SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 16
Download to read offline
A Talismanic Poetry:
Martyrdom Iconography and Mahmoud Darwish
Lisa Wolk
ENG5110
Casmier
5 May 2015
Note: Portions of this essay were previously submitted as the Mid-term essay for this same
course.
Wolk 2
“Every beautiful poem is an act of resistance”
–Mahmoud Darwish
It has been conservatively estimated that 3,800 Palestinians were killed between 2000
and 2005 during the second intifada (uprising) (Allen 113). Rather than merely just burying the
deceased and quickly moving on in a spirit of defeat and victimhood, Palestinians have created
an entire culture revolving around the powerful iconography of martyrdom. The lowly victim has
been transformed into the robust mythical martyr, manipulated to espouse nationalist and
collectivist sentiments, uniting the Palestinian people under a banner of shared suffering and
hope for a better future—something of which the weak, despairing victim is incapable. Since the
Palestinian people do not have the same vast array of military equipment as the Israeli Defense
Forces, they have used the one weapon that is readily available: their bodies. Commemoration of
martyrs can be found in many forms, including movies, television, literature, and poetry, but the
two most popular (and public) have consistently been martyr funerals and posters (Allen 107).
Though deep respect is still attached to martyrdom itself, these commemorations have
nonetheless become a commonplace, dulling Palestinians’ reactions, and recently have even been
criticized by some as “boring” (113). Despite their ubiquity however, the martyrs’ posters still
enact the religious folk traditions that have formed the bedrock of Palestinian culture, especially
that of the talisman. The power of the Quranic word displayed on the posters cannot be
underestimated, and the words of poetry, such as in the poems of Mahmoud Darwish, one of the
most-respected Palestinian poets of recent memory, share the same mystical power. Uncovering
the power of the talisman, therefore, reveals a way of reading Darwish’s poetry.
After multiple fruitless attempts to write an elegy for the deceased writer Ghassan
Kanafani, Darwish asked the question, “Can ink achieve the status of blood?” (Abu Hashhash
Wolk 3
403). Borrowing concepts from vernacular theory, specifically Henry Louis Gates’s The
Signifying Monkey, I will show that Darwish’s poetry, as a poetic talisman, can indeed become
the life-giving blood of the martyr, unlike the martyrs’ posters which merely perform the
representation of the martyr’s sacrifice. Though Hussain Hamzah explores Darwish’s use of
martyrdom in his 2014 essay, “Resistance, Martyrdom, and Death in Mahmoud Darwish’s
Poetry,” he does so on a thematic, rather than semiological, level—so this essay will be my
attempt to do just that. While Hussain explores examples of individual and collective death,
glorification of death, and martyrdom in Darwish’s poetry, he does not explore how these themes
engage with Palestinian culture or the ways in which the poetry enacts certain elements of
Palestinian religious practices.
What the Western press calls “suicide operations,” the Palestinian press (and, generally
the Arab press as well) prefers to term “self-sacrifice” or “martyrdom” operations (Whitehead
and Abufarha 395). Though a seemingly subtle difference in semantics, the very act of calling a
suicide operation a self-sacrifice is a galvanizing move designed to increase support for
resistance against Israel, both within the Palestinian community itself and within the global
community at large (399). Far from being considered repulsive, the violence that occurs through
such operations is welcomed as a viable alternative to simply standing by and doing nothing. As
Whitehead and Abufarha suggest in “Suicide, Violence, and Cultural Conceptions of Martyrdom
in Palestine,” “[In Palestine], violence is considered ennobling, redeeming, and necessary to the
continuance of life itself” (396). Of course, in order for them to have any effect on the greater
community, these acts of violence cannot occur in a vacuum. In his 2009 article, “Poetics and the
Performance of Violence in Israel/Palestine,” David McDonald argues that any act of violence
finds it power in its “capacity to communicate meaning,” not merely in its resulting casualties
Wolk 4
(59). It is this “capacity to communicate meaning” which gives the act of stone throwing its
power; though typically not resulting in death, this act does result in fear on behalf of the Israeli
soldiers and a sense of empowerment on behalf of the Palestinians. Acts of violence then,
McDonald asserts, must “draw from a common lexicon or vocabulary of symbolic action” and
“be performed for an audience in order for [them] to have any social meaning” (59). While the
stone is not necessarily an intimidating weapon, the symbolic action of throwing one in the face
of an IDF soldier reminds both parties of the Palestinian’s unwillingness to discontinue their
resistance against the state of Israel. The performance of violence in the case of martyrdom
operations is then commemorated and memorialized so that it becomes a self-seeding and self-
sustaining phenomenon: today’s martyr begets ten more martyrs tomorrow. In summary,
martyrdom represents a form of resistance against the perceived injustices of the Israeli
occupation and is considered one of the highest ideals a Palestinian can aspire to. As Whitehead
and Abufarha write in a “Suicide, Violence, and Cultural Conceptions of Martyrdom in
Palestine,” “Through their performance and wider representation such acts [as suicide bombings]
generate collective conceptions among Palestinians and at the same time continue a violent
dialogue with the Israeli state” (395). They continue, “[A] new discourse of ishtishhadiyeen
(martyrous ones) has been articulated in a way that highlights the intentionality of martyrdom as
an act of heroism” (398). The importance to Palestinians of calling these acts of violence
martyrdom operations versus suicide attacks cannot be underestimated. As McDonald explains:
The salient meaning of suicide bombing is not found in the devastation wrought
(number of casualties, buildings, or buses destroyed), but in the act of sacrifice
itself. The willingness to offer one’s body to the cause carries far more
significance simply because it resonates with the subversive poetics of violence
Wolk 5
and self-sacrifice articulated across various performative domains. […] Martyr
operations, perhaps the most iconographic form of Palestinian violence/resistance
against the occupation […] carries incredible symbolic meaning for many
Palestinians due in large part to its usage of the body itself as the instrument of
attack (80).1
As McDonald suggests above, the martyr’s body itself carries significant symbolical
weight in the Palestinian conception of martyrdom iconography. Borrowing Constantine
Kalokyris definition of icon from “The Essence of Orthodox Iconography,” “iconography seeks
by means of symbols, shapes, and forms largely withdrawn from reality to speak to the soul of
the faithful” (42). As icons, then, the martyr has a “worshipful purpose” (43).We see these
elements in play in the Palestinians’ deep valorization of the martyr. As an icon, the martyr
achieves the status of myth, and, in Barthes’s taxonomy, the physical body of the martyr
becomes that myth. As Susan Raine writes in “Body, Emotion and Violence: Palestinian Suicide
Bombing/Martyrdom,” “The martyr’s body becomes a medium of communication—a symbol,
that paradoxically, must disintegrate in order to impart its message” (2). This physical
disintegration of the martyr’s body during the bombing operation facilitates two processes of
metaphorical regeneration: first, “the blood is ‘water’ that nourishes the fields where streams
would flow and birds would sing.[Secondly,] the human flesh is ‘soil’ where flowers bloom […]
Thus the sacrifice creates a new ontology through metonymic reconstitution of body-as-
landscape” (Whitehead and Abufarha 401-02). Going back to Barthes’s conception of myth, we
see that the martyr’s body has “a double function: it points out and it notifies, it makes us
understand something and it imposes it on us… “(Barthes 83). The physical destruction of the
1
I know on my mid-term you said to indent .5” but the MLA handbook says “one-inch from the left margin,” so this
is what I did.
Wolk 6
body points out to us that it represents the Palestinian conception of the cycle of life and in its
very act of destruction, imposes on us its mythical meaning. The un-martyred body does not
recall the same life-generating properties of that of the martyr. Furthermore, there is, of course,
nothing inherent about the body’s destruction to lead us to make this connection—it is an
arbitrary assignment determined by the Palestinians’ attempts to grapple with constant death. As
Corina Daba-Buzioanu and Christina Cirtita-Buzoianu describe in “Myths Beyond and
Throughout History,” “[Myths] resolve a problem: the conscious return of man towards a role
model which becomes known and understood due to the way in which the social culture relates
to it. Therefore, myths are milestones of thought, answers communities would give to
fundamental themes” (125). Summarizing Barthes’s arguments on myth, Daba-Buzioanu and
Cirtita-Buzoianu write that, for Barthes, “myth is a true instrument of social communication and
of interpreting reality” (126). Therefore, the Palestinians have created this myth of the martyr to
understand and cope with their situation of violence and displacement.
Lining both the exterior and interior walls of shops, cafes, and even in some cases homes,
the martyr’s poster is a constant visual reminder of the unfortunate ubiquity of death in Palestine.
As Abu Hashhash explains in “On the Visual Representation of Martyrdom in Palestine,”
“Martyrs’ posters are loaded with classical, religious, and national references [...] In general
there are three indispensable and consistent elements […]: the photograph of the martyr, the
‘obituary’ text that usually includes a Qur’anic verse, and various symbols” (392). Each political
faction2
has their own set of design elements that are used to identify the martyr with that
particular group, in an attempt to establish its validity and popular support (Allen 117-18). The
2
While I am limiting my discussion to groups within the Palestinian territories (Al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigades, Hamas,
Palestinian Islamic Jihad, etc), the same can be said of resistance groups such as Hizbollah operating within the
borders of Lebanon.
Wolk 7
posters are an important preservation of the martyrdom myth, enabling the Palestinians to “start
representing themselves as courageous heroes rather than victim” (Abu Hashash 393). Lori
Allen, in “The Polyvalent Politics of Martyrdom Commemorations in the Palestinian Intifada,”
explains this process of martyrdom to myth:
“Posters were an important part of the process through which martyrs became
icons. In semiotic terms, the posters would be considered iconic signs, insofar as
they represent their ‘object’ (martyr) by means of resemblance, just as any
photograph does. The posters are semiologically complex, representing both the
person who was killed and the martyr that person has become. [...] Thus the
posters capture what, in religious terms, is the kind of eternal life of the martyr
who is not believed to be dead (in a literal sense). […] Posters also created social
icons, representations of heroism and idealized sacrifice. Adding to the iconic
power of posters is the indexicality of the photographic portrait on them. While
the ultimately unstable meaning and political force of the posters is a product of
the social and political exigencies of the second intifada, it is the photograph’s
casual and physical relationship between signifier and signified that lends it an
extra layer of authority.” (117).
Like the martyr’s body, the martyr’s poster participates in the “hidden semiology” of myth,
imposing martyrdom as an acceptable—nay, an ideal—form of resistance for Palestine.
Like both the martyr’s body and the poster, Darwish’s conception of martyrs and
martyrdom in his poetry is a positive one. As Hussain Hamzah explains in “Resistance,
Martyrdom, and Death in Mahmoud Darwish’s Poetry,” “The word ‘martyr’ (shahīd) in
Darwish’s poetry is associated with manifestations of life and revival” and “martyrdom turns
Wolk 8
into the equal of life and fertility” (171, 172). An example of this “life and revival” through
martyrdom is Darwish’s continued use of the metaphor of a wedding to represent the martyr’s
“marriage” to the land of Palestine. In “Blessing for Something which has Not Come” (1989),
Darwish writes: This is the Palestinian wedding/ The lover does not come to the beloved/ Except
as a martyr or wanderer” (qtd in Hamzah 172). As a marriage typically begets life, the martyr’s
blood begets life for Palestine, as explained earlier. In “Diary of a Palestinian Wound”
(Quatrains for Fadwa Tuqan) (1987), Darwish further elaborates this trope:
This land absorbs the skins of martyrs.
This land promises wheat and stars.
Worship it!
We are its salt and its water.
We are its wound, but a wound that fights… Ah my intractable wound!
My country is not a suitcase
I am not a traveller
I am the lover and the land is the beloved. (qtd in Salti 43).
Like the martyrs’ posters, Darwish’s poetry speaks of both the individual and the
collective (Alshaer 92). Both are steeped in a uniquely Palestinian aesthetic of “liberation and
hope” (96). Where I think Darwish’s poetry surpasses the posters, however, can be found in his
use of somewhat enigmatic language. The posters rely on a common, even over-used, set of
symbols to perpetuate the myth of the martyr. The predictability of these posters dulls their
effects on the viewer. As Allen writes, “Palestinians point to these practices [of martyr
memorialization] as symptoms of superficial patriotism and empty politics said to characterize
the uprising […] and this symbolic, spatial and visual deluge has led so many people to the
Wolk 9
distraction, boredom, and ennui that are elements of zahaq (weariness, a state of being ‘fed up’)”
(110). Contrarily, Darwish’s poetry is unpredictable, and remains novel even after multiple re-
readings. As Mustapha Marrouchi elaborates in “Cry No More for Me, Palestine—Mahmoud
Darwish,” “There is no style that can quite match his poetry’s combination of carefully
subordinated clauses with occasional bursts of monosyllabic simplicity. It is a daunting task
trying to decipher the meanings and double-meanings the poems carry within them. They need to
be read time and again” (22). Darwish’s great talent, Marrouchi writes, “make his readers want
to supply the tragic emotions that he does not directly represent” (21). This gap in Darwish’s
poetry—meaning the reader has to supply his or her own emotions—is in direct contrast to the
posters, which elucidate a specific, calculated response over and over from the viewer, no matter
which specific martyr is depicted. In fact, many of the design elements of the posters are carried
over from one to the next, with only the photograph of the martyr changing.
An important element of the posters we cannot overlook, though, is the inclusion of
verses from the Quran. Both secular and religious parties tend to include at least one verse of the
Quran on their martyrs posters, along with a reiteration of the Quranic promise of Paradise to
those who “die for Allah.” This practice of including Quranic verses stems from the Palestinians’
folk religious practices, and its effect is akin to hanging framed calligraphic Quranic verses in
one’s house. As Tawqfiq Canaan explains in The Decipherment of Arabic Talismans3
, “Qoranic
[sic] verses hung up in houses have to be regarded not only as a decorative feature, but also as a
protective measure” (70, emphasis added). The writing, Canaan argues, has “intrinsic power”
(71). These physical representations of the Quranic verses act as talismans for the viewer—they
3
Dr. Tawfiq Canaan began collecting and examining talismans and amulets that he noticed his patients wearing in
the beginning of the twentieth century. He collected more than 1400 items from countries such as Egypt, Syria,
Lebanon, Jordan, Saudia Arabic, Iraq, and Yemen. For more information about his collection, see al-Ju-‘beh, Baha’,
“Magic and Talismans: The Tawfiq Canaan Collection of Palestinian Amulets.” Jerusalem Quarterly. 22.23: (2005):
103-108. For Canaan’s analysis of the items, see his The Decipherment of Arabic Talismans.
Wolk 10
are, as Canaan explains, “prayers” for people “seeking protection” (73). An informal survey of
several martyrs’ posters reveals many of the same Quranic verses described by Canaan in his
study of Arabic talismans. Where does this modern talismanic practice come from? As M.C.
Hughes argues in “The Evolution of Islamism in the Palestinian Territories,” modern Palestinian
culture is built on the past. Hughes writes, “The roots of modern Palestinian Islamist movements
such as Hamas are deeply set in history, reaching back farther than the establishment of Israel as
a state and the resulting expulsion of Palestinians into the outlying territories” (15). Hughes gives
a detailed history of modern Palestine, beginning with the 1900s when Palestine was subjected to
British rule under the Mandate of from the League of Nations. As Hughes describes, “Life in
mandatory Palestine remained rooted in patriarchal tradition, family and clan loyalty, and a
talismanic approach to Islam” (24). By talismanic approach, he means that “practitioners took to
praying and fasting as supernatural spiritual duties that brought emotional comfort and social
acceptance” (25). Therefore, including the Quranic verses on martyrs’ posters today, Palestinians
are reminded of the magical power of those verses to comfort the living and assure them the
deceased has entered Paradise.
We can see how powerful the spoken Quranic verse can be as well in Nasra Hassan’s
article, “An Arsenal of Believers,” from The New Yorker. In Hassan’s re-telling of a would-be
martyr who failed at first to carry out his mission, we see how reciting the Quran works in the
same way as a visual talisman:
“All he [the young Palestinian, referred to only as ‘M.’] had to do was unzip his
bag of explosives and press the detonator. ‘But at the moment he was to press the
button he forgot Paradise,’ one of his former cellmates recalled. ‘He felt a split
second of fear, a slight hesitation. To bolster himself, he recited from the Koran.
Wolk 11
Refreshed and strengthened, he again began to think of Paradise. When he felt
ready, he tried again.’” (Hassan n.p.).
Though his mission was not ultimately completed due to technical difficulties, the young
Palestinian was clearly “re-charged” to continue his work by the mere recitation of Quranic
verses. He attributes his ability to press the button of the detonator to the powerful and
stimulating act of reciting the Quran—clearly, the words had functioned in a protective way for
him, and, as such, is a talismanic belief. Borrowing again from Hughes’s description above, we
can transfer Canaan’s theory of talismanic power from a physical object (the talisman) to a
bodily movement (prayer and fasting). We can also connect this to the performative utterance, a
la J.L. Austen. In Austen’s terminology, the performative “does something” (qtd. in Crary 61).
Therefore, the martyr is not merely saying something with his words—the statements are
actually performing a function. In this case, they are performing the action of being a talisman,
of providing supernatural assurance to the would-be martyr.
The point of analyzing these Palestinian cultural practices—the valorization of the
martyr, the commemoration of the martyr, the recitation of Quranic verses—is to provide a way
of reading Darwish’s poetry, in the same vein that Henry Louis Gates, Jr., in The Signifying
Monkey uses elements of African culture to read black texts in the “New World.” As Gates
argues, black slaves relied on oral literature to preserve African traditions and practices while in
the New World (5). In his discussion of the trickster and “Signifying Monkey” of slave culture,
Gates stresses the importance of examining these items to reveal elements of black aesthetic and
literary culture today. As Gates writes, “We must remember that the Signifying Monkey tales are
the repositories of the black vernacular tradition’s rhetorical principles, coded dictionaries of
black tropes” (63). This same type of coded language forms the structure of Darwish’s poems,
Wolk 12
recreating the talismanic practices of Palestinian folk culture. As Tawfiq Yousef writes in
“Mahmoud Dariwsh and the Quest for Identity,” [Darwish] viewed history as giving the
individual a sense of pride and belonging in addition to providing him with a sense of self-
definition […] Sometimes Darwish resorted to the historical past as an attempt to attach the
Palestinians to their heritage in order to overcome their feelings of isolation, aloneness, and
uprootedness” (679). In addition to incorporating historical elements in his poetry, Darwish
consistently used his poems to explore solutions to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. In a 1996
interview, Darwish states “I built my homeland, I even established a state, in my language”
(Yeshurun 5). Darwish’s interviews reflect the power his poems have. Darwish’s words, then,
become the magical talisman that instills feelings of protection and calm…they become the life-
generating blood of the martyr, the “‘water’ that nourishes the fields where streams would flow
and birds would sing,” and cultivates the minds of the Palestinians. To answer Darwish’s
question posed at the beginning of this essay, his poems most surely achieve the status of blood.
Wolk 13
Works Cited
Abu Hashhash, Mahmoud. “On the Visual Representation of Martyrdom in Palestine.” Third
Text. 20.3/4 (2006): 391-403. Scopus. Web. 2 March 2015.
Allen, Lori A. “The Polyvalent Politics of Martyrdom Commemorations in the Palestinian
Intifada. History and Memory. 18.2 (2006): 107-38. JSTOR. Web. 3 March 2015.
Alshaer, Atef “Identity in Mahmoud Darwish’s Poem ‘The Dice Player.’” Middle East Journal
of Culture and Communications. 4 (2011): 90-110. Communication and Mass Media
Complete. Web. 3 March 2015.
Barthes, Roland. “Excerpt from Mythologies.” Literary Theory: An Anthology. Ed. Julie Rivkin
and Michael Ryan. Massachusetts: Blackwell, 2004. 81-96. Print.
Canaan, Tewfik. The Decipherment of Arabic Talismans. Syrian Orphanage Press (1939). Web.
25 March 2015.
Crary, Alice. "The Happy Truth: J.L. Austin's How To Do Things With Words." Inquiry. 45.1
(2002): 59. Business Source Premier. Web. 14 Apr. 2015.
Daba-Bouzianu, Corina and Christina Cirtita-Bouzioanu. “Myths Beyond and Throughout
History: A Study on Traditional and Modern Myths.” The Scientific Journal of
Humanistic Studies. 3.5 (2011): 125-128. Academic Search Alumni Edition. Web. 14
Apr. 2015.
Gates, Henry Louis Jr. The Signifying Monkey: A Theory of African-American Literary
Criticism. Oxford: Oxford UP, 1988. Print.
Hamzah, Hussain. “Resistance, Martyrdom, and Death in Mahmoud Darwish’s Poetry.” Holy
Land Studies. 13.2 (2014): 159-186. Publisher Provided Full Text Searching File. Web. 5
March 2015.
Hassan, Nasra. “An Arsenal of Believers.” The New Yorker Magazine. 19 Nov. 2001. Web. 21
Wolk 14
April 2015.
Hughes, Michael. “The Evolution of Islamism in the Palestinian Territories: Historical and
Ethnographic Analysis. AHS Capstone Projects. Paper 24 (2010). Google Scholar. Web.
21 April 2015.
Kalokyris, Constantine. “The Essence of Orthodox Iconography.” Greek Orthodox Theological
Review. 14.1 (1969): 42-64. ATLA Religion Database. Web. 23 March 2015.
Marrouchi, Mustapha. “Cry No More for Me, Palestine—Mahmoud Darwish.” College
Literature. 38.4 (2011): 1-43. JSTOR. Web. 3 March 2015.
McDonald, David. “Poetics and the Performance of Violence in Israel/Palestine.”
Ethnomusicology. 53.1 (2009): 85-85. JSTOR. Web. 3 March 2015.
Raine, Susan. “Body, Emotion, and Violence: Palestinian Suicide Bombing/Martyrdom (1993-
2005). Marburg Journal of Religion. 17.2 (2013): 1-21. Google Scholar. Web. 5 March
2015.
Salti, Rasha. “From Resistance and Bearing Witness to the Power of the Fantastical: Icons and
Symbols in Palestinian Poetry and Cinema.” Third Text. 24.1 (2010): 39-52. Art Full
Text. Web. 5 March 2015.
Yeshurun, Helit. “‘Exile is So Strong Within Me, I May Bring it to the Land’: A Landmark 1996
Interview with Mahmoud Darwish.” Journal of Palestinian Studies. 42.1 (2012): 46-63.
Web. 14 April 2015.
Yousef, Tawfiq. “Mahmoud Darwish and the Quest for Identity.” Dirasat, Human and Social
Sciences. 38.2 (2011): 674-88. Google Scholar. Web. 11 April 2015.
Whitehead, Neil L. and Nasser Abufarha. Suicide, Violence, and Cultural Conceptions of
Wolk 15
Martyrdom in Palestine.” Social Research: An International Quarterly. 75.2 (2008): 395-
416. Project Muse. Web. 5 March 2015.
Works Consulted
Al-Ju’Beh, Baha’. “Magic and Talismans: The Tawfiq Canaan Collection of Palestinian
Amulets.” Jerusalem Quarterly. 22.23 (2005): 103-108. Web. 25 March 2015.
Al-Udhari, Abdullah, Trans. Victims of a Map: Mahmud Darwish, Samih al-Qasim, Adonis.
London: Al Saqi Books, 1984. Print.
Borrowman, Glenn. “Popular Palestinian Practices around Holy Places and Those Who Oppose
Them: A Historical Introduction.” Religion Compass. 7.3 (2013): 69-78. Google Scholar.
Web. 11 April 2015.
Darwish, Mahmoud. If I Were Another. Trans. Fady Joudah. New York: Farrar, Straus and
Giroux, 2009. Print.
Gana, Nouri. “War, Poetry, Mourning: Darwish, Adonis, Iraq.” Poetic Culture. 22.1 (2010): 33-
65. Google Scholar. Web. 23 March 2015.
Ghanim, Honaida. “Poetics of Disaster: Nationalism, Gender, and Social Change Among
Palestinian Poets in Israel After Nakba.” International Journal of Politics, Culture, and
Society. 22.1 (2009): 23-39. JSTOR. Web. 21 April 2015.
Glock, Albert. “Archaeology as Cultural Survival: The Future of the Palestinian Past.” Journal of
Palestinian Studies. 23.3 (1994): 70-84. JSTOR. Web. 12 April 2015.
Jassim, Muhsin al-Musawi. “Engaging Tradition in Modern Arab Poetics.” Journal of Arabic
Literature. 33.2 (2002): 172-210. JSTOR. Web. 21 April 2015.
Joseph, Roger. “Toward a Semiotics of Middle Eastern Cultures.” International Journal of
Middle East Studies. 12.3 (1980): 319-29. JSTOR. Web. 3 March 2015.
Wolk 16
Munro, Andrew. "Reading Austin Rhetorically." Philosophy and Rhetoric. 46.1 (2013): 22-43.
MLA International Bibliography. Web. 14 Apr. 2015.
Oxman, Elena. "Sensing the Image: Roland Barthes and the Affect of the Visual." Substance: A
Review of Theory & Literary Criticism. 39.2 (2010): 71-90. Humanities International
Complete. Web. 14 Apr. 2015.
Schick, Irvin Cemil. “The Iconicity of Islamic Calligraphy in Turkey.” RES: Anthropology and
Aesthetics. 53.54 (2008): 211-24. JSTOR. Web. 23 March 2015.
Sheiladeh, Raja. “Mahmoud Darwish” (Interview). Bomb. Fall 2002. Google Scholar. Web. 25
April 2015.
Sylvain, Patrick. “Darwish’s Essentialist Poetics in a State of Siege.” Human Architecture:
Journal of the Sociology of Self-Knowledge. 7 (2009): 137-150. Print.

More Related Content

What's hot

Thesis - A promised land | A relentless war
Thesis - A promised land | A relentless warThesis - A promised land | A relentless war
Thesis - A promised land | A relentless warSaskia Lubnow
 
He loved big_brother_winstons_movement
He loved big_brother_winstons_movementHe loved big_brother_winstons_movement
He loved big_brother_winstons_movementGoswami Mahirpari
 
D R E A M & V I S O N D R
D R E A M &  V I S O N  D RD R E A M &  V I S O N  D R
D R E A M & V I S O N D RBadar Daimi
 
bookreviewanalysis
bookreviewanalysisbookreviewanalysis
bookreviewanalysisAlex Rinkus
 

What's hot (6)

ttg sp 13
ttg sp 13ttg sp 13
ttg sp 13
 
Thesis - A promised land | A relentless war
Thesis - A promised land | A relentless warThesis - A promised land | A relentless war
Thesis - A promised land | A relentless war
 
He loved big_brother_winstons_movement
He loved big_brother_winstons_movementHe loved big_brother_winstons_movement
He loved big_brother_winstons_movement
 
essay criminal texts 2016
essay criminal texts 2016essay criminal texts 2016
essay criminal texts 2016
 
D R E A M & V I S O N D R
D R E A M &  V I S O N  D RD R E A M &  V I S O N  D R
D R E A M & V I S O N D R
 
bookreviewanalysis
bookreviewanalysisbookreviewanalysis
bookreviewanalysis
 

Viewers also liked

Practica iiii
Practica iiiiPractica iiii
Practica iiiipig1703
 
La vada de acaba cuando dejas de soñar
La vada de acaba cuando dejas de soñarLa vada de acaba cuando dejas de soñar
La vada de acaba cuando dejas de soñarluisnoctusgarcia
 
Pinehurst real estate
Pinehurst real estatePinehurst real estate
Pinehurst real estatepinehurstreal
 
Web Personalization - A Must for Your 2017 Marketing Plans
Web Personalization - A Must for Your 2017 Marketing PlansWeb Personalization - A Must for Your 2017 Marketing Plans
Web Personalization - A Must for Your 2017 Marketing PlansMarketo
 

Viewers also liked (7)

Practica iiii
Practica iiiiPractica iiii
Practica iiii
 
La vada de acaba cuando dejas de soñar
La vada de acaba cuando dejas de soñarLa vada de acaba cuando dejas de soñar
La vada de acaba cuando dejas de soñar
 
Alp mb-rs 4x4
Alp mb-rs 4x4Alp mb-rs 4x4
Alp mb-rs 4x4
 
Pinehurst real estate
Pinehurst real estatePinehurst real estate
Pinehurst real estate
 
Treatmentt
TreatmenttTreatmentt
Treatmentt
 
Tik 8 uts 2
Tik 8 uts 2Tik 8 uts 2
Tik 8 uts 2
 
Web Personalization - A Must for Your 2017 Marketing Plans
Web Personalization - A Must for Your 2017 Marketing PlansWeb Personalization - A Must for Your 2017 Marketing Plans
Web Personalization - A Must for Your 2017 Marketing Plans
 

Similar to A Talismanic Poetry: Martyrdom Iconography in Mahmoud Darwish

Race, Violence, and Revolution
Race, Violence, and RevolutionRace, Violence, and Revolution
Race, Violence, and RevolutionJarrad Felgenhauer
 
Abjection In Dambudzo Marechera S The House Of Hunger
Abjection In Dambudzo Marechera S The House Of HungerAbjection In Dambudzo Marechera S The House Of Hunger
Abjection In Dambudzo Marechera S The House Of HungerHeather Strinden
 
Howard f. stein the holocaust, and the myth of the past as history - journa...
Howard f. stein   the holocaust, and the myth of the past as history - journa...Howard f. stein   the holocaust, and the myth of the past as history - journa...
Howard f. stein the holocaust, and the myth of the past as history - journa...RareBooksnRecords
 
Gender Studies-paper
Gender Studies-paperGender Studies-paper
Gender Studies-paperSaide Tawk
 
Partition-Literature-I.pptx
Partition-Literature-I.pptxPartition-Literature-I.pptx
Partition-Literature-I.pptxPallabRoy40
 
Postcolonial study research
Postcolonial study researchPostcolonial study research
Postcolonial study researchAbir Aboutaha
 
Archetypes And Meta-Narratives In Heart Of Darkness And Their Contemporary In...
Archetypes And Meta-Narratives In Heart Of Darkness And Their Contemporary In...Archetypes And Meta-Narratives In Heart Of Darkness And Their Contemporary In...
Archetypes And Meta-Narratives In Heart Of Darkness And Their Contemporary In...Audrey Britton
 
The National Power of the Wizard
The National Power of the WizardThe National Power of the Wizard
The National Power of the WizardBrittney Cannon
 
Humanisim in dorris lessing’s novels an overview
Humanisim in dorris lessing’s novels an overviewHumanisim in dorris lessing’s novels an overview
Humanisim in dorris lessing’s novels an overviewAhmed Badran
 
Captain America's Empire
Captain America's EmpireCaptain America's Empire
Captain America's EmpireSeth Blazer
 
The Depiction of the Metaphysical in German and African Fiction: a study of s...
The Depiction of the Metaphysical in German and African Fiction: a study of s...The Depiction of the Metaphysical in German and African Fiction: a study of s...
The Depiction of the Metaphysical in German and African Fiction: a study of s...iosrjce
 
COSMOPOLITANISM AND KOSMOPOLITIZM IN THE POLITICAL IMAGINARY OF SOVIET CITIZ...
 COSMOPOLITANISM AND KOSMOPOLITIZM IN THE POLITICAL IMAGINARY OF SOVIET CITIZ... COSMOPOLITANISM AND KOSMOPOLITIZM IN THE POLITICAL IMAGINARY OF SOVIET CITIZ...
COSMOPOLITANISM AND KOSMOPOLITIZM IN THE POLITICAL IMAGINARY OF SOVIET CITIZ...Madiha Debbabi
 
A Feminist Critical Discourse Analysis Of Qaisra Shahraz S The Holy Woman In ...
A Feminist Critical Discourse Analysis Of Qaisra Shahraz S The Holy Woman In ...A Feminist Critical Discourse Analysis Of Qaisra Shahraz S The Holy Woman In ...
A Feminist Critical Discourse Analysis Of Qaisra Shahraz S The Holy Woman In ...Joe Osborn
 
An End To Cosmic Loneliness Alice Walker S Essays As Abolitionist Enchantment
An End To Cosmic Loneliness  Alice Walker S Essays As Abolitionist EnchantmentAn End To Cosmic Loneliness  Alice Walker S Essays As Abolitionist Enchantment
An End To Cosmic Loneliness Alice Walker S Essays As Abolitionist EnchantmentSandra Long
 

Similar to A Talismanic Poetry: Martyrdom Iconography in Mahmoud Darwish (17)

Race, Violence, and Revolution
Race, Violence, and RevolutionRace, Violence, and Revolution
Race, Violence, and Revolution
 
Abjection In Dambudzo Marechera S The House Of Hunger
Abjection In Dambudzo Marechera S The House Of HungerAbjection In Dambudzo Marechera S The House Of Hunger
Abjection In Dambudzo Marechera S The House Of Hunger
 
Howard f. stein the holocaust, and the myth of the past as history - journa...
Howard f. stein   the holocaust, and the myth of the past as history - journa...Howard f. stein   the holocaust, and the myth of the past as history - journa...
Howard f. stein the holocaust, and the myth of the past as history - journa...
 
War Trauma
War TraumaWar Trauma
War Trauma
 
Gender Studies-paper
Gender Studies-paperGender Studies-paper
Gender Studies-paper
 
Partition-Literature-I.pptx
Partition-Literature-I.pptxPartition-Literature-I.pptx
Partition-Literature-I.pptx
 
Postcolonial study research
Postcolonial study researchPostcolonial study research
Postcolonial study research
 
Archetypes And Meta-Narratives In Heart Of Darkness And Their Contemporary In...
Archetypes And Meta-Narratives In Heart Of Darkness And Their Contemporary In...Archetypes And Meta-Narratives In Heart Of Darkness And Their Contemporary In...
Archetypes And Meta-Narratives In Heart Of Darkness And Their Contemporary In...
 
The National Power of the Wizard
The National Power of the WizardThe National Power of the Wizard
The National Power of the Wizard
 
Humanisim in dorris lessing’s novels an overview
Humanisim in dorris lessing’s novels an overviewHumanisim in dorris lessing’s novels an overview
Humanisim in dorris lessing’s novels an overview
 
Short Essay Myself
Short Essay MyselfShort Essay Myself
Short Essay Myself
 
Captain America's Empire
Captain America's EmpireCaptain America's Empire
Captain America's Empire
 
The Depiction of the Metaphysical in German and African Fiction: a study of s...
The Depiction of the Metaphysical in German and African Fiction: a study of s...The Depiction of the Metaphysical in German and African Fiction: a study of s...
The Depiction of the Metaphysical in German and African Fiction: a study of s...
 
COSMOPOLITANISM AND KOSMOPOLITIZM IN THE POLITICAL IMAGINARY OF SOVIET CITIZ...
 COSMOPOLITANISM AND KOSMOPOLITIZM IN THE POLITICAL IMAGINARY OF SOVIET CITIZ... COSMOPOLITANISM AND KOSMOPOLITIZM IN THE POLITICAL IMAGINARY OF SOVIET CITIZ...
COSMOPOLITANISM AND KOSMOPOLITIZM IN THE POLITICAL IMAGINARY OF SOVIET CITIZ...
 
Constructing India
Constructing IndiaConstructing India
Constructing India
 
A Feminist Critical Discourse Analysis Of Qaisra Shahraz S The Holy Woman In ...
A Feminist Critical Discourse Analysis Of Qaisra Shahraz S The Holy Woman In ...A Feminist Critical Discourse Analysis Of Qaisra Shahraz S The Holy Woman In ...
A Feminist Critical Discourse Analysis Of Qaisra Shahraz S The Holy Woman In ...
 
An End To Cosmic Loneliness Alice Walker S Essays As Abolitionist Enchantment
An End To Cosmic Loneliness  Alice Walker S Essays As Abolitionist EnchantmentAn End To Cosmic Loneliness  Alice Walker S Essays As Abolitionist Enchantment
An End To Cosmic Loneliness Alice Walker S Essays As Abolitionist Enchantment
 

A Talismanic Poetry: Martyrdom Iconography in Mahmoud Darwish

  • 1. A Talismanic Poetry: Martyrdom Iconography and Mahmoud Darwish Lisa Wolk ENG5110 Casmier 5 May 2015 Note: Portions of this essay were previously submitted as the Mid-term essay for this same course.
  • 2. Wolk 2 “Every beautiful poem is an act of resistance” –Mahmoud Darwish It has been conservatively estimated that 3,800 Palestinians were killed between 2000 and 2005 during the second intifada (uprising) (Allen 113). Rather than merely just burying the deceased and quickly moving on in a spirit of defeat and victimhood, Palestinians have created an entire culture revolving around the powerful iconography of martyrdom. The lowly victim has been transformed into the robust mythical martyr, manipulated to espouse nationalist and collectivist sentiments, uniting the Palestinian people under a banner of shared suffering and hope for a better future—something of which the weak, despairing victim is incapable. Since the Palestinian people do not have the same vast array of military equipment as the Israeli Defense Forces, they have used the one weapon that is readily available: their bodies. Commemoration of martyrs can be found in many forms, including movies, television, literature, and poetry, but the two most popular (and public) have consistently been martyr funerals and posters (Allen 107). Though deep respect is still attached to martyrdom itself, these commemorations have nonetheless become a commonplace, dulling Palestinians’ reactions, and recently have even been criticized by some as “boring” (113). Despite their ubiquity however, the martyrs’ posters still enact the religious folk traditions that have formed the bedrock of Palestinian culture, especially that of the talisman. The power of the Quranic word displayed on the posters cannot be underestimated, and the words of poetry, such as in the poems of Mahmoud Darwish, one of the most-respected Palestinian poets of recent memory, share the same mystical power. Uncovering the power of the talisman, therefore, reveals a way of reading Darwish’s poetry. After multiple fruitless attempts to write an elegy for the deceased writer Ghassan Kanafani, Darwish asked the question, “Can ink achieve the status of blood?” (Abu Hashhash
  • 3. Wolk 3 403). Borrowing concepts from vernacular theory, specifically Henry Louis Gates’s The Signifying Monkey, I will show that Darwish’s poetry, as a poetic talisman, can indeed become the life-giving blood of the martyr, unlike the martyrs’ posters which merely perform the representation of the martyr’s sacrifice. Though Hussain Hamzah explores Darwish’s use of martyrdom in his 2014 essay, “Resistance, Martyrdom, and Death in Mahmoud Darwish’s Poetry,” he does so on a thematic, rather than semiological, level—so this essay will be my attempt to do just that. While Hussain explores examples of individual and collective death, glorification of death, and martyrdom in Darwish’s poetry, he does not explore how these themes engage with Palestinian culture or the ways in which the poetry enacts certain elements of Palestinian religious practices. What the Western press calls “suicide operations,” the Palestinian press (and, generally the Arab press as well) prefers to term “self-sacrifice” or “martyrdom” operations (Whitehead and Abufarha 395). Though a seemingly subtle difference in semantics, the very act of calling a suicide operation a self-sacrifice is a galvanizing move designed to increase support for resistance against Israel, both within the Palestinian community itself and within the global community at large (399). Far from being considered repulsive, the violence that occurs through such operations is welcomed as a viable alternative to simply standing by and doing nothing. As Whitehead and Abufarha suggest in “Suicide, Violence, and Cultural Conceptions of Martyrdom in Palestine,” “[In Palestine], violence is considered ennobling, redeeming, and necessary to the continuance of life itself” (396). Of course, in order for them to have any effect on the greater community, these acts of violence cannot occur in a vacuum. In his 2009 article, “Poetics and the Performance of Violence in Israel/Palestine,” David McDonald argues that any act of violence finds it power in its “capacity to communicate meaning,” not merely in its resulting casualties
  • 4. Wolk 4 (59). It is this “capacity to communicate meaning” which gives the act of stone throwing its power; though typically not resulting in death, this act does result in fear on behalf of the Israeli soldiers and a sense of empowerment on behalf of the Palestinians. Acts of violence then, McDonald asserts, must “draw from a common lexicon or vocabulary of symbolic action” and “be performed for an audience in order for [them] to have any social meaning” (59). While the stone is not necessarily an intimidating weapon, the symbolic action of throwing one in the face of an IDF soldier reminds both parties of the Palestinian’s unwillingness to discontinue their resistance against the state of Israel. The performance of violence in the case of martyrdom operations is then commemorated and memorialized so that it becomes a self-seeding and self- sustaining phenomenon: today’s martyr begets ten more martyrs tomorrow. In summary, martyrdom represents a form of resistance against the perceived injustices of the Israeli occupation and is considered one of the highest ideals a Palestinian can aspire to. As Whitehead and Abufarha write in a “Suicide, Violence, and Cultural Conceptions of Martyrdom in Palestine,” “Through their performance and wider representation such acts [as suicide bombings] generate collective conceptions among Palestinians and at the same time continue a violent dialogue with the Israeli state” (395). They continue, “[A] new discourse of ishtishhadiyeen (martyrous ones) has been articulated in a way that highlights the intentionality of martyrdom as an act of heroism” (398). The importance to Palestinians of calling these acts of violence martyrdom operations versus suicide attacks cannot be underestimated. As McDonald explains: The salient meaning of suicide bombing is not found in the devastation wrought (number of casualties, buildings, or buses destroyed), but in the act of sacrifice itself. The willingness to offer one’s body to the cause carries far more significance simply because it resonates with the subversive poetics of violence
  • 5. Wolk 5 and self-sacrifice articulated across various performative domains. […] Martyr operations, perhaps the most iconographic form of Palestinian violence/resistance against the occupation […] carries incredible symbolic meaning for many Palestinians due in large part to its usage of the body itself as the instrument of attack (80).1 As McDonald suggests above, the martyr’s body itself carries significant symbolical weight in the Palestinian conception of martyrdom iconography. Borrowing Constantine Kalokyris definition of icon from “The Essence of Orthodox Iconography,” “iconography seeks by means of symbols, shapes, and forms largely withdrawn from reality to speak to the soul of the faithful” (42). As icons, then, the martyr has a “worshipful purpose” (43).We see these elements in play in the Palestinians’ deep valorization of the martyr. As an icon, the martyr achieves the status of myth, and, in Barthes’s taxonomy, the physical body of the martyr becomes that myth. As Susan Raine writes in “Body, Emotion and Violence: Palestinian Suicide Bombing/Martyrdom,” “The martyr’s body becomes a medium of communication—a symbol, that paradoxically, must disintegrate in order to impart its message” (2). This physical disintegration of the martyr’s body during the bombing operation facilitates two processes of metaphorical regeneration: first, “the blood is ‘water’ that nourishes the fields where streams would flow and birds would sing.[Secondly,] the human flesh is ‘soil’ where flowers bloom […] Thus the sacrifice creates a new ontology through metonymic reconstitution of body-as- landscape” (Whitehead and Abufarha 401-02). Going back to Barthes’s conception of myth, we see that the martyr’s body has “a double function: it points out and it notifies, it makes us understand something and it imposes it on us… “(Barthes 83). The physical destruction of the 1 I know on my mid-term you said to indent .5” but the MLA handbook says “one-inch from the left margin,” so this is what I did.
  • 6. Wolk 6 body points out to us that it represents the Palestinian conception of the cycle of life and in its very act of destruction, imposes on us its mythical meaning. The un-martyred body does not recall the same life-generating properties of that of the martyr. Furthermore, there is, of course, nothing inherent about the body’s destruction to lead us to make this connection—it is an arbitrary assignment determined by the Palestinians’ attempts to grapple with constant death. As Corina Daba-Buzioanu and Christina Cirtita-Buzoianu describe in “Myths Beyond and Throughout History,” “[Myths] resolve a problem: the conscious return of man towards a role model which becomes known and understood due to the way in which the social culture relates to it. Therefore, myths are milestones of thought, answers communities would give to fundamental themes” (125). Summarizing Barthes’s arguments on myth, Daba-Buzioanu and Cirtita-Buzoianu write that, for Barthes, “myth is a true instrument of social communication and of interpreting reality” (126). Therefore, the Palestinians have created this myth of the martyr to understand and cope with their situation of violence and displacement. Lining both the exterior and interior walls of shops, cafes, and even in some cases homes, the martyr’s poster is a constant visual reminder of the unfortunate ubiquity of death in Palestine. As Abu Hashhash explains in “On the Visual Representation of Martyrdom in Palestine,” “Martyrs’ posters are loaded with classical, religious, and national references [...] In general there are three indispensable and consistent elements […]: the photograph of the martyr, the ‘obituary’ text that usually includes a Qur’anic verse, and various symbols” (392). Each political faction2 has their own set of design elements that are used to identify the martyr with that particular group, in an attempt to establish its validity and popular support (Allen 117-18). The 2 While I am limiting my discussion to groups within the Palestinian territories (Al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigades, Hamas, Palestinian Islamic Jihad, etc), the same can be said of resistance groups such as Hizbollah operating within the borders of Lebanon.
  • 7. Wolk 7 posters are an important preservation of the martyrdom myth, enabling the Palestinians to “start representing themselves as courageous heroes rather than victim” (Abu Hashash 393). Lori Allen, in “The Polyvalent Politics of Martyrdom Commemorations in the Palestinian Intifada,” explains this process of martyrdom to myth: “Posters were an important part of the process through which martyrs became icons. In semiotic terms, the posters would be considered iconic signs, insofar as they represent their ‘object’ (martyr) by means of resemblance, just as any photograph does. The posters are semiologically complex, representing both the person who was killed and the martyr that person has become. [...] Thus the posters capture what, in religious terms, is the kind of eternal life of the martyr who is not believed to be dead (in a literal sense). […] Posters also created social icons, representations of heroism and idealized sacrifice. Adding to the iconic power of posters is the indexicality of the photographic portrait on them. While the ultimately unstable meaning and political force of the posters is a product of the social and political exigencies of the second intifada, it is the photograph’s casual and physical relationship between signifier and signified that lends it an extra layer of authority.” (117). Like the martyr’s body, the martyr’s poster participates in the “hidden semiology” of myth, imposing martyrdom as an acceptable—nay, an ideal—form of resistance for Palestine. Like both the martyr’s body and the poster, Darwish’s conception of martyrs and martyrdom in his poetry is a positive one. As Hussain Hamzah explains in “Resistance, Martyrdom, and Death in Mahmoud Darwish’s Poetry,” “The word ‘martyr’ (shahīd) in Darwish’s poetry is associated with manifestations of life and revival” and “martyrdom turns
  • 8. Wolk 8 into the equal of life and fertility” (171, 172). An example of this “life and revival” through martyrdom is Darwish’s continued use of the metaphor of a wedding to represent the martyr’s “marriage” to the land of Palestine. In “Blessing for Something which has Not Come” (1989), Darwish writes: This is the Palestinian wedding/ The lover does not come to the beloved/ Except as a martyr or wanderer” (qtd in Hamzah 172). As a marriage typically begets life, the martyr’s blood begets life for Palestine, as explained earlier. In “Diary of a Palestinian Wound” (Quatrains for Fadwa Tuqan) (1987), Darwish further elaborates this trope: This land absorbs the skins of martyrs. This land promises wheat and stars. Worship it! We are its salt and its water. We are its wound, but a wound that fights… Ah my intractable wound! My country is not a suitcase I am not a traveller I am the lover and the land is the beloved. (qtd in Salti 43). Like the martyrs’ posters, Darwish’s poetry speaks of both the individual and the collective (Alshaer 92). Both are steeped in a uniquely Palestinian aesthetic of “liberation and hope” (96). Where I think Darwish’s poetry surpasses the posters, however, can be found in his use of somewhat enigmatic language. The posters rely on a common, even over-used, set of symbols to perpetuate the myth of the martyr. The predictability of these posters dulls their effects on the viewer. As Allen writes, “Palestinians point to these practices [of martyr memorialization] as symptoms of superficial patriotism and empty politics said to characterize the uprising […] and this symbolic, spatial and visual deluge has led so many people to the
  • 9. Wolk 9 distraction, boredom, and ennui that are elements of zahaq (weariness, a state of being ‘fed up’)” (110). Contrarily, Darwish’s poetry is unpredictable, and remains novel even after multiple re- readings. As Mustapha Marrouchi elaborates in “Cry No More for Me, Palestine—Mahmoud Darwish,” “There is no style that can quite match his poetry’s combination of carefully subordinated clauses with occasional bursts of monosyllabic simplicity. It is a daunting task trying to decipher the meanings and double-meanings the poems carry within them. They need to be read time and again” (22). Darwish’s great talent, Marrouchi writes, “make his readers want to supply the tragic emotions that he does not directly represent” (21). This gap in Darwish’s poetry—meaning the reader has to supply his or her own emotions—is in direct contrast to the posters, which elucidate a specific, calculated response over and over from the viewer, no matter which specific martyr is depicted. In fact, many of the design elements of the posters are carried over from one to the next, with only the photograph of the martyr changing. An important element of the posters we cannot overlook, though, is the inclusion of verses from the Quran. Both secular and religious parties tend to include at least one verse of the Quran on their martyrs posters, along with a reiteration of the Quranic promise of Paradise to those who “die for Allah.” This practice of including Quranic verses stems from the Palestinians’ folk religious practices, and its effect is akin to hanging framed calligraphic Quranic verses in one’s house. As Tawqfiq Canaan explains in The Decipherment of Arabic Talismans3 , “Qoranic [sic] verses hung up in houses have to be regarded not only as a decorative feature, but also as a protective measure” (70, emphasis added). The writing, Canaan argues, has “intrinsic power” (71). These physical representations of the Quranic verses act as talismans for the viewer—they 3 Dr. Tawfiq Canaan began collecting and examining talismans and amulets that he noticed his patients wearing in the beginning of the twentieth century. He collected more than 1400 items from countries such as Egypt, Syria, Lebanon, Jordan, Saudia Arabic, Iraq, and Yemen. For more information about his collection, see al-Ju-‘beh, Baha’, “Magic and Talismans: The Tawfiq Canaan Collection of Palestinian Amulets.” Jerusalem Quarterly. 22.23: (2005): 103-108. For Canaan’s analysis of the items, see his The Decipherment of Arabic Talismans.
  • 10. Wolk 10 are, as Canaan explains, “prayers” for people “seeking protection” (73). An informal survey of several martyrs’ posters reveals many of the same Quranic verses described by Canaan in his study of Arabic talismans. Where does this modern talismanic practice come from? As M.C. Hughes argues in “The Evolution of Islamism in the Palestinian Territories,” modern Palestinian culture is built on the past. Hughes writes, “The roots of modern Palestinian Islamist movements such as Hamas are deeply set in history, reaching back farther than the establishment of Israel as a state and the resulting expulsion of Palestinians into the outlying territories” (15). Hughes gives a detailed history of modern Palestine, beginning with the 1900s when Palestine was subjected to British rule under the Mandate of from the League of Nations. As Hughes describes, “Life in mandatory Palestine remained rooted in patriarchal tradition, family and clan loyalty, and a talismanic approach to Islam” (24). By talismanic approach, he means that “practitioners took to praying and fasting as supernatural spiritual duties that brought emotional comfort and social acceptance” (25). Therefore, including the Quranic verses on martyrs’ posters today, Palestinians are reminded of the magical power of those verses to comfort the living and assure them the deceased has entered Paradise. We can see how powerful the spoken Quranic verse can be as well in Nasra Hassan’s article, “An Arsenal of Believers,” from The New Yorker. In Hassan’s re-telling of a would-be martyr who failed at first to carry out his mission, we see how reciting the Quran works in the same way as a visual talisman: “All he [the young Palestinian, referred to only as ‘M.’] had to do was unzip his bag of explosives and press the detonator. ‘But at the moment he was to press the button he forgot Paradise,’ one of his former cellmates recalled. ‘He felt a split second of fear, a slight hesitation. To bolster himself, he recited from the Koran.
  • 11. Wolk 11 Refreshed and strengthened, he again began to think of Paradise. When he felt ready, he tried again.’” (Hassan n.p.). Though his mission was not ultimately completed due to technical difficulties, the young Palestinian was clearly “re-charged” to continue his work by the mere recitation of Quranic verses. He attributes his ability to press the button of the detonator to the powerful and stimulating act of reciting the Quran—clearly, the words had functioned in a protective way for him, and, as such, is a talismanic belief. Borrowing again from Hughes’s description above, we can transfer Canaan’s theory of talismanic power from a physical object (the talisman) to a bodily movement (prayer and fasting). We can also connect this to the performative utterance, a la J.L. Austen. In Austen’s terminology, the performative “does something” (qtd. in Crary 61). Therefore, the martyr is not merely saying something with his words—the statements are actually performing a function. In this case, they are performing the action of being a talisman, of providing supernatural assurance to the would-be martyr. The point of analyzing these Palestinian cultural practices—the valorization of the martyr, the commemoration of the martyr, the recitation of Quranic verses—is to provide a way of reading Darwish’s poetry, in the same vein that Henry Louis Gates, Jr., in The Signifying Monkey uses elements of African culture to read black texts in the “New World.” As Gates argues, black slaves relied on oral literature to preserve African traditions and practices while in the New World (5). In his discussion of the trickster and “Signifying Monkey” of slave culture, Gates stresses the importance of examining these items to reveal elements of black aesthetic and literary culture today. As Gates writes, “We must remember that the Signifying Monkey tales are the repositories of the black vernacular tradition’s rhetorical principles, coded dictionaries of black tropes” (63). This same type of coded language forms the structure of Darwish’s poems,
  • 12. Wolk 12 recreating the talismanic practices of Palestinian folk culture. As Tawfiq Yousef writes in “Mahmoud Dariwsh and the Quest for Identity,” [Darwish] viewed history as giving the individual a sense of pride and belonging in addition to providing him with a sense of self- definition […] Sometimes Darwish resorted to the historical past as an attempt to attach the Palestinians to their heritage in order to overcome their feelings of isolation, aloneness, and uprootedness” (679). In addition to incorporating historical elements in his poetry, Darwish consistently used his poems to explore solutions to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. In a 1996 interview, Darwish states “I built my homeland, I even established a state, in my language” (Yeshurun 5). Darwish’s interviews reflect the power his poems have. Darwish’s words, then, become the magical talisman that instills feelings of protection and calm…they become the life- generating blood of the martyr, the “‘water’ that nourishes the fields where streams would flow and birds would sing,” and cultivates the minds of the Palestinians. To answer Darwish’s question posed at the beginning of this essay, his poems most surely achieve the status of blood.
  • 13. Wolk 13 Works Cited Abu Hashhash, Mahmoud. “On the Visual Representation of Martyrdom in Palestine.” Third Text. 20.3/4 (2006): 391-403. Scopus. Web. 2 March 2015. Allen, Lori A. “The Polyvalent Politics of Martyrdom Commemorations in the Palestinian Intifada. History and Memory. 18.2 (2006): 107-38. JSTOR. Web. 3 March 2015. Alshaer, Atef “Identity in Mahmoud Darwish’s Poem ‘The Dice Player.’” Middle East Journal of Culture and Communications. 4 (2011): 90-110. Communication and Mass Media Complete. Web. 3 March 2015. Barthes, Roland. “Excerpt from Mythologies.” Literary Theory: An Anthology. Ed. Julie Rivkin and Michael Ryan. Massachusetts: Blackwell, 2004. 81-96. Print. Canaan, Tewfik. The Decipherment of Arabic Talismans. Syrian Orphanage Press (1939). Web. 25 March 2015. Crary, Alice. "The Happy Truth: J.L. Austin's How To Do Things With Words." Inquiry. 45.1 (2002): 59. Business Source Premier. Web. 14 Apr. 2015. Daba-Bouzianu, Corina and Christina Cirtita-Bouzioanu. “Myths Beyond and Throughout History: A Study on Traditional and Modern Myths.” The Scientific Journal of Humanistic Studies. 3.5 (2011): 125-128. Academic Search Alumni Edition. Web. 14 Apr. 2015. Gates, Henry Louis Jr. The Signifying Monkey: A Theory of African-American Literary Criticism. Oxford: Oxford UP, 1988. Print. Hamzah, Hussain. “Resistance, Martyrdom, and Death in Mahmoud Darwish’s Poetry.” Holy Land Studies. 13.2 (2014): 159-186. Publisher Provided Full Text Searching File. Web. 5 March 2015. Hassan, Nasra. “An Arsenal of Believers.” The New Yorker Magazine. 19 Nov. 2001. Web. 21
  • 14. Wolk 14 April 2015. Hughes, Michael. “The Evolution of Islamism in the Palestinian Territories: Historical and Ethnographic Analysis. AHS Capstone Projects. Paper 24 (2010). Google Scholar. Web. 21 April 2015. Kalokyris, Constantine. “The Essence of Orthodox Iconography.” Greek Orthodox Theological Review. 14.1 (1969): 42-64. ATLA Religion Database. Web. 23 March 2015. Marrouchi, Mustapha. “Cry No More for Me, Palestine—Mahmoud Darwish.” College Literature. 38.4 (2011): 1-43. JSTOR. Web. 3 March 2015. McDonald, David. “Poetics and the Performance of Violence in Israel/Palestine.” Ethnomusicology. 53.1 (2009): 85-85. JSTOR. Web. 3 March 2015. Raine, Susan. “Body, Emotion, and Violence: Palestinian Suicide Bombing/Martyrdom (1993- 2005). Marburg Journal of Religion. 17.2 (2013): 1-21. Google Scholar. Web. 5 March 2015. Salti, Rasha. “From Resistance and Bearing Witness to the Power of the Fantastical: Icons and Symbols in Palestinian Poetry and Cinema.” Third Text. 24.1 (2010): 39-52. Art Full Text. Web. 5 March 2015. Yeshurun, Helit. “‘Exile is So Strong Within Me, I May Bring it to the Land’: A Landmark 1996 Interview with Mahmoud Darwish.” Journal of Palestinian Studies. 42.1 (2012): 46-63. Web. 14 April 2015. Yousef, Tawfiq. “Mahmoud Darwish and the Quest for Identity.” Dirasat, Human and Social Sciences. 38.2 (2011): 674-88. Google Scholar. Web. 11 April 2015. Whitehead, Neil L. and Nasser Abufarha. Suicide, Violence, and Cultural Conceptions of
  • 15. Wolk 15 Martyrdom in Palestine.” Social Research: An International Quarterly. 75.2 (2008): 395- 416. Project Muse. Web. 5 March 2015. Works Consulted Al-Ju’Beh, Baha’. “Magic and Talismans: The Tawfiq Canaan Collection of Palestinian Amulets.” Jerusalem Quarterly. 22.23 (2005): 103-108. Web. 25 March 2015. Al-Udhari, Abdullah, Trans. Victims of a Map: Mahmud Darwish, Samih al-Qasim, Adonis. London: Al Saqi Books, 1984. Print. Borrowman, Glenn. “Popular Palestinian Practices around Holy Places and Those Who Oppose Them: A Historical Introduction.” Religion Compass. 7.3 (2013): 69-78. Google Scholar. Web. 11 April 2015. Darwish, Mahmoud. If I Were Another. Trans. Fady Joudah. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2009. Print. Gana, Nouri. “War, Poetry, Mourning: Darwish, Adonis, Iraq.” Poetic Culture. 22.1 (2010): 33- 65. Google Scholar. Web. 23 March 2015. Ghanim, Honaida. “Poetics of Disaster: Nationalism, Gender, and Social Change Among Palestinian Poets in Israel After Nakba.” International Journal of Politics, Culture, and Society. 22.1 (2009): 23-39. JSTOR. Web. 21 April 2015. Glock, Albert. “Archaeology as Cultural Survival: The Future of the Palestinian Past.” Journal of Palestinian Studies. 23.3 (1994): 70-84. JSTOR. Web. 12 April 2015. Jassim, Muhsin al-Musawi. “Engaging Tradition in Modern Arab Poetics.” Journal of Arabic Literature. 33.2 (2002): 172-210. JSTOR. Web. 21 April 2015. Joseph, Roger. “Toward a Semiotics of Middle Eastern Cultures.” International Journal of Middle East Studies. 12.3 (1980): 319-29. JSTOR. Web. 3 March 2015.
  • 16. Wolk 16 Munro, Andrew. "Reading Austin Rhetorically." Philosophy and Rhetoric. 46.1 (2013): 22-43. MLA International Bibliography. Web. 14 Apr. 2015. Oxman, Elena. "Sensing the Image: Roland Barthes and the Affect of the Visual." Substance: A Review of Theory & Literary Criticism. 39.2 (2010): 71-90. Humanities International Complete. Web. 14 Apr. 2015. Schick, Irvin Cemil. “The Iconicity of Islamic Calligraphy in Turkey.” RES: Anthropology and Aesthetics. 53.54 (2008): 211-24. JSTOR. Web. 23 March 2015. Sheiladeh, Raja. “Mahmoud Darwish” (Interview). Bomb. Fall 2002. Google Scholar. Web. 25 April 2015. Sylvain, Patrick. “Darwish’s Essentialist Poetics in a State of Siege.” Human Architecture: Journal of the Sociology of Self-Knowledge. 7 (2009): 137-150. Print.