2. Basic Value Creation Formula: Fundamental Idea
1) Re-focuses acquired businesses resulting in lower costs
and improved efficiency.
2) Value is created through basic finance that says debt can
increase firm value if you can afford it!
• Exploits corporate aversion to debt (Henry McVey,
Morgan Stanley).
3) Regulatory Arbitrage – Sarbanes-Oxley
3. The Basic Value Creation Formula
Debt can increase Value
Dupont Equation
Equity
Assets
Total
X
Assets
Total
Sales
X
Sales
NI
Equity
NI
ROE
Leverage – Debt as % of Assets
Equity Multiplier ROE
4. The Basic Value Creation Formula
Debt can increase Value – Unleveraged
Firm (all Equity Financed) vs Leverage
Firm
ROE
Equity
Assets
Total
X
Assets
Total
Sales
X
Sales
NI
%
16
100
16
100
100
100
160
160
16
X
X
Consider a company that takes on debt at a cost of $3 in Net Income, but
changes NOTHING ELSE.
Could drop NI to 4.8 and still match the previous ROE!!
%
40
30
12
30
100
100
160
160
12
X
X
5. Analysis of Value Creation
Unleveraged Firm/All Equity Financing:
• NPM is $ 16 M; Sales=$ 160 M; Total Assets = $ 100 M
Leveraged Firm:
NPM is $ 12 M; Sales=$ 160 M; Total Assets = $ 100 M; Interest Cost= $ 4
M
Note: Difference in NPM in both firms is $ 4 M that represents Interest Cost
Leverage Ratios:
Equity Multiplier = $ 100 M / $ 30 M = 3.33 times
Debt to Equity = [$ 100 - $ 30]/ $ 30 M = 2.33 times
ROE is way to higher for leveraged firm as opposed to all equity financed
firm: 40% versus 16%!
6. Growth Equity
• Growth equity (also known as growth capital or
expansion capital) is a type of investment
opportunity in relatively mature companies that
are going through some transformational event in
their lifecycle with potential for some
dramatic growth.
7. Growth Equity
• Growth equity funds invest in fast-growing
businesses (which have moved beyond the start-
up stage) in exchange for a minority equity stake.
• Given the lack of control, a strong working
relationship and trust-based partnership between
the investors, existing owners, and management
are required to achieve the desired outcome:
advancing the company to a new stage of
development.
10. Buyout Funds
• In private equity, Buyout Funds and investors
seek out underperforming or undervalued
companies that they can take private and turn
around.
12. Leveraged Buyout (LBO)
Case 1 (5 years) – No Profit Increase Case 2 (5 years) – Profit Increase
The Basic Value Creation Formula – An Example
of Carlyle Group
13. Analysis of Buyout Transaction
Key Financial Prior to Buyout:
Annual Profit of Target/Investee Co. : $ 10 Million
Entry Multiple: Price Paid for Buyout
10 Times multiple of Annual Profit:
10 x $ 10 Million = $ 100 Million
Debt Level: $ 70 Million
Equity: $ 30 Million
14. Analysis of Buyout Transaction
Exit Scenario – I [With Partial Debt Repayment]:
Debt Repayment: $ 30 Million
Remaining Debt: $ 40 Million
Exit Multiple: @ 10 Times => 10 X $ 10 Million = $ 100 Million
Net Proceeds: Sale Price – Remaining Debt
$ 100 Million - $ 40 Million = $ 60 Million
Return on Investment (ROI): Net Proceeds / Equity Investment
= $ 60 M /$30 M = 100%
Annualized ROI: 14.9% approx. 15% (5 years)
15. Analysis of Buyout Transaction
Exit Scenario – II [No Debt Repayment]:
Debt Repayment: $ -0-
Remaining Debt: $ 70 Million
Exit Multiple: @ 15 Times => 15 X $ 10 Million = $ 150 Million
Net Proceeds: Sale Price – Remaining Debt
$ 150 Million - $ 70 Million = $ 80 Million
Return on Investment (ROI): Net Proceeds / Equity Investment
= $ 80 M /$30 M = 100%
Annualized ROI: 21.7% approx. 22% (5 years)