Story highlightsLeaked documents show spy agencies pried into online video games"World of Warcraft" ...

1. Leak: Government spies snooped in 'Warcraft,' other games
Story highlightsLeaked documents show spy agencies pried into online video games"World of
Warcraft" and "Second Life" were among those targetedDocuments were leaked by former
contractor Edward SnowdenTech companies have called for tighter surveillance restraintsSpies with
surveillance agencies in the United States and United Kingdom may have spent time undercover as
orcs and blood elves, infiltrating video games like "World of Warcraft" in a hunt for terrorists "hiding
in plain sight" online.
That's the finding of the most recent round of documents released by National Security Agency
leaker Edward Snowden to British newspaper The Guardian.
Agents from the CIA, FBI and Pentagon and England's Government Communications Headquarters
infiltrated WoW and virtual world "Second Life," as well as collecting information on the Xbox Live
gaming network, according to the documents.
A 2008 NSA memo called online gaming a "target-rich communications network" where terrorists
could communicate "in plain sight."
None of the newly leaked documents, published this time in conjunction with ProPublica and the
New York Times, mentioned specific terrorist activity foiled via the projects.
But apparently so many agents were engaged in playing video games for national security that a
"deconfliction" group was created to make sure government agents weren't accidentally spying on

2. each other.
Unlike traditional console and desktop games in which players compete in a closed environment,
massively multiplayer online games (MMOs) allow players from around the world to team up and
play together, often in real time using in-game communication tools.
"World of Warcraft" is the most popular online role-playing game ever. It peaked at about 12 million
subscribers in 2010 and still has more than 7 million, according to Blizzard.
It's unclear whether the agencies had surveillance capabilities within the massively multi-player
games that normal players would not. A spokesman for Blizzard Entertainment, which owns "World
of Warcraft," told The Guardian it is unaware of any surveillance having taken place.
"If it was, it would have been done without our knowledge or permission," the spokesman said.
On Friday, Microsoft announced it was strengthening encryption across many of its services in an
effort to push back against "government snooping."
And Monday, the company joined Google, Facebook, Yahoo, Apple, Twitter and LinkedIn issuing a
public statement asking the world's governments to rein in online surveillance.
While acknowledging the scope and popularity of online gaming, some security experts were
questioning Monday whether spying on digital playgrounds is either wise or effective.
"I think I've heard it all now," wrote British security analyst Graham Cluely.
"Obviously online games which include chat or IM facilities do provide a method for people to
communicate ... but how practical is it to have a team of spies sniffing around 'World of Warcraft' to
see what they might find?" he wrote.
Opinion: Why we should watch out for the watchmen of government secrecy
"Why aren't they also snooping -- maybe they are! -- on the chess app I have on my smartphone?
Perhaps every time I mess up my Dutch Stonewall defence it's not really an indication that I'm a
lousy chess student, but instead a coded message for my opponent to launch an attack on SCADA
systems in the Netherlands?"
Snowden, 30, has admitted he was the source behind the leak of classified NSA documents, which
revealed the existence of top-secret surveillance programs that collect records of domestic e-mails
and telephone calls in the United States and monitor the cell phone and Internet activity of overseas
residents.
A former contractor with the agency, he is wanted in the United States on espionage charges.
Microsoft fights back against NSA 'snooping'
http://www.cnn.com/2013/12/09/tech/web/nsa-spying-video-games/