SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 4
Download to read offline
Contact - +91-8793460606║ +91-9960666779 ║ +91-9503357577
E-mail – tushar.abhipray@gmail.com ║ kush.abhipray@gmail.com Page 1
अभिप्राय
Office – 56/62, Rajat Path, Mansarovar, Jaipur, Rajasthan – 302020
About Us:
Abhipray means “opinion” in Sanskrit. As the name suggests our aim is to provide bespoke
legal assistance to lawyers and cater the law industry with a whole new concept.
We are a consultancy firm assisting lawyers and advocates in the extensive and pain taking yet
very important aspect of any case i.e. research work be it factual or legal. We are a group of
well qualified professionals aiming to revolutionize the legal industry by providing customized
legal assistance to our clients. Our team has prior experience of working with top firms in India
and Middle East.
A list of things we do, so that you don’t have to –
1. Legal research:
1.1 Issue based research: This service is recommended for those clients who need us to
do research on a particular issue. Here we provide legal and factual research on
issue, as required by the client. This service will support client in affirming his
statement with our extensive research report.
1.2 Case based research: This service is recommended for those clients who wish to take
our research expertise for the whole case. Irrespective of number of issues in that
case, our research team will assist you throughout the case.
1.3 Retainer: This service is recommended for those clients who seek our research
expertise in various numbers of cases at the same time. If client has diversified work,
he may opt for retainer wherein we will provide research on any required issues and
charge on hourly basis.
2. Agreement reviewing:
2.1 We summarize, vet and review the agreements as per the needs of the client. We
offer our own inputs to make the agreement up to the mark.
Contact - +91-8793460606║ +91-9960666779 ║ +91-9503357577
E-mail – tushar.abhipray@gmail.com ║ kush.abhipray@gmail.com Page 2
3. Drafting:
3.1 To help save the precious time of lawyers, we assist in drafting all types of plaints
and notices.
4. Document reviewing:
4.1 We review the documents of our client to ensure that everything is in place. We do
the tedious and time consuming work to ensure that lawyers spend their time in
doing more productive and important activities.
Our Research Methodology:
We use online databases like Manupatra, SCC Online, Lexis Nexis, Westlaw India to provide
latest judgments not only of Indian courts but also from International Courts. We also provide
extensive and in depth study of terms (within the issue) by studying judgments, conventions,
treaties and law dictionaries which enhances the drafting and provides in depth understanding
of the issue in hand. This helps to boost up the chances of winning the case.
At Abhipray we have developed a step by step scientific legal research process
1. Plan and organize our research: Here we try to understand basic information about the
issue in hand like parties, events, and claims.
2. Defining and understanding of the issue: We use an array of texts, journals, seminar
papers, etc. to define and provide basic understanding of the issue in hand.
3. Search of case law or other relevant information: After defining the issue we run a
search for case laws and other information as asked by the client on our various
subscribed legal databases. We also use secondary sources to dig out the required
results.
4. Reading techniques:
4.1 We read not only for the content but for the context of the case: As a Supreme
Court judge once said that “if text is the texture then context is the color of any reading”.
4.2 We look to the context within the case itself, such as lower court decisions and
arguments of counsel. We also look to the context outside the case, obtained from
news sources, literature, government documents and other information sources.
4.3 Reading of the judgments as a rhetorical document: We mull judgments as a
rhetorical document trying to persuade the reader and challenge the belief that the
language of judicial opinions is a neutral medium for the expression of the
disembodied reason. By studying the word choice and use of precedent, our team
tries to analyze the larger rhetorical design.
Contact - +91-8793460606║ +91-9960666779 ║ +91-9503357577
E-mail – tushar.abhipray@gmail.com ║ kush.abhipray@gmail.com Page 3
4.4 Reading of omissions: Here we look for what is left out, disregarded or considered
unimportant in a case and also consider whether the gaps can be filled in without
altering the conclusion.
5. Restate the issues and refine the strategy:
5.1 Restate the issue: Often it is needed to restate the issues after finding some relevant
cases and review secondary sources. At this point if required we flesh out the issues,
by adding sub-issues, and determining which issues are straightforward and which
are problematic. This whole process helps in expanding the horizons of our research
to determine the relevant sub-issues such as applicable remedies, defenses available,
limitation issues and interpretation.
5.2 Refining of research: We refine our researched content and try to find out conflicting
case laws, and rulings which may help our client to be extra prepared for any surprise
from the opposing counsel.
6. Review and assessment: This is the final bay where we review and assess the
researched cases in a threefold manner:
6.1 Weighing of the case: At this stage we read the cases again and assess the weight the
court would give a case based on :
6.1.1 Whether the case is binding or persuasive.
6.1.2 The level and jurisdiction of the court.
6.1.3 The closeness of the facts to client’s case.
6.1.4 The closeness of the legal issues to client’s case.
6.1.5 The soundness of the reasoning in the case.
6.1.6 Whether the court considered pertinent case law in reaching its decision.
6.1.7 The age of the case.
6.2 Analyzing of the case: It is unusual that a particular legal rule shall be stated
consistently throughout a line of cases. So we prepare a table comparing the factors
and reasoning in each relevant case to evaluate the cases we have found and
synthesize the reasoning and rules in them.
Contact - +91-8793460606║ +91-9960666779 ║ +91-9503357577
E-mail – tushar.abhipray@gmail.com ║ kush.abhipray@gmail.com Page 4
6.3 Critical reading of the cases: This part of the research is done by a different set of
researcher where they apply some techniques to critically evaluate the case.
Following points are assessed at this stage:
6.3.1 Noticing what the court said about the rule.
6.3.2 Noticing how the court applied the rule.
6.3.3 Noticing how the court did not apply the rule.
6.3.4 Noticing of the facts court laid emphasized on.
6.3.5 Noticing of the policy considerations the court described.
Our team also considers whether the reasoning employed in the case is:
 Rule – based: Has the court reached an answer by establishing and applying
a rule of law
 Analogical: Whether a case with similar facts should govern.
 Policy-based: Whether the court has reached the answer on the basis that this
result will be best for society at large.
 Narrative: Whether the case tells a story that calls forth this result.
Narrative: As Linda Edward suggests “that case analysis should include consideration of what is the
story being told, the prototypical narrative underlying the text “. So we figure out the role of
narrative in the judicial decision to analyze them:
 By comparison of conflicting decisions on a similar point of law and identify the stories
being told.
 By considering the tension between the narrative reasoning and rule based reasoning:
whether the judge decided the case based on story or outcome that most appealed to the
judge, without regard for the governing law, or did the judge use the narrative or
analogical reasoning to further shape the rule of law.
To summarize we do not simply paraphrase the case we give it another perspective.
`

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Manually remove www search.info from computer
Manually remove www search.info from computerManually remove www search.info from computer
Manually remove www search.info from computerharoNaroum
 
Patti Cole Resume 2015
Patti Cole Resume 2015Patti Cole Resume 2015
Patti Cole Resume 2015Patti Cole
 
Online Personalization That Actually Works
Online Personalization That Actually WorksOnline Personalization That Actually Works
Online Personalization That Actually WorksCara Harshman
 
Chicago Med Portfolio
Chicago Med PortfolioChicago Med Portfolio
Chicago Med PortfolioJuan Bautista
 
RHBC 1/10/16 Announcements
RHBC 1/10/16 AnnouncementsRHBC 1/10/16 Announcements
RHBC 1/10/16 Announcementsrhbc
 
V center operations standard presentation
V center operations standard presentationV center operations standard presentation
V center operations standard presentationsolarisyourep
 
How to uninstall mpc cleaner rogue program
How to uninstall mpc cleaner rogue programHow to uninstall mpc cleaner rogue program
How to uninstall mpc cleaner rogue programharoNaroum
 
Presentation v mworld 2011
Presentation   v mworld 2011Presentation   v mworld 2011
Presentation v mworld 2011solarisyourep
 
04/24/16 Announcements
04/24/16 Announcements04/24/16 Announcements
04/24/16 Announcementsrhbc
 
DAVID MASON DESIGN Salt & Pepper Mills 2014
DAVID MASON DESIGN Salt & Pepper Mills 2014DAVID MASON DESIGN Salt & Pepper Mills 2014
DAVID MASON DESIGN Salt & Pepper Mills 2014Roxxor International
 
How to remove yeabd66.cc
How to remove yeabd66.ccHow to remove yeabd66.cc
How to remove yeabd66.ccharoNaroum
 
Manually remove www.smartnewtab.com redirect virus
Manually remove www.smartnewtab.com redirect virusManually remove www.smartnewtab.com redirect virus
Manually remove www.smartnewtab.com redirect virusharoNaroum
 

Viewers also liked (13)

Manually remove www search.info from computer
Manually remove www search.info from computerManually remove www search.info from computer
Manually remove www search.info from computer
 
Patti Cole Resume 2015
Patti Cole Resume 2015Patti Cole Resume 2015
Patti Cole Resume 2015
 
Online Personalization That Actually Works
Online Personalization That Actually WorksOnline Personalization That Actually Works
Online Personalization That Actually Works
 
Chicago Med Portfolio
Chicago Med PortfolioChicago Med Portfolio
Chicago Med Portfolio
 
RHBC 1/10/16 Announcements
RHBC 1/10/16 AnnouncementsRHBC 1/10/16 Announcements
RHBC 1/10/16 Announcements
 
V center operations standard presentation
V center operations standard presentationV center operations standard presentation
V center operations standard presentation
 
How to uninstall mpc cleaner rogue program
How to uninstall mpc cleaner rogue programHow to uninstall mpc cleaner rogue program
How to uninstall mpc cleaner rogue program
 
La Rochere Bistrot 2015
La Rochere Bistrot 2015La Rochere Bistrot 2015
La Rochere Bistrot 2015
 
Presentation v mworld 2011
Presentation   v mworld 2011Presentation   v mworld 2011
Presentation v mworld 2011
 
04/24/16 Announcements
04/24/16 Announcements04/24/16 Announcements
04/24/16 Announcements
 
DAVID MASON DESIGN Salt & Pepper Mills 2014
DAVID MASON DESIGN Salt & Pepper Mills 2014DAVID MASON DESIGN Salt & Pepper Mills 2014
DAVID MASON DESIGN Salt & Pepper Mills 2014
 
How to remove yeabd66.cc
How to remove yeabd66.ccHow to remove yeabd66.cc
How to remove yeabd66.cc
 
Manually remove www.smartnewtab.com redirect virus
Manually remove www.smartnewtab.com redirect virusManually remove www.smartnewtab.com redirect virus
Manually remove www.smartnewtab.com redirect virus
 

Similar to Abhipray - Profile

Lexhawk headnote writing services 1
Lexhawk headnote writing services 1Lexhawk headnote writing services 1
Lexhawk headnote writing services 1Arulsagai Arulsamy
 
Chapter 8 9_advocacy_abct_week_8
Chapter 8 9_advocacy_abct_week_8Chapter 8 9_advocacy_abct_week_8
Chapter 8 9_advocacy_abct_week_8Nyi Maw
 
ADRB Vol. 1 Issue No. 5
ADRB Vol. 1 Issue No. 5ADRB Vol. 1 Issue No. 5
ADRB Vol. 1 Issue No. 5Kirsten Dow
 
LS311BUSINESS LAWINTRODUCTION AND SOURCES OF BUSINESS.docx
LS311BUSINESS LAWINTRODUCTION AND SOURCES OF BUSINESS.docxLS311BUSINESS LAWINTRODUCTION AND SOURCES OF BUSINESS.docx
LS311BUSINESS LAWINTRODUCTION AND SOURCES OF BUSINESS.docxsmile790243
 
1 How to Brief a Case Prepared for the Legal S.docx
1  How to Brief a Case  Prepared for the Legal S.docx1  How to Brief a Case  Prepared for the Legal S.docx
1 How to Brief a Case Prepared for the Legal S.docxhoney725342
 
Legal Ethics On The Web
Legal Ethics On The WebLegal Ethics On The Web
Legal Ethics On The Weblegalinfo
 
Paralegal's Guide to the Methodology of Effective Legal Research
Paralegal's Guide to the Methodology of Effective Legal ResearchParalegal's Guide to the Methodology of Effective Legal Research
Paralegal's Guide to the Methodology of Effective Legal ResearchMichael Kaiser, JD.
 
Final Assignment for CRJ302 –Criminal Procedure Due 11.docx
Final Assignment for CRJ302 –Criminal Procedure  Due  11.docxFinal Assignment for CRJ302 –Criminal Procedure  Due  11.docx
Final Assignment for CRJ302 –Criminal Procedure Due 11.docxcharlottej5
 
LEGAL WRITING AND RESEARCH FOR LAWYERS.pptx
LEGAL WRITING AND RESEARCH FOR LAWYERS.pptxLEGAL WRITING AND RESEARCH FOR LAWYERS.pptx
LEGAL WRITING AND RESEARCH FOR LAWYERS.pptxs59j8j6fjd
 
Analyzing Legal Costs for Reasonableness - Reasonable Attorneys' Fees
Analyzing Legal Costs for Reasonableness - Reasonable Attorneys' FeesAnalyzing Legal Costs for Reasonableness - Reasonable Attorneys' Fees
Analyzing Legal Costs for Reasonableness - Reasonable Attorneys' FeesJerome (Joe) Studer
 
Case Analysis Content FormatThe case analysis must include the .docx
Case Analysis Content FormatThe case analysis must include the .docxCase Analysis Content FormatThe case analysis must include the .docx
Case Analysis Content FormatThe case analysis must include the .docxtidwellveronique
 
1 Saint Leo University CRMPOL 123 Introduction.docx
1 Saint Leo University  CRMPOL 123 Introduction.docx1 Saint Leo University  CRMPOL 123 Introduction.docx
1 Saint Leo University CRMPOL 123 Introduction.docxjeremylockett77
 
OverviewWrite a 2–page executive briefing of a selected busine.docx
OverviewWrite a 2–page executive briefing of a selected busine.docxOverviewWrite a 2–page executive briefing of a selected busine.docx
OverviewWrite a 2–page executive briefing of a selected busine.docxaman341480
 
The Role of a Managed Document Review Provider in Legal Cases.pptx
The Role of a Managed Document Review Provider in Legal Cases.pptxThe Role of a Managed Document Review Provider in Legal Cases.pptx
The Role of a Managed Document Review Provider in Legal Cases.pptxLDM Global
 
Justice Delayed is Justice Denied: Enabling Legal Artificial Intelligence via...
Justice Delayed is Justice Denied: Enabling Legal Artificial Intelligence via...Justice Delayed is Justice Denied: Enabling Legal Artificial Intelligence via...
Justice Delayed is Justice Denied: Enabling Legal Artificial Intelligence via...IIIT Hyderabad
 
ACEDS-Streamline Litigation March 2015 Webcast
ACEDS-Streamline Litigation March 2015 WebcastACEDS-Streamline Litigation March 2015 Webcast
ACEDS-Streamline Litigation March 2015 WebcastLogikcull.com
 

Similar to Abhipray - Profile (20)

Lexhawk headnote writing services 1
Lexhawk headnote writing services 1Lexhawk headnote writing services 1
Lexhawk headnote writing services 1
 
MoversandLawyers
MoversandLawyersMoversandLawyers
MoversandLawyers
 
How to Do a Legal Research: Definition, Types, Examples, Methodology - Legodesk
How to Do a Legal Research: Definition, Types, Examples, Methodology - LegodeskHow to Do a Legal Research: Definition, Types, Examples, Methodology - Legodesk
How to Do a Legal Research: Definition, Types, Examples, Methodology - Legodesk
 
Chapter 8 9_advocacy_abct_week_8
Chapter 8 9_advocacy_abct_week_8Chapter 8 9_advocacy_abct_week_8
Chapter 8 9_advocacy_abct_week_8
 
ADRB Vol. 1 Issue No. 5
ADRB Vol. 1 Issue No. 5ADRB Vol. 1 Issue No. 5
ADRB Vol. 1 Issue No. 5
 
LS311BUSINESS LAWINTRODUCTION AND SOURCES OF BUSINESS.docx
LS311BUSINESS LAWINTRODUCTION AND SOURCES OF BUSINESS.docxLS311BUSINESS LAWINTRODUCTION AND SOURCES OF BUSINESS.docx
LS311BUSINESS LAWINTRODUCTION AND SOURCES OF BUSINESS.docx
 
1 How to Brief a Case Prepared for the Legal S.docx
1  How to Brief a Case  Prepared for the Legal S.docx1  How to Brief a Case  Prepared for the Legal S.docx
1 How to Brief a Case Prepared for the Legal S.docx
 
Legal Ethics On The Web
Legal Ethics On The WebLegal Ethics On The Web
Legal Ethics On The Web
 
Paralegal's Guide to the Methodology of Effective Legal Research
Paralegal's Guide to the Methodology of Effective Legal ResearchParalegal's Guide to the Methodology of Effective Legal Research
Paralegal's Guide to the Methodology of Effective Legal Research
 
Final Assignment for CRJ302 –Criminal Procedure Due 11.docx
Final Assignment for CRJ302 –Criminal Procedure  Due  11.docxFinal Assignment for CRJ302 –Criminal Procedure  Due  11.docx
Final Assignment for CRJ302 –Criminal Procedure Due 11.docx
 
LEGAL WRITING AND RESEARCH FOR LAWYERS.pptx
LEGAL WRITING AND RESEARCH FOR LAWYERS.pptxLEGAL WRITING AND RESEARCH FOR LAWYERS.pptx
LEGAL WRITING AND RESEARCH FOR LAWYERS.pptx
 
JOINT MEETING OF THE ASQDE AND THE ASFDE INC
JOINT MEETING OF THE ASQDE AND THE ASFDE INCJOINT MEETING OF THE ASQDE AND THE ASFDE INC
JOINT MEETING OF THE ASQDE AND THE ASFDE INC
 
Analyzing Legal Costs for Reasonableness - Reasonable Attorneys' Fees
Analyzing Legal Costs for Reasonableness - Reasonable Attorneys' FeesAnalyzing Legal Costs for Reasonableness - Reasonable Attorneys' Fees
Analyzing Legal Costs for Reasonableness - Reasonable Attorneys' Fees
 
Case Analysis Content FormatThe case analysis must include the .docx
Case Analysis Content FormatThe case analysis must include the .docxCase Analysis Content FormatThe case analysis must include the .docx
Case Analysis Content FormatThe case analysis must include the .docx
 
1 Saint Leo University CRMPOL 123 Introduction.docx
1 Saint Leo University  CRMPOL 123 Introduction.docx1 Saint Leo University  CRMPOL 123 Introduction.docx
1 Saint Leo University CRMPOL 123 Introduction.docx
 
OverviewWrite a 2–page executive briefing of a selected busine.docx
OverviewWrite a 2–page executive briefing of a selected busine.docxOverviewWrite a 2–page executive briefing of a selected busine.docx
OverviewWrite a 2–page executive briefing of a selected busine.docx
 
The Role of a Managed Document Review Provider in Legal Cases.pptx
The Role of a Managed Document Review Provider in Legal Cases.pptxThe Role of a Managed Document Review Provider in Legal Cases.pptx
The Role of a Managed Document Review Provider in Legal Cases.pptx
 
Titans
TitansTitans
Titans
 
Justice Delayed is Justice Denied: Enabling Legal Artificial Intelligence via...
Justice Delayed is Justice Denied: Enabling Legal Artificial Intelligence via...Justice Delayed is Justice Denied: Enabling Legal Artificial Intelligence via...
Justice Delayed is Justice Denied: Enabling Legal Artificial Intelligence via...
 
ACEDS-Streamline Litigation March 2015 Webcast
ACEDS-Streamline Litigation March 2015 WebcastACEDS-Streamline Litigation March 2015 Webcast
ACEDS-Streamline Litigation March 2015 Webcast
 

Abhipray - Profile

  • 1. Contact - +91-8793460606║ +91-9960666779 ║ +91-9503357577 E-mail – tushar.abhipray@gmail.com ║ kush.abhipray@gmail.com Page 1 अभिप्राय Office – 56/62, Rajat Path, Mansarovar, Jaipur, Rajasthan – 302020 About Us: Abhipray means “opinion” in Sanskrit. As the name suggests our aim is to provide bespoke legal assistance to lawyers and cater the law industry with a whole new concept. We are a consultancy firm assisting lawyers and advocates in the extensive and pain taking yet very important aspect of any case i.e. research work be it factual or legal. We are a group of well qualified professionals aiming to revolutionize the legal industry by providing customized legal assistance to our clients. Our team has prior experience of working with top firms in India and Middle East. A list of things we do, so that you don’t have to – 1. Legal research: 1.1 Issue based research: This service is recommended for those clients who need us to do research on a particular issue. Here we provide legal and factual research on issue, as required by the client. This service will support client in affirming his statement with our extensive research report. 1.2 Case based research: This service is recommended for those clients who wish to take our research expertise for the whole case. Irrespective of number of issues in that case, our research team will assist you throughout the case. 1.3 Retainer: This service is recommended for those clients who seek our research expertise in various numbers of cases at the same time. If client has diversified work, he may opt for retainer wherein we will provide research on any required issues and charge on hourly basis. 2. Agreement reviewing: 2.1 We summarize, vet and review the agreements as per the needs of the client. We offer our own inputs to make the agreement up to the mark.
  • 2. Contact - +91-8793460606║ +91-9960666779 ║ +91-9503357577 E-mail – tushar.abhipray@gmail.com ║ kush.abhipray@gmail.com Page 2 3. Drafting: 3.1 To help save the precious time of lawyers, we assist in drafting all types of plaints and notices. 4. Document reviewing: 4.1 We review the documents of our client to ensure that everything is in place. We do the tedious and time consuming work to ensure that lawyers spend their time in doing more productive and important activities. Our Research Methodology: We use online databases like Manupatra, SCC Online, Lexis Nexis, Westlaw India to provide latest judgments not only of Indian courts but also from International Courts. We also provide extensive and in depth study of terms (within the issue) by studying judgments, conventions, treaties and law dictionaries which enhances the drafting and provides in depth understanding of the issue in hand. This helps to boost up the chances of winning the case. At Abhipray we have developed a step by step scientific legal research process 1. Plan and organize our research: Here we try to understand basic information about the issue in hand like parties, events, and claims. 2. Defining and understanding of the issue: We use an array of texts, journals, seminar papers, etc. to define and provide basic understanding of the issue in hand. 3. Search of case law or other relevant information: After defining the issue we run a search for case laws and other information as asked by the client on our various subscribed legal databases. We also use secondary sources to dig out the required results. 4. Reading techniques: 4.1 We read not only for the content but for the context of the case: As a Supreme Court judge once said that “if text is the texture then context is the color of any reading”. 4.2 We look to the context within the case itself, such as lower court decisions and arguments of counsel. We also look to the context outside the case, obtained from news sources, literature, government documents and other information sources. 4.3 Reading of the judgments as a rhetorical document: We mull judgments as a rhetorical document trying to persuade the reader and challenge the belief that the language of judicial opinions is a neutral medium for the expression of the disembodied reason. By studying the word choice and use of precedent, our team tries to analyze the larger rhetorical design.
  • 3. Contact - +91-8793460606║ +91-9960666779 ║ +91-9503357577 E-mail – tushar.abhipray@gmail.com ║ kush.abhipray@gmail.com Page 3 4.4 Reading of omissions: Here we look for what is left out, disregarded or considered unimportant in a case and also consider whether the gaps can be filled in without altering the conclusion. 5. Restate the issues and refine the strategy: 5.1 Restate the issue: Often it is needed to restate the issues after finding some relevant cases and review secondary sources. At this point if required we flesh out the issues, by adding sub-issues, and determining which issues are straightforward and which are problematic. This whole process helps in expanding the horizons of our research to determine the relevant sub-issues such as applicable remedies, defenses available, limitation issues and interpretation. 5.2 Refining of research: We refine our researched content and try to find out conflicting case laws, and rulings which may help our client to be extra prepared for any surprise from the opposing counsel. 6. Review and assessment: This is the final bay where we review and assess the researched cases in a threefold manner: 6.1 Weighing of the case: At this stage we read the cases again and assess the weight the court would give a case based on : 6.1.1 Whether the case is binding or persuasive. 6.1.2 The level and jurisdiction of the court. 6.1.3 The closeness of the facts to client’s case. 6.1.4 The closeness of the legal issues to client’s case. 6.1.5 The soundness of the reasoning in the case. 6.1.6 Whether the court considered pertinent case law in reaching its decision. 6.1.7 The age of the case. 6.2 Analyzing of the case: It is unusual that a particular legal rule shall be stated consistently throughout a line of cases. So we prepare a table comparing the factors and reasoning in each relevant case to evaluate the cases we have found and synthesize the reasoning and rules in them.
  • 4. Contact - +91-8793460606║ +91-9960666779 ║ +91-9503357577 E-mail – tushar.abhipray@gmail.com ║ kush.abhipray@gmail.com Page 4 6.3 Critical reading of the cases: This part of the research is done by a different set of researcher where they apply some techniques to critically evaluate the case. Following points are assessed at this stage: 6.3.1 Noticing what the court said about the rule. 6.3.2 Noticing how the court applied the rule. 6.3.3 Noticing how the court did not apply the rule. 6.3.4 Noticing of the facts court laid emphasized on. 6.3.5 Noticing of the policy considerations the court described. Our team also considers whether the reasoning employed in the case is:  Rule – based: Has the court reached an answer by establishing and applying a rule of law  Analogical: Whether a case with similar facts should govern.  Policy-based: Whether the court has reached the answer on the basis that this result will be best for society at large.  Narrative: Whether the case tells a story that calls forth this result. Narrative: As Linda Edward suggests “that case analysis should include consideration of what is the story being told, the prototypical narrative underlying the text “. So we figure out the role of narrative in the judicial decision to analyze them:  By comparison of conflicting decisions on a similar point of law and identify the stories being told.  By considering the tension between the narrative reasoning and rule based reasoning: whether the judge decided the case based on story or outcome that most appealed to the judge, without regard for the governing law, or did the judge use the narrative or analogical reasoning to further shape the rule of law. To summarize we do not simply paraphrase the case we give it another perspective. `