestation of cardiac disease; 34% had a history of significant cerebrovascular disease; and 78% were considered to have at least RENAL FUNCTION RESPONSE mild renal insufficiency, as evidenced by a serum creatinine con- centration of 1.3 mg/dl or greater. Ischemic nephropathy was seen A significant change in excretory renal function was defined in 244 patients (49%), including 40 patients who were dependent as a change of at least 20% in the estimated glomerular filtration on dialysis before operation. rate (EGFR), measured at least 3 weeks after repair. Of patients Angiographic evaluation demonstrated the presence of bilater- al renal artery disease in 60% of these atherosclerotic patients.The renal artery lesion was considered ostial in 97% of cases, and 16% Table 2 Summary of Operative Management of of renal arteries were completely occluded. A total of 720 renal Atherosclerotic Renovascular Disease2 artery reconstructions were performed [see Table 2]. Aortorenal by- pass was performed in two thirds of the repairs, and two thirds of Total renal reconstructions 720 these bypasses were done with venous grafts.Thromboendarterec- Aortorenal bypass 384 tomy was performed in almost one third of the cases. Renal artery Venous graft 204 reimplantation was performed in 56 instances, splanchnorenal by- PTFE graft 159 pass in only 13 instances. Although there were 124 renal artery oc- Dacron graft 21 clusions, only 56 of these were treated by means of nephrectomy. Reimplantation 56 Twenty-three patients (4.6%) died in the hospital or within 30 Thromboendarterectomy 267 days of renal reconstruction. Mortality varied significantly with Splanchnorenal bypass 13 the magnitude of procedure. Mortality after isolated renal artery Total nephrectomies 56 repair was substantially lower than mortality after combined aor- tic and bilateral renal artery repair (0.8% versus 6.9%). Moreover, Total kidneys operated on 776
  • 7. © 2005 WebMD, Inc. All rights reserved. ACS Surgery: Principles and Practice 6 VASCULAR SYSTEM 22 OPEN PROCEDURES FOR RENOVASCULAR DISEASE — 7 100 Table 3 Results of Operative Treatment of Atherosclerotic Renovascular Disease among 90 472 Surgical Survivors2 80 Result Rate (%) 70 Dialysis-Free Survival (%) Perioperative mortality 4.6 Hypertension response 60 Cured 12 Improved 73 50 Failed 15 Renal function response* 40 Improved 58 Unchanged 35 30 Worsened 7 20 *For 220 patients with preoperative serum creatinine concentrations ≥ 1.8 mg/dl; a significant change is defined as a ≥ 20% change in EGFR. 10 0 with preoperative ischemic nephropathy, 58% showed improve- 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 ments in renal function, including 30 patients removed from dialysis dependence [see Table 3]. In contrast to previous reports Follow-up (months) that suggested the existence of a lower limit of renal dysfunction EGFR EGFR EGFR beyond which recovery could not be observed, the percentage of Improved Unchanged Worsened patients who showed improvement rose with increasing preop- Figure 7 Illustrated are product-limit estimates of time to death erative serum creatinine concentration. Overall, 75% of dialysis- or dialysis, stratified according to postoperative renal function dependent patients were permanently removed from dialysis response for patients with a preoperative EGFR of 25 ml/min/m2. after renal artery repair. In addition, the site of disease and the The interaction between preoperative EGFR and renal function extent of repair were found to influence increases in the EGFR. response for dialysis-free survival was significant and independent.2 100 Although each subgroup of patients who underwent operation demonstrated some improvement in renal function, the greatest 90 incremental increase in the EGFR was observed in those who underwent bilateral renal reconstruction for significant bilateral 80 disease.3,7 RELATIONSHIP OF HYPERTENSION RESPONSE AND RENAL 70 Dialysis-Free Survival (%) FUNCTION RESPONSE TO DIALYSIS-FREE SURVIVAL 60 At a mean follow-up of 56 months, 171 patient deaths had occurred.When outcomes were considered in terms of the blood 50 pressure response to operative intervention, only hypertension cured was found to be significantly and independently associat- 40 ed with survival or dialysis dependence: patients whose hyper- tension was cured experienced improved dialysis-free survival 30 [see Figure 6]. In contrast, all outcome categories for the renal function response influenced both survival and eventual dialysis 20 dependence. Patients with improved renal function experienced a significant increase in dialysis-free survival [see Figure 7].2 For patients whose renal function remained unchanged after oper- 10 ation, however, the risk of eventual dialysis dependence and death was equivalent to that of patients whose renal function 0 worsened after surgery. Whereas renal function that is un- 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 changed after intervention is frequently described as “stabilized” N=472 N=376 N=271 N=184 N=113 N=67 N=30 N=8 or “preserved,” our experience suggests that patients with ische- Follow-up (months) mic nephropathy and atherosclerotic renovascular disease whose renal function is unchanged postoperatively remain at increased Cured Improved Failed risk for eventual dialysis dependence and death.Whether similar Figure 6 Illustrated are product-limit estimates of time to death associations exist for patients treated by means of catheter-based or dialysis, stratified according to blood pressure response to oper- methods is unknown, but the question certainly merits future ation for atherosclerotic renovascular disease.2 study.
  • 8. © 2005 WebMD, Inc. All rights reserved. ACS Surgery: Principles and Practice 6 VASCULAR SYSTEM 22 OPEN PROCEDURES FOR RENOVASCULAR DISEASE — 8 References 1. Dean RH, Benjamin ME, Hansen KJ: Surgical man- tion. J Vasc Surg 29:140, 1999 8. Benjamin ME, Dean RH: Techniques in renal agement of renovascular hypertension. Curr Probl artery reconstruction: part I. Ann Vasc Surg 5. Hansen KJ, Deitch JS, Oskin TC, et al: Renal artery Surg 34:209, 1997 10:306, 1996 repair: consequence of operative failures. Ann Surg 2. Cherr GS, Hansen KJ, Craven TE, et al: Surgical 227:678, 1998 9. Benjamin ME, Dean RH: Techniques in renal management of atherosclerotic renovascular disease. J Vasc Surg 35:236, 2002 6. Hansen KJ, Reavis SW, Dean RH: Duplex scanning artery reconstruction: part II. Ann Vasc Surg in renovascular disease. Geriatr Nephrol Urol 6:89, 10:409, 1996 3. Hansen KJ, Cherr GS, Craven TE, et al: Manage- ment of ischemic nephropathy: dialysis-free survival 1996 10. Hansen KJ,Wong JM: Aortorenal bypass for renovas- after surgical repair. J Vasc Surg 32:472, 2000 7. Dean RH,Tribble RW, Hansen KJ, et al: Evolution of cular hypertension in adults. Current Therapy in Vas- 4. Oskin TC, Hansen KJ, Deitch JS, et al: Chronic renal renal insufficiency in ischemic nephropathy. Ann cular Surgery, 4th ed. Ernst CB, Stanley JC, Eds. artery occlusion: nephrectomy versus revasculariza- Surg 213:446, 1991 Harcourt Health Sciences, St Louis, 2000, p 735 Recommended Reading Deitch JS, Hansen KJ, Craven TE, et al: Renal artery re- study. J Vasc Surg 36:443, 2002 sonography: main renal artery versus hilar analysis. J Vasc pair in African-Americans. J Vasc Surg 26:465, 1997 Hansen KJ, Tribble RW, Reavis SW, et al: Renal duplex Surg 32:462, 2000 Edwards MS, Hansen KJ, Craven TE, et al: Relationships sonography: evaluation of clinical utility. J Vasc Surg between renovascular disease, blood pressure, and renal 12:227, 1990 function in the elderly: a population-based study. Am J Hunt JC, Strong CG: Renovascular hypertension: mecha- Kidney Dis 41:990, 2003 nisms, natural history and treatment. Am J Cardiol Acknowledgment Hansen KJ, Edwards MS, Craven TE, et al: Prevalence of 32:562, 1973 renovascular disease in the elderly: a population-based Motew SJ, Cherr GS, Craven TE, et al: Renal duplex Figures 1 through 4 Alice Y. Chen.